-
Molecular dynamics simulations of the defect evolution in tungsten on successive collision cascades
Authors:
Utkarsh Bhardwaj,
Manoj Warrier
Abstract:
Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of successive collision cascades within the same simulation domain were performed using two different inter-atomic potentials (IAP) in tungsten, one EAM based and the other a `quantum accurate' machine learning potential, SNAP. The micro-structural changes are analyzed as a function of displacements per atom (dpa) up-to irradiation dose of 3 dpa. Five simulation…
▽ More
Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of successive collision cascades within the same simulation domain were performed using two different inter-atomic potentials (IAP) in tungsten, one EAM based and the other a `quantum accurate' machine learning potential, SNAP. The micro-structural changes are analyzed as a function of displacements per atom (dpa) up-to irradiation dose of 3 dpa. Five simulations are carried out at primary knock-on atom (PKA) energies of 20 keV and 50 keV for observing stochastic differences in the evolution of damage. Results for the variation of the number of defects, number of defect clusters, their size and morphology distribution are compared for the two energies and two IAPs, up-to irradiation doses of 1-3 dpa.
It is seen that for a given IAP, the number density of defect clusters as a function of dpa does not depend on the energy of the PKA used in the simulations implying that, like dpa, it could be a good measure of material property changes in irradiated materials. In contrast, the defect sizes depend strongly on the energy of the PKA. It is also seen that the micro-structure resulting from the EAM potential was mostly composed of <1 1 1> and <1 0 0> dislocations, while that from the SNAP potential was mostly composed of small, sessile, C15 ring like structures with a smattering of smaller <1 1 1> dislocations and very few <1 0 0> dislocations. The significant disagreement between the two IAPs with regard to defect morphology can be used for validation by comparing against the experimental results of dislocation types, density and size distributions.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Defect Cluster Morphology in W from Collision Cascades: Results Comparing Five Inter-atomic potentials
Authors:
M. Warrier,
U. Bhardwaj
Abstract:
The size and morphology of defect clusters formed during primary damage play an important part in the subsequent evolution of the micro-structure of irradiated materials. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of collision cascades in W have been carried out using five interatomic potentials (IAP) including the quantum accurate machine learned (ML) spectral neighbor analysis potential (WSNAP), the ML…
▽ More
The size and morphology of defect clusters formed during primary damage play an important part in the subsequent evolution of the micro-structure of irradiated materials. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of collision cascades in W have been carried out using five interatomic potentials (IAP) including the quantum accurate machine learned (ML) spectral neighbor analysis potential (WSNAP), the ML based tabGAP potential and three embedded atom method (EAM) based potentials. A total of 3500 MD simulations with the primary knock-on atoms (PKA) having energys 5, 10, 20, 50, 75, 100 and 150 keV were carried out. The PKA are launched in hundred random directions at each of the PKA energies to obtain statistically valid results. Analysis using CSaransh, a web based tool to analyze a large collision cascade database, was carried out to obtain the number of defects (individual and in clusters), the defect cluster morphologies, the defect cluster size distributions and the number of sub-cascades formed. It is seen that <1 1 1> clusters dominate across all the inter-atomic potentials (IAP), except for the WSNAP potential. The WSNAP potential shows significantly higher number of C-15 like rings across all PKA energies. The WSNAP potential also shows a higher fraction of in-cluster vacancies. It is also seen that the stiffness and range of IAP do not affect the number of defects, defect clustering or vacancy clusters, but shows a tendency to form more sub-cascades for PKA energies less than 60 keV.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Identifying Subcascades From The Primary Damage State Of Collision Cascades
Authors:
Utkarsh Bhardwaj,
Manoj Warrier
Abstract:
The morphology of a collision cascade is an important aspect in understanding the formation of defects and their distribution. While the number of subcascades is an essential parameter to describe the cascade morphology, the methods to compute this parameter are limited. We present a method to compute the number of subcascades from the primary damage state of the collision cascade. Existing method…
▽ More
The morphology of a collision cascade is an important aspect in understanding the formation of defects and their distribution. While the number of subcascades is an essential parameter to describe the cascade morphology, the methods to compute this parameter are limited. We present a method to compute the number of subcascades from the primary damage state of the collision cascade. Existing methods analyse peak damage state or the end of ballistic phase to compute the number of subcascades which is not always available in collision cascade databases. We use density based clustering algorithm from unsupervised machine learning domain to identify the subcascades from the primary damage state. To validate the results of our method we first carry out a parameter sensitivity study of the existing algorithms. The study shows that the results are sensitive to input parameters and the choice of the time-frame analyzed. On a database of 100 collision cascades in W, we show that the method we propose, which analyzes primary damage state to predict number of subcascades, is in good agreement with the existing method that works on the peak state. We also show that the number of subcascades found with different parameters can be used to classify and group together the cascades that have similar time-evolution and fragmentation.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Stability of <100> Dislocations formed in W Collision Cascades
