-
Angular momentum transport via gravitational instability in the Elias 2-27 disc
Authors:
Cristiano Longarini,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Cathie J. Clarke,
Jessica Speedie,
Teresa Paneque-Carreno,
Edoardo Arrigoni,
Pietro Curone,
Claudia Toci,
Cassandra Hall
Abstract:
Gravitational instability is thought to be one of the main drivers of angular momentum transport in young protoplanetary discs. The disc around Elias 2-27 offers a unique example of gravitational instability at work. It is young and massive, displaying two prominent spiral arms in dust continuum emission and global non-axisymmetric kinematic signatures in molecular line data. In this work, we used…
▽ More
Gravitational instability is thought to be one of the main drivers of angular momentum transport in young protoplanetary discs. The disc around Elias 2-27 offers a unique example of gravitational instability at work. It is young and massive, displaying two prominent spiral arms in dust continuum emission and global non-axisymmetric kinematic signatures in molecular line data. In this work, we used archival ALMA observations of $^{13}$CO line emission to measure the efficiency of angular momentum transport in the Elias 2-27 system through the kinematic signatures generated by gravitational instability, known as 'GI wiggles'. Assuming the angular momentum is transported by the observed spiral structure and leveraging previously-derived dynamical disc mass measurements, the amount of angular momentum transport we found corresponds to an $α-$viscosity of $α=0.038\pm0.018$. This value implies an accretion rate onto the central star of $\log_{10}\dot{M}_\star=-6.99\pm0.17\text{M}_\odot/\text{yr, which}$ reproduces the one observed value of $\log_{10}\dot{M}_{\star,\text{obs}}=-7.2\pm0.5\text{M}_\odot/\text{yr }$ very well. The excellent agreement we have found serves as further proof that gravitational instability is the main driver of angular momentum transport acting in this system.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2024; v1 submitted 9 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Planet-driven spirals in protoplanetary discs: limitations of the semi-analytical theory for observations
Authors:
D. Fasano,
A. J. Winter,
M. Benisty,
G. Rosotti,
A. Ruzza,
G. Lodato,
C. Toci,
T. Hilder,
A. Izquierdo,
D. Price
Abstract:
Detecting protoplanets during their formation stage is an important but elusive goal of modern astronomy. Kinematic detections via the spiral wakes in the gaseous disc are a promising avenue to achieve this goal. We aim to test the applicability to observations in the low and intermediate planet mass regimes of a commonly used semi-analytical model for planet induced spiral waves. In contrast with…
▽ More
Detecting protoplanets during their formation stage is an important but elusive goal of modern astronomy. Kinematic detections via the spiral wakes in the gaseous disc are a promising avenue to achieve this goal. We aim to test the applicability to observations in the low and intermediate planet mass regimes of a commonly used semi-analytical model for planet induced spiral waves. In contrast with previous works which proposed to use the semi-analytical model to interpret observations, in this study we analyse for the first time both the structure of the velocity and density perturbations. We run a set of FARGO3D hydrodynamic simulations and compare them with the output of the semi-analytic model in the code wakeflow, which is obtained by solving Burgers' equation using the simulations as an initial condition. We find that the velocity field derived from the analytic theory is discontinuous at the interface between the linear and nonlinear regions. After 0.2 r$_p$ from the planet, the behaviour of the velocity field closely follows that of the density perturbations. In the low mass limit, the analytical model is in qualitative agreement with the simulations, although it underestimates the azimuthal width and the amplitude of the perturbations, predicting a stronger decay but a slower azimuthal advance of the shock fronts. In the intermediate regime, the discrepancy increases, resulting in a different pitch angle between the spirals of the simulations and the analytic model. The implementation of a fitting procedure based on the minimisation of intensity residuals is bound to fail due to the deviation in pitch angle between the analytic model and the simulations. In order to apply this model to observations, it needs to be revisited accounting also for higher planet masses.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2024; v1 submitted 24 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Orbital dynamics in the GG Tau A system: investigating its enigmatic disc
Authors:
Claudia Toci,
Simone Ceppi,
Nicolás Cuello,
Gaspard Duchêne,
Enrico Ragusa,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Francesca Farina,
François Ménard,
Hossam Aly
Abstract:
GG Tau is one of the most studied multiple young stellar systems: GG Tau A is a hierarchical triple surrounded by a massive disc and its companion, GG Tau B, is also a binary. Despite numerous observational attempts, an understanding of the geometry of the GG Tau A system is still elusive. We provide new astrometric measures of the system and we run a set of hydrodynamical simulations with two rep…
▽ More
GG Tau is one of the most studied multiple young stellar systems: GG Tau A is a hierarchical triple surrounded by a massive disc and its companion, GG Tau B, is also a binary. Despite numerous observational attempts, an understanding of the geometry of the GG Tau A system is still elusive. We provide new astrometric measures of the system and we run a set of hydrodynamical simulations with two representative orbits to test how they impact a disc composed of dust and gas. We test the dynamical evolution of the two scenarios on short and long timescales. We obtain synthetic flux emission from our simulations and we compare them with 1300 $μ$m ALMA dust continuum emission and 1.67 $μ$m SPHERE dust scattering images to infer the most likely orbital arrangement. We extend the analysis of the binary orbital parameters using six new epochs from archival data, showing that the current measurements alone are not capable of breaking the degeneracy between families of coplanar and misaligned orbits. We found that the time-scale for the onset of the disc eccentricity growth, $τ_{ecc}$, is a fundamental time-scale for the morphology of the system. Results from numerical simulations show that the best match between is obtained with the misaligned configuration ($Δθ= 30^\circ$) on timescales shorter than $τ_{ecc}$. The results exhibit an almost circular cavity and dust ring. However, for both scenarios, the cavity size and its eccentricity quickly grow for timescales longer than $τ_{ecc}$ and the models do not reproduce the observed morphology anymore. This implies that either the age of the system is shorter than $τ_{ecc}$ or that the disc eccentricity growth is not triggered or dissipated. This finding raises questions on the future evolution of the GG Tau A system and, more in general, on the time evolution of eccentric binaries and their circumbinary discs.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Full orbital solutions in pre-main sequence high-order multiple systems: GG Tau Ab and UX Tau B
