-
Chandra and HST Snapshots of Fossil System Progenitors
Authors:
Lucas E. Johnson,
Jimmy A. Irwin,
Raymond E. White III,
Ka-Wah Wong,
Renato A. Dupke
Abstract:
The search for the progenitors to today's fossil galaxy systems has been restricted to N-body simulations until recently, where 12 fossil progenitors were identified in the CASSOWARY catalog of strong lensing systems. All 12 systems lie in the predicted redshift range for finding fossils in mid brightest group galaxy (BGG) assembly, and all show complex merging environments at their centers. None…
▽ More
The search for the progenitors to today's fossil galaxy systems has been restricted to N-body simulations until recently, where 12 fossil progenitors were identified in the CASSOWARY catalog of strong lensing systems. All 12 systems lie in the predicted redshift range for finding fossils in mid brightest group galaxy (BGG) assembly, and all show complex merging environments at their centers. None of these progenitors had archival X-ray data, and many were lacking high resolution optical data making precision photometry extremely difficult. Here, we present Chandra and Hubble Space Telescope (HST) snapshots of eight of these strong lensing fossil progenitors at varying stages of evolution. We find that our lensing progenitors exhibit higher than expected X-ray luminosities and temperatures consistent with previously observed non-lensing fossil systems. More precise galaxy luminosity functions are generated which strengthen past claims that progenitors are the transition phase between non-fossils and fossils. We also find evidence suggesting that the majority of differences between fossils and non-fossils lie in their BGGs and that fossil systems may themselves be a phase of galaxy system evolution and not a separate class of object.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Using Strong Gravitational Lensing to Identify Fossil Group Progenitors
Authors:
Lucas E. Johnson,
Jimmy A. Irwin,
Raymond E. White III,
Ka-Wah Wong,
W. Peter Maksym,
Renato A. Dupke,
Eric D. Miller,
Eleazar R. Carrasco
Abstract:
Fossil galaxy systems are classically thought to be the end result of galaxy group/cluster evolution, as galaxies experiencing dynamical friction sink to the center of the group potential and merge into a single, giant elliptical that dominates the rest of the members in both mass and luminosity. Most fossil systems discovered lie within $z < 0.2$, which leads to the question: what were these syst…
▽ More
Fossil galaxy systems are classically thought to be the end result of galaxy group/cluster evolution, as galaxies experiencing dynamical friction sink to the center of the group potential and merge into a single, giant elliptical that dominates the rest of the members in both mass and luminosity. Most fossil systems discovered lie within $z < 0.2$, which leads to the question: what were these systems' progenitors? Such progenitors are expected to have imminent or ongoing major merging near the brightest group galaxy (BGG) that, when concluded, will meet the fossil criteria within the look back time. Since strong gravitational lensing preferentially selects groups merging along the line of sight, or systems with a high mass concentration like fossil systems, we searched the CASSOWARY survey of strong lensing events with the goal of determining if lensing systems have any predisposition to being fossil systems or progenitors. We find that $\sim$13% of lensing groups are identified as traditional fossils while only $\sim$3% of non-lensing control groups are. We also find that $\sim$23% of lensing systems are traditional fossil progenitors compared to $\sim$17% for the control sample. Our findings show that strong lensing systems are more likely to be fossil/pre-fossil systems than comparable non-lensing systems. Cumulative galaxy luminosity functions of the lensing and non-lensing groups also indicate a possible, fundamental difference between strong lensing and non-lensing systems' galaxy populations with lensing systems housing a greater number of bright galaxies even in the outskirts of groups.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
The Cheshire Cat Gravitational Lens: The Formation of a Massive Fossil Group
Authors:
Jimmy A. Irwin,
Renato Dupke,
Eleazar R. Carrasco,
W. Peter Maksym,
Lucas Johnson,
Raymond E. White III
Abstract:
The Cheshire Cat is a relatively poor group of galaxies dominated by two luminous elliptical galaxies surrounded by at least four arcs from gravitationally lensed background galaxies that give the system a humorous appearance. Our combined optical/X-ray study of this system reveals that it is experiencing a line of sight merger between two groups with a roughly equal mass ratio with a relative vel…
▽ More
The Cheshire Cat is a relatively poor group of galaxies dominated by two luminous elliptical galaxies surrounded by at least four arcs from gravitationally lensed background galaxies that give the system a humorous appearance. Our combined optical/X-ray study of this system reveals that it is experiencing a line of sight merger between two groups with a roughly equal mass ratio with a relative velocity of ~1350 km/s. One group was most likely a low-mass fossil group, while the other group would have almost fit the classical definition of a fossil group. The collision manifests itself in a bimodal galaxy velocity distribution, an elevated central X-ray temperature and luminosity indicative of a shock, and gravitational arc centers that do not coincide with either large elliptical galaxy. One of the luminous elliptical galaxies has a double nucleus embedded off-center in the stellar halo. The luminous ellipticals should merge in less than a Gyr, after which observers will see a massive 1.2-1.5 x 10^14 solar mass fossil group with an M_r = -24.0 brightest group galaxy at its center. Thus, the Cheshire Cat offers us the first opportunity to study a fossil group progenitor. We discuss the limitations of the classical definition of a fossil group in terms of magnitude gaps between the member galaxies. We also suggest that if the merging of fossil (or near-fossil) groups is a common avenue for creating present-day fossil groups, the time lag between the final galactic merging of the system and the onset of cooling in the shock-heated core could account for the observed lack of well-developed cool cores in some fossil groups.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
The Scatter in the Hot Gas Content of Early-Type Galaxies
Authors:
Yuanyuan Su,
Jimmy A. Irwin,
Raymond E. White III,
Michael C. Cooper
Abstract:
Optically-similar early-type galaxies are observed to have a large and poorly understood range in the amount of hot, X-ray-emitting gas they contain.To investigate the origin of this diversity, we studied the hot gas properties of all 42 early-type galaxies in the multiwavelength ATLAS$^{\rm 3D}$ survey that have sufficiently deep {\sl Chandra} X-ray observations. We related their hot gas properti…
▽ More
