Showing 1–50 of 75 results for author: Grason, G M

Thermal Preconditioning of Membrane Stress to Control the Shapes of Ultrathin Crystals

Authors: Hao Wan, Geunwoong Jeon, Gregory M. Grason, Maria M. Santore

Abstract: We employ the phospholipid bilayer membranes of giant unilamellar vesicles as a free-standing environment for the growth of membrane-integrated ultrathin phospholipid crystals possessing a variety of shapes with 6-fold symmetry. Crystal growth within vesicle membranes, where more elaborate shapes grow on larger vesicles is dominated by the bending energy of the membrane itself, creating a means to… ▽ More We employ the phospholipid bilayer membranes of giant unilamellar vesicles as a free-standing environment for the growth of membrane-integrated ultrathin phospholipid crystals possessing a variety of shapes with 6-fold symmetry. Crystal growth within vesicle membranes, where more elaborate shapes grow on larger vesicles is dominated by the bending energy of the membrane itself, creating a means to manipulate crystal morphology. Here we demonstrate how cooling rate preconditions the membrane tension before nucleation, in turn regulating nucleation and growth, and directing the morphology of crystals by the time they are large enough to be visualized. The crystals retain their shapes during further growth through the two phase region. Experiments demonstrate this behavior for single crystals growing within the membrane of each vesicle, ultimately comprising up to 13% of the vesicle area and length scales of up to 50 microns. A model for stress evolution, employing only physical property data, reveals how the competition between thermal membrane contraction and water diffusion from tensed vesicles produces a size- and time-dependence of the membrane tension as a result of cooling history. The tension, critical in the contribution of bending energy in the fluid membrane regions, in turn selects for crystal shape for vesicles of a given size. The model reveals unanticipated behaviors including a low steady state tension on small vesicles that allows compact domains to develop, rapid tension development on large vesicles producing flower-shaped domains, and a stress relaxation through water diffusion across the membrane with a time constant scaling as the square of the vesicle radius, consistent with measurable tensions only in the largest vesicles. △ Less

Submitted 6 July, 2024; originally announced July 2024.

Comments: Main text 32 pages and 7 figures; SI 4 pages and 4 figures

Geometrically frustrated, mechanical metamaterial membranes: Large-scale stress accumulation and size-selective assembly

Authors: Micheal Wang, Sourav Roy, Christian D. Santangelo, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: We study the effect of geometric frustration on dilational mechanical metamaterial membranes. While shape frustrated elastic plates can only accommodate non-zero Gaussian curvature up to size scales that ultimately vanish with their elastic thickness, we show that frustrated {\it metamembranes} accumulate hyperbolic curvatures up to mesoscopic length scales that are ultimately independent of the s… ▽ More We study the effect of geometric frustration on dilational mechanical metamaterial membranes. While shape frustrated elastic plates can only accommodate non-zero Gaussian curvature up to size scales that ultimately vanish with their elastic thickness, we show that frustrated {\it metamembranes} accumulate hyperbolic curvatures up to mesoscopic length scales that are ultimately independent of the size of their microscopic constituents. A continuum elastic theory and discrete numerical model describe the size-dependent shape and internal stresses of axisymmetric, trumpet-like frustrated metamembranes, revealing a non-trivial crossover to a much weaker power-law growth in elastic strain energy with size than in frustrated elastic membranes. We study a consequence of this for the self-limiting assembly thermodynamics of frustrated trumpets, showing a several-fold increase the size range of self-limitation of metamembranes relative to elastic membranes. △ Less

Submitted 24 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Comments: 6 pages, 3 figures, supplementary text appendices

Helical close-packing of anisotropic tubes

Authors: Benjamin R. Greenvall, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Helically close-packed states of filaments are common in natural and engineered material systems, ranging from nanoscopic biomolecules to macroscopic structural components. While the simplest models of helical close-packing, described by the ideal rope model, neglect anisotropy perpendicular to the backbone, physical filaments are often quite far from circular in their cross-section. Here, we cons… ▽ More Helically close-packed states of filaments are common in natural and engineered material systems, ranging from nanoscopic biomolecules to macroscopic structural components. While the simplest models of helical close-packing, described by the ideal rope model, neglect anisotropy perpendicular to the backbone, physical filaments are often quite far from circular in their cross-section. Here, we consider an anisotropic generalization of the ideal rope model and show that cross-section anisotropy has a strongly non-linear impact on the helical close-packing configurations of helical filaments. We show that the topology and composition of the close-packing landscape depends on the cross-sectional aspect ratio and is characterized by several distinct states of self-contact. We characterize the local density of these distinct states based on the notion of confinement within a 'virtual' cylindrical capillary, and show that states of optimal density vary strongly with the degree of anisotropy. While isotropic filaments are densest in a straight configuration, any measure of anisotropy leads to helicity of the maximal density state. We show the maximally dense states exhibit a sequence of transitions in helical geometry and cross-sectional tilt with increasing anisotropy, from spiral tape to spiral screw packings. Furthermore, we show that maximal capillary density saturates in a lower bound for volume fraction of $π/4$ in the large-anisotropy, spiral-screw limit. While cross-sectional anisotropy is well-known to impact the mechanical properties of filaments, our study shows its strong effects to shape the configuration space and packing efficiency of this elementary material motif. △ Less

Submitted 3 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: 32 pages, 15 figures

Shape equilibria of vesicles with rigid planar inclusions

Authors: Geunwoong Jeon, Justin Fagnoni, Hao Wan, Maria M. Santore, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Motivated by recent studies of two-phase lipid vesicles possessing 2D solid domains integrated within a fluid bilayer phase, we study the shape equilibria of closed vesicles possessing a single planar, circular inclusion. While 2D solid elasticity tends to expel Gaussian curvature, topology requires closed vesicles to maintain an average, non-zero Gaussian curvature leading to an elementary mechan… ▽ More Motivated by recent studies of two-phase lipid vesicles possessing 2D solid domains integrated within a fluid bilayer phase, we study the shape equilibria of closed vesicles possessing a single planar, circular inclusion. While 2D solid elasticity tends to expel Gaussian curvature, topology requires closed vesicles to maintain an average, non-zero Gaussian curvature leading to an elementary mechanism of shape frustration that increases with inclusion size. We study elastic ground states of the Helfrich model of the planar-fluid composite vesicles, analytically and computationally, as a function of planar fraction and reduced volume. Notably, we show that incorporation of a planar inclusion of only a few percent dramatically shifts the ground state shapes of vesicles from predominantly {\it prolate} to {\it oblate}, and moreover, shifts the optimal surface to volume ratio far from spherical shapes. We show that for sufficiently small planar inclusions, the elastic ground states break symmetry via a complex variety of asymmetric oblate, prolate, and triaxial shapes, while inclusion sizes above about $8\%$ drive composite vesicles to adopt axisymmetric oblate shapes. These predictions cast useful light on the emergent shape and mechanical responses of fluid-solid composite vesicles. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: 15 pages, 13 figures, 3 appendices

Symmetry-guided inverse design of self-assembling multiscale DNA origami tilings

Authors: Daichi Hayakawa, Thomas E. Videbæk, Gregory M. Grason, W. Benjamin Rogers

Abstract: Recent advances enable the creation of nanoscale building blocks with complex geometries and interaction specificities for self-assembly. This nearly boundless design space necessitates design principles for defining the mutual interactions between multiple particle species to target a user-specified complex structure or pattern. In this article, we develop a symmetry-based method to generate the… ▽ More Recent advances enable the creation of nanoscale building blocks with complex geometries and interaction specificities for self-assembly. This nearly boundless design space necessitates design principles for defining the mutual interactions between multiple particle species to target a user-specified complex structure or pattern. In this article, we develop a symmetry-based method to generate the interaction matrices that specify the assembly of two-dimensional tilings which we illustrate using equilateral triangles. By exploiting the allowed 2D symmetries, we develop an algorithmic approach by which any periodic 2D tiling can be generated from an arbitrarily large number of subunit species, notably addressing an unmet challenge of engineering 2D crystals with periodicities that can be arbitrarily larger than subunit size. To demonstrate the utility of our design approach, we encode specific interactions between triangular subunits synthesized by DNA origami and show that we can guide their self-assembly into tilings with a wide variety of symmetries, using up to 12 unique species of triangles. By conjugating specific triangles with gold nanoparticles, we fabricate gold-nanoparticle supercrystals whose lattice parameter spans up to 300 nm. Finally, to generate economical design rules, we compare the design economy of various tilings. In particular, we show that (1) higher symmetries allow assembly of larger unit cells with fewer subunits and (2) linear supercrystals can be designed more economically using linear primitive unit cells. This work provides a simple algorithmic approach to designing periodic assemblies, which may open new doors to the multiscale assembly of superlattices of nanostructured "metatoms" with engineered plasmonic functions. △ Less

Submitted 28 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: Main text 10 pages, 4 figures, SI 27 pages, 19 figures, and 3 tables

Mesoscale Polymer Arrays: High Aspect Ratio Surface Structures and Their Digital Reconstruction

Authors: Demi E. Moed, Michael S. Dimitriyev, Benjamin R. Greenvall, Gregory M. Grason, Alfred J. Crosby

Abstract: Inspired by adhesive bio-filamentous structure, such as bacterial pili, this work details the methods used to fabricate and characterize a surface-anchored array of thin, flexible and shape-responsive mesoscale polymer ribbons with a length-to-thickness aspect ratio of up to 100,000. The resulting structures exhibit geometrically complex and dynamic morphologies consistent with elastocapillary ben… ▽ More Inspired by adhesive bio-filamentous structure, such as bacterial pili, this work details the methods used to fabricate and characterize a surface-anchored array of thin, flexible and shape-responsive mesoscale polymer ribbons with a length-to-thickness aspect ratio of up to 100,000. The resulting structures exhibit geometrically complex and dynamic morphologies consistent with elastocapillary bending that experience an increase in curvature over hours of aging due to creep. We develop a computational image analysis framework to generate 3D reconstructions of these densely crowded geometries and extract quantitative descriptors to demonstrate morphological changes due to aging. We demonstrate the robustness of this quantitative method by characterizing the creep-induced change in an aging ribbon array's shape and develop a scaling relationship to describe the importance of ribbon thickness for shape and dynamical observations. These methods demonstrate an essential baseline to probe morphology-property relationships of mesoscale polymer ribbon arrays fabricated from a variety of materials in numerous environments. Through the introduction of perfluorodecalin droplets, we illustrate the potential of these ribbon arrays towards applications in adhesive, microrobotic, and biomedical devices. △ Less

Submitted 25 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 29 pages, 8 figures, supplemental included at the end

Self-limiting stacks of curvature-frustrated colloidal plates: Roles of intra-particle versus inter-particle deformations

