-
Hyperuniformity in phase ordering: the roles of activity, noise, and non-constant mobility
Authors:
Filippo De Luca,
Xiao Ma,
Cesare Nardini,
Michael E. Cates
Abstract:
Hyperuniformity emerges generically in the coarsening regime of phase-separating fluids. Numerical studies of active and passive systems have shown that the structure factor $S(q)$ behaves as $q^ς$ for $q\to 0$, with hyperuniformity exponent $ς= 4$. For passive systems, this result was explained in 1991 by a qualitative scaling analysis of Tomita, exploiting isotropy at scales much larger than the…
▽ More
Hyperuniformity emerges generically in the coarsening regime of phase-separating fluids. Numerical studies of active and passive systems have shown that the structure factor $S(q)$ behaves as $q^ς$ for $q\to 0$, with hyperuniformity exponent $ς= 4$. For passive systems, this result was explained in 1991 by a qualitative scaling analysis of Tomita, exploiting isotropy at scales much larger than the coarsening length $\ell$. Here we reconsider and extend Tomita's argument to address cases of active phase separation and of non-constant mobility, again finding $ς=4$. We further show that dynamical noise of variance $D$ creates a transient $ς= 2$ regime for $\hat q\ll \hat{q}_\ast \sim \sqrt{D} t^{[1-(d+2)ν]/2}$, crossing over to $ς= 4$ at larger $\hat{q}$. Here, $ν$ is the coarsening exponent, with $\ell\sim t^ν$, and $\hat{q} \propto q \ell$ is the rescaled wavenumber. In diffusive coarsening, $ν=1/3$, so the rescaled crossover wavevector $\hat{q}_\ast$ vanishes at large times when $d\geq 2$. The slowness of this decay suggests a natural explanation for experiments that observe a long-lived $ς= 2$ scaling in phase-separating active fluids (where noise is typically large). Conversely, in $d=1$, we demonstrate that with noise the $ς= 2$ regime survives as $t\to\infty$, with $\hat{q}_\ast\sim D^{5/6}$. (The structure factor is not then determined by the zero-temperature fixed point.) We confirm our analytical predictions by numerical simulations of active and passive continuum theories in the deterministic case and of Model B for the stochastic case. We also compare them with related findings for a system near an absorbing-state transition rather than undergoing phase separation. A central role is played throughout by the presence or absence of a conservation law for the centre of mass position of the order parameter field.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Fluctuation-Induced First Order Transition to Collective Motion
Authors:
David Martin,
Gianmarco Spera,
Hugues Chaté,
Charlie Duclut,
Cesare Nardini,
Julien Tailleur,
Frédéric van Wijland
Abstract:
The nature of the transition to collective motion in assemblies of aligning self-propelled particles remains a long-standing matter of debate. In this article, we focus on dry active matter and show that weak fluctuations suffice to generically turn second-order mean-field transitions into a `discontinuous' coexistence scenario. Our theory shows how fluctuations induce a density-dependence of the…
▽ More
The nature of the transition to collective motion in assemblies of aligning self-propelled particles remains a long-standing matter of debate. In this article, we focus on dry active matter and show that weak fluctuations suffice to generically turn second-order mean-field transitions into a `discontinuous' coexistence scenario. Our theory shows how fluctuations induce a density-dependence of the polar-field mass, even when this effect is absent at mean-field level. In turn, this dependency on density triggers a feedback loop between ordering and advection that ultimately leads to an inhomogeneous transition to collective motion and the emergence of non-linear travelling `flocks'. Importantly, we show that such a fluctuation-induced first order transition is present in both metric models, in which particles align with neighbors within a finite distance, and in topological ones, in which alignment is not based on relative distances. We compute analytically the noise-induced renormalization of the polar-field mass using stochastic calculus, which we further back up by a one-loop field-theoretical analysis. Finally, we confirm our analytical predictions by numerical simulations of fluctuating hydrodynamics as well as of topological microscopic models with either $k$-nearest neighbors or Voronoi alignment.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Collective motion in a sheet of microswimmers
Authors:
Dóra Bárdfalvy,
Viktor Škultéty,
Cesare Nardini,
Alexander Morozov,
Joakim Stenhammar
Abstract:
Self-propelled micron-size particles suspended in a fluid, like bacteria or synthetic microswimmers, are strongly non-equilibrium systems where particle motility breaks the microscopic detailed balance, often resulting in large-scale collective motion. Previous theoretical work has identified long-range hydrodynamic interactions as the main driver of collective motion in unbounded dilute suspensio…
▽ More
Self-propelled micron-size particles suspended in a fluid, like bacteria or synthetic microswimmers, are strongly non-equilibrium systems where particle motility breaks the microscopic detailed balance, often resulting in large-scale collective motion. Previous theoretical work has identified long-range hydrodynamic interactions as the main driver of collective motion in unbounded dilute suspension of rear-actuated ("pusher") microswimmers. In contrast, most experimental studies of collective motion in microswimmer suspensions have been carried out in quasi-2-dimensional geometries such as in thin films or near solid or fluid interfaces, where both the swimmers' motion and their long-range flow fields become altered due to the proximity of a boundary. Here, we study numerically a minimal model of microswimmers in such a restricted geometry, where the particles move in the midplane between two no-slip walls. For pushers, we demonstrate collective motion with only short-ranged order, in contrast with the long-ranged flows observed in unbounded systems. For front-actuated ("puller") microswimmers, we discover a long-wavelength density instability resulting in the formation of dense microswimmer clusters. Both types of collective motion are fundamentally different from their previously studied counterparts in unbounded domains. Our results illustrate that hydrodynamic screening due to the presence of a wall is subdominant in determining the collective state of the suspension, which is instead dictated by the geometrical restriction of the swimmers' motion.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2024; v1 submitted 9 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Hydrodynamic instabilities in a 2-D sheet of microswimmers embedded in a 3-D fluid
Authors:
Viktor Škultéty,
Dóra Bárdfalvy,
Joakim Stenhammar,
Cesare Nardini,
Alexander Morozov
Abstract:
A collection of microswimmers immersed in an incompressible fluid is characterised by strong interactions due to the long-range nature of the hydrodynamic fields generated by individual organisms. As a result, suspensions of rear-actuated `pusher' swimmers such as bacteria exhibit a collective motion state often referred to as `bacterial turbulence', characterised by large-scale chaotic flows. The…
▽ More
