-
Modeling JWST MIRI-MRS Observations of T Cha: Mid-IR Noble Gas Emission Tracing a Dense Disk Wind
Authors:
Andrew D. Sellek,
Naman S. Bajaj,
Ilaria Pascucci,
Cathie J. Clarke,
Richard Alexander,
Chengyan Xie,
Giulia Ballabio,
Dingshan Deng,
Uma Gorti,
Andras Gaspar,
Jane Morrison
Abstract:
[Ne II] 12.81 $μ\mathrm{m}$ emission is a well-used tracer of protoplanetary disk winds due to its blueshifted line profile. MIRI-MRS recently observed T Cha, detecting this line along with lines of [Ne III], [Ar II] and [Ar III], with the [Ne II] and [Ne III] lines found to be extended while the [Ar II] was not. In this complementary work, we use these lines to address long-debated questions abou…
▽ More
[Ne II] 12.81 $μ\mathrm{m}$ emission is a well-used tracer of protoplanetary disk winds due to its blueshifted line profile. MIRI-MRS recently observed T Cha, detecting this line along with lines of [Ne III], [Ar II] and [Ar III], with the [Ne II] and [Ne III] lines found to be extended while the [Ar II] was not. In this complementary work, we use these lines to address long-debated questions about protoplanetary disk winds regarding their mass-loss rate, the origin of their ionization, and the role of magnetically-driven winds as opposed to photoevaporation. To this end, we perform photoionization radiative transfer on simple hydrodynamic wind models to map the line emission. We compare the integrated model luminosities to those observed with MIRI-MRS to identify which models most closely reproduce the data and produce synthetic images from these to understand what information is captured by measurements of the line extents. Along with the low degree of ionization implied by the line ratios, the relative compactness of [Ar II] compared to [Ne II] is particularly constraining. This requires Ne II production by hard X-rays and Ar II production by soft X-rays (and/or EUV) in an extended ($\gtrsim 10$ au) wind that is shielded from soft X-rays - necessitating a dense wind with material launched on scales down to ~1 au. Such conditions could be produced by photoevaporation, whereas an extended MHD wind producing equal shielding would likely underpredict the line fluxes. However, a tenuous inner MHD wind may still contribute to shielding the extended wind. This picture is consistent with constraints from spectrally-resolved line profiles.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Correlation between accretion rate and free-free emission in protoplanetary disks -- A multi-wavelength analysis of central mm/cm emission in transition disks
Authors:
Alessia A. Rota,
Jurrian D. Meijerhof,
Nienke van der Marel,
Logan Francis,
Floris S. van der Tak,
Andrew D. Sellek
Abstract:
The inner regions of protoplanetary disks are the locations where most of planets are thought to form and where processes that influence the global evolution of the disk, such as MHD-winds and photoevaporation, originate. Transition disks (TDs) with large inner dust cavities are the ideal targets to study the inner tens of au of disks, as the central emission can be fully disentangled from the out…
▽ More
The inner regions of protoplanetary disks are the locations where most of planets are thought to form and where processes that influence the global evolution of the disk, such as MHD-winds and photoevaporation, originate. Transition disks (TDs) with large inner dust cavities are the ideal targets to study the inner tens of au of disks, as the central emission can be fully disentangled from the outer disk emission. We present a homogeneous multi-wavelength analysis of the continuum emission in a sample of 11 TDs. We investigate the nature of the central emission close to the star, distinguishing between thermal dust and free-free emission. Spatially resolved measurements of continuum emission from archival ALMA data are combined with literature cm-wave observations to study the spectral indices of the inner and outer disks separately. While the emission from the outer disks is consistent with thermal dust emission, 10/11 of the spectral indices estimated for the central emission close to the star suggest that this emission is free-free emission, likely associated with an ionized jet or a disk wind. No correlation between the free-free luminosity and the accretion luminosity or the X-ray luminosity is found, arguing against the photoevaporative wind origin. A sub-linear correlation between the ionized mass loss rate and the accretion rate onto the star is observed, suggesting an origin in an ionized jet. The relative lack of mm-dust grains in the majority of inner disks in transition disks suggests that either such dust grains have drifted quickly towards the central star, grain growth is less efficient in the inner disk, or grains grow rapidly to planetesimal sizes in the inner disk. The observed correlation between the ionized mass loss rate and the accretion rate suggests the outflow is strictly connected with the stellar accretion and that accretion in these disks is driven by a jet.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2024; v1 submitted 11 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