Optically-similar early-type galaxies are observed to have a large and poorly understood range in the amount of hot, X-ray-emitting gas they contain.To investigate the origin of this diversity, we studied the hot gas properties of all 42 early-type galaxies in the multiwavelength ATLAS$^{\rm 3D}$ survey that have sufficiently deep {\sl Chandra} X-ray observations. We related their hot gas properties to a number of internal and external physical quantities. To characterize the amount of hot gas relative to the stellar light, we use the ratio of the gaseous X-ray luminosity to the stellar $K$-band luminosity, $L_{X_{\rm gas}}/L_K$; we also use the deviations of $L_{X_{\rm gas}}$ from the best-fit $L_{X_{\rm gas}}$--$L_K$ relation (denoted $ΔL_{X_{\rm gas}}$). We quantitatively confirm previous suggestions that various effects conspire to produce the large scatter in the observed $L_X/L_K$ relation. In particular, we find that the deviations $ΔL_{X_{\rm gas}}$ are most strongly positively correlated with the (low rates of) star formation and the hot gas temperatures in the sample galaxies. This suggests that mild stellar feedback may energize the gas without pushing it out of the host galaxies. We also find that galaxies in high galaxy density environments tend to be massive slow-rotators, while galaxies in low galaxy density environments tend to be low mass, fast-rotators. Moreover, cold gas in clusters and fields may have different origins. The star formation rate increases with cold gas mass for field galaxies but it appears to be uncorrelated with cold gas for cluster galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Suzaku Observations of the X-ray Brightest Fossil Group ESO 3060170
Authors:
Yuanyuan Su,
Raymond E. White,
Eric D. Miller
Abstract:
"Fossil" galaxy groups, each dominated by a relatively isolated giant elliptical galaxy, have many properties intermediate between groups and clusters of galaxies. We used the {\sl Suzaku} X-ray observatory to observe the X-ray brightest fossil group, ESO 3060170, out to $R_{200}$, in order to better elucidate the relation between fossil groups, normal groups, and clusters. We determined the intra…
▽ More
"Fossil" galaxy groups, each dominated by a relatively isolated giant elliptical galaxy, have many properties intermediate between groups and clusters of galaxies. We used the {\sl Suzaku} X-ray observatory to observe the X-ray brightest fossil group, ESO 3060170, out to $R_{200}$, in order to better elucidate the relation between fossil groups, normal groups, and clusters. We determined the intragroup gas temperature, density, and metal abundance distributions and derived the entropy, pressure and mass profiles for this group. The entropy and pressure profiles in the outer regions are flatter than in simulated clusters, similar to what is seen in observations of massive clusters. This may indicate that the gas is clumpy and/or the gas has been redistributed. Assuming hydrostatic equilibrium, the total mass is estimated to be $\sim1.7\times10^{14}$ $M_{\odot}$ within a radius $R_{200}$ of $\sim1.15$ Mpc, with an enclosed baryon mass fraction of 0.14. The integrated iron mass-to-light ratio of this fossil group is larger than in most groups and comparable to those of clusters, indicating that this fossil group has retained the bulk of its metals. A galaxy luminosity density map on a scale of 25 Mpc shows that this fossil group resides in a relatively isolated environment, unlike the filamentary structures in which typical groups and clusters are embedded.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Different Methods of Forming Cold Fronts in Non-Merging Clusters
Authors:
Renato A. Dupke,
Raymond E. White III,
Joel N. Bregman
Abstract:
Sharp edges in X-ray surface brightness with continuous gas pressure called cold fronts have been often found in relaxed galaxy clusters such as Abell 496. Models that explain cold fronts as surviving cores of head-on subcluster mergers do not work well for these clusters and competing models involving gas sloshing have been recently proposed. Here, we test some concrete predictions of these mod…
▽ More
Sharp edges in X-ray surface brightness with continuous gas pressure called cold fronts have been often found in relaxed galaxy clusters such as Abell 496. Models that explain cold fronts as surviving cores of head-on subcluster mergers do not work well for these clusters and competing models involving gas sloshing have been recently proposed. Here, we test some concrete predictions of these models in a combined analysis of density, temperature, metal abundances and abundance ratios in a deep Chandra exposure of Abell 496. We confirm that the chemical discontinuities found in this cluster are not consistent with a core merger remnant scenario. However, we find chemical gradients across a spiral "arm" discovered at 73 kpc north of the cluster center and coincident with the sharp edge of the main cold front in the cluster. Despite the overall SN Ia iron mass fraction dominance found within the cooling radius of this cluster, the metal enrichment along the arm, determined from silicon and iron abundances, is consistent with a lower SN Ia iron mass fraction (51% +- 14%) than that measured in the surrounding regions (85% +- 14%). The "arm" is also significantly colder than the surroundings by 0.5-1.6 keV. The arm extends from a boxy colder region surrounding the center of the cluster, where two other cold fronts are found. This cold arm is a prediction of current high resolution numerical simulations as a result of an off-center encounter with a less massive pure dark matter halo and we suggest that the cold fronts in A496 provide the first clear corroboration of such model, where the closest encounter happened ~ 0.5 Gyr ago. We also argue for a possible candidate dark matter halo responsible for the cold fronts in the outskirts of A496.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
-
The Spiral Host Galaxy of the Double Radio Source 0313-192
Authors:
William C. Keel,
Raymond E. White III,
Frazer N. Owen,
Michael J. Ledlow
Abstract:
We present new Hubble, Gemini-S, and Chandra observations of the radio galaxy 0313-192, which hosts a 350-kpc double source and jets, even though previous data have suggested that it is a spiral galaxy. We measure the bulge scale and luminosity, radial and vertical profiles of disk starlight, and consider the distributions of H II regions and absorbing dust. In each case, the HST data confirm it…
▽ More
We present new Hubble, Gemini-S, and Chandra observations of the radio galaxy 0313-192, which hosts a 350-kpc double source and jets, even though previous data have suggested that it is a spiral galaxy. We measure the bulge scale and luminosity, radial and vertical profiles of disk starlight, and consider the distributions of H II regions and absorbing dust. In each case, the HST data confirm its classification as an edge-on spiral galaxy, the only such system known to produce such an extended radio source of this kind. The Gemini near-IR images and Chandra spectral fit reveal a strongly obscured central AGN, seen through the entire ISM path length of the disk and showing X-ray evidence of additional absorption from warm or dense material close to the central object. We consider several possible mechanisms for producing such a rare combination of AGN and host properties, some combination of which may be at work. These include an unusually luminous bulge (suggesting a black hole of mass 0.5-0.9 billion solar masses), orientation of the jets near the pole of the gas-rich disk, and some evidence of a weak gravitational interaction which has warped the disk and could have enhanced fuelling of the central engine. An X-ray counterpart of the kiloparsec-scale radio jet emerges to the south; jet/counterjet limits in both radio and X-ray allow them to be symmetric if seen more than 15 degrees from the plane of the sky, still consistent with the jet axes being within ~30 degrees of the poles of the gas-rich galaxy disk. A linear or disklike emission-line structure is seen around thenucleus, inclined by ~20 degrees to the stellar disk but nearly perpendicular to the jets; this may represent the aftermath of a galaxy encounter, where gas is photoionized by the nuclear continuum.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2006;
originally announced August 2006.
