-
Optimal photometry of point sources: Joint source flux and background determination on array detectors -- from theory to practical implementation
Authors:
Mario L. Vicuña,
Jorge F. Silva,
Rene A. Mendez,
Marcos E. Orchard,
Sebastian Espinosa,
Jeremy Tregloan-Reed
Abstract:
In this paper we study the joint determination of source and background flux for point sources as observed by digital array detectors. We explicitly compute the two-dimensional Cramér-Rao absolute lower bound (CRLB) as well as the performance bounds for high-dimensional implicit estimators from a generalized Taylor expansion. This later approach allows us to obtain computable prescriptions for the…
▽ More
In this paper we study the joint determination of source and background flux for point sources as observed by digital array detectors. We explicitly compute the two-dimensional Cramér-Rao absolute lower bound (CRLB) as well as the performance bounds for high-dimensional implicit estimators from a generalized Taylor expansion. This later approach allows us to obtain computable prescriptions for the bias and variance of the joint estimators. We compare these prescriptions with empirical results from numerical simulations in the case of the weighted least squares estimator (introducing an improved version, denoted stochastic weighted least-squares) as well as with the maximum likelihood estimator, finding excellent agreement. We demonstrate that these estimators provide quasi-unbiased joint estimations of the flux and background, with a variance that approaches the CRLB very tightly and are, hence, optimal, unlike the case of sequential estimation used commonly in astronomical photometry which is sub-optimal. We compare our predictions with numerical simulations of realistic observations, as well as with observations of a bona-fide non-variable stellar source observed with TESS, and compare it to the results from the sequential estimation of background and flux, confirming our theoretical expectations. Our practical estimators can be used as benchmarks for general photometric pipelines, or for applications that require maximum precision and accuracy in absolute photometry.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Optimal observational scheduling framework for binary and multiple stellar systems
Authors:
Miguel Videla,
Rene A. Mendez,
Jorge F. Silva,
Marcos E. Orchard
Abstract:
The optimal instant of observation of astrophysical phenomena for objects that vary on human time-sales is an important problem, as it bears on the cost-effective use of usually scarce observational facilities. In this paper we address this problem for the case of tight visual binary systems through a Bayesian framework based on the maximum entropy sampling principle. Our proposed information-driv…
▽ More
The optimal instant of observation of astrophysical phenomena for objects that vary on human time-sales is an important problem, as it bears on the cost-effective use of usually scarce observational facilities. In this paper we address this problem for the case of tight visual binary systems through a Bayesian framework based on the maximum entropy sampling principle. Our proposed information-driven methodology exploits the periodic structure of binary systems to provide a computationally efficient estimation of the probability distribution of the optimal observation time. We show the optimality of the proposed sampling methodology in the Bayes sense and its effectiveness through direct numerical experiments. We successfully apply our scheme to the study of two visual-spectroscopic binaries, and one purely astrometric triple hierarchical system. We note that our methodology can be applied to any time-evolving phenomena, a particularly interesting application in the era of dedicated surveys, where a definition of the cadence of observations can have a crucial impact on achieving the science goals.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Bayesian inference in single-line spectroscopic binaries with a visual orbit
Authors:
Miguel Videla,
Rene A. Mendez,
Ruben M. Claveria,
Jorge F. Silva,
Marcos E. Orchard
Abstract:
We present a Bayesian inference methodology for the estimation of orbital parameters on single-line spectroscopic binaries with astrometric data, based on the No-U-Turn sampler Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm. Our approach is designed to provide a precise and efficient estimation of the joint posterior distribution of the orbital parameters in the presence of partial and heterogeneous observati…
▽ More
We present a Bayesian inference methodology for the estimation of orbital parameters on single-line spectroscopic binaries with astrometric data, based on the No-U-Turn sampler Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm. Our approach is designed to provide a precise and efficient estimation of the joint posterior distribution of the orbital parameters in the presence of partial and heterogeneous observations. This scheme allows us to directly incorporate prior information about the system - in the form of a trigonometric parallax, and an estimation of the mass of the primary component from its spectral type - to constrain the range of solutions, and to estimate orbital parameters that cannot be usually determined (e.g. the individual component masses), due to the lack of observations or imprecise measurements. Our methodology is tested by analyzing the posterior distributions of well-studied double-line spectroscopic binaries treated as single-line binaries by omitting the radial velocity data of the secondary object. Our results show that the system's mass ratio can be estimated with an uncertainty smaller than 10% using our approach. As a proof of concept, the proposed methodology is applied to twelve single-line spectroscopic binaries with astrometric data that lacked a joint astrometric-spectroscopic solution, for which we provide full orbital elements. Our sample-based methodology allows us also to study the impact of different posterior distributions in the corresponding observations space. This novel analysis provides a better understanding of the effect of the different sources of information on the shape and uncertainty of the orbit and radial velocity curve.