Authors:
Gaspard Duchêne,
Jean-Baptiste LeBouquin,
François Ménard,
Nicolás Cuello,
Claudia Toci,
Maud Langlois
Abstract:
High-order multiple (triple and beyond) systems are relatively common. Their interaction with circumstellar and circumbinary material can have a large impact on the formation and evolution of planetary systems and depends on their orbital properties. GG\,Tau and UX\,Tau are two pre-main sequence high-order multiple systems in which the tightest pair has a projected separation of $\approx5$--20\,au…
▽ More
High-order multiple (triple and beyond) systems are relatively common. Their interaction with circumstellar and circumbinary material can have a large impact on the formation and evolution of planetary systems and depends on their orbital properties. GG\,Tau and UX\,Tau are two pre-main sequence high-order multiple systems in which the tightest pair has a projected separation of $\approx5$--20\,au. Characterizing precisely their orbits is crucial to establish their long-term stability, to predict the dynamics and evolution of circumstellar matter, and to evaluate the potential for planet formation in such systems. We combine existing astrometric measurements with previously unpublished high-resolution observations of the GG\,Tau\,Ab and UX\,Tau\,B pairs and perform Keplerian orbital fits. For GG\,Tau\,Ab the data presented here represent the first detection of orbital motion. For both systems they yield dramatic increases in orbital coverage ($\gtrsim60\%$ and $\approx100\%$ for UX\,Tau\,B and GG\,Tau\,Ab, for orbital periods of $\approx32$ and $\approx8$\,yr, respectively) and allow us to obtain well-constrained orbital fits, including dynamical masses with $\lesssim10\%$ and $\lesssim7\%$ random and systematic uncertainties. We find that both GG\,Tau\,A and UX\,Tau\,A--B likely form stable hierarchical systems, although one possible deprojection solution for GG\,Tau is strongly misaligned and could experience von Zeipel-Lidov-Kozai oscillations. We further find that the UX\,Tau\,B orbit is much more eccentric than the GG\,Tau\,Ab one, possibly explaining the lack of circumstellar material in the former. The newly-determined orbits revive the question of the dynamical fate of gas and dust in these two hierarchical systems and should spur new dedicated simulations to assess the long-term evolution of the systems and the dynamical perturbations imposed by the close binaries they host.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
The time evolution of $M_{\mathrm{d}}/\dot M$ in protoplanetary discs as a way to disentangle between viscosity and MHD winds
Authors:
Alice Somigliana,
Leonardo Testi,
Giovanni Rosotti,
Claudia Toci,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Benoît Tabone,
Carlo Manara,
Marco Tazzari
Abstract:
As the classic viscous paradigm for protoplanetary disk accretion is challenged by the observational evidence of low turbulence, the alternative scenario of MHD disk winds is being explored as potentially able to reproduce the same observed features traditionally explained with viscosity. Although the two models lead to different disk properties, none of them has been ruled out by observations - m…
▽ More
As the classic viscous paradigm for protoplanetary disk accretion is challenged by the observational evidence of low turbulence, the alternative scenario of MHD disk winds is being explored as potentially able to reproduce the same observed features traditionally explained with viscosity. Although the two models lead to different disk properties, none of them has been ruled out by observations - mainly due to instrumental limitations. In this work, we present a viable method to distinguish between the viscous and MHD framework based on the different evolution of the distribution in the disk mass ($M_{\mathrm{d}}$) - accretion rate ($\dot M$) plane of a disk population. With a synergy of analytical calculations and 1D numerical simulations, performed with the population synthesis code \texttt{Diskpop}, we find that both mechanisms predict the spread of the observed ratio $M_{\mathrm{d}}/\dot M$ in a disk population to decrease over time; however, this effect is much less pronounced in MHD-dominated populations as compared to purely viscous populations. Furthermore, we demonstrate that this difference is detectable with the current observational facilities: we show that convolving the intrinsic spread with the observational uncertainties does not affect our result, as the observed spread in the MHD case remains significantly larger than in the viscous scenario. While the most recent data available show a better agreement with the wind model, ongoing and future efforts to obtain direct gas mass measurements with ALMA and ngVLA will cause a reassessment of this comparison in the near future.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Radio multiwavelength analysis of the compact disk CX Tau: Presence of strong free-free variability or anomalous microwave emission
Authors:
Pietro Curone,
Leonardo Testi,
Enrique Macias,
Marco Tazzari,
Stefano Facchini,
Jonathan P. Williams,
Cathie J. Clarke,
Antonella Natta,
Giovanni Rosotti,
Claudia Toci,
Giuseppe Lodato
Abstract:
Protoplanetary disks emit radiation across a broad range of wavelengths, requiring a multiwavelength approach to fully understand their physical mechanisms and how they form planets. Observations at sub-millimeter to centimeter wavelengths can provide insights into the thermal emission from dust, free-free emission from ionized gas, and possible gyro-synchrotron emission from the stellar magnetosp…
▽ More
Protoplanetary disks emit radiation across a broad range of wavelengths, requiring a multiwavelength approach to fully understand their physical mechanisms and how they form planets. Observations at sub-millimeter to centimeter wavelengths can provide insights into the thermal emission from dust, free-free emission from ionized gas, and possible gyro-synchrotron emission from the stellar magnetosphere. This work is focused on CX Tau, a ${\sim}0.4\,M_\odot$ star with an extended gas emission and a compact and apparently structureless dust disk, with an average millimeter flux when compared to Class II sources in Taurus. We present observations from the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA) across four bands (between 9.0 mm and 6.0 cm) and combine them with archival data from the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA), the Submillimeter Array (SMA) and the Plateau de Bure Interferometer (PdBI). This multiwavelength approach allows us to separate the dust continuum from other emissions. After isolating the dust thermal emission, we derived an upper limit of the dust disk extent at 1.3 cm which is consistent with theoretical predictions of a radial drift-dominated disk. Centimeter data show a peculiar behavior: deep observations at 6.0 cm did not detect the source, while at 1.3 cm the flux density is anomalously higher than adjacent bands. Intraband spectral indices suggest a dominant contribution from free-free emission, whereas gyro-synchrotron emission is excluded. To explain these observations, we propose a strong variability among the free-free emission with timescales shorter than a month. Another possible interpretation is the presence of anomalous microwave emission from spinning dust grains.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2023; v1 submitted 20 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Testing protoplanetary disc evolution with CO fluxes. A proof of concept in Lupus and Upper Sco
