Showing 1–50 of 185 results for author: Nakar, E

The neutron-star merger delay-time distribution, r-process "knees", and the metal budget of the Galaxy

Authors: Dan Maoz, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: For a sample of 18 recycled millisecond pulsars (rMSPs) that are in double neutron star (DNS) systems, and 42 rMSPs that are not in DNS pairs, we analyze the distributions of the characteristic age, $τ_c$, and the time until merger of the double systems, $τ_{\rm gw}$. Based on the $τ_c$ distribution of non-DNS rMSPs, we argue that $τ_c$ is a reasonable estimator of true pulsar age and that rMSPs a… ▽ More For a sample of 18 recycled millisecond pulsars (rMSPs) that are in double neutron star (DNS) systems, and 42 rMSPs that are not in DNS pairs, we analyze the distributions of the characteristic age, $τ_c$, and the time until merger of the double systems, $τ_{\rm gw}$. Based on the $τ_c$ distribution of non-DNS rMSPs, we argue that $τ_c$ is a reasonable estimator of true pulsar age and that rMSPs are active as pulsars for a long (~Hubble) time. Among the DNSs there is an excess of young systems (small $τ_c$) with short life expectancy (small $τ_{\rm gw}$) compared to model expectations for the distributions of $τ_c$ and $τ_{\rm gw}$ if, at birth, DNSs have a delay-time distribution (DTD) of the form $t^{-1}$ (expected generically for close binaries), or for that matter, from expectations from any single power-law DTD. A two-population DNS model solves the problem: the data are best fit by the combination of a "fast" population with DTD going as $t^{-1.9\pm0.4}$, and a "slow" population of DNSs, with DTD proportional to $t^{-1.1\pm0.15}$. The fast population can be equivalently represented by a DTD with an exponential cutoff beyond t~300 Myr. The fast population completely dominates, by a factor A~10-100, the numbers of DNSs that merge within a Hubble time, and that presumably lead to short gamma-ray bursts and kilonova explosions. With a simple, empirically based, chemical-evolution calculation, we show that the fast/steep kilonova DTD, convolved with the measured star-formation history of the Milky Way's thick-disk population, naturally reproduces the "knee" structure seen in abundance-ratio diagrams of thick-disk stars, for europium and two other r-process elements. As a corollary we show, based again solely on empirical input, that the Milky Way is nearly a "closed box" that has retained at least ~70-90% of the metals produced over the Galaxy's lifetime. △ Less

Submitted 12 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Comments: ApJ, submitted, comments welcome

Stripped-envelope supernova light curves argue for central engine activity

Authors: Ósmar Rodríguez, Ehud Nakar, Dan Maoz

Abstract: The luminosity of ``stripped-envelope supernovae'', a common type of stellar explosions, has been generally thought to be driven by the radioactive decay of the nickel synthesized in the explosion and carried in its ejecta. Additional possible energy sources have been previously suggested, but these claims have been statistically inconclusive or model-dependent. Here, we analyse the energy budget… ▽ More The luminosity of ``stripped-envelope supernovae'', a common type of stellar explosions, has been generally thought to be driven by the radioactive decay of the nickel synthesized in the explosion and carried in its ejecta. Additional possible energy sources have been previously suggested, but these claims have been statistically inconclusive or model-dependent. Here, we analyse the energy budget of a sample of 54 well-observed stripped-envelope supernovae of all sub-types, and present statistically significant, largely model-independent, observational evidence for a non-radioactive power source in most of them (and possibly in all). We consider various energy sources, or alternatively, plausible systematic errors, that could drive this result, and conclude that the most likely option is the existence of a ``central engine'', such as a magnetar (a highly magnetic neutron star) or an accreting neutron star or black hole, operating over hours to days after the explosion. We infer from the observations constraints on the engines, finding that if these are magnetars, then their initial magnetic fields are about $10^{15}\,$G and their initial rotation period is 1--100 ms, implying that stripped-envelope supernovae could be the formative events of magnetars. △ Less

Submitted 16 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

The Structure and Evolution of Relativistic Jetted Blast Waves

Authors: Taya Govreen-Segal, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: We study, analytically and numerically, the structure and evolution of relativistic jetted blast waves that propagate in uniform media, such as those that generate afterglows of gamma-ray bursts. Similar to previous studies, we find that the evolution can be divided into two parts: (i) a pre-spreading phase, in which the jet core angle is roughly constant, $θ_{c,0}$, and the shock Lorentz factor a… ▽ More We study, analytically and numerically, the structure and evolution of relativistic jetted blast waves that propagate in uniform media, such as those that generate afterglows of gamma-ray bursts. Similar to previous studies, we find that the evolution can be divided into two parts: (i) a pre-spreading phase, in which the jet core angle is roughly constant, $θ_{c,0}$, and the shock Lorentz factor along the axis, $Γ_a$, evolves as a part of the Blandford-Mckee solution, and (ii) a spreading phase, in which $Γ_a$ drops exponentially with the radius and the core angle, $θ_c$, grows rapidly. Nevertheless, the jet remains collimated during the relativistic phase, where $θ_c(Γ_aβ_a=1)\simeq 0.4θ_{c,0}^{1/3}$. The transition between the phases takes place when $Γ_a\simeq 0.2θ_{c,0}^{-1}$. We find that the "wings" of jets with initial "narrow" structure ($\frac{d \log\,E_{iso}}{d\log\,θ}<-3$ outside of the core, where $E_{iso}$ is isotropic equivalent energy), start evolving during the pre-spreading phase. By the spreading phase these jets evolve to a self-similar profile, which is independent of the initial structure, where in the wings $Γ(θ)\proptoθ^{-1.5}$ and $E_{iso}(θ)\propto θ^{-2.6}$. Jets with initial "wide" structure roughly keep their initial profile during their entire evolution. We provide analytic description of the jet lateral profile evolution for a range of initial structures, as well as the evolution of $Γ_a$ and $θ_c$. For off-axis GRBs, we present a relation between the initial jet structure and the light curve rising phase. Applying our model to GW170817, we find that initially the jet had $θ_{c,0}=0.4-4.5~°$ and wings which are consistent with $E_{iso} \propto θ^{-3}-θ^{-4}$. △ Less

Submitted 15 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Constraints on the accretion properties of quasi-periodic erupters from GRMHD simulations

Authors: Anna Chashkina, Omer Bromberg, Amir Levinson, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: Context: Some apparently quiescent supermassive black holes (BHs) at centers of galaxies show quasi-periodic eruptions (QPEs) in the X-ray band, the nature of which is still unknown. A possible origin for the eruptions is an accretion disk, however the properties of such disks are restricted by the timescales of reccurance and durations of the flares. Aims: In this work we test the possibility tha… ▽ More Context: Some apparently quiescent supermassive black holes (BHs) at centers of galaxies show quasi-periodic eruptions (QPEs) in the X-ray band, the nature of which is still unknown. A possible origin for the eruptions is an accretion disk, however the properties of such disks are restricted by the timescales of reccurance and durations of the flares. Aims: In this work we test the possibility that the known QPEs can be explained by accretion from a compact accretion disk with an outer radius $r_{\rm out}\sim 10-40 r_{\rm g}$, focusing on a particular object GSN 069. Methods: We run several 3D GRMHD simulations with the {\tt HARMPI} code of thin and thick disks and study how the initial disk parameters such as thickness, magnetic field configuration, magnetization and Kerr parameter affect the observational properties of QPEs. Results: We show that accretion onto a slowly rotating BH through a small, thick accretion disk with an initially low plasma $β$ can explain the observed flare duration, the time between outbursts and the lack of evidence for a variable jet emission. In order to form such a disk the accreting matter should have a low net angular momentum. A potential source for such low angular momentum matter with a quasi periodic feeding mechanism might be a tight binary of wind launching stars. △ Less

Submitted 6 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Comments: Submitted to Astronomy and Astrophysics

Relativistic Spherical Shocks in Expanding Media

Authors: Taya Govreen-Segal, Noam Youngerman, Ishika Palit, Ehud Nakar, Amir Levinson, Omer Bromberg