-
Chandra Analysis of Abell 496 - No Chemical Gradients Across Cold Fronts
Authors:
Renato A. Dupke,
Raymond E. White III
Abstract:
We present the results of a spatially-resolved spectroscopic analysis of the galaxy cluster Abell 496 with the S3 chip on-board the Chandra satellite. We confirm the presence of a central positive temperature gradient consistent with a cooling flow, but with a minimum gas temperature of ~0.5-0.9 keV. The cluster also exhibits sharp edges in gas density and temperature which are consistent with "…
▽ More
We present the results of a spatially-resolved spectroscopic analysis of the galaxy cluster Abell 496 with the S3 chip on-board the Chandra satellite. We confirm the presence of a central positive temperature gradient consistent with a cooling flow, but with a minimum gas temperature of ~0.5-0.9 keV. The cluster also exhibits sharp edges in gas density and temperature which are consistent with "cold front" substructures. The iron abundance profile is not radially symmetric relative to the cluster center. Towards the direction of the most prominent (northerly) cold front, the iron abundance is roughly flat, with nearly solar values. In the opposite (southerly) direction from the center, the iron abundance distribution shows an "off-center" peak. Various abundance ratios suggest that the heavy elements in the central regions of the cluster are dominated by SN Ia ejecta. However, for radii greater than 100 kpc, the abundance ratios vary in such a way that different abundance ratios provide very different estimates of the proportion of SN Ia/II ejecta. Nonetheless, observed abundances and abundance ratios are continuous across the cold fronts, which suggests that the cold fronts are not likely to be the result of a subcluster merger. We suggest instead that the cold fronts in A496 are caused by "sloshing" of the central cooling flow gas, induced by the motion of the cD about the cluster center.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2002;
originally announced December 2002.
-
X-ray Binaries and Globular Clusters in Elliptical Galaxies
Authors:
Raymond E. White III,
Craig L. Sarazin,
Shrinivas R. Kulkarni
Abstract:
The X-ray emission from normal elliptical galaxies has two major components: soft emission from diffuse gas and harder emission from populations of accreting (low-mass) stellar X-ray binaries (LMXB). If LMXB populations are tied to the field stellar populations in galaxies, their total X-ray luminosities should be proportional to the optical luminosities of galaxies. However, recent ASCA and Cha…
▽ More
The X-ray emission from normal elliptical galaxies has two major components: soft emission from diffuse gas and harder emission from populations of accreting (low-mass) stellar X-ray binaries (LMXB). If LMXB populations are tied to the field stellar populations in galaxies, their total X-ray luminosities should be proportional to the optical luminosities of galaxies. However, recent ASCA and Chandra X-ray observations show that the global luminosities of LMXB components in ellipticals exhibit significant scatter at a given optical luminosity. This scatter may reflect a range of evolutionary stages among LMXB populations in ellipticals of different ages. If so, the ratio of the global LMXB X-ray luminosity to the galactic optical luminosity, L_LMXB/L_opt, may be used to determine when the bulk of stars were formed in individual ellipticals. To test this, we compare variations in L_LMXB/L_opt for LMXB populations in ellipticals to optically-derived estimates of stellar ages in the same galaxies. We find no correlation, implying that L_LMXB/L_opt variations are not good age indicators for ellipticals. Alternatively, LMXBs may be formed primarily in globular clusters (through stellar tidal interactions), rather than in the stellar fields of galaxies. Since elliptical galaxies exhibit a wide range of globular cluster populations for a given galaxian luminosity, this may induce a dispersion in the LMXB populations of ellipticals with similar optical luminosities. Indeed, we find that L_LMXB/L_opt ratios for LMXB populations are strongly correlated with the specific globular cluster frequencies in elliptical galaxies. This suggests that most LMXBs were formed in globular clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2002;
originally announced April 2002.
-
Stellar X-ray Binary Populations in Elliptical Galaxies
Authors:
Raymond E. White III
Abstract:
Chandra's high angular resolution can resolve emission from stellar X-ray binaries out of the diffuse X-ray emission from gaseous atmospheres within elliptical galaxies. Variations in the X-ray binary populations (per unit galaxian optical luminosity) are correlated with variations in the specific frequency of globular clusters in ellipticals. This indicates that X-ray binaries are largely forme…
▽ More
Chandra's high angular resolution can resolve emission from stellar X-ray binaries out of the diffuse X-ray emission from gaseous atmospheres within elliptical galaxies. Variations in the X-ray binary populations (per unit galaxian optical luminosity) are correlated with variations in the specific frequency of globular clusters in ellipticals. This indicates that X-ray binaries are largely formed in globular clusters, rather than being a primordial field population.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2001;
originally announced November 2001.
-
Chandra Analysis of Abell 496
Authors:
Renato A. Dupke,
Raymond E. White III
Abstract:
We present preliminary results of imaging and spectral analysis of the cluster A496 with the S3 chip on-board the Chandra satellite. We confirm the presence of a cooling flow and radial gradients in elemental abundances. The cluster's core has clear signs of substructures (sharp edges, cavities), similar to those recently found in other cooling flow clusters. The O/Fe ratio distribution indicate…
▽ More
We present preliminary results of imaging and spectral analysis of the cluster A496 with the S3 chip on-board the Chandra satellite. We confirm the presence of a cooling flow and radial gradients in elemental abundances. The cluster's core has clear signs of substructures (sharp edges, cavities), similar to those recently found in other cooling flow clusters. The O/Fe ratio distribution indicates that the gas in the core of the cluster is significantly enriched by SN Ia ejecta.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2001;
originally announced October 2001.
