-
The AGORA High-resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project IV: Halo and Galaxy Mass Assembly in a Cosmological Zoom-in Simulation at $z\le2$
Authors:
Santi Roca-Fàbrega,
Ji-hoon Kim,
Joel R. Primack,
Minyong Jung,
Anna Genina,
Loic Hausammann,
Hyeonyong Kim,
Alessandro Lupi,
Kentaro Nagamine,
Johnny W. Powell,
Yves Revaz,
Ikkoh Shimizu,
Clayton Strawn,
Héctor Velázquez,
Tom Abel,
Daniel Ceverino,
Bili Dong,
Thomas R. Quinn,
Eun-** Shin,
Alvaro Segovia-Otero,
Oscar Agertz,
Kirk S. S. Barrow,
Corentin Cadiou,
Avishai Dekel,
Cameron Hummels
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
In this fourth paper from the AGORA Collaboration, we study the evolution down to redshift $z=2$ and below of a set of cosmological zoom-in simulations of a Milky Way mass galaxy by eight of the leading hydrodynamic simulation codes. We also compare this CosmoRun suite of simulations with dark matter-only simulations by the same eight codes. We analyze general properties of the halo and galaxy at…
▽ More
In this fourth paper from the AGORA Collaboration, we study the evolution down to redshift $z=2$ and below of a set of cosmological zoom-in simulations of a Milky Way mass galaxy by eight of the leading hydrodynamic simulation codes. We also compare this CosmoRun suite of simulations with dark matter-only simulations by the same eight codes. We analyze general properties of the halo and galaxy at $z=4$ and 3, and before the last major merger, focusing on the formation of well-defined rotationally-supported disks, the mass-metallicity relation, the specific star formation rate, the gas metallicity gradients, and the non-axisymmetric structures in the stellar disks. Codes generally converge well to the stellar-to-halo mass ratios predicted by semi-analytic models at $z\sim$2. We see that almost all the hydro codes develop rotationally-supported structures at low redshifts. Most agree within 0.5 dex with the observed MZR at high and intermediate redshifts, and reproduce the gas metallicity gradients obtained from analytical models and low-redshift observations. We confirm that the inter-code differences in the halo assembly history reported in the first paper of the collaboration also exist in CosmoRun, making the code-to-code comparison more difficult. We show that such differences are mainly due to variations in code-dependent parameters that control the time-step** strategy of the gravity solver. We find that variations in the early stellar feedback can also result in differences in the timing of the low-redshift mergers. All the simulation data down to $z=2$ and the auxiliary data will be made publicly available.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
The AGORA High-resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project. V: Satellite Galaxy Populations In A Cosmological Zoom-in Simulation of A Milky Way-mass Halo
Authors:
Minyong Jung,
Santi Roca-Fàbrega,
Ji-hoon Kim,
Anna Genina,
Loic Hausammann,
Hyeonyong Kim,
Alessandro Lupi,
Kentaro Nagamine,
Johnny W. Powell,
Yves Revaz,
Ikkoh Shimizu,
Héctor Velázquez,
Daniel Ceverino,
Joel R. Primack,
Thomas R. Quinn,
Clayton Strawn,
Tom Abel,
Avishai Dekel,
Bili Dong,
Boon Kiat Oh,
Romain Teyssier
Abstract:
We analyze and compare the satellite halo populations at $z\sim2$ in the high-resolution cosmological zoom-in simulations of a $10^{12}\,{\rm M}_{\odot}$ target halo ($z=0$ mass) carried out on eight widely-used astrophysical simulation codes ({\sc Art-I}, {\sc Enzo}, {\sc Ramses}, {\sc Changa}, {\sc Gadget-3}, {\sc Gear}, {\sc Arepo-t}, and {\sc Gizmo}) for the {\it AGORA} High-resolution Galaxy…
▽ More
We analyze and compare the satellite halo populations at $z\sim2$ in the high-resolution cosmological zoom-in simulations of a $10^{12}\,{\rm M}_{\odot}$ target halo ($z=0$ mass) carried out on eight widely-used astrophysical simulation codes ({\sc Art-I}, {\sc Enzo}, {\sc Ramses}, {\sc Changa}, {\sc Gadget-3}, {\sc Gear}, {\sc Arepo-t}, and {\sc Gizmo}) for the {\it AGORA} High-resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project. We use slightly different redshift epochs near $z=2$ for each code (hereafter ``$z\sim2$') at which the eight simulations are in the same stage in the target halo's merger history. After identifying the matched pairs of halos between the {\it CosmoRun} simulations and the DMO simulations, we discover that each {\it CosmoRun} halo tends to be less massive than its DMO counterpart. When we consider only the halos containing stellar particles at $z\sim2$, the number of satellite {\it galaxies} is significantly fewer than that of dark matter halos in all participating {\it AGORA} simulations, and is comparable to the number of present-day satellites near the Milky Way or M31. The so-called ``missing satellite problem' is fully resolved across all participating codes simply by implementing the common baryonic physics adopted in {\it AGORA} and the stellar feedback prescription commonly used in each code, with sufficient numerical resolution ($\lesssim100$ proper pc at $z=2$). We also compare other properties such as the stellar mass$-$halo mass relation and the mass$-$metallicity relation. Our work highlights the value of comparison studies such as {\it AGORA}, where outstanding problems in galaxy formation theory are studied simultaneously on multiple numerical platforms.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