Authors: Kyle T. Sullivan, Ryan C. Hayward, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: In geometrically frustrated assemblies local inter-subunit misfits propagate to intra-assembly strain gradients, giving rise to anomalous self-limiting assembly thermodynamics. Here, we use theory and coarse-grained simulation to study a recently developed class of ``curvamer'' particles, flexible shell-like particles that exhibit self-limiting assembly due to the build up of curvature deformation… ▽ More In geometrically frustrated assemblies local inter-subunit misfits propagate to intra-assembly strain gradients, giving rise to anomalous self-limiting assembly thermodynamics. Here, we use theory and coarse-grained simulation to study a recently developed class of ``curvamer'' particles, flexible shell-like particles that exhibit self-limiting assembly due to the build up of curvature deformation in cohesive stacks. To address a generic, yet poorly understood aspect of frustrated assembly, we introduce a model of curvamer assembly that incorporates both {\it intra-particle} shape deformation as well as compliance of {\it inter-particle} cohesive gaps, an effect we can attribute to a {\it finite range of attraction} between particles. We show that the ratio of intra-particle (bending elasticity) to inter-particle stiffness not only controls the regimes of self-limitation but also the nature of frustration propagation through curvamer stacks. We find a transition from uniformly-bound, curvature-focusing stacks at small size to gap-opened, uniformly curved stacks at large size is controlled by a dimensionless measure of inter- versus intra-curvamer stiffness. The finite range of inter-particle attraction determines range of cohesion in stacks are self-limiting, a prediction which is in strong agreement with numerical studies of our coarse-grained colloidal model. These predictions provide critical guidance for experimental realizations of frustrated particle systems designed to exhibit self-limitation at especially large multi-particle scales. △ Less

Submitted 3 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 23 pages, 16 figures, 7 appendices

Non-affinity of liquid networks and bicontinuous mesophases

Authors: Michael S. Dimitriyev, Xueyan Feng, Edwin L. Thomas, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Amphiphiles self-assemble into a variety of bicontinuous mesophases whose equilibrium structures take the form of high-symmetry cubic networks. Here, we show that the symmetry-breaking distortions in these systems give rise to anomalously large, non-affine collective deformations, which we argue to be a generic consequence of mass equilibration within deformed networks. We propose and study a mini… ▽ More Amphiphiles self-assemble into a variety of bicontinuous mesophases whose equilibrium structures take the form of high-symmetry cubic networks. Here, we show that the symmetry-breaking distortions in these systems give rise to anomalously large, non-affine collective deformations, which we argue to be a generic consequence of mass equilibration within deformed networks. We propose and study a minimal liquid network model of bicontinuous networks, in which acubic distortions are modeled by the relaxation of residually-stressed mechanical networks with constant-tension bonds. We show that non-affinity is strongly dependent on the valency of the network as well as the degree of strain-softening/stiffening force in the bonds. Taking diblock copolymer melts as a model system, liquid network theory captures quantitative features of two bicontinuous phases based on comparison with self-consistent field theory predictions and direct experimental characterization of acubic distortions, which are likely to be pronounced in soft amphiphilic systems more generally. △ Less

Submitted 13 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Comments: 23 pages, 9 figures

Economical routes to size-specific assembly of self-closing structures

Authors: Thomas E. Videbæk, Daichi Hayakawa, Gregory M. Grason, Michael F. Hagan, Seth Fraden, W. Benjamin Rogers

Abstract: Self-assembly is one of the prevalent strategies used by living systems to fabricate ensembles of precision nanometer-scale structures and devices. The push for analogous approaches to create synthetic nanomaterials has led to the development of a large class of programmable crystalline structures. However, many applications require `self-limiting' assemblies, which autonomously terminate growth a… ▽ More Self-assembly is one of the prevalent strategies used by living systems to fabricate ensembles of precision nanometer-scale structures and devices. The push for analogous approaches to create synthetic nanomaterials has led to the development of a large class of programmable crystalline structures. However, many applications require `self-limiting' assemblies, which autonomously terminate growth at a well-defined size and geometry. For example, curved architectures such as tubules, vesicles, or capsids can be designed to self-close at a particular size, symmetry, and topology. But develo** synthetic strategies for self-closing assembly has been challenging, in part because such structures are prone to polymorphism that arises from thermal fluctuations of their local curvature, a problem that worsens with increased target size. Here we demonstrate a strategy to eliminate this source of polymorphism in self-closing assembly of tubules by increasing the assembly complexity. In the limit of single-component assembly, we find that thermal fluctuations allow the system to assemble nearby, off-target structures with varying widths, helicities, and chirality. By increasing the number of distinct components, we reduce the density of off-target states, thereby increasing the selectivity of a user-specified target structure to nearly 100%. We further show that by reducing the design constraints by targeting either the pitch or the width of tubules, fewer components are needed to reach complete selectivity. Combining experiments with theory, our results reveal an economical limit, which determines the minimum number of components that are required to create arbitrary assembly sizes with full selectivity. In the future, this approach could be extended to more complex self-limited structures, such as shells or triply periodic surfaces. △ Less

Submitted 12 January, 2024; v1 submitted 2 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Comments: Main text 8 pages, 5 figures, SI 22 pages, 12 figures, 5 tables. Slight changes to the text from previous version

Chain trajectories, domain shapes and terminal boundaries in block copolymers

Authors: Benjamin R. Greenvall, Michael S. Dimitriyev, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: The packing geometry of macromolecules in complex mesophases is of key importance to self-organization in synthetic and biological soft materials. While approximate or heuristic models rely on often-untested assumptions about how flexible molecules "fit in" to distinct locations of complex assemblies, physical assemblies derive from ensembles of fluctuating conformations, obscuring the connection… ▽ More The packing geometry of macromolecules in complex mesophases is of key importance to self-organization in synthetic and biological soft materials. While approximate or heuristic models rely on often-untested assumptions about how flexible molecules "fit in" to distinct locations of complex assemblies, physical assemblies derive from ensembles of fluctuating conformations, obscuring the connection between mesophase geometry and the underlying arrangements. Here, we present an approach to extract and analyze features of molecular packing in diblock block copolymer (BCP) melts, a prototypical soft matter system, based on the statistical description of chain conformations in self-consistent field (SCF) theory. We show how average BCP chain trajectories in ordered morphologies can be analyzed from the SCF-derived orientational order parameter of chain segments. We use these extracted trajectories to analyze the features of local packing geometry, including chain bending and tilt, as well as the terminal boundaries that delineate distinct domains in ordered BCP morphologies. We illustrate this analysis by focusing on measurable features of packing frustration in 2D (columnar) and 3D (spherical and bicontinuous) morphologies, notably establishing an explicit link between chain conformations in complex morphologies and their medial geometry. △ Less

Submitted 3 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 19 pages, 15 figures

Limits of economy and fidelity for programmable assembly of size-controlled triply-periodic polyhedra

Authors: Carlos M. Duque, Douglas M. Hall, Botond Tyukodi, Michael F. Hagan, Christian D. Santangelo, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: We propose and investigate an extension of the Caspar-Klug symmetry principles for viral capsid assembly to the programmable assembly of size-controlled triply-periodic polyhedra, discrete variants of the Primitive, Diamond, and Gyroid cubic minimal surfaces. Inspired by a recent class of programmable DNA origami colloids, we demonstrate that the economy of design in these crystalline assemblies -… ▽ More We propose and investigate an extension of the Caspar-Klug symmetry principles for viral capsid assembly to the programmable assembly of size-controlled triply-periodic polyhedra, discrete variants of the Primitive, Diamond, and Gyroid cubic minimal surfaces. Inspired by a recent class of programmable DNA origami colloids, we demonstrate that the economy of design in these crystalline assemblies -- in terms of the growth of the number of distinct particle species required with the increased size-scale (e.g. periodicity) -- is comparable to viral shells. We further test the role of geometric specificity in these assemblies via dynamical assembly simulations, which show that conditions for simultaneously efficient and high-fidelity assembly require an intermediate degree of flexibility of local angles and lengths in programmed assembly. Off-target misassembly occurs via incorporation of a variant of disclination defects, generalized to the case of hyperbolic crystals. The possibility of these topological defects is a direct consequence of the very same symmetry principles that underlie the economical design, exposing a basic tradeoff between design economy and fidelity of programmable, size controlled assembly. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Comments: 15 pages, 5 figures, 6 supporting movies (linked), Supporting Appendix

Flowering of Developable 2D Crystal Shapes in Closed, Fluid Membranes

Authors: Hao Wan, Geunwoong Jeon, Weiyue Xin, Gregory M. Grason, Maria M. Santore

Abstract: The morphologies of two-dimensional (2D) crystals, nucleated, grown, and integrated within 2D elastic fluids, for instance in giant vesicle membranes, are dictated by an interplay of mechanics, permeability, and thermal contraction. Mitigation of solid strain drives formation of crystals with developable shapes (e.g. planar or cylindrical) that expel Gaussian curvature into the 2D fluid. However,… ▽ More The morphologies of two-dimensional (2D) crystals, nucleated, grown, and integrated within 2D elastic fluids, for instance in giant vesicle membranes, are dictated by an interplay of mechanics, permeability, and thermal contraction. Mitigation of solid strain drives formation of crystals with developable shapes (e.g. planar or cylindrical) that expel Gaussian curvature into the 2D fluid. However, upon cooling to grow the crystals, large vesicles sustain greater inflation and tension because their small area to volume ratio slows water permeation. As a result, more elaborate shapes, for instance flowers with bendable but inextensible petals form on large vesicles despite their more gradual curvature, while small vesicles harbor compact planar crystals. This size dependence runs counter to the known cumulative growth of strain energy of 2D colloidal crystals on rigid spherical templates. This interplay of intra-membrane mechanics and processing points to the scalable production of flexible molecular crystals of controllable complex shape. △ Less

Submitted 5 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: Main text 27 pages and 6 figures; SI 25 pages and 14 figures

Medial packing, frustration and competing network phases in strongly-segregated block copolymers

