-
Illustrating an Effective Workflow for Accelerated Materials Discovery
Authors:
Mrinalini Mulukutla,
A. Nicole Person,
Sven Voigt,
Lindsey Kuettner,
Branden Kappes,
Danial Khatamsaz,
Robert Robinson,
Daniel Salas,
Wenle Xu,
Daniel Lewis,
Hongkyu Eoh,
Kailu Xiao,
Haoren Wang,
Jaskaran Singh Saini,
Raj Mahat,
Trevor Hastings,
Matthew Skokan,
Vahid Attari,
Michael Elverud,
James D. Paramore,
Brady Butler,
Kenneth Vecchio,
Surya R. Kalidindi,
Douglas Allaire,
Ibrahim Karaman
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Algorithmic materials discovery is a multi-disciplinary domain that integrates insights from specialists in alloy design, synthesis, characterization, experimental methodologies, computational modeling, and optimization. Central to this effort is a robust data management system paired with an interactive work platform. This platform should empower users to not only access others data but also inte…
▽ More
Algorithmic materials discovery is a multi-disciplinary domain that integrates insights from specialists in alloy design, synthesis, characterization, experimental methodologies, computational modeling, and optimization. Central to this effort is a robust data management system paired with an interactive work platform. This platform should empower users to not only access others data but also integrate their analyses, paving the way for sophisticated data pipelines. To realize this vision, there is a need for an integrative collaboration platform, streamlined data sharing and analysis tools, and efficient communication channels. Such a collaborative mechanism should transcend geographical barriers, facilitating remote interaction and fostering a challenge-response dynamic. In this paper, we present our ongoing efforts in addressing the critical challenges related to an accelerated Materials Discovery Framework as a part of the High-Throughput Materials Discovery for Extreme Conditions Initiative. Our BIRDSHOT Center has successfully harnessed various tools and strategies, including the utilization of cloud-based storage, a standardized sample naming convention, a structured file system, the implementation of sample travelers, a robust sample tracking method, and the incorporation of knowledge graphs for efficient data management. Additionally, we present the development of a data collection platform, reinforcing seamless collaboration among our team members. In summary, this paper provides an illustration and insight into the various elements of an efficient and effective workflow within an accelerated materials discovery framework while highlighting the dynamic and adaptable nature of the data management tools and sharing platforms.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
An Interoperable Multi Objective Batch Bayesian Optimization Framework for High Throughput Materials Discovery
Authors:
Trevor Hastings,
Mrinalini Mulukutla,
Danial Khatamsaz,
Daniel Salas,
Wenle Xu,
Daniel Lewis,
Nicole Person,
Matthew Skokan,
Braden Miller,
James Paramore,
Brady Butler,
Douglas Allaire,
Ibrahim Karaman,
George Pharr,
Ankit Srivastava,
Raymundo Arroyave
Abstract:
In this study, we introduce a groundbreaking framework for materials discovery, we efficiently navigate a vast phase space of material compositions by leveraging Batch Bayesian statistics in order to achieve specific performance objectives. This approach addresses the challenge of identifying optimal materials from an untenably large array of possibilities in a reasonable timeframe with high confi…
▽ More
In this study, we introduce a groundbreaking framework for materials discovery, we efficiently navigate a vast phase space of material compositions by leveraging Batch Bayesian statistics in order to achieve specific performance objectives. This approach addresses the challenge of identifying optimal materials from an untenably large array of possibilities in a reasonable timeframe with high confidence. Crucially, our batchwise methods align seamlessly with existing material processing infrastructure for synthesizing and characterizing materials. By applying this framework to a specific high entropy alloy system, we demonstrate its versatility and robustness in optimizing properties like strain hardening, hardness, and strain rate sensitivity. The fact that the Bayesian model is adept in refining and expanding the property Pareto front highlights its broad applicability across various materials, including steels, shape memory alloys, ceramics, and composites. This study advances the field of materials science and sets a new benchmark for material discovery methodologies. By proving the effectiveness of Bayesian optimization, we showcase its potential to redefine the landscape of materials discovery.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Two-Shot Optimization of Compositionally Complex Refractory Alloys
