Showing 1–50 of 61 results for author: Rein, H

TRACE: a Time-Reversible Algorithm for Close Encounters

Authors: Tiger Lu, David M. Hernandez, Hanno Rein

Abstract: We present TRACE, a time-reversible hybrid integrator for the planetary N-body problem. Like hybrid symplectic integrators, TRACE can resolve close encounters between particles while retaining many of the accuracy and speed advantages of a fixed timestep symplectic method such the Wisdom-Holman map. TRACE switches methods time-reversibly during close encounters following the prescription of Hernan… ▽ More We present TRACE, a time-reversible hybrid integrator for the planetary N-body problem. Like hybrid symplectic integrators, TRACE can resolve close encounters between particles while retaining many of the accuracy and speed advantages of a fixed timestep symplectic method such the Wisdom-Holman map. TRACE switches methods time-reversibly during close encounters following the prescription of Hernandez and Dehnen (2023). In this paper we describe the derivation and implementation of TRACE and study its performance for a variety of astrophysical systems. In all our test cases TRACE is at least as accurate and fast as the hybrid symplectic integrator MERCURIUS. In many cases TRACE's performance is vastly superior to that of MERCURIUS. In test cases with planet-planet close encounters, TRACE is as accurate as MECURIUS with a 13x speedup. If close encounters with the central star are considered, TRACE achieves good error performance while MERCURIUS fails to give qualitatively correct results. In ensemble tests of violent scattering systems, TRACE matches the high-accuracy IAS15 while providing a 20x speed-up. In large N systems simulating lunar accretion, TRACE qualitatively gives the same results as IAS15 but at a 47x speedup. We also discuss some cases such as von Zeipel-Lidov-Kozai cycles where hybrid integrators perform poorly and provide some guidance on which integrator to use for which system. TRACE is freely available within the REBOUND package. △ Less

Submitted 6 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: Submitted to MNRAS

Polluting White Dwarfs with Oort Cloud Comets

Authors: Dang Pham, Hanno Rein

Abstract: Observations point to old white dwarfs (WDs) accreting metals at a relatively constant rate over 8~Gyrs. Exo-Oort clouds around WDs have been proposed as potential reservoirs of materials, with galactic tide as a mechanism to deliver distant comets to the WD's Roche limit. In this work, we characterise the dynamics of comets around a WD with a companion having semi-major axes on the orders of 10 -… ▽ More Observations point to old white dwarfs (WDs) accreting metals at a relatively constant rate over 8~Gyrs. Exo-Oort clouds around WDs have been proposed as potential reservoirs of materials, with galactic tide as a mechanism to deliver distant comets to the WD's Roche limit. In this work, we characterise the dynamics of comets around a WD with a companion having semi-major axes on the orders of 10 - 100 AU. We develop simulation techniques capable of integrating a large number ($10^8$) of objects over a 1 Gyr timescale. Our simulations include galactic tide and are capable of resolving close-interactions with a massive companion. Through simulations, we study the accretion rate of exo-Oort cloud comets into a WD's Roche limit. We also characterise the dynamics of precession and scattering induced on a comet by a massive companion. We find that (i) WD pollution by an exo-Oort cloud can be sustained over a Gyr timescale, (ii) an exo-Oort cloud with structure like our own Solar System's is capable of delivering materials into an isolated WD with pollution rate $\sim 10^8 \mathrm{~g~s^{-1}}$, (iii) adding a planetary-mass companion reduces the pollution rate to $\sim 10^7 \mathrm{~g~s^{-1}}$, and (iv) if the companion is stellar-mass, with $M_p \gtrsim 0.1 M_\odot$, the pollution rate reduces to $\sim 3 \times 10^5 \mathrm{~g~s^{-1}}$ due to a combination of precession induced on a comet by the companion, a strong scattering barrier, and low-likelihood of direct collisions of comets with the companion. △ Less

Submitted 10 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: 19 content pages, 4 appendices, 18 figures; accepted for publication in MNRAS; doi: 10.1093/mnras/stae986

Satellite Visibility During the April 2024 Total Eclipse

Authors: Samantha M. Lawler, Hanno Rein, Aaron C. Boley

Abstract: On 8 April 2024, tens of millions of people across North America will be able to view a total solar eclipse. Such astronomical events have been important throughout history, but with nearly 10,000 satellites in orbit, we question whether total eclipses will now reveal a sky full of satellites, fundamentally changing this experience for humanity. Using the current population of Starlink satellites,… ▽ More On 8 April 2024, tens of millions of people across North America will be able to view a total solar eclipse. Such astronomical events have been important throughout history, but with nearly 10,000 satellites in orbit, we question whether total eclipses will now reveal a sky full of satellites, fundamentally changing this experience for humanity. Using the current population of Starlink satellites, we find that the brightest satellites would be naked-eye visible in dark skies, but the high sky brightness during totality will make them undetectable to the unaided eye. Our model does not take into account the effects of chance reflections from large, flat surfaces like solar panels, which we expect will cause glints and flares that could be visible from large satellites and abandoned rocket bodies. Time-lapse all-sky imaging might reveal satellites during the eclipse. △ Less

Submitted 27 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: submitted to RNAAS

A new timestep criterion for N-body simulations

Authors: Dang Pham, Hanno Rein, David S. Spiegel

Abstract: We derive a new criterion for estimating characteristic dynamical timescales in N-body simulations. The criterion uses the second, third, and fourth derivatives of particle positions: acceleration, jerk, and snap. It can be used for choosing timesteps in integrators with adaptive step size control. For any two-body problem the criterion is guaranteed to determine the orbital period and pericenter… ▽ More We derive a new criterion for estimating characteristic dynamical timescales in N-body simulations. The criterion uses the second, third, and fourth derivatives of particle positions: acceleration, jerk, and snap. It can be used for choosing timesteps in integrators with adaptive step size control. For any two-body problem the criterion is guaranteed to determine the orbital period and pericenter timescale regardless of eccentricity. We discuss why our criterion is the simplest derivative-based expression for choosing adaptive timesteps with the above properties and show its superior performance over existing criteria in numerical tests. Because our criterion uses lower order derivatives, it is less susceptible to rounding errors caused by finite floating point precision. This significantly decreases the volume of phase space where an adaptive integrator fails or gets stuck due to unphysical timestep estimates. For example, our new criterion can accurately estimate timesteps for orbits around a 50m sized Solar System object located at 40AU from the coordinate origin when using double floating point precision. Previous methods where limited to objects larger than 10km. We implement our new criterion in the high order IAS15 integrator which is part of the freely available N-body package REBOUND. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Comments: 8 pages, 7 figures, accepted for publication in The Open Journal of Astrophysics, notebooks to reproduce all figures can be found at https://github.com/hannorein/PhamReinSpiegel2024

Journal ref: The Open Journal of Astrophysics 7, January 2024

WHFast512: A symplectic N-body integrator for planetary systems optimized with AVX512 instructions

Authors: Pejvak Javaheri, Hanno Rein, Dan Tamayo

Abstract: We describe the implementation of the symplectic N-body integrator WHFast512 using Single Instruction Multiple Data (SIMD) parallelism and 512-bit Advanced Vector Extensions (AVX512). We are able to speed up integrations of planetary systems by up to 4.7x compared to the non-vectorized version of WHFast. WHFast512 can integrate the Solar System with 8 planets for 5 billion years in less than 1.4 d… ▽ More We describe the implementation of the symplectic N-body integrator WHFast512 using Single Instruction Multiple Data (SIMD) parallelism and 512-bit Advanced Vector Extensions (AVX512). We are able to speed up integrations of planetary systems by up to 4.7x compared to the non-vectorized version of WHFast. WHFast512 can integrate the Solar System with 8 planets for 5 billion years in less than 1.4 days. To our knowledge, this makes WHFast512 the fastest direct N-body integrator for systems of this kind. As an example, we present an ensemble of 40-Gyr integrations of the Solar System. Ignoring the Sun's post-main sequence evolution, we show that the instability rate is well captured by a diffusion model. WHFast512 is freely available within the REBOUND package. △ Less

Submitted 22 July, 2023; v1 submitted 11 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 8 pages, 4 figures, 4.7x faster, accepted by the Open Journal of Astrophysics, WHFast512 source code available at https://github.com/hannorein/rebound/

ASSIST: An Ephemeris-Quality Test Particle Integrator

Authors: Matthew J. Holman, Arya Akmal, Davide Farnocchia, Hanno Rein, Matthew J. Payne, Robert Weryk, Daniel Tamayo, David M. Hernandez

Abstract: We introduce ASSIST, a software package for ephemeris-quality integrations of test particles. ASSIST is an extension of the REBOUND framework and makes use of its IAS15 integrator to integrate test particle trajectories in the field of the Sun, Moon, planets, and 16 massive asteroids, with the positions of the masses coming from the JPL DE441 ephemeris and its associated asteroid perturber file. T… ▽ More We introduce ASSIST, a software package for ephemeris-quality integrations of test particles. ASSIST is an extension of the REBOUND framework and makes use of its IAS15 integrator to integrate test particle trajectories in the field of the Sun, Moon, planets, and 16 massive asteroids, with the positions of the masses coming from the JPL DE441 ephemeris and its associated asteroid perturber file. The package incorporates the most significant gravitational harmonics and general relativistic corrections. ASSIST also accounts for position- and velocity-dependent non-gravitational effects. The first order variational equations are included for all terms to support orbit fitting and covariance map**. This new framework is meant to provide an open-source package written in a modern language to enable high-precision orbital analysis and science by the small body community. ASSIST is open source, freely distributed under the GNU General Public license, version 3. △ Less

Submitted 28 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: Submitted to PSJ (27 January 2023), Revised (28 March 2023)