A collection of microswimmers immersed in an incompressible fluid is characterised by strong interactions due to the long-range nature of the hydrodynamic fields generated by individual organisms. As a result, suspensions of rear-actuated `pusher' swimmers such as bacteria exhibit a collective motion state often referred to as `bacterial turbulence', characterised by large-scale chaotic flows. The onset of collective motion in pusher suspensions is classically understood within the framework of mean-field kinetic theories for dipolar swimmers. In bulk 2-D and 3-D, the theory predicts that the instability leading to bacterial turbulence is due to mutual swimmer reorientation and sets in at the largest length scale available to the suspension. Here, we construct a similar kinetic theory for the case of a dipolar microswimmer suspension restricted to a two-dimensional plane embedded in a three-dimensional incompressible fluid. This setting qualitatively mimics the effect of swimming close to a two-dimensional interface. We show that the in-plane flow fields are effectively compressible in spite of the incompressibility of the 3-D bulk fluid, and that microswimmers on average act as sources (pushers) or sinks (pullers). We analyse stability of the homogeneous and isotropic state, and find two types of instability that are qualitatively different from the bulk, three-dimensional case: First, we show that the analogue of the orientational pusher instability leading to bacterial turbulence in bulk systems instead occurs at the smallest length-scale available to the system. Second, an instability associated with density variations arises in puller suspensions as a generic consequence of the effective in-plane compressibility. We conclude that confinement can have a crucial role in determining the collective behaviour of microswimmer suspensions.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2023; v1 submitted 27 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Classical Nucleation Theory for Active Fluid Phase Separation
Authors:
M. E. Cates,
C. Nardini
Abstract:
Classical nucleation theory (CNT), linking rare nucleation events to the free energy landscape of a growing nucleus, is central to understanding phase-change kinetics in passive fluids. Nucleation in non-equilibrium systems is much harder to describe because there is no free energy, but instead a dynamics-dependent quasi-potential that typically must be found numerically. Here we extend CNT to a c…
▽ More
Classical nucleation theory (CNT), linking rare nucleation events to the free energy landscape of a growing nucleus, is central to understanding phase-change kinetics in passive fluids. Nucleation in non-equilibrium systems is much harder to describe because there is no free energy, but instead a dynamics-dependent quasi-potential that typically must be found numerically. Here we extend CNT to a class of active phase separating systems governed by a minimal field-theoretic model (Active Model B+). In the small noise and supersaturation limits that CNT assumes, we compute analytically the quasi-potential, and hence nucleation barrier, for liquid-vapor phase separation. Crucially to our results, detailed balance, although broken microscopically by activity, is restored along the instanton trajectory, which in CNT involves the nuclear radius as the sole reaction coordinate.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2023; v1 submitted 11 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Interface roughening in nonequilibrium phase-separated systems
Authors:
Marc Besse,
Giordano Fausti,
Michael E. Cates,
Bertrand Delamotte,
Cesare Nardini
Abstract:
Interfaces of phase-separated systems roughen in time due to capillary waves. Because of fluxes in the bulk, their dynamics is nonlocal in real space and is not described by the Edwards-Wilkinson or Kardar-Parisi-Zhang (KPZ) equations, nor their conserved counterparts. We show that in the absence of detailed balance, the phase-separated interface is described by a new universality class that we te…
▽ More
Interfaces of phase-separated systems roughen in time due to capillary waves. Because of fluxes in the bulk, their dynamics is nonlocal in real space and is not described by the Edwards-Wilkinson or Kardar-Parisi-Zhang (KPZ) equations, nor their conserved counterparts. We show that in the absence of detailed balance, the phase-separated interface is described by a new universality class that we term |q|KPZ. We compute the associated critical exponents via one-loop renormalization group, and corroborate the results by numerical integration of the |q|KPZ equation. Deriving the effective interface dynamics from a minimal field theory of active phase separation, we finally argue that the |q|KPZ universality class generically describes liquid-vapor interfaces in active systems.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2023; v1 submitted 12 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Fluctuating kinetic theory and fluctuating hydrodynamics of aligning active particles: the dilute limit
Authors:
Ouassim Feliachi,
Marc Besse,
Cesare Nardini,
Julien Barré
Abstract:
Kinetic and hydrodynamic theories are widely employed for describing the collective behaviour of active matter systems. At the fluctuating level, these have been obtained from explicit coarse-graining procedures in the limit where each particle interacts weakly with many others, so that the total forces and torques exerted on each of them is of order unity at all times. Such limit is however not r…
▽ More
Kinetic and hydrodynamic theories are widely employed for describing the collective behaviour of active matter systems. At the fluctuating level, these have been obtained from explicit coarse-graining procedures in the limit where each particle interacts weakly with many others, so that the total forces and torques exerted on each of them is of order unity at all times. Such limit is however not relevant for dilute systems that mostly interact via alignment; there, collisions are rare and make the self-propulsion direction to change abruptly. We derive a fluctuating kinetic theory, and the corresponding fluctuating hydrodynamics, for aligning self-propelled particles in the limit of dilute systems. We discover that fluctuations at kinetic level are not Gaussian and depend on the interactions among particles, but that only their Gaussian part survives in the hydrodynamic limit. At variance with fluctuating hydrodynamics for weakly interacting particles, we find that the noise variance at hydrodynamic level depends on the interaction rules among particles and is proportional to the square of the density, reflecting the binary nature of the aligning process. The results of this paper, which are derived for polar self-propelled particles with polar alignment, could be straightforwardly extended to polar particles with nematic alignment or to fully nematic systems.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2022; v1 submitted 23 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Stochastic Hydrodynamics of Complex Fluids: Discretisation and Entropy Production
Authors:
Michael E. Cates,
Étienne Fodor,
Tomer Markovich,
Cesare Nardini,
Elsen Tjhung
Abstract:
Many complex fluids can be described by continuum hydrodynamic field equations, to which noise must be added in order to capture thermal fluctuations. In almost all cases, the resulting coarse-grained stochastic partial differential equations carry a short-scale cutoff -- which is also reflected in numerical discretisation schemes. We draw together our recent findings concerning the construction o…
▽ More
Many complex fluids can be described by continuum hydrodynamic field equations, to which noise must be added in order to capture thermal fluctuations. In almost all cases, the resulting coarse-grained stochastic partial differential equations carry a short-scale cutoff -- which is also reflected in numerical discretisation schemes. We draw together our recent findings concerning the construction of such schemes and the interpretation of their continuum limits, focusing for simplicity on models with a purely diffusive scalar field, such as `Model B' which describes phase separation in binary fluid mixtures. We address the requirement that the steady state entropy production rate (EPR) must vanish for any stochastic hydrodynamic model in thermal equilibrium. Only if this is achieved can the given discretisation scheme be relied upon to correctly calculate the nonvanishing EPR for `active field theories' in which new terms are deliberately added to the fluctuating hydrodynamic equations that break detailed balance. To compute the correct probabilities of forward and time-reversed paths (whose ratio determines the EPR) we must make a careful treatment of so-called `spurious drift' and other closely related terms that depend on the discretisation scheme. We show that such subtleties can arise not only in the temporal discretisation (as is well documented for stochastic ODEs with multiplicative noise) but also from spatial discretisation, even when noise is additive, as most active field theories assume. We then review how such noise can become multiplicative, via off-diagonal couplings to additional fields that encode thermodynamically the underlying chemical processes responsible for activity. In this case the spurious drift terms need careful accounting, not just to evaluate correctly the EPR, but also to numerically implement the Langevin dynamics itself.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2022; v1 submitted 17 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Absorbing phase transitions in systems with mediated interactions
