-
An Optimization Framework for Power Infrastructure Planning
Authors:
Nina Wiedemann,
David Adjiashvili
Abstract:
The ubiquitous expansion and transformation of the energy supply system involves large-scale power infrastructure construction projects. In the view of investments of more than a million dollars per kilometre, planning authorities aim to minimise the resistances posed by multiple stakeholders. Mathematical optimisation research offers efficient algorithms to compute globally optimal routes based o…
▽ More
The ubiquitous expansion and transformation of the energy supply system involves large-scale power infrastructure construction projects. In the view of investments of more than a million dollars per kilometre, planning authorities aim to minimise the resistances posed by multiple stakeholders. Mathematical optimisation research offers efficient algorithms to compute globally optimal routes based on geographic input data. We propose a framework that utilizes a graph model where vertices represent possible locations of transmission towers, and edges are placed according to the feasible distance between neighbouring towers. In order to cope with the specific challenges arising in linear infrastructure layout, we first introduce a variant of the Bellman-Ford algorithm that efficiently computes the minimal-angle shortest path. Secondly, an iterative procedure is proposed that yields a locally optimal path at considerably lower memory requirements and runtime. Third, we discuss and analyse methods to output k diverse path alternatives. Experiments on real data show that compared to previous work, our approach reduces the resistances by more than 10% in feasible time, while at the same time offering much more flexibility and functionality. Our methods are demonstrated in a simple and intuitive graphical user interface, and an open-source package (LION) is available at https://pypi.org/project/lion-sp.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2021; v1 submitted 9 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Fault-Tolerant Edge-Disjoint Paths -- Beyond Uniform Faults
Authors:
David Adjiashvili,
Felix Hommelsheim,
Moritz Mühlenthaler,
Oliver Schaudt
Abstract:
The overwhelming majority of survivable (fault-tolerant) network design models assume a uniform fault model. Such a model assumes that every subset of the network resources (edges or vertices) of a given cardinality $k$ may fail. While this approach yields problems with clean combinatorial structure and good algorithms, it often fails to capture the true nature of the scenario set coming from appl…
▽ More
The overwhelming majority of survivable (fault-tolerant) network design models assume a uniform fault model. Such a model assumes that every subset of the network resources (edges or vertices) of a given cardinality $k$ may fail. While this approach yields problems with clean combinatorial structure and good algorithms, it often fails to capture the true nature of the scenario set coming from applications. One natural refinement of the uniform model is obtained by partitioning the set of resources into vulnerable and safe resources. The scenario set contains every subset of at most $k$ faulty resources. This work studies the Fault-Tolerant Path (FTP) problem, the counterpart of the Shortest Path problem in this fault model and the Fault-Tolerant Flow problem (FTF), the counterpart of the $\ell$-disjoint Shortest $s$-$t$ Path problem. We present complexity results alongside exact and approximation algorithms for both models. We emphasize the vast increase in the complexity of the problem with respect to the uniform analogue, the Edge-Disjoint Paths problem.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Flexible Graph Connectivity: Approximating Network Design Problems Between 1- and 2-connectivity
Authors:
David Adjiashvili,
Felix Hommelsheim,
Moritz Mühlenthaler
Abstract:
Graph connectivity and network design problems are among the most fundamental problems in combinatorial optimization. The minimum spanning tree problem, the two edge-connected spanning subgraph problem (2-ECSS) and the tree augmentation problem (TAP) are all examples of fundamental well-studied network design tasks that postulate different initial states of the network and different assumptions on…
▽ More
Graph connectivity and network design problems are among the most fundamental problems in combinatorial optimization. The minimum spanning tree problem, the two edge-connected spanning subgraph problem (2-ECSS) and the tree augmentation problem (TAP) are all examples of fundamental well-studied network design tasks that postulate different initial states of the network and different assumptions on the reliability of network components. In this paper we motivate and study \emph{Flexible Graph Connectivity} (FGC), a problem that mixes together both the modeling power and the complexities of all aforementioned problems and more. In a nutshell, FGC asks to design a connected network, while allowing to specify different reliability levels for individual edges. While this non-uniform nature of the problem makes it appealing from the modeling perspective, it also renders most existing algorithmic tools for dealing with network design problems unfit for approximating FGC.
