-
The Complexity of Data-Driven Norm Synthesis and Revision
Authors:
Davide Dell'Anna,
Natasha Alechina,
Brian Logan,
Maarten Löffler,
Fabiano Dalpiaz,
Mehdi Dastani
Abstract:
Norms have been widely proposed as a way of coordinating and controlling the activities of agents in a multi-agent system (MAS). A norm specifies the behaviour an agent should follow in order to achieve the objective of the MAS. However, designing norms to achieve a particular system objective can be difficult, particularly when there is no direct link between the language in which the system obje…
▽ More
Norms have been widely proposed as a way of coordinating and controlling the activities of agents in a multi-agent system (MAS). A norm specifies the behaviour an agent should follow in order to achieve the objective of the MAS. However, designing norms to achieve a particular system objective can be difficult, particularly when there is no direct link between the language in which the system objective is stated and the language in which the norms can be expressed. In this paper, we consider the problem of synthesising a norm from traces of agent behaviour, where each trace is labelled with whether the behaviour satisfies the system objective. We show that the norm synthesis problem is NP-complete.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Causality, Responsibility and Blame in Team Plans
Authors:
Natasha Alechina,
Joseph Y. Halpern,
Brian Logan
Abstract:
Many objectives can be achieved (or may be achieved more effectively) only by a group of agents executing a team plan. If a team plan fails, it is often of interest to determine what caused the failure, the degree of responsibility of each agent for the failure, and the degree of blame attached to each agent. We show how team plans can be represented in terms of structural equations, and then appl…
▽ More
Many objectives can be achieved (or may be achieved more effectively) only by a group of agents executing a team plan. If a team plan fails, it is often of interest to determine what caused the failure, the degree of responsibility of each agent for the failure, and the degree of blame attached to each agent. We show how team plans can be represented in terms of structural equations, and then apply the definitions of causality introduced by Halpern [2015] and degree of responsibility and blame introduced by Chockler and Halpern [2004] to determine the agent(s) who caused the failure and what their degree of responsibility/blame is. We also prove new results on the complexity of computing causality and degree of responsibility and blame, showing that they can be determined in polynomial time for many team plans of interest.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Coalition and Group Announcement Logic
Authors:
Rustam Galimullin,
Natasha Alechina
Abstract:
Dynamic epistemic logics which model abilities of agents to make various announcements and influence each other's knowledge have been studied extensively in recent years. Two notable examples of such logics are Group Announcement Logic and Coalition Announcement Logic. They allow us to reason about what groups of agents can achieve through joint announcements in non-competitive and competitive env…
▽ More
Dynamic epistemic logics which model abilities of agents to make various announcements and influence each other's knowledge have been studied extensively in recent years. Two notable examples of such logics are Group Announcement Logic and Coalition Announcement Logic. They allow us to reason about what groups of agents can achieve through joint announcements in non-competitive and competitive environments. In this paper, we consider a combination of these logics -- Coalition and Relativised Group Announcement Logic and provide its complete axiomatisation. Moreover, we partially answer the question of how group and coalition announcement operators interact, and settle some other open problems.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Resource Logics with a Diminishing Resource
Authors:
Natasha Alechina,
Brian Logan
Abstract:
Model-checking resource logics with production and consumption of resources is a computationally hard and often undecidable problem. We introduce a simple and realistic assumption that there is at least one diminishing resource, that is, a resource that cannot be produced and every action has a non-zero cost on this resource. An example of such resource is time. We show that, with this assumption,…
▽ More
Model-checking resource logics with production and consumption of resources is a computationally hard and often undecidable problem. We introduce a simple and realistic assumption that there is at least one diminishing resource, that is, a resource that cannot be produced and every action has a non-zero cost on this resource. An example of such resource is time. We show that, with this assumption, problems that are undecidable even for the underlying Alternating Time Temporal Logic, such as model-checking under imperfect information and perfect recall, become decidable for resource logics with a diminishing resource.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Coalition and Group Announcement Logic
Authors:
Rustam Galimullin,
Natasha Alechina
Abstract:
Dynamic epistemic logics which model abilities of agents to make various announcements and influence each other's knowledge have been studied extensively in recent years. Two notable examples of such logics are Group Announcement Logic and Coalition Announcement Logic. They allow us to reason about what groups of agents can achieve through joint announcements in non-competitive and competitive env…
▽ More
Dynamic epistemic logics which model abilities of agents to make various announcements and influence each other's knowledge have been studied extensively in recent years. Two notable examples of such logics are Group Announcement Logic and Coalition Announcement Logic. They allow us to reason about what groups of agents can achieve through joint announcements in non-competitive and competitive environments. In this paper, we consider a combination of these logics -- Coalition and Group Announcement Logic and provide its complete axiomatisation. Moreover, we partially answer the question of how group and coalition announcement operators interact, and settle some other open problems.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Expressibility of norms in temporal logic
Authors:
Natasha Alechina,
Mehdi Dastani,
Brian Logan
Abstract:
In this short note we address the issue of expressing norms (such as obligations and prohibitions) in temporal logic. In particular, we address the argument from [Governatori 2015] that norms cannot be expressed in Linear Time Temporal Logic (LTL).