-
Seeing Galaxies though Thick and Thin. IV. The Superimposed Spiral Galaxies of NGC 3314
Authors:
William C. Keel,
Raymond E. White III
Abstract:
The superimposed pair of spiral galaxies NGC 3314 offers a unique opportunity to trace the dust properties in a spiral galaxy. We analyze multicolor HST imaging, supported by ground-based near-IR imaging and fiber-array spectroscopy to measure dust extinction in the foreground Sc galaxy NGC 3314A, which is backlit by the Sb system NGC 3314B. We can measure extinctions over a wide range of galact…
▽ More
The superimposed pair of spiral galaxies NGC 3314 offers a unique opportunity to trace the dust properties in a spiral galaxy. We analyze multicolor HST imaging, supported by ground-based near-IR imaging and fiber-array spectroscopy to measure dust extinction in the foreground Sc galaxy NGC 3314A, which is backlit by the Sb system NGC 3314B. We can measure extinctions over a wide range of galactocentric radii in the foreground galaxy, from 0.4-4.5 kpc. In the outer disk, the extinction is strongly localized in discrete dust lanes. These dust features show an extinction curve with a slope close to the Galactic mean (R = 3.5+/-0.3) from 1.6 to 3.8 kpc, with no radial trend. Using the I-K color of the background nucleus, we derive an extinction A(I) = 3.3 through the disk at a projected distance 400 pc from the nucleus of NGC 3314A. The extinction in even the inner disk of NGC 3314A is quite patchy, since background H-alpha emission is detected from all parts of the system. Local anticorrelations between foreground and background line emission demonstrate that the dust is concentrated to star-forming regions, as has been found for the blue light in several systems. Colors of dust lanes in NGC 3314A which are projected only partially against the background disk indicate that the dust scale height in the foreground disk is substantially smaller than that of the stars.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2001;
originally announced June 2001.
-
Seeing Galaxies Through Thick & Thin. III. HST Imaging of the Dust in Backlit Spiral Galaxies
Authors:
William C. Keel,
Raymond E. White III
Abstract:
We present analysis of WFPC2 imaging of two spiral galaxies partially backlit by E/S0 systems in the pairs AM1316-241 and AM0500-620, and the spiral foreground system in NGC 1275. Images in B and I are used to determine the reddening curve of in these systems. The spiral component of AM1316-241 shows dust strongly concentrated in discrete arms, with a reddening law very close to the Milky Way me…
▽ More
We present analysis of WFPC2 imaging of two spiral galaxies partially backlit by E/S0 systems in the pairs AM1316-241 and AM0500-620, and the spiral foreground system in NGC 1275. Images in B and I are used to determine the reddening curve of in these systems. The spiral component of AM1316-241 shows dust strongly concentrated in discrete arms, with a reddening law very close to the Milky Way mean. The dust distribution is scale-free between about 100 pc and the arm scale. The spiral in AM0500-620 shows dust concentrated in arms and interarm spurs, with measurable interarm extinction as well. Although its dust properties are less well-determined, we find evidence for a steeper extinction law here. The shape of the reddening law suggests that, at least in AM1316-241, we have resolved most of the dust structure. In AM0500-620, the slope of the fractal perimeter-scale relation steepens systematically from low to high extinction. In AM1316-241, we cannot determine a unique fractal dimension from the defining area-perimeter relation, so the projected dust distribution is best defined as fractal-like. In neither galaxy do we see regions even on single-pixel scales in spiral arms with AB > 2.5. The measurements in NGC 1275 are compromised by our lack of independent knowledge of the foreground system's light distribution, but masked sampling of the absorption suggests an effective reddening curve much flatter than the Milky Way mean (perhaps indicating that the foreground system has been affected by immersion in the hot intracluster gas).
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2000;
originally announced November 2000.
-
A Moderate Cluster Cooling Flow Model
Authors:
Noam Soker,
Raymond E. White III,
Laurence P. David,
Brian R. McNamara
Abstract:
We propose that the outer portions of cooling flows (CFs) in clusters of galaxies are frequently disrupted by radio jets, and that their effective ages are much shorter than the cluster ages. The inner regions, where the gas density is higher, are more difficult to disrupt, and may continue to harbor CFs even after disruption events. The main assumption of the proposed scenario is that, on a tim…
▽ More
We propose that the outer portions of cooling flows (CFs) in clusters of galaxies are frequently disrupted by radio jets, and that their effective ages are much shorter than the cluster ages. The inner regions, where the gas density is higher, are more difficult to disrupt, and may continue to harbor CFs even after disruption events. The main assumption of the proposed scenario is that, on a time scale of about 2-4 times 10^9 years the cD galaxies in CF clusters undergo powerful bursts of AGN activity that produce strong radio jets. The jets excite shock waves moving at several thousands km/sec and heat the CF region, hence terminating it in the outer regions. The total accreted mass due to the CF is an order of magnitude lower than the mass accreted according to the "standard" CF model (which assumes an undisturbed CF for a time equal to the age of the cluster). The scenario, therefore, brings to agreement the observations that a large fraction of clusters harbor CFs, that strong optical and radio activity are present only in the very inner regions of CFs, and the lack of a satisfactory reservoir of the expected (in the standard CF model) large mass that has been cooling over the life of the cluster.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2000;
originally announced September 2000.
-
Seeing Galaxies Through Thick and Thin: II. Direct Measures of Extinction in Spiral Disks Through Spectroscopy of Overlap** Galaxies
Authors:
Donovan L. Domingue,
William C. Keel,
Raymond E. White III
Abstract:
We use slit spectroscopy of overlap** pairs of galaxies to directly determine the extinction in disks of foreground spiral galaxies. The Doppler shifts of pair members are determined via cross-correlation and their relative correlation amplitudes are used to separate their contributions to the combined spectra in regions of overlap. This spectroscopic approach is less subject to stringent symm…
▽ More
We use slit spectroscopy of overlap** pairs of galaxies to directly determine the extinction in disks of foreground spiral galaxies. The Doppler shifts of pair members are determined via cross-correlation and their relative correlation amplitudes are used to separate their contributions to the combined spectra in regions of overlap. This spectroscopic approach is less subject to stringent symmetry constraints than our previous purely photometric analyses. Extinctions of foreground members were obtained for 6 of the candidates in our sample of 18 mostly spiral/spiral pairs, when the signal to noise and velocity difference were suitable. In agreement with our previous imaging results, we find that the extinction in interarm regions is very modest, typically A_B=0.1 mag (corrected to face on), while spiral arms exhibit higher extinctions of 0.3 mag.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2000;
originally announced July 2000.
