-
The evolution of collision debris near the $ν_6$ secular resonance and its role in the origin of terrestrial water
Authors:
Á. Süli,
E. Forgács-Dajka
Abstract:
This work presents novel findings that broadens our understanding of the amount of water that can be transported to Earth. The key innovation lies in the combined usage of Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH) and $N$-body codes to assess the role of collision fragments in water delivery. We also present a method for generating initial conditions that enables the projectile to impact at the design…
▽ More
This work presents novel findings that broadens our understanding of the amount of water that can be transported to Earth. The key innovation lies in the combined usage of Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH) and $N$-body codes to assess the role of collision fragments in water delivery. We also present a method for generating initial conditions that enables the projectile to impact at the designated location on the target's surface with the specified velocity. The primary objective of this study is to simulate giant collisions between two Ceres-sized bodies by SPH near the $ν_6$ secular resonance and follow the evolution of the ejected debris by numerical $N$-body code. With our method 6 different initial conditions for the collision were determined and the corresponding impacts were simulated by SPH. Examining the orbital evolution of the debris ejected after collisions, we measured the amount of water delivered to Earth, which is broadly 0.001 ocean equivalents of water, except in one case where one large body transported 7\% oceans of water to the planet. Based on this, and taking into account the frequency of collisions, the amount of delivered water varies between 1.2 and 8.3 ocean's worth of water, depending on the primordial disk mass. According to our results, the prevailing external pollution model effectively accounts for the assumed water content on Earth, whether it's estimated at 1 or 10 ocean's worth of water.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Statistics of collision parameters computed from 2D simulations
Authors:
Áron Süli
Abstract:
There are two popular ways to speed up simulations of planet formation via increasing the collision probability: ({\it i}) confine motion to 2D, ({\it ii}) artificially enhance the physical radii of the bodies by an expansion factor. In this paper I have performed 100 simulations each containing $10^4$ interacting bodies and computed the collision parameters from the results of the runs. Each run…
▽ More
There are two popular ways to speed up simulations of planet formation via increasing the collision probability: ({\it i}) confine motion to 2D, ({\it ii}) artificially enhance the physical radii of the bodies by an expansion factor. In this paper I have performed 100 simulations each containing $10^4$ interacting bodies and computed the collision parameters from the results of the runs. Each run was executed for a lower and a higher accuracy parameter. The main goal is to determine the probability distribution functions of the collision parameters and their dependence on the expansion factor. A simple method is devised to improve the determination of the collision parameters from the simulation data. It was shown that the distribution of the impact parameter is uniform and independent of the expansion factor. For real collisions the impact velocity is greater than 1 mutual escape velocity, a finding that can be explained using the two-body problem. The results casts some doubts on simulations of the terrestrial planets' final accretion that have assumed merge. Collision outcome maps were created adopting the fragmentation model of \cite{Leinhardt2012} to estimate the number of different types of collisions. A detailed comparison with earlier works indicates that there are similarities as well as significant differences between the different works. The results indicate that as the planetary disc matures and the masses of the bodies differs progressively than the majority of collisions lead to mass growth either via partial accretion or via graze-and-merge collision.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Chaos Control with Ion Propulsion
Authors:
Judit Sliz,
Tamas Kovacs,
Aron Suli
Abstract:
The escape dynamics around the triangular Lagrangian point L5 in the real Sun-Earth-Moon-Spacecraft system is investigated. Appearance of the finite time chaotic behaviour suggests that widely used methods and concepts of dynamical system theory can be useful in constructing a desired mission design. Existing chaos control methods are modified in such a way that we are able to protect a test parti…
▽ More
