-
How quickly can sodium-ion learn? Assessing scenarios for techno-economic competitiveness against lithium-ion batteries
Authors:
Adrian Yao,
Sally M. Benson,
William C. Chueh
Abstract:
Sodium-ion batteries have garnered significant attention as a potentially low-cost alternative to lithium-ion batteries, which have experienced supply shortages and pricing volatility of key minerals. Here we assess their techno-economic competitiveness against incumbent lithium-ion batteries using a modeling framework incorporating componential learning curves constrained by minerals prices and e…
▽ More
Sodium-ion batteries have garnered significant attention as a potentially low-cost alternative to lithium-ion batteries, which have experienced supply shortages and pricing volatility of key minerals. Here we assess their techno-economic competitiveness against incumbent lithium-ion batteries using a modeling framework incorporating componential learning curves constrained by minerals prices and engineering design floors. We compare projected sodium-ion and lithium-ion price trends across over 6,000 scenarios while varying Na-ion technology development roadmaps, supply chain scenarios, market penetration, and learning rates. Assuming substantial progress can be made along technology roadmaps via targeted R&D, we forecast many sodium-ion pathways to be price competitive against low-cost lithium-ion variants in the early 2030s. Additionally, we show timelines are highly sensitive to movements in critical minerals supply chains--namely that of lithium, graphite, and nickel. Modeled outcomes suggest increasing sodium-ion energy densities to decrease materials intensity to be among the most impactful ways to improve competitiveness.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2024; v1 submitted 20 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Correlative image learning of chemo-mechanics in phase-transforming solids
Authors:
Haitao D. Deng,
Hongbo Zhao,
Norman L. **,
Lauren Hughes,
Benjamin Savitzky,
Colin Ophus,
Dimitrios Fraggedakis,
András Borbély,
Young-Sang Yu,
Eder Lomeli,
Rui Yan,
Jueyi Liu,
David A. Shapiro,
Wei Cai,
Martin Z. Bazant,
Andrew M. Minor,
William C. Chueh
Abstract:
Constitutive laws underlie most physical processes in nature. However, learning such equations in heterogeneous solids (e.g., due to phase separation) is challenging. One such relationship is between composition and eigenstrain, which governs the chemo-mechanical expansion in solids. In this work, we developed a generalizable, physically-constrained image-learning framework to algorithmically lear…
▽ More
Constitutive laws underlie most physical processes in nature. However, learning such equations in heterogeneous solids (e.g., due to phase separation) is challenging. One such relationship is between composition and eigenstrain, which governs the chemo-mechanical expansion in solids. In this work, we developed a generalizable, physically-constrained image-learning framework to algorithmically learn the chemo-mechanical constitutive law at the nanoscale from correlative four-dimensional scanning transmission electron microscopy and X-ray spectro-ptychography images. We demonstrated this approach on Li$_X$FePO$_4$, a technologically-relevant battery positive electrode material. We uncovered the functional form of composition-eigenstrain relation in this two-phase binary solid across the entire composition range (0 $\leq$ X $\leq$ 1), including inside the thermodynamically-unstable miscibility gap. The learned relation directly validates Vegard's law of linear response at the nanoscale. Our physics-constrained data-driven approach directly visualizes the residual strain field (by removing the compositional and coherency strain), which is otherwise impossible to quantify. Heterogeneities in the residual strain arise from misfit dislocations and were independently verified by X-ray diffraction line profile analysis. Our work provides the means to simultaneously quantify chemical expansion, coherency strain and dislocations in battery electrodes, which has implications on rate capabilities and lifetime. Broadly, this work also highlights the potential of integrating correlative microscopy and image learning for extracting material properties and physics.