-
Time-Dependence of the Mass Accretion Rate in Cluster Cooling Flows
Authors:
Eric A. Lufkin,
Craig L. Sarazin,
Raymond E. White, III
Abstract:
We analyze two time-dependent cluster cooling flow models in spherical symmetry. The first assumes that the intracluster gas resides in a static external potential, and includes the effects of optically thin radiative cooling and mass deposition. This corresponds to previous steady-state cooling flow models calculated by White & Sarazin (1987). Detailed agreement is found between steady-state mo…
▽ More
We analyze two time-dependent cluster cooling flow models in spherical symmetry. The first assumes that the intracluster gas resides in a static external potential, and includes the effects of optically thin radiative cooling and mass deposition. This corresponds to previous steady-state cooling flow models calculated by White & Sarazin (1987). Detailed agreement is found between steady-state models and time-dependent models at fixed times in the simulations. The mass accretion rate is found either to increase or remain nearly constant once flows reach a steady state. The time rate of change of the accretion rate is strongly sensitive to the value of the mass deposition parameter q, but only mildly sensitive to the ratio beta of gravitational binding energy to gas temperature. We show that previous scaling arguments presented by Bertschinger (1988) and White (1988) are valid only for mature cooling flows with weak mass deposition (q ~< 1). The second set of models includes the effects of a secularly deepening cluster potential and secondary infall of gas from the Hubble flow. We find that such heating effects do not prevent the flows from reaching a steady state within an initial central cooling time.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2000;
originally announced May 2000.
-
Constraining SN Ia Models Using X-ray Spectra of Clusters of Galaxies
Authors:
Renato A. Dupke,
Raymond E. White III
Abstract:
We present constraints on theoretical models of Type Ia SNe using spatially resolved ASCA X-ray spectroscopy of four galaxy clusters: Abell 496, Abell 2199, Abell 3571 & Perseus. All four clusters have central Fe abundance enhancements and an ensemble of abundance ratios are used to show that most of the Fe in the central regions of the clusters comes from SN Ia. At the center of each cluster, s…
▽ More
We present constraints on theoretical models of Type Ia SNe using spatially resolved ASCA X-ray spectroscopy of four galaxy clusters: Abell 496, Abell 2199, Abell 3571 & Perseus. All four clusters have central Fe abundance enhancements and an ensemble of abundance ratios are used to show that most of the Fe in the central regions of the clusters comes from SN Ia. At the center of each cluster, simultaneous analysis of spectra from all ASCA instruments shows that the Ni to Fe abundance ratio (normalized by the solar ratio) is ~ 4. We use the Ni/Fe ratio as a discriminator between SN Ia explosion models: the Ni/Fe ratio of ejecta from the "Convective Deflagration" model W7 is consistent with the observations, while those of "delayed detonation" models are not consistent at the 90% confidence level.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2000;
originally announced January 2000.
-
Implications of Abundance Gradients in Intracluster Gas
Authors:
Raymond E. White III,
Renato A. Dupke
Abstract:
Analysis of spatially resolved ASCA spectra of the intracluster gas in Abell 496 confirms that metal abundances increase toward the center. We also find spatial gradients in several abundance ratios, indicating that the fraction of iron from SN Ia increases toward the cluster center. The dominant metal enrichment mechanism near the cluster center must therefore be different than in the outer par…
▽ More
Analysis of spatially resolved ASCA spectra of the intracluster gas in Abell 496 confirms that metal abundances increase toward the center. We also find spatial gradients in several abundance ratios, indicating that the fraction of iron from SN Ia increases toward the cluster center. The dominant metal enrichment mechanism near the cluster center must therefore be different than in the outer parts. We show that ram pressure strip** of gas from cluster galaxies cannot account for the central abundance enhancement. We suggest that two successive stages of galactic winds contaminate intracluster gas: protogalactic winds driven by SN II, followed by less energetic winds driven by SN Ia, which have longer lived progenitors than SN II. The less energetic secondary wind from a cD galaxy may be suppressed, due to its location at the cluster center, leading to the observed central enhancement of SN Ia ejecta.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2000;
originally announced January 2000.
-
Constraints on Type Ia Supernova Models from X-ray Spectra of Galaxy Clusters
Authors:
Renato A. Dupke,
Raymond E. White III
Abstract:
We present constraints on theoretical models of Type Ia supernovae using spatially resolved ASCA X-ray spectroscopy of three galaxy clusters: Abell 496, Abell 2199 and Abell 3571. All three clusters have central iron abundance enhancements; an ensemble of abundance ratios are used to show that most of the iron in the central regions of the clusters comes from SN Ia. These observations are consis…
▽ More
We present constraints on theoretical models of Type Ia supernovae using spatially resolved ASCA X-ray spectroscopy of three galaxy clusters: Abell 496, Abell 2199 and Abell 3571. All three clusters have central iron abundance enhancements; an ensemble of abundance ratios are used to show that most of the iron in the central regions of the clusters comes from SN Ia. These observations are consistent with the suppressed galactic wind scenario proposed by Dupke and White (1999). At the center of each cluster, simultaneous analysis of spectra from all ASCA instruments shows that the nickel to iron abundance ratio (normalized by the solar ratio) is Ni/Fe ~ 4. We use the nickel to iron ratio as a discriminator between SN Ia explosion models: the Ni/Fe ratio of ejecta from the "Convective Deflagration" model W7 is consistent with the observations, while those of "delayed detonation" models are not consistent at the 90% confidence level.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 1999;
originally announced July 1999.
