-
Generalized Entropy Implies Varying-G: Horizon Area Dependent Field Equations and Black Hole-Cosmology Coupling
Authors:
Hengxin Lu,
Sofia Di Gennaro,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
When the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy is modified, ambiguity often arises concerning whether the Hawking temperature or the thermodynamic mass should be modified. The common practice, however, is to keep the black hole solution the same as that in general relativity. On the other hand, if Jacobson's method of deriving Einstein equations from thermodynamic is valid in the general settings, then given…
▽ More
When the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy is modified, ambiguity often arises concerning whether the Hawking temperature or the thermodynamic mass should be modified. The common practice, however, is to keep the black hole solution the same as that in general relativity. On the other hand, if Jacobson's method of deriving Einstein equations from thermodynamic is valid in the general settings, then given a generalized entropy one should first derive the corresponding modified gravity, and then look for the compatible black hole solution before investigating its thermodynamics. We comment on some properties and subtleties in this approach. In particular, we point out that generically generalized entropy would lead to a varying effective gravitational "constant" theory, where $G_\text{eff}$ depends on the horizon area. We discuss in what ways such theories are discernible from general relativity despite its seemingly jarring differences, and how to make sense of area-dependent field equations. As a consequence we show that in the Jacobson's approach, the standard quantum gravitational logarithmic correction to Bekenstein-Hawking entropy is equivalent to a running gravitational "constant". A horizon area dependent $G_\text{eff}$ could also lead to a coupling between black hole masses and cosmological expansion, a scenario that has been studied recently in the literature, but so far lacks strong theoretical motivation. In the Tsallis case, we show that the thermodynamic mass for a Schwarzschild black hole is just a constant multiple of its ADM mass, which is considerably simpler than the approach not utilizing the Jacobson's method.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Testing Cotton gravity as dark matter substitute with weak lensing
Authors:
Geyu Mo,
Qingqing Wang,
Xin Ren,
Weitong Yan,
Yen Chin Ong,
Wentao Luo
Abstract:
Harada proposed a modified theory of gravity called Cotton gravity, and argued that it successfully explains the rotation curves of $84$ galaxies without the need of dark matter. In this work we use galaxy-galaxy lensing technique to test whether the modification effect of Cotton gravity can indeed be a viable substitute for dark matter. Using the spherically symmetric solution of Cotton gravity,…
▽ More
Harada proposed a modified theory of gravity called Cotton gravity, and argued that it successfully explains the rotation curves of $84$ galaxies without the need of dark matter. In this work we use galaxy-galaxy lensing technique to test whether the modification effect of Cotton gravity can indeed be a viable substitute for dark matter. Using the spherically symmetric solution of Cotton gravity, we obtain the deflection angle via Gauss-Bonnet theorem and the weak lensing shear. We use five galaxy catalogs divided in 5 stellar mass bins from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 7 (SDSS DR7), each of which is further divided into blue star forming galaxy and red passive galaxy sub-catalogs. We find that Cotton gravity on its own has significant deviation from the measured galaxy-galaxy lensing signals, thus it cannot replace the role of dark matter. If we consider the combination of dark matter and Cotton gravity, the modification is tightly constrained. Our analysis also applies to other modified gravity theories whose an additional linear term appears in the Schwarzschild solution.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Constrain the linear scalar perturbation theory of Cotton gravity
Authors:
Pengbo Xia,
Dongdong Zhang,
Xin Ren,
Bo Wang,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
We perform a cosmological test of Cotton gravity, which describes gravity by cotton tensor. The model we consider allows for the same background evolution as the $Λ$CDM model. We derive the cosmological perturbation theory of the scalar mode at the linear level, where the difference from the $Λ$CDM model is characterized by the parameter $β$. We incorporate Cotton gravity with a neutrino model and…
▽ More
We perform a cosmological test of Cotton gravity, which describes gravity by cotton tensor. The model we consider allows for the same background evolution as the $Λ$CDM model. We derive the cosmological perturbation theory of the scalar mode at the linear level, where the difference from the $Λ$CDM model is characterized by the parameter $β$. We incorporate Cotton gravity with a neutrino model and perform a Monte Carlo Markov Chain (MCMC) analysis using data from the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS). The analysis constrains parameter $β=-0.00008^{+0.00080}_{-0.00104}$ at the 1-$σ$ confidence level. We conclude that currently, there is no obvious deviation between Cotton gravity and the $Λ$CDM model in the linear cosmological perturbation level for observations.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
An Effective Sign Switching Dark Energy: Lotka-Volterra Model of Two Interacting Fluids
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
One of the recent attempts to address the Hubble and $S_8$ tensions is to consider the Universe started out not as a de Sitter-like spacetime, but rather anti-de Sitter-like. That is, the Universe underwent an "AdS-to-dS" transition at some point. We study the possibility that there are two dark energy fluids, one of which gave rise to the anti-de Sitter-like early Universe. The interaction is mod…
▽ More