Authors:
James D. Paramore,
Brady G. Butler,
Michael T. Hurst,
Trevor Hastings,
Daniel O. Lewis,
Eli Norris,
Benjamin Barkai,
Joshua Cline,
Braden Miller,
Jose Cortes,
Ibrahim Karaman,
George M. Pharr,
Raymundo Arroyave
Abstract:
In this paper, a synergistic computational/experimental approach is presented for the rapid discovery and characterization of novel alloys within the compositionally complex (i.e., "medium/high entropy") refractory alloy space of Ti-V-Nb-Mo-Hf-Ta-W. This was demonstrated via a material design cycle aimed at simultaneously maximizing the objective properties of high specific hardness (hardness norm…
▽ More
In this paper, a synergistic computational/experimental approach is presented for the rapid discovery and characterization of novel alloys within the compositionally complex (i.e., "medium/high entropy") refractory alloy space of Ti-V-Nb-Mo-Hf-Ta-W. This was demonstrated via a material design cycle aimed at simultaneously maximizing the objective properties of high specific hardness (hardness normalized by density) and high specific elastic modulus (elastic modulus normalized by density). This framework utilizes high-throughput computational thermodynamics and intelligent filtering to first reduce the untenably large alloy space to a feasible size, followed by an iterative design cycle comprised of high-throughput synthesis, processing, and characterization in batch sizes of 24 alloys. After the first iteration, Bayesian optimization was utilized to inform selection of the next batch of 24 alloys. This paper demonstrates the benefit of using batch Bayesian optimization (BBO) in material design, as significant gains in the objective properties were observed after only two iterations or "shots" of the design cycle without using any prior knowledge or physical models of how the objective properties relate to the design inputs (i.e., composition). Specifically, the hypervolume of the Pareto front increased by 54% between the first and second iterations. Furthermore, 10 of the 24 alloys in the second iteration dominated all alloys from the first iteration.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Rapid Quantification of Dynamic and Spall Strength of Metals Across Strain Rates
Authors:
Suhas Eswarappa Prameela,
Christopher C. Walker,
Christopher S. DiMarco,
Debjoy D. Mallick,
Xingsheng Sun,
Stephanie Hernandez,
Taisuke Sasaki,
Justin W. Wilkerson,
K. T. Ramesh,
George M. Pharr,
Timothy P. Weihs
Abstract:
The response of metals and their microstructures under extreme dynamic conditions can be markedly different from that under quasistatic conditions. Traditionally, high strain rates and shock stresses are measured using cumbersome and expensive methods such as the Kolsky bar or large spall experiments. These methods are low throughput and do not facilitate high-fidelity microstructure-property link…
▽ More
The response of metals and their microstructures under extreme dynamic conditions can be markedly different from that under quasistatic conditions. Traditionally, high strain rates and shock stresses are measured using cumbersome and expensive methods such as the Kolsky bar or large spall experiments. These methods are low throughput and do not facilitate high-fidelity microstructure-property linkages. In this work, we combine two powerful small-scale testing methods, custom nanoindentation, and laser-driven micro-flyer shock, to measure the dynamic and spall strength of metals. The nanoindentation system is configured to test samples from quasistatic to dynamic strain rate regimes (10$^{-3}$ s$^{-1}$ to 10$^{+4}$ s$^{-1}$). The laser-driven micro-flyer shock system can test samples through impact loading between 10$^{+5}$ s$^{-1}$ to 10$^{+7}$ s$^{-1}$ strain rates, triggering spall failure. The model material used for testing is Magnesium alloys, which are lightweight, possess high-specific strengths and have historically been challenging to design and strengthen due to their mechanical anisotropy. Here, we modulate their microstructure by adding or removing precipitates to demonstrate interesting upticks in strain rate sensitivity and evolution of dynamic strength. At high shock loading rates, we unravel an interesting paradigm where the spall strength of these materials converges, but the failure mechanisms are markedly different. Peak aging, considered to be a standard method to strengthen metallic alloys, causes catastrophic failure, faring much worse than solutionized alloys. Our high throughput testing framework not only quantifies strength but also teases out unexplored failure mechanisms at extreme strain rates, providing valuable insights for the rapid design and improvement of metals for extreme environments.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