Authors:
Francesco Zagaria,
Stefano Facchini,
Anna Miotello,
Carlo F. Manara,
Claudia Toci,
Cathie J. Clarke
Abstract:
The Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) revolutionised our understanding of protoplanetary discs. However, the available data have not given conclusive answers yet on the underlying disc evolution mechanisms (viscosity or MHD winds). Improving upon the current results, mostly based on the analysis of disc sizes, is difficult because larger, deeper and higher angular resolution surv…
▽ More
The Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) revolutionised our understanding of protoplanetary discs. However, the available data have not given conclusive answers yet on the underlying disc evolution mechanisms (viscosity or MHD winds). Improving upon the current results, mostly based on the analysis of disc sizes, is difficult because larger, deeper and higher angular resolution surveys would be required, which could be prohibitive even for ALMA. In this Letter, we introduce an alternative method to study disc evolution based on $^{12}$CO fluxes. In fact, fluxes can be readily collected using less time-consuming, lower resolution observations, while tracing the same disc physico-chemical processes as sizes: assuming that $^{12}$CO is optically thick, fluxes scale with the disc surface area. We developed a semi-analytical model to compute $^{12}$CO fluxes and benchmarked it against the results of DALI thermochemical models, recovering an agreement within a factor of three. As a proof of concept we compared our models with Lupus and Upper Sco data, taking advantage of the increased samples, by a factor 1.3 (Lupus) and 3.6 (Upper Sco), when studying fluxes instead of sizes. Models and data agree well only if CO depletion is considered. However, the uncertainties on the initial conditions limited our interpretation of the observations. Our new method can be used to design future ad hoc observational strategies to collect better data and give conclusive answers on disc evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2023; v1 submitted 4 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Confirmation and Keplerian motion of the gap-carving protoplanet HD 169142 b
Authors:
Iain Hammond,
Valentin Christiaens,
Daniel J. Price,
Claudia Toci,
Christophe Pinte,
Sandrine Juillard,
Himanshi Garg
Abstract:
We present the re-detection of a compact source in the face-on protoplanetary disc surrounding HD 169142, using VLT/SPHERE data in YJH bands. The source is found at a separation of 0.''319 ($\sim$37 au) from the star. Three lines of evidence argue in favour of the signal tracing a protoplanet: (i) it is found in the annular gap separating the two bright rings of the disc, as predicted by theory; (…
▽ More
We present the re-detection of a compact source in the face-on protoplanetary disc surrounding HD 169142, using VLT/SPHERE data in YJH bands. The source is found at a separation of 0.''319 ($\sim$37 au) from the star. Three lines of evidence argue in favour of the signal tracing a protoplanet: (i) it is found in the annular gap separating the two bright rings of the disc, as predicted by theory; (ii) it is moving at the expected Keplerian velocity for an object at $\sim$37 au in the 2015, 2017 and 2019 datasets; (iii) we also detect a spiral-shaped signal whose morphology is consistent with the expected outer spiral wake triggered by a planet in the gap, based on dedicated hydrodynamical simulations of the system. The YJH colours we extracted for the object are consistent with tracing scattered starlight, suggesting that the protoplanet is enshrouded in a significant amount of dust, as expected for a circumplanetary disc or envelope surrounding a gap-clearing Jovian-mass protoplanet.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2023; v1 submitted 22 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
An analytic solution to measure the gas size in protoplanetary discs in the viscous self-similar scenario
Authors:
Claudia Toci,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Francesco Gerardo Livio,
Giovanni Rosotti,
Leon Trapman
Abstract:
In order to understand which mechanism is responsible for accretion in protoplanetary discs, a robust knowledge of the observed disc radius using gas tracers such as $^{12}$CO and other CO isotopologues is pivotal. Indeed, the two main theories proposed, viscous accretion and wind-driven accretion, predict different time evolution for the disc radii. In this Letter, we present an analytical soluti…
▽ More
In order to understand which mechanism is responsible for accretion in protoplanetary discs, a robust knowledge of the observed disc radius using gas tracers such as $^{12}$CO and other CO isotopologues is pivotal. Indeed, the two main theories proposed, viscous accretion and wind-driven accretion, predict different time evolution for the disc radii. In this Letter, we present an analytical solution for the evolution of the disc radii in viscously evolving protoplanetary discs using $^{12}$CO as a tracer, under the assumption that the $^{12}$CO radius is the radius where the surface density of the disc is equal to the threshold for CO photo-dissociation. We discuss the properties of the solution and the limits of its applicability as a simple numerical prescription to evaluate the observed disc radii of populations of discs. Our results suggest that, in addition to photo-dissociation, also freeze out plays an important role in setting the disc size. We find an effective reduction of the CO abundance by about two orders of magnitude at the location of CO photo-dissociation, which however should not be interpreted as the bulk abundance of CO in the disc. The use of our analytical solution will allow to compute disc sizes for large quantities of models without using expensive computational resources such as radiative transfer calculations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2022; v1 submitted 26 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
External or internal companion exciting the spiral arms in CQ Tau?