△ Less
Submitted 13 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Correlative analysis of structure and chemistry of LixFePO4 platelets using 4D-STEM and X-ray ptychography
Authors:
L. A. Hughes,
Benjamin H. Savitzky,
Haitao D. Deng,
Norman L. **,
Eder G. Lomeli,
Young-Sang Yu,
David A. Shapiro,
Patrick Herring,
Abraham Anapolsky,
William C. Chueh,
Colin Ophus,
Andrew M. Minor
Abstract:
Lithium iron phosphate (LixFePO4), a cathode material used in rechargeable Li-ion batteries, phase separates upon de/lithiation under equilibrium. The interfacial structure and chemistry within these cathode materials affects Li-ion transport, and therefore battery performance. Correlative imaging of LixFePO4 was performed using four-dimensional scanning transmission electron microscopy (4D-STEM),…
▽ More
Lithium iron phosphate (LixFePO4), a cathode material used in rechargeable Li-ion batteries, phase separates upon de/lithiation under equilibrium. The interfacial structure and chemistry within these cathode materials affects Li-ion transport, and therefore battery performance. Correlative imaging of LixFePO4 was performed using four-dimensional scanning transmission electron microscopy (4D-STEM), scanning transmission X-ray microscopy (STXM), and X-ray ptychography in order to analyze the local structure and chemistry of the same particle set. Over 50,000 diffraction patterns from 10 particles provided measurements of both structure and chemistry at a nanoscale spatial resolution (16.6-49.5 nm) over wide (several micron) fields-of-view with statistical robustness.LixFePO4 particles at varying stages of delithiation were measured to examine the evolution of structure and chemistry as a function of delithiation. In lithiated and delithiated particles, local variations were observed in the degree of lithiation even while local lattice structures remained comparatively constant, and calculation of linear coefficients of chemical expansion suggest pinning of the lattice structures in these populations. Partially delithiated particles displayed broadly core-shell-like structures, however, with highly variable behavior both locally and per individual particle that exhibited distinctive intermediate regions at the interface between phases, and pockets within the lithiated core that correspond to FePO4 in structure and chemistry.The results provide insight into the LixFePO4 system, subtleties in the scope and applicability of Vegards law (linear lattice parameter-composition behavior) under local versus global measurements, and demonstrate a powerful new combination of experimental and analytical modalities for bridging the crucial gap between local and statistical characterization.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Layer-Resolved Many-Electron Interactions in Delafossite PdCoO2 from Standing-Wave Photoemission Spectroscopy
Authors:
Qiyang Lu,
Henrique Martins,
J. Matthias Kahk,
Gaurab Rimal,
Seongshik Oh,
Inna Vishik,
Matthew Brahlek,
William C. Chueh,
Johannes Lischner,
Slavomir Nemsak
Abstract:
When a three-dimensional material is constructed by stacking different two-dimensional layers into an ordered structure, new and unique physical properties can emerge. An example is the delafossite PdCoO2, which consists of alternating layers of metallic Pd and Mott-insulating CoO2 sheets. To understand the nature of the electronic coupling between the layers that gives rise to the unique properti…
▽ More
When a three-dimensional material is constructed by stacking different two-dimensional layers into an ordered structure, new and unique physical properties can emerge. An example is the delafossite PdCoO2, which consists of alternating layers of metallic Pd and Mott-insulating CoO2 sheets. To understand the nature of the electronic coupling between the layers that gives rise to the unique properties of PdCoO2, we revealed its layer-resolved electronic structure combining standing-wave X-ray photoemission spectroscopy and ab initio many-body calculations. Experimentally, we have decomposed the measured valence band spectrum into contributions from Pd and CoO2 layers. Computationally, we find that many-body interactions in Pd and CoO2 layers are highly different. Holes in the CoO2 layer interact strongly with charge-transfer excitons in the same layer, whereas holes in the Pd layer couple to plasmons in the Pd layer. Interestingly, we find that holes in states hybridized across both layers couple to both types of excitations (charge-transfer excitons or plasmons), with the intensity of photoemission satellites being proportional to the projection of the state onto a given layer. This establishes satellites as a sensitive probe for inter-layer hybridization. These findings pave the way towards a better understanding of complex many-electron interactions in layered quantum materials.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Universal phase dynamics in VO2 switches revealed by ultrafast operando diffraction