Authors: Michael S. Dimitriyev, Abhiram Reddy, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Self-consistent field theory (SCFT) has established that for cubic network phases in diblock copolymer melts, the double-gyroid (DG) is thermodynamically stable relative to the competitor double-diamond (DD) and double-primitive (DP) phases, and exhibits a window of stability intermediate to the classical lamellar and columnar phases. This competition is widely thought to be controlled by "packing… ▽ More Self-consistent field theory (SCFT) has established that for cubic network phases in diblock copolymer melts, the double-gyroid (DG) is thermodynamically stable relative to the competitor double-diamond (DD) and double-primitive (DP) phases, and exhibits a window of stability intermediate to the classical lamellar and columnar phases. This competition is widely thought to be controlled by "packing frustration" -- the incompatibility of uniformly filling melts with a locally preferred chain packing motif. Here, we reassess the thermodynamics of cubic network formation in strongly-segregated diblock melts, based on a recently developed medial strong segregation theory ("mSST") approach that directly connects the shape and thermodynamics of chain packing environments to the medial geometry of tubular network surfaces. We first show that medial packing significantly relaxes prior SST upper bounds on the free energy of network phases, which we attribute to the spreading of terminal chain ends within network nodal regions. Exploring geometric and thermodynamic metrics of chain packing in network phases, we show that mSST reproduces effects dependent on the elastic asymmetry of the blocks that are consistent with SCFT at large $χN$. We then characterize geometric frustration in terms of the spatially-variant distributions of local entropic and enthalpic costs throughout the morphologies, extracted from mSST predictions. We find that the DG morphology, due to its unique medial geometry in the nodal regions, is stabilized by the incorporation of favorable, quasi-lamellar packing over much of its morphology, motifs which are inaccessible to DD and DP morphologies due to "interior corners" in their medial geometries. Finally, we use our results to analyze "hot spots" of chain stretching and discuss implications for network susceptibility to the uptake of guest molecules. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 69 pages, 24 figures

Tracing chirality from molecular organization to triply-periodic network assemblies: Threading biaxial twist through block copolymer gyroids

Authors: Ishan Prasad, Abhiram Reddy, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Chirality transfer from the level of molecular structure up to mesoscopic lengthscales of supramolecular morphologies is a broad and persistent theme in self-assembled soft materials, from biological to synthetic matter. Here, we analyze the mechanism of chirality transfer in a prototypical self-assembly system, block copolymers (BCPs), in particular, its impact on one of the most complex and func… ▽ More Chirality transfer from the level of molecular structure up to mesoscopic lengthscales of supramolecular morphologies is a broad and persistent theme in self-assembled soft materials, from biological to synthetic matter. Here, we analyze the mechanism of chirality transfer in a prototypical self-assembly system, block copolymers (BCPs), in particular, its impact on one of the most complex and functionally vital phases: the cubic, triply-periodic, gyroid network. Motivated by recent experimental studies, we consider a self-consistent field model of ABC* triblock copolymers possessing an end-block of chain chemistry and examine the interplay between chirality at the scale of networks, in alternating double network phases, and the patterns of segmental order within tubular network domains. We show that while segments in gyroids exhibit twist in both polar and nematic segmental order parameters, the magnitude of net nematic twist is generically much larger than polar twist, and more surprising, {\it reverses handedness} relative to the sense of polar order as well as the sense of dihedral twist of the network. Careful analysis of the intra-domain nematic order reveals that this unique chirality transfer mechanism relies on the strongly biaxial nature of segmental order in BCP networks and relates the {\it biaxial twist} to complex patterns of frame rotation of the principal directors in the intra-domain texture. Finally, we show that this mechanism of twist reversal leads to chirality selection of alternating gyroid networks in ABC* triblocks, in the limit of very weak chirality . △ Less

Submitted 13 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: 14 pages, 8 figures, 5 appendices

Journal ref: Giant, v. 14, 100164 (2023)

Dispersed, condensed and self-limiting states of geometrically frustrated assembly

Authors: Nicholas W. Hackney, Christopher Amey, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: In self-assembling systems, geometric frustration leads to complex states characterized by internal gradients of shape misfit. Frustrated assemblies have drawn recent interest due to the unique possibility that their thermodynamics can sense and select the finite size of assembly at length scales much larger than constituent building blocks or their interactions. At present, self-limitation is chi… ▽ More In self-assembling systems, geometric frustration leads to complex states characterized by internal gradients of shape misfit. Frustrated assemblies have drawn recent interest due to the unique possibility that their thermodynamics can sense and select the finite size of assembly at length scales much larger than constituent building blocks or their interactions. At present, self-limitation is chiefly understood to derive from zero-temperature considerations, specifically the competition between cohesion and scale-dependent elastic costs of frustration. While effects of entropy and finite temperature fluctuations are necessarily significant for self-assembling systems, their impact on the self-limiting states of frustrated assemblies is not known. We introduce a generic, minimal model of frustrated assembly, and establish its finite-temperature and concentration dependent thermodynamics by way of simulation and continuum theory. The phase diagram is marked by three distinct states of translation order: a dispersed vapor; a defect-riddled condensate; and the self-limiting aggregate state. We show that, at finite temperature, the self-limiting state is stable at intermediate frustration. Further, in contrast to the prevailing picture, its thermodynamic boundaries with the macroscopic disperse and bulk states are temperature controlled, pointing to the essential importance of translational and conformational entropy in their formation. △ Less

Submitted 5 August, 2023; v1 submitted 3 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: 22 pages, 14 figures, 5 supporting videos, 3 appendices and 1 supporting PDF (data tables and supplementary notes); revised discussion and appendix B added

How does your gyroid grow?: A mesoatomic perspective on supramolecular, soft matter network crystals

Authors: Gregory M. Grason, Edwin L. Thomas

Abstract: We propose a framework to understand supramolecular network crystals formed in soft matter in terms of mesoatomic building blocks, collective grou**s of amphiphilic molecules that play a role analogous to atomic or molecular subunits of hard matter crystals. While the concept of mesoatoms is intuitive and widely invoked in crystalline arrangements of sphere- or cylinder-like (micelle-like) domai… ▽ More We propose a framework to understand supramolecular network crystals formed in soft matter in terms of mesoatomic building blocks, collective grou**s of amphiphilic molecules that play a role analogous to atomic or molecular subunits of hard matter crystals. While the concept of mesoatoms is intuitive and widely invoked in crystalline arrangements of sphere- or cylinder-like (micelle-like) domains, analogous notions of physically meaningful building blocks of triply periodic network crystals, like the double-gyroid or double-diamond structures are obscured by the complex, bicontinuous domain shapes and intercatenated topologies of the double networks. Focusing on the example of diblock copolymer melts, we propose generic rules for decomposing triply-periodic network crystals into a unique set of mesoatomic building blocks, leading to mesoatomic volumes that are non-convex and bound by smoothly curved faces, unlike the more familiar polyhedral shapes associated with sphere- and cylinder-like mesoatoms. We analyze the shapes of these mesoatoms, their internal structure and importantly their local packing with neighbor mesoatomic units. Hypothesizing that mesoatoms are kinetically favored intermediate structures whose local shapes and packing template network crystal assembly on long time scales, we propose and study a minimal energetic model of mesoatom assembly for three different cubic double-network crystals, which predicts a detailed picture for kinetics of intercatenation and surface growth. We discuss potential extensions and elaborations of the mesoatomic description of supramolecular soft matter network crystals, experimental observations of malleable mesoatomic units in the precursor sponge phase as well as in ordered cubic networks, as well as possibilities for observing mesoatoms in primordial, pre-crystalline states. △ Less

Submitted 1 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Comments: 18 figures + supporting movie (link at manuscript end)

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Materials 7, 045603 (2023)

Building blocks of non-Euclidean ribbons: Size-controlled self-assembly via discrete, frustrated particles

Authors: Douglas M. Hall, Mark J. Stevens, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Geometric frustration offers a pathway to soft matter self-assembly with controllable finite sizes. While the understanding of frustration in soft matter assembly derives almost exclusively from continuum elastic descriptions, a current challenge is to understand the connection between microscopic physical properties of misfitting ``building blocks" and emergent assembly behavior at mesoscale. We… ▽ More Geometric frustration offers a pathway to soft matter self-assembly with controllable finite sizes. While the understanding of frustration in soft matter assembly derives almost exclusively from continuum elastic descriptions, a current challenge is to understand the connection between microscopic physical properties of misfitting ``building blocks" and emergent assembly behavior at mesoscale. We present and analyze a particle-based description of what is arguably the best studied example for frustrated soft matter assembly, negative-curvature ribbon assembly, observed in both assemblies of chiral surfactants and shape-frustrated nanoparticles. Based on our particle model, known as {\it saddle wedge monomers}, we numerically test the connection between microscopic shape and interactions of the misfitting subunits and the emergent behavior at the supra-particle scale, specifically focusing on the propagation and relaxation of inter-particle strains, the emergent role of extrinsic shape on frustrated ribbons and the equilibrium regime of finite width selection. Beyond the intuitive role of shape misfit, we show that self-limitation is critically dependent on the finite range of cohesive interactions, with larger size finite assemblies requiring increasing short-range interparticle forces. Additionally, we demonstrate that non-linearities arising from discrete particle interactions alter self-limiting behavior due to both strain-softening in shape-flattened assembly and partial yielding of highly strained bonds, which in turn may give rise to states of hierarchical, multidomain assembly. Tracing the regimes of frustration-limited assembly to the specific microscopic features of misfitting particle shapes and interactions provides necessary guidance for translating the theory of size-programmable assembly into design of intentionally-frustrated colloidal particles. △ Less

Submitted 15 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 26 pages, 12 figures, 2 appendices

Journal ref: Soft Matter, 19, 858-881 (2023)

Stress accumulation versus shape flattening in frustrated, warped-jigsaw particle assemblies

Authors: Isaac R. Spivack, Douglas M. Hall, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Geometrically frustrated assembly has emerged as an attractive paradigm for understanding and engineering assemblies with self-limiting, finite equilibrium dimensions. We propose and study a novel 2D particle based on a so-called "warped jigsaw" (WJ) shape design: directional bonds in a tapered particle favor curvature along multi-particle rows that frustrate 2D lattice order. We investigate how l… ▽ More Geometrically frustrated assembly has emerged as an attractive paradigm for understanding and engineering assemblies with self-limiting, finite equilibrium dimensions. We propose and study a novel 2D particle based on a so-called "warped jigsaw" (WJ) shape design: directional bonds in a tapered particle favor curvature along multi-particle rows that frustrate 2D lattice order. We investigate how large-scale intra-assembly stress gradients emerge from the microscopic properties of the particles using a combination of numerical simulation and continuum elasticity. WJ particles can favor anisotropic ribbon assemblies, whose lateral width may be self-limiting depending on the relative strength of cohesive to elastic forces in the assembly, which we show to be controlled by the range of interactions and degree of shape misfit. The upper limits of self-limited size are controlled by the crossover between two elastic modes in assembly: the accumulation of shear with increasing width at small widths giving way to unbending of preferred row curvature, permitting assembly to grow to unlimited sizes. We show that the stiffness controlling distinct elastic modes is governed by combination and placement of repulsive and attractive binding regions, providing a means to extend the range of accumulating stress to sizes that are far in excess of the single particle size, which we corroborate via numerical studies of discrete particles of variable interactions. Lastly, we relate the ground-state energetics of the model to lower and upper limits on equilibrium assembly size control set by the fluctuations of width along the ribbon boundary. △ Less

Submitted 8 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Comments: 18 pages, 9 figures, 2 appendices

Journal ref: New J. Phys. 24, 063023 (2022)