Authors:
Iain Hammond,
Valentin Christiaens,
Daniel J. Price,
Maria Giulia Ubeira-Gabellini,
Jennifer Baird,
Josh Calcino,
Myriam Benisty,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Leonardo Testi,
Christophe Pinte,
Claudia Toci,
Davide Fedele
Abstract:
We present new high-contrast images in near-infrared wavelengths ($λ$ = 1.04, 1.24, 1.62, 2.18 and 3.78$μ$m) of the young variable star CQ Tau, aiming to constrain the presence of companions in the protoplanetary disc. We reached a Ks-band contrast of 14 magnitudes with SPHERE/IRDIS at separations greater than 0."4 from the star. Our mass sensitivity curve rules out giant planets above 4 M…
▽ More
We present new high-contrast images in near-infrared wavelengths ($λ$ = 1.04, 1.24, 1.62, 2.18 and 3.78$μ$m) of the young variable star CQ Tau, aiming to constrain the presence of companions in the protoplanetary disc. We reached a Ks-band contrast of 14 magnitudes with SPHERE/IRDIS at separations greater than 0."4 from the star. Our mass sensitivity curve rules out giant planets above 4 M$_{\rm Jup}$ immediately outside the spiral arms at $\sim$60 au and above 2-3 M$_{\rm Jup}$ beyond 100 au to 5$σ$ confidence assuming hot-start models. We do, however, detect four spiral arms, a double-arc and evidence for shadows in scattered light cast by a misaligned inner disc. Our observations may be explained by an unseen close-in companion on an inclined and eccentric orbit. Such a hypothesis would also account for the disc CO cavity and disturbed kinematics.
△ Less
Submitted 31 July, 2022; v1 submitted 18 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
On the time evolution of the $M_{\rm d} - M_\star$ and $\dot M - M_\star$ correlations for protoplanetary discs: the viscous timescale increases with stellar mass
Authors:
Alice Somigliana,
Claudia Toci,
Giovanni Rosotti,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Marco Tazzari,
Carlo Manara,
Leonardo Testi,
Federico Lepri
Abstract:
Large surveys of star-forming regions have unveiled power-law correlations between the stellar mass and the disc parameters, such as the disc mass $M_{\mathrm{d}} \propto {M_{\star}}^{λ_{\mathrm{m}}}$ and the accretion rate $\dot M \propto {M_{\star}}^{λ_{\mathrm{acc}}}$. The observed slopes appear to be increasing with time, but the reason behind the establishment of these correlations and their…
▽ More
Large surveys of star-forming regions have unveiled power-law correlations between the stellar mass and the disc parameters, such as the disc mass $M_{\mathrm{d}} \propto {M_{\star}}^{λ_{\mathrm{m}}}$ and the accretion rate $\dot M \propto {M_{\star}}^{λ_{\mathrm{acc}}}$. The observed slopes appear to be increasing with time, but the reason behind the establishment of these correlations and their subsequent evolution is still uncertain. We conduct a theoretical analysis of the impact of viscous evolution on power-law initial conditions for a population of protoplanetary discs. We find that, for evolved populations, viscous evolution enforces the two correlations to have the same slope, $λ_{\mathrm{m}}$ = $λ_{\mathrm{acc}}$, and that this limit is uniquely determined by the initial slopes $λ_{\mathrm{m}, 0}$ and $λ_{\mathrm{acc}, 0}$. We recover the increasing trend claimed from the observations when the difference in the initial values, $δ_0 = λ_{\mathrm{m}, 0} - λ_{\mathrm{acc}, 0}$, is larger than $1/2$; moreover, we find that this increasing trend is a consequence of a positive correlation between the viscous timescale and the stellar mass. We also present the results of disc population synthesis numerical simulations, that allow us to introduce a spread and analyse the effect of sampling, which show a good agreement with our analytical predictions. Finally, we perform a preliminary comparison of our numerical results with observational data, which allows us to constrain the parameter space of the initial conditions to $λ_{\mathrm{m}, 0} \in [1.2, 2.1]$, $λ_{\mathrm{acc}, 0} \in [0.7, 1.5]$.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
A giant planet sha** the disk around the very low-mass star CIDA 1
Authors:
P. Curone,
A. F. Izquierdo,
L. Testi,
G. Lodato,
S. Facchini,
A. Natta,
P. Pinilla,
N. T. Kurtovic,
C. Toci,
M. Benisty,
M. Tazzari,
F. Borsa,
M. Lombardi,
C. F. Manara,
E. Sanchis,
L. Ricci
Abstract:
(Abridged) Exoplanetary research has provided us with exciting discoveries of planets around very low-mass (VLM) stars (e.g., TRAPPIST-1 and Proxima Centauri). However, current theoretical models strive to explain planet formation in these conditions and do not predict the development of giant planets. Recent high-resolution observations from ALMA of the disk around CIDA 1, a VLM star in Taurus, s…
▽ More
(Abridged) Exoplanetary research has provided us with exciting discoveries of planets around very low-mass (VLM) stars (e.g., TRAPPIST-1 and Proxima Centauri). However, current theoretical models strive to explain planet formation in these conditions and do not predict the development of giant planets. Recent high-resolution observations from ALMA of the disk around CIDA 1, a VLM star in Taurus, show substructures hinting at the presence of a massive planet. We aim to reproduce the dust ring of CIDA 1, observed in the dust continuum emission in ALMA Band 7 (0.9 mm) and Band 4 (2.1 mm), along with its $^{12}$CO (J=3-2) and $^{13}$CO (J=3-2) channel maps, assuming the structures are shaped by the interaction of the disk with a massive planet. We seek to retrieve the mass and position of the putative planet. We model the protoplanetary disk with a set of hydrodynamical simulations, varying the mass and locations of the embedded planet. We compute the dust and gas emission using radiative transfer simulations, and, finally, we obtain the synthetic observations treating the images as the actual ALMA observations. Our models indicate that a planet with a minimum mass of $\sim1.4\,\text{M}_\text{Jup}$ orbiting at a distance of $\sim 9-10$ au can explain the morphology and location of the observed dust ring at Band 7 and Band 4. We can reproduce the low spectral index ($\sim 2$) observed where the dust ring is detected. Our synthetic images reproduce the morphology of the $^{12}$CO and $^{13}$CO observed channel maps where the cloud absorption allowed a detection. Applying an empirical relation between planet mass and gap width in the dust, we predict a maximum planet mass of $\sim4 - 8\,\text{M}_\text{Jup}$. Our results suggest the presence of a massive planet orbiting CIDA 1, thus challenging our understanding of planet formation around VLM stars.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2022; v1 submitted 20 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Accretion rates in hierarchical triple systems with discs