Authors:
Romain Mari,
Eric Bertin,
Cesare Nardini
Abstract:
Experiments of periodically sheared colloidal suspensions or soft amorphous solids display a transition from reversible to irreversible particle motion that, when analysed stroboscopically in time, is interpreted as an absorbing phase transition with infinitely many absorbing states. In these systems interactions mediated by hydrodynamics or elasticity are present, causing passive regions to be af…
▽ More
Experiments of periodically sheared colloidal suspensions or soft amorphous solids display a transition from reversible to irreversible particle motion that, when analysed stroboscopically in time, is interpreted as an absorbing phase transition with infinitely many absorbing states. In these systems interactions mediated by hydrodynamics or elasticity are present, causing passive regions to be affected by nearby active ones. We show that mediated interactions induce a new universality class of absorbing phase transitions, distinct from Conserved Directed Percolation, and we obtain the corresponding critical exponents. We do so with large-scale numerical simulations of a minimal model for the stroboscopic dynamics of sheared soft materials and derive the minimal field theoretical description.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Capillary interfacial tension in active phase separation
Authors:
Giordano Fausti,
Elsen Tjhung,
Michael Cates,
Cesare Nardini
Abstract:
In passive fluid-fluid phase separation, a single interfacial tension sets both the capillary fluctuations of the interface and the rate of Ostwald ripening. We show that these phenomena are governed by two different tensions in active systems, and compute the capillary tension $σ_{cw}$ which sets the relaxation rate of interfacial fluctuations in accordance with capillary wave theory. We discover…
▽ More
In passive fluid-fluid phase separation, a single interfacial tension sets both the capillary fluctuations of the interface and the rate of Ostwald ripening. We show that these phenomena are governed by two different tensions in active systems, and compute the capillary tension $σ_{cw}$ which sets the relaxation rate of interfacial fluctuations in accordance with capillary wave theory. We discover that strong enough activity can cause negative $σ_{cw}$. In this regime, depending on the global composition, the system self-organizes, either into a microphase-separated state in which coalescence is highly inhibited, or into an `active foam' state. Our results are obtained for Active Model B+, a minimal continuum model which, although generic, admits significant analytical progress.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2021; v1 submitted 29 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Statistical Mechanics of Active Ornstein Uhlenbeck Particles
Authors:
David Martin,
Jérémy O'Byrne,
Michael E. Cates,
Étienne Fodor,
Cesare Nardini,
Julien Tailleur,
Frédéric van Wijland
Abstract:
We review and extend recent developments on the statistical properties of Active Ornstein Uhlenbeck particles (AOUPs). In this simplest of models, the Gaussian white noise of overdamped Brownian colloids is replaced by a Gaussian colored noise. This suffice to grant this system the hallmark properties of active matter, while still allowing for analytical progress. We first detail the perturbative…
▽ More
We review and extend recent developments on the statistical properties of Active Ornstein Uhlenbeck particles (AOUPs). In this simplest of models, the Gaussian white noise of overdamped Brownian colloids is replaced by a Gaussian colored noise. This suffice to grant this system the hallmark properties of active matter, while still allowing for analytical progress. We first detail the perturbative derivation of the steady state of AOUPs in the small persistence time limit. We show the existence of an effective equilibrium regime in which detailed-balance is obeyed with respect to a non-Boltzmann distribution and detail the corresponding fluctuation-dissipation theorem. We then characterize the departure from equilibrium by computing several relevant observables (entropy production, ratchet current). At the collective level, we show AOUPs to experience motility-induced phase separation both in the presence of pairwise forces or due to quorum-sensing interactions. The latter can be accounted for by considering the steady-state of AOUPs with spatially varying propulsion speed or persistence time. Finally, we discuss how the emerging properties of AOUPs can be characterized from the dynamics of their collective modes, which we construct explicitly.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2021; v1 submitted 29 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Fluctuation-induced phase separation in metric and topological models of collective motion
Authors:
David Martin,
Hugues Chaté,
Cesare Nardini,
Alexandre Solon,
Julien Tailleur,
Frédéric van Wijland
Abstract:
We study the role of noise on the nature of the transition to collective motion in dry active matter. Starting from field theories that predict a continuous transition at the deterministic level, we show that fluctuations induce a density-dependent shift of the onset of order, which in turns changes the nature of the transition into a phase-separation scenario. Our results apply to a range of syst…
▽ More
We study the role of noise on the nature of the transition to collective motion in dry active matter. Starting from field theories that predict a continuous transition at the deterministic level, we show that fluctuations induce a density-dependent shift of the onset of order, which in turns changes the nature of the transition into a phase-separation scenario. Our results apply to a range of systems, including the topological models in which particles interact with a fixed number of nearest neighbors, which were believed so far to exhibit a continuous onset of order. Our analytical predictions are confirmed by numerical simulations of fluctuating hydrodynamics and microscopic models.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Self-Organized Critical Coexistence Phase in Repulsive Active Particles
Authors:
Xia-qing Shi,
Giordano Fausti,
Hugues Chaté,
Cesare Nardini,
Alexandre Solon
Abstract:
We revisit motility-induced phase separation in two models of active particles interacting by pairwise repulsion. We show that the resulting dense phase contains gas bubbles distributed algebraically up to a typically large cutoff scale. At large enough system size and/or global density, all the gas may be contained inside the bubbles, at which point the system is microphase-separated with a finit…
▽ More
We revisit motility-induced phase separation in two models of active particles interacting by pairwise repulsion. We show that the resulting dense phase contains gas bubbles distributed algebraically up to a typically large cutoff scale. At large enough system size and/or global density, all the gas may be contained inside the bubbles, at which point the system is microphase-separated with a finite cut-off bubble scale. We observe that the ordering is anomalous, with different dynamics for the coarsening of the dense phase and of the gas bubbles. This phenomenology is reproduced by a "reduced bubble model" that implements the basic idea of reverse Ostwald ripening put forward in Tjhung et al. [Phys. Rev. X 8, 031080 (2018)].
