-
Thermalization and Criticality on an Analog-Digital Quantum Simulator
Authors:
Trond I. Andersen,
Nikita Astrakhantsev,
Amir H. Karamlou,
Julia Berndtsson,
Johannes Motruk,
Aaron Szasz,
Jonathan A. Gross,
Alexander Schuckert,
Tom Westerhout,
Yaxing Zhang,
Ebrahim Forati,
Dario Rossi,
Bryce Kobrin,
Agustin Di Paolo,
Andrey R. Klots,
Ilya Drozdov,
Vladislav D. Kurilovich,
Andre Petukhov,
Lev B. Ioffe,
Andreas Elben,
Aniket Rath,
Vittorio Vitale,
Benoit Vermersch,
Rajeev Acharya,
Laleh Aghababaie Beni
, et al. (202 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Understanding how interacting particles approach thermal equilibrium is a major challenge of quantum simulators. Unlocking the full potential of such systems toward this goal requires flexible initial state preparation, precise time evolution, and extensive probes for final state characterization. We present a quantum simulator comprising 69 superconducting qubits which supports both universal qua…
▽ More
Understanding how interacting particles approach thermal equilibrium is a major challenge of quantum simulators. Unlocking the full potential of such systems toward this goal requires flexible initial state preparation, precise time evolution, and extensive probes for final state characterization. We present a quantum simulator comprising 69 superconducting qubits which supports both universal quantum gates and high-fidelity analog evolution, with performance beyond the reach of classical simulation in cross-entropy benchmarking experiments. Emulating a two-dimensional (2D) XY quantum magnet, we leverage a wide range of measurement techniques to study quantum states after ramps from an antiferromagnetic initial state. We observe signatures of the classical Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition, as well as strong deviations from Kibble-Zurek scaling predictions attributed to the interplay between quantum and classical coarsening of the correlated domains. This interpretation is corroborated by injecting variable energy density into the initial state, which enables studying the effects of the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) in targeted parts of the eigenspectrum. Finally, we digitally prepare the system in pairwise-entangled dimer states and image the transport of energy and vorticity during thermalization. These results establish the efficacy of superconducting analog-digital quantum processors for preparing states across many-body spectra and unveiling their thermalization dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2024; v1 submitted 27 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Observation of giant two-level systems in a granular superconductor
Authors:
Maximilian Kristen,
Jan Nicolas Voss,
Micha Wildermuth,
Alexander Bilmes,
Jürgen Lisenfeld,
Hannes Rotzinger,
Alexey V. Ustinov
Abstract:
Disordered thin films are a common choice of material for superconducting, high impedance circuits used in quantum information or particle detector physics. A wide selection of materials with different levels of granularity are available, but, despite low microwave losses being reported for some, the high degree of disorder always implies the presence of intrinsic defects. Prominently, quantum cir…
▽ More
Disordered thin films are a common choice of material for superconducting, high impedance circuits used in quantum information or particle detector physics. A wide selection of materials with different levels of granularity are available, but, despite low microwave losses being reported for some, the high degree of disorder always implies the presence of intrinsic defects. Prominently, quantum circuits are prone to interact with two-level systems (TLS), typically originating from solid state defects in the dielectric parts of the circuit, like surface oxides or tunneling barriers. We present an experimental investigation of TLS in granular aluminum thin films under applied mechanical strain and electric fields. The analysis reveals a class of strongly coupled TLS having electric dipole moments up to 30 eA, an order of magnitude larger than dipole moments commonly reported for solid state defects. Notably, these large dipole moments appear more often in films with a higher resistivity. Our observations shed new light on granular superconductors and may have implications for their usage as a quantum circuit material.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2023; v1 submitted 18 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Enhancing the Coherence of Superconducting Quantum Bits with Electric Fields