In this short note we address the issue of expressing norms (such as obligations and prohibitions) in temporal logic. In particular, we address the argument from [Governatori 2015] that norms cannot be expressed in Linear Time Temporal Logic (LTL).
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Decentralised Norm Monitoring in Open Multi-Agent Systems
Authors:
Natasha Alechina,
Joseph Y. Halpern,
Ian A. Kash,
Brian Logan
Abstract:
We consider the problem of detecting norm violations in open multi-agent systems (MAS). We show how, using ideas from scrip systems, we can design mechanisms where the agents comprising the MAS are incentivised to monitor the actions of other agents for norm violations. The cost of providing the incentives is not borne by the MAS and does not come from fines charged for norm violations (fines may…
▽ More
We consider the problem of detecting norm violations in open multi-agent systems (MAS). We show how, using ideas from scrip systems, we can design mechanisms where the agents comprising the MAS are incentivised to monitor the actions of other agents for norm violations. The cost of providing the incentives is not borne by the MAS and does not come from fines charged for norm violations (fines may be impossible to levy in a system where agents are free to leave and rejoin again under a different identity). Instead, monitoring incentives come from (scrip) fees for accessing the services provided by the MAS. In some cases, perfect monitoring (and hence enforcement) can be achieved: no norms will be violated in equilibrium. In other cases, we show that, while it is impossible to achieve perfect enforcement, we can get arbitrarily close; we can make the probability of a norm violation in equilibrium arbitrarily small. We show using simulations that our theoretical results hold for multi-agent systems with as few as 1000 agents---the system rapidly converges to the steady-state distribution of scrip tokens necessary to ensure monitoring and then remains close to the steady state.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Technical Report: Model-Checking for Resource-Bounded ATL with Production and Consumption of Resources
Authors:
Natasha Alechina,
Brian Logan,
Hoang Nga Nguyen,
Franco Raimondi
Abstract:
Several logics for expressing coalitional ability under resource bounds have been proposed and studied in the literature. Previous work has shown that if only consumption of resources is considered or the total amount of resources produced or consumed on any path in the system is bounded, then the model-checking problem for several standard logics, such as Resource-Bounded Coalition Logic (RB-CL)…
▽ More
Several logics for expressing coalitional ability under resource bounds have been proposed and studied in the literature. Previous work has shown that if only consumption of resources is considered or the total amount of resources produced or consumed on any path in the system is bounded, then the model-checking problem for several standard logics, such as Resource-Bounded Coalition Logic (RB-CL) and Resource-Bounded Alternating-Time Temporal Logic (RB-ATL) is decidable. However, for coalition logics with unbounded resource production and consumption, only some undecidability results are known. In this paper, we show that the model-checking problem for RB-ATL with unbounded production and con- sumption of resources is decidable but EXPSPACE-hard. We also investigate some tractable cases and provide a detailed comparison to a variant of the resource logic RAL, together with new complexity results.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Completeness of Epistemic Coalition Logic with Group Knowledge
Authors:
Thomas Ågotnes,
Natasha Alechina
Abstract:
Coalition logic is one of the most popular logics for multi-agent systems. While epistemic extensions of coalition logic have received much attention, existence of their complete axiomatisations has so far been an open problem. In this paper we settle several of those problems. We prove completeness for epistemic coalition logic with common knowledge, with distributed knowledge, and with both comm…
▽ More
Coalition logic is one of the most popular logics for multi-agent systems. While epistemic extensions of coalition logic have received much attention, existence of their complete axiomatisations has so far been an open problem. In this paper we settle several of those problems. We prove completeness for epistemic coalition logic with common knowledge, with distributed knowledge, and with both common and distributed knowledge, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