-
Dust in Spiral Galaxies: Comparing Emission and Absorption to Constrain Small-Scale and Very Cold Structures
Authors:
Donovan L. Domingue,
William C. Keel,
Stuart D. Ryder,
Raymond E. White III
Abstract:
The detailed distribution of dust in the disks of spiral galaxies is important to understanding the radiative transfer within disks, and to measuring overall dust masses if significant quantities of dust are either very opaque or very cold. We address this issue by comparing measures of dust absorption, using the galaxy-overlap technique in the optical, with measures of the dust grains' thermal…
▽ More
The detailed distribution of dust in the disks of spiral galaxies is important to understanding the radiative transfer within disks, and to measuring overall dust masses if significant quantities of dust are either very opaque or very cold. We address this issue by comparing measures of dust absorption, using the galaxy-overlap technique in the optical, with measures of the dust grains' thermal emission from 50-2000 micron using ISOPHOT on board ISO and SCUBA at the JCMT. We examine three spiral galaxies projected partially in front of E/S0 galaxies --- AM1316-241, NGC 5545, and NGC 5091 (for NGC 5091 we have only optical and ISO data). Adopting an empirical exponential model for the dust distribution, we compare column densities and dust masses derived from the absorption and emission techniques. This comparison is sensitive to the amount of dust mass in small, opaque structures, which would not contribute strongly to area-weighted absorption measures, and to very cold dust, which would contribute to optical absorption but provide only a small fraction of the sub-mm emission. In AM1316-241, we find global dust masses of 2-5 x 10^7 M_solar, both techniques agreeing at the 50% level. NGC 5545 has about half this dust mass. The concordance of dust masses is well within the errors expected from our knowledge of the radial distribution of dust, and argues against any dominant part of the dust mass being so cold or opaque. The 50-2000 micron data are well fitted by modified Planck functions with an emissivity law beta=-2, at 21 +/- 2 K. We also present 12 micron ISOCAM observations of these pairs.Comparison of H-alpha and 12 micron images of NGC 5545 indicate that ISOCAM images are reliable tracers of star formation.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 1999;
originally announced June 1999.
-
Metallicity Gradients in the Intracluster Gas of Abell 496
Authors:
Renato A. Dupke,
Raymond E. White III
Abstract:
Analysis of spatially resolved ASCA spectra of the intracluster gas in Abell 496 confirms there are mild metal abundance enhancements near the center, as previously found by White et al. (1994) in a joint analysis of Ginga LAC and Einstein SSS spectra. Simultaneous analysis of spectra from all ASCA instruments (SIS + GIS) shows that the iron abundance is 0.36 +- 0.03 solar 3-12' from the center…
▽ More
Analysis of spatially resolved ASCA spectra of the intracluster gas in Abell 496 confirms there are mild metal abundance enhancements near the center, as previously found by White et al. (1994) in a joint analysis of Ginga LAC and Einstein SSS spectra. Simultaneous analysis of spectra from all ASCA instruments (SIS + GIS) shows that the iron abundance is 0.36 +- 0.03 solar 3-12' from the center of the cluster and rises ~50% to 0.53 +- 0.04 solar within the central 2'. The F-test shows that this abundance gradient is significant at the >99.99% level. Nickel and sulfur abundances are also centrally enhanced. We use a variety of elemental abundance ratios to assess the relative contribution of SN Ia and SN II to the metal enrichment of the intracluster gas. We find spatial gradients in several abundance ratios, indicating that the fraction of iron from SN Ia increases toward the cluster center, with SN Ia accounting for ~50% of the iron mass 3-12' from the center and ~70% within 2'. The increased proportion of SN Ia ejecta at the center is such that the central iron abundance enhancement can be attributed wholly to SN Ia; we find no significant gradient in SN II ejecta. These spatial gradients in the proportion of SN Ia/II ejecta imply that the dominant metal enrichment mechanism near the center is different than in the outer parts of the cluster. We show that the central abundance enhancement is unlikely to be due to ram pressure strip** of gas from cluster galaxies, or to secularly accumulated stellar mass loss within the central cD. We suggest that the additional SN Ia ejecta near the center is the vestige of a secondary SN Ia-driven wind from the cD (following a more energetic protogalactic SN II-driven wind phase), which was partially smothered in the cD due to its location at the cluster center.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2000; v1 submitted 7 February, 1999;
originally announced February 1999.
-
Prevalence and Properties of Dark Matter in Elliptical Galaxies
Authors:
Michael Loewenstein,
Raymond E. White III
Abstract:
Given the recently deduced relationship between X-ray temperatures and stellar velocity dispersions (the "T-sigma relation") in an optically complete sample of elliptical galaxies (Davis & White 1996), we demonstrate that L>L_* ellipticals contain substantial amounts of dark matter in general. We present constraints on the dark matter scale length and on the dark-to-luminous mass ratio within th…
▽ More
Given the recently deduced relationship between X-ray temperatures and stellar velocity dispersions (the "T-sigma relation") in an optically complete sample of elliptical galaxies (Davis & White 1996), we demonstrate that L>L_* ellipticals contain substantial amounts of dark matter in general. We present constraints on the dark matter scale length and on the dark-to-luminous mass ratio within the optical half-light radius and within the entire galaxy. For example, we find that minimum values of dark matter core radii scale as r_dm > 4(L_V/3L_*)^{3/4}h^{-1}_80 kpc and that the minimum dark matter mass fraction is >~20% within one optical effective radius r_e and is >~39-85% within 6r_e, depending on the stellar density profile and observed value of beta_spec. We also confirm the prediction of Davis & White (1996) that the dark matter is characterized by velocity dispersions that are greater than those of the luminous stars: sigma_dm^2 ~ 1.4-2 sigma_*^2. The T-sigma relation implies a nearly constant mass-to-light ratio within six half-light radii: M/L_V ~ 25h_80 M_sun/L_V_sun. This conflicts with the simplest extension of CDM theories of large scale structure formation to galactic scales; we consider a couple of modifications which can better account for the observed T-sigma relation.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 1999;
originally announced January 1999.
