-
Current progress in corrosion of multi principal element alloys
Authors:
M. Ghorbani,
Z. Li,
Y. Qiu,
P. Marcus,
J. R. Scully,
O. Gharbi,
H. Luo,
R. K. Gupta,
Z. R. Zeng,
H. L. Fraser,
M. L. Taheri,
N. Birbilis
Abstract:
Whilst multi-principal element alloys (MPEAs) remain a promising class of materials owing to several attractive mechanical properties, their corrosion performance is also unique. In this concise review, we present an emerging overview of some of the general features related to MPEA corrosion, following a decade of work in the field. This includes highlighting some of the key aspects related to the…
▽ More
Whilst multi-principal element alloys (MPEAs) remain a promising class of materials owing to several attractive mechanical properties, their corrosion performance is also unique. In this concise review, we present an emerging overview of some of the general features related to MPEA corrosion, following a decade of work in the field. This includes highlighting some of the key aspects related to the electrochemical phenomena in MPEA corrosion, and the relevant future works required for a holistic mechanistic understanding. In addition, a comprehensive database of the reported corrosion performance of MPEAs is presented, based on works reported to date. The database is assembled to also allow users to undertake machine learning or their own data analysis, with a parsed representation of alloy composition, test electrolyte, and corrosion related parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Electrochemical Evaluation of Mg and a Mg-Al 5%Zn Metal Rich Primers for Protection of Al-Zn-Mg-Cu Alloy in NaCl
Authors:
A. Korjenic,
L. Blohm,
J. R. Scully
Abstract:
High purity magnesium and a Mg-Al 5wt% Zn metal rich primer (MRP) were compared for their ability to suppress intergranular corrosion (IGC) and intergranular stress corrosion cracking (IG-SCC) in peak aged AA 7075-T651 by sacrificial anode-based cathodic prevention. Tests were conducted in 0.6 M NaCl solution under full immersion. These evaluations considered the ability of the primer to attain an…
▽ More
High purity magnesium and a Mg-Al 5wt% Zn metal rich primer (MRP) were compared for their ability to suppress intergranular corrosion (IGC) and intergranular stress corrosion cracking (IG-SCC) in peak aged AA 7075-T651 by sacrificial anode-based cathodic prevention. Tests were conducted in 0.6 M NaCl solution under full immersion. These evaluations considered the ability of the primer to attain an intermediate negative open circuit potential (OCP) such that the galvanic couple potential with bare aluminum alloy (AA) 7075-T651 resided below a range of potentials where IGC is prevalent. The ability of the primer to achieve an OCP negative enough that the AA 7075-T651 could be protected by sacrificial anode-based cathodic prevention and the ability to sustain this function over time were evaluated as a first step by utilizing a NaCl solution. The primers consisted of epoxy resins embedded with either (1) Mg flake pigments (MgRP) or (2) Mg flake pigments and spherical Al-5 wt.% Zn together as a composite (MgAlRP). MgRP was an effective coating for cathodic protection but dispensed less anodic charge than the composite MgAlRP. Cross-sectional analysis demonstrated that some Mg flakes dissolved while uniform surface oxidation occurred on the remaining Mg flakes which led to impaired activation. The composite MgAlRP maintained a suitably negative OCP over time, remained activated, dispensed high anodic charge, and remained an anode in zero resistance ammeter testing. Chemical stability modeling and zero resistance ammeter testing suggest that Mg corrosion elevates the pH which dissolved aluminum oxides and hydroxide thereby activates the Al-5wt.% Zn pigments, thereby providing a primary (i.e. Mg corrosion) and secondary process to enable superior (activation of Al-5wt%Zn) sacrificial anode-based cathodic protection.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Tuning chemical short-range order for stainless behavior at reduced chromium concentrations in multi-principal element alloys
Authors:
W. H. Blades,
B. W. Y. Redemann,
N. Smith,
D. Sur,
M. S. Barbieri,
Y. Xie,
S. Lech,
E. Anber,
M. L. Taheri,
C. Wolverton,
T. M. McQueen,
J. R. Scully,
K. Sieradzki
Abstract:
Single-phase multi-principal element alloys (MPEAs) hold promise for improved mechanical properties as a result of multiple operative deformation modes. However, the use of many of these alloys in structural applications is limited as a consequence of their poor aqueous corrosion resistance. Here we introduce a new approach for significantly improving the passivation behavior of alloys by tuning t…
▽ More
Single-phase multi-principal element alloys (MPEAs) hold promise for improved mechanical properties as a result of multiple operative deformation modes. However, the use of many of these alloys in structural applications is limited as a consequence of their poor aqueous corrosion resistance. Here we introduce a new approach for significantly improving the passivation behavior of alloys by tuning the chemical short-range order (CSRO) parameter. We show that the addition of only 0.03 to 0.06 mole fraction of Al to a (FeCoNi)0.9Cr0.1 alloy changed both the magnitude and sign of the Cr-Cr CSRO parameter resulting in passivation behavior similar to 304L stainless steel containing twice the amount of Cr. Our analysis is based on comparing electrochemical measures of the kinetics of passive film formation with CSRO characterizations using time-of-flight neutron scattering, cluster expansion methods, density functional theory and Monte Carlo techniques. Our findings are interpreted within the framework of a recently proposed percolation theory of passivation that examines how selective dissolution of the non-passivating alloy components and CSRO results in excellent passive films at reduced levels of the passivating component.