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Bayes-based orbital elements estimation in triple hierarchical stellar systems
Authors:
Constanza Villegas,
Rene A. Mendez,
Jorge F. Silva,
Marcos E. Orchard
Abstract:
Under certain rather prevalent conditions (driven by dynamical orbital evolution), a hierarchical triple stellar system can be well approximated, from the standpoint of orbital parameter estimation, as two binary star systems combined. Even under this simplifying approximation, the inference of orbital elements is a challenging technical problem because of the high dimensionality of the parameter…
▽ More
Under certain rather prevalent conditions (driven by dynamical orbital evolution), a hierarchical triple stellar system can be well approximated, from the standpoint of orbital parameter estimation, as two binary star systems combined. Even under this simplifying approximation, the inference of orbital elements is a challenging technical problem because of the high dimensionality of the parameter space, and the complex relationships between those parameters and the observations (astrometry and radial velocity). In this work we propose a new methodology for the study of triple hierarchical systems using a Bayesian Markov-Chain Monte Carlo-based framework. In particular, graphical models are introduced to describe the probabilistic relationship between parameters and observations in a dynamically self-consistent way. As information sources we consider the cases of isolated astrometry, isolated radial velocity, as well as the joint case with both types of measurements. Graphical models provide a novel way of performing a factorization of the joint distribution (of parameter and observations) in terms of conditional independent components (factors), so that the estimation can be performed in a two-stage process that combines different observations sequentially. Our framework is tested against three well-studied benchmark cases of triple systems, where we determine the inner and outer orbital elements, coupled with the mutual inclination of the orbits, and the individual stellar masses, along with posterior probability (density) distributions for all these parameters. Our results are found to be consistent with previous studies. We also provide a mathematical formalism to reduce the dimensionality in the parameter space for triple hierarchical stellar systems in general.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
The Submillimeter Active Region Excess Brightness Temperature during Solar Cycles 23 and 24
Authors:
C. Guillermo Giménez de Castro,
André L. G. Pereira,
J. Fernando Valle Silva,
Caius L. Selhorst,
Cristina H. Mandrini,
Germán D. Cristiani,
Jean-Pierre Raulin,
Adriana Valio
Abstract:
We report the temporal evolution of the excess brightness temperature above solar active regions (ARs) observed with the Solar Submillimeter Telescope (SST) at 212 (λ = 1.4 mm) and 405 GHz (λ = 0.7 mm) during Cycles 23 and 24. Comparison with the sunspot number (SSN) yields a Pearson's correlation coefficient R = 0.88 and 0.74 for 212 and 405 GHz, respectively. Moreover, when only Cycle 24 is take…
▽ More
We report the temporal evolution of the excess brightness temperature above solar active regions (ARs) observed with the Solar Submillimeter Telescope (SST) at 212 (λ = 1.4 mm) and 405 GHz (λ = 0.7 mm) during Cycles 23 and 24. Comparison with the sunspot number (SSN) yields a Pearson's correlation coefficient R = 0.88 and 0.74 for 212 and 405 GHz, respectively. Moreover, when only Cycle 24 is taken into account the correlation coefficients go to 0.93 and 0.81 for each frequency. We derive the spectral index α between SST frequencies and found a slight anti-correlation with the SSN (R = -0.25); however, since the amplitude of the variation is lower than the standard deviation we cannot draw a definite conclusion. Indeed, α remains almost constant within the uncertainties with a median value approximate to 0 characteristic of an optically thick thermal source. Since the origin of the AR submillimeter radiation is thermal continuum produced at chromospheric heights, the strong correlation between the excess brightness temperature and the magnetic cycle evolution could be related to the available free magnetic energy to be released in reconnection events.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Submillimeter radiation as the thermal component of the Neupert Effect
Authors:
Jorge Fernando Valle Silva,
C. Guillermo Giménez de Castro,
Paulo José de Aguiar Simões,
Jean-Pierre Raulin
Abstract:
The Neupert effect is the empirical observation that the time evolution of non-thermal emission (e.g. hard X-rays) is frequently proportional to the time derivative of the thermal emission flux (soft X-rays), or, vice versa, that time integrated non-thermal flux is proportional to thermal flux. We analyzed the GOES M2.2 event SOL2011-02-14T17:25, and found that the 212 GHz emission plays quite wel…
▽ More
The Neupert effect is the empirical observation that the time evolution of non-thermal emission (e.g. hard X-rays) is frequently proportional to the time derivative of the thermal emission flux (soft X-rays), or, vice versa, that time integrated non-thermal flux is proportional to thermal flux. We analyzed the GOES M2.2 event SOL2011-02-14T17:25, and found that the 212 GHz emission plays quite well the role of the thermal component of the Neupert effect. We show that the maximum of the hard X-ray flux for energies above 50 keV is coincident in time with the time-derivative of the 212 GHz flux, within the uncertainties. The microwave flux density at 15.4 GHz, produced by optically thin gyrosynchrotron mechanism, and hard-X rays above 25 keV mark the typical impulsive phase, and have similar time evolution. On the other hand, the 12 GHz emission is delayed by about 25 seconds with respect of the microwave and hard X-ray peak. We argue that this delay cannot be explained by magnetic trap** of non-thermal electrons. With all the observational evidence, we suggest that the 212 GHz emission is produced by thermal bremsstrahlung, initially in the chromosphere, and shifting to optically thin emission from thehot coronal loops at the end of the gradual phase.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2019; v1 submitted 3 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Visual binary stars with partially missing data: Introducing multiple imputation in astrometric analysis
Authors:
Ruben M. Claveria,
Rene A. Mendez,
Jorge F. Silva,
Marcos E. Orchard
Abstract:
Partial measurements of relative position are a relatively common event during the observation of visual binary stars. However, these observations are typically discarded when estimating the orbit of a visual pair. In this article we present a novel framework to characterize the orbits from a Bayesian standpoint, including partial observations of relative position as an input for the estimation of…
▽ More
Partial measurements of relative position are a relatively common event during the observation of visual binary stars. However, these observations are typically discarded when estimating the orbit of a visual pair. In this article we present a novel framework to characterize the orbits from a Bayesian standpoint, including partial observations of relative position as an input for the estimation of orbital parameters. Our aim is to formally incorporate the information contained in those partial measurements in a systematic way into the final inference. In the statistical literature, an imputation is defined as the replacement of a missing quantity with a plausible value. To compute posterior distributions of orbital parameters with partial observations, we propose a technique based on Markov chain Monte Carlo with multiple imputation. We present the methodology and test the algorithm with both synthetic and real observations, studying the effect of incorporating partial measurements in the parameter estimation. Our results suggest that the inclusion of partial measurements into the characterization of visual binaries may lead to a reduction in the uncertainty associated to each orbital element, in terms of a decrease in dispersion measures (such as the interquartile range) of the posterior distribution of relevant orbital parameters. The extent to which the uncertainty decreases after the incorporation of new data (either complete or partial) depends on how informative those newly-incorporated measurements are. Quantifying the information contained in each measurement remains an open issue.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2019; v1 submitted 14 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Optimality of the Maximum Likelihood estimator in Astrometry
Authors:
Sebastian Espinosa,
Jorge F. Silva,
Rene A. Mendez,
Rodrigo Lobos,
Marcos Orchard
Abstract:
The problem of astrometry is revisited from the perspective of analyzing the attainability of well-known performance limits (the Cramer-Rao bound) for the estimation of the relative position of light-emitting (usually point-like) sources on a CCD-like detector using commonly adopted estimators such as the weighted least squares and the maximum likelihood. Novel technical results are presented to d…
▽ More
The problem of astrometry is revisited from the perspective of analyzing the attainability of well-known performance limits (the Cramer-Rao bound) for the estimation of the relative position of light-emitting (usually point-like) sources on a CCD-like detector using commonly adopted estimators such as the weighted least squares and the maximum likelihood. Novel technical results are presented to determine the performance of an estimator that corresponds to the solution of an optimization problem in the context of astrometry. Using these results we are able to place stringent bounds on the bias and the variance of the estimators in close form as a function of the data. We confirm these results through comparisons to numerical simulations under a broad range of realistic observing conditions. The maximum likelihood and the weighted least square estimators