Abstract: We investigate the propagation of spherically symmetric shocks in relativistic homologously expanding media with density distributions following a power-law profile in their Lorentz factor. That is, $ρ_{ej} \propto t^{-3}γ_{e}(R,t)^{-α}$, where $ρ_{ej}$ is the medium proper density, $γ_{e}$ is its Lorentz factor, $α>0$ is constant and $t$, $R$ are the time and radius from the center. We find that… ▽ More We investigate the propagation of spherically symmetric shocks in relativistic homologously expanding media with density distributions following a power-law profile in their Lorentz factor. That is, $ρ_{ej} \propto t^{-3}γ_{e}(R,t)^{-α}$, where $ρ_{ej}$ is the medium proper density, $γ_{e}$ is its Lorentz factor, $α>0$ is constant and $t$, $R$ are the time and radius from the center. We find that the shocks behavior can be characterized by their proper velocity, $U'=Γ_s'β_s'$, where $Γ_s'$ is the shock Lorentz factor as measured in the immediate upstream frame and $β_s'$ is the corresponding 3-velocity. While generally, we do not expect the shock evolution to be self-similar, for every $α>0$ we find a critical value $U'_c$ for which a self-similar solution with constant $U'$ exists. We then use numerical simulations to investigate the behavior of general shocks. We find that shocks with $U'>U'_c$ have a monotonously growing $U'$, while those with $U'<U'_c$ have a decreasing $U'$ and will eventually die out. Finally, we present an analytic approximation, based on our numerical results, for the evolution of general shocks in the regime where $U'$ is ultra-relativistic. △ Less

Submitted 15 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Rapidly Evolving Transients in Archival ZTF Public Alerts

Authors: Wenxiong Li, Iair Arcavi, Ehud Nakar, Alexei V. Filippenko, Thomas G. Brink, WeiKang Zheng, Marco C. Lam, Ido Keinan, Seán J. Brennan, Noi Shitrit

Abstract: We search the archival Zwicky Transient Facility public survey for rapidly evolving transient (RET) candidates based on well-defined criteria between 2018 May and 2021 December. The search yielded 19 bona-fide RET candidates, corresponding to a discovery rate of $\sim 5.2$ events per year. Even with a Galactic latitude cut of $20^\circ$, 8 of the 19 events ($\sim 42$%) are Galactic, including one… ▽ More We search the archival Zwicky Transient Facility public survey for rapidly evolving transient (RET) candidates based on well-defined criteria between 2018 May and 2021 December. The search yielded 19 bona-fide RET candidates, corresponding to a discovery rate of $\sim 5.2$ events per year. Even with a Galactic latitude cut of $20^\circ$, 8 of the 19 events ($\sim 42$%) are Galactic, including one with a light-curve shape closely resembling that of the GW170817 kilonova (KN). An additional event is a nova in M31. Four out of the 19 events ($\sim 21$%) are confirmed extragalactic RETs (one confirmed here for the first time) and the origin of 6 additional events cannot be determined. We did not find any extragalactic events resembling the GW170817 KN, from which we obtain an upper limit on the volumetric rate of GW170817-like KNe of $R \le$ 2400 Gpc$^{-3}$ yr$^{-1}$ (95% confidence). These results can be used for quantifying contaminants to RET searches in transient alert streams, specifically when searching for kilonovae independently of gravitational-wave and gamma-ray-burst triggers. △ Less

Submitted 22 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: 16 pages, 7 figures, submitted to AAS Journals

Fission and fusion of heavy nuclei induced by the passage of a radiation-mediated shock in BNS mergers

Authors: Alon Granot, Amir Levinson, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: We compute the structure of a Newtonian, multi-ion radiation-mediated shock (RMS) for different compositions anticipated in various stellar explosions. We use a multifluid RMS model that incorporates electrostatic coupling between the different plasma constituents as well as Coulomb friction in a self-consistent manner, and approximates the effect of pair creation and the presence of free neutrons… ▽ More We compute the structure of a Newtonian, multi-ion radiation-mediated shock (RMS) for different compositions anticipated in various stellar explosions. We use a multifluid RMS model that incorporates electrostatic coupling between the different plasma constituents as well as Coulomb friction in a self-consistent manner, and approximates the effect of pair creation and the presence of free neutrons in the shock upstream on the shock structure. We find that under certain conditions a significant velocity separation is developed between different ions in the shock downstream and demonstrate that in fast enough shocks ion-ion collisions may trigger fusion and fission events at a relatively high rate. Our analysis ignores anomalous coupling through plasma microturbulence, that might reduce the velocity spread downstream below the activation energy for nuclear reactions. A rough estimate of the scale separation in RMS suggests that for shocks propagating in BNS merger ejecta the anomalous coupling length may exceed the radiation length, allowing a considerable composition change behind the shock via inelastic collisions of $α$ particles with heavy elements at shock velocities $β_u\gtrsim0.25$. A sufficient abundance of free neutrons in the shock upstream, as expected during the first second after the merger, is also expected to alter the ejecta composition through neutron capture downstream. The resultant change in the composition profile may affect the properties of the early kilonova emission. The generation of microturbulence due to velocity separation can also give rise to particle acceleration that might alter the breakout signal in supernovae and other systems. △ Less

Submitted 27 April, 2024; v1 submitted 15 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Analytic Model for Off-Axis GRB Afterglow Images -- Geometry Measurement and Implications for Measuring $H_0$

Authors: Taya Govreen-Segal, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: We present an analytic model for measuring the jet core angle ($θ_c$) and viewing angle ($θ_{obs}$) of off-axis gamma-ray bursts independently of the jet angular structure outside of the core. We model the images of off-axis jets and using this model we show that $θ_{obs}$ and $θ_c$ can be measured using any two of the three following observables: the afterglow light curve, the flux-centroid motio… ▽ More We present an analytic model for measuring the jet core angle ($θ_c$) and viewing angle ($θ_{obs}$) of off-axis gamma-ray bursts independently of the jet angular structure outside of the core. We model the images of off-axis jets and using this model we show that $θ_{obs}$ and $θ_c$ can be measured using any two of the three following observables: the afterglow light curve, the flux-centroid motion, and the image width. The model is calibrated using 2D relativistic hydrodynamic simulations with a broad range of jet angular structures. We study the systematic errors due to the uncertainty in the jet structure and find that when using the light curve and centroid motion to determine $θ_{obs}$ and $θ_c$, our formulae can be accurate to a level of $5-10\%$ and $30\%$, respectively. In light of the Hubble tension, the systematic error in $\cosθ_{obs}$ in GRBs originating in a binary compact object merger is of special interest. We find that the systematic uncertainty on the measurement of $\cosθ_{obs}$ due to the unknown jet structure is smaller than $1.5\%$ for well-observed events. A similar error is expected if the microphysical parameters evolve at a level that is not easily detected by the light curve. Our result implies that this type of systematic uncertainty will not prevent measurement of $H_0$ to a level of $2\%$ with a sample of well-observed GW events with resolved afterglow image motion. Applying our model to the light curve and centroid motion observations of GW170817 we find $θ_{obs}=19.2\pm 2~°$ (1$σ$) and $θ_c=1.5-4~°$. △ Less

Submitted 28 May, 2023; v1 submitted 20 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS. To match the published version, minor changes have been made to the text

Spherical symmetry in the kilonova AT2017gfo/GW170817

Authors: Albert Sneppen, Darach Watson, Andreas Bauswein, Oliver Just, Rubina Kotak, Ehud Nakar, Dovi Poznanski, Stuart Sim

Abstract: The mergers of neutron stars expel a heavy-element enriched fireball which can be observed as a kilonova. The kilonova's geometry is a key diagnostic of the merger and is dictated by the properties of ultra-dense matter and the energetics of the collapse to a black hole. Current hydrodynamical merger models typically show aspherical ejecta. Previously, Sr$^+$ was identified in the spectrum of the… ▽ More The mergers of neutron stars expel a heavy-element enriched fireball which can be observed as a kilonova. The kilonova's geometry is a key diagnostic of the merger and is dictated by the properties of ultra-dense matter and the energetics of the collapse to a black hole. Current hydrodynamical merger models typically show aspherical ejecta. Previously, Sr$^+$ was identified in the spectrum of the the only well-studied kilonova AT2017gfo, associated with the gravitational wave event GW170817. Here we combine the strong Sr$^+$ P Cygni absorption-emission spectral feature and the blackbody nature of kilonova spectrum, to determine that the kilonova is highly spherical at early epochs. Line shape analysis combined with the known inclination angle of the source also shows the same sphericity independently. We conclude that energy injection by radioactive decay is insufficient to make the ejecta spherical. A magnetar wind or jet from the black hole disk could inject enough energy to induce a more spherical distribution in the overall ejecta, however an additional process seems necessary to make the element distribution uniform △ Less