Authors:
Aditya Sood,
Xiaozhe Shen,
Yin Shi,
Suhas Kumar,
Su Ji Park,
Marc Zajac,
Yifei Sun,
Long-Qing Chen,
Shriram Ramanathan,
Xijie Wang,
William C. Chueh,
Aaron M. Lindenberg
Abstract:
Strongly correlated materials that exhibit an insulator-metal transition are key candidates in the search for new computing platforms. Understanding the pathways and timescales underlying the electrically-driven insulator-metal transition is crucial for uncovering the fundamental limits of device operation. Using stroboscopic electron diffraction, we perform synchronized time-resolved measurements…
▽ More
Strongly correlated materials that exhibit an insulator-metal transition are key candidates in the search for new computing platforms. Understanding the pathways and timescales underlying the electrically-driven insulator-metal transition is crucial for uncovering the fundamental limits of device operation. Using stroboscopic electron diffraction, we perform synchronized time-resolved measurements of atomic motions and electronic transport in operating vanadium dioxide switches. We discover an electrically-triggered, isostructural state that forms transiently on microsecond timescales, stabilized by local heterogeneities and interfacial interactions between the equilibrium phases. This metastable phase bears striking similarity to that formed under photoexcitation within picoseconds, suggesting a universal transformation pathway across eight orders of magnitude of timescale. Our results establish a new route for uncovering non-equilibrium and metastable phases in correlated materials, and open avenues for engineering novel dynamical behavior in nanoelectronics.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Electrochemical Ion Insertion: From Atoms to Devices
Authors:
Aditya Sood,
Andrey D. Poletayev,
Daniel A. Cogswell,
Peter M. Csernica,
J. Tyler Mefford,
Dimitrios Fraggedakis,
Michael F. Toney,
Aaron M. Lindenberg,
Martin Z. Bazant,
William C. Chueh
Abstract:
Electrochemical ion insertion involves coupled ion-electron transfer reactions, transport of guest species, and redox of the host. The hosts are typically anisotropic solids with two-dimensional conduction planes, but can also be materials with one-dimensional or isotropic transport pathways. These insertion compounds have traditionally been studied in the context of energy storage, but also find…
▽ More
Electrochemical ion insertion involves coupled ion-electron transfer reactions, transport of guest species, and redox of the host. The hosts are typically anisotropic solids with two-dimensional conduction planes, but can also be materials with one-dimensional or isotropic transport pathways. These insertion compounds have traditionally been studied in the context of energy storage, but also find extensive applications in electrocatalysis, optoelectronics, and computing. Recent developments in operando, ultrafast, and high-resolution characterization methods, as well as accurate theoretical simulation methods, have led to a renaissance in the understanding of ion-insertion compounds. In this Review, we present a unified framework for understanding insertion compounds across time and length scales ranging from atomic to device levels. Using graphite, transition metal dichalcogenides, layered oxides, oxyhydroxides, and olivines as examples, we explore commonalities in these materials in terms of point defects, interfacial reactions, and phase transformations. We illustrate similarities in the operating principles of various ion-insertion devices ranging from batteries and electrocatalysts to electrochromics and thermal transistors, with the goal of unifying research across disciplinary boundaries.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Coulombically-stabilized oxygen hole polarons enable fully reversible oxygen redox
Authors:
Iwnetim I. Abate,
C. Das Pemmaraju,
Se Young Kim,
Kuan H. Hsu,
Sami Sainio,
Brian Moritz,
John Vinson,
Michael F. Toney,
Wanli Yang,
William E. Gent,
Thomas P. Devereaux,
Linda F. Nazar,
William C. Chueh
Abstract:
Stabilizing high-valent redox couples and exotic electronic states necessitate an understanding of the stabilization mechanism. In oxides, whether they are being considered for energy storage or computing, highly oxidized oxide-anion species rehybridize to form short covalent bonds and are related to significant local structural distortions. In intercalation oxide electrodes for batteries, while s…
▽ More
