Showing 1–50 of 114 results for author: Varma, C M

Quantum-criticality in twisted bi-layer graphene

Authors: C. M. Varma

Abstract: Transport experiments in twisted bilayer graphene (TBG) show a fan-like region near integer fillings with a resistivity linear in temperature down to the lowest temperature measured. This suggests quantum-critical points at the boundaries to long-range ordered phases. The particular order proposed by Blutinck et al. for twisted bi-layer graphene (TBG) is a loop-current order at the carbon length-s… ▽ More Transport experiments in twisted bilayer graphene (TBG) show a fan-like region near integer fillings with a resistivity linear in temperature down to the lowest temperature measured. This suggests quantum-critical points at the boundaries to long-range ordered phases. The particular order proposed by Blutinck et al. for twisted bi-layer graphene (TBG) is a loop-current order at the carbon length-scale together with modulations on the moiré length scale. This is shown to be the ground state of a xy model with translational symmetry and time-reversal broken. Here, this is extended to derive a model for quantum-critical properties. We derive the quantum xy model coupled to fermions in this situation. The kinetic energy operator for the model and the coupling of fermions to the fluctuations of the xy model are derived. The previously derived universal properties in the quantum-critical region of such a model, leading to a marginal Fermi-liquid, irrespective of the underlying microscopics is briefly reviewed. The properties include the resistivity and various other transport properties with and without applying a magnetic field and the instability of the quantum fluctuating state to superconductivity in d-wave symmetry. △ Less

Submitted 27 December, 2023; v1 submitted 24 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Extended superconducting fluctuation region and 6e and 4e flux-quantization in a Kagome compound with a normal state of 3Q-order

Authors: Chandra M. Varma, Ziqiang Wang

Abstract: The superconducting state with the usual 2e-flux quantization formed from a normal state with 3Q charge density or loop-current order is a linear combination of 3 different paired states with an overall gauge invariant phase and two internal phases such that the phases in equilibrium are at $2π/3$ with respect to each other. In the fluctuation regime of such a 3-component superconductor, internal… ▽ More The superconducting state with the usual 2e-flux quantization formed from a normal state with 3Q charge density or loop-current order is a linear combination of 3 different paired states with an overall gauge invariant phase and two internal phases such that the phases in equilibrium are at $2π/3$ with respect to each other. In the fluctuation regime of such a 3-component superconductor, internal phase fluctuations are of the same class as for frustrated classical xy-spins on a triangular lattice. The fluctuation region is known therefore to be abnormally extended below the mean-field or the Kosterlitz-Thouless transition temperature. A 6e-flux and a 4e-flux quantized states can be constructed which are also eigenstates of the BCS Hamiltonian and stationary points of the Ginzburg-Landau free-energy with a transition temperature above that of the renormalized 2e-flux quantized state. Such states have no internal phases and so no frustrating internal phase fluctuations. These state however cannot acquire long-range order because their free-energy is higher than the co-existing fluctuating state of 2e flux-quantization. 6e- as well as 4e- flux-quantized Little-Parks oscillations however occur in which the resistivity increases periodically with field above that of the 2e-fluctuating state in its extended fluctuation regime, as are observed, followed at low temperatures to a condensation of the time-reversal odd 2e-quantized state △ Less

Submitted 24 May, 2024; v1 submitted 1 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: Some important references added, connection to a cascade of resistivity transitions observed in experiments made

Dark Fermions in Fluctuating Valence Insulators

Authors: C. M. Varma

Abstract: A fluctuating-valence impurity in a metal is quantum-critical unlike a Kondo impurity which has the properties of a local Fermi-liquid. A systematic theory for the fluctuating-valence lattice is constructed, based on the hybridization and pairing of itinerant d-orbitals with localized f-orbitals both of which are essential parts of the solution of the impurity problem. It also uses the fact that t… ▽ More A fluctuating-valence impurity in a metal is quantum-critical unlike a Kondo impurity which has the properties of a local Fermi-liquid. A systematic theory for the fluctuating-valence lattice is constructed, based on the hybridization and pairing of itinerant d-orbitals with localized f-orbitals both of which are essential parts of the solution of the impurity problem. It also uses the fact that the single-particle excitations at the Fermi-surface in any dimension can be written as orthogonal Majoranas and those with linear departures from the Fermi-surface as linear combination of bare particles and holes with the same spin. The calculations on the lattice give four spin-degenerate one-particle excitations of fractionalized fermions; two sets disperse across the chemical potential and the other two have gaps. The former are shown to be dark to any linear electro-magnetic probes of their charge and spin and observable only through probes of their free-energy such as a Fermi-liquid specific heat and magneto-oscillations characteristic of a Fermi-surface but without a Zeeman splitting. The excitations with the gaps behave as in insulators but with renormalized amplitudes. The superfluid density is zero. A magnetic field $H$ turns the insulator to a metal with a singularity in magnetization proportional to $\sqrt{H - H_c}$, with $H_c$ related to the gap. Beyond $H_c$, the usual Zeeman splitting appears in the magneto-oscillations. The properties and predictions are compared to the momentous recent discoveries in fluctuating-valence insulators. Similar excitations may be expected in transition metal chalcogenide layers at fluctuating-valence, and quite likely for Kagome lattices, and twisted multi-layer graphene near specific fillings. △ Less

Submitted 18 June, 2024; v1 submitted 25 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: Extended version with clear exposition of the starting basis, calculations, figures and derivation of results in comparison with experiments

Theory of melting of glasses

Authors: Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: Glassy matter like crystals resists change in shape. Therefore a theory for their continuous melting should show how the shear elastic constant $μ$ goes to zero. Since viscosity is the long wave-length low frequency limit of shear correlations, the same theory should give phenomena like the Volger-Fulcher dependence of the viscosity on temperature near the transition. A continuum model interrupted… ▽ More Glassy matter like crystals resists change in shape. Therefore a theory for their continuous melting should show how the shear elastic constant $μ$ goes to zero. Since viscosity is the long wave-length low frequency limit of shear correlations, the same theory should give phenomena like the Volger-Fulcher dependence of the viscosity on temperature near the transition. A continuum model interrupted randomly by asymmetric rigid defects with orientational degrees of freedom is considered. Such defects are orthogonal to the continuum excitations, and are required to be imprisoned by rotational motion of the nearby atoms of the continuum. The defects interact with an angle dependent $μ/r^3$ potential. A renormalization group for the elastic constants, and the fugacity of the defects in 3D is constructed. The principal results are that there is a scale-invariant reduction of $μ$ as a function of length at any temperature $T < T_0$, above which it is 0 macrosopically but has a finite correlation length $ξ(T)$ which diverges as $T \to T_0$. Viscosity is shown to be proportional to $ξ^2(T)$ and has the Vogel-Fulcher form. The specific heat is $\propto ξ^{-3}(T)$. As $T \to T_0$, the Kauzman temperature from above, the configuration entropy of the liquid is exhausted. The theory also gives the ``fragility" of glasses in terms of their $T_0/μ$. △ Less

Submitted 7 November, 2022; v1 submitted 24 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Comments: Exact solution of RG equations with same answers as before and a few typos corrected

Local magnetic moments due to loop currents in metals

Authors: Arkady Shekhter, Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: We present Hartree-Fock calculations on a simple model to obtain the conditions of formation of local magnetic moments due to loop-currents $L_o$ and spin-loop currents $L_s$ and compare them to the conditions of formation of local spin-moments $M$ which were given long ago in a similar approximation by Anderson. A model with three degenerate orbitals sitting on an equilateral triangle, with on-si… ▽ More We present Hartree-Fock calculations on a simple model to obtain the conditions of formation of local magnetic moments due to loop-currents $L_o$ and spin-loop currents $L_s$ and compare them to the conditions of formation of local spin-moments $M$ which were given long ago in a similar approximation by Anderson. A model with three degenerate orbitals sitting on an equilateral triangle, with on-site and nearest-neighbor repulsions $U$ and $V$ respectively, and inter-site kinetic energy, hybridizing with conduction electrons with a parameter $Δ$ is investigated. $L_o$ and $L_s$ are promoted by large $V/Δ$ and their magnitude is relatively unaffected by $U/Δ$. Spin-magnetic moments $M$ promoted by large $U/Δ$ on the other hand are adversely affected by $V/Δ$. In this model, $L_o$ for $V$ multiplied by the number of neighbors is approximately the same as the $M$ promoted by $U$ in Anderson's local model for $M$. $L_o$ and $L_s$ are degenerate if exchange interactions and Hund's rule are neglected but $L_o$ is favored when they are included. Many of the qualitative results are visible in an expression for the Hartree-Fock ground state energy derived as a function of small $L_o, L_s$ and $M$. Numerical minimization of the Hartree-Fock energy is presented for larger values. We also briefly discuss the connection and differences of the interaction generated orbital currents and spin-currents discussed here and generalized to a lattice with the topological states in metals and semi-conductors. △ Less

Submitted 14 December, 2022; v1 submitted 10 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Comments: 7 pages

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 106, 214419 (2022)

Quantum-critical transport of marginal Fermi-liquids

Authors: Hideaki Maebashi, Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: We present exact results for the electrical and thermal conductivity and Seebeck coefficient at low temperatures and frequencies in the quantum-critical region for fermions on a lattice scattering with the collective fluctuations of the quantum xy model. This is done by the asymptotically exact solution of the vertex equation in the Kubo formula for these transport properties. The model is applica… ▽ More We present exact results for the electrical and thermal conductivity and Seebeck coefficient at low temperatures and frequencies in the quantum-critical region for fermions on a lattice scattering with the collective fluctuations of the quantum xy model. This is done by the asymptotically exact solution of the vertex equation in the Kubo formula for these transport properties. The model is applicable to the fluctuations of the loop-current order in cuprates as well as to a class of quasi-two dimensional heavy-fermion and other metallic antiferromagnets, and proposed recently also for the possible loop-current order in Moiré twisted bi-layer graphene and bi-layer WSe$_2$. All these metals have a linear in temperature electrical resistivity in the quantum-critical region of their phase diagrams, often termed "Planckian" resistivity. The solution of the integral equation for the vertex in the Kubo equation for transport shows that all vertex renormalizations except due to Aslamazov-Larkin processes are absent. The latter appear as an Umklapp scattering matrix, which is shown to give only a temperature independent multiplicative factor for electrical resistivity which is non-zero in the pure limit only if the Fermi-surface is large enough, but do not affect thermal conductivity. We also show that the mass renormalization which gives a logarithmic enhancement of the marginal Fermi-liquid specific heat does not appear in the electrical resistivity as well as in the thermal conductivity. On the other hand the mass renormalization appears in the Seebeck coefficient. The results for transport properties are derived for any Fermi-surface on any lattice. As an example, the linear in $T$ electrical resistivity is explicitly calculated for large enough circular Fermi-surfaces on a square lattice. We also discuss in detail the conservation laws that play a crucial role in all transport properties. △ Less