General relativistic precession and the long-term stability of the solar system

Authors: Garett Brown, Hanno Rein

Abstract: The long-term evolution of the solar system is chaotic. In some cases, chaotic diffusion caused by an overlap of secular resonances can increase the eccentricity of planets when they enter into a linear secular resonance, driving the system to instability. Previous work has shown that including general relativistic contributions to the planets' precession frequency is crucial when modelling the so… ▽ More The long-term evolution of the solar system is chaotic. In some cases, chaotic diffusion caused by an overlap of secular resonances can increase the eccentricity of planets when they enter into a linear secular resonance, driving the system to instability. Previous work has shown that including general relativistic contributions to the planets' precession frequency is crucial when modelling the solar system. It reduces the probability that the solar system destabilizes within 5 Gyr by a factor of 60. We run 1280 additional N-body simulations of the solar system spanning 12.5 Gyr where we allow the GR precession rate to vary with time. We develop a simple, unified, Fokker-Planck advection-diffusion model that can reproduce the instability time of Mercury with, without, and with time-varying GR precession. We show that while ignoring GR precession does move Mercury's precession frequency closer to a resonance with Jupiter, this alone does not explain the increased instability rate. It is necessary that there is also a significant increase in the rate of diffusion. We find that the system responds smoothly to a change in the precession frequency: There is no critical GR precession frequency below which the solar system becomes significantly more unstable. Our results show that the long-term evolution of the solar system is well described with an advection-diffusion model. △ Less

Submitted 9 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: 8 pages, 4 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

Self-Consistent Spin, Tidal and Dynamical Equations of Motion in the REBOUNDx Framework

Authors: Tiger Lu, Hanno Rein, Daniel Tamayo, Sam Hadden, Rosemary Mardling, Sarah C. Millholland, Gregory Laughlin

Abstract: We have introduced self-consistent spin, tidal and dynamical equations of motion into REBOUNDx, a library of additional effects for the popular N-body integrator REBOUND. The equations of motion used are derived from the constant time lag approximation to the equilibrium tide model of tidal friction. These effects will allow the study of a variety of systems where the full dynamical picture cannot… ▽ More We have introduced self-consistent spin, tidal and dynamical equations of motion into REBOUNDx, a library of additional effects for the popular N-body integrator REBOUND. The equations of motion used are derived from the constant time lag approximation to the equilibrium tide model of tidal friction. These effects will allow the study of a variety of systems where the full dynamical picture cannot be encapsulated by point particle dynamics. We provide several test cases and benchmark the code's performance against analytic predictions. The open-source code is available in the most recent release of REBOUNDx. △ Less

Submitted 28 February, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: Accepted to ApJ. 15 pages, 6 figures

Thermal hysteresis and front propagation in dense planetary rings

Authors: Rémy Larue, Henrik Latter, Hanno Rein

Abstract: Saturn's rings are composed of icy grains, most in the mm to m size ranges, undergoing several collisions per orbit. Their collective behaviour generates a remarkable array of structure over many orders of magnitude, much of it not well understood. On the other hand, the collisional properties and parameters of individual ring particles are poorly constrained; usually N-body simulations and kineti… ▽ More Saturn's rings are composed of icy grains, most in the mm to m size ranges, undergoing several collisions per orbit. Their collective behaviour generates a remarkable array of structure over many orders of magnitude, much of it not well understood. On the other hand, the collisional properties and parameters of individual ring particles are poorly constrained; usually N-body simulations and kinetic theory employ hard-sphere models with a coefficient of restitution $ε$ that is constant or a decreasing function of impact speed. Due to plastic deformation of surface regolith, however, it is likely that $ε$ will be more complicated, at the very least a non-monotonic function. We undertake N-body simulations with the REBOUND code with non-monotonic $ε$ laws to approximate surfaces that are friable but not sticking. Our simulations reveal that such ring models can support two thermally stable steady states for the same (dynamical) optical depth: a cold and a warm state. If the ring breaks up into radial bands of one or the other state, we find that warmer states tend to migrate into the colder states via a coherent travelling front. We also find stationary `viscous' fronts, which connect states of different optical depth, but the same angular momentum flux. We discuss these preliminary results and speculate on their implications for structure formation in Saturn's B and C-rings, especially with respect to structures that appear in Cassini images but not in occultations. △ Less

Submitted 9 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Comments: MNRAS, accepted

On the long-term stability of the Solar System in the presence of weak perturbations from stellar flybys

Authors: Garett Brown, Hanno Rein

Abstract: The architecture and evolution of planetary systems are shaped in part by stellar flybys. Within this context, we look at stellar encounters which are too weak to immediately destabilize a planetary system but are nevertheless strong enough to measurably perturb the system's dynamical state. We estimate the strength of such perturbations on secularly evolving systems using a simple analytic model… ▽ More The architecture and evolution of planetary systems are shaped in part by stellar flybys. Within this context, we look at stellar encounters which are too weak to immediately destabilize a planetary system but are nevertheless strong enough to measurably perturb the system's dynamical state. We estimate the strength of such perturbations on secularly evolving systems using a simple analytic model and confirm those estimates with direct N-body simulations. We then run long-term integrations and show that even small perturbations from stellar flybys can influence the stability of planetary systems over their lifetime. We find that small perturbations to the outer planets' orbits are transferred between planets, increasing the likelihood that the inner planetary system will destabilize. Specifically, our results for the Solar System show that relative perturbations to Neptune's semi-major axis of order 0.1% are strong enough to increase the probability of destabilizing the Solar System within 5 Gyrs by one order of magnitude. △ Less

Submitted 28 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

Comments: 11 pages, 7 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

An Implementation of Stochastic Forces for the N-body code REBOUND

Authors: Hanno Rein, Nick Choksi

Abstract: We describe the implementation of a new module which can be used to simulate physical systems in which the motion of particles is affected by stochastic forces. Such forces are expected to be present in turbulent circumstellar disks or remnant planetesimal disks. Our implementation offers a convenient way to generate correlated noise with a user-specified amplitude and auto-correlation time for ea… ▽ More We describe the implementation of a new module which can be used to simulate physical systems in which the motion of particles is affected by stochastic forces. Such forces are expected to be present in turbulent circumstellar disks or remnant planetesimal disks. Our implementation offers a convenient way to generate correlated noise with a user-specified amplitude and auto-correlation time for each particle. The module has minimal memory requirements and is freely available within the REBOUNDx additional effects library. △ Less

Submitted 13 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Comments: 3 pages, 1 figure, accepted by RNAAS, source code available at https://github.com/dtamayo/reboundx

Journal ref: Res. Notes AAS 6 95 (2022)

The vertical structure of debris disks and the impact of gas

Authors: Johan Olofsson, Philippe Thébault, Quentin Kral, Amelia Bayo, Anthony Boccaletti, Nicolás Godoy, Thomas Henning, Rob G. van Holstein, Karina Maucó, Julien Milli, Matías Montesinos, Hanno Rein, Antranik A. Sefilian

Abstract: The vertical structure of debris disks provides clues about their dynamical evolution and the collision rate of the unseen planetesimals. Thanks to the ever-increasing angular resolution of contemporary instruments and facilities, we are beginning to constrain the scale height of a handful of debris disks, either at near-infrared or millimeter wavelengths. Nonetheless, this is often done for indiv… ▽ More The vertical structure of debris disks provides clues about their dynamical evolution and the collision rate of the unseen planetesimals. Thanks to the ever-increasing angular resolution of contemporary instruments and facilities, we are beginning to constrain the scale height of a handful of debris disks, either at near-infrared or millimeter wavelengths. Nonetheless, this is often done for individual targets only. We present here the geometric modeling of eight disks close to edge-on, all observed with the same instrument (SPHERE) and using the same mode (dual-beam polarimetric imaging). Motivated by the presence of CO gas in two out of the eight disks, we then investigate the impact that gas can have on the scale height by performing N-body simulations including gas drag and collisions. We show that gas can quickly alter the dynamics of particles (both in the radial and vertical directions), otherwise governed by gravity and radiation pressure. We find that, in the presence of gas, particles smaller than a few tens of microns can efficiently settle toward the midplane at the same time as they migrate outward beyond the birth ring. For second generation gas ($M_\mathrm{gas} \leq 0.1$ $M_\oplus$), the vertical settling should be best observed in scattered light images compared to observations at millimeter wavelengths. But if the gas has a primordial origin ($M_\mathrm{gas} \geq 1$ $M_\oplus$), the disk will appear very flat both at near-infrared and sub-mm wavelengths. Finally, far beyond the birth ring, our results suggest that the surface brightness profile can be as shallow as $\sim -2.25$. △ Less

Submitted 16 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: Accepted in MNRAS, 18 pages, 11 Figures

BEBOP III. Observations and an independent mass measurement of Kepler-16 (AB) b -- the first circumbinary planet detected with radial velocities