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2021; v1 submitted 7 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Symmetric mixtures of pusher and puller microswimmers behave as noninteracting suspensions
Authors:
Dóra Bárdfalvy,
Shan Anjum,
Cesare Nardini,
Alexander Morozov,
Joakim Stenhammar
Abstract:
Suspensions of rear- and front-actuated microswimmers immersed in a fluid, known respectively as ``pushers'' and ``pullers'', display qualitatively different collective behaviours: beyond a characteristic density, pusher suspensions exhibit a hydrodynamic instability leading to collective motion known as active turbulence, a phenomenon which is absent for pullers. In this Letter, we describe the c…
▽ More
Suspensions of rear- and front-actuated microswimmers immersed in a fluid, known respectively as ``pushers'' and ``pullers'', display qualitatively different collective behaviours: beyond a characteristic density, pusher suspensions exhibit a hydrodynamic instability leading to collective motion known as active turbulence, a phenomenon which is absent for pullers. In this Letter, we describe the collective dynamics of a binary pusher--puller mixture using kinetic theory and large-scale particle-resolved simulations. We derive and verify an instability criterion, showing that the critical density for active turbulence moves to higher values as the fraction $χ$ of pullers is increased and disappears for $χ\geq 0.5$. We then show analytically and numerically that the two-point hydrodynamic correlations of the 1:1 mixture are equal to those of a suspension of noninteracting swimmers. Strikingly, our numerical analysis furthermore shows that the full probability distribution of the fluid velocity fluctuations collapses onto the one of a noninteracting system at the same density, where swimmer--swimmer correlations are strictly absent. Our results thus indicate that the fluid velocity fluctuations in 1:1 pusher--puller mixtures are exactly equal to those of the corresponding noninteracting suspension at any density, a surprising cancellation with no counterpart in equilibrium long-range interacting systems.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2020; v1 submitted 15 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Swimming suppresses correlations in dilute suspensions of pusher microorganisms
Authors:
Viktor Škultéty,
Cesare Nardini,
Joakim Stenhammar,
Davide Marenduzzo,
Alexander Morozov
Abstract:
Active matter exhibits various forms of non-equilibrium states in the absence of external forcing, including macroscopic steady-state currents. Such states are often too complex to be modelled from first principles and our understanding of their physics relies heavily on minimal models. These have mostly been studied in the case of "dry" active matter, where particle dynamics are dominated by fric…
▽ More
Active matter exhibits various forms of non-equilibrium states in the absence of external forcing, including macroscopic steady-state currents. Such states are often too complex to be modelled from first principles and our understanding of their physics relies heavily on minimal models. These have mostly been studied in the case of "dry" active matter, where particle dynamics are dominated by friction with their surroundings. Significantly less is known about systems with long-range hydrodynamic interactions that belong to "wet" active matter. Dilute suspensions of motile bacteria, modelled as self-propelled dipolar particles interacting solely through long-ranged hydrodynamic fields, are arguably the most studied example from this class of active systems. Their phenomenology is well-established: at sufficiently high density of bacteria, there appear large-scale vortices and jets comprising many individual organisms, forming a chaotic state commonly known as bacterial turbulence. As revealed by computer simulations, below the onset of collective motion, the suspension exhibits very strong correlations between individual microswimmers stemming from the long-ranged nature of dipolar fields. Here we demonstrate that this phenomenology is captured by the minimal model of microswimmers. We develop a kinetic theory that goes beyond the commonly used mean-field assumption, and explicitly takes into account such correlations. Notably, these can be computed exactly within our theory. We calculate the fluid velocity variance, spatial and temporal correlation functions, the fluid velocity spectrum, and the enhanced diffusivity of tracer particles. We find that correlations are suppressed by particle self-propulsion, although the mean-field behaviour is not restored even in the limit of very fast swimming.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2020; v1 submitted 7 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
The 2019 Motile Active Matter Roadmap
Authors:
Gerhard Gompper,
Roland G. Winkler,
Thomas Speck,
Alexandre Solon,
Cesare Nardini,
Fernando Peruani,
Hartmut Loewen,
Ramin Golestanian,
U. Benjamin Kaupp,
Luis Alvarez,
Thomas Kioerboe,
Eric Lauga,
Wilson Poon,
Antonio De Simone,
Frank Cichos,
Alexander Fischer,
Santiago Muinos Landin,
Nicola Soeker,
Raymond Kapral,
Pierre Gaspard,
Marisol Ripoll,
Francesc Sagues,
Julia Yeomans,
Amin Doostmohammadi,
Igor Aronson
, et al. (12 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Activity and autonomous motion are fundamental in living and engineering systems. This has stimulated the new field of active matter in recent years, which focuses on the physical aspects of propulsion mechanisms, and on motility-induced emergent collective behavior of a larger number of identical agents. The scale of agents ranges from nanomotors and microswimmers, to cells, fish, birds, and peop…
▽ More
Activity and autonomous motion are fundamental in living and engineering systems. This has stimulated the new field of active matter in recent years, which focuses on the physical aspects of propulsion mechanisms, and on motility-induced emergent collective behavior of a larger number of identical agents. The scale of agents ranges from nanomotors and microswimmers, to cells, fish, birds, and people. Inspired by biological microswimmers, various designs of autonomous synthetic nano- and micromachines have been proposed. Such machines provide the basis for multifunctional, highly responsive, intelligent (artificial) active materials, which exhibit emergent behavior and the ability to perform tasks in response to external stimuli. A major challenge for understanding and designing active matter is their inherent nonequilibrium nature due to persistent energy consumption, which invalidates equilibrium concepts such as free energy, detailed balance, and time-reversal symmetry. Unraveling, predicting, and controlling the behavior of active matter is a truly interdisciplinary endeavor at the interface of biology, chemistry, ecology, engineering, mathematics, and physics. The vast complexity of phenomena and mechanisms involved in the self-organization and dynamics of motile active matter comprises a major challenge. Hence, to advance, and eventually reach a comprehensive understanding, this important research area requires a concerted, synergetic approach of the various disciplines.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Particle-resolved lattice Boltzmann simulations of 3-dimensional active turbulence
Authors:
Dora Bardfalvy,
Henrik Nordanger,
Cesare Nardini,
Alexander Morozov,
Joakim Stenhammar
Abstract:
Collective behaviour in suspensions of microswimmers is often dominated by the impact of long-ranged hydrodynamic interactions. These phenomena include active turbulence, where suspensions of pusher bacteria at sufficient densities exhibit large-scale, chaotic flows. To study this collective phenomenon, we use large-scale (up to $N=3\times 10^6$) particle-resolved lattice Boltzmann simulations of…
▽ More
Collective behaviour in suspensions of microswimmers is often dominated by the impact of long-ranged hydrodynamic interactions. These phenomena include active turbulence, where suspensions of pusher bacteria at sufficient densities exhibit large-scale, chaotic flows. To study this collective phenomenon, we use large-scale (up to $N=3\times 10^6$) particle-resolved lattice Boltzmann simulations of model microswimmers described by extended stresslets. Such system sizes enable us to obtain quantitative information about both the transition to active turbulence and characteristic features of the turbulent state itself. In the dilute limit, we test analytical predictions for a number of static and dynamic properties against our simulation results. For higher swimmer densities, where swimmer-swimmer interactions become significant, we numerically show that the length- and timescales of the turbulent flows increase steeply near the predicted finite-system transition density.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2019; v1 submitted 5 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
From bulk to microphase separation in scalar active matter: A perturbative renormalization group analysis
Authors:
Fernando Caballero,
Cesare Nardini,
Michael E. Cates
Abstract:
We consider a dynamical field theory (Active Model B+) that minimally extends the equilibrium Model B for diffusive phase separation of a scalar field, by adding leading-order terms that break time-reversal symmetry. It was recently shown that such active terms can cause the bulk phase separation of Model B to be replaced by a steady state of microphase separation at a finite length scale. This ph…
▽ More
We consider a dynamical field theory (Active Model B+) that minimally extends the equilibrium Model B for diffusive phase separation of a scalar field, by adding leading-order terms that break time-reversal symmetry. It was recently shown that such active terms can cause the bulk phase separation of Model B to be replaced by a steady state of microphase separation at a finite length scale. This phenomenon was understood at mean-field level as due to the activity-induced reversal of the Ostwald ripening mechanism, which provides the kinetic pathway to bulk phase separation in passive fluids. This reversal occurs only in certain ranges for the activity parameters. In this paper we go beyond such a mean-field analysis and develop a $1$-loop Renormalisation Group (RG) approach. We first show that, in the parameter range where bulk phase separation is still present, the critical point belongs formally to the same (Wilson-Fisher) universality class as the passive Model B. In contrast, in a parameter range associated with microphase separation, we find that an unstable non-equilibrium fixed point of the RG flow arises for $d\geq 2$, colliding with the Wilson-Fisher point in $d\to 2^+$ and making it unstable in $d=2$. At large activity, the flow in this region is towards strong coupling. We argue that the phase transition to microphase separation in active systems, in the physically relevant dimensions $d=2$ and $3$, very probably belongs to a new non-equilibrium universality class. Because it is governed by the strong-coupling regime of the RG flow, our perturbative analysis leaves open the quantitative characterization of this new class.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2018; v1 submitted 27 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Strong coupling in conserved surface roughening: A new universality class?