Submitted 13 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Journal ref: Nature, Febuary 16th 2023: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-05616-x

Magnetically driven coupling in relativistic radiation-mediated shocks

Authors: J. F. Mahlmann, A. Vanthieghem, A. A. Philippov, A. Levinson, E. Nakar, F. Fiuza

Abstract: The radiation drag in photon-rich environments of cosmic explosions can seed kinetic instabilities by inducing velocity spreads between relativistically streaming plasma components. Such microturbulence is likely imprinted on the breakout signals of radiation-mediated shocks. However, large-scale, transverse magnetic fields in the deceleration region of the shock transition can suppress the domina… ▽ More The radiation drag in photon-rich environments of cosmic explosions can seed kinetic instabilities by inducing velocity spreads between relativistically streaming plasma components. Such microturbulence is likely imprinted on the breakout signals of radiation-mediated shocks. However, large-scale, transverse magnetic fields in the deceleration region of the shock transition can suppress the dominant kinetic instabilities by preventing the development of velocity separations between electron-positron pairs and a heavy ion species. We use a one-dimensional (1D) five-fluid radiative transfer code to generate self-consistent profiles of the radiation drag force and plasma composition in the deceleration region. For increasing magnetization, our models predict rapidly growing pair multiplicities and a substantial radiative drag develo** self-similarly throughout the deceleration region. We extract the critical magnetization parameter $σ_{c}$, determining the limiting magnetic field strength at which a three-species plasma can develop kinetic instabilities before reaching the isotropized downstream. For a relativistic, single ion plasma drifting with $γ_{u} = 10$ in the upstream of a relativistic radiation-mediated shock, we find the threshold $σ_{c}\approx 10^{-7}$ for the onset of microturbulence. Suppression of plasma instabilities in the case of multi-ion composition would likely require much higher values of $σ_{c}$. Identifying high-energy signatures of microturbulence in shock-breakout signals and combining them with the magnetization limits provided in this work will allow a deeper understanding of the magnetic environment of cosmic explosions like supernovae, gamma-ray bursts, and neutron star binary mergers. △ Less

Submitted 24 January, 2023; v1 submitted 14 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 12 pages, 11 figures, Accepted for publication by MNRAS

The Iron Yield of Core-collapse Supernovae

Authors: Ósmar Rodríguez, Dan Maoz, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: We present a systematic analysis of 191 stripped-envelope supernovae (SE SNe), aimed to compute their $^{56}$Ni masses from the luminosity in their radioactive tails ($M_\mathrm{Ni}^\mathrm{tail}$) and/or in their maximum light, and the mean $^{56}$Ni and iron yields of SE SNe and core-collapse SNe. Our sample consists of SNe IIb, Ib, and Ic from the literature and from the Zwicky Transient Facili… ▽ More We present a systematic analysis of 191 stripped-envelope supernovae (SE SNe), aimed to compute their $^{56}$Ni masses from the luminosity in their radioactive tails ($M_\mathrm{Ni}^\mathrm{tail}$) and/or in their maximum light, and the mean $^{56}$Ni and iron yields of SE SNe and core-collapse SNe. Our sample consists of SNe IIb, Ib, and Ic from the literature and from the Zwicky Transient Facility Bright Transient Survey. To calculate luminosities from optical photometry, we compute bolometric corrections using 49 SE SNe with optical and near-IR photometry, and develop corrections to account for the unobserved UV and IR flux. We find that the equation of Khatami & Kasen for radioactive $^{56}$Ni-powered transients with a single free parameter does not fit the observed peak time-luminosity relation of SE SNe. Instead, we find a correlation between $M_\mathrm{Ni}^\mathrm{tail}$, peak time, peak luminosity, and decline rate, which allows measuring individual $^{56}$Ni masses to a precision of 14%. Applying this method to the whole sample, we find, for SNe IIb, Ib, and Ic, mean $^{56}$Ni masses of $0.066\pm0.006$, $0.082\pm0.009$, and $0.132\pm0.011\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}$, respectively. After accounting for their relative rates, for SE SNe as a whole we compute mean $^{56}$Ni and iron yields of $0.090\pm0.005$ and $0.097\pm0.007\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}$, respectively. Combining these results with the recent Type II SN mean $^{56}$Ni mass derived by Rodríguez et al., core-collapse SNe, as a whole, have mean $^{56}$Ni and iron yields of $0.055\pm0.006$ and $0.058\pm0.007\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}$, respectively. We also find that radioactive $^{56}$Ni-powered models typically underestimate the peak luminosity of SE SNe by 60-70%, suggesting the presence of an additional power source contributing to the luminosity at peak. △ Less

Submitted 21 June, 2023; v1 submitted 12 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: 59 pages, 42 figures. Submitted to AAS

The velocity distribution of outflows driven by choked jets in stellar envelopes

Authors: Matteo Pais, Tsvi Piran, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: Many stripped envelope supernovae (SNe) present a signature of high-velocity material responsible for broad absorption lines in the observed spectrum. These include SNe that are associated with long gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs) and low-luminosity GRBs (llGRBs), and SNe that are not associated with GRBs. Recently it was suggested that this high velocity material originates from a cocoon that is driven… ▽ More Many stripped envelope supernovae (SNe) present a signature of high-velocity material responsible for broad absorption lines in the observed spectrum. These include SNe that are associated with long gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs) and low-luminosity GRBs (llGRBs), and SNe that are not associated with GRBs. Recently it was suggested that this high velocity material originates from a cocoon that is driven by a relativistic jet. In LGRBs this jet breaks out successfully from the stellar envelope, while in llGRBs and SNe that are not associated with GRBs the jet is choked. Here we use numerical simulations to explore the velocity distribution of an outflow that is driven by a choked jet and its dependence on the jet and progenitor properties. We find that in all cases where the jet is not choked too deep within the star, the outflow carries a roughly constant amount of energy per logarithmic scale of proper velocity over a wide range of velocities, which depends mostly on the cocoon volume at the time of its breakout. This is a universal property of jets driven outflows, which does not exist in outflows of spherically symmetric explosions or when the jets are choked very deep within the star. We therefore conclude that jets that are choked (not too deep) provide a natural explanation to the fast material seen in the early spectra of stripped envelope SNe that are not associated with LGRBs and that properties of this material could reveal information on the otherwise hidden jets. △ Less

Submitted 8 December, 2022; v1 submitted 30 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Comments: 14 pages, 15 figures, accepted for publication on MNRAS

ACM Class: J.2

Observational signatures of stellar explosions driven by relativistic jets

Authors: Moshe Eisenberg, Ore Gottlieb, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: The role of relativistic jets in unbinding the stellar envelope during a supernova (SN) associated with a gamma-ray burst (GRB) is unclear. To study that, we explore observational signatures of stellar explosions that are driven by jets. We focus on the final velocity distribution of the outflow in such explosions and compare its observational imprints to SN/GRB data. We find that jet driven explo… ▽ More The role of relativistic jets in unbinding the stellar envelope during a supernova (SN) associated with a gamma-ray burst (GRB) is unclear. To study that, we explore observational signatures of stellar explosions that are driven by jets. We focus on the final velocity distribution of the outflow in such explosions and compare its observational imprints to SN/GRB data. We find that jet driven explosions produce an outflow with a flat distribution of energy per logarithmic scale of proper velocity. The flat distribution seems to be universal as it is independent of the jet and the progenitor properties that we explored. The velocity range of the flat distribution for typical GRB parameters is $γβ\approx 0.03-3$, where $γ$ is the outflow Lorentz factor and $β$ is its dimensionless velocity. A flat distribution is seen also for collimated choked jets where the highest outflow velocity decreases with the depth at which the jet is choked. Comparison to observations of SN/GRBs rules out jets as the sole explosion source in these events. Instead, in SN/GRB the collapsing star must deposit its energy into two channels - a quasi-spherical (or wide angle) channel and a narrowly collimated one. The former carries most of the energy and is responsible for the SN sub-relativistic ejecta while the latter carries 0.01-0.1 of the total outflow energy and is the source of the GRB. Intriguingly, the same two channels, with a similar energy ratio, were seen in the binary neutron star merger GW170817, suggesting that similar engines are at work in both phenomena. △ Less

Submitted 20 January, 2022; originally announced January 2022.