FRIED v2. A new grid of mass loss rates for externally irradiated protoplanetary discs
Authors:
Thomas J. Haworth,
Gavin A. L. Coleman,
Lin Qiao,
Andrew D. Sellek,
Kanaar Askari
Abstract:
We present a new FRIED grid of mass loss rates for externally far-ultraviolet (FUV) irradiated protoplanetary discs. As a precursor to the new grid, we also explore the microphysics of external photoevaporation, determining the impact of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) abundance, metallicity, coolant depletion (via freeze out and radial drift) and grain growth (depletion of small dust in the…
▽ More
We present a new FRIED grid of mass loss rates for externally far-ultraviolet (FUV) irradiated protoplanetary discs. As a precursor to the new grid, we also explore the microphysics of external photoevaporation, determining the impact of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) abundance, metallicity, coolant depletion (via freeze out and radial drift) and grain growth (depletion of small dust in the outer disc) on disc mass loss rates. We find that metallicity variations typically have a small effect on the mass loss rate, since the impact of changes in heating, cooling and optical depth to the disc approximately cancel out. The new FRIED grid therefore focuses on i) expanding the basic physical parameter space (disc mass, radius, UV field, stellar mass) ii) on enabling variation of the the PAH abundance and iii) including an option for grain growth to have occurred or not in the disc. What we suggest is the fiducial model is comparable to the original FRIED grid. When the PAH-to-dust ratio is lower, or the dust in the wind more abundant, the mass loss rate can be substantially lower. We demonstrate with a small set of illustrative disc evolutionary calculations that this in turn can have a significant impact on the disc mass/radius/ evolution and lifetime.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
The importance of X-ray frequency in driving photoevaporative winds
Authors:
Andrew D. Sellek,
Cathie J. Clarke,
Barbara Ercolano
Abstract:
Photoevaporative winds are a promising mechanism for dispersing protoplanetary discs, but so far theoretical models have been unable to agree on the relative roles that the X-ray, Extreme Ultraviolet or Far Ultraviolet play in driving the winds. This has been attributed to a variety of methodological differences between studies, including their approach to radiative transfer and thermal balance, t…
▽ More
Photoevaporative winds are a promising mechanism for dispersing protoplanetary discs, but so far theoretical models have been unable to agree on the relative roles that the X-ray, Extreme Ultraviolet or Far Ultraviolet play in driving the winds. This has been attributed to a variety of methodological differences between studies, including their approach to radiative transfer and thermal balance, the choice of irradiating spectrum employed, and the processes available to cool the gas. We use the \textsc{mocassin} radiative transfer code to simulate wind heating for a variety of spectra on a static density grid taken from simulations of an EUV-driven wind. We explore the impact of choosing a single representative X-ray frequency on their ability to drive a wind by measuring the maximum heated column as a function of photon energy. We demonstrate that for reasonable luminosities and spectra, the most effective energies are at a few $100~\mathrm{eV}$, firmly in the softer regions of the X-ray spectrum, while X-rays with energies $\sim1000~\mathrm{eV}$ interact too weakly with disc gas to provide sufficient heating to drive a wind. We develop a simple model to explain these findings. We argue that further increases in the cooling above our models - for example due to molecular rovibrational lines - may further restrict the heating to the softer energies but are unlikely to prevent X-ray heated winds from launching entirely; increasing the X-ray luminosity has the opposite effect. The various results of photoevaporative wind models should therefore be understood in terms of the choice of irradiating spectrum.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
The evolution of protoplanetary discs in star formation and feedback simulations
Authors:
Lin Qiao,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Andrew D. Sellek,
Ahmad A. Ali
Abstract:
We couple star cluster formation and feedback simulations of a Carina-like star forming region with 1D disc evolutionary models to study the impact of external photoevaporation on disc populations in massive star forming regions. To investigate the effect of shielding of young stellar objects by star forming material, we track the FUV field history at each star in the cluster with two methods: i)…
▽ More