Stabilizing high-valent redox couples and exotic electronic states necessitate an understanding of the stabilization mechanism. In oxides, whether they are being considered for energy storage or computing, highly oxidized oxide-anion species rehybridize to form short covalent bonds and are related to significant local structural distortions. In intercalation oxide electrodes for batteries, while such reorganization partially stabilizes oxygen redox, it also gives rise to substantial hysteresis. In this work, we investigate oxygen redox in layered Na2-XMn3O7, a positive electrode material with ordered Mn vacancies. We show that coulombic interactions between oxidized oxide-anions and the interlayer Na vacancies can disfavor rehybridization and stabilize hole polarons on oxygen at 4.2 V vs. Na/Na+. These coulombic interactions provide thermodynamic energy saving as large as O-O covalent bonding and enable ~ 40 mV voltage hysteresis over multiple electrochemical cycles with negligible voltage fade. Our results establish a complete picture of redox energetics by highlighting the role of coulombic interactions across several atomic distances and suggest avenues to stabilize highly oxidized oxygen for applications in energy storage and beyond.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Theory of coupled ion-electron transfer kinetics
Authors:
Dimitrios Fraggedakis,
Michael McEldrew,
Raymond B. Smith,
Yamini Krishnan,
Yirui Zhang,
Peng Bai,
William C. Chueh,
Yang Shao-Horn,
Martin Z. Bazant
Abstract:
The microscopic theory of chemical reactions is based on transition state theory, where atoms or ions transfer classically over an energy barrier, as electrons maintain their ground state. Electron transfer is fundamentally different and occurs by tunneling in response to solvent fluctuations. Here, we develop the theory of coupled ion-electron transfer, in which ions and solvent molecules fluctua…
▽ More
The microscopic theory of chemical reactions is based on transition state theory, where atoms or ions transfer classically over an energy barrier, as electrons maintain their ground state. Electron transfer is fundamentally different and occurs by tunneling in response to solvent fluctuations. Here, we develop the theory of coupled ion-electron transfer, in which ions and solvent molecules fluctuate cooperatively to facilitate electron transfer. We derive a general formula of the reaction rate that depends on the overpotential, solvent properties, the electronic structure of the electron donor/acceptor, and the excess chemical potential of ions in the transition state. For Faradaic reactions, the theory predicts curved Tafel plots with a concentration-dependent reaction-limited current. For moderate overpotentials, our formula reduces to the Butler-Volmer equation and explains its relevance, not only in the well-known limit of large electron-transfer (solvent reorganization) energy, but also in the opposite limit of large ion-transfer energy. The rate formula is applied to Li-ion batteries, where reduction of the electrode host material couples with ion insertion. In the case of lithium iron phosphate, the theory accurately predicts the concentration dependence of the exchange current measured by {\it in operando} X-Ray microscopy without any adjustable parameters. These results pave the way for interfacial engineering to enhance ion intercalation rates, not only for batteries, but also for ionic separations and neuromorphic computing.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2020; v1 submitted 25 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Electrochemical kinetics of SEI growth on carbon black, I: Experiments
Authors:
Peter M. Attia,
Supratim Das,
Stephen J. Harris,
Martin Z. Bazant,
William C. Chueh
Abstract:
Growth of the solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) is a primary driver of capacity fade in lithium-ion batteries. Despite its importance to this device and intense research interest, the fundamental mechanisms underpinning SEI growth remain unclear. In Part I of this work, we present an electroanalytical method to measure the dependence of SEI growth on potential, current magnitude, and current dire…
▽ More