Focussing frustration for self-limiting assembly of flexible, curved particles

Authors: Nabila Tanjeem, Douglas M. Hall, Montana B. Minnis, Ryan C. Hayward, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: We show that geometric frustration in a broad class of deformable and naturally curved, shell-like colloidal particles gives rise to self-limiting assembly of finite-sized stacks that far exceed particle dimensions. When inter-particle adhesions favor conformal stacking, particle shape requires {\it curvature focussing} in the stack, leading to a super-extensive accumulation of bending costs that… ▽ More We show that geometric frustration in a broad class of deformable and naturally curved, shell-like colloidal particles gives rise to self-limiting assembly of finite-sized stacks that far exceed particle dimensions. When inter-particle adhesions favor conformal stacking, particle shape requires {\it curvature focussing} in the stack, leading to a super-extensive accumulation of bending costs that ultimately limit the ground-state stack size to a finite value. Using a combination of continuum theory and particle-based simulation, we demonstrate that the self-limiting stack size is controlled by the ratio of the intra-particle bending costs to inter-particle adhesion energy, ultimately achieving assembly sizes that are tuned from a few, up to several tens of, particles. We show that the range of self-limiting assembly is delimited by the two structural modes of "frustration escape" which evade the thermodynamic costs of curvature focussing. Crucially, each of these modes can be suppressed through suitable choice of adhesive range and lateral patchiness of adhesion, providing feasible strategies to program finite assembly size via the interplay between shape-frustration, binding and deformability of colloidal building blocks. △ Less

Submitted 7 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures, supplemental appendix

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 4, 033035 (2022)

Geometrically programmed self-limited assembly of tubules using DNA origami colloids

Authors: Daichi Hayakawa, Thomas E. Videbæk, Douglas M. Hall, Huang Fang, Christian Sigl, Elija Feigl, Hendrik Dietz, Seth Fraden, Michael F. Hagan, Gregory M. Grason, W. Benjamin Rogers

Abstract: Self-assembly is one of the most promising strategies for making functional materials at the nanoscale, yet new design principles for making self-limiting architectures, rather than spatially unlimited periodic lattice structures, are needed. To address this challenge, we explore the trade-offs between addressable assembly and self-closing assembly of a specific class of self-limiting structures:… ▽ More Self-assembly is one of the most promising strategies for making functional materials at the nanoscale, yet new design principles for making self-limiting architectures, rather than spatially unlimited periodic lattice structures, are needed. To address this challenge, we explore the trade-offs between addressable assembly and self-closing assembly of a specific class of self-limiting structures: cylindrical tubules. We make triangular subunits using DNA origami that have specific, valence-limited interactions and designed binding angles, and study their assembly into tubules that have a self-limited width that is much larger than the size of an individual subunit. In the simplest case, the tubules are assembled from a single component by geometrically programming the dihedral angles between neighboring subunits. We show that the tubules can reach many micrometers in length and that their average width can be prescribed through the dihedral angles. We find that there is a distribution in the width and the chirality of the tubules, which we rationalize by develo** a model that considers the finite bending rigidity of the assembled structure as well as the mechanism of self-closure. Finally, we demonstrate that the distributions of tubules can be further sculpted by increasing the number of subunit species, thereby increasing the assembly complexity, and demonstrate that using two subunit species successfully reduces the number of available end states by half. These results help to shed light on the roles of assembly complexity and geometry in self-limited assembly and could be extended to other self-limiting architectures, such as shells, toroids, or triply-periodic frameworks. △ Less

Submitted 2 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: Main text 11 pages and 4 figures; SI 44 pages, 19 figures, 9 tables

Journal ref: PNAS 119 (43) e2207902119 (2022)

Medial packing and elastic asymmetry stabilize the double-gyroid in block copolymers

Authors: Abhiram Reddy, Michael S. Dimitriyev, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Triply-periodic networks are among the most complex and functionally valuable self-assembled morphologies, yet they form in nearly every class of biological and synthetic soft matter building blocks. In contrast to simpler assembly motifs -- spheres, cylinders, layers -- TPN assemblies require molecules to occupy variable local domain shapes, confounding attempts to understand their formation. Her… ▽ More Triply-periodic networks are among the most complex and functionally valuable self-assembled morphologies, yet they form in nearly every class of biological and synthetic soft matter building blocks. In contrast to simpler assembly motifs -- spheres, cylinders, layers -- TPN assemblies require molecules to occupy variable local domain shapes, confounding attempts to understand their formation. Here, we examine the double-gyroid (DG) network phase of block copolymer (BCP) melts, a prototypical soft self-assembly system, by using a geometric formulation of the strong stretching theory (SST) of BCP melts. The theory establishes the direct link between molecular BCP packing, thermodynamics of melt assembly and the {\it medial map}, a generic geometric measure of the center of complex shapes. We show that "medial packing" is essential for thermodynamic stability of DG in strongly-segregated melts, reconciling a long-standing contradiction between infinite- and finite-segregation theories, corroborating our SST predictions at finite-segregation via self-consistent field calculations. Additionally, we find a previously unrecognized non-monotonic dependence of DG stability on the elastic asymmetry, the comparative entropic stiffness of matrix-forming to tubular-network forming blocks. The composition window of stable DG -- intermediate to competitor lamellar and columnar phases -- widens both for large and small elastic asymmetry, seemingly overturning the heuristic view that packing frustration is localized to the tubular domains. This study demonstrates utility of geometric optimization of {\it medial tesselations} for understanding in soft-molecular assembly. As such, the particular medial-based approach deployed here is readily generalizable to study packing frustration far beyond the case of DG morphologies in neat BCP assemblies. △ Less

Submitted 13 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: Main paper: 9 pages, 5 figures and Supporting Information: 20 pages, 14 figures

End exclusion zones in strongly stretched, molten polymer brushes of arbitrary shape

Authors: Michael S. Dimitriyev, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Theories of strongly stretched polymer brushes, particularly the parabolic brush theory, are valuable for providing analytically tractable predictions for the thermodynamic behavior of surface-grafted polymers in a wide range of settings. However, the parabolic brush limit fails to describe polymers grafted to convex, curved substrates, such as the surfaces of spherical nanoparticles or the interf… ▽ More Theories of strongly stretched polymer brushes, particularly the parabolic brush theory, are valuable for providing analytically tractable predictions for the thermodynamic behavior of surface-grafted polymers in a wide range of settings. However, the parabolic brush limit fails to describe polymers grafted to convex, curved substrates, such as the surfaces of spherical nanoparticles or the interfaces of strongly segregated block copolymers. It has been previously shown that strongly-stretched, curved brushes require a boundary layer devoid of free chain ends, requiring modifications of the theoretical analysis. While this "end exclusion zone" has been successfully incorporated into descriptions of brushes grafted onto the outer surfaces of cylinders and spheres, the behavior of brushes on surfaces of arbitrary curvature has not yet been studied. We present a formulation of the strong-stretching theory for molten brushes on surfaces of arbitrary curvature and identify four distinct regimes of interest for which brushes are predicted to possess end exclusion zones, notably including regimes of positive mean curvature but negative Gaussian curvature. Through numerical solutions of the strong-stretching brush equations, we report predicted scaling of the size of the end exclusion zone, the chain end distribution, the chain polarization, and the free energy of stretching with mean and Gaussian surface curvatures. Through these results, we present a comprehensive picture of how brush geometry influences the end exclusions zones and exact strong-stretching free energies, which can be applied, for example, to model the full spectrum of brush geometries encountered in block copolymer melt assembly. △ Less

Submitted 28 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: 12 pages, 4 figures. Submitted to Journal of Chemical Physics. Supplementary software: https://doi.org/10.7275/rtvx-h237

Thermodynamic size control in curvature-frustrated tubules: Self-limitation with open boundaries

Authors: Botond Tyukodi, Farzaneh Mohajerani, Douglas M. Hall, Gregory M. Grason, Michael F. Hagan

Abstract: We use computational modeling to investigate the assembly thermodynamics of a particle-based model for geometrically frustrated assembly, in which the local packing geometry of subunits is incompatible with uniform, strain-free large-scale assembly. The model considers discrete triangular subunits that drive assembly towards a closed, hexagonal-ordered tubule, but have geometries that locally favo… ▽ More We use computational modeling to investigate the assembly thermodynamics of a particle-based model for geometrically frustrated assembly, in which the local packing geometry of subunits is incompatible with uniform, strain-free large-scale assembly. The model considers discrete triangular subunits that drive assembly towards a closed, hexagonal-ordered tubule, but have geometries that locally favor negative Gaussian curvature. We use dynamical Monte Carlo simulations and enhanced sampling methods to compute the free energy landscape and corresponding self-assembly behavior as a function of experimentally accessible parameters that control assembly driving forces and the magnitude of frustration. The results determine the parameter range where finite-temperature self-limiting assembly occurs, in which the equilibrium assembly size distribution is sharply peaked around a well-defined finite size. The simulations also identify two mechanisms by which the system can escape frustration and assemble to unlimited size, and determine the particle-scale properties of subunits that suppress unbounded growth. △ Less

Submitted 2 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Defects in Conformal Crystals: Discrete vs. Continuous Disclination Models

Authors: Qingyou Meng, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: We study the relationship between topological defect formation and ground-state packings in a model of repulsions in external confining potentials. Specifically we consider screened 2D Coulombic repulsions, which conveniently parameterizes the effects of interaction range, but also serves as simple physical model of confined, parallel arrays of polyelectrolyte filaments or vortices in type-II supe… ▽ More We study the relationship between topological defect formation and ground-state packings in a model of repulsions in external confining potentials. Specifically we consider screened 2D Coulombic repulsions, which conveniently parameterizes the effects of interaction range, but also serves as simple physical model of confined, parallel arrays of polyelectrolyte filaments or vortices in type-II superconductors. The countervailing tendencies of repulsions and confinement to, respectively, spread and concentrate particle density leads to an energetic preference for non-uniform densities in the clusters. Ground states in such systems have previously been modeled as {\it conformal crystals}, which are composed of locally equitriangular packings whose local areal densities exhibit long range gradients. Here, we assess two theoretical models that connect the preference for non-uniform density to the formation of disclination defects, one of which assumes a continuum distributions of defect, while the second considers the quantized and localized nature of disclinations in hexagonal conformal crystals. Comparing both models to numerical simulations of discrete particles clusters, we study the influence of interaction range and confining potential on defects in ground states. We show that treating disclinations as continuously distributable well-captures the number of topological defects in the ground state in the regime of long-range interactions, while as interactions become shorter range, it dramatically overpredicts the to growth in total defect charge. Analysis of the discretized defect theory suggests that limitations of the continuous defect theory can be attributed to the asymmetry in the placement of positive vs. negative disclinations in the conformal crystal ground states, as well as a strongly asymmetric dependence of self-energy of disclinations on sign of topological charge. △ Less