Authors: Amaury H. M. J. Triaud, Matthew R. Standing, Neda Heidari, David V. Martin, Isabelle Boisse, Alexandre Santerne, Alexandre C. M. Correia, Lorana Acuña, Matthew Battley, Xavier Bonfils, Andrés Carmona, Andrew Collier Cameron, Pía Cortés-Zuleta, Georgina Dransfield, Shweta Dalal, Magali Deleuil, Xavier Delfosse, João Faria, Thierry Forveille, Nathan C. Hara, Guillaume Hébrard, Sergio Hoyer, Flavien Kiefer, Vedad Kunovac, Pierre F. L. Maxted , et al. (8 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: The radial velocity method is amongst the most robust and most established means of detecting exoplanets. Yet, it has so far failed to detect circumbinary planets despite their relatively high occurrence rates. Here, we report velocimetric measurements of Kepler-16A, obtained with the SOPHIE spectrograph, at the Observatoire de Haute-Provence's 193cm telescope, collected during the BEBOP survey fo… ▽ More The radial velocity method is amongst the most robust and most established means of detecting exoplanets. Yet, it has so far failed to detect circumbinary planets despite their relatively high occurrence rates. Here, we report velocimetric measurements of Kepler-16A, obtained with the SOPHIE spectrograph, at the Observatoire de Haute-Provence's 193cm telescope, collected during the BEBOP survey for circumbinary planets. Our measurements mark the first radial velocity detection of a circumbinary planet, independently determining the mass of Kepler-16~(AB)~b to be $0.313 \pm 0.039\,{\rm M}_{\rm Jup}$, a value in agreement with eclipse timing variations. Our observations demonstrate the capability to achieve photon-noise precision and accuracy on single-lined binaries, with our final precision reaching $\rm 1.5~m\,s^{-1}$ on the binary and planetary signals. Our analysis paves the way for more circumbinary planet detections using radial velocities which will increase the relatively small sample of currently known systems to statistically relevant numbers, using a method that also provides weaker detection biases. Our data also contain a long-term radial velocity signal, which we associate with the magnetic cycle of the primary star. △ Less

Submitted 13 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: under review at MNRAS, 7 pages, 4 figures, all RV data in appendix

Visibility Predictions for Near-Future Satellite Megaconstellations: Latitudes near 50 Degrees will Experience the Worst Light Pollution

Authors: S. M. Lawler, A. C. Boley, H. Rein

Abstract: Megaconstellations of thousands to tens of thousands of artificial satellites (satcons) are rapidly being developed and launched. These satcons will have negative consequences for observational astronomy research, and are poised to drastically interfere with naked-eye stargazing worldwide should mitigation efforts be unsuccessful. Here we provide predictions for the optical brightnesses and on-sky… ▽ More Megaconstellations of thousands to tens of thousands of artificial satellites (satcons) are rapidly being developed and launched. These satcons will have negative consequences for observational astronomy research, and are poised to drastically interfere with naked-eye stargazing worldwide should mitigation efforts be unsuccessful. Here we provide predictions for the optical brightnesses and on-sky distributions of several satcons, including Starlink, OneWeb, Kuiper, and StarNet/GW, for a total of 65,000 satellites on their filed or predicted orbits. We develop a simple model of satellite reflectivity, which is calibrated using published Starlink observations. We use this model to estimate the visible magnitudes and on-sky distributions for these satellites as seen from different places on Earth, in different seasons, and different times of night. For latitudes near 50 degrees North and South, satcon satellites make up a few percent of all visible point sources all night long near the summer solstice, as well as near sunrise and sunset on the equinoxes. Altering the satellites' altitudes only changes the specific impacts of the problem. Without drastic reduction of the reflectivities, or significantly fewer total satellites in orbit, satcons will significantly change the night sky worldwide. △ Less

Submitted 23 November, 2021; v1 submitted 9 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: accepted to AJ

A Bayesian neural network predicts the dissolution of compact planetary systems

Authors: Miles Cranmer, Daniel Tamayo, Hanno Rein, Peter Battaglia, Samuel Hadden, Philip J. Armitage, Shirley Ho, David N. Spergel

Abstract: Despite over three hundred years of effort, no solutions exist for predicting when a general planetary configuration will become unstable. We introduce a deep learning architecture to push forward this problem for compact systems. While current machine learning algorithms in this area rely on scientist-derived instability metrics, our new technique learns its own metrics from scratch, enabled by a… ▽ More Despite over three hundred years of effort, no solutions exist for predicting when a general planetary configuration will become unstable. We introduce a deep learning architecture to push forward this problem for compact systems. While current machine learning algorithms in this area rely on scientist-derived instability metrics, our new technique learns its own metrics from scratch, enabled by a novel internal structure inspired from dynamics theory. Our Bayesian neural network model can accurately predict not only if, but also when a compact planetary system with three or more planets will go unstable. Our model, trained directly from short N-body time series of raw orbital elements, is more than two orders of magnitude more accurate at predicting instability times than analytical estimators, while also reducing the bias of existing machine learning algorithms by nearly a factor of three. Despite being trained on compact resonant and near-resonant three-planet configurations, the model demonstrates robust generalization to both non-resonant and higher multiplicity configurations, in the latter case outperforming models fit to that specific set of integrations. The model computes instability estimates up to five orders of magnitude faster than a numerical integrator, and unlike previous efforts provides confidence intervals on its predictions. Our inference model is publicly available in the SPOCK package, with training code open-sourced. △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: 8 content pages, 7 appendix and references. 8 figures. Source code at: https://github.com/MilesCranmer/bnn_chaos_model inference code at https://github.com/dtamayo/spock

A repository of vanilla long term integrations of the Solar System

Authors: Garett Brown, Hanno Rein

Abstract: We share the source code and a 121 GB dataset of 96 long-term N-body simulations of the Solar System. This dataset can be analyzed by itself to study the dynamics of the Solar System. In addition, our simulations can be the starting point for future studies wishing to explore different initial conditions or additional physical effects on the Solar System. Our simulations can also be used as a comp… ▽ More We share the source code and a 121 GB dataset of 96 long-term N-body simulations of the Solar System. This dataset can be analyzed by itself to study the dynamics of the Solar System. In addition, our simulations can be the starting point for future studies wishing to explore different initial conditions or additional physical effects on the Solar System. Our simulations can also be used as a comparison and benchmark for new numerical algorithms. △ Less

Submitted 9 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: Published in Res. Notes AAS, 3 pages, 1 figure, data repository: https://zenodo.org/record/4299102

Journal ref: 2020 Res. Notes AAS 4 221

Predicting the long-term stability of compact multiplanet systems

Authors: Daniel Tamayo, Miles Cranmer, Samuel Hadden, Hanno Rein, Peter Battaglia, Alysa Obertas, Philip J. Armitage, Shirley Ho, David Spergel, Christian Gilbertson, Naireen Hussain, Ari Silburt, Daniel Jontof-Hutter, Kristen Menou

Abstract: We combine analytical understanding of resonant dynamics in two-planet systems with machine learning techniques to train a model capable of robustly classifying stability in compact multi-planet systems over long timescales of $10^9$ orbits. Our Stability of Planetary Orbital Configurations Klassifier (SPOCK) predicts stability using physically motivated summary statistics measured in integrations… ▽ More We combine analytical understanding of resonant dynamics in two-planet systems with machine learning techniques to train a model capable of robustly classifying stability in compact multi-planet systems over long timescales of $10^9$ orbits. Our Stability of Planetary Orbital Configurations Klassifier (SPOCK) predicts stability using physically motivated summary statistics measured in integrations of the first $10^4$ orbits, thus achieving speed-ups of up to $10^5$ over full simulations. This computationally opens up the stability constrained characterization of multi-planet systems. Our model, trained on $\approx 100,000$ three-planet systems sampled at discrete resonances, generalizes both to a sample spanning a continuous period-ratio range, as well as to a large five-planet sample with qualitatively different configurations to our training dataset. Our approach significantly outperforms previous methods based on systems' angular momentum deficit, chaos indicators, and parametrized fits to numerical integrations. We use SPOCK to constrain the free eccentricities between the inner and outer pairs of planets in the Kepler-431 system of three approximately Earth-sized planets to both be below 0.05. Our stability analysis provides significantly stronger eccentricity constraints than currently achievable through either radial velocity or transit duration measurements for small planets, and within a factor of a few of systems that exhibit transit timing variations (TTVs). Given that current exoplanet detection strategies now rarely allow for strong TTV constraints (Hadden et al., 2019), SPOCK enables a powerful complementary method for precisely characterizing compact multi-planet systems. We publicly release SPOCK for community use. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 2020; v1 submitted 13 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

Comments: Published week of July 13th in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences: https://www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.2001258117. Check out simple usage of package (and regenerate paper figures) at: https://github.com/dtamayo/spock

Embedded operator splitting methods for perturbed systems

Authors: Hanno Rein

Abstract: It is common in classical mechanics to encounter systems whose Hamiltonian $H$ is the sum of an often exactly integrable Hamiltonian $H_0$ and a small perturbation $εH_1$ with $ε\ll1$. Such near-integrability can be exploited to construct particularly accurate operator splitting methods to solve the equations of motion of $H$. However, in many cases, for example in problems related to planetary mo… ▽ More It is common in classical mechanics to encounter systems whose Hamiltonian $H$ is the sum of an often exactly integrable Hamiltonian $H_0$ and a small perturbation $εH_1$ with $ε\ll1$. Such near-integrability can be exploited to construct particularly accurate operator splitting methods to solve the equations of motion of $H$. However, in many cases, for example in problems related to planetary motion, it is computationally expensive to obtain the exact solution to $H_0$. In this paper we present a new family of embedded operator splitting (EOS) methods which do not use the exact solution to $H_0$, but rather approximate it with yet another, embedded operator splitting method. Our new methods have all the desirable properties of classical methods which solve $H_0$ directly. But in addition they are very easy to implement and in some cases faster. When applied to the problem of planetary motion, our EOS methods have error scalings identical to that of the often used Wisdom-Holman method but do not require a Kepler solver, nor any coordinate transformations, or the allocation of memory. The only two problem specific functions that need to be implemented are the straight-forward kick and drift steps typically used in the standard second order leap-frog method. △ Less

Submitted 22 January, 2020; v1 submitted 6 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: 8 pages, 5 figures, accepted for publication by MNRAS

