-
Experimental exploration of geometric cohesion and solid fraction in columns of highly non-convex Platonic polypods
Authors:
David Aponte,
Jonathan Barés,
Mathieu Renouf,
Émilien Azéma,
and Nicolas Estrada
Abstract:
In this study, we investigate the stability and solid fraction of columns comprised of highly non-convex particles. These particles are constructed by extruding arms onto the faces of Platonic solids, a configuration we term \emph{Platonic polypods}. We explore the emergence and disappearance of solid-like behavior in the absence of adhesive forces between the particles, referred to as \emph{geome…
▽ More
In this study, we investigate the stability and solid fraction of columns comprised of highly non-convex particles. These particles are constructed by extruding arms onto the faces of Platonic solids, a configuration we term \emph{Platonic polypods}. We explore the emergence and disappearance of solid-like behavior in the absence of adhesive forces between the particles, referred to as \emph{geometric cohesion}. This investigation is conducted by varying the number of arms of the particles and the thickness of these arms. To accomplish this, columns are assembled by depositing particles within a cylindrical container, followed by the removal of the container to evaluate the stability of the resulting structures. Experiments were carried out using three distinct materials to assess the influence of the friction coefficient between the grains. Our findings reveal that certain granular systems exhibit geometric cohesion, depending on their geometrical and contact properties. Furthermore, we analyze the initial solid fraction of the columns, demonstrating that these arrangements can achieve stability even at highly loose states, which contrasts with traditional granular materials.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Particle scale anisotropy controls bulk properties in sheared granular materials
Authors:
Carmen L. Lee,
Ephraim Bililign,
Emilien Azéma,
Karen E. Daniels
Abstract:
The bulk dynamics of dense granular materials arise through a combination of particle-scale and mesoscale effects. Theoretical and numerical studies have shown that collective effects are created by particle-scale anisotropic structures such as grain connectivity (fabric), force transmission, and frictional mobilization, all of which influence bulk properties like bulk friction and the stress tens…
▽ More
The bulk dynamics of dense granular materials arise through a combination of particle-scale and mesoscale effects. Theoretical and numerical studies have shown that collective effects are created by particle-scale anisotropic structures such as grain connectivity (fabric), force transmission, and frictional mobilization, all of which influence bulk properties like bulk friction and the stress tensor through the Stress-Force-Fabric (SFF) relationship. To date, establishing the relevance of these effects to laboratory systems has remained elusive due to the challenge of measuring both normal and frictional contact forces at the particle scale. In this study, we perform experiments on a sheared photoelastic granular system in an quasi-2D annular (Couette) cell. During these experiments, we measure particle locations, contacts, and normal and frictional forces vectors during loading. We reconstruct the angular distributions of the contact and force vectors, and extract the corresponding emergent anisotropies for each of these metrics. Finally, we show that the SFF relation quantitatively predicts the relationship between particle scale anisotropies, the stress tensor components, and the bulk friction coefficient, capturing even transient behaviors. As such, this method shows promise for application to other dense particulate systems where fabric anisotropy can provide a useful measure of bulk friction.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Steady Granular Flow in a Rotating Drum: Universal description of stress, velocity and packing fraction profiles covering grain shape effects from convex to very concave
Authors:
Weiyi Wang,
Jonathan Barés,
Mathieu Renouf,
Emilien Azéma
Abstract:
The flow behavior of granular matter is significantly influenced by the shape of constituent particles. This effect is particularly pronounced for very concave particles, which exhibit unique flow characteristics such as higher porosity and sharper phase transitions between jamming and unjamming states. Despite the richness and ubiquitousness of these systems, our understanding of their intricate…
▽ More