We couple star cluster formation and feedback simulations of a Carina-like star forming region with 1D disc evolutionary models to study the impact of external photoevaporation on disc populations in massive star forming regions. To investigate the effect of shielding of young stellar objects by star forming material, we track the FUV field history at each star in the cluster with two methods: i) Monte Carlo radiative transfer accounting for the shielding of stars from the FUV by the star forming cloud ii) Geometric dilution of the radiation from other stars which ignores shielding effects. We found that significant shielding only occurs for a small fraction of discs and offers protection from external photoevaporation for < 0.5 Myr. However, this initial protection can prevent significant early gas/dust mass loss and disc radius reduction due to external photoevaporation. Particularly, shielding for 0.5 Myr is sufficient for much of the solid reservoir to evolve to larger sizes where it will not be entrained in an external wind. Shielding is therefore potentially significant for terrestrial planet formation in retaining the solid mass budget, but the continued strip** of gas when shielding ends could still impact migration and the gas reservoir for giant planet atmospheres. Our models highlight issues with treating all discs in a cluster with a single characteristic age, since shielded objects are typically only the youngest. Our model predicts that the majority of discs in a 2 Myr Carina-like environment are subject to strong external photoevaporation.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
The general applicability of self-similar solutions for thermal disc winds
Authors:
Andrew D. Sellek,
Cathie J. Clarke,
Richard A. Booth
Abstract:
Thermal disc winds occur in many contexts and may be particularly important to the secular evolution and dispersal of protoplanetary discs heated by high energy radiation from their central star. In this paper we generalise previous models of self-similar thermal winds - which have self-consistent morphology and variation of flow variables - to the case of launch from an elevated base and to non-i…
▽ More
Thermal disc winds occur in many contexts and may be particularly important to the secular evolution and dispersal of protoplanetary discs heated by high energy radiation from their central star. In this paper we generalise previous models of self-similar thermal winds - which have self-consistent morphology and variation of flow variables - to the case of launch from an elevated base and to non-isothermal conditions. These solutions are well-reproduced by hydrodynamic simulations, in which, as in the case of isothermal winds launched from the mid-plane, we find winds launch at the maximum Mach number for which the streamline solutions extend to infinity without encountering a singularity. We explain this behaviour based on the fact that lower Mach number solutions do not fill the spatial domain. We also show that hydrodynamic simulations reflect the corresponding self-similar models across a range of conditions appropriate to photoevaporating protoplanetary discs, even when gravity, centrifugal forces, or changes in the density gradient mean the problem is not inherently scale free. Of all the parameters varied, the elevation of the wind base affected the launch velocity and flow morphology most strongly, with temperature gradients causing only minor differences. We explore how launching from an elevated base affects Ne II line profiles from winds, finding it increases (reduces) the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the line at low (high) inclination to the line of sight compared with models launched from the disc mid-plane and thus weakens the dependence of the FWHM on inclination.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Proplyds in the Flame Nebula NGC 2024
Authors:
Thomas J. Haworth,
**young S. Kim,
Andrew J. Winter,
Dean C. Hines,
Cathie J. Clarke,
Andrew D. Sellek,
Giulia Ballabio,
Karl R. Stapelfeldt
Abstract:
A recent survey of the inner $0.35\times0.35$pc of the NGC 2024 star forming region revealed two distinct millimetre continuum disc populations that appear to be spatially segregated by the boundary of a dense cloud. The eastern (and more embedded) population is $\sim0.2-0.5$Myr old, with an ALMA mm continuum disc detection rate of about $45\,$per cent. However this drops to only $\sim15$per cent…
▽ More
A recent survey of the inner $0.35\times0.35$pc of the NGC 2024 star forming region revealed two distinct millimetre continuum disc populations that appear to be spatially segregated by the boundary of a dense cloud. The eastern (and more embedded) population is $\sim0.2-0.5$Myr old, with an ALMA mm continuum disc detection rate of about $45\,$per cent. However this drops to only $\sim15$per cent in the 1Myr western population. When presenting this result, van Terwisga et al. (2020) suggested that the two main UV sources, IRS 1 (a B0.5V star in the western region) and IRS 2b (an O8V star in the eastern region, but embedded) have both been evaporating the discs in the depleted western population.