Dynamical Interactions in the Planetary System GJ4276

Authors: Fergus Horrobin, Hanno Rein

Abstract: GJ4276 is an M4.0 dwarf star with an inferred Neptune mass planet from radial velocity (RV) observations. We reanalyse the RV data for this system and focus on the possibility of a second, super earth mass, planet. We compute the timescale for fast resonant librations in the eccentricity to be $\sim 2\,000\,\mathrm{days}$. Given that the observations were taken over $700\,\mathrm{days}$, we expect… ▽ More GJ4276 is an M4.0 dwarf star with an inferred Neptune mass planet from radial velocity (RV) observations. We reanalyse the RV data for this system and focus on the possibility of a second, super earth mass, planet. We compute the timescale for fast resonant librations in the eccentricity to be $\sim 2\,000\,\mathrm{days}$. Given that the observations were taken over $700\,\mathrm{days}$, we expect to see the effect of these librations in the observations. We perform a fully dynamical fit to test this hypothesis. Similar to previous results, we determine that the data could be fit by two planets in a 2:1 mean motion resonance. However, we also find solutions near the 5:4 mean motion resonance which are not present when planet-planet interactions are ignored. Using the MEGNO indicator, we analyze the stability of the system and find that our solutions lie in a stable region of parameter space. We also find that though out of resonance solutions are possible, the system favours a configuration which is in a first order mean motion resonance. The existence of mean motion resonances has important implications in many planet formation theories. Although we do not attempt to distinguish between the one and two planet models in this work, in either case, the predicted orbital parameters are interesting enough to merit further study. Future observations should be able to distinguish between the different scenarios within the next $5\,\mathrm{years}$. △ Less

Submitted 12 September, 2019; v1 submitted 9 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: 8 pages, 7 figures, accepted by MNRAS; Removed comment from sec 4.1 header

REBOUNDx: A Library for Adding Conservative and Dissipative Forces to Otherwise Symplectic N-body Integrations

Authors: Daniel Tamayo, Hanno Rein, Pengshuai Shi, David M. Hernandez

Abstract: Symplectic methods, in particular the Wisdom-Holman map, have revolutionized our ability to model the long-term, conservative dynamics of planetary systems. However, many astrophysically important effects are dissipative. The consequences of incorporating such forces into otherwise symplectic schemes is not always clear. We show that moving to a general framework of non-commutative operators (diss… ▽ More Symplectic methods, in particular the Wisdom-Holman map, have revolutionized our ability to model the long-term, conservative dynamics of planetary systems. However, many astrophysically important effects are dissipative. The consequences of incorporating such forces into otherwise symplectic schemes is not always clear. We show that moving to a general framework of non-commutative operators (dissipative or not) clarifies many of these questions, and that several important properties of symplectic schemes carry over to the general case. In particular, we show that explicit splitting schemes generically exploit symmetries in the applied external forces which often strongly suppress integration errors. Furthermore, we demonstrate that so-called `symplectic correctors' (which reduce energy errors by orders of magnitude at fixed computational cost) apply equally well to weakly dissipative systems and can thus be more generally thought of as `weak splitting correctors.' Finally, we show that previously advocated approaches of incorporating additional forces into symplectic methods work well for dissipative forces, but give qualitatively wrong answers for conservative but velocity-dependent forces like post-Newtonian corrections. We release REBOUNDx, an open-source C library for incorporating additional effects into REBOUND N-body integrations, together with a convenient Python wrapper. All effects are machine-independent and we provide a binary format that interfaces with the SimulationArchive class in REBOUND to enable the sharing and reproducibility of results. Users can add effects from a list of pre-implemented astrophysical forces, or contribute new ones. △ Less

Submitted 8 October, 2019; v1 submitted 15 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: Submitted. Paper repository: https://github.com/dtamayo/reboundxpaper, Library Documentation: https://reboundx.readthedocs.io/en/latest/

On the accuracy of symplectic integrators for secularly evolving planetary systems

Authors: Hanno Rein, Garett Brown, Daniel Tamayo

Abstract: Symplectic integrators have made it possible to study the long-term evolution of planetary systems with direct N-body simulations. In this paper we reassess the accuracy of such simulations by running a convergence test on 20Myr integrations of the Solar System using various symplectic integrators. We find that the specific choice of metric for determining a simulation's accuracy is important. O… ▽ More Symplectic integrators have made it possible to study the long-term evolution of planetary systems with direct N-body simulations. In this paper we reassess the accuracy of such simulations by running a convergence test on 20Myr integrations of the Solar System using various symplectic integrators. We find that the specific choice of metric for determining a simulation's accuracy is important. Only looking at metrics related to integrals of motions such as the energy error can overestimate the accuracy of a method. As one specific example, we show that symplectic correctors do not improve the accuracy of secular frequencies compared to the standard Wisdom-Holman method without symplectic correctors, despite the fact that the energy error is three orders of magnitudes smaller. We present a framework to trace the origin of this apparent paradox to one term in the shadow Hamiltonian. Specifically, we find a term that leads to negligible contributions to the energy error but introduces non-oscillatory errors that result in artificial periastron precession. This term is the dominant error when determining secular frequencies of the system. We show that higher order symplectic methods such as the Wisdom-Holman method with a modified kernel or the SABAC family of integrators perform significantly better in secularly evolving systems because they remove this specific term. △ Less

Submitted 17 October, 2019; v1 submitted 9 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 13 pages, 7 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

High order symplectic integrators for planetary dynamics and their implementation in REBOUND

Authors: Hanno Rein, Daniel Tamayo, Garett Brown

Abstract: Direct N-body simulations and symplectic integrators are effective tools to study the long-term evolution of planetary systems. The Wisdom-Holman (WH) integrator in particular has been used extensively in planetary dynamics as it allows for large timesteps at good accuracy. One can extend the WH method to achieve even higher accuracy using several different approaches. In this paper we survey inte… ▽ More Direct N-body simulations and symplectic integrators are effective tools to study the long-term evolution of planetary systems. The Wisdom-Holman (WH) integrator in particular has been used extensively in planetary dynamics as it allows for large timesteps at good accuracy. One can extend the WH method to achieve even higher accuracy using several different approaches. In this paper we survey integrators developed by Wisdom et al. (1996), Laskar & Robutel (2001, and Blanes et al. (2013). Since some of these methods are harder to implement and not as readily available to astronomers compared to the standard WH method, they are not used as often. This is somewhat unfortunate given that in typical simulations it is possible to improve the accuracy by up to six orders of magnitude (!) compared to the standard WH method without the need for any additional force evaluations. To change this, we implement a variety of high order symplectic methods in the freely available N-body integrator REBOUND. In this paper we catalogue these methods, discuss their differences, describe their error scalings, and benchmark their speed using our implementations. △ Less

Submitted 4 September, 2019; v1 submitted 25 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: 10 pages, 2 figures, accepted by MNRAS, code to reproduce figures available at https://github.com/hannorein/ReinTamayoBrown2019

Hybrid Symplectic Integrators for Planetary Dynamics

Authors: Hanno Rein, David M. Hernandez, Daniel Tamayo, Garett Brown, Emily Eckels, Emma Holmes, Michelle Lau, Rejean Leblanc, Ari Silburt

Abstract: Hybrid symplectic integrators such as MERCURY are widely used to simulate complex dynamical phenomena in planetary dynamics that could otherwise not be investigated. A hybrid integrator achieves high accuracy during close encounters by using a high order integration scheme for the duration of the encounter while otherwise using a standard 2nd order Wisdom-Holman scheme, thereby optimizing both spe… ▽ More Hybrid symplectic integrators such as MERCURY are widely used to simulate complex dynamical phenomena in planetary dynamics that could otherwise not be investigated. A hybrid integrator achieves high accuracy during close encounters by using a high order integration scheme for the duration of the encounter while otherwise using a standard 2nd order Wisdom-Holman scheme, thereby optimizing both speed and accuracy. In this paper we reassess the criteria for choosing the switching function that determines which parts of the Hamiltonian are integrated with the high order integrator. We show that the original motivation for choosing a polynomial switching function in MERCURY is not correct. We explain the nevertheless excellent performance of the MERCURY integrator and then explore a wide range of different switching functions including an infinitely differentiable function and a Heaviside function. We find that using a Heaviside function leads to a significantly simpler scheme compared to MERCURY, while maintaining the same accuracy in short term simulations. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS, 9 pages, 2 figures

Dimensionality and integrals of motion of the Trappist-1 planetary system

Authors: Johannes Floß, Hanno Rein, Paul Brumer

Abstract: The number of isolating integrals of motion of the Trappist-1 system - a late M-dwarf orbited by seven Earth-sized planets - was determined numerically, using an adapted version of the correlation dimension method. It was found that over the investigated time-scales of up to 20 000 years the number of isolating integrals of motion is the same as one would find for a system of seven non-interacting… ▽ More The number of isolating integrals of motion of the Trappist-1 system - a late M-dwarf orbited by seven Earth-sized planets - was determined numerically, using an adapted version of the correlation dimension method. It was found that over the investigated time-scales of up to 20 000 years the number of isolating integrals of motion is the same as one would find for a system of seven non-interacting planets - despite the fact that the planets in the Trappist-1 system are strongly interacting. Considering perturbed versions of the Trappist-1 system shows that the system may occupy an atypical part of phase-space with high stability. These findings are consistent with earlier studies. △ Less

Submitted 18 April, 2018; v1 submitted 22 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Comments: 6 pages, 6 figures, accepted manuscript for publication MNRAS

Journal ref: Mon. Notices Royal Astron. Soc. 477, 4874 (2018)