The role of plasma instabilities in relativistic radiation mediated shocks: stability analysis and particle-in-cell simulations

Authors: Arno Vanthieghem, Jens F. Mahlmann, Amir Levinson, Alexander A. Philippov, Ehud Nakar, Frederico Fiuza

Abstract: Relativistic radiation mediated shocks (RRMS) likely form in prodigious cosmic explosions. The structure and emission of such shocks is regulated by copious production of electron-positron pairs inside the shock transition layer. It has been pointed out recently that substantial abundance of positrons inside the shock leads to a velocity separation of the different plasma constituents, which is ex… ▽ More Relativistic radiation mediated shocks (RRMS) likely form in prodigious cosmic explosions. The structure and emission of such shocks is regulated by copious production of electron-positron pairs inside the shock transition layer. It has been pointed out recently that substantial abundance of positrons inside the shock leads to a velocity separation of the different plasma constituents, which is expected to induce a rapid growth of plasma instabilities. In this paper, we study the hierarchy of plasma microinstabilities growing in an electron-ion plasma loaded with pairs and subject to a radiation force. Linear stability analysis indicates that such a system is unstable to the growth of various plasma modes which ultimately become dominated by a current filamentation instability driven by the relative drift between the ions and the pairs. These results are validated by particle-in-cell simulations that further probe the nonlinear regime of the instabilities, and the pair-ion coupling in the microturbulent electromagnetic field. Based on this analysis, we derive a reduced transport equation for the particles via pitch angle scattering in the microturbulence and demonstrate that it can couple the different species and lead to nonadiabatic compression via a Joule-like heating. The heating of the pairs and, conceivably, the formation of nonthermal distributions, arising from the microturbulence, can affect the observed shock breakout signal in ways unaccounted for by current single-fluid models. △ Less

Submitted 14 January, 2022; originally announced January 2022.

Comments: 12 pages, 9 figures

Bolometric light curves of aspherical shock breakout

Authors: Christopher Irwin, Itai Linial, Ehud Nakar, Tsvi Piran, Re'em Sari

Abstract: The shock breakout emission is the first light that emerges from a supernova. In the spherical case it is characterized by a brief UV flash. In an axisymmetric, non-spherical prolate explosion, the shock first breaches the surface along the symmetry axis, then peels around to larger angles, producing a breakout light curve which may differ substantially from the spherically symmetric case. We stud… ▽ More The shock breakout emission is the first light that emerges from a supernova. In the spherical case it is characterized by a brief UV flash. In an axisymmetric, non-spherical prolate explosion, the shock first breaches the surface along the symmetry axis, then peels around to larger angles, producing a breakout light curve which may differ substantially from the spherically symmetric case. We study the emergence of a non-relativistic, bipolar shock from a spherical star, and estimate the basic properties of the associated bolometric shock breakout signal. We identify four possible classes of breakout light curves, depending on the degree of asphericity. Compared to spherical breakouts, we find that the main distinguishing features of significantly aspherical breakouts are 1) a longer and fainter initial breakout flash and 2) an extended phase of slowly-declining, or even rising, emission which is produced as ejecta flung out by the oblique breakout expand and cool. We find that the breakout flash has a maximum duration of roughly $\sim R_*/v_{\rm bo}$ where $R_*$ is the stellar radius and $v_{\rm bo}$ is the velocity of the fastest-moving ejecta. For a standard Wolf--Rayet progenitor, the duration of the X-ray flash seen in SN 2008D exceeds this limit, and the same holds true for the prompt X-ray emission of low-luminosity GRBs such as GRB 060218. This suggests that these events cannot be explained by an aspherical explosion within a typical Wolf--Rayet star, implying that they originate from non-standard progenitors with larger breakout radii. △ Less

Submitted 27 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: 21 pages, 9 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

A transient radio source consistent with a merger-triggered core collapse supernova

Authors: Dillon Z. Dong, Gregg Hallinan, Ehud Nakar, Anna Y. Q. Ho, Andrew K. Hughes, Kenta Hotokezaka, Steve T. Myers, Kishalay De, Kunal Mooley, Vikram Ravi, Assaf Horesh, Mansi M. Kasliwal, Shri R. Kulkarni

Abstract: A core-collapse supernova occurs when exothermic fusion ceases in the core of a massive star, typically due to exhaustion of nuclear fuel. Theory predicts that fusion could be interrupted earlier, by merging of the star with a compact binary companion. We report a luminous radio transient, VT J121001+495647, found in the Very Large Array Sky Survey. The radio emission is consistent with supernova… ▽ More A core-collapse supernova occurs when exothermic fusion ceases in the core of a massive star, typically due to exhaustion of nuclear fuel. Theory predicts that fusion could be interrupted earlier, by merging of the star with a compact binary companion. We report a luminous radio transient, VT J121001+495647, found in the Very Large Array Sky Survey. The radio emission is consistent with supernova ejecta colliding with a dense shell of material, potentially ejected by binary interaction in the centuries prior to explosion. We associate the supernova with an archival X-ray transient, which implies a relativistic jet was launched during the explosion. The combination of an early relativistic jet and late-time dense interaction is consistent with expectations for a merger-driven explosion. △ Less

Submitted 22 September, 2021; v1 submitted 3 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: 33 pages, 4 figures. v2: Updated fig 1 to include panel D

Journal ref: Science 373, 1125-1129 (2021)

The propagation of relativistic jets in expanding media

Authors: Ore Gottlieb, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: We present a comprehensive analytic model of relativistic jet propagation in expanding homologous media (ejecta). This model covers the entire jet evolution as well as a range of configurations that are relevant to binary neutron star mergers. These include low and high luminosity jets, unmagnetized and mildly magnetized jets, time-dependent luminosity jets, and Newtonian and relativistic head vel… ▽ More We present a comprehensive analytic model of relativistic jet propagation in expanding homologous media (ejecta). This model covers the entire jet evolution as well as a range of configurations that are relevant to binary neutron star mergers. These include low and high luminosity jets, unmagnetized and mildly magnetized jets, time-dependent luminosity jets, and Newtonian and relativistic head velocities. We also extend the existing solution of jets in a static medium to power-law density media with index $α<5$. Our model provides simple analytic formulae (calibrated by 3D simulations) for the jet head propagation and breakout times. We find that the system evolution has two main regimes: strong and weak jets. Strong jets start their propagation immediately within the ejecta. Weak jets are unable to penetrate the ejecta at first, and breach it only after the ejecta expands significantly, thus their evolution is independent of the delay between the onset of the ejecta and the jet launching. After enough time, both strong and weak jets approach a common asymptotic phase. We find that a necessary, but insufficient, criterion for the breakout of unmagnetized [weakly magnetized] jets is $E_{j,{\rm iso,tot}} \gtrsim 3[0.4]E_{ej,{\rm tot}}\left({θ_j}/{0.1{\rm~rad}}\right)^2$, where $E_{j,{\rm iso,tot}}$ is the jet total isotropic equivalent energy, $θ_j$ is its opening angle, and $E_{ej,{\rm tot}}$ is the ejecta energy. Applying our model to short GRBs, we find that there is most likely a large diversity of ejecta mass, where mass $ \lesssim 10^{-3}~{\rm M}_{\odot} $ (at least along the poles) is common. △ Less

Submitted 17 October, 2022; v1 submitted 7 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Intermittent mildly magnetized jets as the source of GRBs