Submitted 15 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 21 pages, 16 figures, 4 appendices

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 104, 034614 (2021)

Mechanics of metric frustration in contorted filament bundles: From local symmetry to columnar elasticity

Authors: Daria W. Atkinson, Christian D. Santangelo, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Bundles of filaments are subject to geometric frustration: certain deformations (e.g. bending while twisted) require longitudinal variations in spacing between filaments. While bundles are common -- from protein fibers to yarns -- the mechanical consequences of longitudinal frustration are unknown. We derive a geometrically-nonlinear formalism for bundle mechanics, using a gauge-like symmetry unde… ▽ More Bundles of filaments are subject to geometric frustration: certain deformations (e.g. bending while twisted) require longitudinal variations in spacing between filaments. While bundles are common -- from protein fibers to yarns -- the mechanical consequences of longitudinal frustration are unknown. We derive a geometrically-nonlinear formalism for bundle mechanics, using a gauge-like symmetry under reptations along filament backbones. We relate force balance to orientational geometry and assess the elastic cost of frustration in twisted toroidal bundles. △ Less

Submitted 7 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Comments: 9 pages, 3 figures

Equilibrium mechanisms of self-limiting assembly

Authors: Michael F. Hagan, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Self-assembly is a ubiquitous process in synthetic and biological systems, broadly defined as the spontaneous organization of multiple subunits (e.g. macromolecules, particles) into ordered multi-unit structures. The vast majority of equilibrium assembly processes give rise to two states: one consisting of dispersed disassociated subunits, and the other, a bulk-condensed state of unlimited size. T… ▽ More Self-assembly is a ubiquitous process in synthetic and biological systems, broadly defined as the spontaneous organization of multiple subunits (e.g. macromolecules, particles) into ordered multi-unit structures. The vast majority of equilibrium assembly processes give rise to two states: one consisting of dispersed disassociated subunits, and the other, a bulk-condensed state of unlimited size. This review focuses on the more specialized class of {\it self-limiting assembly}, which describes equilibrium assembly processes resulting in finite-size structures. These systems pose a generic and basic question, how do thermodynamic processes involving non-covalent interactions between identical subunits ``measure'' and select the size of assembled structures? In this review, we begin with an introduction to the basic statistical mechanical framework for assembly thermodynamics, and use this to highlight the key physical ingredients that ensure equilibrium assembly will terminate at finite dimensions. Then, we introduce examples of self-limiting assembly systems, and classify them within this framework based on two broad categories: {\it self-closing assemblies} and {\it open-boundary assemblies}. These include well-known cases in biology and synthetic soft matter -- micellization of amphiphiles and shell/tubule formation of tapered subunits -- as well as less widely known classes of assemblies, such as short-range attractive/long-range repulsive systems and geometrically-frustrated assemblies. For each of these self-limiting mechanisms, we describe the physical mechanisms that select equilibrium assembly size, as well as potential limitations of finite-size selection. Finally, we discuss alternative mechanisms for finite-size assemblies, and draw contrasts with the size-control that these can achieve relative to self-limitation in equilibrium, single-species assemblies. △ Less

Submitted 14 March, 2021; v1 submitted 3 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

Comments: (2nd version: extensive revisions) 55 pages; 19 figures; 3 appendices

Journal ref: Rev. Mod. Phys. 93, 025008 (2021)

Chiral and achiral mechanisms of self-limiting, twisted bundle assembly

Authors: Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: A generalized theory of the self-limiting assembly of twisted bundles of filaments and columns is presented. Bundles and fibers form in a broad variety of supramolecular systems, from biological to synthetic materials. A widely-invoked mechanism to explain their finite diameter relies on chirality transfer from the molecular constituents to collective twist of the assembly, the effect of which fru… ▽ More A generalized theory of the self-limiting assembly of twisted bundles of filaments and columns is presented. Bundles and fibers form in a broad variety of supramolecular systems, from biological to synthetic materials. A widely-invoked mechanism to explain their finite diameter relies on chirality transfer from the molecular constituents to collective twist of the assembly, the effect of which frustrates the lateral assembly and can select equilibrium, finite diameters of bundles. In this article, the thermodynamics of twisted-bundle assembly is analyzed to understand if chirality transfer is necessary for self-limitation, or instead, if spontaneously-twisting, achiral bundles also exhibit self-limited assembly. A generalized description is invoked for the elastic costs imposed by twist for bundles of various states of intra-bundle order from nematic to crystalline, as well as a generic mechanism for generating twist, classified both by {\it chirality} but also the {\it twist susceptibility} of inter-filament alignment. The theory provides a comprehensive set of predictions for the equilibrium twist and size of bundles as a function of surface energy as well as chirality, twist susceptibility, and elasticity of bundles. Moreover, it shows that while spontaneous twist can lead to self-limitation, assembly of twisted {\it achiral} bundles can be distinguished qualitatively in terms of their range of equilibrium sizes and thermodynamic stability relative to bulk (untwisted) states. △ Less

Submitted 11 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: 16 pages; 9 figures; 2 appendices

Journal ref: Soft Matter 16, 1102-1116 (2020)

All twist and no bend makes raft edges splay: Spontaneous curvature of domain edges in colloidal membranes

Authors: Joia M. Miller, Doug Hall, Joanna Robaszewski, Prerna Sharma, Michael F. Hagan, Gregory M. Grason, Zvonimir Dogic

Abstract: Using a combination of theory and experiments we study the interface between two immiscible domains in a colloidal membrane composed of rigid rods of different lengths. Geometric considerations of rigid rod packing imply that a domain of sufficiently short rods in a background membrane of long rods is more susceptible to twist than the inverse structure, a long-rod domain in a short-rod membrane b… ▽ More Using a combination of theory and experiments we study the interface between two immiscible domains in a colloidal membrane composed of rigid rods of different lengths. Geometric considerations of rigid rod packing imply that a domain of sufficiently short rods in a background membrane of long rods is more susceptible to twist than the inverse structure, a long-rod domain in a short-rod membrane background. The tilt at the inter-domain edge forces splay, which in turn manifests as a spontaneous edge curvature whose energetics are controlled by the length asymmetry of constituent rods. A thermodynamic model of such tilt-curvature coupling at inter-domain edges explains a number of experimental observations, including a non-monotonic dependence of the edge twist on the domain radius, and annularly shaped domains of long rods. Our work shows how coupling between orientational and compositional degrees of freedom in two-dimensional fluids give rise to complex shapes and thermodynamics of domains, analogous to shape transitions in 3D fluid vesicles. △ Less

Submitted 26 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 36 pages, 8 figures

Ground States of Crystalline Caps: Generalized Jellium on Curved Space

Authors: Siyu Li, Roya Zandi, Alex Travesset, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: We study the structure and elastic energy of the ground states of crystalline caps conforming to a spherical surface. These ground states consist of positive disclination defects in structures spanning from flat and weakly curved crystals to closed shells. We compare two different continuum theories and one discrete-lattice approach for the elastic energy of defective caps. We first investigate th… ▽ More We study the structure and elastic energy of the ground states of crystalline caps conforming to a spherical surface. These ground states consist of positive disclination defects in structures spanning from flat and weakly curved crystals to closed shells. We compare two different continuum theories and one discrete-lattice approach for the elastic energy of defective caps. We first investigate the transition between defect-free caps to single-disclination ground states and show that it is characterized by continuous symmetry-breaking transition. Further, we show that ground states with icosahedral subgroup symmetries in caps arise across a range of curvatures, even far from the closure point of complete shells. Thus, while superficially similar to other models of 2D `jellium' (e.g. superconducting disks and 2D Wigner crystals), the interplay between the free edge of crystalline caps and the non-Euclidean geometry of its embedding leads to non trivial ground state behaviors, without counterpart in planar jellium models. △ Less

Submitted 11 June, 2019; v1 submitted 7 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: Main text: 6 pages, 3 figures; Supplemental Information: 9 pages, 8 figures, 1 table (replaced version corrects author listing)

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 145501 (2019)

Constant spacing in filament bundles

Authors: Daria W. Atkinson, Christian D. Santangelo, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Assemblies of filaments appear in a wide range of systems: from biopolymer bundles, columnar liquid crystals, and superconductor vortex arrays; to familiar macroscopic materials, like ropes, cables and textiles. Interactions between the constituent filaments in such systems are most sensitive to the {\it distance of closest approach} between the central curves which approximate their configuration… ▽ More Assemblies of filaments appear in a wide range of systems: from biopolymer bundles, columnar liquid crystals, and superconductor vortex arrays; to familiar macroscopic materials, like ropes, cables and textiles. Interactions between the constituent filaments in such systems are most sensitive to the {\it distance of closest approach} between the central curves which approximate their configuration, subjecting these distinct assemblies to common geometric constraints. In this paper, we consider two distinct notions of constant spacing in multi-filament packings in $\mathbb{R}^3$: {\it equidistance}, where the distance of closest approach is constant along the length of filament pairs; and {\it isometry}, where the distances of closest approach between all neighboring filaments are constant and equal. We show that, although any smooth curve in $\mathbb{R}^3$ permits one dimensional families of collinear equidistant curves belonging to a ruled surface, there are only two families of tangent fields with mutually equidistant integral curves in $\mathbb{R}^3$. The relative shapes and configurations of curves in these families are highly constrained: they must be either (isometric) developable domains, which can bend, but not twist; or (non-isometric) constant-pitch helical bundles, which can twist, but not bend. Thus, simultaneously bent and twisted filament textures, such as twisted toroids of condensed DNA plasmids or wire ropes, are doubly frustrated: twist frustrates constant neighbor spacing in the cross-section, while non-equidistance requires longitudinal variations of inter-filament spacing. To illustrate the consequences of the failure of equidistance, we compare spacing in three "almost equidistant" ansatzes for twisted toroidal bundles and use our formulation of equidistance to construct upper bounds on the growth of longitudinal variations of spacing with bundle thickness. △ Less

Submitted 17 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: 36 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: New J. Phys. 21, 062001 (2019)

Conformational switching of chiral colloidal rafts regulates raft-raft attractions and repulsions

Authors: Joia Miller, Chaitanya Joshi, Prerna Sharma, Aparna Baskaran, Gregory M. Grason, Michael F. Hagan, Zvonimir Dogic