Submitted 16 March, 2023; v1 submitted 25 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Comments: The revised version includes the theory for the Seebeck coefficient in addition to electrical and thermal conductivity and a more detailed summary of the earlier work on the fluctuations of the quantum xy model coupled to fermions. 48 pages, 9 figures

Quantum-critical resistivity of strange metals in a magnetic field

Authors: Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: Resistivity in the quantum-critical fluctuation region of several metallic compounds such as the cuprates, the heavy-fermions, Fe-chalogenides and pnictides, twisted bi-layer graphene and WSe$_2$, is linear in temperature $T$ as well as in a magnetic field $H$. Scattering of fermions by the excitations of a time-reversal odd polar vector field ${\bf Ω}$ characterizing loop-current fluctuations has… ▽ More Resistivity in the quantum-critical fluctuation region of several metallic compounds such as the cuprates, the heavy-fermions, Fe-chalogenides and pnictides, twisted bi-layer graphene and WSe$_2$, is linear in temperature $T$ as well as in a magnetic field $H$. Scattering of fermions by the excitations of a time-reversal odd polar vector field ${\bf Ω}$ characterizing loop-current fluctuations has been shown to give a linear in T resistivity and other anomalous properties in the cuprates. An extension of this theory to an applied magnetic field is presented. Magnetic field is shown to generate vortices in the field ${\bf Ω}$ proportional to $H_z$, the component orthogonal to the conducting planes. The elastic scattering of fermions from the vortices gives a resistivity linear in $H_z$. The coefficient of the linear in $H_z$ resistivity is predicted to vary as the marginal fermi-liquid susceptibility $\propto \ln(\frac{ω_c}{T})$ at criticality. Quantitative comparison with experiments is presented. △ Less

Submitted 19 May, 2022; v1 submitted 23 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: Improved figure for T dependence of the coefficient of linear in H resistivity in Moire' bi-layer graphene. Some minor corrections

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Letters {\bf 128}, 206601 (2022)

Intrinsic new properties of a quantum spin liquid

Authors: Yanxing Yang, Xin Li, Cheng Tan, Zihao Zhu, Jian Zhang, Zhaofeng Ding, Qiong Wu, Changshen Chen, Toni Shiroka, Yuanhua Xia, Douglas E. MacLaughlin, Chandra M. Varma, Lei Shu

Abstract: Quantum fluctuations are expected to lead to highly entangled spin-liquid states in certain two-dimensional spin-1/2 compounds. We have synthesized and measured thermodynamic properties and muon spin relaxation rates in the copper-based two-dimensional triangular-lattice spin liquids Lu$_3$Cu$_2$Sb$_3$O$_{14}$ and Lu$_3$CuZnSb$_3$O$_{14}$. The former is the least disordered of this kind discovered… ▽ More Quantum fluctuations are expected to lead to highly entangled spin-liquid states in certain two-dimensional spin-1/2 compounds. We have synthesized and measured thermodynamic properties and muon spin relaxation rates in the copper-based two-dimensional triangular-lattice spin liquids Lu$_3$Cu$_2$Sb$_3$O$_{14}$ and Lu$_3$CuZnSb$_3$O$_{14}$. The former is the least disordered of this kind discovered to date. Magnetic entropy generation at high temperatures has been ruled out after carefully correcting for the lattice specific heat. Surprisingly, roughly half of the magnetic entropy is missing down to temperatures of O(10$^{-3}$) the exchange energy, independent of magnetic field up to $gμ_B H \gtrsim k_BΘ_W$, where $Θ_W$ is the Weiss temperature. The magnetic specific heat divided by temperature $C_M(T)/T$ and muon spin relaxation rate $λ(T)$ are both temperature-independent at low temperatures, followed by logarithmic decreases with increasing temperature. This behavior can be simply characterized by scale-invariant time-dependent fluctuations with a single parameter. Since no cooperative effects due to impurities are observed, the measured properties are intrinsic. They are evidence that in Lu$_3$Cu$_2$Sb$_3$O$_{14}$ massive quantum fluctuations lead to either a gigantic specific heat peak from singlet excitations at very low temperatures or, perhaps less likely, an extensively degenerate possibly topological singlet ground state. △ Less

Submitted 21 July, 2022; v1 submitted 18 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Observation of broken inversion and chiral symmetries in the pseudogap phase in single and double layer bismuth-based cuprates

Authors: Sejoon Lim, Chandra M. Varma, Hiroshi Eisaki, Aharon Kapitulnik

Abstract: We deduce the symmetry of the pseudogap state in the single and double layer bismuth-based cuprate superconductors by measuring and analyzing their circular and linear photogalvanic responses, which are related linearly to the chirality and inversion breaking respectively of the order parameter. After separating out the trivial contribution arising from the surface where inversion symmetry is alre… ▽ More We deduce the symmetry of the pseudogap state in the single and double layer bismuth-based cuprate superconductors by measuring and analyzing their circular and linear photogalvanic responses, which are related linearly to the chirality and inversion breaking respectively of the order parameter. After separating out the trivial contribution arising from the surface where inversion symmetry is already broken, we show that both responses start below the pseudogap temperature $T^*$ and grow below it to a sizable magnitude, revealing the broken symmetries in the bulk of the crystal. Through a detailed analysis of the dependence of the signals on the angle of incidence, the polarization of the light, and the orientation of the crystal, we are able to discover that the point group symmetry below $T^*$ is limited to $mm2$ or $mm2\underline{1}$ groups. Taking into account formation of domains and previous measurements, our results narrow down the possible symmetries of the microscopic origin of the phase transition(s) at $T^*$. △ Less

Submitted 12 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: 19 pages, 9 figures

Majoranas in mixed-valence insulators

Authors: C. M. Varma

Abstract: A physical model for a mixed-valence impurity in a metal must satisfy the Friedel screening theorem for both valences. Such a model is shown, following earlier work which showed low energy singularities in it, to be supersymmetric, leading to a free Majorana and a phase-shifted Majorana excitation. The theory extended approximately to a lattice of mixed-valence ions at appropriate filling gives, w… ▽ More A physical model for a mixed-valence impurity in a metal must satisfy the Friedel screening theorem for both valences. Such a model is shown, following earlier work which showed low energy singularities in it, to be supersymmetric, leading to a free Majorana and a phase-shifted Majorana excitation. The theory extended approximately to a lattice of mixed-valence ions at appropriate filling gives, without fine-tuning the parameters, a protected gapless Majorana fermion band across the chemical potential, besides the mixed-valence particle and hole bands separated by gaps. In this situation the system is electrically neutral in linear response but has de Haas-van Alphen oscillations. This is used to explain the recently observed magneto-oscillations in mixed-valence insulators as well as their accompanying low energy thermodynamic and relaxation rate anomalies. Some predictions to test the validity of the theoretical results are provided, the most striking of which is that there should be extensive ground state entropy in such compounds. △ Less

Submitted 20 August, 2020; v1 submitted 16 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 102, 155145 (2020)

Thermal Hall effect in the pseudogap phase of cuprates

Authors: Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: The conjecture made recently by the group at Sherbrooke, that their observed anomalous thermal Hall effect in the pseudo-gap phase in the cuprates is due to phonons, is supported on the basis of an earlier result that the observed loop-current order in this phase must induce lattice distortions which are linear in the order parameter and an applied magnetic field. The lowered symmetry of the cryst… ▽ More The conjecture made recently by the group at Sherbrooke, that their observed anomalous thermal Hall effect in the pseudo-gap phase in the cuprates is due to phonons, is supported on the basis of an earlier result that the observed loop-current order in this phase must induce lattice distortions which are linear in the order parameter and an applied magnetic field. The lowered symmetry of the crystal depends on the direction of the field. A consequence is that the elastic constants change proportional to the field and are shown to induce axial thermal transport with the same symmetries as the Lorentz force enforces for the normal electronic Hall effect. Direct measurements of elastic constants in a magnetic field are suggested to verify the quantitative aspects of the results. △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 2020; v1 submitted 24 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 102, 075113 (2020)

Direct measurement of temporal correlations above the spin-glass transition by coherent resonant magnetic x-ray spectroscopy

Authors: **g** Song, Sheena K. K. Patel, Rupak Bhattacharya, Yi Yang, Sudip Pandey, Xiao M. Chen, M. Brian Maple, Eric E. Fullerton, Sujoy Roy, Claudio Mazzoli, Chandra M. Varma, Sunil K. Sinha

Abstract: In the 1970s a new paradigm was introduced that interacting quenched systems, such as a spin-glass, have a phase transition in which long time memory of spatial patterns is realized without spatial correlations. The principal methods to study the spin-glass transition, besides some elaborate and elegant theoretical constructions, have been numerical computer simulations and neutron spin echo measu… ▽ More In the 1970s a new paradigm was introduced that interacting quenched systems, such as a spin-glass, have a phase transition in which long time memory of spatial patterns is realized without spatial correlations. The principal methods to study the spin-glass transition, besides some elaborate and elegant theoretical constructions, have been numerical computer simulations and neutron spin echo measurements . We show here that the dynamical correlations of the spin-glass transition are embedded in measurements of the four-spin correlations at very long times. This information is directly available in the temporal correlations of the intensity, which encode the spin-orientation memory, obtained by the technique of resonant magnetic x-ray photon correlation spectroscopy (RM- XPCS). We have implemented this method to observe and accurately characterize the critical slowing down of the spin orientation fluctuations in the classic metallic spin glass alloy Cu(Mn) over time scales of 1 to 1000 secs. Our method opens the way for studying phase transitions in systems such as spin ices, and quantum spin liquids, as well as the structural glass transition. △ Less

