-
Revealing novel aspects of light-matter coupling in terahertz two-dimensional coherent spectroscopy: the case of the amplitude mode in superconductors
Authors:
Kota Katsumi,
Jacopo Fiore,
Mattia Udina,
Ralph Romero III,
David Barbalas,
John Jesudasan,
Pratap Raychaudhuri,
Goetz Seibold,
Lara Benfatto,
N. P. Armitage
Abstract:
Recently developed terahertz (THz) two-dimensional coherent spectroscopy (2DCS) is a powerful technique to obtain materials information in a fashion qualitatively different from other spectroscopies. Here, we utilized THz 2DCS to investigate the THz nonlinear response of conventional superconductor NbN. Using broad-band THz pulses as light sources, we observed a third-order nonlinear signal whose…
▽ More
Recently developed terahertz (THz) two-dimensional coherent spectroscopy (2DCS) is a powerful technique to obtain materials information in a fashion qualitatively different from other spectroscopies. Here, we utilized THz 2DCS to investigate the THz nonlinear response of conventional superconductor NbN. Using broad-band THz pulses as light sources, we observed a third-order nonlinear signal whose spectral components are peaked at twice the superconducting gap energy $2Δ$. With narrow-band THz pulses, a THz nonlinear signal was identified at the driving frequency $Ω$ and exhibited a resonant enhancement at temperature when $Ω= 2Δ$. General theoretical considerations show that such a resonance can only arise from a disorder-activated paramagnetic coupling between the light and the electronic current. This proves that the nonlinear THz response can access processes distinct from the diamagnetic Raman-like density fluctuations, which are believed to dominate the nonlinear response at optical frequencies in metals. Our numerical simulations reveal that even for a small amount of disorder, the $Ω=2Δ$ resonance is dominated by the superconducting amplitude mode over the entire investigated disorder range. This is in contrast to other resonances, whose amplitude-mode contribution depends on disorder. Our findings demonstrate the unique ability of THz 2DCS to explore collective excitations inaccessible in other spectroscopies.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2024; v1 submitted 27 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Manipulating Plasma Excitations with Terahertz Light Pulses in Superconducting Cuprates
Authors:
Jacopo Fiore,
Niccolò Sellati,
Francesco Gabriele,
Claudio Castellani,
Goetz Seibold,
Mattia Udina,
Lara Benfatto
Abstract:
Layered cuprates offer a preferential playground for optical non-linearity thanks to the emergence, below Tc, of soft out-of-plane Josephson plasmons. The hallmark of such a non-linearity is the observation of Third Harmonic Generation, that has been theoretically understood as a sum-frequency process involving a two-plasmon excitation. However, recent experiments in cuprates with two planes per u…
▽ More
Layered cuprates offer a preferential playground for optical non-linearity thanks to the emergence, below Tc, of soft out-of-plane Josephson plasmons. The hallmark of such a non-linearity is the observation of Third Harmonic Generation, that has been theoretically understood as a sum-frequency process involving a two-plasmon excitation. However, recent experiments in cuprates with two planes per unit cell challenge this interpretation, due to the lack of resonant response at the temperature where the driving frequency matches the plasma energy scale, as observed instead in single-layer cuprates. Here we show that such an apparent discrepancy in bilayer systems can be resolved by taking into account the combined effect of light polarization and Josephson-coupling anisotropy on setting the energy range where three-dimensional layered plasma modes can be resonantly excited. Our results offer a novel perspective on the possibility to tune on demand high-harmonic generation by artificially designing Josephson heterostructures.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Tracing the dynamics of superconducting order via transient third harmonic generation
Authors:
Min-Jae Kim,
Sergey Kovalev,
Mattia Udina,
Rafael Haenel,
Gideok Kim,
Matteo Puviani,
Georg Cristiani,
Igor Ilyakov,
Thales V. A. G. de Oliveira,
Alexey Ponomaryov,
Jan-Christoph Deinert,
Gennady Logvenov,
Bernhard Keimer,
Dirk Manske,
Lara Benfatto,
Stefan Kaiser
Abstract:
Ultrafast optical control of quantum systems is an emerging field of physics. In particular, the possibility of light-driven superconductivity with ultrashort laser pulses has attracted much of attention. To identify non-equilibrium superconductivity, it is necessary to measure fingerprints of superconductivity on ultrafast timescales. Recently non-linear THz third harmonic generation (THG) was sh…
▽ More
Ultrafast optical control of quantum systems is an emerging field of physics. In particular, the possibility of light-driven superconductivity with ultrashort laser pulses has attracted much of attention. To identify non-equilibrium superconductivity, it is necessary to measure fingerprints of superconductivity on ultrafast timescales. Recently non-linear THz third harmonic generation (THG) was shown to directly probe the collective degrees of freedoms of the superconducting condensate including particularly the Higgs mode. Here we extend this idea to light-driven non-equilibrium states in superconducting La2-xSrxCuO4 establishing a protocol to access the transient superconducting (SC) order-parameter fluctuations. We perform an optical pump-THz-THG drive experiment and use a two-dimensional spectroscopy approach to disentangle the driven third-harmonic response of optically excited quasiparticles and the pure condensate response. In this way, 2D spectroscopy separately probes both the ultrafast pair breaking dynamics and transient pairing amplitude of the condensate.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Terahertz ionic Kerr effect: Two-phonon contribution to the nonlinear optical response in insulators