Authors:
Fernando Caballero,
Cesare Nardini,
Frederic van Wijland,
Michael E. Cates
Abstract:
The Kardar-Parisi-Zhang (KPZ) equation defines the main universality class for nonlinear growth and roughening of surfaces. But under certain conditions, a conserved KPZ equation (cKPZ) is thought to set the universality class instead. This has non-mean-field behavior only in spatial dimension $d<2$. We point out here that cKPZ is incomplete: it omits a symmetry-allowed nonlinear gradient term of…
▽ More
The Kardar-Parisi-Zhang (KPZ) equation defines the main universality class for nonlinear growth and roughening of surfaces. But under certain conditions, a conserved KPZ equation (cKPZ) is thought to set the universality class instead. This has non-mean-field behavior only in spatial dimension $d<2$. We point out here that cKPZ is incomplete: it omits a symmetry-allowed nonlinear gradient term of the same order as the one retained. Adding this term, we find a parameter regime where the $1$-loop renormalization group flow diverges. This suggests a phase transition to a new growth phase, possibly ruled by a strong coupling fixed point and thus described by a new universality class, for any $d>1$. In this phase, numerical integration of the model in $d=2$ gives clear evidence of non mean-field behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Extracting maximum power from active colloidal heat engines
Authors:
D. Martin,
C. Nardini,
M. E. Cates,
É. Fodor
Abstract:
Colloidal heat engines extract power out of a fluctuating bath by manipulating a confined tracer. Considering a self-propelled tracer surrounded by a bath of passive colloids, we optimize the engine performances based on the maximum available power. Our approach relies on an adiabatic mean-field treatment of the bath particles which reduces the many-body description into an effective tracer dynami…
▽ More
Colloidal heat engines extract power out of a fluctuating bath by manipulating a confined tracer. Considering a self-propelled tracer surrounded by a bath of passive colloids, we optimize the engine performances based on the maximum available power. Our approach relies on an adiabatic mean-field treatment of the bath particles which reduces the many-body description into an effective tracer dynamics. It leads us to reveal that, when operated at constant activity, an engine can only produce less maximum power than its passive counterpart. In contrast, the output power of an isothermal engine, operating with cyclic variations of the self-propulsion without any passive equivalent, exhibits an optimum in terms of confinement and activity. Direct numerical simulations of the microscopic dynamics support the validity of these results even beyond the mean-field regime, with potential relevance to the design of experimental engines.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2018; v1 submitted 5 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Cluster phases and bubbly phase separation in active fluids: Reversal of the Ostwald process
Authors:
Elsen Tjhung,
Cesare Nardini,
Michael E. Cates
Abstract:
It is known that purely repulsive self-propelled colloids can undergo bulk liquid-vapor phase separation. In experiments and large scale simulations, however, more complex steady states are also seen, comprising a dynamic population of dense clusters in a sea of vapor, or dilute bubbles in a liquid. Here we show that these microphase-separated states should emerge generically in active matter, wit…
▽ More
It is known that purely repulsive self-propelled colloids can undergo bulk liquid-vapor phase separation. In experiments and large scale simulations, however, more complex steady states are also seen, comprising a dynamic population of dense clusters in a sea of vapor, or dilute bubbles in a liquid. Here we show that these microphase-separated states should emerge generically in active matter, without any need to invoke system-specific details. We give a coarse-grained description of them, and predict transitions between regimes of bulk phase separation and microphase separation. We achieve these results by extending the $φ^4$ field theory of passive phase separation to allow for all local currents that break detailed balance at leading order in the gradient expansion. These local active currents, whose form we show to emerge from coarse-graining of microscopic models, include a mixture of irrotational and rotational contributions, and can be viewed as arising from an effective nonlocal chemical potential. Such contributions influence, and in some parameter ranges reverse, the classical Ostwald process that would normally drive bulk phase separation to completion.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2018; v1 submitted 23 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Process interpretation of current entropic bounds
Authors:
Cesare Nardini,
Hugo Touchette
Abstract:
We show for Markov diffusion processes that the quadratic entropic bound, recently derived for the rate functions of nonequilibrium currents, can be seen as being produced by an effective process that creates current fluctuations in a sub-optimal way by modifying only the non-reversible part of the drift or force of the process considered while kee** its reversible part constant. This provides a…
▽ More
We show for Markov diffusion processes that the quadratic entropic bound, recently derived for the rate functions of nonequilibrium currents, can be seen as being produced by an effective process that creates current fluctuations in a sub-optimal way by modifying only the non-reversible part of the drift or force of the process considered while kee** its reversible part constant. This provides a clear interpretation of the bound in terms of a physical process, which explains, among other things, its relation to the fluctuation relation, linear response, and reversible limits. The existence of more general quadratic bounds, and related uncertainty relations, for physical quantities other than currents is also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2017; v1 submitted 26 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
The role of correlations in the collective behaviour of microswimmer suspensions
Authors:
Joakim Stenhammar,
Cesare Nardini,
Rupert W. Nash,
Davide Marenduzzo,
Alexander Morozov
Abstract:
In this Letter, we study the collective behaviour of a large number of self-propelled microswimmers immersed in a fluid. Using unprecedently large-scale lattice Boltzmann simulations, we reproduce the transition to bacterial turbulence. We show that, even well below the transition, swimmers move in a correlated fashion that cannot be described by a mean-field approach. We develop a novel kinetic t…
▽ More
In this Letter, we study the collective behaviour of a large number of self-propelled microswimmers immersed in a fluid. Using unprecedently large-scale lattice Boltzmann simulations, we reproduce the transition to bacterial turbulence. We show that, even well below the transition, swimmers move in a correlated fashion that cannot be described by a mean-field approach. We develop a novel kinetic theory that captures these correlations and is non-perturbative in the swimmer density. To provide an experimentally accessible measure of correlations, we calculate the diffusivity of passive tracers and reveal its non-trivial density dependence. The theory is in quantitative agreement with the lattice Boltzmann simulations and captures the asymmetry between pusher and puller swimmers below the transition to turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2017; v1 submitted 6 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Entropy production in field theories without time reversal symmetry: Quantifying the non-equilibrium character of active matter
Authors:
Cesare Nardini,
Etienne Fodor,
Elsen Tjhung,
Frederic van Wijland,
Julien Tailleur,
Michael E. Cates
Abstract:
Active matter systems operate far from equilibrium due to the continuous energy injection at the scale of constituent particles. At larger scales, described by coarse-grained models, the global entropy production rate S quantifies the probability ratio of forward and reversed dynamics and hence the importance of irreversibility at such scales: it vanishes whenever the coarse-grained dynamics of th…
▽ More
Active matter systems operate far from equilibrium due to the continuous energy injection at the scale of constituent particles. At larger scales, described by coarse-grained models, the global entropy production rate S quantifies the probability ratio of forward and reversed dynamics and hence the importance of irreversibility at such scales: it vanishes whenever the coarse-grained dynamics of the active system reduces to that of an effective equilibrium model. We evaluate S for a class of scalar stochastic field theories describing the coarse-grained density of self-propelled particles without alignment interactions, capturing such key phenomena as motility-induced phase separation. We show how the entropy production can be decomposed locally (in real space) or spectrally (in Fourier space), allowing detailed examination of the spatial structure and correlations that underly departures from equilibrium. For phase-separated systems, the local entropy production is concentrated mainly on interfaces with a bulk contribution that tends to zero in the weak-noise limit. In homogeneous states, we find a generalized Harada-Sasa relation that directly expresses the entropy production in terms of the wavevector-dependent deviation from the fluctuation-dissipation relation between response functions and correlators. We discuss extensions to the case where the particle density is coupled to a momentum-conserving solvent, and to situations where the particle current, rather than the density, should be chosen as the dynamical field. We expect the new conceptual tools developed here to be broadly useful in the context of active matter, allowing one to distinguish when and where activity plays an essential role in the dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2017; v1 submitted 19 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
How far from equilibrium is active matter?