Submitted 11 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: 14 pages, 9 figures

Linear in Temperature Resistivity and Associated Mysteries

Authors: Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: Recent experimental results: (i) the measurement of the $T \ln T$ specific heat in cuprates and the earlier such results in some heavy fermion compounds, (ii) the measurement of the single-particle scattering rates, (iii) the density fluctuation spectrum in cuprates and (iv) the long standing results on the linear temperature dependence of the resistivity, show that a theory of the quantum-critica… ▽ More Recent experimental results: (i) the measurement of the $T \ln T$ specific heat in cuprates and the earlier such results in some heavy fermion compounds, (ii) the measurement of the single-particle scattering rates, (iii) the density fluctuation spectrum in cuprates and (iv) the long standing results on the linear temperature dependence of the resistivity, show that a theory of the quantum-criticality in these compounds based on the solution of the dissipative 2D - XY model gives the temperature and frequency dependence of each of them, and the magnitudes of all four with one dimensionless coupling parameter. These low frequency or temperature dependences persist to an upper cut-off which is measured to be about the same from the singularity in the specific heat or the saturation of the single-particle self-energy. The same two parameters are deduced in the analysis of results of photoemission experiments to give d-wave superconductivity and its transition temperature. The coupling parameter and the cut-off had been estimated in the microscopic theory to within a factor of 2. The simplicity of the results depends on the discovery that orthogonal topological excitations in space and in time determine the fluctuations near criticality such that the space and time metrics are free of each other. The interacting fermions then form a marginal Fermi-liquid. △ Less

Submitted 10 February, 2020; v1 submitted 15 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: A section summarizing that the parameters determining d-wave superconductivity and the transition temperature are the same as determining the normal state marginal fermi-liquid is added. A few other improvements including discussion of the "Planckina" coefficient determining the linear in T resistivity have been made. To be published as Review of Modern Physics-colloque

Journal ref: Rev. Mod. Phys. 92, 31001 (2020)

Pseudogap and Fermi-arcs in underdoped cuprates

Authors: Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: The proposed loop-current order in cuprates cannot give the observed pseudogap and the Fermi-arcs because it preserves translation symmetry. A modification to a periodic arrangement of the four possible orientations of the order parameter with a large period of between about 12 to 30 lattice constants is proposed and shown in a simple and controlled calculation to give one-particle spectra with ev… ▽ More The proposed loop-current order in cuprates cannot give the observed pseudogap and the Fermi-arcs because it preserves translation symmetry. A modification to a periodic arrangement of the four possible orientations of the order parameter with a large period of between about 12 to 30 lattice constants is proposed and shown in a simple and controlled calculation to give one-particle spectra with every feature as in the ARPES experiments. The results follow from (1) the currents at the boundaries of the periodic domains with similar topology as the Affleck-Marston flux phase, and (2) the mixing introduced by the boundary currents between the states near the erstwhile Fermi-surface and the ghost Fermi-surfaces which are displaced from it by mini-reciprocal vectors. The proposed idea can be ruled out or verified by high resolution diffraction or imaging experiments. It does not run afoul of the variety of different experiments consistent with the loop-current order as well as the theory of the marginal Fermi-liquid and d-wave superconductivity based on quantum-critical fluctuations of the loop current order. △ Less

Submitted 22 March, 2019; v1 submitted 11 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 99, 224516 (2019)

Renormalizations in unconventional superconducting states born of normal and singular Fermi-liquids

Authors: Kazumasa Miyake, Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: The density of low energy particle-hole excitations is non-analytic in a singular Fermi-liquid, but it is altered on entering a superconducting state in which, in the pure limit, it vanishes asymptotically at the chemical potential and in general is analytic. The single-particle excitations in the superconducting states are then quasi-particles so that a form of Landau theory may be constructed fo… ▽ More The density of low energy particle-hole excitations is non-analytic in a singular Fermi-liquid, but it is altered on entering a superconducting state in which, in the pure limit, it vanishes asymptotically at the chemical potential and in general is analytic. The single-particle excitations in the superconducting states are then quasi-particles so that a form of Landau theory may be constructed for thermodynamic and transport properties in the superconducting state. In this theory, the renormalization of measurable properties due to quasi-particle interactions, such as specific heat, compressibility, magnetic susceptibility, superfluid density, etc. changes in a temperature dependent fashion from the non-interacting theory. This is illustrated by showing the renormalization of these quantities and the relation between the parameters introduced to account for their temperature dependence. When the renormalizations in the normal state are large or singular, temperature dependence of properties in the superconducting states are then in general not useful for identifying the nodal character or symmetry of the superconducting state except for measurements at very low temperatures, upper limits of which are specified. The results obtained are expected to be useful in interpreting the experimental results for the temperature dependence of various properties in the superconducting state born of singular Fermi liquids. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 98, 174501 (2018)

Chiral spin-order in some purported Kitaev spin-liquid compounds

Authors: K. A. Modic, B. J. Ramshaw, A. Shekhter, C. M. Varma

Abstract: We examine recent magnetic torque measurements in two compounds, $γ$-Li$_2$IrO$_3$ and RuCl$_3$, which have been discussed as possible realizations of the Kitaev model. The analysis of the reported discontinuity in torque, as an external magnetic field is rotated across the $c-$axis in both crystals, suggests that they have a translationally-invariant chiral spin-order of the from… ▽ More We examine recent magnetic torque measurements in two compounds, $γ$-Li$_2$IrO$_3$ and RuCl$_3$, which have been discussed as possible realizations of the Kitaev model. The analysis of the reported discontinuity in torque, as an external magnetic field is rotated across the $c-$axis in both crystals, suggests that they have a translationally-invariant chiral spin-order of the from $<{\bf S}_i. ({\bf S}_j ~\times ~ {\bf S}_k)> \ne 0$ in the ground state and persisting over a very wide range of magnetic field and temperature. An extra-ordinary $|B|B^2$ dependence of the torque for small fields, beside the usual $B^2$ part, is predicted due to the chiral spin-order, and found to be consistent with experiments upon further analysis of the data. Other experiments such as inelastic scattering and thermal Hall effect and several questions raised by the discovery of chiral spin-order, including its topological consequences are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 6 November, 2018; v1 submitted 17 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: Clearer figures of the experimental data provided. Also clearer exposition and comment on related recent work

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 98, 205110 (2018)

Quantum critical singularities in two-dimensional metallic XY ferromagnets

Authors: Chandra M. Varma, W. J. Gannon, M. C. Aronson, J. A. Rodriguez-Rivera, Y. Qiu

Abstract: An important problem in contemporary physics concerns quantum-critical fluctuations in metals. A scaling function for the momentum, frequency, temperature and magnetic field dependence of the correlation function near a 2D-ferromagnetic quantum-critical point (QCP) is constructed, and its singularities are determined by comparing to the recent calculations of the correlation functions of the dissi… ▽ More An important problem in contemporary physics concerns quantum-critical fluctuations in metals. A scaling function for the momentum, frequency, temperature and magnetic field dependence of the correlation function near a 2D-ferromagnetic quantum-critical point (QCP) is constructed, and its singularities are determined by comparing to the recent calculations of the correlation functions of the dissipative quantum XY model (DQXY). The calculations are motivated by the measured properties of the metallic compound YFe$_2$Al$_{10}$, which is a realization of the DQXY model in 2D. The frequency, temperature and magnetic field dependence of the scaling function as well as the singularities measured in the experiments are given by the theory without adjustable exponents. The same model is applicable to the superconductor-insulator transitions, classes of metallic AFM-QCPs, and as fluctuations of the loop-current ordered state in hole-doped cuprates. The results presented here lend credence to the solution found for the 2D-DQXY model, and its applications in understanding quantum-critical properties of diverse systems. △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2018; v1 submitted 1 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: Experimental results on dynamics near the quantum-critical point have been added with some additions in the text to point out their correspondence with theory. Some corrections have also been made

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 97, 085134 (2018)

Dynamic structure function of some singular Fermi-liquids

Authors: Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: The density correlations of some singular Fermi liquids with anomalous properties such as resistivity varying linearly with T at low temperatures, a $T \log T$ contribution to the entropy and thermopower, etc., are expected to be quite different from that in Landau Fermi liquids. A possible statistical mechanical model for the quantum critical fluctuations in diverse systems with such properties i… ▽ More The density correlations of some singular Fermi liquids with anomalous properties such as resistivity varying linearly with T at low temperatures, a $T \log T$ contribution to the entropy and thermopower, etc., are expected to be quite different from that in Landau Fermi liquids. A possible statistical mechanical model for the quantum critical fluctuations in diverse systems with such properties is the 2D dissipative quantum XY model. Exact relations between the density correlations and singular irreducible vertices due to coupling of Fermions to the topological excitations of the 2D dissipative quantum XY model are used to derive results which were proposed phenomenologically long ago but are measurable only recently due to advances in experimental techniques. The density correlations are unusual at all momenta ${\bf q}$ and energy $ν$, from the hydrodynamic limit to that for large momenta and energy. The hydrodynamic limit together with the continuity equation gives the linear in T resistivity. The density correlations are almost independent of frequency up to a high frequency cut-off for $q_{ZB} \gtrsim q >> ν/v_F$; $q_{ZB}$ is the Brillouin zone boundary and $v_F$ is the Fermi-velocity. The results should be applicable to loop-current quantum criticality in cuprates, and to 2D Fe based compounds near their antiferromagnetic quantum-criticality. The relation of the results to the temperature and frequency dependent conductivity and to Raman response is also discussed. △ Less