In this paper we develop a general algorithmic approach for approximating FGC that yields approximation algorithms with ratios that are very close to the best known bounds for many special cases, such as 2-ECSS and TAP. Our algorithm and analysis combine various techniques including a weight-scaling algorithm, a charging argument that uses a variant of exchange bijections between spanning trees and a factor revealing min-max-min optimization problem.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2020; v1 submitted 29 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Robust Assignments with Vulnerable Nodes
Authors:
David Adjiashvili,
Viktor Bindewald,
Dennis Michaels
Abstract:
Various real-life planning problems require making upfront decisions before all parameters of the problem have been disclosed. An important special case of such problem especially arises in scheduling and staff rostering problems, where a set of tasks needs to be assigned to an available set of resources (personnel or machines), in a way that each task is assigned to one resource, while no task is…
▽ More
Various real-life planning problems require making upfront decisions before all parameters of the problem have been disclosed. An important special case of such problem especially arises in scheduling and staff rostering problems, where a set of tasks needs to be assigned to an available set of resources (personnel or machines), in a way that each task is assigned to one resource, while no task is allowed to share a resource with another task. In its nominal form, the resulting computational problem reduces to the well-known assignment problem that can be modeled as matching problems on bipartite graphs.
In recent work \cite{adjiashvili_bindewald_michaels_icalp2016}, a new robust model for the assignment problem was introduced that can deal with situations in which certain resources, i.e.\ nodes or edges of the underlying bipartite graph, are vulnerable and may become unavailable after a solution has been chosen. In the original version from \cite{adjiashvili_bindewald_michaels_icalp2016} the resources subject to uncertainty are the edges of the underlying bipartite graph.
In this follow-up work, we complement our previous study by considering nodes as being vulnerable, instead of edges. The goal is now to choose a minimum-cost collection of nodes such that, if any vulnerable node becomes unavailable, the remaining part of the solution still contains sufficient nodes to perform all tasks. From a practical point of view, such type of unavailability is interesting as it is typically caused e.g.\ by an employee's sickness, or machine failure. We present algorithms and hardness of approximation results for several variants of the problem.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Improved Approximation for Weighted Tree Augmentation with Bounded Costs
Authors:
David Adjiashvili
Abstract:
The Weighted Tree Augmentation Problem (WTAP) is a fundamental well-studied problem in the field of network design. Given an undirected tree $G=(V,E)$, an additional set of edges $L \subseteq V\times V$ disjoint from $E$ called \textit{links}, and a cost vector $c\in \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}^L$, WTAP asks to find a minimum-cost set $F\subseteq L$ with the property that $(V,E\cup F)$ is $2$-edge connect…
▽ More
The Weighted Tree Augmentation Problem (WTAP) is a fundamental well-studied problem in the field of network design. Given an undirected tree $G=(V,E)$, an additional set of edges $L \subseteq V\times V$ disjoint from $E$ called \textit{links}, and a cost vector $c\in \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}^L$, WTAP asks to find a minimum-cost set $F\subseteq L$ with the property that $(V,E\cup F)$ is $2$-edge connected. The special case where $c_\ell = 1$ for all $\ell\in L$ is called the Tree Augmentation Problem (TAP). Both problems are known to be NP-hard.
For the class of bounded cost vectors, we present a first improved approximation algorithm for WTAP since more than three decades. Concretely, for any $M\in \mathbb{Z}_{\geq 1}$ and $ε> 0,$ we present an LP based $(δ+ε)$-approximation for WTAP restricted to cost vectors $c$ in $[1,M]^L$ for $δ\approx 1.96417$. For the special case of TAP we improve this factor to $\frac{5}{3}+ε$.
Our results rely on a new LP, that significantly differs from existing LPs achieving improved bounds for TAP. We round a fractional solution in two phases. The first phase uses the fractional solution to decompose the tree and its fractional solution into so-called $β$-simple pairs losing only an $ε$-factor in the objective function. We then show how to use the additional constraints in our LP combined with the $β$-simple structure to round a fractional solution in each part of the decomposition.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2016; v1 submitted 13 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Robust Assignments via Ear Decompositions and Randomized Rounding
Authors:
David Adjiashvili,
Viktor Bindewald,
Dennis Michaels
Abstract:
Many real-life planning problems require making a priori decisions before all parameters of the problem have been revealed. An important special case of such problem arises in scheduling problems, where a set of tasks needs to be assigned to the available set of machines or personnel (resources), in a way that all tasks have assigned resources, and no two tasks share the same resource. In its nomi…
▽ More
Many real-life planning problems require making a priori decisions before all parameters of the problem have been revealed. An important special case of such problem arises in scheduling problems, where a set of tasks needs to be assigned to the available set of machines or personnel (resources), in a way that all tasks have assigned resources, and no two tasks share the same resource. In its nominal form, the resulting computational problem becomes the \emph{assignment problem} on general bipartite graphs.
