-
3D characterization of kinematic fields and poroelastic swelling near the tip of a propagating crack in a hydrogel
Authors:
Chenzhuo Li,
Danila Zubko,
Damien Delespaul,
John M. Kolinski
Abstract:
In fracture mechanics, polyacrylamide hydrogels have been widely used as a model material for experiments, benefited from its optical transparency, fracture brittleness, and low Rayleigh wave velocity. To describe the brittle fracture in the hydrogels, linear elastic fracture mechanics comes as the first choice. However, in soft materials such as hydrogels, the crack opening can be extremely large…
▽ More
In fracture mechanics, polyacrylamide hydrogels have been widely used as a model material for experiments, benefited from its optical transparency, fracture brittleness, and low Rayleigh wave velocity. To describe the brittle fracture in the hydrogels, linear elastic fracture mechanics comes as the first choice. However, in soft materials such as hydrogels, the crack opening can be extremely large, leading to substantial geometric nonlinearity and material nonlinearity at the crack tip. Furthermore, poroelasticity may also modify the local mechanical state within the polymer network. Direct characterization of the kinematic fields and poroelastic effect at the crack tip is lacking. Here, based on a hybrid method of digital image correlation and particle tracking technique, we retrieved high-resolution 3D particle trajectories near the tip of a slowly propagating crack and measured the near-tip 3D kinematic fields, including the displacement fields, rotation fields, stretch fields, strain fields, and swelling fields. Results confirmed the complex multi-axial stretching near the crack tip and the substantial geometric nonlinearity, particularly on the two wakes of the crack where rotation exceeds $30^{\circ}$. Comparison between the measured and predicted displacement and strain fields, derived from linear elastic fracture mechanics, highlights a disagreement in the direct vicinity of the crack tip, particularly for displacement component $u_x$ and through-thickness strain component $\varepsilon_{zz}$. Significant swelling, due to the poroelastic solvent migration, is also observed, with a strong correlation to the local stretch. Our experimental method, without any assumption of the material properties, can be readily extended to study 3D crack tips in a huge varieties of materials, and our results can shed light on the fundamental fracture mechanics.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2024; v1 submitted 20 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Fluid-mediated impact of soft solids
Authors:
Jacopo Bilotto,
John Martin Kolinski,
Brice Lecampion,
Jean-François Molinari,
Ghatu Subhash,
Joaquin Garcia-Suarez
Abstract:
A viscous, lubrication-like response can be triggered in a thin film of fluid squeezed between a rigid and flat surface and the tip of an incoming projectile. We develop a comprehensive theory for this viscous approach stage of fluid-mediated normal impact, applicable to soft impactors. Under the assumption of mediating fluid being incompressible, the impacting solid displays two limit regimes: on…
▽ More
A viscous, lubrication-like response can be triggered in a thin film of fluid squeezed between a rigid and flat surface and the tip of an incoming projectile. We develop a comprehensive theory for this viscous approach stage of fluid-mediated normal impact, applicable to soft impactors. Under the assumption of mediating fluid being incompressible, the impacting solid displays two limit regimes: one dominated by elasticity and the other by inertia. The transition between the two is predicted by a dimensionless parameter, which can be interpreted as the ratio between two time scales that are the time that it takes for the surface waves to warn the leading edge of the impactor of the forthcoming impact, and the characteristic duration of the final viscous phase of the approach. Additionally, we assess the role of solid compressibility and elucidate why nearly-incompressible solids feature (a) substancial "gliding" prior to contact at the transition between regimes, (b) the largest size of entrapped bubble between the deformed tip of the impactor and the flat surface, and (c) a sudden drop in entrapped bubble radius past the transition between regimes. Finally, we argue that the above time scale ratio (a dimensionless number) can govern the different dynamics reported experimentally for a fluid droplet as a function of its viscosity and surface tension.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2023; v1 submitted 16 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Crack tip kinematics reveal the cohesive zone structure in brittle hydrogel fracture
Authors:
Chenzhuo Li,
Xinyue Wei,
Meng Wang,
Mokhtar Adda-Bedia,
John M. Kolinski
Abstract:
When brittle hydrogels fail, several mechanisms conspire to alter the state of stress near the tip of a crack, and it is challenging to identify which mechanism is dominant. In the fracture of brittle solids, a sufficient far-field stress results in the complete loss of structural strength as the material `unzips' at the tip of a crack, where stresses are concentrated. Direct studies of the so-cal…
▽ More
When brittle hydrogels fail, several mechanisms conspire to alter the state of stress near the tip of a crack, and it is challenging to identify which mechanism is dominant. In the fracture of brittle solids, a sufficient far-field stress results in the complete loss of structural strength as the material `unzips' at the tip of a crack, where stresses are concentrated. Direct studies of the so-called small-scale yielding zone, where deformation is large, are sparing. Using hydrogels as a model brittle solid, we probe the small-scale yielding region with a combination of microscopy methods that resolve the kinematics of the deformation. A zone over which most of the energy is dissipated through the loss of cohesion is identified in the immediate surroundings of the crack tip. With direct measurements, we determine the scale and structure of this zone, and identify how the specific loss mechanisms in this hydrogel material might generalize for brittle material failure.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
How hidden 3D structure within crack fronts reveals energy balance
Authors:
Meng Wang,
Mokhtar Adda-Bedia,
John M. Kolinski,
Jay Fineberg
Abstract:
Griffith's energetic criterion, or `energy balance', has for a century formed the basis for fracture mechanics; the energy flowing into a crack front is precisely balanced by the dissipation (fracture energy) at the front. If the crack front structure is not properly accounted for, energy balance will either appear to fail or lead to unrealistic results. Here, we study the influence of the seconda…
▽ More
Griffith's energetic criterion, or `energy balance', has for a century formed the basis for fracture mechanics; the energy flowing into a crack front is precisely balanced by the dissipation (fracture energy) at the front. If the crack front structure is not properly accounted for, energy balance will either appear to fail or lead to unrealistic results. Here, we study the influence of the secondary structure of low-speed crack propagation in hydrogels under tensile loading conditions. We first show that these cracks are bistable; either simple (cracks having no secondary structure) or faceted crack states (formed by steps propagating along crack fronts) can be generated under identical loading conditions. The selection of either crack state is determined by the form of the initial `seed' crack; perfect seed cracks generate simple cracks while a small local mode~III component generates crack fronts having multiple steps. Step coarsening eventually leads to single steps that propagate along crack fronts. As they evolve, steps locally change the instantaneous structure and motion of the crack front, breaking transverse translational invariance. In contrast to simple cracks, faceted cracks can, therefore, no longer be considered as existing in a quasi-2D system. For both simple and faceted cracks we simultaneously measure the energy flux and local dissipation along these crack fronts over velocities, $v$, spanning $0<v<0.2c_R$ ($c_R$ is the Rayleigh wave speed). We find that, in the presence of secondary structure within the crack front, the implementation of energy balance must be generalized for 3D systems; faceted cracks reveal energy balance, only when we account for the local dynamic dissipation at each point along the crack front.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Dilute concentrations of submicron particles do not alter the brittle fracture of polyacrylamide hydrogels
Authors:
Albert Taureg,
John M. Kolinski
Abstract:
In studies of the dynamic failure of brittle hydrogels, a bound has been placed on the process zone scale - the scale where material separation and ultimate failure occur. For the polyacrylamide hydrogel system under study, this bound is set at 20 microns. Thus, any subtle alterations to the material at a \emph{smaller} scale should not in principle alter the dynamic fracture response of the hydro…
▽ More
In studies of the dynamic failure of brittle hydrogels, a bound has been placed on the process zone scale - the scale where material separation and ultimate failure occur. For the polyacrylamide hydrogel system under study, this bound is set at 20 microns. Thus, any subtle alterations to the material at a \emph{smaller} scale should not in principle alter the dynamic fracture response of the hydrogel. Here we test this directly by embedding sub-micron-scale latex polystyrene microspheres within the brittle polyacrylamide hydrogel at a solids fraction of 0.1 \%. We verify that the spheres are well-distributed throughout the hydrogel material at this concentration with optical microscopy, and reconstruct the 3D distribution of these spheres using laser scanning confocal microscopy in backscatter mode. Finally, we test the fracture behavior of this gel with the dilute, embedded sub-micron spheres, and find that the brittle material failure modality common to this material \emph{without} the sub-micron spheres is indeed retained. By comparing the crack tip opening displacement, fracture energy and the crack's speed with established data from prior experimental work, we demonstrate that this material's failure is brittle, as it is in good agreement with the pure hydrogel system.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2020; v1 submitted 8 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
How moving cracks in brittle solids choose their path
Authors:
Lital Rozen-Levy,
John M. Kolinski,
Gil Cohen,
Jay Fineberg
Abstract:
While we fundamentally understand the dynamics of 'simple' cracks propagating in brittle solids within perfect (homogeneous) materials, we do not understand how paths of moving cracks are determined. We experimentally study strongly perturbed cracks that propagate between 10-95\% of their limiting velocity within a brittle material. These cracks are deflected by either interaction with sparsely im…
▽ More
While we fundamentally understand the dynamics of 'simple' cracks propagating in brittle solids within perfect (homogeneous) materials, we do not understand how paths of moving cracks are determined. We experimentally study strongly perturbed cracks that propagate between 10-95\% of their limiting velocity within a brittle material. These cracks are deflected by either interaction with sparsely implanted defects or via an intrinsic oscillatory instability in defect-free media. Dense, high-speed measurements of the strain fields surrounding the crack tips reveal that crack paths are governed by the direction of maximal strain energy density. This fundamentally important result may be utilized to either direct or guide running cracks.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2020; v1 submitted 7 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
How super-tough gels break
Authors:
Itamar Kolvin,
John M. Kolinski,
Jian ** Gong,
Jay Fineberg
Abstract:
Fracture of highly stretched materials challenges our view of how things break. We directly visualize rupture of tough double-network (DN) gels at >50\% strain. During fracture, crack tip shapes obey a $x\sim y^{1.6}$ power-law, in contrast to the parabolic profile observed in low-strain cracks. A new length-scale $\ell$ emerges from the power-law; we show that $\ell$ scales directly with the stor…
▽ More
Fracture of highly stretched materials challenges our view of how things break. We directly visualize rupture of tough double-network (DN) gels at >50\% strain. During fracture, crack tip shapes obey a $x\sim y^{1.6}$ power-law, in contrast to the parabolic profile observed in low-strain cracks. A new length-scale $\ell$ emerges from the power-law; we show that $\ell$ scales directly with the stored elastic energy, and diverges when the crack velocity approaches the shear wave speed. Our results show that DN gels undergo brittle fracture, and provide a testing ground for large-strain fracture mechanics.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