In this paper we report the firm discovery in archival HST data of 4 proplyds and 4 further candidate proplyds in NGC 2024, confirming that external photoevaporation of discs is occurring. However, the locations of these proplyds changes the picture. Only three of them are in the depleted western population and their evaporation is dominated by IRS 1, with no obvious impact from IRS 2b. The other 5 proplyds are in the younger eastern region and being evaporated by IRS 2b. We propose that both populations are subject to significant external photoevaporation, which happens throughout the region wherever discs are not sufficiently shielded by the interstellar medium. The external photoevaporation and severe depletion of mm grains in the 0.2-0.5Myr eastern part of NGC 2024 would be in competition even with very early planet formation.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
A dusty origin for the correlation between protoplanetary disc accretion rates and dust masses
Authors:
Andrew D. Sellek,
Richard A. Booth,
Cathie J. Clarke
Abstract:
Recent observations have uncovered a correlation between the accretion rates (measured from the UV continuum excess) of protoplanetary discs and their masses inferred from observations of the sub-mm continuum. While viscous evolution models predict such a correlation, the predicted values are in tension with data obtained from the Lupus and Upper Scorpius star forming regions; for example, they un…
▽ More
Recent observations have uncovered a correlation between the accretion rates (measured from the UV continuum excess) of protoplanetary discs and their masses inferred from observations of the sub-mm continuum. While viscous evolution models predict such a correlation, the predicted values are in tension with data obtained from the Lupus and Upper Scorpius star forming regions; for example, they underpredict the scatter in accretion rates, particularly in older regions. Here we argue that since the sub-mm observations trace the discs' dust, by explicitly modelling the dust grain growth, evolution, and emission, we can better understand the correlation. We show that for turbulent viscosities with $α\lesssim 10^{-3}$, the depletion of dust from the disc due to radial drift means we can reproduce the range of masses and accretion rates seen in the Lupus and Upper Sco datasets. One consequence of this model is that the upper locus of accretion rates at a given dust mass does not evolve with the age of the region. Moreover, we find that internal photoevaporation is necessary to produce the lowest accretion rates observed. In order to replicate the correct dust masses at the time of disc dispersal, we favour relatively low photoevaporation rates $\lesssim 10^{-9}~M_{\odot}~\mathrm{yr^{-1}}$ for most sources but cannot discriminate between EUV or X-ray driven winds. A limited number of sources, particularly in Lupus, are shown to have higher masses than predicted by our models which may be evidence for variations in the properties of the dust or dust trap** induced in substructures.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
The evolution of dust in discs influenced by external photoevaporation
Authors:
Andrew D. Sellek,
Richard A. Booth,
Cathie J. Clarke
Abstract:
Protoplanetary discs form and evolve in a wide variety of stellar environments and are accordingly exposed to a wide range of ambient far ultraviolet (FUV) field strengths. Strong FUV fields are known to drive vigorous gaseous flows from the outer disc. In this paper we conduct the first systematic exploration of the evolution of the solid component of discs subject to external photoevaporation. W…
▽ More
Protoplanetary discs form and evolve in a wide variety of stellar environments and are accordingly exposed to a wide range of ambient far ultraviolet (FUV) field strengths. Strong FUV fields are known to drive vigorous gaseous flows from the outer disc. In this paper we conduct the first systematic exploration of the evolution of the solid component of discs subject to external photoevaporation. We find that the main effect of photoevaporation is to reduce the reservoir of dust at large radii and this leads to more efficient subsequent depletion of the disc dust due to radial drift. Efficient radial drift means that photoevaporation causes no significant increase of the dust to gas ratio in the disc. We show that the disc lifetime in both dust and gas is strongly dependent on the level of the FUV background and that the relationship between these two lifetimes just depends on the Shakura-Sunyaev $α$ parameter, with the similar lifetimes observed for gas and dust in discs pointing to higher $α$ values ($\sim 10^{-2}$). On the other hand the distribution of observed discs in the plane of disc size versus flux at $850~μ$m is better reproduced by lower $α$ ($\sim 10^{-3}$). We find that photoevaporation does not assist rocky planet formation but need not inhibit mechanisms (such as pebble accretion at the water snow line) which can be effective sufficiently early in the disc's lifetime (i.e. well within a Myr).
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