One of the recent attempts to address the Hubble and $S_8$ tensions is to consider the Universe started out not as a de Sitter-like spacetime, but rather anti-de Sitter-like. That is, the Universe underwent an "AdS-to-dS" transition at some point. We study the possibility that there are two dark energy fluids, one of which gave rise to the anti-de Sitter-like early Universe. The interaction is modeled by the Lotka-Volterra equations, commonly used in population biology. We consider "competition" models that are further classified as "unfair competition" and "fair competition". The former involves a quintessence in competition with a phantom, and the second involves two phantom fluids. Surprisingly, even in the latter scenario it is possible for the overall dark energy to cross the phantom divide. The latter model also allows a constant $w$ "AdS-to-dS" transition, thus evading the theorem that such a dark energy must possess a singular equation of state. We also consider a "conversion" model in which a phantom fluid still manages to achieve "AdS-to-dS" transition even if it is being converted into a negative energy density quintessence. In these models, the energy density of the late time effective dark energy is related to the coefficient of the quadratic self-interaction term of the fluids, which is analogous to the resource capacity in population biology.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2023; v1 submitted 8 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Sign Switching Dark Energy from a Running Barrow Entropy
Authors:
Sofia Di Gennaro,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
Barrow proposed that the area law of the entropy associated with a horizon might receive a "fractal correction" due to quantum gravitational effects -- in place of $S\propto A$, we have instead $S\propto A^{1+δ/2}$, where $0\leqslant δ\leqslant 1$ measures the deviation from the standard area law ($δ=0$). Based on black hole thermodynamics, we argue that the Barrow entropy should run (i.e., energy…
▽ More
Barrow proposed that the area law of the entropy associated with a horizon might receive a "fractal correction" due to quantum gravitational effects -- in place of $S\propto A$, we have instead $S\propto A^{1+δ/2}$, where $0\leqslant δ\leqslant 1$ measures the deviation from the standard area law ($δ=0$). Based on black hole thermodynamics, we argue that the Barrow entropy should run (i.e., energy scale dependent), which is reasonable given that quantum gravitational corrections are expected to be important only in high energy regime. When applied to the Friedmann equation, we demonstrate the possibility that such a running Barrow entropy index could give rise to a dynamical effective dark energy, which is asymptotically positive and vanishing, but negative at the Big Bang. Such a sign switching dark energy could help to alleviate the Hubble tension. Other cosmological implications are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2022; v1 submitted 18 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Traversable Wormhole in Einstein 3-Form Theory With Self-Interacting Potential
Authors:
Mariam Bouhmadi-López,
Che-Yu Chen,
Xiao Yan Chew,
Yen Chin Ong,
Dong-han Yeom
Abstract:
We numerically construct a symmetric wormhole solution in pure Einstein gravity supported by a massive $3$-form field with a potential that contains a quartic self-interaction term. The wormhole spacetimes have only a single throat and they are everywhere regular and asymptotically flat. Furthermore, their mass and throat circumference increase almost linearly as the coefficient of the quartic sel…
▽ More
We numerically construct a symmetric wormhole solution in pure Einstein gravity supported by a massive $3$-form field with a potential that contains a quartic self-interaction term. The wormhole spacetimes have only a single throat and they are everywhere regular and asymptotically flat. Furthermore, their mass and throat circumference increase almost linearly as the coefficient of the quartic self-interaction term $Λ$ increases. The amount of violation of the null energy condition (NEC) is proportional to the magnitude of $3$-form, thus the NEC is less violated as $Λ$ increases, since the magnitude of $3$-form decreases with $Λ$. In addition, we investigate the geodesics of particles moving around the wormhole. The unstable photon orbit is located at the throat. We also find that the wormhole can cast a shadow whose apparent size is smaller than that cast by the Schwarzschild black hole, but reduces to it when $Λ$ acquires a large value. The behavior of the innermost stable circular orbit around this wormhole is also discussed. The results of this paper hint toward the possibility that the 3-form wormholes could be potential black hole mimickers, as long as $Λ$ is sufficiently large, precisely when NEC is weakly violated.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2021; v1 submitted 16 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Feasibility of Primordial Black Hole Remnants as Dark Matter in View of Hawking Radiation Recoil
Authors:
Sofia Di Gennaro,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
It has recently been suggested that black hole remnants of primordial origin are not a viable dark matter candidate since they would have far too large a velocity due to the recoil of Hawking radiation. We re-examined this interesting claim in more details and found that it does not rule out such a possibility. On the contrary, for models based on non-commutativity of spacetime near the Planck sca…
▽ More
It has recently been suggested that black hole remnants of primordial origin are not a viable dark matter candidate since they would have far too large a velocity due to the recoil of Hawking radiation. We re-examined this interesting claim in more details and found that it does not rule out such a possibility. On the contrary, for models based on non-commutativity of spacetime near the Planck scale, essentially the same argument can be used to estimate the scale at which non-commutativity effect becomes important. If dark matter "particles" are non-commutative black holes that have passed the maximum temperature, this implies that the non-commutative scale is about 100 times the Planck length. The same analysis applies to other black hole remnants whose temperature reaches a maximum before cooling off, for example, black holes in asymptotically safe gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2021; v1 submitted 18 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Stephani Cosmology: Entropically Viable But Observationally Challenged