Submitted 5 August, 2017; v1 submitted 19 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: Some corrections

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 96, 075122 (2017)

Crossovers due to anisotropy and disorder in quantum critical fluctuations

Authors: Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: Scaling relations are used to study cross-overs, due to anisotropic spin interactions or single ion anisotropy, and due to disorder, in the thermodynamics and correlation functions near quantum-critical transitions. The principal results are simple with a wide range of applications. The region of attraction to the stable anisotropic fixed point in the quantum-critical region is exponentially enhan… ▽ More Scaling relations are used to study cross-overs, due to anisotropic spin interactions or single ion anisotropy, and due to disorder, in the thermodynamics and correlation functions near quantum-critical transitions. The principal results are simple with a wide range of applications. The region of attraction to the stable anisotropic fixed point in the quantum-critical region is exponentially enhanced by the dynamical critical exponent $z$ compared to the region of attraction to the fixed point in the quantum disordered region. The result implies that, even for small anisotropy, the region of attraction to the stable incommensurate Ising or planar metallic anti-ferromagnetic critical points, which belong to the universality class of the XY model with $z \to \infty$, covers the entire quantum-critical region. In crossovers due to disorder, the instability of the pure fixed point in the quantum disordered region is exponentially enhanced by $z$ compared to that in the quantum-critical region. This result suggests that for some classes of disorder and for large enough $z$, one may find singularities in the correlations as a function of frequency and temperature down to very low temperatures even though the correlation length in space remains short range. △ Less

Submitted 17 June, 2018; v1 submitted 13 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Comments: Discovered several ambiguous statements and some errors

Quantum criticality in the two-dimensional dissipative quantum XY model-II

Authors: Lijun Zhu, Changtao Hou, Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: Earlier Monte-Carlo calculations on the dissipative two-dimensional XY model are extended in several directions. We study the phase diagram and the correlation functions when dissipation is very small, where it has properties of the classical 3D-XY transition, i.e. one with a dynamical critical exponent $z=1$. The transition changes from $z=1$ to the class of criticality with $z \to \infty$ driven… ▽ More Earlier Monte-Carlo calculations on the dissipative two-dimensional XY model are extended in several directions. We study the phase diagram and the correlation functions when dissipation is very small, where it has properties of the classical 3D-XY transition, i.e. one with a dynamical critical exponent $z=1$. The transition changes from $z=1$ to the class of criticality with $z \to \infty$ driven by topological defects, discovered earlier, beyond a critical dissipation. We also find that the critical correlations have power-law singularities as a function of tuning the ratio of the kinetic energy to the potential energy for fixed large dissipation, as opposed to essential singularities on tuning dissipation kee** the former fixed. A phase with temporal disorder but spatial order of the Kosterlitz-Thouless form is also further investigated. We also present results for the transition when the allowed Caldeira-Leggett form of dissipation and the allowed form of dissipation coupling to the compact rotor variables are both included. The nature of the transition is then determined by the Caldeira-Leggett form. △ Less

Submitted 1 January, 2017; v1 submitted 26 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Comments: Improvements in presentation and addition of a section with results for periodic form of dissipation

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 94, 235156 (2016)

Phase diagram and quantum-criticality of the two dimensional dissipative quantum XY model

Authors: Changtao Hou, Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: The two-dimensional dissipative quantum XY model is applicable to the quantum-critical properties of diverse experimental systems, ranging from the superconductor to insulator transitions, ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic transitions in metals, to the loop-current order transition in the cuprates. We solve the re-expression of this model in terms of topological excitations: vortices and a varie… ▽ More The two-dimensional dissipative quantum XY model is applicable to the quantum-critical properties of diverse experimental systems, ranging from the superconductor to insulator transitions, ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic transitions in metals, to the loop-current order transition in the cuprates. We solve the re-expression of this model in terms of topological excitations: vortices and a variety of instantons, by renormalization group methods. The calculations explain the extraordinary properties of the model discovered in Monte-Carlo calculations: the separability of the quantum critical fluctuations (QCF) in space and time, the spatial correlation length proportional to logarithm of the temporal correlation length near the transition from disordered to the fully ordered state, and the occurrence of a phase with spatial order without temporal order. They are intimately related to the flow of the metric of time in relation to the metric of space, i.e. of the dynamical critical exponent $z$. These properties appear to be essential in understanding the strange metallic phase found in a variety of quantum-critical transitions as well as the accompanying high temperature superconductivity. △ Less

Submitted 4 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 94, 201101 (2016)

Quantum-Critical Fluctuations in 2D Metals: Strange Metals and Superconductivity in Antiferromagnets and in Cuprates

Authors: Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: The anomalous transport and thermodynamic properties in the quantum-critical region, in the cuprates, and in the quasi-two dimensional Fe-based superconductors and heavy-fermion compounds, have the same temperature dependences. This can occur only if, despite their vast microscopic differences, a common statistical mechanical model describes their phase transitions. The antiferromagnetic (AFM)-ic… ▽ More The anomalous transport and thermodynamic properties in the quantum-critical region, in the cuprates, and in the quasi-two dimensional Fe-based superconductors and heavy-fermion compounds, have the same temperature dependences. This can occur only if, despite their vast microscopic differences, a common statistical mechanical model describes their phase transitions. The antiferromagnetic (AFM)-ic models for the latter two, just as the loop-current model for the cuprates, map to the dissipative XY model. The solution of this model in 2+1 D reveals that the critical fluctuations are determined by topological excitations, vortices and a variety of instantons, and not by renormalized spin-wave theories of the Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson type, adapted by Moriya, Hertz and others for quantum-criticality. The absorptive part of the fluctuations is a separable function of momentum ${\bf q}$, measured from the ordering vector, and of the frequency $ω$ and the temperature $T$ which scale as $\tanh(ω/2T)$ at criticality. Direct measurements of the fluctuations by neutron scattering in the quasi-two-dimensional heavy fermion and Fe-based compounds, near their antiferromagnetic quantum critical point, are consistent with this form. Such fluctuations, together with the vertex coupling them to fermions, lead to a marginal fermi-liquid, with the imaginary part of the self-energy $\propto max(ω, T)$ for all momenta, a resistivity $\propto T$, a $T \ln T$ contribution to the specific heat, and other singular fermi-liquid properties common to these diverse compounds, as well as to d-wave superconductivity. This is explicitly verified, in the cuprates, by analysis of the pairing and the normal self-energy directly extracted from the recent high resolution angle resolved photoemission measurements. △ Less

Submitted 14 May, 2016; v1 submitted 13 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Comments: Invited review on special issue on Correlated Fermions in J. Phys. C. Improved version

Quantitative Determination of the Pairing Interactions for High Temperature Superconductivity in Cuprates

Authors: ** Mo Bok, Jong Ju Bae, Han-Yong Choi, Chandra M. Varma, Wentao Zhang, Junfeng He, Yuxiao Zhang, Li Yu, X. J. Zhou

Abstract: A profound problem in modern condensed matter physics is discovering and understanding the nature of the fluctuations and their coupling to fermions in cuprates which lead to high temperature superconductivity and the invariably associated strange metal state. Here we report the quantitative determination of the normal and pairing self-energies, made possible by laser-based angle-resolved photoemi… ▽ More A profound problem in modern condensed matter physics is discovering and understanding the nature of the fluctuations and their coupling to fermions in cuprates which lead to high temperature superconductivity and the invariably associated strange metal state. Here we report the quantitative determination of the normal and pairing self-energies, made possible by laser-based angle-resolved photoemission measurements with unprecedented accuracy and stability. Through a precise inversion procedure, both the effective interactions in the attractive d-wave symmetry and the repulsive part in the full symmetry are determined. The latter are nearly angle independent. Near Tc both interactions are nearly independent of frequency, and have almost the same magnitude, over the complete energy range of up to about 0.4 eV except for a low energy feature around 50 meV present only in the repulsive part which has less than 10% of the total spectral weight. Well below Tc, they both change similarly by superconductivity induced features at low energies. Besides finding the pairing self-energy and the attractive interactions for the first time, these results expose a central paradox of the high Tc problem: how the same frequency independent fluctuations can dominantly scatter at angles +-pi/2 in the attractive channel as well as lead to angle-independent repulsive scattering. The experimental results are compared with the available theoretical calculations based on antiferromagnetic fluctuations, Hubbard model and the quantum-critical fluctuations of loop-current order. △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Comments: 41 Pages, 9 Figures, Including Supplementary Materials, Accepted in Science Advances

Journal ref: Science Advances 2, e1501329 (2016)

Quantum critical response function in quasi-two dimensional itinerant antiferromagnets

Authors: C. M. Varma, Lijun Zhu, Almut Schröder

Abstract: We re-examine the experimental results for the magnetic response function $χ''({\bf q}, E, T)$, for ${\bf q}$ around the anti-ferromagnetic vectors ${\bf Q}$, in the quantum-critical region, obtained by inelastic neutron scattering, on an Fe-based superconductor, and on a heavy Fermion compound. The motivation is to compare the results with a recent theory, which shows that the fluctuations in a g… ▽ More We re-examine the experimental results for the magnetic response function $χ''({\bf q}, E, T)$, for ${\bf q}$ around the anti-ferromagnetic vectors ${\bf Q}$, in the quantum-critical region, obtained by inelastic neutron scattering, on an Fe-based superconductor, and on a heavy Fermion compound. The motivation is to compare the results with a recent theory, which shows that the fluctuations in a generic anti-ferromagnetic model for itinerant fermions map to those in the universality class of the dissipative quantum-XY model. The quantum-critical fluctuations in this model, in a range of parameters, are given by the correlations of spatial and of temporal topological defects. The theory predicts a $χ''({\bf q}, E, T)$ (i) which is a separable function of $({\bf q -Q})$ and of ($E$,$T$), (ii) at crticality, the energy dependent part is $\propto \tanh (E/2T)$ below a cut-off energy, (iii) the correlation time departs from its infinite value at criticality on the disordered side by an essential singularity, and (iv) the correlation length depends logarithmically on the correlation time, so that the dynamical critical exponent $z$ is $\infty$ . The limited existing experimental results are found to be consistent with the first two unusual predictions from which the linear dependence of the resistivity on T and the $T \ln T$ dependence of the entropy also follow. More experiments are suggested, especially to test the theory of variations on the correlation time and length on the departure from criticality. △ Less