are analyzed. We confirm the sub-optimality of the weighted least squares scheme from medium to high signal-to-noise found in an earlier study for the (unweighted) least squares method. We find that the maximum likelihood estimator achieves optimal performance limits across a wide range of relevant observational conditions. Furthermore, from our results, we provide concrete insights for adopting an adaptive weighted least square estimator that can be regarded as a computationally efficient alternative to the optimal maximum likelihood solution. We provide, for the first time, close-form analytical expressions that bound the bias and the variance of the weighted least square and maximum likelihood implicit estimators for astrometry using a Poisson-driven detector. These expressions can be used to formally assess the precision attainable by these estimators in comparison with the minimum variance bound.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Orbits for eighteen visual binaries and two double-line spectroscopic binaries observed with HRCAM on the CTIO SOAR 4m telescope, using a new Bayesian orbit code based on Markov Chain Monte Carlo
Authors:
Rene A. Mendez,
Ruben M. Claveria,
Marcos E. Orchard,
Jorge F. Silva
Abstract:
We present orbital elements and mass sums for eighteen visual binary stars of spectral types B to K (five of which are new orbits) with periods ranging from 20 to more than 500 yr. For two double-line spectroscopic binaries with no previous orbits, the individual component masses, using combined astrometric and radial velocity data, have a formal uncertainty of ~0.1 MSun. Adopting published photom…
▽ More
We present orbital elements and mass sums for eighteen visual binary stars of spectral types B to K (five of which are new orbits) with periods ranging from 20 to more than 500 yr. For two double-line spectroscopic binaries with no previous orbits, the individual component masses, using combined astrometric and radial velocity data, have a formal uncertainty of ~0.1 MSun. Adopting published photometry, and trigonometric parallaxes, plus our own measurements, we place these objects on an H-R diagram, and discuss their evolutionary status. These objects are part of a survey to characterize the binary population of stars in the Southern Hemisphere, using the SOAR 4m telescope+HRCAM at CTIO. Orbital elements are computed using a newly developed Markov Chain Monte Carlo algorithm that delivers maximum likelihood estimates of the parameters, as well as posterior probability density functions that allow us to evaluate the uncertainty of our derived parameters in a robust way. For spectroscopic binaries, using our approach, it is possible to derive a self-consistent parallax for the system from the combined astrometric plus radial velocity data ("orbital parallax"), which compares well with the trigonometric parallaxes. We also present a mathematical formalism that allows a dimensionality reduction of the feature space from seven to three search parameters (or from ten to seven dimensions - including parallax - in the case of spectroscopic binaries with astrometric data), which makes it possible to explore a smaller number of parameters in each case, improving the computational efficiency of our Markov Chain Monte Carlo code.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Analysis of the Bayesian Cramer-Rao lower bound in astrometry: Studying the impact of prior information in the location of an object
Authors:
Alex Echeverria,
Jorge F. Silva,
Rene A. Mendez,
Marcos Orchard
Abstract:
Context. The best precision that can be achieved to estimate the location of a stellar-like object is a topic of permanent interest in the astrometric community.
Aims. We analyse bounds for the best position estimation of a stellar-like object on a CCD detector array in a Bayesian setting where the position is unknown, but where we have access to a prior distribution. In contrast to a parametric…
▽ More
Context. The best precision that can be achieved to estimate the location of a stellar-like object is a topic of permanent interest in the astrometric community.
Aims. We analyse bounds for the best position estimation of a stellar-like object on a CCD detector array in a Bayesian setting where the position is unknown, but where we have access to a prior distribution. In contrast to a parametric setting where we estimate a parameter from observations, the Bayesian approach estimates a random object (i.e., the position is a random variable) from observations that are statistically dependent on the position.
Methods. We characterize the Bayesian Cramer-Rao (CR) that bounds the minimum mean square error (MMSE) of the best estimator of the position of a point source on a linear CCD-like detector, as a function of the properties of detector, the source, and the background.
Results. We quantify and analyse the increase in astrometric performance from the use of a prior distribution of the object position, which is not available in the classical parametric setting. This gain is shown to be significant for various observational regimes, in particular in the case of faint objects or when the observations are taken under poor conditions. Furthermore, we present numerical evidence that the MMSE estimator of this problem tightly achieves the Bayesian CR bound. This is a remarkable result, demonstrating that all the performance gains presented in our analysis can be achieved with the MMSE estimator.