The escape dynamics around the triangular Lagrangian point L5 in the real Sun-Earth-Moon-Spacecraft system is investigated. Appearance of the finite time chaotic behaviour suggests that widely used methods and concepts of dynamical system theory can be useful in constructing a desired mission design. Existing chaos control methods are modified in such a way that we are able to protect a test particle from escape. We introduce initial condition maps in order to have a suitable numerical method to describe the motion in high dimensional phase space. Results show that the structure of initial condition maps can be split into two well-defined domains. One of these two parts has a regular contiguous shape and is responsible for long time escape; it is a long-lived island. The other one shows a filamentary fractal structure in initial condition maps. The short time escape is governed by this object. This study focuses on a low-cost method which successfully transfers a reference trajectory between these two regions using an appropriate continuous control force. A comparison of the Earth-Moon transfer is also presented to show the efficiency of our method.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Water delivery in the Early Solar System
Authors:
Rudolf Dvorak,
Siegfried Eggl,
Áron Süli,
Zsolt Sándor,
Mattia Galiazzo,
Elke Pilat-Lohinger
Abstract:
As part of the national scientific network 'Pathways to Habitable Worlds' the delivery of water onto terrestrial planets is a key question since water is essential for the development of life as we know it. After summarizing the state of the art we show some first results of the transport of water in the early Solar System for scattered main belt objects. Hereby we investigate the questions whethe…
▽ More
As part of the national scientific network 'Pathways to Habitable Worlds' the delivery of water onto terrestrial planets is a key question since water is essential for the development of life as we know it. After summarizing the state of the art we show some first results of the transport of water in the early Solar System for scattered main belt objects. Hereby we investigate the questions whether planetesimals and planetesimal fragments which have gained considerable inclination due to the strong dynamical interactions in the main belt region around 2 AU can be efficient water transporting vessels. The Hungaria asteroid group is the best example that such scenarios are realistic. Assuming that the gas giants and the terrestrial planets are already formed, we monitor the collisions of scattered small bodies containing water (in the order of a few percent) with the terrestrial planets. Thus we are able to give a first estimate concerning the respective contribution of such bodies to the actual water content in the crust of the Earth.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Collisions of planetesimals and formation of planets
Authors:
Rudolf Dvorak,
Thomas I. Maindl,
Áron Süli,
Christoph M. Schäfer,
Roland Speith,
Christoph Burger
Abstract:
We present preliminary results of terrestrial planet formation using on the one hand classical numerical integration of hundreds of small bodies on CPUs and on the other hand -- for comparison reasons -- the results of our GPU code with thousands of small bodies which then merge to larger ones. To be able to determine the outcome of collision events we use our smooth particle hydrodynamics (SPH) c…
▽ More
We present preliminary results of terrestrial planet formation using on the one hand classical numerical integration of hundreds of small bodies on CPUs and on the other hand -- for comparison reasons -- the results of our GPU code with thousands of small bodies which then merge to larger ones. To be able to determine the outcome of collision events we use our smooth particle hydrodynamics (SPH) code which tracks how water is lost during such events.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Control of chaos in the vicinity of the Earth--Moon L5 Lagrangian point to keep a spacecraft in orbit
Authors:
Judit Slíz,
Áron Süli,
Tamás Kovács
Abstract:
The concept of Space Manifold Dynamics is a new method of space research. We have applied it along with the basic idea of the method of Ott, Grebogi and York (OGY method) to stabilize the motion of a spacecraft around the triangular Lagrange point L5 of the Earth--Moon system. We have determined the escape rate of the trajectories in the general three- and four-body problem and estimated the avera…
▽ More
The concept of Space Manifold Dynamics is a new method of space research. We have applied it along with the basic idea of the method of Ott, Grebogi and York (OGY method) to stabilize the motion of a spacecraft around the triangular Lagrange point L5 of the Earth--Moon system. We have determined the escape rate of the trajectories in the general three- and four-body problem and estimated the average lifetime of the particles. Integrating the two models we mapped in detail the phase space around the L5 point of the Earth--Moon system. Using the phase space portrait our next goal was to apply a modified OGY method to keep a spacecraft close to the vicinity of L5. We modified the equation of motions with the addition of a time dependent force to the motion of the spacecraft. In our orbit--kee** procedure there are three free parameters: (i) the magnitude of the thrust, (ii) the start time and (iii) the length of the control. Based on our numerical experiments we were able to determine possible values for these parameters and successfully apply a control phase to a spacecraft to keep it on orbit around L5.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2015; v1 submitted 12 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