Submitted 8 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 92, 155150 (2015)

Quantum Criticality in Quasi-Two Dimensional Itinerant Antiferromagnets

Authors: C. M. Varma

Abstract: Quasi-two dimensional itinerant fermions in the Anti-Ferro-Magnetic (AFM) quantum-critical region of their phase diagram, such as in the Fe-based superconductors or in some of the heavy-fermion compounds, exhibit a resistivity varying linearly with temperature and a contribution to specific heat or thermopower proportional to $T \ln T$. It is shown here that a generic model of itinerant AFM can be… ▽ More Quasi-two dimensional itinerant fermions in the Anti-Ferro-Magnetic (AFM) quantum-critical region of their phase diagram, such as in the Fe-based superconductors or in some of the heavy-fermion compounds, exhibit a resistivity varying linearly with temperature and a contribution to specific heat or thermopower proportional to $T \ln T$. It is shown here that a generic model of itinerant AFM can be canonically transformed such that its critical fluctuations around the AFM-vector $Q$ can be obtained from the fluctuations in the long wave-length limit of a dissipative quantum XY model. The fluctuations of the dissipative quantum XY model in 2D have been evaluated recently and in a large regime of parameters, they are determined, not by renormalized spin-fluctuations but by topological excitations. In this regime, the fluctuations are separable in their spatial and temporal dependence and have a dynamical critical exponent $z =\infty.$ The time dependence gives $ω/T$-scaling at criticality. The observed resistivity and entropy then follow directly. Several predictions to test the theory are also given. △ Less

Submitted 7 November, 2015; v1 submitted 2 February, 2015; originally announced February 2015.

Comments: A supplementary section providing the derivation of the marginal fermi liquid single particle self energy is given and some other improvements made

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 186405 (2015)

Local Quantum Criticality in the Two-dimensional Dissipative Quantum XY Model

Authors: Lijun Zhu, Yan Chen, Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: We use quantum Monte-Carlo simulations to calculate the phase diagram and the correlation functions for the quantum phase transitions in the two-dimensional dissipative XY model with and without four-fold anisotropy. Without anisotropy, the model describes the superconductor to insulator transition in two-dimensional dirty superconductors. With anisotropy, the model represents the loop-current ord… ▽ More We use quantum Monte-Carlo simulations to calculate the phase diagram and the correlation functions for the quantum phase transitions in the two-dimensional dissipative XY model with and without four-fold anisotropy. Without anisotropy, the model describes the superconductor to insulator transition in two-dimensional dirty superconductors. With anisotropy, the model represents the loop-current order observed in the under-doped cuprates and its fluctuations, as well as the fluctuations near the ordering vector in simple models of itinerant antiferromagnets. These calculations test an analytic solution of the model which re-expressed it in terms of topological excitations - the vortices with interactions only in space but none in time, and warps with leading interactions only in time but none in space, as well as sub-leading interactions which are both space and time-dependent. For parameters for which the proliferation of warps dominates the phase transition, the critical fluctuations as a function of the deviation of the dissipation parameter $α$ from its critical value $α_c$ are scale-invariant in imaginary time $τ$ as the correlation length in time $ξ_τ = τ_c e^{|α_c/(α_c-α)|^{1/2}}$ diverges. On the other hand, the spatial correlations develop with a correlation length $ξ_x \approx ξ_0 \log{(ξ_τ)}$, with $ξ_0$ of the order of a lattice constant. The dynamic correlation exponent $z$ is therefore $\infty$. These results are consistent with the phenomenology proposed for the strange metal properties of the cuprates. The Monte-Carlo calculations also directly show warps and vortices. Their density and correlations across the various transitions in the model are calculated and related to those of the order parameter in the original model. △ Less

Submitted 26 April, 2015; v1 submitted 22 December, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Comments: 31 pages, 14 figures, submitted to Phys. Rev. B

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 91, 205129 (2015)

Landau Renormalizations of Superfluid density in Heavy Fermion Superconductor CeCoIn5

Authors: Lei Shu, D. E. MacLaughlin, C. M. Varma, O. O. Bernal, P. -C. Ho, R. H. Fukuda, X. P. Shen, M. B. Maple

Abstract: The formation of heavy fermion bands can occur by means of the conversion of a periodic array of local moments into itinerant electrons via the Kondo effect and the huge consequent Fermi-liquid renormalizations. Leggett predicted for liquid $^3$He that Fermi-liquid renormalizations change in the superconducting state, leading to a temperature dependence of the London penetration depth~$Λ$ quite di… ▽ More The formation of heavy fermion bands can occur by means of the conversion of a periodic array of local moments into itinerant electrons via the Kondo effect and the huge consequent Fermi-liquid renormalizations. Leggett predicted for liquid $^3$He that Fermi-liquid renormalizations change in the superconducting state, leading to a temperature dependence of the London penetration depth~$Λ$ quite different from that in the BCS theory. Using Leggett's theory, as modified for heavy fermions, it is possible to extract from the measured temperature dependence of $Λ$ in high quality samples both Landau parameters $F_0^s$ and $F_1^s$; this has never been accomplished before. A modification of the temperature dependence of the specific heat $C_\mathrm{el}$, related to that of $Λ$, is also expected. We have carefully determined the magnitude and temperature dependence of $Λ$ in CeCoIn$_5$ by muon spin relaxation rate measurements to obtain $F_0^s = 36 \pm 1$ and $F_1^s = 1.2 \pm 0.3$, and find a consistent change in the temperature dependence of electronic specific heat $C_\mathrm{el}$. This, the first determination of $F_1^s$ with a value~$\ll F_0^s$ in a heavy fermion compound, tests the basic assumption of the theory of heavy fermions, that the frequency dependence of the self-energy is much more important than its momentum dependence. △ Less

Submitted 11 October, 2014; originally announced October 2014.

Comments: Accepted by Phys. Rev. Lett

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 113 166401 (2014)

Amplitude / Higgs Modes in Condensed Matter Physics

Authors: David Pekker, C. M. Varma

Abstract: The order parameter and its variations in space and time in many different states in condensed matter physics at low temperatures are described by the complex function $Ψ({\bf r}, t)$. These states include superfluids, superconductors, and a subclass of antiferromagnets and charge-density waves. The collective fluctuations in the ordered state may then be categorized as oscillations of phase and a… ▽ More The order parameter and its variations in space and time in many different states in condensed matter physics at low temperatures are described by the complex function $Ψ({\bf r}, t)$. These states include superfluids, superconductors, and a subclass of antiferromagnets and charge-density waves. The collective fluctuations in the ordered state may then be categorized as oscillations of phase and amplitude of $Ψ({\bf r}, t)$. The phase oscillations are the {\it Goldstone} modes of the broken continuous symmetry. The amplitude modes, even at long wavelengths, are well defined and decoupled from the phase oscillations only near particle-hole symmetry, where the equations of motion have an effective Lorentz symmetry as in particle physics, and if there are no significant avenues for decay into other excitations. They bear close correspondence with the so-called {\it Higgs} modes in particle physics, whose prediction and discovery is very important for the standard model of particle physics. In this review, we discuss the theory and the possible observation of the amplitude or Higgs modes in condensed matter physics -- in superconductors, cold-atoms in periodic lattices, and in uniaxial antiferromagnets. We discuss the necessity for at least approximate particle-hole symmetry as well as the special conditions required to couple to such modes because, being scalars, they do not couple linearly to the usual condensed matter probes. △ Less

Submitted 9 February, 2015; v1 submitted 11 June, 2014; originally announced June 2014.

Comments: 39 pages, 12 figures. Replaced with published version; Annual Reviews of Condensed Matter Physics Volume 6 (2015)

Specific Heat and Sound Velocity Distinguish the Relevant Competing Phase in the Pseudogap Region of High Temperature Superconductors

Authors: Chandra M. Varma, Lijun Zhu

Abstract: A great step forward towards the understanding of high temperature superconductors are the variety of experimental results which have led to the wide-spread acceptance of the idea that a phase with a broken symmetry competes with superconductivity in the under-doped region, often called the pseudo-gap region. There are a plethora of suggested phases. The idea, that a broken symmetry phase competes… ▽ More A great step forward towards the understanding of high temperature superconductors are the variety of experimental results which have led to the wide-spread acceptance of the idea that a phase with a broken symmetry competes with superconductivity in the under-doped region, often called the pseudo-gap region. There are a plethora of suggested phases. The idea, that a broken symmetry phase competes with superconductivity makes thermodynamic sense only if the energy gained due to it is comparable to that gained through the superconducting transition in their co-existence region. Extraordinarily, however, no specific heat signature of a phase transition has been identified at the pseudo-gap temperature $T^*$. We use the recent highly accurate sound-velocity measurements and the best available specific heat measurements in YBa$_2$Cu$_3$O$_{6+δ}$ to show that phase transitions to the universality class of the loop-current ordered state with free-energy reduction similar to the measured superconducting condensation are consistent with the sound velocity and with lack of identifiable observation in the specific heat. We also compare the measured specific heat with some more usual transitions and show that transitions with such symmetry classes can easily be shown by existing specific heat measurements to have energy reduction due to them less than 1/20 the superconducting condensation energy. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2014; originally announced April 2014.