The random walk of cars and their collision probabilities with planets

Authors: Hanno Rein, Daniel Tamayo, David Vokrouhlicky

Abstract: On February 6th, 2018 SpaceX launched a Tesla Roadster on a Mars-crossing orbit. We perform N-body simulations to determine the fate of the object over the next 15 Myr. The orbital evolution is initially dominated by close encounters with the Earth. While a precise orbit can not be predicted beyond the next several centuries due to these repeated chaotic scatterings, one can reliably predict the l… ▽ More On February 6th, 2018 SpaceX launched a Tesla Roadster on a Mars-crossing orbit. We perform N-body simulations to determine the fate of the object over the next 15 Myr. The orbital evolution is initially dominated by close encounters with the Earth. While a precise orbit can not be predicted beyond the next several centuries due to these repeated chaotic scatterings, one can reliably predict the long-term outcomes by statistically analyzing a large suite of possible trajectories with slightly perturbed initial conditions. Repeated gravitational scatterings with Earth lead to a random walk. Collisions with the Earth, Venus and the Sun represent primary sinks for the Roadster's orbital evolution. Collisions with Mercury and Mars, or ejections from the Solar System by Jupiter, are highly unlikely. We calculate a dynamical half-life of the Tesla of approximately 15 Myr, with some 22%, 12% and 12% of Roadster orbit realizations impacting the Earth, Venus, and the Sun within one half-life, respectively. Because the eccentricities and inclinations in our ensemble increase over time due to mean-motion and secular resonances, the impact rates with the terrestrial planets decrease beyond a few million years, whereas the impact rate on the Sun remains roughly constant. △ Less

Submitted 5 March, 2018; v1 submitted 13 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures, plots updated with data from 15Myr simulations, submitted to MNRAS

Journal ref: Aerospace. 2018; 5(2):57

Ejection of rocky and icy material from binary star systems: Implications for the origin and composition of 1I/`Oumuamua

Authors: Alan P. Jackson, Daniel Tamayo, Noah Hammond, Mohamad Ali-Dib, Hanno Rein

Abstract: In single star systems like our own Solar system, comets dominate the mass budget of bodies that are ejected into interstellar space, since they form further away and are less tightly bound. However 1I/`Oumuamua, the first interstellar object detected, appears asteroidal in its spectra and in its lack of detectable activity. We argue that the galactic budget of interstellar objects like 1I/`Oumuam… ▽ More In single star systems like our own Solar system, comets dominate the mass budget of bodies that are ejected into interstellar space, since they form further away and are less tightly bound. However 1I/`Oumuamua, the first interstellar object detected, appears asteroidal in its spectra and in its lack of detectable activity. We argue that the galactic budget of interstellar objects like 1I/`Oumuamua should be dominated by planetesimal material ejected during planet formation in circumbinary systems, rather than in single star systems or widely separated binaries. We further show that in circumbinary systems, rocky bodies should be ejected in comparable numbers to icy ones. This suggests that a substantial fraction of additional interstellar objects discovered in the future should display an active coma. We find that the rocky population, of which 1I/`Oumuamua seems to be a member, should be predominantly sourced from A-type and late B-star binaries. △ Less

Submitted 28 March, 2018; v1 submitted 12 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures. accepted in MNRAS Letters, updated with reviewer comments

Resonant structure, formation and stability of the planetary system HD155358

Authors: Ari Silburt, Hanno Rein

Abstract: Two Jovian-sized planets are orbiting the star HD155358 near exact mean motion resonance (MMR) commensurability. In this work we re-analyze the radial velocity (RV) data previously collected by Robertson et al. (2012). Using a Bayesian framework we construct two models - one that includes and one that excludes gravitational planet-planet interactions (PPI). We find that the orbital parameters from… ▽ More Two Jovian-sized planets are orbiting the star HD155358 near exact mean motion resonance (MMR) commensurability. In this work we re-analyze the radial velocity (RV) data previously collected by Robertson et al. (2012). Using a Bayesian framework we construct two models - one that includes and one that excludes gravitational planet-planet interactions (PPI). We find that the orbital parameters from our PPI and noPPI models differ by up to $2σ$, with our noPPI model being statistically consistent with previous results. In addition, our new PPI model strongly favours the planets being in MMR while our noPPI model strongly disfavours MMR. We conduct a stability analysis by drawing samples from our PPI model's posterior distribution and simulating them for $10^9$ years, finding that our best-fit values land firmly in a stable region of parameter space. We explore a series of formation models that migrate the planets into their observed MMR. We then use these models to directly fit to the observed RV data, where each model is uniquely parameterized by only three constants describing its migration history. Using a Bayesian framework we find that a number of migration models fit the RV data surprisingly well, with some migration parameters being ruled out. Our analysis shows that planet-planet interactions are important to take into account when modelling observations of multi-planetary systems. The additional information that one can gain from interacting models can help constrain planet migration parameters. △ Less

Submitted 11 May, 2017; originally announced May 2017.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS, 8 Pages, 4 Figures

JANUS: A bit-wise reversible integrator for N-body dynamics

Authors: Hanno Rein, Daniel Tamayo

Abstract: Hamiltonian systems such as the gravitational N-body problem have time-reversal symmetry. However, all numerical N-body integration schemes, including symplectic ones, respect this property only approximately. In this paper, we present the new N-body integrator JANUS, for which we achieve exact time-reversal symmetry by combining integer and floating point arithmetic. JANUS is explicit, formally s… ▽ More Hamiltonian systems such as the gravitational N-body problem have time-reversal symmetry. However, all numerical N-body integration schemes, including symplectic ones, respect this property only approximately. In this paper, we present the new N-body integrator JANUS, for which we achieve exact time-reversal symmetry by combining integer and floating point arithmetic. JANUS is explicit, formally symplectic and satisfies Liouville's theorem exactly. Its order is even and can be adjusted between two and ten. We discuss the implementation ofJANUS and present tests of its accuracy and speed by performing and analyzing long-term integrations of the Solar System. We show that JANUS is fast and accurate enough to tackle a broad class of dynamical problems. We also discuss the practical and philosophical implications of running exactly time-reversible simulations. △ Less

Submitted 21 September, 2017; v1 submitted 25 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: Accepted for publication by MNRAS, 7 pages, 4 figures, source code available at https://github.com/hannorein/rebound , iPython notebooks to reproduce figures available at https://github.com/hannorein/JanusPaper

Convergent Migration Renders TRAPPIST-1 Long-lived

Authors: Daniel Tamayo, Hanno Rein, Cristobal Petrovich, Norman Murray

Abstract: TRAPPIST-1 is a late M-dwarf orbited by seven Earth-sized planets with orbital period ratios near a chain of mean motion resonances. Due to uncertain system parameters, most orbital configurations drawn from the inferred posterior distribution are unstable on short timescales of $\sim$ 0.5 Myr, even when including the eccentricity dam** effect of tides. By contrast, we show that most physically… ▽ More TRAPPIST-1 is a late M-dwarf orbited by seven Earth-sized planets with orbital period ratios near a chain of mean motion resonances. Due to uncertain system parameters, most orbital configurations drawn from the inferred posterior distribution are unstable on short timescales of $\sim$ 0.5 Myr, even when including the eccentricity dam** effect of tides. By contrast, we show that most physically plausible resonant configurations generated through disk migration are stable even without tidal dissipation on timescales of at least 50 Myr ($10^{10}$ orbits), an increase of at least two orders of magnitude. This result, together with the remarkable chain of period ratios in the system, provide strong evidence for convergent migration naturally emplacing the system near an equilibrium configuration forced by the resonant chain. We provide an openly available database of physically plausible initial conditions for TRAPPIST-1 generated through parametrized planet-disk interactions, as well as bit-by-bit reproducible N-body integrations over $10^9-10^{10}$ orbits. △ Less

Submitted 8 May, 2017; v1 submitted 10 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: 7 pages 5 figures. Accepted in ApJ Letters. Scripts to visualize the dataset and reproduce the figures in this manuscript are available at https://github.com/dtamayo/trappist

Connecting HL Tau to the Observed Exoplanet Sample

Authors: Christopher Simbulan, Daniel Tamayo, Cristobal Petrovich, Hanno Rein, Norman Murray

Abstract: The Atacama Large Millimeter/submilimeter Array (ALMA) recently revealed a set of nearly concentric gaps in the protoplanetary disk surrounding the young star HL Tau. If these are carved by forming gas giants, this provides the first set of orbital initial conditions for planets as they emerge from their birth disks. Using N-body integrations, we have followed the evolution of the system for 5 Gyr… ▽ More The Atacama Large Millimeter/submilimeter Array (ALMA) recently revealed a set of nearly concentric gaps in the protoplanetary disk surrounding the young star HL Tau. If these are carved by forming gas giants, this provides the first set of orbital initial conditions for planets as they emerge from their birth disks. Using N-body integrations, we have followed the evolution of the system for 5 Gyr to explore the possible outcomes. We find that HL Tau initial conditions scaled down to the size of typically observed exoplanet orbits naturally produce several populations in the observed exoplanet sample. First, for a plausible range of planetary masses, we can match the observed eccentricity distribution of dynamically excited radial velocity giant planets with eccentricities $>$ 0.2. Second, we roughly obtain the observed rate of hot Jupiters around FGK stars. Finally, we obtain a large efficiency of planetary ejections of $\approx 2$ per HL Tau-like system, but the small fraction of stars observed to host giant planets makes it hard to match the rate of free-floating planets inferred from microlensing observations. In view of upcoming GAIA results, we also provide predictions for the expected mutual inclination distribution, which is significantly broader than the absolute inclination distributions typically considered by previous studies. △ Less

Submitted 27 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Comments: Accepted in MNRAS. 11 pages

A new paradigm for reproducing and analyzing N-body simulations of planetary systems

