-
Striking the right tone: toward a self-consistent framework for measuring black hole ringdowns
Authors:
Teagan A. Clarke,
Maximiliano Isi,
Paul D. Lasky,
Eric Thrane,
Michael Boyle,
Nils Deppe,
Lawrence E. Kidder,
Keefe Mitman,
Jordan Moxon,
Kyle C. Nelli,
William Throwe,
Nils L. Vu
Abstract:
The ringdown portion of a binary black hole merger consists of a sum of modes, each containing an infinite number of tones that are exponentially damped sinusoids. In principle, these can be measured as gravitational-waves with observatories like LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA, however in practice it is unclear how many tones can be meaningfully resolved. We investigate the consistency and resolvability of the…
▽ More
The ringdown portion of a binary black hole merger consists of a sum of modes, each containing an infinite number of tones that are exponentially damped sinusoids. In principle, these can be measured as gravitational-waves with observatories like LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA, however in practice it is unclear how many tones can be meaningfully resolved. We investigate the consistency and resolvability of the overtones of the quadrupolar $\ell = m = 2$ mode by starting at late times when the gravitational waveform is expected to be well-approximated by the $\ell m n = 220$ tone alone. We present a Bayesian inference framework to measure the tones in numerical relativity data. We measure tones at different start times, checking for consistency: we classify a tone as stably recovered if and only if the 95\% credible intervals for amplitude and phase at time $t$ overlap with the credible intervals at all subsequent times. We test a set of tones including the first four overtones of the fundamental mode and the 320 tone and find that the 220 and 221 tones can be measured consistently with the inclusion of additional overtones. The 222 tone measurements can be stabilised when we include the 223 tone, but only in a narrow time window, after which it is too weak to measure. The 223 tone recovery appears to be unstable, and does not become stable with the introduction of the 224 tone. We find that $N=3$ tones can be stably recovered simultaneously. However, when analysing $N \geq 4$ tones, the amplitude of one tone is consistent with zero. Thus, within our framework, one can identify only $N=3$ tones with non-zero amplitude that are simultaneously stable.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2024; v1 submitted 5 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Nonlinear Effects In Black Hole Ringdown From Scattering Experiments I: spin and initial data dependence of quadratic mode coupling
Authors:
Hengrui Zhu,
Justin L. Ripley,
Frans Pretorius,
Sizheng Ma,
Keefe Mitman,
Robert Owen,
Michael Boyle,
Yitian Chen,
Nils Deppe,
Lawrence E. Kidder,
Jordan Moxon,
Kyle C. Nelli,
Harald P. Pfeiffer,
Mark A. Scheel,
William Throwe,
Nils L. Vu
Abstract:
We investigate quadratic quasinormal mode coupling in black hole spacetime through numerical simulations of single perturbed black holes using both numerical relativity and second-order black hole perturbation theory. Focusing on the dominant $\ell=|m|=2$ quadrupolar modes, we find good agreement (within $\sim10\%$) between these approaches, with discrepancies attributed to truncation error and un…
▽ More
We investigate quadratic quasinormal mode coupling in black hole spacetime through numerical simulations of single perturbed black holes using both numerical relativity and second-order black hole perturbation theory. Focusing on the dominant $\ell=|m|=2$ quadrupolar modes, we find good agreement (within $\sim10\%$) between these approaches, with discrepancies attributed to truncation error and uncertainties from mode fitting. Our results align with earlier studies extracting the coupling coefficients from select binary black hole merger simulations, showing consistency for the same remnant spins. Notably, the coupling coefficient is insensitive to a diverse range of initial data, including configurations that led to a significant (up to $5\%$) increase in the remnant black hole mass. These findings present opportunities for testing the nonlinear dynamics of general relativity with ground-based gravitational wave observatories. Lastly, we provide evidence of a bifurcation in coupling coefficients between counter-rotating and co-rotating quasinormal modes as black hole spin increases.