This paper deals with a robust variant of the assignment problem modeling situations where certain edges in the corresponding graph are \emph{vulnerable} and may become unavailable after a solution has been chosen. The goal is to choose a minimum-cost collection of edges such that if any vulnerable edge becomes unavailable, the remaining part of the solution contains an assignment of all tasks.
We present approximation results and hardness proofs for this type of problems, and establish several connections to well-known concepts from matching theory, robust optimization and LP-based techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Firefighting on Trees Beyond Integrality Gaps
Authors:
David Adjiashvili,
Andrea Baggio,
Rico Zenklusen
Abstract:
The Firefighter problem and a variant of it, known as Resource Minimization for Fire Containment (RMFC), are natural models for optimal inhibition of harmful spreading processes. Despite considerable progress on several fronts, the approximability of these problems is still badly understood. This is the case even when the underlying graph is a tree, which is one of the most-studied graph structure…
▽ More
The Firefighter problem and a variant of it, known as Resource Minimization for Fire Containment (RMFC), are natural models for optimal inhibition of harmful spreading processes. Despite considerable progress on several fronts, the approximability of these problems is still badly understood. This is the case even when the underlying graph is a tree, which is one of the most-studied graph structures in this context and the focus of this paper. In their simplest version, a fire spreads from one fixed vertex step by step from burning to adjacent non-burning vertices, and at each time step, $B$ many non-burning vertices can be protected from catching fire. The Firefighter problem asks, for a given $B$, to maximize the number of vertices that will not catch fire, whereas RMFC (on a tree) asks to find the smallest $B$ that allows for saving all leaves of the tree. Prior to this work, the best known approximation ratios were an $O(1)$-approximation for the Firefighter problem and an $O(\log^* n)$-approximation for RMFC, both being LP-based and essentially matching the integrality gaps of two natural LP relaxations.
We improve on both approximations by presenting a PTAS for the Firefighter problem and an $O(1)$-approximation for RMFC, both qualitatively matching the known hardness results. Our results are obtained through a combination of the known LPs with several new techniques, which allow for efficiently enumerating subsets of super-constant size of a good solution to obtain stronger LPs.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2016; v1 submitted 3 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Model-Driven Automatic Tiling with Cache Associativity Lattices
Authors:
David Adjiashvili,
Utz-Uwe Haus,
Adrian Tate
Abstract:
Traditional compiler optimization theory distinguishes three separate classes of cache miss -- Cold, Conflict and Capacity. Tiling for cache is typically guided by capacity miss counts. Models of cache function have not been effectively used to guide cache tiling optimizations due to model error and expense. Instead, heuristic or empirical approaches are used to select tilings. We argue that confl…
▽ More
Traditional compiler optimization theory distinguishes three separate classes of cache miss -- Cold, Conflict and Capacity. Tiling for cache is typically guided by capacity miss counts. Models of cache function have not been effectively used to guide cache tiling optimizations due to model error and expense. Instead, heuristic or empirical approaches are used to select tilings. We argue that conflict misses, traditionally neglected or seen as a small constant effect, are the only fundamentally important cache miss category, that they form a solid basis by which caches can become modellable, and that models leaning on cache associatvity analysis can be used to generate cache performant tilings. We develop a mathematical framework that expresses potential and actual cache misses in associative caches using Associativity Lattices. We show these lattices to possess two theoretical advantages over rectangular tiles -- volume maximization and miss regularity. We also show that to generate such lattice tiles requires, unlike rectangular tiling, no explicit, expensive lattice point counting. We also describe an implementation of our lattice tiling approach, show that it can be used to give speedups of over 10x versus unoptimized code, and despite currently only tiling for one level of cache, can already be competitive with the aggressive compiler optimizations used in general purposes compares such as GCC and Intel's ICC. We also show that the tiling approach can lead to reasonable automatic parallelism when compared to existing auto-threading compilers.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Non-Uniform Robust Network Design in Planar Graphs
Authors:
David Adjiashvili
Abstract:
Robust optimization is concerned with constructing solutions that remain feasible also when a limited number of resources is removed from the solution. Most studies of robust combinatorial optimization to date made the assumption that every resource is equally vulnerable, and that the set of scenarios is implicitly given by a single budget constraint. This paper studies a robustness model of a dif…
▽ More
Robust optimization is concerned with constructing solutions that remain feasible also when a limited number of resources is removed from the solution. Most studies of robust combinatorial optimization to date made the assumption that every resource is equally vulnerable, and that the set of scenarios is implicitly given by a single budget constraint. This paper studies a robustness model of a different kind. We focus on \textbf{bulk-robustness}, a model recently introduced~\cite{bulk} for addressing the need to model non-uniform failure patterns in systems.