△ Less
Submitted 29 February, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
A High Throughput Aqueous Passivation Testing Methodology for Compositionally Complex Alloys using Scanning Droplet Cell
Authors:
Debashish Sur,
Howie Joress,
Jason Hattrick-Simpers,
John R. Scully
Abstract:
Compositionally complex alloy systems containing more than five principal elements allow exploring a wide range of compositions, processing, and structural variables with the hope for identifying unique properties. Such opportunities also apply to designing materials for improved corrosion resistance, regulated by a self-healing passive film. Such a rich landscape in reactivity and protectivity de…
▽ More
Compositionally complex alloy systems containing more than five principal elements allow exploring a wide range of compositions, processing, and structural variables with the hope for identifying unique properties. Such opportunities also apply to designing materials for improved corrosion resistance, regulated by a self-healing passive film. Such a rich landscape in reactivity and protectivity demands the search for high-throughput experimental testing workflows to uncover key metrics, indicative of superior properties. In this communication, one such methodology is demonstrated for evaluating passivation performance of a combinatorial library of Al0.7-x-yCoxCryFe0.15Ni0.15 thin film alloys in deaerated 0.1 mol/L H2SO4(aq), using a scanning droplet cell.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2023; v1 submitted 20 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
An experimental high-throughput to high-fidelity study towards discovering Al-Cr containing corrosion-resistant compositionally complex alloys
Authors:
Debashish Sur,
Emily F. Holcombe,
William H. Blades,
Elaf A. Anber,
Daniel L. Foley,
Brian L. DeCost,
**g Liu,
Jason Hattrick-Simpers,
Karl Sieradzki,
Howie Joress,
John R. Scully,
Mitra L. Taheri
Abstract:
Compositionally complex alloys hold the promise of simultaneously attaining superior combinations of properties, such as corrosion resistance, light-weighting, and strength. Achieving this goal is a challenge due in part to a large number of possible compositions and structures in the vast alloy design space. High-throughput methods offer a path forward, but a strong connection between the synthes…
▽ More
Compositionally complex alloys hold the promise of simultaneously attaining superior combinations of properties, such as corrosion resistance, light-weighting, and strength. Achieving this goal is a challenge due in part to a large number of possible compositions and structures in the vast alloy design space. High-throughput methods offer a path forward, but a strong connection between the synthesis of an alloy of a given composition and structure with its properties has not been fully realized to date. Here, we present the rapid identification of corrosion-resistant alloys based on combinations of Al and Cr in a base Al-Co-Cr-Fe-Ni alloy. Previously unstudied alloy stoichiometries were identified using a combination of high-throughput experimental screening coupled with key metallurgical and electrochemical corrosion tests, identifying alloys with excellent passivation behavior. The alloy native oxide performance and its self-healing attributes were probed using rapid tests in deaerated 0.1 mol/L H2SO4. Importantly, a correlation was found between the electrochemical impedance modulus of the exposure-modified air-formed film and self-healing rate of the CCAs. Multi-element extended x-ray absorption fine structure analyses connected more ordered type chemical short-range order in the Ni-Al 1st nearest-neighbor shell to poorer corrosion resistance. This report underscores the utility of high throughput exploration of compositionally complex alloys for the identification and rapid screening of a vast stoichiometric space.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2024; v1 submitted 15 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
One Dimensional Wormhole Corrosion in Metals
Authors:
Yang Yang,
Weiyue Zhou,
Sheng Yin,
Sarah Y. Wang,
Qin Yu,
Matthew J. Olszta,
Ya-Qian Zhang,
Steven E. Zeltmann,
Mingda Li,
Miaomiao **,
Daniel K. Schreiber,
Jim Ciston,
M. C. Scott,
John R. Scully,
Robert O. Ritchie,
Mark Asta,
Ju Li,
Michael P. Short,
Andrew M. Minor
Abstract:
Corrosion is a ubiquitous failure mode of materials in extreme environments. The more localized it is, the more difficult it is to detect and more deleterious its effects. Often, the progression of localized corrosion is accompanied by the evolution of porosity in materials, creating internal void-structures that facilitate the ingress of the external environment into the interior of the material,…
▽ More