The AGORA High-resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project. VI. Similarities and Differences in the Circumgalactic Medium
Authors:
Clayton Strawn,
Santi Roca-Fàbrega,
Joel R. Primack,
Ji-hoon Kim,
Anna Genina,
Loic Hausammann,
Hyeonyong Kim,
Alessandro Lupi,
Kentaro Nagamine,
Johnny W. Powell,
Yves Revaz,
Ikkoh Shimizu,
Héctor Velázquez,
Tom Abel,
Daniel Ceverino,
Bili Dong,
Minyong Jung,
Thomas R. Quinn,
Eun-** Shin,
Kirk S. S. Barrow,
Avishai Dekel,
Boon Kiat Oh,
Nir Mandelker,
Romain Teyssier,
Cameron Hummels
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We analyze the circumgalactic medium (CGM) for eight commonly-used cosmological codes in the AGORA collaboration. The codes are calibrated to use identical initial conditions, cosmology, heating and cooling, and star formation thresholds, but each evolves with its own unique code architecture and stellar feedback implementation. Here, we analyze the results of these simulations in terms of the str…
▽ More
We analyze the circumgalactic medium (CGM) for eight commonly-used cosmological codes in the AGORA collaboration. The codes are calibrated to use identical initial conditions, cosmology, heating and cooling, and star formation thresholds, but each evolves with its own unique code architecture and stellar feedback implementation. Here, we analyze the results of these simulations in terms of the structure, composition, and phase dynamics of the CGM. We show properties such as metal distribution, ionization levels, and kinematics are effective tracers of the effects of the different code feedback and implementation methods, and as such they can be highly divergent between simulations. This is merely a fiducial set of models, against which we will in the future compare multiple feedback recipes for each code. Nevertheless, we find that the large parameter space these simulations establish can help disentangle the different variables that affect observable quantities in the CGM, e.g., showing that abundances for ions with higher ionization energy are more strongly determined by the simulation's metallicity, while abundances for ions with lower ionization energy are more strongly determined by the gas density and temperature.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Merger Tree-based Galaxy Matching: A Comparative Study Across Different Resolutions
Authors:
Minyong Jung,
Ji-hoon Kim,
Boon Kiat Oh,
Sungwook E. Hong,
Jaehyun Lee,
Juhan Kim
Abstract:
We introduce a novel halo/galaxy matching technique between two cosmological simulations with different resolutions, which utilizes the positions and masses of halos along their subhalo merger tree. With this tool, we conduct a study of resolution biases through the {\it galaxy-by-galaxy} inspection of a pair of simulations that have the same simulation configuration but different mass resolutions…
▽ More
We introduce a novel halo/galaxy matching technique between two cosmological simulations with different resolutions, which utilizes the positions and masses of halos along their subhalo merger tree. With this tool, we conduct a study of resolution biases through the {\it galaxy-by-galaxy} inspection of a pair of simulations that have the same simulation configuration but different mass resolutions, utilizing a suite of {\sc IllustrisTNG} simulations to assess the impact on galaxy properties. We find that, with the subgrid physics model calibrated for TNG100-1, subhalos in TNG100-1 (high resolution) have $\lesssim0.5$ dex higher stellar masses than their counterparts in the TNG100-2 (low-resolution). It is also discovered that the subhalos with $M_{\mathrm{gas}}\sim10^{8.5}\,{\rm M}_\odot$ in TNG100-1 have $\sim0.5$ dex higher gas mass than those in TNG100-2. The mass profiles of the subhalos reveal that the dark matter masses of subhalos in TNG100-2 converge well with those from TNG100-1, except within 4 kpc of the resolution limit. The differences in stellar mass and hot gas mass are most pronounced in the central region. We exploit machine learning to build a correction map** for the physical quantities of subhalos from low- to high-resolution simulations (TNG300-1 and TNG100-1), which enables us to find an efficient way to compile a high-resolution galaxy catalog even from a low-resolution simulation. Our tools can easily be applied to other large cosmological simulations, testing and mitigating the resolution biases of their numerical codes and subgrid physics models.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2024; v1 submitted 4 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Dense stellar clump formation driven by strong quasar winds in the FIRE cosmological hydrodynamic simulations