Authors:
Étienne Fodor,
Cesare Nardini,
Mike E. Cates,
Julien Tailleur,
Paolo Visco,
Frédéric van Wijland
Abstract:
Active matter systems are driven out of thermal equilibrium by a lack of generalized Stokes-Einstein relation between injection and dissipation of energy at the microscopic scale. We consider such a system of interacting particles, propelled by persistent noises, and show that, at small but finite persistence time, their dynamics still satisfy a time-reversal symmetry. To do so, we compute perturb…
▽ More
Active matter systems are driven out of thermal equilibrium by a lack of generalized Stokes-Einstein relation between injection and dissipation of energy at the microscopic scale. We consider such a system of interacting particles, propelled by persistent noises, and show that, at small but finite persistence time, their dynamics still satisfy a time-reversal symmetry. To do so, we compute perturbatively their steady-state measure and show that, for short persistent times, the entropy production rate vanishes. This endows such systems with an effective Fluctuation-Dissipation theorem akin to that of thermal equilibrium systems. Last we show how interacting particle systems with viscous drags and correlated noises can be seen as in equilibrium with a visco-elastic bath but driven out of equilibrium by non-conservative forces, hence providing an energetic insight on the departure of active systems from equilibrium.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Fluctuations of large-scale jets in the stochastic 2D Euler equation
Authors:
Cesare Nardini,
Tomás Tangarife
Abstract:
Two-dimensional turbulence in a rectangular domain self-organises into large-scale unidirectional jets. While several results are present to characterize the mean jets velocity profile, much less is known about the fluctuations. We study jets dynamics in the stochastically forced two-dimensional Euler equations. In the limit where the average jets velocity profile evolves slowly with respect to tu…
▽ More
Two-dimensional turbulence in a rectangular domain self-organises into large-scale unidirectional jets. While several results are present to characterize the mean jets velocity profile, much less is known about the fluctuations. We study jets dynamics in the stochastically forced two-dimensional Euler equations. In the limit where the average jets velocity profile evolves slowly with respect to turbulent fluctuations, we employ a multi-scale (kinetic theory) approach, which relates jet dynamics to the statistics of Reynolds stresses. We study analytically the Gaussian fluctuations of Reynolds stresses and predict the spatial structure of the jets velocity covariance. Our results agree qualitatively well with direct numerical simulations, clearly showing that the jets velocity profile are enhanced away from the stationary points of the average velocity profile. A numerical test of our predictions at quantitative level seems out of reach at the present day.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Kinetic theory and quasilinear theories of jet dynamics
Authors:
F Bouchet,
C Nardini,
T Tangarife
Abstract:
We review progress that has been made to constructa theory for the jet formation and maintenance in planetary atmospheres. The theory is built in the regime where velocityfluctuations around the base jet are very small compared to the zonaljet velocity itself. Such situations are frequent in many naturaljets, for instance in the atmosphere of outer planets, the most prominentexample being probably…
▽ More
We review progress that has been made to constructa theory for the jet formation and maintenance in planetary atmospheres. The theory is built in the regime where velocityfluctuations around the base jet are very small compared to the zonaljet velocity itself. Such situations are frequent in many naturaljets, for instance in the atmosphere of outer planets, the most prominentexample being probably Jupiter's troposphere jets. As discussed inother chapters of this book, fluctuations close to Jupiter zonaljets are smaller than the zonal jets themselves. In such a regime, it is natural and often justified to treat the non-zonalpart of the dynamics with a quasi-linear approximation: at leadingorder the dynamics of the non-zonal flow is described by theequation linearized close to the quasi-stationary zonal jets. The theory, based on a multi-scale method called stochastic averaging, share similarities with Stochastic Structural Stability Theory (S3T) and with second order closure(CE2), also discussed in other chapters of the book.The aim of this contribution is to discuss the theoretical aspects of sucha quasilinear description of statistically stationary jets. The basicquestions are: when does such an approach is expected to be valid,why, what are the limitations and the expected errors done doing suchapproximations?
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2016; v1 submitted 9 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Perturbative calculation of quasi-potential in non-equilibrium diffusions: a mean-field example
Authors:
Freddy Bouchet,
Krzysztof Gawedzki,
Cesare Nardini
Abstract:
In stochastic systems with weak noise, the logarithm of the stationary distribution becomes proportional to a large deviation rate function called the quasi-potential. The quasi-potential, and its characterization through a variational problem, lies at the core of the Freidlin-Wentzell large deviations theory%.~\cite{freidlin1984}.In many interacting particle systems, the particle density is descr…
▽ More
In stochastic systems with weak noise, the logarithm of the stationary distribution becomes proportional to a large deviation rate function called the quasi-potential. The quasi-potential, and its characterization through a variational problem, lies at the core of the Freidlin-Wentzell large deviations theory%.~\cite{freidlin1984}.In many interacting particle systems, the particle density is described by fluctuating hydrodynamics governed by Macroscopic Fluctuation Theory%, ~\cite{bertini2014},which formally fits within Freidlin-Wentzell's framework with a weak noise proportional to $1/\sqrt{N}$, where $N$ is the number of particles. The quasi-potential then appears as a natural generalization of the equilibrium free energy to non-equilibrium particle systems. A key physical and practical issue is to actually compute quasi-potentials from their variational characterization for non-equilibrium systems for which detailed balance does not hold. We discuss how to perform such a computation perturbatively in an external parameter $λ$, starting from a known quasi-potential for $λ=0$. In a general setup, explicit iterative formulae for all terms of the power-series expansion of the quasi-potential are given for the first time. The key point is a proof of solvability conditions that assure the existence of the perturbation expansion to all orders. We apply the perturbative approach to diffusive particles interacting through a mean-field potential. For such systems, the variational characterization of the quasi-potential was proven by Dawson and Gartner%. ~\cite{dawson1987,dawson1987b}. Our perturbative analysis provides new explicit results about the quasi-potential and about fluctuations of one-particle observables in a simple example of mean field diffusions: the Shinomoto-Kuramoto model of coupled rotators%. ~\cite{shinomoto1986}. This is one of few systems for which non-equilibrium free energies can be computed and analyzed in an effective way, at least perturbatively.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2016; v1 submitted 10 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Density of states of the $XY$ model: an energy landscape approach
Authors:
Cesare Nardini,
Rachele Nerattini,
Lapo Casetti
Abstract:
Among the stationary configurations of the Hamiltonian of a classical O$(n)$ lattice spin model, a class can be identified which is in one-to-one correspondence with all the the configurations of an Ising model defined on the same lattice and with the same interactions. Starting from this observation it has been recently proposed that the microcanonical density of states of an O$(n)$ model could b…
▽ More