The flow behavior of granular matter is significantly influenced by the shape of constituent particles. This effect is particularly pronounced for very concave particles, which exhibit unique flow characteristics such as higher porosity and sharper phase transitions between jamming and unjamming states. Despite the richness and ubiquitousness of these systems, our understanding of their intricate flow behavior and the local mechanisms driving these behaviors remains incomplete. In this work, we investigate the effect of particle shape, ranging from spherical to highly concave, on steady flows in a rotating drum - a system that facilitates a continuous phase transition from a jamming state at greater depths to an unjamming state at shallower regions. We develop an analytical model to elucidate granular behavior within the rotating drum: (i) Firstly, by decomposing the shear stress, we reconcile the discrepancy between simulation data and theoretical predictions, establishing a relationship with the angle of repose. (ii)Secondly, we extend the generalized Bagnold scaling , coupled with a non-local fluidity relation based on packing fraction, providing a framework for a correlation between shear stress, shear rate, and packing fraction. Additionally, we introduce a characteristic length to quantify the influence of particle shape and drum speed. This analytical model offers explicit functional forms for physical quantity profiles, which are validated experimentally in a thin rotating drum and numerically in a two-dimensional rotating drum. Our results demonstrate that this model accurately describes the change of velocity due to the phase transition of granular flow within a rotating drum. Moreover, for different shapes of particle and drum speeds, the characteristic length captures the interplay between shear stress, shear rate, and the variation of packing fraction.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Compacting an assembly of soft balls far beyond the jammed state: insights from 3D imaging
Authors:
Jonathan Barés,
Manuel Cárdenas-Barrantes,
Gustavo Pinzón,
Edward andó,
Mathieu Renouf,
Gioacchino Viggiani,
Emilien Azéma
Abstract:
Very soft grain assemblies have unique shape-changing capabilities that allow them to be compressed far beyond the rigid jammed state by filling void spaces more effectively. However, accurately following the formation of these systems by monitoring the creation of new contacts, the changes in grain shape, and measuring grain-scale stresses is challenging. We developed an experimental method overt…
▽ More
Very soft grain assemblies have unique shape-changing capabilities that allow them to be compressed far beyond the rigid jammed state by filling void spaces more effectively. However, accurately following the formation of these systems by monitoring the creation of new contacts, the changes in grain shape, and measuring grain-scale stresses is challenging. We developed an experimental method overtaking these challenges and connecting their microscale behavior to their macroscopic response. By tracking the local strain energy during compression, we reveal a transition from granular-like to continuous-like material. Mean contact geometry is shown to vary linearly with the packing fraction, which is supported by a mean field approximation. We also validate a theoretical framework which describes the compaction from a local view. Our experimental framework provides insights into the granular micro-mechanisms and opens new perspectives for rheological analysis of highly deformable grain assemblies in various fields ranging from biology to engineering.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Softer than soft: diving into squishy granular matter
Authors:
Jonathan Barés,
Manuel Cárdenas-Barrantes,
David Cantor,
Mathieu Renouf,
Émilien Azéma
Abstract:
Softer than soft, squishy granular matter is composed of grains capable of significantly changing their shape (typically larger than 10% of deformation) without tearing or breaking. Because of the difficulty to test these materials experimentally and numerically, such a family of discrete systems remains largely ignored in the granular matter physics field despite being commonly found in nature an…
▽ More
Softer than soft, squishy granular matter is composed of grains capable of significantly changing their shape (typically larger than 10% of deformation) without tearing or breaking. Because of the difficulty to test these materials experimentally and numerically, such a family of discrete systems remains largely ignored in the granular matter physics field despite being commonly found in nature and industry. Either from a numerical, experimental, or analytical point of view, the study of highly deformable granular matter involves several challenges covering, for instance: ($i$) the need to include a large diversity of grain rheology, ($ii$) the need to consider \dc{large material} deformations, and ($iii$) the analysis upon the effects the large body distortion has on the global scale. In this article, we propose a thorough definition of these squishy granular systems, and we summarize the upcoming challenges in their study.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Experimental validation of a micromechanically-based compaction law for soft/hard grain mixtures
Authors:
Manuel Cárdenas-Barrantes,
Jonathan Barés,
Mathieu Renouf,
Émilien Azéma
Abstract:
In this letter, we report on an experimental study which analyzes the compressive behavior of 2D bidisperse granular assemblies made of soft (hyperelastic) and hard grains in varying proportions ($κ$). By means of a recently developed uniaxial compression set-up \cite{vu2019_pre} and using advanced Digital Image Correlation (DIC) method, we follow, beyond the jamming point, the evolution of the ma…