Authors:
Jonathan Mercedes-Feliz,
Daniel Anglés-Alcázar,
Boon Kiat Oh,
Christopher C. Hayward,
Rachel K. Cochrane,
Alexander J. Richings,
Claude-André Faucher-Giguère,
Sarah Wellons,
Bryan A. Terrazas,
Jorge Moreno,
Kung Yi Su,
Philip F. Hopkins
Abstract:
We investigate the formation of dense stellar clumps in a suite of high-resolution cosmological zoom-in simulations of a massive, star forming galaxy at $z \sim 2$ under the presence of strong quasar winds. Our simulations include multi-phase ISM physics from the Feedback In Realistic Environments (FIRE) project and a novel implementation of hyper-refined accretion disk winds. We show that powerfu…
▽ More
We investigate the formation of dense stellar clumps in a suite of high-resolution cosmological zoom-in simulations of a massive, star forming galaxy at $z \sim 2$ under the presence of strong quasar winds. Our simulations include multi-phase ISM physics from the Feedback In Realistic Environments (FIRE) project and a novel implementation of hyper-refined accretion disk winds. We show that powerful quasar winds can have a global negative impact on galaxy growth while in the strongest cases triggering the formation of an off-center clump with stellar mass ${\rm M}_{\star}\sim 10^{7}\,{\rm M}_{\odot}$, effective radius ${\rm R}_{\rm 1/2\,\rm Clump}\sim 20\,{\rm pc}$, and surface density $Σ_{\star} \sim 10^{4}\,{\rm M}_{\odot}\,{\rm pc}^{-2}$. The clump progenitor gas cloud is originally not star-forming, but strong ram pressure gradients driven by the quasar winds (orders of magnitude stronger than experienced in the absence of winds) lead to rapid compression and subsequent conversion of gas into stars at densities much higher than the average density of star-forming gas. The AGN-triggered star-forming clump reaches ${\rm SFR} \sim 50\,{\rm M}_{\odot}\,{\rm yr}^{-1}$ and $Σ_{\rm SFR} \sim 10^{4}\,{\rm M}_{\odot}\,{\rm yr}^{-1}\,{\rm kpc}^{-2}$, converting most of the progenitor gas cloud into stars in $\sim$2\,Myr, significantly faster than its initial free-fall time and with stellar feedback unable to stop star formation. In contrast, the same gas cloud in the absence of quasar winds forms stars over a much longer period of time ($\sim$35\,Myr), at lower densities, and losing spatial coherency. The presence of young, ultra-dense, gravitationally bound stellar clumps in recently quenched galaxies could thus indicate local positive feedback acting alongside the strong negative impact of powerful quasar winds, providing a plausible formation scenario for globular clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2024; v1 submitted 30 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Growth of A Massive Black Hole Via Tidal Disruption Accretion
Authors:
Seungjae Lee,
Ji-hoon Kim,
Boon Kiat Oh
Abstract:
Stars that are tidally disrupted by the massive black hole (MBH) may contribute significantly to the growth of the MBH, especially in dense nuclear star clusters (NSCs). Yet, this tidal disruption accretion (TDA) of stars onto the MBH has largely been overlooked compared to the gas accretion (GA) channel in most numerical experiments until now. In this work, we implement a black hole growth channe…
▽ More
Stars that are tidally disrupted by the massive black hole (MBH) may contribute significantly to the growth of the MBH, especially in dense nuclear star clusters (NSCs). Yet, this tidal disruption accretion (TDA) of stars onto the MBH has largely been overlooked compared to the gas accretion (GA) channel in most numerical experiments until now. In this work, we implement a black hole growth channel via TDA in the high-resolution adaptive mesh refinement code Enzo to investigate its influence on a MBH seed's early evolution. We find that a MBH seed grows rapidly from $10^3\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$ to $\gtrsim 10^6\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$ in 200\,Myrs in some of the tested simulations. Compared to a MBH seed that grows only via GA, TDA can enhance the MBH's growth rate by up to more than an order of magnitude. However, as predicted, TDA mainly helps the early growth of the MBH (from $10^{3-4}\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$ to $\lesssim10^{5}\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$) while the later evolution is generally dominated by GA. We also observe that the star formation near the MBH is suppressed when TDA is most active, sometimes with a visible cavity in gas (of size $\sim$ a few pc) created in the vicinity of the MBH. It is because the MBH may grow expeditiously with both GA and TDA, and the massive MBH could consume its neighboring gas faster than being replenished by gas inflows. Our study demonstrates the need to consider different channels of black hole accretion that may provide clues for the existence of supermassive black holes at high redshifts.