Authors:
Jürgen Lisenfeld,
Alexander Bilmes,
Alexey V. Ustinov
Abstract:
In the endeavour to make quantum computers a reality, integrated superconducting circuits have become a promising architecture. A major challenge of this approach is decoherence originating from spurious atomic tunneling defects at the interfaces of qubit electrodes, which may resonantly absorb energy from the qubit's oscillating electric field and reduce the qubit's energy relaxation time $T_1$.…
▽ More
In the endeavour to make quantum computers a reality, integrated superconducting circuits have become a promising architecture. A major challenge of this approach is decoherence originating from spurious atomic tunneling defects at the interfaces of qubit electrodes, which may resonantly absorb energy from the qubit's oscillating electric field and reduce the qubit's energy relaxation time $T_1$. Here, we show that qubit coherence can be improved by tuning dominating defects away from the qubit resonance using an applied DC-electric field. We demonstrate a method that optimizes the applied field bias and enhances the 30-minute averaged qubit $T_1$ time by 23\%. We also discuss how local gate electrodes can be implemented in superconducting quantum processors to enable simultaneous in-situ coherence optimization of individual qubits.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2023; v1 submitted 2 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Observation of Time-Crystalline Eigenstate Order on a Quantum Processor
Authors:
Xiao Mi,
Matteo Ippoliti,
Chris Quintana,
Ami Greene,
Zijun Chen,
Jonathan Gross,
Frank Arute,
Kunal Arya,
Juan Atalaya,
Ryan Babbush,
Joseph C. Bardin,
Joao Basso,
Andreas Bengtsson,
Alexander Bilmes,
Alexandre Bourassa,
Leon Brill,
Michael Broughton,
Bob B. Buckley,
David A. Buell,
Brian Burkett,
Nicholas Bushnell,
Benjamin Chiaro,
Roberto Collins,
William Courtney,
Dripto Debroy
, et al. (80 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Quantum many-body systems display rich phase structure in their low-temperature equilibrium states. However, much of nature is not in thermal equilibrium. Remarkably, it was recently predicted that out-of-equilibrium systems can exhibit novel dynamical phases that may otherwise be forbidden by equilibrium thermodynamics, a paradigmatic example being the discrete time crystal (DTC). Concretely, dyn…
▽ More
Quantum many-body systems display rich phase structure in their low-temperature equilibrium states. However, much of nature is not in thermal equilibrium. Remarkably, it was recently predicted that out-of-equilibrium systems can exhibit novel dynamical phases that may otherwise be forbidden by equilibrium thermodynamics, a paradigmatic example being the discrete time crystal (DTC). Concretely, dynamical phases can be defined in periodically driven many-body localized systems via the concept of eigenstate order. In eigenstate-ordered phases, the entire many-body spectrum exhibits quantum correlations and long-range order, with characteristic signatures in late-time dynamics from all initial states. It is, however, challenging to experimentally distinguish such stable phases from transient phenomena, wherein few select states can mask typical behavior. Here we implement a continuous family of tunable CPHASE gates on an array of superconducting qubits to experimentally observe an eigenstate-ordered DTC. We demonstrate the characteristic spatiotemporal response of a DTC for generic initial states. Our work employs a time-reversal protocol that discriminates external decoherence from intrinsic thermalization, and leverages quantum typicality to circumvent the exponential cost of densely sampling the eigenspectrum. In addition, we locate the phase transition out of the DTC with an experimental finite-size analysis. These results establish a scalable approach to study non-equilibrium phases of matter on current quantum processors.