We significantly extend the techniques used in~\cite{bulk} to design approximation algorithm for bulk-robust network design problems in planar graphs. Our techniques use an augmentation framework, combined with linear programming (LP) rounding that depends on a planar embedding of the input graph. A connection to cut covering problems and the dominating set problem in circle graphs is established. Our methods use few of the specifics of bulk-robust optimization, hence it is conceivable that they can be adapted to solve other robust network design problems.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Labeling Schemes for Bounded Degree Graphs
Authors:
David Adjiashvili,
Noy Rotbart
Abstract:
We investigate adjacency labeling schemes for graphs of bounded degree $Δ= O(1)$. In particular, we present an optimal (up to an additive constant) $\log n + O(1)$ adjacency labeling scheme for bounded degree trees. The latter scheme is derived from a labeling scheme for bounded degree outerplanar graphs. Our results complement a similar bound recently obtained for bounded depth trees [Fraigniaud…
▽ More
We investigate adjacency labeling schemes for graphs of bounded degree $Δ= O(1)$. In particular, we present an optimal (up to an additive constant) $\log n + O(1)$ adjacency labeling scheme for bounded degree trees. The latter scheme is derived from a labeling scheme for bounded degree outerplanar graphs. Our results complement a similar bound recently obtained for bounded depth trees [Fraigniaud and Korman, SODA 10], and may provide new insights for closing the long standing gap for adjacency in trees [Alstrup and Rauhe, FOCS 02]. We also provide improved labeling schemes for bounded degree planar graphs. Finally, we use combinatorial number systems and present an improved adjacency labeling schemes for graphs of bounded degree $Δ$ with $(e+1)\sqrt{n} < Δ\leq n/5$.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Fault-Tolerant Shortest Paths - Beyond the Uniform Failure Model
Authors:
David Adjiashvili
Abstract:
The overwhelming majority of survivable (fault-tolerant) network design models assume a uniform scenario set. Such a scenario set assumes that every subset of the network resources (edges or vertices) of a given cardinality $k$ comprises a scenario. While this approach yields problems with clean combinatorial structure and good algorithms, it often fails to capture the true nature of the scenario…
▽ More
The overwhelming majority of survivable (fault-tolerant) network design models assume a uniform scenario set. Such a scenario set assumes that every subset of the network resources (edges or vertices) of a given cardinality $k$ comprises a scenario. While this approach yields problems with clean combinatorial structure and good algorithms, it often fails to capture the true nature of the scenario set coming from applications.
One natural refinement of the uniform model is obtained by partitioning the set of resources into faulty and secure resources. The scenario set contains every subset of at most $k$ faulty resources. This work studies the Fault-Tolerant Path (FTP) problem, the counterpart of the Shortest Path problem in this failure model. We present complexity results alongside exact and approximation algorithms for FTP. We emphasize the vast increase in the complexity of the problem with respect to its uniform analogue, the Edge-Disjoint Paths problem.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
The Online Replacement Path Problem
Authors:
David Adjiashvili,
Marco Senatore
Abstract:
We study a natural online variant of the replacement path problem. The \textit{replacement path problem} asks to find for a given graph $G = (V,E)$, two designated vertices $s,t\in V$ and a shortest $s$-$t$ path $P$ in $G$, a \textit{replacement path} $P_e$ for every edge $e$ on the path $P$. The replacement path $P_e$ is simply a shortest $s$-$t$ path in the graph, which avoids the \textit{failed…
▽ More
We study a natural online variant of the replacement path problem. The \textit{replacement path problem} asks to find for a given graph $G = (V,E)$, two designated vertices $s,t\in V$ and a shortest $s$-$t$ path $P$ in $G$, a \textit{replacement path} $P_e$ for every edge $e$ on the path $P$. The replacement path $P_e$ is simply a shortest $s$-$t$ path in the graph, which avoids the \textit{failed} edge $e$. We adapt this problem to deal with the natural scenario, that the edge which failed is not known at the time of solution implementation. Instead, our problem assumes that the identity of the failed edge only becomes available when the routing mechanism tries to cross the edge. This situation is motivated by applications in distributed networks, where information about recent changes in the network is only stored locally, and fault-tolerant optimization, where an adversary tries to delay the discovery of the materialized scenario as much as possible. Consequently, we define the \textit{online replacement path problem}, which asks to find a nominal $s$-$t$ path $Q$ and detours $Q_e$ for every edge on the path $Q$, such that the worst-case arrival time at the destination is minimized. Our main contribution is a label setting algorithm, which solves the problem in undirected graphs in time $O(m \log n)$ and linear space for all sources and a single destination. We also present algorithms for extensions of the model to any bounded number of failed edges.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