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2022; v1 submitted 4 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
The fate of baryons in counterfactual universes
Authors:
Boon Kiat Oh,
John A. Peacock,
Sadegh Khochfar,
Britton D. Smith
Abstract:
We present results from nine simulations that compare the standard $Λ$ Cold Dark Matter cosmology ($Λ$CDM) with counterfactual universes, for approximately $100\,{\rm Gyr}$ using the Enzo simulation code. We vary the value of $Λ$ and the fluctuation amplitude to explore the effect on the evolution of the halo mass function (HMF), the intergalactic medium (IGM) and the star formation history (SFH).…
▽ More
We present results from nine simulations that compare the standard $Λ$ Cold Dark Matter cosmology ($Λ$CDM) with counterfactual universes, for approximately $100\,{\rm Gyr}$ using the Enzo simulation code. We vary the value of $Λ$ and the fluctuation amplitude to explore the effect on the evolution of the halo mass function (HMF), the intergalactic medium (IGM) and the star formation history (SFH). The distinct peak in star formation rate density (SFRD) and its subsequent decline are both affected by the interplay between gravitational attraction and the accelerating effects of $Λ$. The IGM cools down more rapidly in models with a larger $Λ$ and also with a lower $σ_8$, reflecting the reduced SFRD associated with these changes -- although changing $σ_8$ is not degenerate with changing $Λ$, either regarding the thermal history of the IGM or the SFH. However, these induced changes to the IGM or ionizing background have little impact on the calculated SFRD. We provide fits for the evolution of the SFRD in these different universes, which we integrate over time to derive an asymptotic star formation efficiency. Together with Weinberg's uniform prior on $Λ$, the estimated probability of observers experiencing a value of $Λ$ no greater than the observed value is 13%, substantially larger than some alternative estimates. Within the Enzo model framework, then, observer selection within a multiverse is able to account statistically for the small value of the cosmological constant, although $Λ$ in our universe does appear to be at the low end of the predicted range.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Machine-guided Exploration and Calibration of Astrophysical Simulations
Authors:
Boon Kiat Oh,
Hongjun An,
Eun-** Shin,
Ji-hoon Kim,
Sungwook E. Hong
Abstract:
We apply a novel method with machine learning to calibrate sub-grid models within numerical simulation codes to achieve convergence with observations and between different codes. It utilizes active learning and neural density estimators. The hyper parameters of the machine are calibrated with a well-defined projectile motion problem. Then, using a set of 22 cosmological zoom simulations, we tune t…
▽ More
We apply a novel method with machine learning to calibrate sub-grid models within numerical simulation codes to achieve convergence with observations and between different codes. It utilizes active learning and neural density estimators. The hyper parameters of the machine are calibrated with a well-defined projectile motion problem. Then, using a set of 22 cosmological zoom simulations, we tune the parameters of a popular star formation and feedback model within Enzo to match simulations. The parameters that are adjusted include the star formation efficiency, coupling of thermal energy from stellar feedback, and volume into which the energy is deposited. This number translates to a factor of more than three improvements over manual calibration. Despite using fewer simulations, we obtain a better agreement to the observed baryon makeup of a Milky-Way (MW) sized halo. Switching to a different strategy, we improve the consistency of the recommended parameters from the machine. Given the success of the calibration, we then apply the technique to reconcile metal transport between grid-based and particle-based simulation codes using an isolated galaxy. It is an improvement over manual exploration while hinting at a less known relation between the diffusion coefficient and the metal mass in the halo region. The exploration and calibration of the parameters of the sub-grid models with a machine learning approach is concluded to be versatile and directly applicable to different problems.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