Authors:
Simone Ceppi,
Nicolás Cuello,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Cathie Clarke,
Claudia Toci,
Daniel J. Price
Abstract:
Young multiple systems accrete most of their final mass in the first few Myr of their lifetime, during the protostellar and protoplanetary phases. Previous studies showed that in binary systems the majority of the accreted mass falls onto the lighter star, thus evolving to mass equalisation. However, young stellar systems often comprise more than two stars, which are expected to be in hierarchical…
▽ More
Young multiple systems accrete most of their final mass in the first few Myr of their lifetime, during the protostellar and protoplanetary phases. Previous studies showed that in binary systems the majority of the accreted mass falls onto the lighter star, thus evolving to mass equalisation. However, young stellar systems often comprise more than two stars, which are expected to be in hierarchical configurations. Despite its astrophysical relevance, differential accretion in hierarchical systems remains to be understood. In this work, we investigate whether the accretion trends expected in binaries are valid for higher order multiples. We performed a set of 3D Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics simulations of binaries and of hierarchical triples (HTs) embedded in an accretion disc, with the code Phantom. We identify for the first time accretion trends in HTs and their deviations compared to binaries. These deviations, due to the interaction of the small binary with the infalling material from the circum-triple disc, can be described with a semi-analytical prescription. Generally, the smaller binary of a HT accretes more mass than a single star of the same mass as the smaller binary. We found that in a HT, if the small binary is heavier than the third body, the standard differential accretion scenario (whereby the secondary accretes more of the mass) is hampered. Reciprocally, if the small binary is lighter than the third body, the standard differential accretion scenario is enhanced. The peculiar differential accretion mechanism we find in HTs is expected to affect their mass ratio distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Investigating Protoplanetary Disk Cooling through Kinematics: Analytical GI Wiggle
Authors:
Cristiano Longarini,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Claudia Toci,
Benedetta Veronesi,
Cassandra Hall,
Ruobing Dong,
Jason Patrick Terry
Abstract:
It is likely that young protostellar disks undergo a self-gravitating phase. Such systems are characterized by the presence of a spiral pattern that can be either in a quasi-steady state or in a nonlinear unstable condition. This spiral wave affects both the gas dynamics and kinematics, resulting in deviations from the Keplerian rotation. Recently, a lot of attention has been devoted to kinematic…
▽ More
It is likely that young protostellar disks undergo a self-gravitating phase. Such systems are characterized by the presence of a spiral pattern that can be either in a quasi-steady state or in a nonlinear unstable condition. This spiral wave affects both the gas dynamics and kinematics, resulting in deviations from the Keplerian rotation. Recently, a lot of attention has been devoted to kinematic studies of planet-forming environments, and we are now able to measure even small perturbations of velocity field ($\lesssim 1 \%$ of the Keplerian speed) thanks to high spatial and spectral resolution observations of protostellar disks. In this work, we investigate the kinematic signatures of gravitational instability: we perform an analytical study of the linear response of a self-gravitating disk to a spiral-like perturbation, focusing our attention on the velocity field perturbations. We show that unstable disks have clear kinematic imprints into the gas component across the entire disk extent, due to the GI spiral wave perturbation, resulting in deviations from Keplerian rotation. The shape of these signatures depends on several parameters, but they are significantly affected by the cooling factor: by detecting these features, we can put constraints on protoplanetary disk cooling.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2022; v1 submitted 25 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Constraining protoplanetary disc mass using the GI wiggle
Authors:
J. P. Terry,
C. Hall,
Cristiano Longarini,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Claudia Toci,
B. Veronesi,
T. Paneque-Carreño,
C. Pinte
Abstract:
Exoplanets form in protoplanetary accretion discs. The total protoplanetary disc mass is the most fundamental parameter, since it sets the mass budget for planet formation. Although observations with the Atacama Large Millimeter/Submillimeter array (ALMA) have dramatically increased our understanding of these discs, total protoplanetary disc mass remains difficult to measure. If a disc is sufficie…
▽ More
Exoplanets form in protoplanetary accretion discs. The total protoplanetary disc mass is the most fundamental parameter, since it sets the mass budget for planet formation. Although observations with the Atacama Large Millimeter/Submillimeter array (ALMA) have dramatically increased our understanding of these discs, total protoplanetary disc mass remains difficult to measure. If a disc is sufficiency massive ($\gtrsim$ 10\% of the host star mass), it can excite gravitational instability (GI). Recently, it has been revealed that GI leaves kinematic imprints of its presence known as the "GI Wiggle." In this work, we use numerical simulations to empirically determine an approximately linear relationship between the amplitude of the wiggle and the host disc-to-star mass ratio, and show that measurements of the amplitude are possible with the spatial and spectral capabilities of ALMA. These measurements can therefore be used to constrain disc-to-star mass ratio.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2021; v1 submitted 25 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Circumbinary and circumstellar discs around the eccentric binary IRAS 04158+2805 -- a testbed for binary-disc interaction