△ Less
Submitted 11 August, 2021; v1 submitted 28 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Realizing topologically ordered states on a quantum processor
Authors:
K. J. Satzinger,
Y. Liu,
A. Smith,
C. Knapp,
M. Newman,
C. Jones,
Z. Chen,
C. Quintana,
X. Mi,
A. Dunsworth,
C. Gidney,
I. Aleiner,
F. Arute,
K. Arya,
J. Atalaya,
R. Babbush,
J. C. Bardin,
R. Barends,
J. Basso,
A. Bengtsson,
A. Bilmes,
M. Broughton,
B. B. Buckley,
D. A. Buell,
B. Burkett
, et al. (73 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The discovery of topological order has revolutionized the understanding of quantum matter in modern physics and provided the theoretical foundation for many quantum error correcting codes. Realizing topologically ordered states has proven to be extremely challenging in both condensed matter and synthetic quantum systems. Here, we prepare the ground state of the toric code Hamiltonian using an effi…
▽ More
The discovery of topological order has revolutionized the understanding of quantum matter in modern physics and provided the theoretical foundation for many quantum error correcting codes. Realizing topologically ordered states has proven to be extremely challenging in both condensed matter and synthetic quantum systems. Here, we prepare the ground state of the toric code Hamiltonian using an efficient quantum circuit on a superconducting quantum processor. We measure a topological entanglement entropy near the expected value of $\ln2$, and simulate anyon interferometry to extract the braiding statistics of the emergent excitations. Furthermore, we investigate key aspects of the surface code, including logical state injection and the decay of the non-local order parameter. Our results demonstrate the potential for quantum processors to provide key insights into topological quantum matter and quantum error correction.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Resolving the positions of defects in superconducting quantum bits
Authors:
Alexander Bilmes,
Anthony Megrant,
Paul Klimov,
Georg Weiss,
John M. Martinis,
Alexey V. Ustinov,
Jürgen Lisenfeld
Abstract:
Solid-state quantum coherent devices are quickly progressing. Superconducting circuits, for instance, have already been used to demonstrate prototype quantum processors comprising a few tens of quantum bits. This development also revealed that a major part of decoherence and energy loss in such devices originates from a bath of parasitic material defects. However, neither the microscopic structure…
▽ More
Solid-state quantum coherent devices are quickly progressing. Superconducting circuits, for instance, have already been used to demonstrate prototype quantum processors comprising a few tens of quantum bits. This development also revealed that a major part of decoherence and energy loss in such devices originates from a bath of parasitic material defects. However, neither the microscopic structure of defects nor the mechanisms by which they emerge during sample fabrication are understood. Here, we present a technique to obtain information on locations of defects relative to the thin film edge of the qubit circuit. Resonance frequencies of defects are tuned by exposing the qubit sample to electric fields generated by electrodes surrounding the chip. By determining the defect's coupling strength to each electrode and comparing it to a simulation of the field distribution, we obtain the probability at which location and at which interface the defect resides. This method is applicable to already existing samples of various qubit types, without further on-chip design changes. It provides a valuable tool for improving the material quality and nano-fabrication procedures towards more coherent quantum circuits.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2020; v1 submitted 19 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Electric field spectroscopy of material defects in transmon qubits
Authors:
Jürgen Lisenfeld,
Alexander Bilmes,
Anthony Megrant,
Rami Barends,
Julian Kelly,
Paul Klimov,
Georg Weiss,
John M. Martinis,
Alexey V. Ustinov
Abstract:
Superconducting integrated circuits have demonstrated a tremendous potential to realize integrated quantum computing processors. However, the downside of the solid-state approach is that superconducting qubits suffer strongly from energy dissipation and environmental fluctuations caused by atomic-scale defects in device materials. Further progress towards upscaled quantum processors will require i…
▽ More