Abstract: Membrane-mediated particle interactions depend both on the properties of the particles themselves and the membrane environment in which they are suspended. Experiments have shown that chiral rod-like inclusions dissolved in a colloidal membrane of opposite handedness assemble into colloidal rafts, which are finite-sized reconfigurable droplets consisting of a large but precisely defined number of… ▽ More Membrane-mediated particle interactions depend both on the properties of the particles themselves and the membrane environment in which they are suspended. Experiments have shown that chiral rod-like inclusions dissolved in a colloidal membrane of opposite handedness assemble into colloidal rafts, which are finite-sized reconfigurable droplets consisting of a large but precisely defined number of rods. Here, we systematically tune the chirality of the background membrane, and find that in the achiral limit colloidal rafts acquire fundamentally new structural properties and interactions. In particular, rafts can switch between two chiral states of opposite handedness, which dramatically alters the nature of the membrane-mediated raft-raft interactions. Rafts with the same chirality have long-ranged repulsions, while those with opposite chirality acquire attractions with a well-defined minimum. Both attractive and repulsive interactions are explained by a continuum model that accounts for the coupling between the membrane thickness and the local tilt of the constituent rods. These switchable interactions enable assembly of colloidal rafts into intricate higher-order architectures with unusual symmetries, including stable tetrameric clusters and "ionic crystallites" of counter-twisting domains organized on a binary square lattice. Furthermore, the properties of individual rafts, such as their sizes, are controlled by their complexation with other rafts. The emergence of these complex behaviors can be rationalized purely in terms of generic couplings between compositional and orientational order of fluids of rod-like elements. Thus, the uncovered principles might have relevance for conventional lipid bilayers, in which the assembly of higher-order structures is also mediated by complex membrane-mediated interactions. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: Main text: 27 pages, 9 figures, Supplementary information: 11 pages, 3 figures

Geometrically incompatible confinement of solids

Authors: Benny Davidovitch, Yiwei Sun, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: The complex morphologies exhibited by spatially confined thin objects have long challenged human efforts to understand and manipulate them, from the representation of patterns in draped fabric in Renaissance art to current day efforts to engineer flexible sensors that conform to the human body. We introduce a theoretical principle, broadly generalizing Euler's {\emph{elastica}} -- a core concept o… ▽ More The complex morphologies exhibited by spatially confined thin objects have long challenged human efforts to understand and manipulate them, from the representation of patterns in draped fabric in Renaissance art to current day efforts to engineer flexible sensors that conform to the human body. We introduce a theoretical principle, broadly generalizing Euler's {\emph{elastica}} -- a core concept of continuum mechanics that invokes the energetic preference of bending over straining a thin solid object and has been widely applied to classical and modern studies of beams and rods. We define a class of {\emph{geometrically incompatible confinement}} problems, whereby the topography imposed on a thin solid body is incompatible with its intrinsic ("target") metric and, as a consequence of Gauss' {\emph{Theorema Egregium}}, induces strain. Focusing on a prototypical example of a sheet attached to a spherical substrate, numerical simulations and analytical study demonstrate that the mechanics is governed by a principle, which we call the "Gauss-Euler {\emph{elastica}}". This emergent rule states that - despite the unavoidable strain in such an incompatible confinement - the ratio between the energies stored in straining and bending the solid may be arbitrarily small. The Gauss-Euler {\emph{elastica}} underlies a theoretical framework that greatly simplifies the daunting task of solving the highly nonlinear equations that describe thin solids at mechanical equilibrium. This development thus opens new possibilities for attacking a broad class of phenomena governed by the coupling of geometry and mechanics. △ Less

Submitted 4 January, 2019; v1 submitted 18 September, 2018; originally announced September 2018.

Comments: Revised version 18 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Published in Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 2019

Stable Frank-Kasper phases of self-assembled, soft matter spheres

Authors: Abhiram Reddy, Michael B. Buckley, Akash Arora, Frank S. Bates, Kevin D. Dorfman, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Single molecular species can self-assemble into Frank Kasper (FK) phases, finite approximants of dodecagonal quasicrystals, defying intuitive notions that thermodynamic ground states are maximally symmetric. FK phases are speculated to emerge as the minimal-distortional packings of space-filling spherical domains, but a precise quantitation of this distortion and how it affects assembly thermodyna… ▽ More Single molecular species can self-assemble into Frank Kasper (FK) phases, finite approximants of dodecagonal quasicrystals, defying intuitive notions that thermodynamic ground states are maximally symmetric. FK phases are speculated to emerge as the minimal-distortional packings of space-filling spherical domains, but a precise quantitation of this distortion and how it affects assembly thermodynamics remains ambiguous. We use two complementary approaches to demonstrate that the principles driving FK lattice formation in diblock copolymers emerge directly from the strong-stretching theory of spherical domains, in which minimal inter-block area competes with minimal stretching of space-filling chains. The relative stability of FK lattices is studied first using a diblock foam model with unconstrained particle volumes and shapes, which correctly predicts not only the equilibrium σ lattice, but also the unequal volumes of the equilibrium domains. We then provide a molecular interpretation for these results via self-consistent field theory, illuminating how molecular stiffness regulates the coupling between intra-domain chain configurations and the asymmetry of local packing. These findings shed new light on the role of volume exchange on the formation of distinct FK phases in copolymers, and suggest a paradigm for formation of FK phases in soft matter systems in which unequal domain volumes are selected by the thermodynamic competition between distinct measures of shape asymmetry. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Comments: 40 pages, 22 figures

Intradomain phase transitions in flexible block copolymers with self-aligning segments

Authors: Christopher J. Burke, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: We study a model of flexible block copolymers (BCPs) in which there is an enlthalpic preference for local alignment, among like-block segments. We describe a generalization of the self-consistent field theory (SCFT) of flexible BCPs to include inter-segment orientational interactions via a Landau-DeGennes free energy associated with a polar or nematic order parameter for segments of one component… ▽ More We study a model of flexible block copolymers (BCPs) in which there is an enlthalpic preference for local alignment, among like-block segments. We describe a generalization of the self-consistent field theory (SCFT) of flexible BCPs to include inter-segment orientational interactions via a Landau-DeGennes free energy associated with a polar or nematic order parameter for segments of one component of a diblock copolymer. We study the equilibrium states of this model numerically, using a pseudo-spectral approach to solve for chain conformation statistics in the presence of a self-consistent torque generated by inter-segment alignment forces. Applying this theory to the structure of lamellar domains composed of symmetric diblocks possessing a single block of "self-aligning", polar segments, we show the emergence of spatially complex segment order parameters (segment director fields) within a given lamellar domain. Because BCP phase separation gives rise to spatially inhomogeneous orientation order of segments even in the absence of explicit intra-segment aligning forces, the director fields of BCPs, as well as thermodynamics of lamellar domain formation, exhibit a highly non-linear dependence on both the inter-block segregation ($χN$) and the enthalpy of alignment ($\varepsilon$). Specifically, we predict the stability of new phases of lamellar order in which distinct regions of alignment coexist within a single mesodomain, and which spontaneously break the symmetry of the lamella pattern of composition in the melt via in-plane tilt of the director in the centers of the like-composition domains. We show further that, in analogy to a Freedericksz transition in confined nematics, that the elastic costs to reorient segments within the domain, as described by Frank elasticity, increase the threshold value $\varepsilon$ needed to induce this intra-domain phase transition. △ Less

Submitted 13 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Persistence of perfect packing in twisted bundles of elastic filaments

Authors: Andreea Panaitescu, Gregory M. Grason, Arshad Kudrolli

Abstract: It is generally understood that geometric frustration prevents maximal hexagonal packings in uniform filament bundles upon twist. We demonstrate that a hexagonal packed elastic filament bundle can preserve its order over a wide range of twist due to a subtle counteraction of geometric expansion with elastic contraction. Using x-ray scanning and by locating each filament in the bundle, we show the… ▽ More It is generally understood that geometric frustration prevents maximal hexagonal packings in uniform filament bundles upon twist. We demonstrate that a hexagonal packed elastic filament bundle can preserve its order over a wide range of twist due to a subtle counteraction of geometric expansion with elastic contraction. Using x-ray scanning and by locating each filament in the bundle, we show the remarkable persistence of order even as the twist is increased well above 360 degrees, by measuring the spatial correlation function across the bundle crosssection. We introduce a model which analyzes the combined effects of elasticity including filament stretching, and radial and hoop compression necessary to explain this generic preservation of order observed with Hookean filaments. △ Less

Submitted 3 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Comments: 5 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 248002 (2018)

Anatomy of triply-periodic network assemblies: Characterizing skeletal and inter-domain surface geometry of block copolymer gyroids

Authors: Ishan Prasad, Hiroshi **nai, Rong-Ming Ho, Edwin L. Thomas, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Triply-periodic networks (TPNs), like the well-known gyroid and diamond network phases, abound in soft matter assemblies, from block copolymers (BCPs), lyotropic liquid crystals and surfactants to functional architectures in biology. While TPNs are, in reality, volume-filling patterns of spatially-varying molecular composition, physical and structural models most often reduce their structure to lo… ▽ More Triply-periodic networks (TPNs), like the well-known gyroid and diamond network phases, abound in soft matter assemblies, from block copolymers (BCPs), lyotropic liquid crystals and surfactants to functional architectures in biology. While TPNs are, in reality, volume-filling patterns of spatially-varying molecular composition, physical and structural models most often reduce their structure to lower-dimensional geometric objects: the {\it 2D interfaces} between chemical domains; and the {\it 1D skeletons} that thread through inter-connected, tubular domains. These lower-dimensional structures provide a useful basis of comparison to idealized geometries based on triply-periodic minimal, or constant-mean curvature surfaces, and shed important light on the spatially heterogeneous packing of molecular constituents that form the networks. Here, we propose a simple, efficient and flexible method to extract a 1D skeleton from 3D volume composition data of self-assembled networks. We apply this method to both self-consistent field theory predictions as well as experimental electron microtomography reconstructions of the double-gyroid phase of an ABA triblock copolymer. We further demonstrate how the analysis of 1D skeleton, 2D inter-domain surfaces, and combinations therefore, provide physical and structural insight into TPNs, across multiple length scales. Specifically, we propose and compare simple measures of {\it network chirality} as well as {\it domain thickness}, and analyze their spatial and statistical distributions in both ideal (theoretical) and non-ideal (experimental) double gyroid assemblies. △ Less

Submitted 9 January, 2018; originally announced January 2018.