SPH-based simulation of multi-material asteroid collisions
Authors:
Thomas I. Maindl,
Christoph Schäfer,
Roland Speith,
Áron Süli,
Emese Forgács-Dajka,
Rudolf Dvorak
Abstract:
We give a brief introduction to smoothed particle hydrodynamics methods for continuum mechanics. Specifically, we present our 3D SPH code to simulate and analyze collisions of asteroids consisting of two types of material: basaltic rock and ice. We consider effects like brittle failure, fragmentation, and merging in different impact scenarios. After validating our code against previously published…
▽ More
We give a brief introduction to smoothed particle hydrodynamics methods for continuum mechanics. Specifically, we present our 3D SPH code to simulate and analyze collisions of asteroids consisting of two types of material: basaltic rock and ice. We consider effects like brittle failure, fragmentation, and merging in different impact scenarios. After validating our code against previously published results we present first collision results based on measured values for the Weibull flaw distribution parameters of basalt.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Detailed survey of the phase space around Nix and Hydra
Authors:
Áron Süli,
Zsuzsa Zsigmond
Abstract:
We present a detailed survey of the dynamical structure of the phase space around the new moons of the Pluto - Charon system. The spatial elliptic restricted three-body problem was used as model and stability maps were created by chaos indicators. The orbital elements of the moons are in the stable domain both on the semimajor axis - eccentricity and - inclination spaces. The structures related…
▽ More
We present a detailed survey of the dynamical structure of the phase space around the new moons of the Pluto - Charon system. The spatial elliptic restricted three-body problem was used as model and stability maps were created by chaos indicators. The orbital elements of the moons are in the stable domain both on the semimajor axis - eccentricity and - inclination spaces. The structures related to the 4:1 and 6:1 mean motion resonances are clearly visible on the maps. They do not contain the positions of the moons, confirming previous studies. We showed the possibility that Nix might be in the 4:1 resonance if its argument of pericenter or longitude of node falls in a certain range. The results strongly suggest that Hydra is not in the 6:1 resonance for arbitrary values of the argument of pericenter or longitude of node.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2009;
originally announced October 2009.
-
Dynamics of the TrES-2 system
Authors:
Florian Freistetter,
Áron Süli,
Barbara Funk
Abstract:
The TrES-2 system harbors one planet which was discovered with the transit technique. In this work we investigate the dynamical behavior of possible additional, lower-mass planets. We identify the regions where such planets can move on stable orbits and show how they depend on the initial eccentricity and inclination. We find, that there are stable regions inside and outside the orbit of TrES-2b…
▽ More
The TrES-2 system harbors one planet which was discovered with the transit technique. In this work we investigate the dynamical behavior of possible additional, lower-mass planets. We identify the regions where such planets can move on stable orbits and show how they depend on the initial eccentricity and inclination. We find, that there are stable regions inside and outside the orbit of TrES-2b where additional, smaller planets can move. We also show that those planets can have a large orbital inclination which makes a detection with the transit technique very difficult.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2009;
originally announced May 2009.
-
Secondary resonances of co-orbital motions
Authors:
B. Erdi,
I. Nagy,
Z. Sandor,
A. Suli,
G. Frohlich
Abstract:
The size distribution of the stability region around the Lagrangian point L4 is investigated in the elliptic restricted three-body problem as the function of the mass parameter and the orbital eccentricity of the primaries. It is shown that there are minimum zones in the size distribution of the stability regions, and these zones are connected with secondary resonances between the frequencies of…
▽ More
The size distribution of the stability region around the Lagrangian point L4 is investigated in the elliptic restricted three-body problem as the function of the mass parameter and the orbital eccentricity of the primaries. It is shown that there are minimum zones in the size distribution of the stability regions, and these zones are connected with secondary resonances between the frequencies of librational motions around L4. The results can be applied to hypothetical Trojan planets for predicting values of the mass parameter and the eccentricity for which such objects can be expected or their existence is less probable.