Journal ref: PNAS 112, 6331 (2015)

Zeeman Modulated Spin Echo in Orthorhombic Symmetry

Authors: Changtao Hou, D. E. MacLaughlin, C. M. Varma

Abstract: The experimental study of the modulation of the envelope of spin-echo signals due to internal and external fields is an important spectroscopic tool to detect very small internal magnetic fields. We derive the free induction decay and the frequency spectrum and amplitude of spin-echo signals for arbitrary orientation of fields with respect to crystalline axis for nuclei in a crystal of orthorhombi… ▽ More The experimental study of the modulation of the envelope of spin-echo signals due to internal and external fields is an important spectroscopic tool to detect very small internal magnetic fields. We derive the free induction decay and the frequency spectrum and amplitude of spin-echo signals for arbitrary orientation of fields with respect to crystalline axis for nuclei in a crystal of orthorhombic symmetry. Results reproduce the results that no modulation should be observed in tetragonal crystals for fields either along the c-axis or any direction in the basal plane and give details of the signal as a function of the orthorhombicity parameter. They are used to discuss recent experimental results and provide guidelines for future experiments. △ Less

Submitted 5 February, 2014; originally announced February 2014.

Gyrotropic Birefringence in the Under-doped Cuprates

Authors: C. M. Varma

Abstract: The optical effects due to the loop-current order parameter in under-doped cuprates are studied in order to understand the recent observation of unusual birefringence in electromagnetic propagation in under-doped cuprates. It is shown why birefringence occurs even in multiple domains of order with size of domains much smaller than the wave-length and in twinned samples. Not only is there a rotatio… ▽ More The optical effects due to the loop-current order parameter in under-doped cuprates are studied in order to understand the recent observation of unusual birefringence in electromagnetic propagation in under-doped cuprates. It is shown why birefringence occurs even in multiple domains of order with size of domains much smaller than the wave-length and in twinned samples. Not only is there a rotation of polarization of incident light but also a rotation of the principal optical axis from the crystalline axes. Both are calculated in relative agreement with experiments in terms of the same parameters. The magnitude of the effect is orders of magnitude larger than the unusual Kerr effect observed in under-doped cuprates earlier. The new observations, including their comparison with the Kerr effect, test the symmetry of the proposed order decisively and confirm the conclusions from polarized neutron scattering. △ Less

Submitted 30 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Paraelectric and Ferroelectric States in a Model for Relaxor Ferroelectrics

Authors: G. G. Guzmán-Verri, P. B. Littlewood, C. M. Varma

Abstract: We study the free energy landscape of a minimal model for relaxor ferroelectrics. Using a variational method which includes leading correlations beyond the mean-field approximation as well as disorder averaging at the level of a simple replica theory, we find metastable paraelectric states with a stability region that extends to zero temperature. The free energy of such states exhibits an essentia… ▽ More We study the free energy landscape of a minimal model for relaxor ferroelectrics. Using a variational method which includes leading correlations beyond the mean-field approximation as well as disorder averaging at the level of a simple replica theory, we find metastable paraelectric states with a stability region that extends to zero temperature. The free energy of such states exhibits an essential singularity for weak compositional disorder pointing to their necessary occurrence. Ferroelectric states appear as local minima in the free energy at high temperatures and become stable below a coexistence temperature $T_c$. We calculate the phase diagram in the electric field-temperature plane and find a coexistence line of the polar and non-polar phases which ends at a critical point. First-order phase transitions are induced for fields sufficiently large to cross the region of stability of the metastable paraelectric phase. These polar and non-polar states have distinct structure factors from those of conventional ferroelectrics. We use this theoretical framework to compare and to gain physical understanding of various experimental results in typical relaxors. △ Less

Submitted 9 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: 10 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 88, 134106 (2013)

Pseudogap in Cuprates and other Metals or How to Almost Elude Bloch's Theorem

Authors: C. M. Varma

Abstract: The loop-current state discovered in under-doped cuprates is characterized by a vector ${\bf Ω}$ which has four possible orientations which correspond to different domains of order in a perfect sample. Since translational symmetry remains unchanged in the pure limit, no gap occurs at the chemical potential. On the other hand Scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) has revealed that the magnitude of th… ▽ More The loop-current state discovered in under-doped cuprates is characterized by a vector ${\bf Ω}$ which has four possible orientations which correspond to different domains of order in a perfect sample. Since translational symmetry remains unchanged in the pure limit, no gap occurs at the chemical potential. On the other hand Scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) has revealed that the magnitude of the pseudo-gap in under-doped cuprates varies spatially and is correlated with disorder. For disorder coupling also to the direction of ${\bf Ω}$, there can only be a finite temperature dependent static correlation length for the loop-current state below the ordering temperature of the pure problem. It is shown that, in this situation, singular forward scattering of fermions for large correlation lengths induces an angle dependent pseudo-gap in the single-particle spectral function near the chemical potential. The peaks in the spectral function at the fermi-vectors are away from the chemical potential proportionally to the square of the average loop order parameter measurable by polarized neutron scattering. This result is tested. Due to the finite correlation length there always exist low frequency excitations at long wavelength at all temperatures in the "ordered" phase. Such fluctuations motionally average over the shifts in frequencies of local probes such as NMR and muon resonance expected for a truly static order. △ Less

Submitted 30 December, 2014; v1 submitted 4 July, 2013; originally announced July 2013.

Comments: Improved version

Journal ref: J. Phys.: Condens. Matter, volume 26, 505701 (2014)

Sharp low energy feature in single-particle spectra due to forward scattering in $d$-wave cuprate superconductors

Authors: Seung Hwan Hong, ** Mo Bok, Wentao Zhang, Junfeng He, X. J. Zhou, Chandra M. Varma, Han-Yong Choi

Abstract: There is an enormous interest in renormalization of quasi-particle (qp) dispersion relation of cuprate superconductors both below and above the critical temperature $T_c$ because it enables determination of the fluctuation spectrum to which the qps are coupled. A remarkable discovery by angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) is a sharp low energy feature (LEF) in qp spectra well below t… ▽ More There is an enormous interest in renormalization of quasi-particle (qp) dispersion relation of cuprate superconductors both below and above the critical temperature $T_c$ because it enables determination of the fluctuation spectrum to which the qps are coupled. A remarkable discovery by angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) is a sharp low energy feature (LEF) in qp spectra well below the superconducting energy gap but with its energy increasing in proportion to $T_c$ and its intensity increasing sharply below $T_c$. This unexpected feature needs to be reconciled with $d$-wave superconductivity. Here, we present a quantitative analysis of ARPES data from Bi$_2$Sr$_2$CaCu$_2$O$_{8+δ}$ (Bi2212) using Eliashberg equations to show that the qp scattering rate due to the forward scattering impurities far from the Cu-O planes is modified by the energy gap below $T_c$ and shows up as the LEF. This is also a necessary step to analyze ARPES data to reveal the spectrum of fluctuations promoting superconductivity. △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2014; v1 submitted 16 June, 2013; originally announced June 2013.

Comments: 11 pages, 7 figure, 1 table, Accepted for publication in Phys Rev Lett, Includes the Supplemental Material

Journal ref: PRL 113, 057001 (2014)

Intrinsic Anomalous Hall Effect in Magneto-Chiral States

Authors: Yan He, P. A. Lee, C. M. Varma

Abstract: We show that a finite Hall effect in zero applied magnetic field occurs for partially filled bands in certain time-reversal violating states with zero net flux per unit-cell. These states are the Magneto-chiral states with parameters in the effective one-particle Hamiltonian such that they do not satisfy the Haldane-type constraints for topological electronic states. The results extend an earlier… ▽ More We show that a finite Hall effect in zero applied magnetic field occurs for partially filled bands in certain time-reversal violating states with zero net flux per unit-cell. These states are the Magneto-chiral states with parameters in the effective one-particle Hamiltonian such that they do not satisfy the Haldane-type constraints for topological electronic states. The results extend an earlier discussion of the Kerr effect observed in the cuprates but may be applicable to other experimental situations. △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2014; v1 submitted 30 May, 2013; originally announced May 2013.

Comments: published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 89, 035119 (2014)

Phase Diagram of a Three Orbital Model for the high-T$_c$ cuprates

Authors: Cedric Weber, Thierry Giamarchi, Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: We study the phase diagram of an effective three orbital model of the cuprates using Variational Monte-Carlo calculations (VMC) on asymptotically large lattices and exact diagonalization on a 24-site cluster. States with ordered orbital current loops (LC), itinerant Anti-ferromagnetism (AFM), d-wave superconductivity (SC), and the Fermi-liquid (FL) are investigated using appropriate Slater determi… ▽ More We study the phase diagram of an effective three orbital model of the cuprates using Variational Monte-Carlo calculations (VMC) on asymptotically large lattices and exact diagonalization on a 24-site cluster. States with ordered orbital current loops (LC), itinerant Anti-ferromagnetism (AFM), d-wave superconductivity (SC), and the Fermi-liquid (FL) are investigated using appropriate Slater determinants refined by Jastrow functions for on-site and inter-site correlations. We find an LC state stable in the thermodynamic limit for a range of parameters compatible with the Fermi surface of a typical hole doped superconductors provided the transfer integrals between the oxygen atoms have signs determined by the effects of indirect transfer through the Cu-4s orbitals as suggested by O.K. Andersen. The results of the calculations are that this phase gives way at lower do**s to an AFM phase and at larger co**s to a SC phase followed by a FL phase. △ Less

Submitted 30 May, 2013; originally announced May 2013.

Superconducting Transition Temperatures for Spin-Fluctuation Promoted Superconductivity in Heavy Fermion Compounds

Authors: Shinya Nishiyama, K. Miyake, C. M. Varma

Abstract: The quantum critical Antiferromagnetic (AFM) fluctuation spectra measured by inelastic neutron scattering recently in two heavy fermion superconductors are used together with their other measured properties to calculate their D-wave superconducting transition temperatures $T_{\rm c}$. To this end, the linearized Eliashberg equations for D-wave superconductivity induced by AFM fluctuations are solv… ▽ More The quantum critical Antiferromagnetic (AFM) fluctuation spectra measured by inelastic neutron scattering recently in two heavy fermion superconductors are used together with their other measured properties to calculate their D-wave superconducting transition temperatures $T_{\rm c}$. To this end, the linearized Eliashberg equations for D-wave superconductivity induced by AFM fluctuations are solved in models of fermions with various levels of nesting. The results for the ratio of $T_{\rm c}$ to the characteristic spin-fluctuation energy are well parametrized by a dimensionless coupling constant and the AFM correlation length. Comparing the results with experiments suggests that one may reasonably conclude that superconductivity in these compounds is indeed caused by AFM fluctuations. This conclusion is strengthened by a calculation with the same parameters of the measured coefficient of the normal state quantum-critical resistivity $\propto T^{3/2}$ characteristic of {\it gaussian} AFM quantum-critical fluctuations. The calculations give details of the superconducting coupling as a function of the correlation length and the integrated fluctuation spectra useful in other compounds. △ Less

Submitted 22 July, 2013; v1 submitted 8 February, 2013; originally announced February 2013.