The contribution of plastic sink-in to the static friction of single asperity microscopic contacts
Authors:
Owen Brazil,
John B. Pethica,
George M. Pharr
Abstract:
We report microscale friction experiments for diamond/metal and diamond/silica contacts under gigapascal contact pressures. Using a new nanoprobe technique which has sufficient dynamic range of force and stiffness, we demonstrate the processes involved in the transition from purely interface sliding at the nanoscale to the situation where at least one of the sliding bodies undergoes some plastic d…
▽ More
We report microscale friction experiments for diamond/metal and diamond/silica contacts under gigapascal contact pressures. Using a new nanoprobe technique which has sufficient dynamic range of force and stiffness, we demonstrate the processes involved in the transition from purely interface sliding at the nanoscale to the situation where at least one of the sliding bodies undergoes some plastic deformation. For sliding of micrometer-scale diamond spherical tips on metallic substrates, additional local plastic yielding of the substrate resulting from tangential tractions causes the tip to sink into the surface, increasing the contact area in the direction of loading and resulting in a static friction coefficient higher than the kinetic during ploughing. This sink-in is largely absent in fused silica, and no friction drop is observed, along with lower friction in general. The transition from sinking in within the static friction regime to ploughing in the sliding friction regime is mediated by failure of the contact interface, indicated by a sharp increase in energy dissipation. At lower contact pressures, the elastic interfacial sliding behaviour characteristic of scanning probe or surface force apparatus experiments is recovered, bridging the gap between the exotic realm of nanotribology and plasticity dominated macroscale friction. We delineate the material and geometric factors which determine the transition. We also find that some unexpected light is cast on the origins of the difference between static and dynamic friction.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Measuring Poisson's ratio during nanoindentation via lateral contact stiffness; issues of slip and plasticity
Authors:
Owen Brazil,
George Pharr
Abstract:
Although Poisson's ratio, v, is a quantity of great importance in materials design, presently, very few methods are available to measure it at small (micrometre) scales and those typically involve intensive geometric refinement of the sample. In this work we show how Poisson's ratio may be measured during nanoindentation experiments by means of a second load actuator oriented orthogonally to the p…
▽ More
Although Poisson's ratio, v, is a quantity of great importance in materials design, presently, very few methods are available to measure it at small (micrometre) scales and those typically involve intensive geometric refinement of the sample. In this work we show how Poisson's ratio may be measured during nanoindentation experiments by means of a second load actuator oriented orthogonally to the primary vertical load axis. We apply a small oscillating lateral load to Berkovich and sphero-conical indenter tips during nanoindentation into fused silica and metallic samples. This enables the elastic lateral contact stiffness to be measured as a function of depth in a manner analogous to continuous stiffness measurements in conventional indentation experiments. The stiffness may in turn be used to calculate v. During constant strain rate experiments, we extract values of v = 0.16 for fused silica and v = 0.34 for polycrystalline aluminium over indentation depths of several hundred nanometres. We highlight two critical issues that must be addressed to ensure accurate measurement of v during indentation; partial slip and additional plasticity brought about through the added shear under tangential loading. We study these separate phenomena in fused silica and single crystal nickel, suggesting that interfacial slip is favoured in harder, brittle materials, while plasticity is dominant in more ductile materials. We offer some suggestions on how to mitigate these problems based on tip geometry and loading protocols.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