▽ More
In this letter, we report on an experimental study which analyzes the compressive behavior of 2D bidisperse granular assemblies made of soft (hyperelastic) and hard grains in varying proportions ($κ$). By means of a recently developed uniaxial compression set-up \cite{vu2019_pre} and using advanced Digital Image Correlation (DIC) method, we follow, beyond the jamming point, the evolution of the main mechanical observables, from the global scale down to the strain field inside each deformable grain. First, we experimentally validate and extend to the uni-axial case a recently proposed micro-mechanical compaction model linking the evolution of the applied pressure $P$ to the packing fraction $φ$ \cite{cantor2020_prl}. Second, we reveal two different linear regimes depending on whether the system is above or below a cross-over strain unraveling a transition from a discrete to a continuous-like system. Third, the evolution of these linear laws are found to vary linearly with $κ$, up to a saturation point around $κ=80$\% of hard particles. These results provide a comprehensive experimental and theoretical framework that can now be extended to a more general class of polydisperse soft granular systems.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Three-dimensional compaction of soft granular packings
Authors:
Manuel Cárdenas-Barrantes,
David Cantor,
Jonathan Barés,
Mathieu Renouf,
Emilien Azéma
Abstract:
This paper analyzes the compaction behavior of assemblies composed of soft (elastic) spherical particles beyond the jammed state, using three-dimensional non-smooth contact dynamic simulations. The assemblies of particles are characterized using the evolution of the packing fraction, the coordination number, and the von Misses stress distribution within the particles as the confining stress increa…
▽ More
This paper analyzes the compaction behavior of assemblies composed of soft (elastic) spherical particles beyond the jammed state, using three-dimensional non-smooth contact dynamic simulations. The assemblies of particles are characterized using the evolution of the packing fraction, the coordination number, and the von Misses stress distribution within the particles as the confining stress increases. The packing fraction increases and tends toward a maximum value close to $1$, and the mean coordination number increases as a square root of the packing fraction. As the confining stress increases, a transition is observed from a granular-like material with exponential tails of the shear stress distributions to a continuous-like material characterized by Gaussian-like distributions of the shear stresses. We develop an equation that describes the evolution of the packing fraction as a function of the applied pressure. This equation, based on the micromechanical expression of the granular stress tensor, the limit of the Hertz contact law for small deformation, and the power-law relation between the packing fraction and the coordination of the particles, provides good predictions from the jamming point up to very high densities without the need of tuning any parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Strength and energy consumption of inherently anisotropic rocks at failure
Authors:
David Cantor,
Carlos Ovalle,
Emilien Azéma
Abstract:
Using a discrete-element approach and a bonding interaction law, we model and test crushable inherently anisotropic structures reminiscent of the layering found in sedimentary and metamorphic rocks. By systematically modifying the level of inherent anisotropy, we characterize the evolution of the failure strength of circular rock samples discretized using a modified Voronoi tesselation under diame…
▽ More
Using a discrete-element approach and a bonding interaction law, we model and test crushable inherently anisotropic structures reminiscent of the layering found in sedimentary and metamorphic rocks. By systematically modifying the level of inherent anisotropy, we characterize the evolution of the failure strength of circular rock samples discretized using a modified Voronoi tesselation under diametral point loading at different orientations relative to the sample's layers. We characterize the failure strength, which can dramatically increase as the loading becomes orthogonal to the rock layers. We also describe the evolution of the macroscopic failure modes as a function of the loading orientation and the energy consumption at fissuring. Our simulation strategy let us conclude that the length of bonds between Voronoi cells controls the energy being consumed in fissuring the rock sample, although failure modes and strength are considerably changing. We end up this work showing that the microstructure is largely afected by the level of inherent anisotropy and loading orientation.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Bulk modulus of soft particle assemblies under compression
Authors:
David Cantor,
Manuel Cárdenas-Barrantes,
Itthichai Preechawuttipong,
Mathieu Renouf,
Emilien Azéma
Abstract:
Using a numerical approach based on the coupling of the discrete and finite element methods, we explore the variation of the bulk modulus K of soft particle assemblies undergoing isotropic compression. As the assemblies densify under pressure-controlled boundary conditions, we show that the non-linearities of K rapidly deviate from predictions standing on a small-strain framework or the Equivalent…
▽ More
Using a numerical approach based on the coupling of the discrete and finite element methods, we explore the variation of the bulk modulus K of soft particle assemblies undergoing isotropic compression. As the assemblies densify under pressure-controlled boundary conditions, we show that the non-linearities of K rapidly deviate from predictions standing on a small-strain framework or the Equivalent Medium Theory (EMT). Using the granular stress tensor and extracting the bulk properties of single representative grains under compression, we propose a model to predict the evolution of K as a function of the sample's solid fraction and a reference state as the applied pressure P tends to zero. The model closely reproduces the trends observed in our numerical experiments confirming the behavior scalability of soft particle assemblies from the individual particle scale. Finally, we present the effect of the interparticle friction on K's evolution and how our model easily adapts to such a mechanical constraint.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Highly strained mixtures of bidimensional soft and rigid grains: an experimental approach from the local scale
Authors:
Jonathan Barés,
Manuel Cárdenas-Barrantes,
David Cantor,
Émilien Azéma,
Mathieu Renouf
Abstract:
Granular systems are not always homogeneous and can be composed of grains with very different mechanical properties. To improve our understanding of the behavior of real granular systems, in this experimental study, we compress 2D bidisperse systems made of both soft and rigid grains. By means of a recently developed experimental set-up, \md{from the measurement of the displacement field we can} f…
▽ More
Granular systems are not always homogeneous and can be composed of grains with very different mechanical properties. To improve our understanding of the behavior of real granular systems, in this experimental study, we compress 2D bidisperse systems made of both soft and rigid grains. By means of a recently developed experimental set-up, \md{from the measurement of the displacement field we can} follow all the mechanical observables of this granular medium from the inside of each particle up-to-the whole system scale. We \md{are able to} detect the jamming transition from these observables and study their evolution deep in the jammed state for packing fractions as high as $0.915$. We show the uniqueness of the behavior of such a system, \md{in which way} it is similar to purely soft or rigid systems and how it is different from them. This study constitutes the first step toward a better understanding of the mechanical behavior of granular materials that are polydisperse in terms of grain rheology.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Microstructural origins of crushing strength for inherently anisotropic brittle materials
Authors:
David Cantor,
Carlos Ovalle,
Emilien Azéma
Abstract:
We study the crushing strength of brittle materials whose internal structure (e.g., mineral particles or graining) presents a layered arrangement reminiscent of sedimentary and metamorphic rocks. Taking a discrete-element approach, we probe the failure strength of circular-shaped samples intended to reproduce specific mineral configurations. To do so, assemblies of cells, products of a modified Vo…
▽ More
We study the crushing strength of brittle materials whose internal structure (e.g., mineral particles or graining) presents a layered arrangement reminiscent of sedimentary and metamorphic rocks. Taking a discrete-element approach, we probe the failure strength of circular-shaped samples intended to reproduce specific mineral configurations. To do so, assemblies of cells, products of a modified Voronoi tessellation, are joined in mechanically-stable layerings using a bonding law. The cells' shape distribution allows us to set a level of inherent anisotropy to the material. Using a diametral point loading, and systematically changing the loading orientation with respect to the cells' configuration, we characterize the failure strength of increasingly anisotropic structures. This approach ends up reproducing experimental observations and lets us quantify the statistical variability of strength, the consumption of the fragmentation energy, and the induced anisotropies linked to the cell's geometry and force transmission in the samples. Based on a fine description of geometrical and mechanical properties at the onset of failure, we develop a micromechanical breakdown of the crushing strength variability using an analytical decomposition of the stress tensor and the geometrical and force anisotropies. We can conclude that the origins of failure strength in anisotropic layered media rely on compensations of geometrical and mechanical anisotropies, as well as an increasing average radial force between minerals indistinctive of tensile or compressive components.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Micromechanical description of the compaction of soft pentagon assemblies