Growth of the solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) is a primary driver of capacity fade in lithium-ion batteries. Despite its importance to this device and intense research interest, the fundamental mechanisms underpinning SEI growth remain unclear. In Part I of this work, we present an electroanalytical method to measure the dependence of SEI growth on potential, current magnitude, and current direction during galvanostatic cycling of carbon black/Li half cells. We find that SEI growth strongly depends on all three parameters; most notably, we find SEI growth rates increase with nominal C rate and are significantly higher on lithiation than on delithiation. We observe this directional effect in both galvanostatic and potentiostatic experiments and discuss hypotheses that could explain this observation. This work identifies a strong coupling between SEI growth and charge storage (e.g., intercalation and capacitance) in carbon negative electrodes.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2019; v1 submitted 4 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Fingerprint oxygen redox reactions in batteries through high-efficiency map** of resonant inelastic X-ray scattering (mRIXS)
Authors:
**peng Wu,
Qinghao Li,
Shawn Sallis,
Zengqing Zhuo,
William E. Gent,
William C. Chueh,
Shishen Yan,
Yi-de Chuang,
Wanli Yang
Abstract:
Realizing reversible reduction-oxidation (Redox) reactions of lattice oxygen in batteries is a promising way to improve the energy and power density. However, conventional oxygen absorption spectroscopy fails to distinguish the critical oxygen chemistry in oxide-based battery electrodes. Therefore, high-efficiency full-range map** of resonant inelastic X-ray scattering (mRIXS) has been developed…
▽ More
Realizing reversible reduction-oxidation (Redox) reactions of lattice oxygen in batteries is a promising way to improve the energy and power density. However, conventional oxygen absorption spectroscopy fails to distinguish the critical oxygen chemistry in oxide-based battery electrodes. Therefore, high-efficiency full-range map** of resonant inelastic X-ray scattering (mRIXS) has been developed as a reliable probe of oxygen redox reactions. Here, based on mRIXS results collected from a series of Li1.17Ni0.21Co0.08Mn0.54O2 electrodes at different electrochemical states and its comparison with peroxides, we provide a comprehensive analysis of five components observed in the mRIXS results. While almost all the components change upon electrochemical cycling, comparison with peroxide species show that only two evolving features correspond to the critical oxidized oxygen states. One is a specific feature at 531.0eV excitation and 523.7eV emission energy, the other is a low-energy loss feature. We show that both features evolve with electrochemical cycling of Li1.17Ni0.21Co0.08Mn0.54O2 electrodes, and could be used for characterizing oxygen redox states in battery electrodes. This work is the first benchmark for a complete assignment of all the important mRIXS features collected from battery materials, which provides guidelines for future studies in characterization, analysis and theoretical calculation for probing and understanding oxygen redox reactions.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
High Reversibility of Lattice Oxygen Redox in Na-ion and Li-ion Batteries Quantified by Direct Bulk Probes of both Anionic and Cationic Redox Reactions
Authors:
Kehua Dai,
**peng Wu,
Zengqing Zhuo,
Qinghao Li,
Shawn Sallis,
**g Mao,
Guo Ai,
Chihang Sun,
Zaiyuan Li,
William E. Gent,
William C. Chueh,
Yi-de Chuang,
Rong Zeng,
Zhi-xun Shen,
Feng Pan,
Shishen Yan,
Louis F. J. Piper,
Zahid Hussain,
Gao Liu,
Wanli Yang
Abstract:
The reversibility and cyclability of anionic redox in battery electrodes hold the key to its practical employments. Here, through map** of resonant inelastic X-ray scattering (mRIXS), we have independently quantified the evolving redox states of both cations and anions in Na2/3Mg1/3Mn2/3O2. The bulk-Mn redox emerges from initial discharge and is quantified by inverse-partial fluorescence yield (…
▽ More
The reversibility and cyclability of anionic redox in battery electrodes hold the key to its practical employments. Here, through map** of resonant inelastic X-ray scattering (mRIXS), we have independently quantified the evolving redox states of both cations and anions in Na2/3Mg1/3Mn2/3O2. The bulk-Mn redox emerges from initial discharge and is quantified by inverse-partial fluorescence yield (iPFY) from Mn-L mRIXS. Bulk and surface Mn activities likely lead to the voltage fade. O-K super-partial fluorescence yield (sPFY) analysis of mRIXS shows 79% lattice oxygen-redox reversibility during initial cycle, with 87% capacity sustained after 100 cycles. In Li1.17Ni0.21Co0.08Mn0.54O2, lattice-oxygen redox is 76% initial-cycle reversible but with only 44% capacity retention after 500 cycles. These results unambiguously show the high reversibility of lattice-oxygen redox in both Li-ion and Na-ion systems. The contrast between Na2/3Mg1/3Mn2/3O2 and Li1.17Ni0.21Co0.08Mn0.54O2 systems suggests the importance of distinguishing lattice-oxygen redox from other oxygen activities for clarifying its intrinsic properties.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.