△ Less
Submitted 1 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Black Hole Spectroscopy for Precessing Binary Black Hole Coalescences
Authors:
Hengrui Zhu,
Harrison Siegel,
Keefe Mitman,
Maximiliano Isi,
Will M. Farr,
Michael Boyle,
Nils Deppe,
Lawrence E. Kidder,
Sizheng Ma,
Jordan Moxon,
Kyle C. Nelli,
Harald P. Pfeiffer,
Mark A. Scheel,
Saul A. Teukolsky,
William Throwe,
Vijay Varma,
Nils L. Vu
Abstract:
To accurately perform black hole spectroscopy, it is essential to know which quasinormal modes dominate astrophysical ringdown signals. In this Letter, we present a phenomenological description of the quasinormal modes that are excited in the ringdowns of comparable mass, quasi-circular precessing binary black hole coalescences. By analyzing an exhaustive catalog of numerical relativity simulation…
▽ More
To accurately perform black hole spectroscopy, it is essential to know which quasinormal modes dominate astrophysical ringdown signals. In this Letter, we present a phenomenological description of the quasinormal modes that are excited in the ringdowns of comparable mass, quasi-circular precessing binary black hole coalescences. By analyzing an exhaustive catalog of numerical relativity simulations, we confirm that the relative fundamental quasinormal mode amplitudes of precessing systems are related to those of non-precessing systems by a simple rotation, and that additional structure in the spectrum is connected to the system's kick velocity and other asymmetries in the orbital dynamics. We find that the ringdowns of precessing systems need not be dominated by the ${(\ell,m)=(2,\pm 2)}$ quasinormal modes. These results build upon previous works on waveform modeling, and are consistent with a recent ringdown analysis of the LIGO-Virgo gravitational wave signal GW190521.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Simulating magnetized neutron stars with discontinuous Galerkin methods
Authors:
Nils Deppe,
François Hébert,
Lawrence E. Kidder,
William Throwe,
Isha Anantpurkar,
Cristóbal Armaza,
Gabriel S. Bonilla,
Michael Boyle,
Himanshu Chaudhary,
Matthew D. Duez,
Nils L. Vu,
Francois Foucart,
Matthew Giesler,
Jason S. Guo,
Yoonsoo Kim,
Prayush Kumar,
Isaac Legred,
Dongjun Li,
Geoffrey Lovelace,
Sizheng Ma,
Alexandra Macedo,
Denyz Melchor,
Marlo Morales,
Jordan Moxon,
Kyle C. Nelli
, et al. (11 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Discontinuous Galerkin methods are popular because they can achieve high order where the solution is smooth, because they can capture shocks while needing only nearest-neighbor communication, and because they are relatively easy to formulate on complex meshes. We perform a detailed comparison of various limiting strategies presented in the literature applied to the equations of general relativisti…
▽ More
Discontinuous Galerkin methods are popular because they can achieve high order where the solution is smooth, because they can capture shocks while needing only nearest-neighbor communication, and because they are relatively easy to formulate on complex meshes. We perform a detailed comparison of various limiting strategies presented in the literature applied to the equations of general relativistic magnetohydrodynamics. We compare the standard minmod/$ΛΠ^N$ limiter, the hierarchical limiter of Krivodonova, the simple WENO limiter, the HWENO limiter, and a discontinuous Galerkin-finite-difference hybrid method. The ultimate goal is to understand what limiting strategies are able to robustly simulate magnetized TOV stars without any fine-tuning of parameters. Among the limiters explored here, the only limiting strategy we can endorse is a discontinuous Galerkin-finite-difference hybrid method.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2022; v1 submitted 24 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Magnetic Ergostars, Jet Formation and Gamma-Ray Bursts: Ergoregions versus Horizons
Authors:
Milton Ruiz,
Antonios Tsokaros,
Stuart L. Shapiro,
Kyle C. Nelli,
Sam Qunell
Abstract:
We perform the first fully general relativistic, magnetohydrodynamic simulations of dynamically stable hypermassive neutron stars with and without ergoregions to assess the impact of ergoregions on launching magnetically--driven outflows. The hypermassive neutron stars are modeled by a compressible and causal equation of state and are initially endowed with a dipolar magnetic field extending from…
▽ More
We perform the first fully general relativistic, magnetohydrodynamic simulations of dynamically stable hypermassive neutron stars with and without ergoregions to assess the impact of ergoregions on launching magnetically--driven outflows. The hypermassive neutron stars are modeled by a compressible and causal equation of state and are initially endowed with a dipolar magnetic field extending from the stellar interior into its exterior. We find that, after a few Alfvén times, magnetic field lines in the ergostar (star that contains ergoregions) and the normal star have been tightly wound in both cases into a helical funnel within which matter begins to flow outward. The maximum Lorentz factor in the outflow is $Γ_L \sim 2.5$, while the force-free parameter holds at $B^2/8πρ_0\lesssim 10$. These values are incompatible with highly relativistic, magnetically-driven outflows (jets) and short $γ$-ray bursts. We compare these results with those of a spinning black hole surrounded by a magnetized, massless accretion disk that launches a bona fide jet. Our simulations suggest that the Blandford-Znajek mechanism for launching relativistic jets only operates when a black hole is present, though the Poynting luminosity in all cases is comparable. Therefore, one cannot distinguish a magnetized, accreting black hole from a magnetized hypermassive neutron star in the so-called mass-gap based solely on the value of the observed Poynting luminosity. These results complement our previous studies of supramassive remnants and suggest that it would be challenging for either normal neutron stars or ergostars in a hypermassive state to be the progenitors of short $γ$-ray bursts.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2020; v1 submitted 18 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.