Authors:
Martina Basini,
Mattia Udina,
Matteo Pancaldi,
Vivek Unikandanunni,
Stefano Bonetti,
Lara Benfatto
Abstract:
The THz Kerr effect measures the birefringence induced in an otherwise isotropic material by a strong THz pulse driving the Raman-active excitations of the systems. Here we provide experimental evidence of a sizable Kerr response in insulating SrTiO3 due to infrared-active lattice vibrations. Such a signal, named ionic Kerr effect, is associated with the simultaneous excitation of multiple phonons…
▽ More
The THz Kerr effect measures the birefringence induced in an otherwise isotropic material by a strong THz pulse driving the Raman-active excitations of the systems. Here we provide experimental evidence of a sizable Kerr response in insulating SrTiO3 due to infrared-active lattice vibrations. Such a signal, named ionic Kerr effect, is associated with the simultaneous excitation of multiple phonons. Thanks to a theoretical modeling of the time, polarization and temperature dependence of the birefringence we can disentangle the ionic Kerr effect from the off-resonant electronic excitations, providing an alternative tunable mechanism to modulate the refractive index on ultrashort time-scales via infra-red active phonons.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2024; v1 submitted 25 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Terahertz electric-field driven dynamical multiferroicity in SrTiO$_3$
Authors:
M. Basini,
M. Pancaldi,
B. Wehinger,
M. Udina,
T. Tadano,
M. C. Hoffmann,
A. V. Balatsky,
S. Bonetti
Abstract:
The emergence of collective order in matter is among the most fundamental and intriguing phenomena in physics. In recent years, the ultrafast dynamical control and creation of novel ordered states of matter not accessible in thermodynamic equilibrium is receiving much attention. Among those, the theoretical concept of dynamical multiferroicity has been introduced to describe the emergence of magne…
▽ More
The emergence of collective order in matter is among the most fundamental and intriguing phenomena in physics. In recent years, the ultrafast dynamical control and creation of novel ordered states of matter not accessible in thermodynamic equilibrium is receiving much attention. Among those, the theoretical concept of dynamical multiferroicity has been introduced to describe the emergence of magnetization by means of a time-dependent electric polarization in non-ferromagnetic materials. In simple terms, a large amplitude coherent rotating motion of the ions in a crystal induces a magnetic moment along the axis of rotation. However, the experimental verification of this effect is still lacking. Here, we provide evidence of room temperature magnetization in the archetypal paraelectric perovskite SrTiO$_3$ due to this mechanism. To achieve it, we resonantly drive the infrared-active soft phonon mode with intense circularly polarized terahertz electric field, and detect a large magneto-optical Kerr effect. A simple model, which includes two coupled nonlinear oscillators whose forces and couplings are derived with ab-initio calculations using self-consistent phonon theory at a finite temperature, reproduces qualitatively our experimental observations on the temporal and frequency domains. A quantitatively correct magnitude of the effect is obtained when one also considers the phonon analogue of the reciprocal of the Einsten - de Haas effect, also called the Barnett effect, where the total angular momentum from the phonon order is transferred to the electronic one. Our findings show a new path for designing ultrafast magnetic switches by means of coherent control of lattice vibrations with light.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Contribution of Collective Excitations to Third Harmonic Generation in Multiband Superconductors: the case of MgB$_2$
Authors:
Jacopo Fiore,
Mattia Udina,
Marco Marciani,
Goetz Seibold,
Lara Benfatto
Abstract:
Multiband superconductors can host collective excitations with marked differences with respect to their single-band counterpart. We first study the spectrum of collective amplitude fluctuations in a clean two-bands superconductor, showing that the spectral weight of the Higgs mode rapidly deviates from the naive extension of the single band case as the interband coupling is turned on. These result…
▽ More
Multiband superconductors can host collective excitations with marked differences with respect to their single-band counterpart. We first study the spectrum of collective amplitude fluctuations in a clean two-bands superconductor, showing that the spectral weight of the Higgs mode rapidly deviates from the naive extension of the single band case as the interband coupling is turned on. These results are then used to critically analyze the non-linear optical response in MgB$_2$, providing an explanation for the apparently contradictory results of recent experiments, pointing towards a selective relevance either of the Leggett mode or of the amplitude fluctuations at twice the lower gap. By using exact numerical simulations and realistic estimate of disorder we compute the relative contribution of the quasiparticle, amplitude and phase fluctuations to the non-linear optical response. We show that at low pum** frequency only the resonance at twice the smaller gap emerges, as due to the BCS response, while the Leggett mode dominates only in a narrow range of higher pum** frequencies matching its low-temperature value. Our findings provide a fresh perspective on the potential of non-linear THz spectroscopy to detect collective modes in other multiband systems, as e.g. iron-based superconductors.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Terahertz displacive excitation of a coherent Raman-active phonon in V$_2$O$_3$