-
An X-Ray Temperature Map of the Merging Cluster Abell 2255
Authors:
David S. Davis,
Raymond E. White III
Abstract:
We present a spatially resolved map of intracluster gas temperatures in the rich cluster Abell 2255, using ROSAT PSPC data. The intracluster gas is strongly non-isothermal and the temperature distribution supports the conclusions of Burns et al. (1995) that Abell~2255 is currently undergoing a merger. The hottest regions are near the core, northwest of the center. A map of the ratio of softer to…
▽ More
We present a spatially resolved map of intracluster gas temperatures in the rich cluster Abell 2255, using ROSAT PSPC data. The intracluster gas is strongly non-isothermal and the temperature distribution supports the conclusions of Burns et al. (1995) that Abell~2255 is currently undergoing a merger. The hottest regions are near the core, northwest of the center. A map of the ratio of softer to harder X-ray photons reveals an anomalously soft region northeast of the center, coincident with a radio ridge discovered by Burns et al (1995). We suggest that this cooler region is associated with an infalling group of galaxies which is giving rise to the radio ridge. Meanwhile, a much more substantial recent merger between comparably sized subcluster components can account for the more global merger signatures, which include the extensive central radio halo, the large scale gas temperature variations, the pair of central dominant ellipticals, elliptical X-ray isophotes offset from these dominant galaxies, and the very high velocity dispersion of galaxies in the cluster.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 1997;
originally announced September 1997.
-
The Nature of the X-Ray Point Source in the Bar of NGC 6822
Authors:
Paul B. Eskridge,
Raymond E. White, III
Abstract:
We have analysed archival ROSAT PSPC and Einstein HRI data for the x-ray point source in the bar of NGC 6822. The source decreased in x-ray flux by at least half an order of magnitude in the 13 years between the HRI and PSPC observations. It has a PSPC flux of f_X = 8 x 10E-14 erg/cm^2/s, giving L_X = 2.4 x 10E36 erg/s for a distance of 500 kpc. The source appears to be related to the optical em…
▽ More
We have analysed archival ROSAT PSPC and Einstein HRI data for the x-ray point source in the bar of NGC 6822. The source decreased in x-ray flux by at least half an order of magnitude in the 13 years between the HRI and PSPC observations. It has a PSPC flux of f_X = 8 x 10E-14 erg/cm^2/s, giving L_X = 2.4 x 10E36 erg/s for a distance of 500 kpc. The source appears to be related to the optical emission-line object Ho 12. It is unclear if Ho 12 is an HII region or a supernova remnant, although the latter interpretation is better supported by the available optical data. The x-rays are unlikely to be direct emission from a supernova remnant, due to the observed strong x-ray variability. The x-ray spectrum of the source is very soft. Acceptable fits are found for either a Raymond-Smith thermal model with kT = 0.56 keV, or a blackbody model with kT = 0.06 keV. The latter model would place the source amongst the class of Super-Soft x-ray sources first found in the Magellanic Clouds. If the thermal model is correct, the source appears similar to Galactic and Magellanic Cloud stellar-mass black hole binary candidates. We have identified a list of potential optical counterparts from published photometry. However, for either model discussed above, we expect the apparent magnitude of the optical counterpart to be in the range 21.5 < V < 24.0. Thus the optical counterpart may be below the limit of published photometry.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 1997;
originally announced June 1997.
-
Seeing Galaxies Through Thick and Thin: I. Optical Opacity Measures in Overlap** Galaxies
Authors:
Raymond E. White III,
William C. Keel,
Christopher J. Conselice
Abstract:
We describe the use of partially overlap** galaxies to provide direct measurements of the effective absorption in galaxy disks, independent of assumptions about internal disk structure. The non-overlap** parts of the galaxies and symmetry considerations are used to reconstruct, via differential photometry, how much background galaxy light is lost in passing through the foreground disks. Exte…
▽ More
We describe the use of partially overlap** galaxies to provide direct measurements of the effective absorption in galaxy disks, independent of assumptions about internal disk structure. The non-overlap** parts of the galaxies and symmetry considerations are used to reconstruct, via differential photometry, how much background galaxy light is lost in passing through the foreground disks. Extensive catalog searches yield ~15-25 nearby galaxy pairs suitable for varying degrees of our analysis; ten of the best such examples are presented here. From these pairs, we find that interarm extinction is modest, declining from A_B ~1 magnitude at 0.3 R_25^B to essentially zero by R_25^B; the interarm dust has a scale length consistent with that of the disk starlight. In contrast, dust in spiral arms and resonance rings may be optically thick (A_B > 2) at virtually any radius. Some disks have flatter extinction curves than the Galaxy, with A_B/A_I = 1.6; this is probably the signature of clumpy dust distributions. Even though typical spirals are not optically thick throughout their disks, where they {\it are} optically thick is correlated with where they are most luminous: in spiral arms and inner disks. This correlation between absorption and emission regions may account for their apparent surface brightness being only mildly dependent on inclination, erroneously indicating that spirals are generally optically thick. Taken as an ensemble, the opacities of spiral galaxies may be just great enough to significantly affect QSO counts, though not enough to cause their high redshift cutoff.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 1996;
originally announced August 1996.
-
ROSAT Temperatures and Abundances for a Complete Sample of Elliptical Galaxies
Authors:
David S. Davis,
Raymond E. White III
Abstract:
We determine X-ray temperatures and abundances for elliptical galaxies drawn from a complete, optically selected sample. The optical magnitude-limited sample consists of 43 galaxies, complete to a (corrected) B magnitude of m_B^o=11.36. Of these, 30 have enough X-ray spectral counts to allow temperature determinations. We find that the temperatures of the X-ray emitting gas in these ellipticals…
▽ More
We determine X-ray temperatures and abundances for elliptical galaxies drawn from a complete, optically selected sample. The optical magnitude-limited sample consists of 43 galaxies, complete to a (corrected) B magnitude of m_B^o=11.36. Of these, 30 have enough X-ray spectral counts to allow temperature determinations. We find that the temperatures of the X-ray emitting gas in these ellipticals are correlated with the central stellar velocity dispersions: T ~ sigma^1.45; this is a shallower trend than the simple thermal relation T ~ sigma^2. The diffuse gas is substantially hotter than the kinetic temperature of the luminous stars, since kT > mu m_p sigma^2 for all galaxies with measurable temperatures. This strongly indicates that dark matter halos are characterized by velocity dispersions which exceed those of the luminous stars. We see no evidence of emission from X-ray binaries becoming progressively more dominant in lower luminosity ellipticals. We find that so-called "supersoft" sources adhere to the observed kT-sigma relation, so they are no softer than expected for their velocity dispersions. We also find that ISM temperatures and abundances are correlated, with the gas in hotter systems being more enriched than in cooler galaxies. However, no correlation is found between gaseous abundances and stellar abundances, as inferred from Mg_2 indices.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 1996;
originally announced July 1996.