How Metals Are Transported In And Out Of A Galactic Disk: Dependence On The Hydrodynamic Schemes In Numerical Simulations
Authors:
Eun-** Shin,
Ji-hoon Kim,
Boon Kiat Oh
Abstract:
Metallicity is a fundamental probe for understanding the baryon physics in a galaxy. Since metals are intricately associated with radiative cooling, star formation, and feedback, reproducing the observed metal distribution through numerical experiments will provide a prominent way to examine our understandings of galactic baryon physics. In this study, we analyze the dependence of the galactic met…
▽ More
Metallicity is a fundamental probe for understanding the baryon physics in a galaxy. Since metals are intricately associated with radiative cooling, star formation, and feedback, reproducing the observed metal distribution through numerical experiments will provide a prominent way to examine our understandings of galactic baryon physics. In this study, we analyze the dependence of the galactic metal distribution on the numerical schemes and quantify the differences in the metal mixing among modern galaxy simulation codes (the mesh-based code Enzo and the particle-based codes Gadget-2 and Gizmo-PSPH). In particular, we examine different stellar feedback strengths and an explicit metal diffusion scheme in particle-based codes, as a way to alleviate the well-known discrepancy in metal transport between mesh-based and particle-based simulations. We demonstrate that a sufficient number of gas particles are needed in the gas halo to properly investigate the metal distribution therein. Including an explicit metal diffusion scheme does not significantly affect the metal distribution in the galactic disk but does change the amount of low-metallicity gas in the hot-diffuse halo. We also find that the spatial distribution of metals depends strongly on how the stellar feedback is modeled. We demonstrate that the previously reported discrepancy in metals between mesh-based and particle-based simulations can be mitigated with our proposed prescription, enabling these simulations to be reliably utilized in the study of metals in galactic halos and the circumgalactic medium.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Evolving beyond z=0: insights about the future of stars and the intergalactic medium
Authors:
Boon Kiat Oh,
John A. Peacock,
Sadegh Khochfar,
Britton D. Smith
Abstract:
We present results from seven cosmological simulations that have been extended beyond the present era as far as redshift $z=-0.995$ or $t\approx96\,{\rm Gyr}$, using the Enzo simulation code. We adopt the calibrated star formation and feedback prescriptions from our previous work on reproducing the Milky Way with Enzo with modifications to the simulation code, chemistry and cooling library. We the…
▽ More
We present results from seven cosmological simulations that have been extended beyond the present era as far as redshift $z=-0.995$ or $t\approx96\,{\rm Gyr}$, using the Enzo simulation code. We adopt the calibrated star formation and feedback prescriptions from our previous work on reproducing the Milky Way with Enzo with modifications to the simulation code, chemistry and cooling library. We then consider the future behaviour of the halo mass function (HMF), the equation of state (EOS) of the IGM, and the cosmic star formation history (SFH). Consistent with previous work, we find a freeze-out in the HMF at $z\approx-0.6$. The evolution of the EOS of the IGM presents an interesting case study of the cosmological coincidence problem, where there is a sharp decline in the IGM temperature immediately after $z=0$. For the SFH, the simulations produce a peak and a subsequent decline into the future. However, we do find a turnaround in the SFH after $z\approx-0.98$ in some simulations, probably due to the limitations of the criteria used for star formation. By integrating the SFH in time up to $z=-0.92$, the simulation with the best spatial resolution predicts an asymptotic total stellar mass that is very close to that obtained from extrapolating the fit of the observed SFR. Lastly, we investigate the future evolution of the partition of baryons within a Milky Way-sized galaxy, using both a zoom and a box simulation. Despite vastly different resolutions, these simulations predict individual haloes containing an equal fraction of baryons in stars and gas at the time of freeze-out ($t\approx30\,{\rm Gyr}$).