Conclusions The Bayesian CR bound can be used as a benchmark indicator of the expected maximum positional precision of a set of astrometric measurements in which prior information can be incorporated. This bound can be achieved through the conditional mean estimator, in contrast to the parametric case where no unbiased estimator precisely reaches the CR bound.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Performance analysis of the Least-Squares estimator in Astrometry
Authors:
Rodrigo A. Lobos,
Jorge F. Silva,
Rene A. Mendez,
Marcos Orchard
Abstract:
We characterize the performance of the widely-used least-squares estimator in astrometry in terms of a comparison with the Cramer-Rao lower variance bound. In this inference context the performance of the least-squares estimator does not offer a closed-form expression, but a new result is presented (Theorem 1) where both the bias and the mean-square-error of the least-squares estimator are bounded…
▽ More
We characterize the performance of the widely-used least-squares estimator in astrometry in terms of a comparison with the Cramer-Rao lower variance bound. In this inference context the performance of the least-squares estimator does not offer a closed-form expression, but a new result is presented (Theorem 1) where both the bias and the mean-square-error of the least-squares estimator are bounded and approximated analytically, in the latter case in terms of a nominal value and an interval around it. From the predicted nominal value we analyze how efficient is the least-squares estimator in comparison with the minimum variance Cramer-Rao bound. Based on our results, we show that, for the high signal-to-noise ratio regime, the performance of the least-squares estimator is significantly poorer than the Cramer-Rao bound, and we characterize this gap analytically. On the positive side, we show that for the challenging low signal-to-noise regime (attributed to either a weak astronomical signal or a noise-dominated condition) the least-squares estimator is near optimal, as its performance asymptotically approaches the Cramer-Rao bound. However, we also demonstrate that, in general, there is no unbiased estimator for the astrometric position that can precisely reach the Cramer-Rao bound. We validate our theoretical analysis through simulated digital-detector observations under typical observing conditions. We show that the nominal value for the mean-square-error of the least-squares estimator (obtained from our theorem) can be used as a benchmark indicator of the expected statistical performance of the least-squares method under a wide range of conditions. Our results are valid for an idealized linear (one-dimensional) array detector where intra-pixel response changes are neglected, and where flat-fielding is achieved with very high accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Analysis of the Cramer-Rao lower uncertainty bound in the joint estimation of astrometry and photometry
Authors:
Rene A. Mendez,
Jorge F. Silva,
Rodrigo Orsotica,
Rodrigo Lobos
Abstract:
In this paper we use the Cramer-Rao lower uncertainty bound to estimate the maximum precision that could be achieved on the joint simultaneous (or 2D) estimation of photometry and astrometry of a point source measured by a linear CCD detector array. We develop exact expressions for the Fisher matrix elements required to compute the Cramer-Rao bound in the case of a source with a Gaussian light pro…
▽ More
In this paper we use the Cramer-Rao lower uncertainty bound to estimate the maximum precision that could be achieved on the joint simultaneous (or 2D) estimation of photometry and astrometry of a point source measured by a linear CCD detector array. We develop exact expressions for the Fisher matrix elements required to compute the Cramer-Rao bound in the case of a source with a Gaussian light profile. From these expressions we predict the behavior of the Cramer-Rao astrometric and photometric precision as a function of the signal and the noise of the observations, and compare them to actual observations - finding a good correspondence between them.
We show that the astrometric Cramer-Rao bound goes as $(S/N)^{-1}$ (similar to the photometric bound) but, additionally, we find that this bound is quite sensitive to the value of the background - suppressing the background can greatly enhance the astrometric accuracy.
We present a systematic analysis of the elements of the Fisher matrix in the case when the detector adequately samples the source (oversampling regime), leading to closed-form analytical expressions for the Cramer-Rao bound. We show that, in this regime, the joint parametric determination of photometry and astrometry for the source become decoupled from each other, and furthermore, it is possible to write down expressions (approximate to first order in the small quantities F/B or B/F) for the expected minimum uncertainty in flux and position. These expressions are shown to be quite resilient to the oversampling condition, and become thus very valuable benchmark tools to estimate the approximate behavior of the maximum photometric and astrometric precision attainable under pre-specified observing conditions and detector properties.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