-
Distribution and Content of Dust in Overlap** Galaxy Systems
Authors:
Raymond E. White III,
William C. Keel,
Christopher J. Conselice
Abstract:
Partially overlap** galaxies are used to directly determine the effective absorption in spiral galaxy disks. The non-overlap** parts of the galaxies and symmetry considerations are used to reconstruct, via differential photometry, how much background galaxy light is lost in passing through the foreground disks.
Partially overlap** galaxies are used to directly determine the effective absorption in spiral galaxy disks. The non-overlap** parts of the galaxies and symmetry considerations are used to reconstruct, via differential photometry, how much background galaxy light is lost in passing through the foreground disks.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 1996;
originally announced April 1996.
-
Non-isothermal X-ray Emitting Gas in Clusters of Galaxies
Authors:
Mark J. Henriksen,
Raymond E. White III
Abstract:
We have analyzed X-ray spectra from six galaxy clusters which contain cooling flows: A85, A478, A1795, A2142, A2147, & A2199. The X-ray spectra were taken with the HEAO1-A2 Medium and High Energy Detectors and the Einstein Solid State Spectrometer. For each cluster, we simultaneously fit the spectra from these three detectors with models incorporating one or more emission components comprised of…
▽ More
We have analyzed X-ray spectra from six galaxy clusters which contain cooling flows: A85, A478, A1795, A2142, A2147, & A2199. The X-ray spectra were taken with the HEAO1-A2 Medium and High Energy Detectors and the Einstein Solid State Spectrometer. For each cluster, we simultaneously fit the spectra from these three detectors with models incorporating one or more emission components comprised of either thermal or cooling flow models. Five of the clusters (all but A2142) are better fit by a multi-component model (a cooling flow plus one or two thermal components or a two thermal component model) than by isothermal models. In four of the clusters (A85, A1795, A2147, & A2199), we find evidence for cool gas outside of the canonical cooling flow region. These latter four clusters can be characterized by three temperature components: a temperature inversion in the central region, a hotter region with an emission-weighted temperature which is higher than that of an isothermal model fit to the entire cluster, and a cooler region with an emission-weighted temperature of ~1 keV. The cool component outside the cooling flow region has a large minimum emission measure which we attribute, in part, to diffuse cool gas in the outer cluster atmosphere. If at least some of the cool exterior gas is virialized, this would imply a radially decreasing temperature profile. Together with the density profiles we have found, this leads to a baryon fraction in gas which increases with radius and is larger than that for an isothermal cluster atmosphere. Consequently, if clusters of galaxies trace the mass distribution in the Universe, the gas mass fraction we have calculated for an isothermal gas (which is ~15%) together with the nominal galaxy contribution (~5%) gives a baryon fraction of ~20%. Using the upper limit to the baryon density derived from Big
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 1996;
originally announced April 1996.
-
X-Ray Emission from M32: X-Ray Binaries or a micro-AGN?
Authors:
Paul B. Eskridge,
Raymond E. White III,
David S. Davis
Abstract:
We have analysed archival {\it ROSAT} PSPC data for M32 in order to study the x-ray emission from this nearest elliptical galaxy. We fit spectra from three long exposures with Raymond-Smith, thermal bremsstrahlung, and power-law models. All models give excellent fits. The thermal fits have kT$\approx$4 keV, the Raymond-Smith iron abundance is $0.4^{+0.7}_{-0.3}$ Solar, the power-law fit has $α$=…
▽ More
We have analysed archival {\it ROSAT} PSPC data for M32 in order to study the x-ray emission from this nearest elliptical galaxy. We fit spectra from three long exposures with Raymond-Smith, thermal bremsstrahlung, and power-law models. All models give excellent fits. The thermal fits have kT$\approx$4 keV, the Raymond-Smith iron abundance is $0.4^{+0.7}_{-0.3}$ Solar, the power-law fit has $α$=1.6$\pm$0.1, and all fits have $N_H$ consistent with the Galactic column. The source is centered on M32 to an accuracy of 9$''$, and unresolved at 27$''$ FWHM ($\sim$90 pc). M32 is x-ray variable by a factor of 3--5 on timescales of a decade down to minutes, with evidence for a possible period of $\sim$1.3 days.
There are two plausible interpretations for these results: 1) Emission due to low-mass x-ray binaries; 2) Emission due to accretion onto a massive central black hole. Both of these possibilities are supported by arguments based on previous studies of M32 and other old stellar systems; the {\it ROSAT} PSPC data do not allow us to unambiguously choose between them. Observations with the {\it ROSAT} HRI and with {\it ASCA} are required to determine which of these two very different physical models is correct.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 1996;
originally announced March 1996.
-
Abundance Gradients in Cooling Flow Clusters: Ginga Lac & Einstein SSS Spectra of A496, A1795, A2142 & A2199
Authors:
Raymond E. White III,
C. S. R. Day,
Isamu Hatsukade,
John P. Hughes
Abstract:
We analyze the Ginga LAC and Einstein SSS spectra of four cooling flow clusters, A496, A1795, A2142 and A2199, each of which shows firm evidence of a relatively cool component. The inclusion of such cool spectral components in joint fits of SSS and LAC data leads to somewhat higher global temperatures than are derived from the high energy LAC data alone. We find little evidence of cool emission…
▽ More
We analyze the Ginga LAC and Einstein SSS spectra of four cooling flow clusters, A496, A1795, A2142 and A2199, each of which shows firm evidence of a relatively cool component. The inclusion of such cool spectral components in joint fits of SSS and LAC data leads to somewhat higher global temperatures than are derived from the high energy LAC data alone. We find little evidence of cool emission outside the SSS field of view. Metal abundances appear to be centrally enhanced in all four cluster, with varying degrees of model dependence and statistical significance: the evidence is statistically strongest for A496 and A2142, somewhat weaker for A2199 and weakest for A1795. We also explore the model-dependence in the amount of cold, X-ray absorbing matter discovered in these clusters by White et al. (1991).
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 1994;
originally announced April 1994.