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Dark Matter Deficient Galaxies Produced Via High-velocity Galaxy Collisions In High-resolution Numerical Simulations
Authors:
Eun-** Shin,
Minyong Jung,
Goo** Kwon,
Ji-hoon Kim,
Joohyun Lee,
Yongseok Jo,
Boon Kiat Oh
Abstract:
The recent discovery of diffuse dwarf galaxies that are deficient in dark matter appears to challenge the current paradigm of structure formation in our Universe. We describe the numerical experiments to determine if the so-called dark matter deficient galaxies (DMDGs) could be produced when two gas-rich, dwarf-sized galaxies collide with a high relative velocity of $\sim 300\,{\rm kms^{-1}}$. Usi…
▽ More
The recent discovery of diffuse dwarf galaxies that are deficient in dark matter appears to challenge the current paradigm of structure formation in our Universe. We describe the numerical experiments to determine if the so-called dark matter deficient galaxies (DMDGs) could be produced when two gas-rich, dwarf-sized galaxies collide with a high relative velocity of $\sim 300\,{\rm kms^{-1}}$. Using idealized high-resolution simulations with both mesh-based and particle-based gravito-hydrodynamics codes, we find that DMDGs can form as high-velocity galaxy collisions separate dark matter from the warm disk gas which subsequently is compressed by shock and tidal interaction to form stars. Then using a large simulated universe IllustrisTNG, we discover a number of high-velocity galaxy collision events in which DMDGs are expected to form. However, we did not find evidence that these types of collisions actually produced DMDGs in the TNG100-1 run. We argue that the resolution of the numerical experiment is critical to realize the "collision-induced" DMDG formation scenario. Our results demonstrate one of many routes in which galaxies could form with unconventional dark matter fractions.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2020; v1 submitted 20 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Calibration of a star formation and feedback model for cosmological simulations with Enzo
Authors:
Boon Kiat Oh,
Britton D. Smith,
John A. Peacock,
Sadegh Khochfar
Abstract:
We present results from seventy-one zoom simulations of a Milky Way-sized (MW) halo, exploring the parameter space for a widely-used star formation and feedback model in the {\tt Enzo} simulation code. We propose a novel way to match observations, using functional fits to the observed baryon makeup over a wide range of halo masses. The model MW galaxy is calibrated using three parameters: the star…
▽ More
We present results from seventy-one zoom simulations of a Milky Way-sized (MW) halo, exploring the parameter space for a widely-used star formation and feedback model in the {\tt Enzo} simulation code. We propose a novel way to match observations, using functional fits to the observed baryon makeup over a wide range of halo masses. The model MW galaxy is calibrated using three parameters: the star formation efficiency $\left(f_*\right)$, the efficiency of thermal energy from stellar feedback $\left(ε\right)$ and the region into which feedback is injected $\left(r\ {\rm and}\ s\right)$. We find that changing the amount of feedback energy affects the baryon content most significantly. We then identify two sets of feedback parameter values that are both able to reproduce the baryonic properties for haloes between $10^{10}\,\mathrm{M_\odot}$ and $10^{12}\,\mathrm{M_\odot}$. We can potentially improve the agreement by incorporating more parameters or physics. If we choose to focus on one property at a time, we can obtain a more realistic halo baryon makeup. We show that the employed feedback prescription is insensitive to dark matter mass resolution between $10^5\,{\rm M_\odot}$ and $10^7\,{\rm M_\odot}$. Contrasting both star formation criteria and the corresponding combination of optimal feedback parameters, we also highlight that feedback is self-consistent: to match the same baryonic properties, with a relatively higher gas to stars conversion efficiency, the feedback strength required is lower, and vice versa. Lastly, we demonstrate that chaotic variance in the code can cause deviations of approximately 10\% and 25\% in the stellar and baryon mass in simulations evolved from identical initial conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.