Comments: 13 pages, 7 figures, 3 pages supporting pdf

Defect-driven shape instabilities of bundles

Authors: Isaac R. Bruss, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Topological defects are crucial to the thermodynamics and structure of condensed matter systems. For instance, when incorporated into crystalline membranes like graphene, disclinations with positive and negative topological charge elastically buckle the material into conical and saddle-like shapes respectively. A recently uncovered map** between the inter-element spacing in 2D columnar structure… ▽ More Topological defects are crucial to the thermodynamics and structure of condensed matter systems. For instance, when incorporated into crystalline membranes like graphene, disclinations with positive and negative topological charge elastically buckle the material into conical and saddle-like shapes respectively. A recently uncovered map** between the inter-element spacing in 2D columnar structures and the metric properties of curved surfaces motivates basic questions about the interplay between defects in the cross section of a columnar bundle and its 3D shape. Such questions are critical to the structure of a broad class of filamentous materials, from biological assemblies like protein fibers to nano- or micro-structured synthetic materials like carbon nanotube bundles. Here, we explore the buckling behavior for elementary disclinations in hexagonal bundles using a combination of continuum elasticity theory and numerical simulations of discrete-filaments. We show that shape instabilities are controlled by a single material-dependent parameter that characterizes the ratio of inter-filament to intra-filament elastic energies. Along with a host of previously unknown shape equilibria---the filamentous analogs to the conical and saddle-like shapes of defective membranes---we find a profoundly asymmetric response to positive and negative topologically charged defects in the infinite length limit that is without parallel to the membrane analog. The highly non-linear dependence on the sign of the disclination charge is shown to have a purely geometric origin, stemming the from the distinct compatibility (or incompatibility) of effectively positive- (or negative-) curvature geometries with lengthwise-constant filament spacing. △ Less

Submitted 25 August, 2018; v1 submitted 2 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: 18 pages, 11 figures, 1 table; (v2: text revisions + revised Figures 2 & 8)

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. X 8, 031046 (2018)

Sub-Jamming Transition in Binary Sphere Mixtures

Authors: Ishan Prasad, Christian D. Santangelo, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: We study the influence of particle size asymmetry on structural evolution of randomly jammed binary sphere mixtures with varying large-sphere/small-sphere composition. Simulations of jammed packings are used to assess the transition from large-sphere dominant to small-sphere dominant mixtures. For weakly asymmetric particle sizes, packing properties evolve smoothly, but not monotonically, with inc… ▽ More We study the influence of particle size asymmetry on structural evolution of randomly jammed binary sphere mixtures with varying large-sphere/small-sphere composition. Simulations of jammed packings are used to assess the transition from large-sphere dominant to small-sphere dominant mixtures. For weakly asymmetric particle sizes, packing properties evolve smoothly, but not monotonically, with increasing small sphere composition, $f$. Our simulations reveal that at high values of ratio $α$ of large to small sphere radii, ($α\geq α_c \approx 5.75$) evolution of structural properties such as packing density, fraction of jammed spheres and contact statistics with $f$ exhibit features that suggest a sharp transition, either through discontinuities in structural measures or their derivatives. We argue that this behavior is related to the singular, composition dependence of close-packing fraction predicted in infinite aspect ratio mixtures $α\rightarrow\infty$ by the Furnas model, but occurring for finite values range of $α$ above a critical value, $α_c \approx 5.75$. The existence of a sharp transition from small- to large-$f$ values for $α\geq α_c$ can be attributed to the existence of a {\it sub-jamming transition} of small spheres in the interstices of jammed large spheres along the line of compositions $f_{sub}(α)$. We argue that the critical value of finite size asymmetry $α_c \simeq 5.75$ is consistent with the geometric criterion for the transmission of small sphere contacts between neighboring tetrahedrally close packed interstices of large spheres, facilitating a cooperative sub-jamming transition of small spheres confined within the disjoint volumes. △ Less

Submitted 20 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 12 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 96, 052905 (2017)

Measuring geometric frustration in twisted inextensible filament bundles

Authors: Andreea Panaitescu, Gregory M. Grason, Arshad Kudrolli

Abstract: We investigate with experiments and novel map** the structure of a hexagonally ordered filament bundle that is held near its ends and progressively twisted around its central axis. The filaments are free to slide relative to each other and are further held under tension-free boundary conditions. Measuring the bundle packing with micro x-ray imaging, we find that the filaments develop the helical… ▽ More We investigate with experiments and novel map** the structure of a hexagonally ordered filament bundle that is held near its ends and progressively twisted around its central axis. The filaments are free to slide relative to each other and are further held under tension-free boundary conditions. Measuring the bundle packing with micro x-ray imaging, we find that the filaments develop the helical rotation $Ω$ imposed at the boundaries. We then show that the observed structure is consistent with a map** of the filament positions to disks packed on a dual non-Euclidean surface with a Gaussian curvature which increases with twist. We further demonstrate that the mean inter-filament distance is minimal on the surface which can be approximated by a hemisphere with an effective curvature $K_{eff} = 3Ω^2$. Examining the packing on the dual surface, we analyze the geometric frustration of packing in twisted bundles and find the core to remain relatively hexagonally ordered with inter-filament strains growing from the bundle center, driving the formation of defects at the exterior of highly twisted bundles. △ Less

Submitted 12 May, 2017; originally announced May 2017.

Comments: 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 95, 052503 (2017)

Intradomain Textures in Block Copolymers: Multizone Alignment and Biaxiality

Authors: Ishan Prasad, Youngmi Seo, Lisa M. Hall, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Block copolymer (BCP) melt assembly has been the subject of decades of study, with focus largely on self-organized spatial patterns of periodically-ordered segment density. In this study, we demonstrate that underlying these otherwise well-known composition profiles (i.e. ordered lamella, cylinders, spheres and networks) are generic and heterogeneous patterns of segment orientation that couple str… ▽ More Block copolymer (BCP) melt assembly has been the subject of decades of study, with focus largely on self-organized spatial patterns of periodically-ordered segment density. In this study, we demonstrate that underlying these otherwise well-known composition profiles (i.e. ordered lamella, cylinders, spheres and networks) are generic and heterogeneous patterns of segment orientation that couple strongly to morphology, even in the absence of specific factors that promote intra- or inter-chain segment alignment. We employ a combination of self-consistent field theory and coarse-grained simulation methods to measure polar and nematic order parameters of segments in a freely-jointed chain model of diblock melts. We show that BCP morphologies are generically characterized by a {\it multizone} texture, with segments predominantly aligned normal and parallel to inter-domain interfaces in the respective brush and interfacial regions of the microdomain. Further, morphologies with anisotropically-curved interfaces (i.e. cylinders and networks) exhibit biaxial order that is aligned to the principal curvature axes of the interface. Understanding these generic features of intra-domain texture provide new opportunities for manipulating multi-scale structure and functional properties of BCP assembly. △ Less

Submitted 31 December, 2016; v1 submitted 23 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 20 pages (10 main text + 10 appendix and references); 8 figures (4 main text + 4 appendix); 3 appendices v2, Corrected typos and refs

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 247801 (2017)

How geometric frustration shapes twisted fibers, inside and out: Competing morphologies of chiral filament assembly

Authors: Douglas M. Hall, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Chirality frustrates and shapes the assembly of flexible filaments in rope-like, twisted bundles and fibers by introducing gradients of both filament shape (i.e. curvature) and packing throughout the structure. Previous models of chiral filament bundle formation have shown that this frustration gives rise to several distinct morphological responses, including self-limiting bundle widths, anisotrop… ▽ More Chirality frustrates and shapes the assembly of flexible filaments in rope-like, twisted bundles and fibers by introducing gradients of both filament shape (i.e. curvature) and packing throughout the structure. Previous models of chiral filament bundle formation have shown that this frustration gives rise to several distinct morphological responses, including self-limiting bundle widths, anisotropic domain (tape-like) formation and topological defects in the lateral inter-filament order. In this paper, we employ a combination of continuum elasticity theory and discrete filament bundle simulations to explore how these distinct morphological responses compete in the broader phase diagram of chiral filament assembly. We show that the most generic model of bundle formation exhibits at least four classes of equilibrium structure -- finite-width, twisted bundles with isotropic and anisotropic shapes, with and without topological defects, as well as bulk phases of untwisted, columnar assembly (i.e. "frustration escape"). These competing equilibrium morphologies are selected by only a relatively small number of parameters describing filament assembly: bundle surface energy, preferred chiral twist and stiffness of chiral filament interactions, and mechanical stiffness of filaments and their lateral interactions. Discrete filament bundle simulations test and verify continuum theory predictions for dependence of bundle structure (shape, size and packing defects of 2D cross section) on these key parameters. △ Less

Submitted 7 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: Submitted to RSC Interface Focus

Perspective: Geometrically-Frustrated Assemblies

Authors: Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: This perspective will overview an emerging paradigm for self-organized soft materials, {\it geometrically-frustrated assemblies}, where interactions between self-assembling elements (e.g. particles, macromolecules, proteins) favor local packing motifs that are incompatible with uniform global order in the assembly. This classification applies to a broad range of material assemblies including self-… ▽ More This perspective will overview an emerging paradigm for self-organized soft materials, {\it geometrically-frustrated assemblies}, where interactions between self-assembling elements (e.g. particles, macromolecules, proteins) favor local packing motifs that are incompatible with uniform global order in the assembly. This classification applies to a broad range of material assemblies including self-twisting protein filament bundles, amyloid fibers, chiral smectics and membranes, particle-coated droplets, curved protein shells and phase-separated lipid vesicles. In assemblies, geometric frustration leads to a host of anomalous structural and thermodynamic properties, including heterogeneous and internally-stressed equilibrium structures, self-limiting assembly and topological defects in the equilibrium assembly structures. The purpose of this perspective is to 1) highlight the unifying principles and consequences of geometric frustration in soft matter assemblies, 2) to classify the known distinct "modes" of frustration and review corresponding experimental examples, and 3) to describe outstanding questions not yet addressed about the unique properties and behaviors of this broad class of systems. △ Less

Submitted 18 September, 2016; v1 submitted 28 August, 2016; originally announced August 2016.