Authors:
Enrico Ragusa,
Daniele Fasano,
Claudia Toci,
Gaspard Duchêne,
Nicolás Cuello,
Marion Villenave,
Gerrit van der Plas,
Giuseppe Lodato,
François Ménard,
Daniel J. Price,
Christophe Pinte,
Karl Stapelfeldt,
Schuyler Wolff
Abstract:
IRAS~04158+2805 has long been thought to be a very low mass T-Tauri star (VLMS) surrounded by a nearly edge-on, extremely large disc. Recent observations revealed that this source hosts a binary surrounded by an extended circumbinary disc with a central dust cavity. In this paper, we combine ALMA multi-wavelength observations of continuum and $^{12}$CO line emission, with H$α$ imaging and Keck ast…
▽ More
IRAS~04158+2805 has long been thought to be a very low mass T-Tauri star (VLMS) surrounded by a nearly edge-on, extremely large disc. Recent observations revealed that this source hosts a binary surrounded by an extended circumbinary disc with a central dust cavity. In this paper, we combine ALMA multi-wavelength observations of continuum and $^{12}$CO line emission, with H$α$ imaging and Keck astrometric measures of the binary to develop a coherent dynamical model of this system. The system features an azimuthal asymmetry detected at the western edge of the cavity in Band~7 observations and a wiggling outflow. Dust emission in ALMA Band 4 from the proximity of the individual stars suggests the presence of marginally resolved circumstellar discs. We estimate the binary orbital parameters from the measured arc of the orbit from Keck and ALMA astrometry. We further constrain these estimates using considerations from binary-disc interaction theory. We finally perform three SPH gas + dust simulations based on the theoretical constraints; we post-process the hydrodynamic output using radiative transfer Monte Carlo methods and directly compare the models with observations. Our results suggest that a highly eccentric $e\sim 0.5\textrm{--}0.7$ equal mass binary, with a semi-major axis of $\sim 55$ au, and small/moderate orbital plane vs. circumbinary disc inclination $θ\lesssim 30^\circ$ provides a good match with observations. A dust mass of $\sim 1.5\times 10^{-4} {\rm M_\odot}$ best reproduces the flux in Band 7 continuum observations. Synthetic CO line emission maps qualitatively capture both the emission from the central region and the non-Keplerian nature of the gas motion in the binary proximity.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
On the secular evolution of the ratio between gas and dust radii in protoplanetary discs
Authors:
Claudia Toci,
Giovanni Rosotti,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Leonardo Testi,
Leon Trapman
Abstract:
A key problem in protoplanetary disc evolution is understanding the efficiency of dust radial drift. This process makes the observed dust disc sizes shrink on relatively short timescales, implying that discs started much larger than what we see now. In this paper we use an independent constraint, the gas radius (as probed by CO rotational emission), to test disc evolution models. In particular, we…
▽ More
A key problem in protoplanetary disc evolution is understanding the efficiency of dust radial drift. This process makes the observed dust disc sizes shrink on relatively short timescales, implying that discs started much larger than what we see now. In this paper we use an independent constraint, the gas radius (as probed by CO rotational emission), to test disc evolution models. In particular, we consider the ratio between the dust and gas radius, $R_{\rm CO}/R_{\rm dust}$. We model the time evolution of protoplanetary discs under the influence of viscous evolution, grain growth, and radial drift. Then, using the radiative transfer code RADMC with approximate chemistry, we compute the dust and gas radii of the models and investigate how $R_{\rm CO}/R_{\rm dust}$ evolves. Our main finding is that, for a broad range of values of disc mass, initial radius, and viscosity, $R_{\rm CO}/R_{\rm dust}$ becomes large (>5) after only a short time (<1 Myr) due to radial drift. This is at odds with measurements in young star forming regions such as Lupus, which find much smaller values, implying that dust radial drift is too efficient in these models. Substructures, commonly invoked to stop radial drift in large, bright discs, must then be present, although currently unresolved, in most discs.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
ALMA 870 $μ$m continuum observations of HD 100546. Evidence of a giant planet on a wide orbit
Authors:
D. Fedele,
C. Toci,
L. Maud,
G. Lodato
Abstract:
This paper reports on a new analysis of archival ALMA $870\,μ$m dust continuum observations. Along with the previously observed bright inner ring ($r \sim 20-40\,$au), two addition substructures are evident in the new continuum image: a wide dust gap, $r \sim 40-150\,$au, and a faint outer ring ranging from $r \sim 150\,$au to $r \sim 250\,$au and whose presence was formerly postulated in low-angu…
▽ More
This paper reports on a new analysis of archival ALMA $870\,μ$m dust continuum observations. Along with the previously observed bright inner ring ($r \sim 20-40\,$au), two addition substructures are evident in the new continuum image: a wide dust gap, $r \sim 40-150\,$au, and a faint outer ring ranging from $r \sim 150\,$au to $r \sim 250\,$au and whose presence was formerly postulated in low-angular-resolution ALMA cycle 0 observations but never before observed. Notably, the dust emission of the outer ring is not homogeneous, and it shows two prominent azimuthal asymmetries that resemble an eccentric ring with eccentricity $e = 0.07 $. The characteristic double-ring dust structure of HD 100546 is likely produced by the interaction of the disk with multiple giant protoplanets. This paper includes new smoothed-particle-hydrodynamic simulations with two giant protoplanets, one inside of the inner dust cavity and one in the dust gap. The simulations qualitatively reproduce the observations, and the final masses and orbital distances of the two planets in the simulations are 3.1 $M_{J}$ at 15 au and 8.5 $M_{J}$ at 110 au, respectively. The massive outer protoplanet substantially perturbs the disk surface density distribution and gas dynamics, producing multiple spiral arms both inward and outward of its orbit. This can explain the observed perturbed gas dynamics inward of 100 au as revealed by ALMA observations of CO.