Superconducting integrated circuits have demonstrated a tremendous potential to realize integrated quantum computing processors. However, the downside of the solid-state approach is that superconducting qubits suffer strongly from energy dissipation and environmental fluctuations caused by atomic-scale defects in device materials. Further progress towards upscaled quantum processors will require improvements in device fabrication techniques which need to be guided by novel analysis methods to understand and prevent mechanisms of defect formation. Here, we present a new technique to analyse individual defects in superconducting qubits by tuning them with applied electric fields. This provides a new spectroscopy method to extract the defects' energy distribution, electric dipole moments, and coherence times. Moreover, it enables one to distinguish defects residing in Josephson junction tunnel barriers from those at circuit interfaces. We find that defects at circuit interfaces are responsible for about 60% of the dielectric loss in the investigated transmon qubit sample. About 40% of all detected defects are contained in the tunnel barriers of the large-area parasitic Josephson junctions that occur collaterally in shadow evaporation, and only about 3% are identified as strongly coupled defects which presumably reside in the small-area qubit tunnel junctions. The demonstrated technique provides a valuable tool to assess the decoherence sources related to circuit interfaces and to tunnel junctions that is readily applicable to standard qubit samples.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2019; v1 submitted 20 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Dynamical Decoupling of Quantum Two-Level Systems by Coherent Multiple Landau-Zener Transitions
Authors:
Shlomi Matityahu,
Hartmut Schmidt,
Alexander Bilmes,
Alexander Shnirman,
Georg Weiss,
Alexey V. Ustinov,
Moshe Schechter,
Jürgen Lisenfeld
Abstract:
Increasing and stabilizing the coherence of superconducting quantum circuits and resonators is of utmost importance for various technologies ranging from quantum information processors to highly sensitive detectors of low-temperature radiation in astrophysics. A major source of noise in such devices is a bath of quantum two-level systems (TLSs) with broad distribution of energies, existing in diso…
▽ More
Increasing and stabilizing the coherence of superconducting quantum circuits and resonators is of utmost importance for various technologies ranging from quantum information processors to highly sensitive detectors of low-temperature radiation in astrophysics. A major source of noise in such devices is a bath of quantum two-level systems (TLSs) with broad distribution of energies, existing in disordered dielectrics and on surfaces. Here we study the dielectric loss of superconducting resonators in the presence of a periodic electric bias field, which sweeps near-resonant TLSs in and out of resonance with the resonator, resulting in a periodic pattern of Landau-Zener transitions. We show that at high sweep rates compared to the TLS relaxation rate, the coherent evolution of the TLS over multiple transitions yields a significant reduction in the dielectric loss relative to the intrinsic value. This behavior is observed both in the classical high-power regime and in the quantum single-photon regime, possibly suggesting a viable technique to dynamically decouple TLSs from a qubit.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2019; v1 submitted 19 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Correlating decoherence in transmon qubits: Low frequency noise by single fluctuators
Authors:
Steffen Schlör,
Jürgen Lisenfeld,
Clemens Müller,
Alexander Bilmes,
Andre Schneider,
David P. Pappas,
Alexey V. Ustinov,
Martin Weides
Abstract:
We report on long-term measurements of a highly coherent, non-tunable superconducting transmon qubit, revealing low-frequency burst noise in coherence times and qubit transition frequency. We achieve this through a simultaneous measurement of the qubit's relaxation and dephasing rate as well as its resonance frequency. The analysis of correlations between these parameters yields information about…
▽ More
We report on long-term measurements of a highly coherent, non-tunable superconducting transmon qubit, revealing low-frequency burst noise in coherence times and qubit transition frequency. We achieve this through a simultaneous measurement of the qubit's relaxation and dephasing rate as well as its resonance frequency. The analysis of correlations between these parameters yields information about the microscopic origin of the intrinsic decoherence mechanisms in Josephson qubits. Our results are consistent with a small number of microscopic two-level systems located at the edges of the superconducting film, which is further confirmed by a spectral noise analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2019; v1 submitted 16 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Interplay between kinetic inductance, non-linearity and quasiparticle dynamics in granular aluminum MKIDs
Authors:
Francesco Valenti,
Fábio Henriques,
Gianluigi Catelani,
Nataliya Maleeva,
Lukas Grünhaupt,
Uwe von Lüpke,
Sebastian T. Skacel,
Patrick Winkel,
Alexander Bilmes,
Alexey V. Ustinov,
Johannes Goupy,
Martino Calvo,
Alain Benoît,
Florence Lévy-Bertrand,
Alessandro Monfardini,
Ioan M. Pop
Abstract:
Microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKIDs) are thin film, cryogenic, superconducting resonators. Incident Cooper pair-breaking radiation increases their kinetic inductance, thereby measurably lowering their resonant frequency. For a given resonant frequency, the highest MKID responsivity is obtained by maximizing the kinetic inductance fraction $α$. However, in circuits with $α$ close to unity…