△ Less
Submitted 31 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
-
Solving Linearized Equations of the $N$-body Problem Using the Lie-integration Method
Authors:
Andras Pal,
Aron Suli
Abstract:
Several integration schemes exits to solve the equations of motion of the $N$-body problem. The Lie-integration method is based on the idea to solve ordinary differential equations with Lie-series. In the 1980s this method was applied for the $N$-body problem by giving the recurrence formula for the calculation of the Lie-terms. The aim of this works is to present the recurrence formulae for the…
▽ More
Several integration schemes exits to solve the equations of motion of the $N$-body problem. The Lie-integration method is based on the idea to solve ordinary differential equations with Lie-series. In the 1980s this method was applied for the $N$-body problem by giving the recurrence formula for the calculation of the Lie-terms. The aim of this works is to present the recurrence formulae for the linearized equations of motion of $N$-body systems. We prove a lemma which greatly simplifies the derivation of the recurrence formulae for the linearized equations if the recurrence formulae for the equations of motions are known. The Lie-integrator is compared with other well-known methods. The optimal step size and order of the Lie-integrator are calculated. It is shown that a fine-tuned Lie-integrator can be 30%-40% faster than other integration methods.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
-
Pluto's moon system: survey of the phase space I
Authors:
I. Nagy,
A. Suli,
B. Erdi
Abstract:
The dynamical structure of the phase space of the Pluto--Charon system is studied in the model of the spatial circular restricted three-body problem by using numerical methods. With the newly discovered two small satellites S/2005 P1 and S/2005 P2, the Pluto--Charon system can be considered as the first known binary system in which celestial bodies move in P-type orbits. It is shown that the two…
▽ More
The dynamical structure of the phase space of the Pluto--Charon system is studied in the model of the spatial circular restricted three-body problem by using numerical methods. With the newly discovered two small satellites S/2005 P1 and S/2005 P2, the Pluto--Charon system can be considered as the first known binary system in which celestial bodies move in P-type orbits. It is shown that the two satellites are in the stable region of the phase space and their origin by capture is unlikely. Also the large mass parameter allows to regard the satellites as a model of a new class of exoplanets orbiting around stellar binary systems.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2006; v1 submitted 24 February, 2006;
originally announced February 2006.
-
The stability of the terrestrial planets with a more massive "Earth"
Authors:
Áron Süli,
Rudolf Dvorak,
Florian Freistetter
Abstract:
Although the long-term numerical integrations of planetary orbits indicate that our planetary system is dynamically stable at least +/- Gyr, the dynamics of our Solar System includes both chaotic and stable motions: the large planets exhibit remarkable stability on gigayear timescales, while the subsystem of the terrestrial planets is weekly chaotic with a maximum Lyapunov exponent reaching the…
▽ More
Although the long-term numerical integrations of planetary orbits indicate that our planetary system is dynamically stable at least +/- Gyr, the dynamics of our Solar System includes both chaotic and stable motions: the large planets exhibit remarkable stability on gigayear timescales, while the subsystem of the terrestrial planets is weekly chaotic with a maximum Lyapunov exponent reaching the value of 1/5 Myr. In this paper the dynamics of the Sun--Venus--Earth--Mars-Jupiter--Saturn model is studied, where the mass of Earth was magnified via a mass factor $κ_E$. The resulting systems dominated by a massive Earth may serve also as models for exoplanetary systems that are similar to our one. This work is a continuation of our previous study, where the same model was used and the masses of the inner planets were uniformly magnified. That model was found to be substantially stable against the mass growth. Our simulations were undertaken for more then 100 different values of K for a time of 20, in some cases for 100 Myrs. A major result was the appearance of an instability window at K = 5, where Mars escaped. This new result has important implications for the theories of the planetary system formation process and mechanism. It is shown that with increasing K the system splits into two, well separated subsystems: one consists of the inner, the other one consists of the outer planets. According to the results the model became more stable as K increases and only when K >= 540 Mars escaped, on a Myr timescale. We found an interesting protection mechanism for Venus. These results give insights also to the stability of the habitable zone of exoplanetary systems, which harbour planets with relatively small eccentricities and inclinations.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2005;
originally announced August 2005.