Authors:
Flavio Giorgianni,
Mattia Udina,
Tommaso Cea,
Eugenio Paris,
Marco Caputo,
Milan Radovic,
Larissa Boie,
Joe Sakai,
Christof W. Schneider,
Steven Lee Johnson
Abstract:
Nonlinear processes involving frequency-mixing of light fields set the basis for ultrafast coherent spectroscopy of collective modes in solids. In certain semimetals and semiconductors, generation of coherent phonon modes can occur by a displacive force on the lattice at the difference-frequency mixing of a laser pulse excitation on the electronic system. Here, as a low-frequency counterpart of th…
▽ More
Nonlinear processes involving frequency-mixing of light fields set the basis for ultrafast coherent spectroscopy of collective modes in solids. In certain semimetals and semiconductors, generation of coherent phonon modes can occur by a displacive force on the lattice at the difference-frequency mixing of a laser pulse excitation on the electronic system. Here, as a low-frequency counterpart of this process, we demonstrate that coherent phonon excitations can be induced by the sum-frequency components of an intense terahertz light field, coupled to intraband electronic transitions. This nonlinear process leads to charge-coupled coherent dynamics of Raman-active phonon modes in the strongly correlated metal V$_2$O$_3$. Our results show a new up-conversion pathway for the optical control of Raman-active modes in solids mediated by terahertz-driven electronic excitation.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
THz non-linear optical response in cuprates: predominance of the BCS response over the Higgs mode
Authors:
Mattia Udina,
Jacopo Fiore,
Tommaso Cea,
Claudio Castellani,
Goetz Seibold,
Lara Benfatto
Abstract:
Recent experiments with strong THz fields in unconventional cuprates superconductors have clearly evidenced an increase of the non-linear optical response below the superconducting critical temperature Tc. As in the case of conventional superconductors, a theoretical estimate of the various effects contributing to the non-linear response is needed in order to interpret the experimental findings. H…
▽ More
Recent experiments with strong THz fields in unconventional cuprates superconductors have clearly evidenced an increase of the non-linear optical response below the superconducting critical temperature Tc. As in the case of conventional superconductors, a theoretical estimate of the various effects contributing to the non-linear response is needed in order to interpret the experimental findings. Here we report a detailed quantitative analysis of the non-linear THz optical kernel in cuprates within a realistic model, accounting for the band structure and disorder level appropriate for these systems. We show that the BCS quasiparticle response is the dominant contribution for cuprates, and its polarization dependence accounts very well for the third-harmonic generation measurements. On the other hand, the polarization dependence of the THz Kerr effect is only partly captured by our calculations, suggesting the presence of additional effects when the system is probed using light pulses with different central frequencies.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Third harmonic generation from collective modes in disordered superconductors
Authors:
G. Seibold,
M. Udina,
C. Castellani,
L. Benfatto
Abstract:
Recent experiments with strong THz fields in both conventional and unconventional superconductors have clearly evidenced a marked third-harmonic generation below the superconducting temperature $T_c$. Its interpretation challenged substantial theoretical work aimed at establishing the relative efficiency of quasiparticle excitations and collective modes in triggering such a resonant response. Here…
▽ More
Recent experiments with strong THz fields in both conventional and unconventional superconductors have clearly evidenced a marked third-harmonic generation below the superconducting temperature $T_c$. Its interpretation challenged substantial theoretical work aimed at establishing the relative efficiency of quasiparticle excitations and collective modes in triggering such a resonant response. Here we compute the non-linear current by implementing a time-dependent Bogoljubov de-Gennes approach, with the twofold aim to account non-perturbatively for the effect of local disorder, and to include the contribution of all collective modes, i.e. superconducting amplitude (Higgs) and phase fluctuations, and charge fluctuations. We show that, in agreement with previous work, already at small disorder the quasiparticle response is dominated by paramagnetic effects. We further demonstrate that paramagnetic processes mediate also the response of all collective modes, with a substantial contribution of charge/phase fluctuations. These processes, which have been overlooked so far, turn out to dominate the third-order current at strong disorder. In addition, we show that disorder strongly influences the polarization dependence of the non-linear response, with a marked difference between the clean and the disordered case. Our results are particularly relevant for recent experiments in cuprates, whose band structure is in a first approximation reproduced by our lattice model.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Non-linear Terahertz Driving of Plasma Waves in Layered Cuprates