▽ More
Microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKIDs) are thin film, cryogenic, superconducting resonators. Incident Cooper pair-breaking radiation increases their kinetic inductance, thereby measurably lowering their resonant frequency. For a given resonant frequency, the highest MKID responsivity is obtained by maximizing the kinetic inductance fraction $α$. However, in circuits with $α$ close to unity, the low supercurrent density reduces the maximum number of readout photons before bifurcation due to self-Kerr non-linearity, therefore setting a bound for the maximum $α$ before the noise equivalent power (NEP) starts to increase. By fabricating granular aluminum MKIDs with different resistivities, we effectively sweep their kinetic inductance from tens to several hundreds of pH per square. We find a NEP minimum in the range of $25\; \text{aW}/\sqrt{\text{Hz}}$ at $α\approx 0.9$, which results from a tradeoff between the onset of non-linearity and a non-monotonic dependence of the noise spectral density vs. resistivity.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2018; v1 submitted 29 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Transmission-line resonators for the study of individual two-level tunneling systems
Authors:
Jan David Brehm,
Alexander Bilmes,
Georg Weiss,
Alexey V. Ustinov,
Jürgen Lisenfeld
Abstract:
Parasitic two-level tunneling systems (TLS) emerge in amorphous dielectrics and constitute a serious nuisance for various microfabricated devices, where they act as a source of noise and decoherence. Here, we demonstrate a new test bed for the study of TLS in various materials which provides access to properties of individual TLS as well as their ensemble response. We terminate a superconducting t…
▽ More
Parasitic two-level tunneling systems (TLS) emerge in amorphous dielectrics and constitute a serious nuisance for various microfabricated devices, where they act as a source of noise and decoherence. Here, we demonstrate a new test bed for the study of TLS in various materials which provides access to properties of individual TLS as well as their ensemble response. We terminate a superconducting transmission-line resonator with a capacitor that hosts TLS in its dielectric. By tuning TLS via applied mechanical strain, we observe the signatures of individual TLS strongly coupled to the resonator in its transmission characteristics and extract the coupling components of their dipole moments and energy relaxation rates. The strong and well-defined coupling to the TLS bath results in pronounced resonator frequency fluctuations and excess phase noise, through which we can study TLS ensemble effects such as spectral diffusion, and probe theoretical models of TLS interaction.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
An argon ion beam milling process for native $\text{AlO}_\text{x}$ layers enabling coherent superconducting contacts
Authors:
Lukas Grünhaupt,
Uwe von Lüpke,
Daria Gusenkova,
Sebastian T. Skacel,
Nataliya Maleeva,
Steffen Schlör,
Alexander Bilmes,
Hannes Rotzinger,
Alexey V. Ustinov,
Martin Weides,
Ioan M. Pop
Abstract:
We present an argon ion beam milling process to remove the native oxide layer forming on aluminum thin films due to their exposure to atmosphere in between lithographic steps. Our cleaning process is readily integrable with conventional fabrication of Josephson junction quantum circuits. From measurements of the internal quality factors of superconducting microwave resonators with and without cont…
▽ More
We present an argon ion beam milling process to remove the native oxide layer forming on aluminum thin films due to their exposure to atmosphere in between lithographic steps. Our cleaning process is readily integrable with conventional fabrication of Josephson junction quantum circuits. From measurements of the internal quality factors of superconducting microwave resonators with and without contacts, we place an upper bound on the residual resistance of an ion beam milled contact of 50$\,\mathrm{m}Ω\cdot μ\mathrm{m}^2$ at a frequency of 4.5 GHz. Resonators for which only $6\%$ of the total foot-print was exposed to the ion beam milling, in areas of low electric and high magnetic field, showed quality factors above $10^6$ in the single photon regime, and no degradation compared to single layer samples. We believe these results will enable the development of increasingly complex superconducting circuits for quantum information processing.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Rabi noise spectroscopy of individual two-level tunneling defects
Authors:
Shlomi Matityahu,
Jürgen Lisenfeld,
Alexander Bilmes,
Alexander Shnirman,
Georg Weiss,
Alexey V. Ustinov,
Moshe Schechter
Abstract:
Understanding the nature of two-level tunneling defects is important for minimizing their disruptive effects in various nano-devices. By exploiting the resonant coupling of these defects to a superconducting qubit, one can probe and coherently manipulate them individually. In this work we utilize a phase qubit to induce Rabi oscillations of single tunneling defects and measure their dephasing rate…
▽ More
Understanding the nature of two-level tunneling defects is important for minimizing their disruptive effects in various nano-devices. By exploiting the resonant coupling of these defects to a superconducting qubit, one can probe and coherently manipulate them individually. In this work we utilize a phase qubit to induce Rabi oscillations of single tunneling defects and measure their dephasing rates as a function of the defect's asymmetry energy, which is tuned by an applied strain. The dephasing rates scale quadratically with the external strain and are inversely proportional to the Rabi frequency. These results are analyzed and explained within a model of interacting standard defects, in which pure dephasing of coherent high-frequency (GHz) defects is caused by interaction with incoherent low-frequency thermally excited defects.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Electronic Decoherence of Two-Level Systems in a Josephson Junction
Authors:
Alexander Bilmes,
Sebastian Zanker,
Andreas Heimes,
Michael Marthaler,
Gerd Schön,
Georg Weiss,
Alexey V. Ustinov,
Jürgen Lisenfeld
Abstract:
The sensitivity of superconducting qubits allows for spectroscopy and coherence measurements on individual two-level systems present in the disordered tunnel barrier of an $\mathrm{Al/AlO_x/Al}$ Josephson junction. We report experimental evidence for the decoherence of two-level systems by Bogoliubov quasiparticles leaking into the insulating $\mathrm{AlO_x}$ barrier. We control the density of qua…
▽ More
The sensitivity of superconducting qubits allows for spectroscopy and coherence measurements on individual two-level systems present in the disordered tunnel barrier of an $\mathrm{Al/AlO_x/Al}$ Josephson junction. We report experimental evidence for the decoherence of two-level systems by Bogoliubov quasiparticles leaking into the insulating $\mathrm{AlO_x}$ barrier. We control the density of quasiparticles in the junction electrodes either by the sample temperature or by injecting them using an on-chip dc-SQUID driven to its resistive state. The decoherence rates were measured by observing the two-level system's quantum state evolving under application of resonant microwave pulses and were found to increase linearly with quasiparticle density, in agreement with theory. This interaction with electronic states provides a noise and decoherence mechanism that is relevant for various microfabricated devices such as qubits, single-electron transistors, and field-effect transistors. The presented experiments also offer a possibility to determine the location of the probed two-level systems across the tunnel barrier, providing clues about the fabrication step in which they emerge.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2017; v1 submitted 14 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Decoherence spectroscopy with individual two-level tunneling defects
Authors:
Jürgen Lisenfeld,
Alexander Bilmes,
Shlomi Matityahu,
Sebastian Zanker,
Michael Marthaler,
Moshe Schechter,
Gerd Schön,
Alexander Shnirman,
Georg Weiss,
Alexey V. Ustinov
Abstract:
Recent progress with microfabricated quantum devices has revealed that an ubiquitous source of noise originates in tunneling material defects that give rise to a sparse bath of parasitic two-level systems (TLSs). For superconducting qubits, TLSs residing on electrode surfaces and in tunnel junctions account for a major part of decoherence and thus pose a serious roadblock to the realization of sol…
▽ More
Recent progress with microfabricated quantum devices has revealed that an ubiquitous source of noise originates in tunneling material defects that give rise to a sparse bath of parasitic two-level systems (TLSs). For superconducting qubits, TLSs residing on electrode surfaces and in tunnel junctions account for a major part of decoherence and thus pose a serious roadblock to the realization of solid-state quantum processors.
Here, we utilize a superconducting qubit to explore the quantum state evolution of coherently operated TLSs in order to shed new light on their individual properties and environmental interactions. We identify a frequency-dependence of TLS energy relaxation rates that can be explained by a coupling to phononic modes rather than by anticipated mutual TLS interactions. Most investigated TLSs are found to be free of pure dephasing at their energy degeneracy points, around which their Ramsey and spin-echo dephasing rates scale linearly and quadratically with asymmetry energy, respectively. We provide an explanation based on the standard tunneling model, and identify interaction with incoherent low-frequency (thermal) TLSs as the major mechanism of the pure dephasing in coherent high-frequency TLS.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.