Authors: Hanno Rein, Daniel Tamayo

Abstract: The reproducibility of experiments is one of the main principles of the scientific method. However, numerical N-body experiments, especially those of planetary systems, are currently not reproducible. In the most optimistic scenario, they can only be replicated in an approximate or statistical sense. Even if authors share their full source code and initial conditions, differences in compilers, lib… ▽ More The reproducibility of experiments is one of the main principles of the scientific method. However, numerical N-body experiments, especially those of planetary systems, are currently not reproducible. In the most optimistic scenario, they can only be replicated in an approximate or statistical sense. Even if authors share their full source code and initial conditions, differences in compilers, libraries, operating systems or hardware often lead to qualitatively different results. We provide a new set of easy-to-use, open-source tools that address the above issues, allowing for exact (bit-by-bit) reproducibility of N-body experiments. In addition to generating completely reproducible integrations, we show that our framework also offers novel and innovative ways to analyze these simulations. As an example, we present a high-accuracy integration of the Solar System spanning 10Gyrs, requiring several weeks to run on a modern CPU. In our framework we can not only easily access simulation data at predefined intervals for which we save snapshots, but at any time during the integration. We achieve this by integrating an on-demand reconstructed simulation forward in time from the nearest snapshot. This allows us to extract arbitrary quantities at any point in the saved simulation exactly (bit-by-bit), and within seconds rather than weeks. We believe that the tools we present in this paper offer a new paradigm for how N-body simulations are run, analyzed, and shared across the community. △ Less

Submitted 25 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS, REBOUND code available at https://github.com/hannorein/rebound , script and data files to reproduce plots in the paper available at https://github.com/hannorein/reproducibility-paper

Planetary rings and other astrophysical disks

Authors: Henrik N. Latter, Gordon I. Ogilvie, Hanno Rein

Abstract: This chapter explores the physics shared by planetary rings and the various disks that populate the Universe. It begins with an observational overview, ranging from protoplanetary disks to spiral galaxies, and then compares and contrasts these astrophysical disks with the rings of the Solar System. Emphasis is placed on fundamental physics and dynamics, and how research into the two classes of obj… ▽ More This chapter explores the physics shared by planetary rings and the various disks that populate the Universe. It begins with an observational overview, ranging from protoplanetary disks to spiral galaxies, and then compares and contrasts these astrophysical disks with the rings of the Solar System. Emphasis is placed on fundamental physics and dynamics, and how research into the two classes of object connects. Topics covered include disk formation, accretion, collisional processes, waves, instabilities, and satellite-disk interactions. △ Less

Submitted 16 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Comments: To appear in: Tiscareno & Murray Eds (2017), Planetary Ring Systems, Cambridge University Press

A Machine Learns to Predict the Stability of Tightly Packed Planetary Systems

Authors: Daniel Tamayo, Ari Silburt, Diana Valencia, Kristen Menou, Mohamad Ali-Dib, Cristobal Petrovich, Chelsea X. Huang, Hanno Rein, Christa van Laerhoven, Adiv Paradise, Alysa Obertas, Norman Murray

Abstract: The requirement that planetary systems be dynamically stable is often used to vet new discoveries or set limits on unconstrained masses or orbital elements. This is typically carried out via computationally expensive N-body simulations. We show that characterizing the complicated and multi-dimensional stability boundary of tightly packed systems is amenable to machine learning methods. We find tha… ▽ More The requirement that planetary systems be dynamically stable is often used to vet new discoveries or set limits on unconstrained masses or orbital elements. This is typically carried out via computationally expensive N-body simulations. We show that characterizing the complicated and multi-dimensional stability boundary of tightly packed systems is amenable to machine learning methods. We find that training an XGBoost machine learning algorithm on physically motivated features yields an accurate classifier of stability in packed systems. On the stability timescale investigated ($10^7$ orbits), it is 3 orders of magnitude faster than direct N-body simulations. Optimized machine learning classifiers for dynamical stability may thus prove useful across the discipline, e.g., to characterize the exoplanet sample discovered by the upcoming Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS). This proof of concept motivates investing computational resources to train algorithms capable of predicting stability over longer timescales and over broader regions of phase space. △ Less

Submitted 21 November, 2016; v1 submitted 17 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Comments: Accepted in ApJ letters. 7 pages, 3 figures

The Astropy Problem

Authors: Demitri Muna, Michael Alexander, Alice Allen, Richard Ashley, Daniel Asmus, Ruyman Azzollini, Michele Bannister, Rachael Beaton, Andrew Benson, G. Bruce Berriman, Maciej Bilicki, Peter Boyce, Joanna Bridge, Jan Cami, Eryn Cangi, Xian Chen, Nicholas Christiny, Christopher Clark, Michelle Collins, Johan Comparat, Neil Cook, Darren Croton, Isak Delberth Davids, Éric Depagne, John Donor , et al. (129 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: The Astropy Project (http://astropy.org) is, in its own words, "a community effort to develop a single core package for Astronomy in Python and foster interoperability between Python astronomy packages." For five years this project has been managed, written, and operated as a grassroots, self-organized, almost entirely volunteer effort while the software is used by the majority of the astronomical… ▽ More The Astropy Project (http://astropy.org) is, in its own words, "a community effort to develop a single core package for Astronomy in Python and foster interoperability between Python astronomy packages." For five years this project has been managed, written, and operated as a grassroots, self-organized, almost entirely volunteer effort while the software is used by the majority of the astronomical community. Despite this, the project has always been and remains to this day effectively unfunded. Further, contributors receive little or no formal recognition for creating and supporting what is now critical software. This paper explores the problem in detail, outlines possible solutions to correct this, and presents a few suggestions on how to address the sustainability of general purpose astronomical software. △ Less

Submitted 10 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Second-order variational equations for N-body simulations

Authors: Hanno Rein, Daniel Tamayo

Abstract: First-order variational equations are widely used in N-body simulations to study how nearby trajectories diverge from one another. These allow for efficient and reliable determinations of chaos indicators such as the Maximal Lyapunov characteristic Exponent (MLE) and the Mean Exponential Growth factor of Nearby Orbits (MEGNO). In this paper we lay out the theoretical framework to extend the idea… ▽ More First-order variational equations are widely used in N-body simulations to study how nearby trajectories diverge from one another. These allow for efficient and reliable determinations of chaos indicators such as the Maximal Lyapunov characteristic Exponent (MLE) and the Mean Exponential Growth factor of Nearby Orbits (MEGNO). In this paper we lay out the theoretical framework to extend the idea of variational equations to higher order. We explicitly derive the differential equations that govern the evolution of second-order variations in the N-body problem. Going to second order opens the door to new applications, including optimization algorithms that require the first and second derivatives of the solution, like the classical Newton's method. Typically, these methods have faster convergence rates than derivative-free methods. Derivatives are also required for Riemann manifold Langevin and Hamiltonian Monte Carlo methods which provide significantly shorter correlation times than standard methods. Such improved optimization methods can be applied to anything from radial-velocity/transit-timing-variation fitting to spacecraft trajectory optimization to asteroid deflection. We provide an implementation of first and second-order variational equations for the publicly available REBOUND integrator package. Our implementation allows the simultaneous integration of any number of first and second-order variational equations with the high-accuracy IAS15 integrator. We also provide routines to generate consistent and accurate initial conditions without the need for finite differencing. △ Less

Submitted 10 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

Comments: 11 pages, accepted for publication in MNRAS, code available at https://github.com/hannorein/rebound, figures can be reproduced interactively with binder at http://mybinder.org/repo/hannorein/variations

Tides Alone Cannot Explain Kepler Planets Close to 2:1 MMR

Authors: Ari Silburt, Hanno Rein

Abstract: A number of Kepler planet pairs lie just wide of first-order mean motion resonances (MMRs). Tides have been frequently proposed to explain these pileups, but it is still an ongoing discussion. We contribute to this discussion by calculating an optimistic theoretical estimate on the minimum initial eccentricity required by Kepler planets to explain the current observed spacing, and compliment these… ▽ More A number of Kepler planet pairs lie just wide of first-order mean motion resonances (MMRs). Tides have been frequently proposed to explain these pileups, but it is still an ongoing discussion. We contribute to this discussion by calculating an optimistic theoretical estimate on the minimum initial eccentricity required by Kepler planets to explain the current observed spacing, and compliment these calculations with N-body simulations. In particular, we investigate 27 Kepler systems having planets within 6% of the 2:1 MMR, and find that the initial eccentricities required to explain the observed spacings are unreasonable from simple dynamical arguments. Furthermore, our numerical simulations reveal resonant tugging, an effect which conspires against the migration of resonant planets away from the 2:1 MMR, requiring even higher initial eccentricities in order to explain the current Kepler distribution. Overall, we find that tides alone cannot explain planets close to 2:1 MMR, and additional mechanisms are required to explain these systems. △ Less

Submitted 19 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS, 9 pages, 5 figures, 1 table

High Order Harmonics in Light Curves of Kepler Planets

Authors: Caden Armstrong, Hanno Rein

Abstract: The Kepler mission was launched in 2009 and has discovered thousands of planet candidates. In a recent paper, Esteves et al. (2013) found a periodic signal in the light curves of KOI-13 and HAT-P-7, with a frequency triple the orbital frequency of a transiting planet. We found similar harmonics in many systems with a high occurrence rate. At this time, the origins of the signal are not entirely ce… ▽ More The Kepler mission was launched in 2009 and has discovered thousands of planet candidates. In a recent paper, Esteves et al. (2013) found a periodic signal in the light curves of KOI-13 and HAT-P-7, with a frequency triple the orbital frequency of a transiting planet. We found similar harmonics in many systems with a high occurrence rate. At this time, the origins of the signal are not entirely certain. We look carefully at the possibility of errors being introduced through our data processing routines but conclude that the signal is real. The harmonics on multiples of the orbital frequency are a result of non-sinusoidal periodic signals. We speculate on their origin and generally caution that these harmonics could lead to wrong estimates of planet albedos, beaming mass estimates, and ellipsoidal variations. △ Less

Submitted 4 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS Letters, 6 pages, 2 figures

WHFast: A fast and unbiased implementation of a symplectic Wisdom-Holman integrator for long term gravitational simulations