Authors: Ore Gottlieb, Omer Bromberg, Amir Levinson, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) are powered by relativistic jets that exhibit intermittency over a broad range of timescales - from $ \sim $ ms to seconds. Previous numerical studies have shown that hydrodynamic (i.e., unmagnetized) jets that are expelled from a variable engine are subject to strong mixing of jet and cocoon material, which strongly inhibits the GRB emission. In this paper we conduct 3D RM… ▽ More Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) are powered by relativistic jets that exhibit intermittency over a broad range of timescales - from $ \sim $ ms to seconds. Previous numerical studies have shown that hydrodynamic (i.e., unmagnetized) jets that are expelled from a variable engine are subject to strong mixing of jet and cocoon material, which strongly inhibits the GRB emission. In this paper we conduct 3D RMHD simulations of mildly magnetized jets with power modulation over durations of 0.1 s and 1 s, and a steady magnetic field at injection. We find that when the jet magnetization at the launching site is $σ\sim 0.1$, the initial magnetization is amplified by shocks formed in the flow to the point where it strongly suppresses baryon loading. We estimate that a significant contamination can be avoided if the magnetic energy at injection constitutes at least a few percent of the jet energy. The variability timescales of the jet after it breaks out of the star are then governed by the injection cycles rather than by the mixing process, suggesting that in practice jet injection should fluctuate on timescales as short as $ \sim 10 $ ms in order to account for the observed light curves. Better stability is found for jets with shorter modulations. We conclude that for sufficiently hot jets, the Lorentz factor near the photosphere can be high enough to allow efficient photospheric emission. Our results imply that jets with $ 10^{-2} < σ< 1 $ injected by a variable engine with $ \sim 10 $ ms duty cycle are plausible sources of long GRBs. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2021; v1 submitted 29 January, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Spherical shocks in a steep density gradient of expanding media

Authors: Taya Govreen-Segal, Ehud Nakar, Amir Levinson

Abstract: We study the propagation of a Newtonian shock in a spherically symmetric, homologously expanding ejecta. We focus on media with a steep power-law density profile of the form $ρ\propto t^{-3}v^{-α}$, with $α>5$, where $v$ is the velocity of the expanding medium and $t$ is time. Such profiles are expected in the leading edge of supernovae ejecta and sub-relativistic outflows from binary neutron star… ▽ More We study the propagation of a Newtonian shock in a spherically symmetric, homologously expanding ejecta. We focus on media with a steep power-law density profile of the form $ρ\propto t^{-3}v^{-α}$, with $α>5$, where $v$ is the velocity of the expanding medium and $t$ is time. Such profiles are expected in the leading edge of supernovae ejecta and sub-relativistic outflows from binary neutron star mergers. We find that such shocks always accelerate in the observer frame and lose causal contact with the bulk of the driver gas, owing to the steep density profile. However, the prolonged shock evolution exhibits two distinct pathways: In one, the shock strength diminishes with time until the shock eventually dies out. In the other, the shock strength steadily increases, and the solution approaches the self-similar solution of a shock is a static medium. By map** the parameter space of shock solutions, we find that the evolutionary pathways are dictated by $α$ and by the initial ratio between the shock velocity and the local upstream velocity. We find that for $α<ω_c$ ($ω_c \approx 8$), the shock always decays, and that for $α>ω_c$ the shock may decay or grow stronger depending on the initial value of the velocity ratio. These two branches bifurcate from a self-similar solution derived analytically for a constant velocity ratio. We analyze properties of the solutions that may have an impact on the observational signatures of such systems, and assess the conditions required for decaying shocks to break out from a finite medium. △ Less

Submitted 9 December, 2020; v1 submitted 20 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

The structure of weakly-magnetized $ γ$-ray burst jets

Authors: Ore Gottlieb, Omer Bromberg, Chandra B. Singh, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: The interaction of gamma-ray burst (GRB) jets with the dense media into which they are launched promote the growth of local hydrodynamic instabilities along the jet boundary. In a companion paper we study the evolution of hydrodynamic (unmagnetized) jets, finding that mixing of jet-cocoon material gives rise to an interface layer, termed jet-cocoon interface (JCI), which contains a significant fra… ▽ More The interaction of gamma-ray burst (GRB) jets with the dense media into which they are launched promote the growth of local hydrodynamic instabilities along the jet boundary. In a companion paper we study the evolution of hydrodynamic (unmagnetized) jets, finding that mixing of jet-cocoon material gives rise to an interface layer, termed jet-cocoon interface (JCI), which contains a significant fraction of the system energy. We find that the angular structure of the jet + JCI, when they reach the homologous phase, can be approximated by a flat core (the jet) + a power-law function (the JCI) with indices that depend on the degree of mixing. In this paper we examine the effect of subdominant toroidal magnetic fields on the jet evolution and morphology. We find that weak fields can stabilize the jet against local instabilities. The suppression of the mixing diminishes the JCI and thus reshapes the jet's post-breakout structure. Nevertheless, the overall shape of the outflow can still be approximated by a flat core + a power-law function, although the JCI power-law decay is steeper. The effect of weak fields is more prominent in long GRB jets, where the mixing in hydrodynamic jets is stronger. In short GRB jets there is small mixing in both weakly magnetized and unmagnetized jets. This result influences the expected jet emission which is governed by the jet's morphology. Therefore, prompt and afterglow observations in long GRBs may be used as probes for the magnetic nature at the base of the jets. △ Less

Submitted 19 August, 2020; v1 submitted 22 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

Monte-Carlo simulations of fast Newtonian and mildly relativistic shock breakout from a stellar wind

Authors: Hirotaka Ito, Amir Levinson, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: Strong explosion of a compact star surrounded by a thick stellar wind drives a fast ($>0.1c$) radiation mediated shock (RMS) that propagates in the wind, and ultimately breaks out gradually once photons start esca** from the shock transition layer. In exceptionally strong or aspherical explosions the shock velocity may even be relativistic. The properties of the breakout signal depend on the dyn… ▽ More Strong explosion of a compact star surrounded by a thick stellar wind drives a fast ($>0.1c$) radiation mediated shock (RMS) that propagates in the wind, and ultimately breaks out gradually once photons start esca** from the shock transition layer. In exceptionally strong or aspherical explosions the shock velocity may even be relativistic. The properties of the breakout signal depend on the dynamics and structure of the shock during the breakout phase. Here we present, for the first time, spectra and lightcurves of the breakout emission of fast Newtonian and mildly relativistic shocks, that were calculated using self-consistent Monte-Carlo simulations of finite RMS with radiative losses. We find a strong dependence of the $νF_ν$ peak on shock velocity, ranging from $\sim 1$ keV for $v_s/c=0.1$ to $\sim 100$ keV for $v_s/c=0.5$, with a shift to lower energies as losses increase. For all cases studied the spectrum below the peak exhibits a nearly flat component ($F_ν\sim ν^0$) that extends down to the break frequency below which absorption becomes important. This implies much bright optical/UV emission than hitherto expected. The computed lightcurves show a gradual rise over tens to hundreds of seconds for representative conditions. The application to SN 2008D/XRT 080109 and the detectability limits are also discussed. We predict a detection rate of about one per year with eROSITA. △ Less

Submitted 25 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 11 pages, 11 figures, submitted to MNRAS

Report number: RIKEN-iTHEMS-Report-20

The structure of hydrodynamic $ γ$-ray burst jets

Authors: Ore Gottlieb, Ehud Nakar, Omer Bromberg

Abstract: After being launched, GRB jets propagate through dense media prior to their breakout. The jet-medium interaction results in the formation of a complex structured outflow, often referred to as a "structured jet". The underlying physics of the jet-medium interaction that sets the post-breakout jet morphology has never been explored systematically. Here we use a suite of 3D simulations to follow the… ▽ More After being launched, GRB jets propagate through dense media prior to their breakout. The jet-medium interaction results in the formation of a complex structured outflow, often referred to as a "structured jet". The underlying physics of the jet-medium interaction that sets the post-breakout jet morphology has never been explored systematically. Here we use a suite of 3D simulations to follow the evolution of hydrodynamic long and short gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) jets after breakout to study the post-breakout structure induced by the interaction. Our simulations feature Rayleigh-Taylor fingers that grow from the cocoon into the jet, mix cocoon with jet material and destabilize the jet. The mixing gives rise to a previously unidentified region sheathing the jet from the cocoon, which we denote the jet-cocoon interface (JCI). long GRBs undergo strong mixing, resulting in most of the jet energy to drift into the JCI, while in short GRBs weaker mixing is possible, leading to a comparable amount of energy in the two components. Remarkably, the jet structure (jet-core plus JCI) can be characterized by simple universal angular power-law distributions, with power-law indices that depend solely on the mixing level. This result supports the commonly used power-law angular distribution, and disfavors Gaussian jets. At larger angles, where the cocoon dominates, the structure is more complex. The mixing shapes the prompt emission light curve and implies that typical long GRB afterglows are different from those of short GRBs. Our predictions can be used to infer jet characteristics from prompt and afterglow observations. △ Less