Among the stationary configurations of the Hamiltonian of a classical O$(n)$ lattice spin model, a class can be identified which is in one-to-one correspondence with all the the configurations of an Ising model defined on the same lattice and with the same interactions. Starting from this observation it has been recently proposed that the microcanonical density of states of an O$(n)$ model could be written in terms of the density of states of the corresponding Ising model. Later, it has been shown that a relation of this kind holds exactly for two solvable models, the mean-field and the one-dimensional $XY$ model, respectively. We apply the same strategy to derive explicit, albeit approximate, expressions for the density of states of the two-dimensional $XY$ model with nearest-neighbor interactions on a square lattice. The caloric curve and the specific heat as a function of the energy density are calculated and compared against simulation data, yielding a very good agreement over the entire energy density range. The concepts and methods involved in the approximations presented here are valid in principle for any O$(n)$ model.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Kinetic theory of jet dynamics in the stochastic barotropic and 2D Navier-Stokes equations
Authors:
Freddy Bouchet,
Cesare Nardini,
Tomás Tangarife
Abstract:
We discuss the dynamics of zonal (or unidirectional) jets for barotropic flows forced by Gaussian stochastic fields with white in time correlation functions. This problem contains the stochastic dynamics of 2D Navier-Stokes equation as a special case. We consider the limit of weak forces and dissipation, when there is a time scale separation between the inertial time scale (fast) and the spin-up o…
▽ More
We discuss the dynamics of zonal (or unidirectional) jets for barotropic flows forced by Gaussian stochastic fields with white in time correlation functions. This problem contains the stochastic dynamics of 2D Navier-Stokes equation as a special case. We consider the limit of weak forces and dissipation, when there is a time scale separation between the inertial time scale (fast) and the spin-up or spin-down time (large) needed to reach an average energy balance. In this limit, we show that an adiabatic reduction (or stochastic averaging) of the dynamics can be performed. We then obtain a kinetic equation that describes the slow evolution of zonal jets over a very long time scale, where the effect of non-zonal turbulence has been integrated out. The main theoretical difficulty, achieved in this work, is to analyze the stationary distribution of a Lyapunov equation that describes quasi-Gaussian fluctuations around each zonal jet, in the inertial limit. This is necessary to prove that there is no ultraviolet divergence at leading order in such a way that the asymptotic expansion is self-consistent. We obtain at leading order a Fokker--Planck equation, associated to a stochastic kinetic equation, that describes the slow jet dynamics. Its deterministic part is related to well known phenomenological theories (for instance Stochastic Structural Stability Theory) and to quasi-linear approximations, whereas the stochastic part allows to go beyond the computation of the most probable zonal jet. We argue that the effect of the stochastic part may be of huge importance when, as for instance in the proximity of phase transitions, more than one attractor of the dynamics is present.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2013; v1 submitted 4 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Absence of thermalization for systems with long-range interactions coupled to a thermal bath
Authors:
Pierre de Buyl,
Giovanni De Ninno,
Duccio Fanelli,
Cesare Nardini,
Aurelio Patelli,
Francesco Piazza,
Yoshiyuki Y. Yamaguchi
Abstract:
We investigate the dynamics of a small long-range interacting system, in contact with a large long-range thermal bath. Our analysis reveals the existence of striking anomalies in the energy flux between the bath and the system. In particular, we find that the evolution of the system is not influenced by the kinetic temperature of the bath, as opposed to what happens for short-range collisional sys…
▽ More
We investigate the dynamics of a small long-range interacting system, in contact with a large long-range thermal bath. Our analysis reveals the existence of striking anomalies in the energy flux between the bath and the system. In particular, we find that the evolution of the system is not influenced by the kinetic temperature of the bath, as opposed to what happens for short-range collisional systems. As a consequence, the system may get hotter also when its initial temperature is larger than the bath temperature. This observation is explained quantitatively in the framework of the collisionless Vlasov description of toy models with long-range interactions and shown to be valid whenever the Vlasov picture applies, from cosmology to plasma physics.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2016; v1 submitted 12 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Kinetic theory of nonequilibrium stochastic long-range systems: Phase transition and bistability
Authors:
Cesare Nardini,
Shamik Gupta,
Stefano Ruffo,
Thierry Dauxois,
Freddy Bouchet
Abstract:
We study long-range interacting systems driven by external stochastic forces that act collectively on all the particles constituting the system. Such a scenario is frequently encountered in the context of plasmas, self-gravitating systems, two-dimensional turbulence, and also in a broad class of other systems. Under the effect of stochastic driving, the system reaches a stationary state where exte…
▽ More
We study long-range interacting systems driven by external stochastic forces that act collectively on all the particles constituting the system. Such a scenario is frequently encountered in the context of plasmas, self-gravitating systems, two-dimensional turbulence, and also in a broad class of other systems. Under the effect of stochastic driving, the system reaches a stationary state where external forces balance dissipation on average. These states have the invariant probability that does not respect detailed balance, and are characterized by non-vanishing currents of conserved quantities. In order to analyze spatially homogeneous stationary states, we develop a kinetic approach that generalizes the one known for deterministic long-range systems; we obtain a very good agreement between predictions from kinetic theory and extensive numerical simulations. Our approach may also be generalized to describe spatially inhomogeneous stationary states. We also report on numerical simulations exhibiting a first-order nonequilibrium phase transition from homogeneous to inhomogeneous states. Close to the phase transition, the system shows bistable behavior between the two states, with a mean residence time that diverges as an exponential in the inverse of the strength of the external stochastic forces, in the limit of low values of such forces.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2012; v1 submitted 1 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Caloric curve of star clusters
Authors:
Lapo Casetti,
Cesare Nardini
Abstract:
Self-gravitating systems, like globular clusters or elliptical galaxies, are the prototypes of many-body systems with long-range interactions, and should be the natural arena where to test theoretical predictions on the statistical behaviour of long-range-interacting systems. Systems of classical self-gravitating particles can be studied with the standard tools of equilibrium statistical mechanics…
▽ More
Self-gravitating systems, like globular clusters or elliptical galaxies, are the prototypes of many-body systems with long-range interactions, and should be the natural arena where to test theoretical predictions on the statistical behaviour of long-range-interacting systems. Systems of classical self-gravitating particles can be studied with the standard tools of equilibrium statistical mechanics, provided the potential is regularized at small length scales and the system is confined in a box. The confinement condition looks rather unphysical in general, so that it is natural to ask whether what we learn with these studies is relevant to real self-gravitating systems. In order to provide a first answer to this question we consider a basic, simple, yet effective model of globular clusters, the King model. This model describes a self-consistently confined system, without the need of any external box, but the stationary state is a non-thermal one. In particular, we consider the King model with a short-distance cutoff on the interactions and we discuss how such a cutoff affects the caloric curve, i.e. the relation between temperature and energy. We find that the cutoff stabilizes a low-energy phase which is absent in the King model without cutoff; the caloric curve of the model with cutoff turns out to be very similar to that of previously studied confined and regularized models, but for the absence of a high-energy gas-like phase. We briefly discuss the possible phenomenological as well as theoretical implications of these results.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2012;
originally announced March 2012.