Finally, the reduced dust surface density in the $\sim 40-150\,$au dust gap can nicely clarify the origin of the previously detected H$_2$O gas and ice emission.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Dynamical dust traps in misaligned circumbinary discs: analytical theory and numerical simulations
Authors:
Cristiano Longarini,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Claudia Toci,
Hossam Aly
Abstract:
Recent observations have shown that circumbinary discs can be misaligned with respect to the binary orbital plane.The lack of spherical symmetry, together with the non-planar geometry of these systems, causes differential precession which might induce the propagation of warps. While gas dynamics in such environments is well understood, little is known about dusty discs. In this work, we analytical…
▽ More
Recent observations have shown that circumbinary discs can be misaligned with respect to the binary orbital plane.The lack of spherical symmetry, together with the non-planar geometry of these systems, causes differential precession which might induce the propagation of warps. While gas dynamics in such environments is well understood, little is known about dusty discs. In this work, we analytically study the problem of dust traps formation in misaligned circumbinary discs. We find that pile-ups may be induced not by pressure maxima, as the usual dust traps, but by a difference in precession rates between the gas and dust. Indeed, this difference makes the radial drift inefficient in two locations, leading to the formation of two dust rings whose position depends on the system parameters. This phenomenon is likely to occur to marginally coupled dust particles $(\text{St}\gtrsim1)$ as both the effect of gravitational and drag force are considerable. We then perform a suite of three-dimensional SPH numerical simulations to compare the results with our theoretical predictions. We explore the parameter space, varying stellar mass ratio, disc thickness, radial extension, and we find a general agreement with the analytical expectations. Such dust pile-up prevents radial drift, fosters dust growth and may thus promote the planet formation in circumbinary discs.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Planet migration, resonant locking and accretion streams in PDS70: Comparing models and data
Authors:
Claudia Toci,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Valentin Christiaens,
Davide Fedele,
Christophe Pinte,
Daniel J. Price,
Leonardo Testi
Abstract:
The disc surrounding PDS 70, with two directly imaged embedded giant planets, is an ideal laboratory to study planet-disc interaction. We present three-dimensional smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations of the system. In our simulations, planets, which are free to migrate and accrete mass, end up in a locked resonant configuration that is dynamically stable. We show that features observed at…
▽ More
The disc surrounding PDS 70, with two directly imaged embedded giant planets, is an ideal laboratory to study planet-disc interaction. We present three-dimensional smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations of the system. In our simulations, planets, which are free to migrate and accrete mass, end up in a locked resonant configuration that is dynamically stable. We show that features observed at infrared (scattered light) and millimetre (thermal continuum) wavelengths are naturally explained by the accretion stream onto the outer planet, without requiring a circumplanetary disc around planet c. We post-processed our near-infrared synthetic images in order to account for observational biases known to affect high-contrast images. Our successful reproduction of the observations indicates that planet-disc dynamical interactions alone are sufficient to explain the observations of PDS 70.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2020; v1 submitted 24 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
What causes the fragmentation of debris streams in TDEs?
Authors:
Andrea Sacchi,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Claudia Toci,
Valentina Motta
Abstract:
A tidal disruption event (TDE) occurs when a star passes too close to a supermassive black hole and gets torn apart by its gravitational tidal field. After the disruption, the stellar debris form an expanding gaseous stream. The morphology and evolution of this stream is particularly interesting as it ultimately determines the observational properties of the event itself. In this work we perform 3…
▽ More
A tidal disruption event (TDE) occurs when a star passes too close to a supermassive black hole and gets torn apart by its gravitational tidal field. After the disruption, the stellar debris form an expanding gaseous stream. The morphology and evolution of this stream is particularly interesting as it ultimately determines the observational properties of the event itself. In this work we perform 3D hydrodynamical simulations of the TDE of a star modelled as a polytropic sphere of index γ = 5/3, and study the gravitational stability of the resulting gas stream. We provide an analytical solution for the evolution of the stream in the bound, unbound and marginally bound case, that allows us to describe the stream properties and analyse the time-scales of the physical processes involved, applying a formalism developed in star formation context. Our results are that, when fragmentation occurs, it is fueled by the failure of pressure in supporting the gas against its self-gravity. We also show that a stability criterion that includes also the stream gas pressure proves to be far more accurate than one that only considers the black hole tidal forces, giving analytical predictions of the time evolution of the various forces associated to the stream. Our results point out that fragmentation occurs on timescales longer compared with the observational windows of these events and is thus not expected to give rise to significant observational features.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Effects of photoevaporation on protoplanetary disc `isochrones'
Authors:
Alice Somigliana,
Claudia Toci,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Giovanni Rosotti,
Carlo Felice Manara
Abstract:
Protoplanetary discs are the site of star and planet formation, and their evolution and consequent dispersal deeply affect the formation of planetary systems. In the standard scenario they evolve on timescales ~Myr due to the viscous transport of angular momentum. The analytical self-similar solution for their evolution predicts also specific disc isochrones in the accretion rate - disc mass plane…
▽ More
Protoplanetary discs are the site of star and planet formation, and their evolution and consequent dispersal deeply affect the formation of planetary systems. In the standard scenario they evolve on timescales ~Myr due to the viscous transport of angular momentum. The analytical self-similar solution for their evolution predicts also specific disc isochrones in the accretion rate - disc mass plane. However, photoevaporation by radiation emitted by the central star is likely to dominate the gas disc dispersal of the innermost region, introducing another (shorter) timescale for this process. In this paper, we include the effect of internal (X and EUV) photoevaporation on the disc evolution, finding numerical solutions for a population of protoplanetary discs. Our models naturally reproduce the expected quick dispersal of the inner region of discs when their accretion rates match the rate of photoevaporative mass loss, in line with previous studies. We find that photoevaporation preferentially removes the lightest discs in the sample. The net result is that, counter-intuitively, photoevaporation increases the average disc mass in the sample, by dispersing the lightest discs. At the same time, photoevaporation also reduces the mass accretion rate by cutting the supply of material from the outer to the inner disc. In a purely viscous framework, this would be interpreted as the result of a longer viscous evolution, leading to an overestimate of the disc age. Our results thus show that photoevaporation is a necessary ingredient to include when interpreting observations of large disc samples with measured mass accretion rates and disc masses. Photoevaporation leaves a characteristic imprint on the shape of the isochrone. Accurate data in the accretion rate - disc mass plane in the low disc mass region therefore give clues on the typical photoevaporation rate.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Long lived dust rings around HD169142