Submitted 1 November, 2020; v1 submitted 3 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

The Panchromatic Afterglow of GW170817: The full uniform dataset, modeling, comparison with previous results and implications

Authors: Sphesihle Makhathini, Kunal P. Mooley, Murray Brightman, Kenta Hotokezaka, AJ Nayana, Huib T. Intema, Dougal Dobie, E. Lenc, Daniel A. Perley, Christoffer Fremling, Javier Moldon, Davide Lazzati, David L. Kaplan, Arvind Balasubramanian, Ian Brown, Dario Carbone, Poonam Chandra, Alessandra Corsi, Fernando Camilo, Adam T. Deller, Dale A. Frail, Tara Murphy, Eric J. Murphy, Ehud Nakar, Oleg Smirnov , et al. (13 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We present the full panchromatic afterglow light curve data of GW170817, including new radio data as well as archival optical and X-ray data, between 0.5 and 940 days post-merger. By compiling all archival data, and reprocessing a subset of it, we have evaluated the impact of differences in data processing or flux determination methods used by different groups, and attempted to mitigate these diff… ▽ More We present the full panchromatic afterglow light curve data of GW170817, including new radio data as well as archival optical and X-ray data, between 0.5 and 940 days post-merger. By compiling all archival data, and reprocessing a subset of it, we have evaluated the impact of differences in data processing or flux determination methods used by different groups, and attempted to mitigate these differences to provide a more uniform dataset. Simple power-law fits to the uniform afterglow light curve indicate a $t^{0.86\pm0.04}$ rise, a $t^{-1.92\pm0.12}$ decline, and a peak occurring at $155\pm4$ days. The afterglow is optically thin throughout its evolution, consistent with a single spectral index ($-0.584\pm0.002$) across all epochs. This gives a precise and updated estimate of the electron power-law index, $p=2.168\pm0.004$. By studying the diffuse X-ray emission from the host galaxy, we place a conservative upper limit on the hot ionized ISM density, $<$0.01 cm$^{-3}$, consistent with previous afterglow studies. Using the late-time afterglow data we rule out any long-lived neutron star remnant having magnetic field strength between 10$^{10.4}$ G and 10$^{16}$ G. Our fits to the afterglow data using an analytical model that includes VLBI proper motion from Mooley et al. (2018), and a structured jet model that ignores the proper motion, indicates that the proper motion measurement needs to be considered while seeking an accurate estimate of the viewing angle. △ Less

Submitted 4 October, 2021; v1 submitted 3 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: Accepted by ApJ. Revised X-ray and up-to-date afterglow measurements are available in ASCII format on GitHub (https://github.com/kmooley/GW170817/) and mirrored on tauceti.caltech.edu (http://www.tauceti.caltech.edu/kunal/gw170817/). The online dataset will be continuously updated as new measurements become available

Afterglow constraints on the viewing angle of binary neutron star mergers and determination of the Hubble constant

Authors: Ehud Nakar, Tsvi Piran

Abstract: One of the key properties of any binary is its viewing angle (i.e., inclination), $θ_{\rm obs}$. In binary neutron star (BNS) mergers it is of special importance due to the role that it plays in the measurement of the Hubble constant, $H_0$. The opening angle of the jet that these mergers launch, $θ_j$, is also of special interest. Following the detection of the first BNS merger, GW170817, there w… ▽ More One of the key properties of any binary is its viewing angle (i.e., inclination), $θ_{\rm obs}$. In binary neutron star (BNS) mergers it is of special importance due to the role that it plays in the measurement of the Hubble constant, $H_0$. The opening angle of the jet that these mergers launch, $θ_j$, is also of special interest. Following the detection of the first BNS merger, GW170817, there were numerous attempts to estimate these angles using the afterglow light curve, finding a wide range of values. Here we provide a simple formula for the ratio $θ_{\rm obs}/θ_j$ based on the afterglow light curve and show that this is the only quantity that can be determined from the light curve alone. Namely, it is impossible to determine each of the angles separately without additional information. Our result explains the inconsistency of the values found by the various studies of GW170817 that were largely driven by the different priors taken in each study. Among the additional information that can be used to estimate $θ_{\rm obs}$ and $θ_j$, the most useful is a VLBI measurement of the afterglow image superluminal motion. An alternative is an identification of the afterglow transition to the sub-relativistic phase. These observations are possible only for mergers observed at small viewing angles, whose afterglow is significantly brighter than the detector's threshold. We discuss the implications of these results to measurements of $H_0$ using GW observations. We show that while the viewing angle will be measured only in a small fraction of future BNS mergers, it can significantly reduce the uncertainty in $H_0$ in each one of these events, possibly to a level of 4-5\%. A minority of the mergers with high precision measurements of this kind may dominate in the future the precision in which $H_0$ will be measured using this method. △ Less

Submitted 12 January, 2021; v1 submitted 4 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: Accepted for publication in ApJ

Shock breakouts from red supergiants: analytical and numerical predictions

Authors: Alexandra Kozyreva, Ehud Nakar, Roni Waldman, Sergei Blinnikov, Petr Baklanov

Abstract: Shock breakout (SBO) signal is the first signature of the supernova explosion apart from gravitational waves and neutrinos. Observational properties of SBO, such as bolometric luminosity and colour temperature, connect to the supernova progenitor and explosion parameters. Detecting SBO or SBO-cooling will constrain the progenitor and explosion models of collapsing stars. In the light of recently l… ▽ More Shock breakout (SBO) signal is the first signature of the supernova explosion apart from gravitational waves and neutrinos. Observational properties of SBO, such as bolometric luminosity and colour temperature, connect to the supernova progenitor and explosion parameters. Detecting SBO or SBO-cooling will constrain the progenitor and explosion models of collapsing stars. In the light of recently launched eROSITA telescope, the rate for detection of SBO is a few events during a year. In the current study, we examine the analytic formulae derived by Shussman et al. (2016). We use four red supergiant models from their study, while running explosions with the radiation hydrodynamics code STELLA. We conclude that there is a good agreement between analytic and numerical approaches for bolometric luminosity and colour temperature during SBO. The analytic formulae for the SBO signal based on the global supernova parameters can be used instead of running time-consuming numerical simulations. We define spectral range where analytic formulae for the SBO spectra are valid. We provide improved analytical expression for the SBO spectral energy distribution. We confirm dependence of colour temperature on radius derived by analytical studies and suggest to use early time observations to confine the progenitor radius. Additionally we show the prediction for the SBO signal from red supergiants as seen by eROSITA instrument. △ Less

Submitted 31 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Comments: 12 figures, 2 tables. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

Intermittent hydrodynamic jets in collapsars do not produce GRBs

Authors: Ore Gottlieb, Amir Levinson, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: Strong variability is a common characteristic of the prompt emission of gamma-ray bursts (GRB). This observed variability is widely attributed to an intermittency of the central engine, through formation of strong internal shocks in the GRB-emitting jet expelled by the engine. In this paper we study numerically the propagation of hydrodynamic jets, injected periodically by a variable engine, throu… ▽ More Strong variability is a common characteristic of the prompt emission of gamma-ray bursts (GRB). This observed variability is widely attributed to an intermittency of the central engine, through formation of strong internal shocks in the GRB-emitting jet expelled by the engine. In this paper we study numerically the propagation of hydrodynamic jets, injected periodically by a variable engine, through the envelope of a collapsed star. By post-processing the output of 3D numerical simulations, we compute the net radiative efficiency of the outflow. We find that all intermittent jets are subject to heavy baryon contamination that inhibits the emission at and above the photosphere well below detection limits. This is in contrast to continuous jets that, as shown recently, produce a highly variable gamma-ray photospheric emission with high efficiency, owing to the interaction of the jet with the stellar envelope. Our results challenge the variable engine model for hydrodynamic jets, and may impose constraints on the duty cycle of GRB engines. If such systems exist in nature, they are not expected to produce bright gamma-ray emission, but should appear as X-ray, optical and radio transients that resemble a delayed GRB afterglow signal. △ Less