Authors:
Manuel Cárdenas-Barrantes,
David Cantor,
Jonathan Barés,
Mathieu Renouf,
Emilien Azéma
Abstract:
We analyze the isotropic compaction of assemblies composed of soft pentagons interacting through classical Coulomb friction via numerical simulations. The effect of the initial particle shape is discussed by comparing packings of pentagons with packings of soft circular particles. We characterize the evolution of the packing fraction, the elastic modulus, and the microstructure (particle rearrange…
▽ More
We analyze the isotropic compaction of assemblies composed of soft pentagons interacting through classical Coulomb friction via numerical simulations. The effect of the initial particle shape is discussed by comparing packings of pentagons with packings of soft circular particles. We characterize the evolution of the packing fraction, the elastic modulus, and the microstructure (particle rearrangement, connectivity, contact force and particle stress distributions) as a function of the applied stresses. Both systems behave similarly; the packing fraction increases and tends asymptotically to a maximum value $φ_{max}$, where the bulk modulus diverges. At the microscopic scale we show that particle rearrangements occur even beyond the jammed state, the mean coordination increases as a square root of the packing fraction and, the force and stress distributions become more homogeneous as the packing fraction increases. Soft pentagons present larger particle rearrangements than circular ones, and such behavior decreases proportionally to the friction. Interestingly, the friction between particles also contributes to a better homogenization of the contact force network in both systems. From the expression of the granular stress tensor, we develop a model that describes the compaction behavior as a function of the applied pressure, the Young modulus and the initial shape of the particles. This model, settled on the joint evolution of the particle connectivity and the contact stress, provides outstanding predictions from the jamming point up to very high densities.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Compaction of mixtures of rigid and highly deformable particles: a micro-mechanical model
Authors:
Manuel Cárdenas-Barrantes,
David Cantor,
Jonathan Barés,
Mathieu Renouf,
Emilien Azéma
Abstract:
We analyze the isotropic compaction of mixtures composed of rigid and deformable incompressible particles by the non-smooth contact dynamics approach (NSCD). The deformable bodies are simulated using a hyper-elastic neo-Hookean constitutive law by means of classical finite elements. For mixtures that varied from totally rigid to totally deformable particles, we characterize the evolution of the pa…
▽ More
We analyze the isotropic compaction of mixtures composed of rigid and deformable incompressible particles by the non-smooth contact dynamics approach (NSCD). The deformable bodies are simulated using a hyper-elastic neo-Hookean constitutive law by means of classical finite elements. For mixtures that varied from totally rigid to totally deformable particles, we characterize the evolution of the packing fraction, the elastic modulus, and the connectivity as a function of the applied stresses when varying inter-particle coefficient of friction. We show first that the packing fraction increases and tends asymptotically to a maximum value $φ_{max}$, which depends on both the mixture ratio and the inter-particle friction. The bulk modulus is also shown to increase with the packing fraction and to diverges as it approaches $φ_{max}$. From the micro-mechanical expression of the granular stress tensor, we develop a model to describe the compaction behavior as a function of the applied pressure, the Young modulus of the deformable particles, and the mixture ratio. A bulk equation is also derived from the compaction equation. This model lays on the characterization of a single deformable particle under compression together with a power-law relation between connectivity and packing fraction. This compaction model, set by well-defined physical quantities, results in outstanding predictions from the jamming point up to very high densities and allows us to give a direct prediction of $φ_{max}$ as a function of both the mixture ratio and the friction coefficient.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Particle shape dependence in 2D granular media
Authors:
B. Saint-Cyr,
K. Szarf,
C. Voivret,
E. Azéma,
V. Richefeu,
J. -Y. Delenne,
G. Combe,
C. Nouguier-Lehon,
P. Villard,
P. Sornay,
M. Chaze,
F. Radjaï
Abstract:
Particle shape is a key to the space-filling and strength properties of granular matter. We consider a shape parameter $η$ describing the degree of distortion from a perfectly spherical shape. Encompassing most specific shape characteristics such as elongation, angularity and nonconvexity, $η$ is a low-order but generic parameter that we used in a numerical benchmark test for a systematic investig…