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong,
S. Sedigheh Hashemi,
Rui An,
Bin Wang
Abstract:
Inhomogeneous cosmological models such as the Stephani universes could, in principle, provide an explanation for the observed accelerated expansion of the Universe. Working with a concrete, popular model of the Stephani cosmology -- the Stephani-Dabrowski model, we found that it is entropically viable. We also comment on the energy conditions and the two-sheeted geometry of the spacetime. However,…
▽ More
Inhomogeneous cosmological models such as the Stephani universes could, in principle, provide an explanation for the observed accelerated expansion of the Universe. Working with a concrete, popular model of the Stephani cosmology -- the Stephani-Dabrowski model, we found that it is entropically viable. We also comment on the energy conditions and the two-sheeted geometry of the spacetime. However, similar to the LTB models, despite satisfying the holographic principle, Stephani cosmology has difficulty satisfying all the constraints from observations.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2018; v1 submitted 6 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Acausality and Nonunique Evolution in Generalized Teleparallel Gravity
Authors:
Keisuke Izumi,
Je-An Gu,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
We show the existence of physical superluminal modes and acausality in the Brans-Dicke type of extension of teleparallel gravity that includes F(T) gravity and teleparallel dark energy as special cases. We derive the characteristic hypersurface for the extra degrees of freedom in the theory, thereby showing that the time evolution is not unique and closed causal curves can appear. Furthermore, we…
▽ More
We show the existence of physical superluminal modes and acausality in the Brans-Dicke type of extension of teleparallel gravity that includes F(T) gravity and teleparallel dark energy as special cases. We derive the characteristic hypersurface for the extra degrees of freedom in the theory, thereby showing that the time evolution is not unique and closed causal curves can appear. Furthermore, we present a concrete disastrous solution in Bianchi type I spacetime, in which the anisotropy in expansion can be any function of time, and thus anisotropy can emerge suddenly, a simple demonstration that the theory is physically problematic.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2014; v1 submitted 25 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Problems with Propagation and Time Evolution in f(T) Gravity
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong,
Keisuke Izumi,
James M. Nester,
Pisin Chen
Abstract:
Teleparallel theories of gravity have a long history. They include a special case referred to as the Teleparallel Equivalent of General Relativity (TEGR, aka GR$_{\|}$). Recently this theory has been generalized to f(T) gravity. Tight constraints from observations suggest that f(T) gravity is not as robust as initially hoped. This might hint at hitherto undiscovered problems at the theoretical lev…
▽ More
Teleparallel theories of gravity have a long history. They include a special case referred to as the Teleparallel Equivalent of General Relativity (TEGR, aka GR$_{\|}$). Recently this theory has been generalized to f(T) gravity. Tight constraints from observations suggest that f(T) gravity is not as robust as initially hoped. This might hint at hitherto undiscovered problems at the theoretical level. In this work, we point out that a generic f(T) theory can be expected to have certain problems including superluminal propagating modes, the presence of which can be revealed by using the characteristic equations that govern the dynamics in f(T) gravity and/or the Hamiltonian structure of the theory via Dirac constraint analysis. We use several examples from simpler gauge field theories to explain how such superluminal modes could arise. We also point out problems with the Cauchy development of a constant time hypersurface in FLRW spacetime in f(T) gravity. The time evolution from a FLRW (and as a special case, Minkowski spacetime) initial condition is not unique.
△ Less
Submitted 31 July, 2013; v1 submitted 5 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
Cosmological Perturbation in f(T) Gravity Revisited
Authors:
Keisuke Izumi,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
We perform detailed investigation of cosmological perturbations in f(T) theory of gravity coupled with scalar field. Our work emphasizes on the way to gauge fix the theory and we examine all possible modes of perturbations up to second order. The analysis includes pseudoscalar and pseudovector modes in addition to the usual scalar, vector, and tensor modes. We find no gravitational propagating deg…
▽ More
We perform detailed investigation of cosmological perturbations in f(T) theory of gravity coupled with scalar field. Our work emphasizes on the way to gauge fix the theory and we examine all possible modes of perturbations up to second order. The analysis includes pseudoscalar and pseudovector modes in addition to the usual scalar, vector, and tensor modes. We find no gravitational propagating degree of freedom in the scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, as well as pseudovector modes. In addition, we find that the scalar and tensor perturbations have exactly the same form as their counterparts in usual general relativity with scalar field, except that the factor of reduced Planck mass squared $M_{\text{pl}}^2 \equiv 1/(8πG)$ that occurs in the latter has now been replaced by an effective time-dependentgravitational coupling $-2 (df/dT)|_{T=T_0}$, with $T_0$ being the background torsion scalar. The absence of extra degrees of freedom of f(T) gravity at second order linear perturbation indicates that f(T) gravity is highly nonlinear. Consequently one cannot conclusively analyze stability of the theory without performing nonlinear analysis that can reveal the propagation of the extra degrees of freedom.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2013; v1 submitted 23 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