Journal ref: Physical Review B 88, 014510 (2013)

Structure Factor of a Relaxor Ferroelectric

Authors: G. G. Guzmán-Verri, C. M. Varma

Abstract: We study a minimal model for a relaxor ferroelectric including dipolar interactions, and short-range harmonic and anharmonic forces for the critical modes as in the theory of pure ferroelectrics together with quenched disorder coupled linearly to the critical modes. We present the simplest approximate solution of the model necessary to obtain the principal features of the correlation functions. Sp… ▽ More We study a minimal model for a relaxor ferroelectric including dipolar interactions, and short-range harmonic and anharmonic forces for the critical modes as in the theory of pure ferroelectrics together with quenched disorder coupled linearly to the critical modes. We present the simplest approximate solution of the model necessary to obtain the principal features of the correlation functions. Specifically, we calculate and compare the structure factor measured by neutron scattering in different characteristic regimes of temperature in the relaxor PbMg$_{1/3}$Nb$_{2/3}$O$_3$. △ Less

Submitted 21 April, 2015; v1 submitted 14 December, 2012; originally announced December 2012.

Comments: 7 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 91, 144105 (2015)

Collective modes in singlet superconductors

Authors: Yafis Barlas, C. M. Varma

Abstract: A brief summary of collective mode excitations that can exist in singlet superconductors with irreducible representation $L$ is given. Such excitations may be classified as the coupled excitations of the charge density $ρ$ and the phase $φ$ of the order parameter, or of the amplitude $Δ$ of order parameter. Each of these classes may be further characterized in the long wavelength limit by the irre… ▽ More A brief summary of collective mode excitations that can exist in singlet superconductors with irreducible representation $L$ is given. Such excitations may be classified as the coupled excitations of the charge density $ρ$ and the phase $φ$ of the order parameter, or of the amplitude $Δ$ of order parameter. Each of these classes may be further characterized in the long wavelength limit by the irreducible representation $\ell$ of the excitation, which may or may not be the same as the ground state $L$. △ Less

Submitted 30 November, 2012; originally announced November 2012.

Comments: An addendum to our earlier paper titled "Higgs modes in D-wave Superconductors"

Coexistence of Two Sharp-Mode Couplings and Their Unusual Momentum Dependence in the Superconducting State of Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8+d Superconductor Revealed by Laser-Based Angle-Resolved Photoemission

Authors: Junfeng He, Wentao Zhang, ** Mo Bok, Daixiang Mou, Lin Zhao, Yingying Peng, Shaolong He, Guodong Liu, Xiaoli Dong, Jun Zhang, J. S. Wen, Z. J. Xu, G. D. Gu, Xiaoyang Wang, Qinjun Peng, Zhimin Wang, Shen** Zhang, Feng Yang, Chuangtian Chen, Zuyan Xu, H. -Y. Choi, C. M. Varma, X. J. Zhou

Abstract: Super-high resolution laser-based angle-resolved photoemission measurements have been carried out on Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8+d (Bi2212) superconductors to investigate momentum dependence of electron coupling with collective excitations (modes). Two coexisting energy scales are clearly revealed over a large momentum space for the first time in the superconducting state of an overdoped Bi2212 superconductor.… ▽ More Super-high resolution laser-based angle-resolved photoemission measurements have been carried out on Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8+d (Bi2212) superconductors to investigate momentum dependence of electron coupling with collective excitations (modes). Two coexisting energy scales are clearly revealed over a large momentum space for the first time in the superconducting state of an overdoped Bi2212 superconductor. These two energy scales exhibit distinct momentum dependence: one keeps its energy near 78 meV over a large momentum space while the other changes its energy from $\sim$40 meV near the antinodal region to $\sim$70 meV near the nodal region. These observations provide a new picture on momentum evolution of electron-boson coupling in Bi2212 that electrons are coupled with two sharp modes simultaneously over a large momentum space in the superconducting states. Their unusual momentum dependence poses a challenge to our current understanding of electron-mode-coupling and its role for high temperature superconductivity in cuprate superconductors. △ Less

Submitted 2 October, 2012; originally announced October 2012.

Comments: 14 Pages, 4 Figures

Journal ref: Physical Review Letters 111 (2013) 107005

Fermi pockets in a d-wave superconductor with coexisting loop-current order

Authors: S. A. Kivelson, C. M. Varma

Abstract: A d-wave superconducting phase with coexisting intra-unit-cell orbital current order has the remarkable property that it supports finite size Fermi pockets of Bougoliubov quasiparticles. Experimentally detectable consequences of this include a residual $T$-linear term in the specific heat in the absence of disorder and residual features in the thermal and microwave conductivity in the low disorder… ▽ More A d-wave superconducting phase with coexisting intra-unit-cell orbital current order has the remarkable property that it supports finite size Fermi pockets of Bougoliubov quasiparticles. Experimentally detectable consequences of this include a residual $T$-linear term in the specific heat in the absence of disorder and residual features in the thermal and microwave conductivity in the low disorder limit. △ Less

Submitted 31 August, 2012; originally announced August 2012.

Comments: 4 pages, 2 figures

Higgs Bosons in D-wave Superconductors

Authors: Yafis Barlas, C. M. Varma

Abstract: The concept of "broken symmetry", that the symmetry of the vacuum may be lower than the Hamiltonian of a quantum theory, plays an important role in modern physics. A manifestation of this phenomena is the Higgs boson in particle physics whose long awaited discovery is imminent. An equivalent mode in superconductors is implicit in the early theories of their collective fluctuations. Spurred by some… ▽ More The concept of "broken symmetry", that the symmetry of the vacuum may be lower than the Hamiltonian of a quantum theory, plays an important role in modern physics. A manifestation of this phenomena is the Higgs boson in particle physics whose long awaited discovery is imminent. An equivalent mode in superconductors is implicit in the early theories of their collective fluctuations. Spurred by some mysterious experimental results, the theory of the oscillation of the amplitude of superconductivity order parameter, which is the equivalent to the Higgs modes in s-wave superconductors and its identification in the experiments, was explicitly provided. It was also shown that a necessary condition for this to occur is the emergent Lorentz invariance in the superconducting state while the metallic state and the region just below $T_c$ is manifestly non-Lorentz invariant. Here we show that d-wave superconductors, such as the high temperature Cuprate superconductors, should have a rich assortment of Higgs bosons, each in a different irreducible representation of the point-group symmetries of the lattice. We also show that these modes have a characteristic singular spectral structure which can be discovered in Raman scattering experiments. △ Less

Submitted 2 June, 2012; originally announced June 2012.

Theory of Polarized Neutron Scattering in the Loop Ordered Phase of Cuprates

Authors: Yan He, C. M. Varma

Abstract: The collective modes observed in the loop-current ordered state in under-doped cuprates by polarized neutron scattering require that the ground state is a linear combination in each unit-cell of the four basis states which are the possible classical magnetic moment configurations in each unit-cell. The direction of such moments is in the c-axis of the crystals. The basis states are connected by bo… ▽ More The collective modes observed in the loop-current ordered state in under-doped cuprates by polarized neutron scattering require that the ground state is a linear combination in each unit-cell of the four basis states which are the possible classical magnetic moment configurations in each unit-cell. The direction of such moments is in the c-axis of the crystals. The basis states are connected by both time-reversal as well as spatial rotations about the center of the unit-cells. Several new features arise in the theory of polarized neutron scattering cross-section in this situation which appear not to have been encountered before. An important consequence of these is that a finite component transverse to the classical magnetic moment directions is detected in the experiments. We show that this transverse component is of purely quantum-mechanical origin and that its direction in the plane normal to the c-axis is not detectable, even in principle, in experiments, at least in the quantum-mechanical model we have adopted. We estimate the direction of the "tilt" in the moment, i.e. the ratio of the transverse component to the c-axis component, using parameters of the ground state obtained by fitting to the observed dispersion of the collective modes in the ordered state. We can obtain reasonable agreement with experiments but only by introducing a parameter for which only an approximate magnitude can be estimated. Approximate calculations of the form-factors are also provided. △ Less

Submitted 28 March, 2012; v1 submitted 27 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: 12 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 86, 035124 (2012)

Ordered Loop Current States in Bilayer Graphene

Authors: Lijun Zhu, Vivek Aji, Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: While single-layer graphene shows extraordinary phenomena which are stable against electronic interactions, the non-interacting state of bilayer graphene is unstable to infinitesimal interactions leading to one of many possible exotic states. Indeed a gapped state is found in experiments but none of the states proposed so far can provide full accounts of its properties. Here we show that a magneto… ▽ More While single-layer graphene shows extraordinary phenomena which are stable against electronic interactions, the non-interacting state of bilayer graphene is unstable to infinitesimal interactions leading to one of many possible exotic states. Indeed a gapped state is found in experiments but none of the states proposed so far can provide full accounts of its properties. Here we show that a magnetoelectric (ME) state is consistent with the experimental observations. This state breaks time-reversal symmetry through a pair of spontaneously generated current loops in each layer, and has odd-parity with respect to the two layers. We also suggest further experiments to check whether the ME state is indeed the gapped state found in experiments. △ Less

Submitted 6 February, 2013; v1 submitted 3 February, 2012; originally announced February 2012.