Corrosion is a ubiquitous failure mode of materials in extreme environments. The more localized it is, the more difficult it is to detect and more deleterious its effects. Often, the progression of localized corrosion is accompanied by the evolution of porosity in materials, creating internal void-structures that facilitate the ingress of the external environment into the interior of the material, further accelerating the internal corrosion. Previously, the dominant morphology of such void-structures has been reported to be either three-dimensional (3D) or two-dimensional (2D). Here, we report a more localized form of corrosion, which we call 1D wormhole corrosion. Using electron tomography, we show multiple examples of this 1D and percolating morphology that manifests a significantly high aspect ratio differentiable from 2D and 3D corrosion. To understand the origin of this mechanism in a Ni-Cr alloy corroded by molten salt, we combined energy-filtered four-dimensional scanning transmission electron microscopy (EF-4D-STEM) and ab initio density functional theory (DFT) calculations to develop a vacancy map** method with nanometer-resolution, identifying a remarkably high vacancy concentration in the diffusion-induced grain boundary migration (DIGM) zone, up to 100 times the equilibrium value at the melting point. These vacancy supersaturation regions act as the precursors of wormholes, and lead to the asymmetrical growth of voids along GBs. We show that similar 1D penetrating corrosion morphologies could also occur in other materials or corrosion conditions, implying the broad impact of this extremely localized corrosion mechanism. Deciphering the origins of 1D corrosion is an important step towards designing structural materials with enhanced corrosion resistance, and also offers new pathways to create ordered-porous materials for functional applications.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Electrical properties of thermal oxide scales on pure iron in liquid lead-bismuth eutectic
Authors:
Jie Qiu,
Junsoo Han,
Ryan Schoell,
Miroslav Popovic,
Elmira Ghanbari,
Djamel Kaoumi,
John R Scully,
Digby D Macdonald,
Peter Hosemann
Abstract:
The impedance behavior of pre-oxidized iron in liquid lead-bismuth eutectic (LBE) at 200 oC is studied using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy. The structures and resistance of oxide grown on iron oxidized in air at different temperatures and durations are compared. The results show that the resistance of the oxide film increases with increasing oxidizing temperature, due to the formation of…
▽ More
The impedance behavior of pre-oxidized iron in liquid lead-bismuth eutectic (LBE) at 200 oC is studied using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy. The structures and resistance of oxide grown on iron oxidized in air at different temperatures and durations are compared. The results show that the resistance of the oxide film increases with increasing oxidizing temperature, due to the formation of a thicker scale and fewer defects. At the same temperature (600 oC), increasing the oxidation time can also reduce the defect concentration in the oxide film and improve the impedance of the oxide scale in LBE.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
On the suitability of slow strain rate tensile testing for assessing hydrogen embrittlement susceptibility
Authors:
Emilio Martínez-Pañeda,
Zachary D. Harris,
Sandra Fuentes-Alonso,
John R. Scully,
James T. Burns
Abstract:
The onset of sub-critical crack growth during slow strain rate tensile testing (SSRT) is assessed through a combined experimental and modeling approach. A systematic comparison of the extent of intergranular fracture and expected hydrogen ingress suggests that hydrogen diffusion alone is insufficient to explain the intergranular fracture depths observed after SSRT experiments in a Ni-Cu superalloy…
▽ More
The onset of sub-critical crack growth during slow strain rate tensile testing (SSRT) is assessed through a combined experimental and modeling approach. A systematic comparison of the extent of intergranular fracture and expected hydrogen ingress suggests that hydrogen diffusion alone is insufficient to explain the intergranular fracture depths observed after SSRT experiments in a Ni-Cu superalloy. Simulations of these experiments using a new phase field formulation indicate that crack initiation occurs as low as 40% of the time to failure. The implications of such sub-critical crack growth on the validity and interpretation of SSRT metrics are then explored.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Non-equilibrium Solute Capture in Passivating Oxide Films
Authors:
Xiao-xiang Yu,
Ahmet Gulec,
Quentin Sherman,
Katie Lutton Cwalina,
John R. Scully,
John H. Perepezko,
Peter W. Voorhees,
Laurence D. Marks
Abstract:
If all humans vanished tomorrow, almost every metal structure would collapse within a century or less, the metal converting to an oxide. In applications ranging from the mature technology of nuts and bolts to high technology batteries, nuclear fuels and turbine engines, protective oxide films are critical to limiting oxidation. To date models of these oxide films have assumed that they form thermo…
▽ More
If all humans vanished tomorrow, almost every metal structure would collapse within a century or less, the metal converting to an oxide. In applications ranging from the mature technology of nuts and bolts to high technology batteries, nuclear fuels and turbine engines, protective oxide films are critical to limiting oxidation. To date models of these oxide films have assumed that they form thermodynamic equilibrium stable or metastable phases doped within thermodynamic solubility limits. Here we demonstrate experimentally and theoretically the formation of unusual non-equilibrium oxide phases, that can be predicted using a scientific framework for solute capture at a moving oxide/substrate interface. The theory shows that solute capture is likely a generic process for many electrochemical processes, and suggests that similar phenomena yielding non-equilibrium phases can occur and be predicted for a wide range of other processes involving solid-fluid and solid-solid chemical reactions.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