Authors:
Claudia Toci,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Davide Fedele,
Leonardo Testi,
Christophe Pinte
Abstract:
Recent ALMA observations of the protoplanetary disc around HD~169142 reveal a peculiar structure made of concentric dusty rings: a main ring at $\sim$20 au, a triple system of rings at $\sim 55-75$ au in millimetric continuum emission and a perturbed gas surface density from the $^{12}$CO,$^{13}$CO and C$^{18}$O$(J=2-1)$ surface brightness profile. In this Letter, we perform three-dimensional nume…
▽ More
Recent ALMA observations of the protoplanetary disc around HD~169142 reveal a peculiar structure made of concentric dusty rings: a main ring at $\sim$20 au, a triple system of rings at $\sim 55-75$ au in millimetric continuum emission and a perturbed gas surface density from the $^{12}$CO,$^{13}$CO and C$^{18}$O$(J=2-1)$ surface brightness profile. In this Letter, we perform three-dimensional numerical simulations and radiative transfer modeling exploring the possibility that two giant planets interacting with the disc and orbiting in resonant locking can be responsible for the origin of the observed dust inner rings structure. We find that in this configuration the dust structure is actually long lived while the gas mass of the disc is accreted onto the star and the giant planets, emptying the inner region. In addition, we also find that the innermost planet is located at the inner edge of the dust ring, and can accrete mass from the disc, generating a signature in the dust ring shape that can be observed in mm ALMA observations.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Sub-structure formation in starless cores
Authors:
C. Toci,
D. Galli,
A. Verdini,
L. Del Zanna,
S. Landi
Abstract:
Motivated by recent observational searches of sub-structure in starless molecular cloud cores, we investigate the evolution of density perturbations on scales smaller than the Jeans length embedded in contracting isothermal clouds, adopting the same formalism developed for the expanding Universe and the solar wind. We find that initially small amplitude, Jeans-stable perturbations (propagating as…
▽ More
Motivated by recent observational searches of sub-structure in starless molecular cloud cores, we investigate the evolution of density perturbations on scales smaller than the Jeans length embedded in contracting isothermal clouds, adopting the same formalism developed for the expanding Universe and the solar wind. We find that initially small amplitude, Jeans-stable perturbations (propagating as sound waves in the absence of a magnetic field), are amplified adiabatically during the contraction, approximately conserving the wave action density, until they either become nonlinear and steepen into shocks at a time $t_{\rm nl}$, or become gravitationally unstable when the Jeans length decreases below the scale of the perturbations at a time $t_{\rm gr}$. We evaluate analytically the time $t_{\rm nl}$ at which the perturbations enter the non-linear stage using a Burgers' equation approach, and we verify numerically that this time marks the beginning of the phase of rapid dissipation of the kinetic energy of the perturbations. We then show that for typical values of the rms Mach number in molecular cloud cores, $t_{\rm nl}$ is smaller than $t_{\rm gr}$, and therefore density perturbations likely dissipate before becoming gravitational unstable. Solenoidal modes grow at a faster rate than compressible modes, and may eventually promote fragmentation through the formation of vortical structures.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Polytropic models of filamentary interstellar clouds -II. Helical magnetic fields
Authors:
Claudia Toci,
Daniele Galli
Abstract:
We study the properties of magnetised cylindrical polytropes as models for interstellar filamentary clouds, extending the analysis presented in a companion paper (Toci & Galli 2014a). We formulate the general problem of magnetostatic equilibrium in the presence of a helical magnetic field, with the aim of determining the degree of support or compression resulting from the magnetisation of the clou…
▽ More
We study the properties of magnetised cylindrical polytropes as models for interstellar filamentary clouds, extending the analysis presented in a companion paper (Toci & Galli 2014a). We formulate the general problem of magnetostatic equilibrium in the presence of a helical magnetic field, with the aim of determining the degree of support or compression resulting from the magnetisation of the cloud. We derive scale-free solutions appropriate to describe the properties of the envelopes of filaments at radii larger than the flat-density region. In these solutions, the polytropic exponent determines the radial profiles of the density and the magnetic field. The latter decreases with radius less steeply than the density, and field lines are helices twisted over cylindrical surfaces. A soft equation of state supports magnetic configurations that preferentially compress and confine the filament, whereas in the isothermal limit the field provides support. For each value of the polytropic exponent, the Lorentz force is directed outward or inward depending on whether the pitch angle is below or above some critical value which is a function of the polytropic exponent only.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Polytropic models of filamentary interstellar clouds - I. Structure and stability
Authors:
Claudia Toci,
Daniele Galli
Abstract:
The properties of filamentary interstellar clouds observed at sub-millimetre wavelengths, especially by the Herschel Space Observatory, are analysed with polytropic models in cylindrical symmetry. The observed radial density profiles are well reproduced by negative-index cylindrical polytropes with polytropic exponent $1/3\lesssim γ_{\rm p} \lesssim 2/3$ (polytropic index…
▽ More
The properties of filamentary interstellar clouds observed at sub-millimetre wavelengths, especially by the Herschel Space Observatory, are analysed with polytropic models in cylindrical symmetry. The observed radial density profiles are well reproduced by negative-index cylindrical polytropes with polytropic exponent $1/3\lesssim γ_{\rm p} \lesssim 2/3$ (polytropic index $-3\lesssim n \lesssim -3/2$), indicating either external heating or non-thermal pressure components. However, the former possibility requires unrealistically high gas temperatures at the filament's surface and is therefore very unlikely. Non-thermal support, perhaps resulting from a superposition of small-amplitude Alfvén waves (corresponding to $γ_{\rm p}=1/2$), is a more realistic possibility, at least for the most massive filaments. If the velocity dispersion scales as the square root of the density (or column density) on the filament's axis, as suggested by observations, then polytropic models are characterised by a uniform width. The mass per unit length of pressure-bounded cylindrical polytropes depends on the conditions at the boundary and is not limited as in the isothermal case. However, polytropic filaments can remain stable to radial collapse for values of the axis-to-surface density contrast as large as the values observed only if they are supported by a non-isentropic pressure component.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.