Comments: 8 pages, 10 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 87, 035427 (2013)

Collective Modes in the Loop Current Ordered Phase of Cuprates

Authors: Yan He, C. M. Varma

Abstract: Recently two branches of weakly dispersive collective modes have been discovered in under-doped cuprates by inelastic neutron scattering. Polarization analysis reveals that the modes are magnetic excitations. They are only visible for temperatures below the transition temperature to a broken symmetry phase which was discovered earlier and their intensity increases as temperature is further decreas… ▽ More Recently two branches of weakly dispersive collective modes have been discovered in under-doped cuprates by inelastic neutron scattering. Polarization analysis reveals that the modes are magnetic excitations. They are only visible for temperatures below the transition temperature to a broken symmetry phase which was discovered earlier and their intensity increases as temperature is further decreased. The broken symmetry phase itself has symmetries consistent with ordering of orbital current loops within a unit-cell without breaking translational symmetry. In order to calculate the collective modes of such a state we add quantum terms to the Ashkin-Teller (AT) model with which the classical loop current order has been described. We derive that the mean field ground state of the quantum model is a product over all unit-cells of linear combination of the four possible classical configurations of the loop current order in each unit-cell. The collective modes are calculated by using a generalized Holstein-Primakoff boson representation of orbital moment operators and lead to three branches of gapped weakly dispersive collective modes. The experimental results are consistent with the two lower energy branches; the third mode is at a higher energy than looked for by present neutron scattering experiments and might also be over-damped. Implications of the discovery of the collective modes are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 28 January, 2012; originally announced January 2012.

Comments: 16 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 85, 155102 (2012)

A variational method in the problem of screening an external charge in strongly correlated metals

Authors: G. G. Guzmán-Verri, Arkady Shekhter, C. M. Varma

Abstract: We describe a variational calculation for the problem of screening of a point charge in a layered correlated metal for do**s close to the Mott transition where the screening is non-linear due to the proximity to the incompressible insulating state. We find that external charge can induce locally incompressible regions and that the non-linear dependence of the screening on density can induce over… ▽ More We describe a variational calculation for the problem of screening of a point charge in a layered correlated metal for do**s close to the Mott transition where the screening is non-linear due to the proximity to the incompressible insulating state. We find that external charge can induce locally incompressible regions and that the non-linear dependence of the screening on density can induce overscreening in the nearest nearby layers while preserving overall charge neutrality. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2013; v1 submitted 23 January, 2012; originally announced January 2012.

Comments: 7 pages, 1 figure, final version as published

Journal ref: EPL, 103 (2013) 27003

Berry phase and Anomalous Hall Effect in a Three-orbital Tight-binding Hamiltonian

Authors: Yan He, Joel Moore, C. M. Varma

Abstract: We consider the Anomalous Hall (AH) state induced by interactions in a three-orbital per unit-cell model. To be specific we consider a model appropriate for the Copper-Oxide lattice to highlight the necessary conditions for time-reversal breaking states which are AH states and which are not. We compare the singularities of the wave-functions of the three-orbital model, which are related to the non… ▽ More We consider the Anomalous Hall (AH) state induced by interactions in a three-orbital per unit-cell model. To be specific we consider a model appropriate for the Copper-Oxide lattice to highlight the necessary conditions for time-reversal breaking states which are AH states and which are not. We compare the singularities of the wave-functions of the three-orbital model, which are related to the nonzero Berry curvature, and their variation with a change of gauge to those in the two-orbital model introduced in a seminal paper by Haldane. Explicit derivation using wave-functions rather than the more powerful abstract methods may provide additional physical understanding of the phenomena. △ Less

Submitted 3 January, 2012; v1 submitted 29 December, 2011; originally announced December 2011.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 85, 155106 (2012)

Superconductivity in the Cuprates: Deduction of Mechanism for D-Wave Pairing Through Analysis of ARPES

Authors: Han-Yong Choi, C. M. Varma, Xingjiang Zhou

Abstract: In the Eliashberg integral equations for d-wave superconductivity, two different functions $(α^2 F)_n(ω, θ)$ and $(α^2 F)_{p,d}(ω)$ determine, respectively, the "normal" and the "pairing" self-energies. We present a quantitative analysis of the high-resolution laser based ARPES data on the compound Bi-2212 to deduce the function$(α^2 F)_n(ω, θ)$. Besides its detailed $ω$ dependence, we find the re… ▽ More In the Eliashberg integral equations for d-wave superconductivity, two different functions $(α^2 F)_n(ω, θ)$ and $(α^2 F)_{p,d}(ω)$ determine, respectively, the "normal" and the "pairing" self-energies. We present a quantitative analysis of the high-resolution laser based ARPES data on the compound Bi-2212 to deduce the function$(α^2 F)_n(ω, θ)$. Besides its detailed $ω$ dependence, we find the remarkable result that this function is nearly independent of $θ$ between the ($π,π$)-direction and 25 degrees from it. Assuming that the same fluctuations determine both the normal and the pairing self-energy, we ask what theories give the function $(α^2 F)_{p,d}(ω)$ required for the d-wave pairing instability at high temperatures as well as the deduced $(α^2 F)_n(θ, ω)$. We show that the deduced $(α^2 F)_n(θ, ω)$ can only be obtained from Antiferromagnetic (AFM) fluctuations if their correlation length is smaller than a lattice constant. Using $(α^2 F)_{p,d}(ω)$ consistent with such a correlation length and the symmetry of matrix-elements scattering fermions off AFM fluctuations, we calculate $T_c$ an show that AFM fluctuations are excluded as the pairing mechanism for d-wave superconductivity in cuprates. We also consider the quantum-critical fluctuations derived microscopically as the fluctuations of the observed loop-current order discovered in the under-doped cuprates. We show that their frequency dependence and the momentum dependence of their matrix-elements to scatter fermions are consistent with the $θ$ and $ω$ dependence of the deduced $(α^2 F)_n(ω, θ)$. The pairing kernel $(α^2 F)_{p,d}(ω)$ calculated using the experimental values in the Eliashberg equation gives $d-wave$ instability at $T_c$ comparable to the experiments. △ Less

Submitted 25 October, 2011; originally announced October 2011.

Analysis of Laser ARPES from Bi$_2$Sr$_2$CaCu$_2$O$_{8+δ}$ in superconductive state: angle resolved self-energy and fluctuation spectrum

Authors: Jae Hyun Yun, ** Mo Bok, Han-Yong Choi, Wentao Zhang, X. J. Zhou, Chandra M. Varma

Abstract: We analyze the ultra high resolution laser angle resolved photo-emission spectroscopy (ARPES) intensity from the slightly underdoped Bi$_2$Sr$_2$CaCu$_2$O$_{8+δ}$ in the superconductive (SC) state. The momentum distribution curves (MDC) were fitted at each energy $\w$ employing the SC Green's function along several cuts perpendicular to the Fermi surface with the tilt angle $θ$ with respect to the… ▽ More We analyze the ultra high resolution laser angle resolved photo-emission spectroscopy (ARPES) intensity from the slightly underdoped Bi$_2$Sr$_2$CaCu$_2$O$_{8+δ}$ in the superconductive (SC) state. The momentum distribution curves (MDC) were fitted at each energy $\w$ employing the SC Green's function along several cuts perpendicular to the Fermi surface with the tilt angle $θ$ with respect to the nodal cut. The clear observation of particle-hole mixing was utilized such that the complex self-energy as a function of $ω$ is directly obtained from the fitting. The obtained angle resolved self-energy is then used to deduce the Eliashberg function $α^2 F^{(+)}(þ,\w)$ in the diagonal channel by inverting the d-wave Eliashberg equation using the maximum entropy method. Besides a broad featureless spectrum up to the cutoff energy $ω_c$, the deduced $α^2 F$ exhibits two peaks around 0.05 eV and 0.015 eV. The former and the broad feature are already present in the normal state, while the latter emerges only below $T_c$. Both peaks become enhanced as $T$ is lowered or the angle $þ$ moves away from the nodal direction. The implication of these findings are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 28 September, 2011; v1 submitted 8 August, 2011; originally announced August 2011.

Comments: 7 pages, 5 figures, summited to PRB

Journal ref: Physical Review B 84, 104521 (2011)

Extraction of Electron Self-Energy and Gap Function in the Superconducting State of Bi_2Sr_2CaCu_2O_8 Superconductor via Laser-Based Angle-Resolved Photoemission

Authors: Wentao Zhang, ** Mo Bok, Jae Hyun Yun, Junfeng He, Guodong Liu, Lin Zhao, Haiyun Liu, Jianqiao Meng, Xiaowen Jia, Yingying Peng, Daixiang Mou, Shanyu Liu, Li Yu, Shaolong He, Xiaoli Dong, Jun Zhang, J. S. Wen, Z. J. Xu, G. D. Gu, Guiling Wang, Yong Zhu, Xiaoyang Wang, Qinjun Peng, Zhimin Wang, Shen** Zhang , et al. (6 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: Super-high resolution laser-based angle-resolved photoemission measurements have been performed on a high temperature superconductor Bi_2Sr_2CaCu_2O_8. The band back-bending characteristic of the Bogoliubov-like quasiparticle dispersion is clearly revealed at low temperature in the superconducting state. This makes it possible for the first time to experimentally extract the complex electron self-… ▽ More Super-high resolution laser-based angle-resolved photoemission measurements have been performed on a high temperature superconductor Bi_2Sr_2CaCu_2O_8. The band back-bending characteristic of the Bogoliubov-like quasiparticle dispersion is clearly revealed at low temperature in the superconducting state. This makes it possible for the first time to experimentally extract the complex electron self-energy and the complex gap function in the superconducting state. The resultant electron self-energy and gap function exhibit features at ~54 meV and ~40 meV, in addition to the superconducting gap-induced structure at lower binding energy and a broad featureless structure at higher binding energy. These information will provide key insight and constraints on the origin of electron pairing in high temperature superconductors. △ Less

Submitted 18 March, 2011; originally announced March 2011.

Comments: 4 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Physical Review B 85 (2012) 064514