Submitted 15 April, 2021; v1 submitted 27 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

The electromagnetic counterparts of compact binary mergers

Authors: Ehud Nakar

Abstract: Mergers of binaries consisting of two neutron stars, or a black hole and a neutron star, offer a unique opportunity to study a range of physical and astrophysical processes using two different and almost orthogonal probes - gravitational waves (GW) and electromagnetic (EM) emission. The GW signal probes the binary and the physical processes that take place during the last stages of the merger, whi… ▽ More Mergers of binaries consisting of two neutron stars, or a black hole and a neutron star, offer a unique opportunity to study a range of physical and astrophysical processes using two different and almost orthogonal probes - gravitational waves (GW) and electromagnetic (EM) emission. The GW signal probes the binary and the physical processes that take place during the last stages of the merger, while the EM emission provides clues to the material that is thrown out following the merger. The accurate localization, which only the EM emission can provide, also indicates the astrophysical setting in which the merger took place. In addition, the combination of the two signals provides constraints on the nature of gravity and on the expansion rate of the Universe. The first detection of a binary neutron star merger by the LIGO-Virgo collaboration, GW170817, initiated the era of multi-messenger GW-EM astrophysics and demonstrated the great promise it holds. The event produced an unprecedented data set, and although it was only a single event, it provided remarkable results that revolutionized our knowledge of neutron star mergers. GW170817 is especially exciting since we know that it is not one of a kind and that many more events will be detected during the next decade. In this review, I summarize, first, the theory of EM emission from compact binary mergers, highlighting the unique information that the combined GW-EM detection provides. I then describe the entire set of GW and EM observations of GW170817, and summarize the range of insights that it offers. This includes clues about the role that similar events play in the r-process elements budget of the Universe, the neutron star equation of state, the properties of the relativistic outflow that followed the merger, and the connection between neutron star binary mergers and short gamma-ray bursts. △ Less

Submitted 11 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: A review, submitted to Physics Reports

GROWTH on S190814bv: Deep Synoptic Limits on the Optical/Near-Infrared Counterpart to a Neutron Star-Black Hole Merger

Authors: Igor Andreoni, Daniel A. Goldstein, Mansi M. Kasliwal, Peter E. Nugent, Rongpu Zhou, Jeffrey A. Newman, Mattia Bulla, Francois Foucart, Kenta Hotokezaka, Ehud Nakar, Samaya Nissanke, Geert Raaijmakers, Joshua S. Bloom, Kishalay De, Jacob E. Jencson, Charlotte Ward, Tomás Ahumada, Shreya Anand, David A. H. Buckley, Maria D. Caballero-García, Alberto J. Castro-Tirado, Christopher M. Copperwheat, Michael W. Coughlin, S. Bradley Cenko, Mariusz Gromadzki , et al. (27 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: On 2019 August 14, the Advanced LIGO and Virgo interferometers detected the high-significance gravitational wave (GW) signal S190814bv. The GW data indicated that the event resulted from a neutron star--black hole (NSBH) merger, or potentially a low-mass binary black hole merger. Due to the low false alarm rate and the precise localization (23 deg$^2$ at 90\%), S190814bv presented the community wi… ▽ More On 2019 August 14, the Advanced LIGO and Virgo interferometers detected the high-significance gravitational wave (GW) signal S190814bv. The GW data indicated that the event resulted from a neutron star--black hole (NSBH) merger, or potentially a low-mass binary black hole merger. Due to the low false alarm rate and the precise localization (23 deg$^2$ at 90\%), S190814bv presented the community with the best opportunity yet to directly observe an optical/near-infrared counterpart to a NSBH merger. To search for potential counterparts, the GROWTH collaboration performed real-time image subtraction on 6 nights of public Dark Energy Camera (DECam) images acquired in the three weeks following the merger, covering $>$98\% of the localization probability. Using a worldwide network of follow-up facilities, we systematically undertook spectroscopy and imaging of optical counterpart candidates. Combining these data with a photometric redshift catalog, we ruled out each candidate as the counterpart to S190814bv and we placed deep, uniform limits on the optical emission associated with S190814bv. For the nearest consistent GW distance, radiative transfer simulations of NSBH mergers constrain the ejecta mass of S190814bv to be $M_\mathrm{ej} < 0.04$~$M_{\odot}$ at polar viewing angles, or $M_\mathrm{ej} < 0.03$~$M_{\odot}$ if the opacity is $κ< 2$~cm$^2$g$^{-1}$. Assuming a tidal deformability for the neutron star at the high end of the range compatible with GW170817 results, our limits would constrain the BH spin component aligned with the orbital momentum to be $ χ< 0.7$ for mass ratios $Q < 6$, with weaker constraints for more compact neutron stars. We publicly release the photometry from this campaign at http://www.astro.caltech.edu/~danny/static/s190814bv. △ Less

Submitted 31 December, 2019; v1 submitted 29 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: Accepted to ApJ with no major changes

Physics of radiation mediated shocks and its applications to GRBs, supernovae, and neutron star mergers

Authors: Amir Levinson, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: The first electromagnetic signal observed in different types of cosmic explosions is released upon emergence of a shock created in the explosion from the opaque envelope enshrouding the central source. Notable examples are the early emission from various types of supernovae and low luminosity GRBs, the prompt photospheric emission in long GRBs, and the gamma-ray emission that accompanied the gravi… ▽ More The first electromagnetic signal observed in different types of cosmic explosions is released upon emergence of a shock created in the explosion from the opaque envelope enshrouding the central source. Notable examples are the early emission from various types of supernovae and low luminosity GRBs, the prompt photospheric emission in long GRBs, and the gamma-ray emission that accompanied the gravitational wave signal in neutron star mergers. In all of these examples, the shock driven by the explosion is mediated by the radiation trapped inside it, and its velocity and structure, that depend on environmental conditions, dictate the characteristics of the observed electromagnetic emission at early times, and potentially also their neutrino emission. Much efforts have been devoted in recent years to develop a detailed theory of radiation mediated shocks in an attempt to predict the properties of the early emission in the aforementioned systems. These efforts are timely in view of the anticipated detection rate of shock breakout candidates by upcoming transient factories, and the potential detection of a gamma-ray flash from shock breakout in neutron star mergers like GW170817. This review aims at providing a comprehensive overview of the theory and applications of radiation mediated shocks, starting from basic principles. The classification of shock solutions, which are governed by the conditions prevailing in each class of objects, and the methods used to solve the shock equations in different regimes will be described, with particular emphasis on the observational diagnostics. The applications to supernovae, low-luminosity GRBs, long GRBs, neutron star mergers, and neutrino emission will be highlighted. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2020; v1 submitted 23 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: Invited review, Physics Reports