-
Linear response theory for long-range interacting systems in quasistationary states
Authors:
Aurelio Patelli,
Shamik Gupta,
Cesare Nardini,
Stefano Ruffo
Abstract:
Long-range interacting systems, while relaxing to equilibrium, often get trapped in long-lived quasistationary states which have lifetimes that diverge with the system size. In this work, we address the question of how a long-range system in a quasistationary state (QSS) responds to an external perturbation. We consider a long-range system that evolves under deterministic Hamilton dynamics. The pe…
▽ More
Long-range interacting systems, while relaxing to equilibrium, often get trapped in long-lived quasistationary states which have lifetimes that diverge with the system size. In this work, we address the question of how a long-range system in a quasistationary state (QSS) responds to an external perturbation. We consider a long-range system that evolves under deterministic Hamilton dynamics. The perturbation is taken to couple to the canonical coordinates of the individual constituents. Our study is based on analyzing the Vlasov equation for the single-particle phase space distribution. The QSS represents stable stationary solution of the Vlasov equation in the absence of the external perturbation. In the presence of small perturbation, we linearize the perturbed Vlasov equation about the QSS to obtain a formal expression for the response observed in a single-particle dynamical quantity. For a QSS that is homogeneous in the coordinate, we obtain an explicit formula for the response. We apply our analysis to a paradigmatic model, the Hamiltonian mean-field model, that involves particles moving on a circle under Hamilton dynamics. Our prediction for the response of three representative QSSs in this model (the water-bag QSS, the Fermi-Dirac QSS, and the Gaussian QSS) is found to be in good agreement with $N$-particle simulations for large $N$. We also show the long-time relaxation of the water-bag QSS to the Boltzmann-Gibbs equilibrium state.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2012; v1 submitted 5 December, 2011;
originally announced December 2011.
-
Kinetic theory for non-equilibrium stationary states in long-range interacting systems
Authors:
Cesare Nardini,
Shamik Gupta,
Stefano Ruffo,
Thierry Dauxois,
Freddy Bouchet
Abstract:
We study long-range interacting systems perturbed by external stochastic forces. Unlike the case of short-range systems, where stochastic forces usually act locally on each particle, here we consider perturbations by external stochastic fields. The system reaches stationary states where external forces balance dissipation on average. These states do not respect detailed balance and support non-van…
▽ More
We study long-range interacting systems perturbed by external stochastic forces. Unlike the case of short-range systems, where stochastic forces usually act locally on each particle, here we consider perturbations by external stochastic fields. The system reaches stationary states where external forces balance dissipation on average. These states do not respect detailed balance and support non-vanishing fluxes of conserved quantities. We generalize the kinetic theory of isolated long-range systems to describe the dynamics of this non-equilibrium problem. The kinetic equation that we obtain applies to plasmas, self-gravitating systems, and to a broad class of other systems. Our theoretical results hold for homogeneous states, but may also be generalized to apply to inhomogeneous states. We obtain an excellent agreement between our theoretical predictions and numerical simulations. We discuss possible applications to describe non-equilibrium phase transitions.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2012; v1 submitted 29 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Density of states of continuous and discrete spin models: a case study
Authors:
Cesare Nardini,
Rachele Nerattini,
Lapo Casetti
Abstract:
A relation between O(n) lattice spin models and Ising models defined on the same lattice was recently put forward [L. Casetti, C. Nardini, and R. Nerattini, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 057208 (2011)]. Such a relation, inspired by an energy landscape analysis, implies that the density of states of an O(n) spin model on a lattice can be effectively approximated, at least close to the phase transition, in…
▽ More
A relation between O(n) lattice spin models and Ising models defined on the same lattice was recently put forward [L. Casetti, C. Nardini, and R. Nerattini, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 057208 (2011)]. Such a relation, inspired by an energy landscape analysis, implies that the density of states of an O(n) spin model on a lattice can be effectively approximated, at least close to the phase transition, in terms of the density of states of an Ising model defined on the same lattice and with the same interactions. In the present paper we show that such a relation exactly holds, albeit in a slightly modified form, in the special cases of the mean-field XY model and of the one-dimensional XY model. We also discuss the possible consequences of this result for the general case.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2012; v1 submitted 6 October, 2011;
originally announced October 2011.
-
On a microcanonical relation between continuous and discrete spin models
Authors:
Lapo Casetti,
Cesare Nardini,
Rachele Nerattini
Abstract:
A relation between a class of stationary points of the energy landscape of continuous spin models on a lattice and the configurations of a Ising model defined on the same lattice suggests an approximate expression for the microcanonical density of states. Based on this approximation we conjecture that if a O(n) model with ferromagnetic interactions on a lattice has a phase transition, its critical…
▽ More
A relation between a class of stationary points of the energy landscape of continuous spin models on a lattice and the configurations of a Ising model defined on the same lattice suggests an approximate expression for the microcanonical density of states. Based on this approximation we conjecture that if a O(n) model with ferromagnetic interactions on a lattice has a phase transition, its critical energy density is equal to that of the n = 1 case, i.e., a system of Ising spins with the same interactions. The conjecture holds true in the case of long-range interactions. For nearest-neighbor interactions, numerical results are consistent with the conjecture for n=2 and n=3 in three dimensions. For n=2 in two dimensions (XY model) the conjecture yields a prediction for the critical energy of the Berezinskij-Kosterlitz-Thouless transition, which would be equal to that of the two-dimensional Ising model. We discuss available numerical data in this respect.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
-
Solvable model of a self-gravitating system
Authors:
Lapo Casetti,
Cesare Nardini
Abstract:
We introduce and discuss an effective model of a self-gravitating system whose equilibrium thermodynamics can be solved in both the microcanonical and the canonical ensemble, up to a maximization with respect to a single variable. Such a model can be derived from a model of self-gravitating particles confined on a ring, referred to as the self-gravitating ring (SGR) model, allowing a quantitative…
▽ More
We introduce and discuss an effective model of a self-gravitating system whose equilibrium thermodynamics can be solved in both the microcanonical and the canonical ensemble, up to a maximization with respect to a single variable. Such a model can be derived from a model of self-gravitating particles confined on a ring, referred to as the self-gravitating ring (SGR) model, allowing a quantitative comparison between the thermodynamics of the two models. Despite the rather crude approximations involved in its derivation, the effective model compares quite well with the SGR model. Moreover, we discuss the relation between the effective model presented here and another model introduced by Thirring forty years ago. The two models are very similar and can be considered as examples of a class of minimal models of self-gravitating systems.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
-
Energy landscape and phase transitions in the self-gravitating ring model
Authors:
Cesare Nardini,
Lapo Casetti
Abstract:
We apply a recently proposed criterion for the existence of phase transitions, which is based on the properties of the saddles of the energy landscape, to a simplified model of a system with gravitational interactions, referred to as the self-gravitating ring model. We show analytically that the criterion correctly singles out the phase transition between a homogeneous and a clustered phase and…
▽ More
We apply a recently proposed criterion for the existence of phase transitions, which is based on the properties of the saddles of the energy landscape, to a simplified model of a system with gravitational interactions, referred to as the self-gravitating ring model. We show analytically that the criterion correctly singles out the phase transition between a homogeneous and a clustered phase and also suggests the presence of another phase transition, not previously known. On the basis of the properties of the energy landscape we conjecture on the nature of the latter transition.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