Authors:
Francesco Gabriele,
Mattia Udina,
Lara Benfatto
Abstract:
The hallmark of superconductivity is the rigidity of the quantum-mechanical phase of electrons, responsible for superfluid behavior and Meissner effect. The strength of the phase stiffness is set by the Josephson coupling, which is strongly anisotropic in layered superconducting cuprates. So far, THz light pulses have been efficiently used to achieve non-linear control of the out-of-plane Josephso…
▽ More
The hallmark of superconductivity is the rigidity of the quantum-mechanical phase of electrons, responsible for superfluid behavior and Meissner effect. The strength of the phase stiffness is set by the Josephson coupling, which is strongly anisotropic in layered superconducting cuprates. So far, THz light pulses have been efficiently used to achieve non-linear control of the out-of-plane Josephson plasma mode, whose frequency scale lies in the THz range. However, the high-energy in-plane plasma mode has been assumed to be insensitive to THz pum**. Here, we show that THz driving of both low-frequency and high-frequency plasma waves is possible via a general two-plasmon excitation mechanism. The anisotropy of the Josephson couplings leads to marked differences in the thermal effects among the out-of-plane and in-plane response, consistently with the experiments. Our results link the observed survival of the in-plane THz non-linear driving above $T_c$ to enhanced fluctuating effects in the phase stiffness in cuprates, paving the way to THz impulsive control of phase rigidity in unconventional superconductors.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2020; v1 submitted 3 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Raman response in the nematic phase of FeSe
Authors:
Mattia Udina,
Marco Grilli,
Lara Benfatto,
Andrey V. Chubukov
Abstract:
Raman experiments on bulk FeSe revealed that the low-frequency part of $B_{1g}$ Raman response $R_{B_{1g}}$, which probes nematic fluctuations, rapidly decreases below the nematic transition at $T_n \sim 85$K. Such behavior is usually associated with the gap opening and at a first glance is inconsistent with the fact that FeSe remains a metal below $T_n$, with sizable hole and electron pockets. We…
▽ More
Raman experiments on bulk FeSe revealed that the low-frequency part of $B_{1g}$ Raman response $R_{B_{1g}}$, which probes nematic fluctuations, rapidly decreases below the nematic transition at $T_n \sim 85$K. Such behavior is usually associated with the gap opening and at a first glance is inconsistent with the fact that FeSe remains a metal below $T_n$, with sizable hole and electron pockets. We argue that the drop of $R_{B_{1g}}$ in a nematic metal comes about because the nematic order drastically changes the orbital content of the pockets and makes them nearly mono-orbital. In this situation $B_{1g}$ Raman response gets reduced by the same vertex corrections that enforce charge conservation. The reduction holds at low frequencies and gives rise to gap-like behavior of $R_{B_{1g}}$, in full agreement with the experimental data.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Theory of coherent oscillations detection in THz pump-probe spectroscopy: from phonons to electronic collective modes
Authors:
Mattia Udina,
Tommaso Cea,
Lara Benfatto
Abstract:
Time-resolved spectroscopies using intense THz pulses appear as a promising tool to address collective electronic excitations in condensed matter. In particular recent experiments showed the possibility to selectively excite collective modes emerging across a phase transition, as it is the case for superconducting and charge-density-wave (CDW) systems. One possible signature of these excitations i…
▽ More
Time-resolved spectroscopies using intense THz pulses appear as a promising tool to address collective electronic excitations in condensed matter. In particular recent experiments showed the possibility to selectively excite collective modes emerging across a phase transition, as it is the case for superconducting and charge-density-wave (CDW) systems. One possible signature of these excitations is the emergence of coherent oscillations of the differential probe field in pump-probe protocols. While the analogy with the case of phonon modes suggests that the basic underlying mechanism should be a sum-frequency stimulated Raman process, a general theoretical scheme able to describe the experiments and to define the relevant optical quantity is still lacking. Here we provide this scheme by showing that coherent oscillations as a function of the pump-probe time delay can be linked to the convolution in the frequency domain between the squared pump field and a Raman-like non-linear optical kernel. This approach is applied and discussed in few paradigmatic examples: ordinary phonons in an insulator, and collective charge and Higgs fluctuations across a superconducting and a CDW transition. Our results not only account very well for the existing experimental data in a wide variety of systems, but they also offer an useful perspective to design future experiments in emerging materials.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2019; v1 submitted 13 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