Authors: Hanno Rein, Daniel Tamayo

Abstract: We present WHFast, a fast and accurate implementation of a Wisdom-Holman symplectic integrator for long-term orbit integrations of planetary systems. WHFast is significantly faster and conserves energy better than all other Wisdom-Holman integrators tested. We achieve this by significantly improving the Kepler-solver and ensuring numerical stability of coordinate transformations to and from Jacobi… ▽ More We present WHFast, a fast and accurate implementation of a Wisdom-Holman symplectic integrator for long-term orbit integrations of planetary systems. WHFast is significantly faster and conserves energy better than all other Wisdom-Holman integrators tested. We achieve this by significantly improving the Kepler-solver and ensuring numerical stability of coordinate transformations to and from Jacobi coordinates. These refinements allow us to remove the linear secular trend in the energy error that is present in other implementations. For small enough timesteps we achieve Brouwer's law, i.e. the energy error is dominated by an unbiased random walk due to floating-point round-off errors. We implement symplectic correctors up to order eleven that significantly reduce the energy error. We also implement a symplectic tangent map for the variational equations. This allows us to efficiently calculate two widely used chaos indicators the Lyapunov characteristic number (LCN) and the Mean Exponential Growth factor of Nearby Orbits (MEGNO). WHFast is freely available as a flexible C package, as a shared library, and as an easy-to-use python module. △ Less

Submitted 2 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: Accepted by MNRAS, 13 pages, 4 figures, source code and tutorials available at http://github.com/hannorein/rebound

Dynamical Stability of Imaged Planetary Systems in Formation: Application to HL Tau

Authors: Daniel Tamayo, Amaury H. M. J. Triaud, Kristen Menou, Hanno Rein

Abstract: A recent ALMA image revealed several concentric gaps in the protoplanetary disk surrounding the young star HL Tau. We consider the hypothesis that these gaps are carved by planets, and present a general framework for understanding the dynamical stability of such systems over typical disk lifetimes, providing estimates for the maximum planetary masses. We collect these easily evaluated constraints… ▽ More A recent ALMA image revealed several concentric gaps in the protoplanetary disk surrounding the young star HL Tau. We consider the hypothesis that these gaps are carved by planets, and present a general framework for understanding the dynamical stability of such systems over typical disk lifetimes, providing estimates for the maximum planetary masses. We collect these easily evaluated constraints into a workflow that can help guide the design and interpretation of new observational campaigns and numerical simulations of gap opening in such systems. We argue that the locations of resonances should be significantly shifted in massive disks like HL Tau, and that theoretical uncertainties in the exact offset, together with observational errors, imply a large uncertainty in the dynamical state and stability in such disks. This presents an important barrier to using systems like HL Tau as a proxy for the initial conditions following planet formation. An important observational avenue to breaking this degeneracy is to search for eccentric gaps, which could implicate resonantly interacting planets. Unfortunately, massive disks like HL Tau should induce swift pericenter precession that would smear out any such eccentric features of planetary origin. This motivates pushing toward more typical, less massive disks. For a nominal non-resonant model of the HL Tau system with five planets, we find a maximum mass for the outer three bodies of approximately 2 Neptune masses. In a resonant configuration, these planets can reach at least the mass of Saturn. The inner two planets' masses are unconstrained by dynamical stability arguments. △ Less

Submitted 20 March, 2015; v1 submitted 17 February, 2015; originally announced February 2015.

Comments: Accepted in ApJ. 16 pages 8 figures

Reanalysis of radial velocity data from the resonant planetary system HD128311

Authors: Hanno Rein

Abstract: The multi-planetary system HD128311 hosts at least two planets. Its dynamical formation history has been studied extensively in the literature. We reanalyse the latest radial velocity data for this system with the affine-invariant Markov chain Monte Carlo sampler EMCEE. Using the high order integrator IAS15, we perform a fully dynamical fit, allowing the planets to interact during the sampling pro… ▽ More The multi-planetary system HD128311 hosts at least two planets. Its dynamical formation history has been studied extensively in the literature. We reanalyse the latest radial velocity data for this system with the affine-invariant Markov chain Monte Carlo sampler EMCEE. Using the high order integrator IAS15, we perform a fully dynamical fit, allowing the planets to interact during the sampling process. A stability analysis using the MEGNO indicator reveals that the system is located in a stable island of the parameter space. In contrast to a previous study, we find that the system is locked in a 2:1 mean motion resonance. The resonant angle $\varphi_1$ is librating with a libration amplitude of approximately 37°. The existence of mean motion resonances has important implication for planet formation theories. Our results confirm predictions of models involving planet migration and stochastic forces. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2015; originally announced January 2015.

Comments: 4 pages, 2 figures, accepted by MNRAS Letters

IAS15: A fast, adaptive, high-order integrator for gravitational dynamics, accurate to machine precision over a billion orbits

Authors: Hanno Rein, David S. Spiegel

Abstract: We present IAS15, a 15th-order integrator to simulate gravitational dynamics. The integrator is based on a Gauß-Radau quadrature and can handle conservative as well as non-conservative forces. We develop a step-size control that can automatically choose an optimal timestep. The algorithm can handle close encounters and high-eccentricity orbits. The systematic errors are kept well below machine pre… ▽ More We present IAS15, a 15th-order integrator to simulate gravitational dynamics. The integrator is based on a Gauß-Radau quadrature and can handle conservative as well as non-conservative forces. We develop a step-size control that can automatically choose an optimal timestep. The algorithm can handle close encounters and high-eccentricity orbits. The systematic errors are kept well below machine precision and long-term orbit integrations over $10^9$ orbits show that IAS15 is optimal in the sense that it follows Brouwer's law, i.e. the energy error behaves like a random walk. Our tests show that IAS15 is superior to a mixed-variable symplectic integrator (MVS) and other popular integrators, including high-order ones, in both speed and accuracy. In fact, IAS15 preserves the symplecticity of Hamiltonian systems better than the commonly-used nominally symplectic integrators to which we compared it. We provide an open-source implementation of IAS15. The package comes with several easy-to-extend examples involving resonant planetary systems, Kozai-Lidov cycles, close encounters, radiation pressure, quadrupole moment, and generic dam** functions that can, among other things, be used to simulate planet-disc interactions. Other non-conservative forces can be added easily. △ Less

Submitted 15 October, 2014; v1 submitted 16 September, 2014; originally announced September 2014.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS, 14 pages, 7 figures, source code in c and python bindings available at http://github.com/hannorein/rebound

Some inconvenient truths about biosignatures involving two chemical species on Earth-like exoplanets

Authors: Hanno Rein, Yuka Fujii, David S. Spiegel

Abstract: The detection of strong thermochemical disequilibrium in the atmosphere of an extrasolar planet is thought to be a potential biosignature. In this article we present a new kind of false positive that can mimic a disequilibrium or any other biosignature that involves two chemical species. We consider a scenario where the exoplanet hosts a moon that has its own atmosphere and neither of the atmosphe… ▽ More The detection of strong thermochemical disequilibrium in the atmosphere of an extrasolar planet is thought to be a potential biosignature. In this article we present a new kind of false positive that can mimic a disequilibrium or any other biosignature that involves two chemical species. We consider a scenario where the exoplanet hosts a moon that has its own atmosphere and neither of the atmospheres is in chemical disequilibrium. Our results show that the integrated spectrum of the planet and the moon closely resembles that of a single object in strong chemical disequilibrium. We derive a firm limit on the maximum spectral resolution that can be obtained for both directly-imaged and transiting planets. The spectral resolution of even idealized space-based spectrographs that might be achievable in the next several decades is in general insufficient to break the degeneracy. Both chemical species can only be definitively confirmed in the same object if absorption features of both chemicals can be unambiguously identified and their combined depth exceeds 100%. △ Less

Submitted 25 April, 2014; originally announced April 2014.

Comments: Accepted for publication in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), 6 pages, 3 figures

SMACK: A New Algorithm for Modeling Collisions and Dynamics of Planetesimals in Debris Disks

Authors: Erika R. Nesvold, Marc J. Kuchner, Hanno Rein, Margaret Pan

Abstract: We present the Superparticle Model/Algorithm for Collisions in Kuiper belts and debris disks (SMACK), a new method for simultaneously modeling, in 3-D, the collisional and dynamical evolution of planetesimals in a debris disk with planets. SMACK can simulate azimuthal asymmetries and how these asymmetries evolve over time. We show that SMACK is stable to numerical viscosity and numerical heating o… ▽ More We present the Superparticle Model/Algorithm for Collisions in Kuiper belts and debris disks (SMACK), a new method for simultaneously modeling, in 3-D, the collisional and dynamical evolution of planetesimals in a debris disk with planets. SMACK can simulate azimuthal asymmetries and how these asymmetries evolve over time. We show that SMACK is stable to numerical viscosity and numerical heating over 10^7 yr, and that it can reproduce analytic models of disk evolution. We use SMACK to model the evolution of a debris ring containing a planet on an eccentric orbit. Differential precession creates a spiral structure as the ring evolves, but collisions subsequently break up the spiral, leaving a narrower eccentric ring. △ Less

Submitted 9 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: 14 pages, 9 figures, Accepted for publication in ApJ

The formation of systems with closely spaced low-mass planets and the application to Kepler-36

Authors: Sijme-Jan Paardekooper, Hanno Rein, Willy Kley

Abstract: The Kepler-36 system consists of two planets that are spaced unusually close together, near the 7:6 mean motion resonance. While it is known that mean motion resonances can easily form by convergent migration, Kepler-36 is an extreme case due to the close spacing and the relatively high planet masses of 4 and 8 times that of the Earth. In this paper, we investigate whether such a system can be obt… ▽ More The Kepler-36 system consists of two planets that are spaced unusually close together, near the 7:6 mean motion resonance. While it is known that mean motion resonances can easily form by convergent migration, Kepler-36 is an extreme case due to the close spacing and the relatively high planet masses of 4 and 8 times that of the Earth. In this paper, we investigate whether such a system can be obtained by interactions with the protoplanetary disc. These discs are thought to be turbulent and exhibit density fluctuations which might originate from the magneto-rotational instability. We adopt a realistic description for stochastic forces due to these density fluctuations and perform both long term hydrodynamical and N-body simulations. Our results show that planets in the Kepler-36 mass range can be naturally assembled into a closely spaced planetary system for a wide range of migration parameters in a turbulent disc similar to the minimum mass solar nebula. The final orbits of our formation scenarios tend to be Lagrange stable, even though large parts of the parameter space are chaotic and unstable. △ Less

Submitted 2 July, 2013; v1 submitted 17 April, 2013; originally announced April 2013.