Comments: 19 pages, 10 figures; revised version with corrected typos and references

Journal ref: Journal of Chemical Physics 145, 110901 (2016)

Shape selection of surface-bound helical filaments: biopolymers on curved membranes

Authors: D. A. Quint, A. Gopinathan, G. M. Grason

Abstract: Motivated to understand the behavior of biological filaments interacting with membranes of various types, we study a theoretical model for the shape and thermodynamics of intrinsically-helical filaments bound to curved membranes. We show filament-surface interactions lead to a host of non-uniform shape equilibria, in which filaments progressively unwind from their native twist with increasing surf… ▽ More Motivated to understand the behavior of biological filaments interacting with membranes of various types, we study a theoretical model for the shape and thermodynamics of intrinsically-helical filaments bound to curved membranes. We show filament-surface interactions lead to a host of non-uniform shape equilibria, in which filaments progressively unwind from their native twist with increasing surface interaction and surface curvature, ultimately adopting uniform-contact curved shapes. The latter effect is due to non-linear coupling between elastic twist and bending of filaments on anisotropically-curved surfaces, such as the cylindrical surfaces considered here. Via a combination of numerical solutions and asymptotic analysis of shape equilibria we show that filament conformations are critically sensitive to the surface curvature in both the strong- and weak-binding limits. These results suggest that local structure of membrane-bound chiral filaments is generically sensitive to the curvature-radius of the surface to which it is bound, even when that radius is much larger than the filament intrinsic pitch. Typical values of elastic parameters and interaction energies for several prokaryotic and eukaryotic filaments indicate that biopolymers are inherently very sensitive to the coupling between twist, interactions and geometry and that this could be exploited for regulation of a variety of processes such as the targeted exertion of forces, signaling and self-assembly in response to geometric cues including the local mean and Gaussian curvatures. △ Less

Submitted 25 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

Neutral versus charged defect patterns in curved crystals

Authors: Amir Azadi, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Characterizing the complex spectrum of topological defects in ground states of curved crystals is a long-standing problem with wide implications, from the mathematical Thomson problem to diverse physical realizations, including fullerenes and particle-coated droplets. While the excess number of "topologically-charged" 5-fold disclinations in a closed, spherical crystal is fixed, here, we study the… ▽ More Characterizing the complex spectrum of topological defects in ground states of curved crystals is a long-standing problem with wide implications, from the mathematical Thomson problem to diverse physical realizations, including fullerenes and particle-coated droplets. While the excess number of "topologically-charged" 5-fold disclinations in a closed, spherical crystal is fixed, here, we study the elementary transition from defect-free, flat crystals to curved-crystals possessing an excess of "charged" disclinations in their bulk. Specifically, we consider the impact of topologically-neutral patterns of defects -- in the form of multi-dislocation chains or "scars" stable for small lattice spacing -- on the transition from neutral to charged ground-state patterns of a crystalline cap bound to a spherical surface. Based on the asymptotic theory of caps in continuum limit of vanishing lattice spacing, we derive the morphological phase diagram of ground state defect patterns, spanned by surface coverage of the sphere and forces at the cap edge. For the singular limit of zero edge forces, we find that scars reduce (by half) the threshold surface coverage for excess disclinations. Even more significant, scars flatten the geometric dependence of excess disinclination number on Gaussian curvature, leading to a transition between stable "charged" and "neutral" patterns that is, instead, critically sensitive to the compressive vs. tensile nature of boundary forces on the cap. △ Less

Submitted 29 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Comments: 15 pages

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 94, 013003 (2016)

Geometry and Optimal Packing of Twisted Columns and Filaments

Authors: Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: This review presents recent progress in understanding constraints and consequences of close-packing geometry of filamentous or columnar materials possessing non-trivial textures, focusing in particular on the common motifs of twisted and toroidal structures. The mathematical framework is presented that relates spacing between line-like, filamentous elements to their backbone orientations, highligh… ▽ More This review presents recent progress in understanding constraints and consequences of close-packing geometry of filamentous or columnar materials possessing non-trivial textures, focusing in particular on the common motifs of twisted and toroidal structures. The mathematical framework is presented that relates spacing between line-like, filamentous elements to their backbone orientations, highlighting the explicit connection between the inter-filament {\it metric} properties and the geometry of non-Euclidean surfaces. The consequences of the hidden connection between packing in twisted filament bundles and packing on positively curved surfaces, like the Thomson problem, are demonstrated for the defect-riddled ground states of physical models of twisted filament bundles. The connection between the "ideal" geometry of {\it fibrations} of curved three-dimensional space, including the Hopf fibration, and the non-Euclidean constraints of filament packing in twisted and toroidal bundles is presented, with a focus on the broader dependence of metric geometry on the simultaneous twisting and folded of multi-filament bundles. △ Less

Submitted 30 January, 2015; v1 submitted 27 October, 2014; originally announced October 2014.

Comments: 19 pages; 16 figures; text revisions + additional references

Journal ref: Reviews of Modern Physics, v. 87, 401 (2015)

Measuring cohesion between macromolecular filaments, one pair at a time: Depletion-induced microtubule bundling

Authors: Feodor Hilitski, Andrew R. Ward, Luis Cajamarca, Michael F. Hagan, Gregory M. Grason, Zvonimir Dogic

Abstract: In presence of non-adsorbing polymers, colloidal particles experience ubiquitous attractive interactions induced by depletion forces. Here, we measure the depletion interaction between a pair of microtubule filaments using a method that combines single filament imaging with optical trap**. By quantifying the dependence of filament cohesion on both polymer concentration and solution ionic strengt… ▽ More In presence of non-adsorbing polymers, colloidal particles experience ubiquitous attractive interactions induced by depletion forces. Here, we measure the depletion interaction between a pair of microtubule filaments using a method that combines single filament imaging with optical trap**. By quantifying the dependence of filament cohesion on both polymer concentration and solution ionic strength, we demonstrate that the minimal model of depletion, based on the Asakura-Oosawa theory, fails to quantitatively describe the experimental data. By measuring the cohesion strength in two- and three- filament bundles we verify pairwise additivity of depletion interactions for the specific experimental conditions. The described experimental technique can be used to measure pairwise interactions between various biological or synthetic filaments and complements information extracted from bulk osmotic stress experiments. △ Less

Submitted 11 February, 2015; v1 submitted 21 August, 2014; originally announced August 2014.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 138102 (2015)

Geometry of flexible filament cohesion: Better contact through twist?

Authors: Luis Cajamarca, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Cohesive interactions between filamentous molecules have broad implications for a range of biological and synthetic materials. While long-standing theoretical approaches have addressed the problem of inter-filament forces from the limit of infinitely rigid rods, the ability of flexible filaments to deform intra-filament shape in response to changes in inter-filament geometry has a profound affect… ▽ More Cohesive interactions between filamentous molecules have broad implications for a range of biological and synthetic materials. While long-standing theoretical approaches have addressed the problem of inter-filament forces from the limit of infinitely rigid rods, the ability of flexible filaments to deform intra-filament shape in response to changes in inter-filament geometry has a profound affect on the nature of cohesive interactions. In this paper, we study two theoretical models of inter-filament cohesion in the opposite limit, in which filaments are sufficiently flexible to maintain cohesive contact along their contours, and address, in particular, the role played by helical-interfilament geometry in defining interactions. Specifically, we study models of featureless, tubular filaments interacting via 1) pair-wise Lennard-Jones (LJ) interactions between surface elements and 2) depletion-induced filament binding stabilized by electrostatic surface repulsion. Analysis of these models reveals a universal preference for cohesive filament interactions for non-zero helical skew, and further, that in the asymptotic limit of vanishing interaction range relative to filament diameter, the skew-dependence of cohesion approaches a geometrically defined limit described purely by the close-packing geometry of twisted tubular filaments. We further analyze non-universal features of the skew-dependence of cohesion at small-twist for both potentials, and argue that in the LJ model the pair-wise surface attraction generically destabilizes parallel filaments, while in the second model, pair-wise electrostatic repulsion in combination with non-pairwise additivity of depletion leads to a meta-stable parallel state. △ Less

Submitted 3 November, 2014; v1 submitted 16 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: 14 pages, 14 figures

Emergent structure of multi-dislocation ground states in curved crystals

Authors: Amir Azadi, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: We study the structural features and underlying principles of multi-dislocation ground states of a crystalline spherical cap. In the continuum limit where the ratio of crystal size to lattice spacing $W/a$ diverges, dislocations proliferate and ground states approach a characteristic sequence of structures composed of radial grain boundaries ("neutral scars"), extending radially from the boundary… ▽ More We study the structural features and underlying principles of multi-dislocation ground states of a crystalline spherical cap. In the continuum limit where the ratio of crystal size to lattice spacing $W/a$ diverges, dislocations proliferate and ground states approach a characteristic sequence of structures composed of radial grain boundaries ("neutral scars"), extending radially from the boundary and terminating in the bulk. Employing a combination of numerical simulations and asymptotic analysis of continuum elasticity theory, we prove that an energetic hierarchy gives rise to a structural hierarchy, whereby dislocation number and scar number diverge as $a/W \to 0$ while scar length and dislocation number per scar become {\it independent} of lattice spacing. We characterize a secondary transition occurring as scar length grows, where the $n$-fold scar symmetry is broken and ground states are characterized by polydisperse, forked-scar morphologies. △ Less

Submitted 16 December, 2013; originally announced December 2013.

Comments: 10 pages, 3 figures + supporting info

Tensorial conservation law for nematic polymers

Authors: Daniel Svenšek, Gregory M. Grason, Rudolf Podgornik

Abstract: We derive the "conservation law" for nematic polymers in tensorial form valid for quadrupolar orientational order in contradistinction to the conservation law in the case of polar orientational order. Due to microscopic differences in the coupling between the orientational field deformations and the density variations for polar and quadrupolar order, we find that respective order parameters satisf… ▽ More We derive the "conservation law" for nematic polymers in tensorial form valid for quadrupolar orientational order in contradistinction to the conservation law in the case of polar orientational order. Due to microscopic differences in the coupling between the orientational field deformations and the density variations for polar and quadrupolar order, we find that respective order parameters satisfy fundamentally distinct constraints. Being necessarily scalar in its form, the tensorial conservation law is obtained straightforwardly from the gradients of the polymer nematic tensor field and connects the spatial variation of this tensor field with density variations. We analyze the differences between the polar and the tensorial forms of the conservation law, present some explicit orientational fields that satisfy this new constraint and discuss the role of singular "hairpins", which do not affect local quadrupolar order of polymer nematics, but nevertheless influence its gradients. △ Less

Submitted 5 November, 2013; v1 submitted 27 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: 10 pages, 6 figures

Topological Defects, Surface Geometry and Cohesive Energy of Twisted Filament Bundles

Authors: Isaac R. Bruss, Gregory M. Grason

Abstract: Cohesive assemblies of filaments are a common structural motif found in diverse contexts, ranging from biological materials such as fibrous proteins, to artificial materials such as carbon nanotube ropes and micropatterned filament arrays. In this paper, we analyze the complex dependence of cohesive energy on twist, a key structural parameter of both self-assembled and fabricated filament bundles.… ▽ More Cohesive assemblies of filaments are a common structural motif found in diverse contexts, ranging from biological materials such as fibrous proteins, to artificial materials such as carbon nanotube ropes and micropatterned filament arrays. In this paper, we analyze the complex dependence of cohesive energy on twist, a key structural parameter of both self-assembled and fabricated filament bundles. Based on the analysis of simulated ground states of cohesive bundles, we show that the non-linear influence of twist derives from two distinct geometric features of twisted bundles: (i) the geometrical frustration of inter-filament packing in the bundle cross-section; and (ii) the evolution of the surface geometry of bundles with twist, which dictates the cohesive cost of non-contacting filaments at the surface. Packing frustration in the bundle core gives rise to the appearance of a universal sequence of topological defects, excess 5-fold disclinations, with increasing twist, while the evolution of filament contact at the surface of the bundle generically favors twisted geometries for sufficiently long filaments. Our analysis of both continuum and discrete models of filament bundles shows that, even in the absence of external torque or intrinsic chirality, cohesive energy universally favors twisted ground states above a critical (length/radius) aspect ratio and below a critical filament stiffness threshold. △ Less

Submitted 5 July, 2013; v1 submitted 6 March, 2013; originally announced March 2013.

Comments: 21 pages, 19 figures