▽ More
Particle shape is a key to the space-filling and strength properties of granular matter. We consider a shape parameter $η$ describing the degree of distortion from a perfectly spherical shape. Encompassing most specific shape characteristics such as elongation, angularity and nonconvexity, $η$ is a low-order but generic parameter that we used in a numerical benchmark test for a systematic investigation of shape-dependence in sheared granular packings composed of particles of different shapes. We find that the shear strength is an increasing function of $η$ with nearly the same trend for all shapes, the differences appearing thus to be of second order compared to $η$. We also observe a nontrivial behavior of packing fraction which, for all our simulated shapes, increases with $η$ from the random close packing fraction for disks, reaches a peak considerably higher than that for disks, and subsequently declines as $η$ is further increased. These findings suggest that a low-order description of particle shape accounts for the principal trends of packing fraction and shear strength. Hence, the effect of second-order shape parameters may be investigated by considering different shapes at the same level of $η$.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Identification of rolling resistance as a shape parameter in sheared granular media
Authors:
Nicolas Estrada,
Émilien Azema,
Farhang Radjaï,
Alfredo Taboada
Abstract:
Using contact dynamics simulations, we compare the effect of rolling resistance at the contacts in granular systems composed of disks with the effect of angularity in granular systems composed of regular polygonal particles. In simple shear conditions, we consider four aspects of the mechanical behavior of these systems in the steady state: shear strength, solid fraction, force and fabric anisotro…
▽ More
Using contact dynamics simulations, we compare the effect of rolling resistance at the contacts in granular systems composed of disks with the effect of angularity in granular systems composed of regular polygonal particles. In simple shear conditions, we consider four aspects of the mechanical behavior of these systems in the steady state: shear strength, solid fraction, force and fabric anisotropies, and probability distribution of contact forces. Our main finding is that, based on the energy dissipation associated with relative rotation between two particles in contact, the effect of rolling resistance can explicitly be identified with that of the number of sides in a regular polygonal particle. This finding supports the use of rolling resistance as a shape parameter accounting for particle angularity and shows unambiguously that one of the main influencing factors behind the mechanical behavior of granular systems composed of noncircular particles is the partial hindrance of rotations as a result of angular particle shape.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2011;
originally announced May 2011.
-
Stress-strain behavior and geometrical properties of packings of elongated particles
Authors:
Émilien Azema,
Farhang Radjaï
Abstract:
We present a numerical analysis of the effect of particle elongation on the quasistatic behavior of sheared granular media by means of the Contact Dynamics method. The particle shapes are rounded-cap rectangles characterized by their elongation. The macroscopic and microstructural properties of several packings subjected to biaxial compression are analyzed as a function of particle elongation. We…
▽ More
We present a numerical analysis of the effect of particle elongation on the quasistatic behavior of sheared granular media by means of the Contact Dynamics method. The particle shapes are rounded-cap rectangles characterized by their elongation. The macroscopic and microstructural properties of several packings subjected to biaxial compression are analyzed as a function of particle elongation. We find that the shear strength is an increasing linear function of elongation. Performing an additive decomposition of the stress tensor based on a harmonic approximation of the angular dependence of branch vectors, contact normals and forces, we show that the increasing mobilization of friction force and the associated anisotropy are key effects of particle elongation. These effects are correlated with partial nematic ordering of the particles which tend to be oriented perpendicular to the major principal stress direction and form side-to-side contacts. However, the force transmission is found to be mainly guided by cap-to-side contacts, which represent the largest fraction of contacts for the most elongated particles. Another interesting finding is that, in contrast to shear strength, the solid fraction first increases with particle elongation, but declines as the particles become more elongated. It is also remarkable that the coordination number does not follow this trend so that the packings of more elongated particles are looser but more strongly connected.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2010;
originally announced April 2010.