Comments: 13 pages, 8 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

A proposal for community driven and decentralized astronomical databases and the Open Exoplanet Catalogue

Authors: Hanno Rein

Abstract: I present a new kind of astronomical database based on small text files and a distributed version control system. This encourages the community to work collaboratively. It creates a decentralized, completely open and democratic way of managing small to medium sized heterogeneous astronomical databases and catalogues. The use of the XML file format allows an easy to parse and read, yet dynamic and… ▽ More I present a new kind of astronomical database based on small text files and a distributed version control system. This encourages the community to work collaboratively. It creates a decentralized, completely open and democratic way of managing small to medium sized heterogeneous astronomical databases and catalogues. The use of the XML file format allows an easy to parse and read, yet dynamic and extendable database structure. The Open Exoplanet Catalogue is based on these principles and presented as an example. It is a catalogue of all discovered extra-solar planets. It is the only catalogue that can correctly represent the orbital structure of planets in arbitrary binary, triple and quadruple star systems, as well as orphan planets. △ Less

Submitted 4 December, 2012; v1 submitted 29 November, 2012; originally announced November 2012.

Comments: 6 pages, 3 listings, 1 table, updated thanks to feedback from various people, more comments welcome

Large-scale N-body simulations of the viscous overstability in Saturn's rings

Authors: Hanno Rein, Henrik Latter

Abstract: We present results from large-scale particle simulations of the viscous overstability in Saturn's rings. The overstability generates a variety of structure on scales covering a few hundred metres to several kilometres, including axisymmetric wavetrains and larger-scale modulations. Such patterns have been observed in Saturn's rings by the Cassini spacecraft. Our simulations model the collisional e… ▽ More We present results from large-scale particle simulations of the viscous overstability in Saturn's rings. The overstability generates a variety of structure on scales covering a few hundred metres to several kilometres, including axisymmetric wavetrains and larger-scale modulations. Such patterns have been observed in Saturn's rings by the Cassini spacecraft. Our simulations model the collisional evolution of particles in a co-rotating patch of the disk. These are the largest N-body simulations of the viscous overstability yet performed. The radial box size is five orders of magnitude larger than a typical particle radius, and so describes a 20-50 km radial portion of the rings. Its evolution is tracked for more than 10,000 orbits. In agreement with hydrodynamics, our N-body simulations reveal that the viscous overstability exhibits a rich set of dynamics characterised by nonlinear travelling waves with wavelengths of a few hundred meters. In addition, wave defects, such as sources and shocks, punctuate this bed of waves and break them up into large-scale divisions of radial width ~5 km. We find that the wavelength of the travelling waves is positively correlated with the mean optical depth. In order to assess the role of the numerical boundary conditions and also background ring structure, we include simulations of broad spreading rings and simulations with a gradient in the background surface density. Overall, our numerical results and approach provide a tool with which to interpret Cassini occultation observations of microstructure in Saturn's rings. We present an example of such a synthetic occultation observation and discuss what features to expect. We also make the entire source code freely available. △ Less

Submitted 24 January, 2013; v1 submitted 11 October, 2012; originally announced October 2012.

Comments: 15 pages, 12 figures, accepted for publication by MNRAS

Period ratios in multi-planetary systems discovered by Kepler are consistent with planet migration

Authors: Hanno Rein

Abstract: The Kepler planet candidates are an interesting testbed for planet formation scenarios. We present results from N-body simulations of multi-planetary systems that resemble those observed by Kepler. We add both smooth (Type I/II) and stochastic migration forces. The observed period ratio distribution is inconsistent with either of those two scenarios on its own. However, applying both stochastic… ▽ More The Kepler planet candidates are an interesting testbed for planet formation scenarios. We present results from N-body simulations of multi-planetary systems that resemble those observed by Kepler. We add both smooth (Type I/II) and stochastic migration forces. The observed period ratio distribution is inconsistent with either of those two scenarios on its own. However, applying both stochastic and smooth migration forces to the planets simultaneously results in a period ratio distribution that is similar to the observed one. This is a natural scenario if planets form in a turbulent proto-planetary disk where these forces are always present. We show how the observed period ratio and eccentricity distribution can constrain the relative strength of these forces, a parameter which has been notoriously hard to predict for decades. We make the source code of our simulations and the initial conditions freely available to enable the community to expand this study and include effect other than planetary migration. △ Less

Submitted 31 August, 2012; v1 submitted 17 August, 2012; originally announced August 2012.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS Letters, update: added inset to plots

Stochastic flights of propellers

Authors: Margaret Pan, Hanno Rein, Eugene Chiang, Steven N. Evans

Abstract: Kilometer-sized moonlets in Saturn's A ring create S-shaped wakes called "propellers" in surrounding material. The Cassini spacecraft has tracked the motions of propellers for several years and finds that they deviate from Keplerian orbits having constant semimajor axes. The inferred orbital migration is known to switch sign. We show using a statistical test that the time series of orbital longitu… ▽ More Kilometer-sized moonlets in Saturn's A ring create S-shaped wakes called "propellers" in surrounding material. The Cassini spacecraft has tracked the motions of propellers for several years and finds that they deviate from Keplerian orbits having constant semimajor axes. The inferred orbital migration is known to switch sign. We show using a statistical test that the time series of orbital longitudes of the propeller Blériot is consistent with that of a time-integrated Gaussian random walk. That is, Blériot's observed migration pattern is consistent with being stochastic. We further show, using a combination of analytic estimates and collisional N-body simulations, that stochastic migration of the right magnitude to explain the Cassini observations can be driven by encounters with ring particles 10-20 m in radius. That the local ring mass is concentrated in decameter-sized particles is supported on independent grounds by occultation analyses. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2012; v1 submitted 15 June, 2012; originally announced June 2012.

Comments: 10 pages, 7 figures, 1 table; accepted to MNRAS. v2: edited for mathematical and expositional clarity and completeness

Traditional formation scenarios fail to explain 4:3 mean motion resonances

Authors: Hanno Rein, Matthew J. Payne, Dimitri Veras, Eric B. Ford

Abstract: At least two multi-planetary systems in a 4:3 mean motion resonance have been found by radial velocity surveys. These planets are gas giants and the systems are only stable when protected by a resonance. Additionally the Kepler mission has detected at least 4 strong candidate planetary systems with a period ratio close to 4:3. This paper investigates traditional dynamical scenarios for the forma… ▽ More At least two multi-planetary systems in a 4:3 mean motion resonance have been found by radial velocity surveys. These planets are gas giants and the systems are only stable when protected by a resonance. Additionally the Kepler mission has detected at least 4 strong candidate planetary systems with a period ratio close to 4:3. This paper investigates traditional dynamical scenarios for the formation of these systems. We systematically study migration scenarios with both N-body and hydro-dynamic simulations. We investigate scenarios involving the in-situ formation of two planets in resonance. We look at the results from finely tuned planet-planet scattering simulations with gas disk dam**. Finally, we investigate a formation scenario involving isolation-mass embryos. Although the combined planet-planet scattering and dam** scenario seems promising, none of the above scenarios is successful in forming enough systems in 4:3 resonance with planetary masses similar to the observed ones. This is a negative result but it has important implications for planet formation. Previous studies were successful in forming 2:1 and 3:2 resonances. This is generally believed to be evidence of planet migration. We highlight the main differences between those studies and our failure in forming a 4:3 resonance. We also speculate on more exotic and complicated ideas. These results will guide future investigators toward exploring the above scenarios and alternative mechanisms in a more general framework. △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2012; v1 submitted 4 April, 2012; originally announced April 2012.

Comments: 18 pages, 15 figures, accepted by MNRAS, comments welcome

Journal ref: MNRAS Volume 426, Issue 1, p187-202, October 2012

The gravitational instability of a stream of co-orbital particles

Authors: Henrik N. Latter, Hanno Rein, Gordon I. Ogilvie

Abstract: We describe the dynamics of a stream of equally spaced macroscopic particles in orbit around a central body (e.g. a planet or star). A co-orbital configuration of small bodies may be subject to gravitational instability, which takes the system to a spreading, disordered and collisional state. We detail the linear instability's mathematical and physical features using the shearing sheet model and s… ▽ More We describe the dynamics of a stream of equally spaced macroscopic particles in orbit around a central body (e.g. a planet or star). A co-orbital configuration of small bodies may be subject to gravitational instability, which takes the system to a spreading, disordered and collisional state. We detail the linear instability's mathematical and physical features using the shearing sheet model and subsequently track its nonlinear evolution with local N-body simulations. This model provides a convenient tool with which to understand the gravitational and collisional dynamics of narrow belts, such as Saturn's F-ring and the streams of material wrenched from tidally disrupted bodies. In particular, we study the tendency of these systems to form long-lived particle aggregates. Finally, we uncover an unexpected connection between the linear dynamics of the gravitational instability and the magnetorotational instability. △ Less

Submitted 19 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: 11 pages, 7 figures, 1 table. MNRAS, accepted