Authors:
Utkarsh Bhardwaj,
Andread E. Sand,
Manoj Warrier
Abstract:
Experiments and simulations both have verified the presence of <100> dislocations in irradiated W. It is essential to know the properties and behavior of these defects to study the evolution of microstructures at higher scales. We study the thermal stability and transition mechanism of various <100> dislocations formed in a molecular dynamics (MD) database of 230 collision cascades using three dif…
▽ More
Experiments and simulations both have verified the presence of <100> dislocations in irradiated W. It is essential to know the properties and behavior of these defects to study the evolution of microstructures at higher scales. We study the thermal stability and transition mechanism of various <100> dislocations formed in a molecular dynamics (MD) database of 230 collision cascades using three different interatomic potentials. The energy of transition of <100> dislocations to more stable <111> dislocations is calculated for various defects that transition within the 100 nanosecond time scale readily accessible to MD. The stability of <100> dislocations increases with size, but the trend is not strict. The reasons for irregularities are the aspects of internal configuration such as (i) the arrangement of <100> directed crowdions within the defect, (ii) the presence and arrangement of non-<100> crowdions on the fringes of the defect. We show the typical pathways of transitions and discuss the sources of instability in the defect configurations. We also discuss the similarities and differences in stability found across different interatomic potentials. Understanding transition mechanisms and internal morphology gives insights into the stability of <100> dislocations, useful in higher scale models such as Kinetic Monte Carlo (KMC).
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2022; v1 submitted 31 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Comparison of SIA Defect Morphologies from Different Interatomic Potentials for Collision Cascades in W
Authors:
Utkarsh Bhardwaj,
Andrea E. Sand,
Manoj Warrier
Abstract:
The morphology of defects formed in collision cascades is an essential aspect of the subsequent evolution of the microstructure. The morphological composition of a defect decides its stability, interaction, and migration properties. We compare the defect morphologies in the primary radiation damage caused by high energy collision cascades simulated using three different interatomic potentials in W…
▽ More
The morphology of defects formed in collision cascades is an essential aspect of the subsequent evolution of the microstructure. The morphological composition of a defect decides its stability, interaction, and migration properties. We compare the defect morphologies in the primary radiation damage caused by high energy collision cascades simulated using three different interatomic potentials in W. An automated method to identify morphologies of defects is used. While most defects form 1/2\3 dislocation loops, other specific morphologies include \1 dislocation loops, multiple loops clustered together, rings corresponding to C15 configuration and its constituent structures, and a combination of rings and dislocations. The analysis quantifies the distribution of defects among different morphologies and the size distribution of each morphology. We show that the disagreement between predictions of the different potentials regarding defect morphology is much stronger than the differences in predicted defect numbers.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2021; v1 submitted 30 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Graph Theory Based Approach to Characterize Self Interstitial Defect Morphology
Authors:
Utkarsh Bhardwaj,
Andrea E. Sand,
Manoj Warrier
Abstract:
The defect morphology is an essential aspect of the evolution of crystals' microstructure and its response to stress. Existing methods either only report defect concentration or characterize only some of the defect morphologies. The need for an efficient and comprehensive algorithm to study defects is becoming more evident with the increase in the amount of simulation data and improvements in data…
▽ More
The defect morphology is an essential aspect of the evolution of crystals' microstructure and its response to stress. Existing methods either only report defect concentration or characterize only some of the defect morphologies. The need for an efficient and comprehensive algorithm to study defects is becoming more evident with the increase in the amount of simulation data and improvements in data-driven algorithms.
We present a method to characterize a defect's morphology precisely by reducing the problem into graph theoretical concepts of finding connected components and cycles. The algorithm can identify the different homogenous components within a defect cluster having mixed morphology. We apply the method to classify morphologies of over a thousand point defect clusters formed in high energy W collision cascades. We highlight our method's comparative advantage for its completeness, computational speed, and quantitative details.
△ Less
Submitted 24 December, 2020; v1 submitted 29 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