Radioactive heating rate of r-process elements and macronova light curve

Authors: Kenta Hotokezaka, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: We study the heating rate of r-process nuclei and thermalization of decay products in neutron star merger ejecta and macronova (kilonova) light curves. Thermalization of charged decay products, i.e., electrons, $α$-particles, and fission fragments is calculated according to their injection energy. The $γ$-ray thermalization processes are also properly calculated by taking the $γ$-ray spectrum of e… ▽ More We study the heating rate of r-process nuclei and thermalization of decay products in neutron star merger ejecta and macronova (kilonova) light curves. Thermalization of charged decay products, i.e., electrons, $α$-particles, and fission fragments is calculated according to their injection energy. The $γ$-ray thermalization processes are also properly calculated by taking the $γ$-ray spectrum of each decay into account. We show that the $β$-decay heating rate at later times approaches a power-law decline as $\propto t^{-2.8}$, which agrees with the result of Waxman et al. (2019). We present a new analytic model to calculate macronova light curves, in which the density structure of the ejecta is accounted for. We demonstrate that the observed bolometric light curve and temperature evolution of the macronova associated with GW170817 are reproduced well by the $β$-decay heating rate with the solar r-process abundance pattern. We interpret the break in the observed bolometric light curve around a week as a result of the diffusion wave crossing a significant part of the ejecta rather than a thermalization break. We also show that the time-weighted integral of the bolometric light curve (Katz integral) is useful to provide an estimate of the total r-process mass from the observed data, which is independent of the highly uncertain radiative transfer. For the macronova in GW170817, the ejecta mass is robustly estimated as $\approx 0.05M_{\odot}$ for $A_{\rm min}\leq 72$ and $85\leq A_{\rm min}\leq 130$ with the solar r-process abundance pattern. The code for computation of the heating rate and light curve for given initial nuclear abundances is publicly available. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: 16 pages, 11 figures, code available at https://github.com/hotokezaka/HeatingRate

Jet-driven bubbles in Fanaroff-Riley type I sources

Authors: Christopher M. Irwin, ** Tang, Tsvi Piran, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: Observations of several Fanaroff-Riley (FR) type I sources reveal outflowing bipolar bubbles of hot gas surrounded by a weak forward shock. We consider the possibility that these bubbles were driven by choked relativistic jets which failed to penetrate the ambient intracluster medium (ICM). Using new results on choked jets linking the geometry of the forward shock to the jet properties, we infer r… ▽ More Observations of several Fanaroff-Riley (FR) type I sources reveal outflowing bipolar bubbles of hot gas surrounded by a weak forward shock. We consider the possibility that these bubbles were driven by choked relativistic jets which failed to penetrate the ambient intracluster medium (ICM). Using new results on choked jets linking the geometry of the forward shock to the jet properties, we infer robust limits on the radius $R_{ch}$ at which the jet was quenched in 5 well-studied FRI sources, finding typically $R_{ch}\sim 10$ kpc. We further show that, in order to reach this radius in less than the current age of the system, the jet must have been tightly collimated, with the jet head subtending an angle of $θ_h < 2^\circ$. The ambient pressure is not high enough to explain this collimation, suggesting that the jet was collimated by interaction with its own cocoon. Although the choking radius is well-constrained, we find a degeneracy between the initial jet opening angle before collimation, $θ_0$, and the duration of jet activity, $t_b$, with $(t_b/1\rm{Myr})(θ_0/5^\circ)^{-2} \sim 0.1$. We speculate that the working time and/or opening angle of the jet may be important factors contributing to the FR type I/type II morphology in galaxy clusters, with short-lived or wide jets being choked to form bipolar bubbles filled with diffuse radio emission, and longer-lived or narrow jets successfully esca** the cluster core to produce cocoons with radio hotspots. △ Less

Submitted 18 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: 12 pages, 6 figures, submitted to MNRAS

The propagation of choked jet outflows in power-law external media

Authors: Christopher M. Irwin, Ehud Nakar, Tsvi Piran

Abstract: Observations of both gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) and active galactic nuclei (AGNs) point to the idea that some relativistic jets are suffocated by their environment before we observe them. In these "choked" jets, all the jet's kinetic energy is transferred into a hot and narrow cocoon of near-uniform pressure. We consider the evolution of an elongated, axisymmetric cocoon formed by a choked jet as it… ▽ More Observations of both gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) and active galactic nuclei (AGNs) point to the idea that some relativistic jets are suffocated by their environment before we observe them. In these "choked" jets, all the jet's kinetic energy is transferred into a hot and narrow cocoon of near-uniform pressure. We consider the evolution of an elongated, axisymmetric cocoon formed by a choked jet as it expands into a cold power-law ambient medium $ρ\propto R^{-α}$, in the case where the shock is decelerating ($α<3$). The evolution proceeds in three stages, with two breaks in behaviour: the first occurs once the outflow has doubled its initial width, and the second once it has doubled its initial height. Using the Kompaneets approximation, we derive analytical formulae for the shape of the cocoon shock, and obtain approximate expressions for the height and width of the outflow versus time in each of the three dynamical regimes. The asymptotic behaviour is different for flat ($α\le 2$) and steep ($2 < α< 3$) density profiles. Comparing the analytical model to numerical simulations, we find agreement to within $\sim15$ per cent out to 45 degrees from the axis, but discrepancies of a factor of 2-3 near the equator. The shape of the cocoon shock can be measured directly in AGNs, and is also expected to affect the early light from failed GRB jets. Observational constraints on the shock geometry provide a useful diagnostic of the jet properties, even long after jet activity ceases. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: 30 pages, 19 figures, submitted to MNRAS

Recombination Effects on Supernova Light Curves

Authors: Tamar Faran, Tomer Goldfriend, Ehud Nakar, Re'em Sari

Abstract: The light curves of type-II supernovae (SNe) are believed to be highly affected by recombination of hydrogen that takes place in their envelopes. In this work, we analytically investigate the transition from a fully ionized envelope to a partially recombined one and its effects on the SN light curve. The motivation is to establish the underlying processes that dominate the evolution at late times… ▽ More The light curves of type-II supernovae (SNe) are believed to be highly affected by recombination of hydrogen that takes place in their envelopes. In this work, we analytically investigate the transition from a fully ionized envelope to a partially recombined one and its effects on the SN light curve. The motivation is to establish the underlying processes that dominate the evolution at late times when recombination takes place in the envelope, yet early enough so that $^{56}$Ni decay is a negligible source of energy. We consider the diffusion of photons through the envelope while analyzing the ionization fraction and the coupling between radiation and gas, and find that the main effect of recombination is on the evolution of the observed temperature. Before recombination the temperature decreases relatively fast, while after recombination starts it significantly reduces the rate at which the observed temperature drops with time. This behaviour is the main cause for the observed flattening in the optical bands, where for a typical red supergiant explosion, the recombination wave affects the bolometric luminosity only mildly during most of the photospheric phase. Moreover, the plateau phase observed in some type-II SNe is not a generic result of recombination, and it also depends on the density structure of the progenitor. This is one possible explanation to the different light curve decay rates observed in type II (P and L) SNe. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: Submitted to ApJ, after first referee report. This is a major revision of arXiv:1404.6313

High efficiency photospheric emission entailed by formation of a collimation shock in gamma-ray bursts

Authors: Ore Gottlieb, Amir Levinson, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: The primary dissipation mechanism in jets of gamma-ray bursts (GRBs), and the high efficiency of the prompt emission are long standing issues. One possibility is strong collimation of a weakly magnetized relativistic jet by the surrounding medium, which can considerably enhance the efficiency of the photospheric emission. We derive a simple analytic criterion for the radiative efficiency of a coll… ▽ More The primary dissipation mechanism in jets of gamma-ray bursts (GRBs), and the high efficiency of the prompt emission are long standing issues. One possibility is strong collimation of a weakly magnetized relativistic jet by the surrounding medium, which can considerably enhance the efficiency of the photospheric emission. We derive a simple analytic criterion for the radiative efficiency of a collimated jet showing that it depends most strongly on the baryon loading. We confirm this analytic result by 3D numerical simulations, and further find that mixing of jet and cocoon material at the collimation throat leads to a substantial stratification of the outflow as well as sporadic loading, even if the injected jet is uniform and continuous. One consequence of this mixing is a strong angular dependence of the radiative efficiency. Another is large differences in the Lorentz factor of different fluid elements that lead to formation of internal shocks. Our analysis indicates that in both long and short GRBs a prominent photospheric component cannot be avoided when observed within an angle of a few degrees to the axis, unless the asymptotic Lorentz factor is limited by baryon loading at the jet base to $Γ_\infty <100$ (with a weak dependence on outflow power). Photon generation by newly created pairs behind the collimation shock regulates the observed temperature at $\sim 50~θ_0^{-1}$ keV, where $θ_0$ is the initial jet opening angle, in remarkable agreement with the observed peak energies of prompt emission spectra. Further consequences for the properties of the prompt emission are discussed at the end. △ Less

Submitted 28 June, 2019; v1 submitted 15 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Detectability of neutron star merger afterglows

Authors: Ore Gottlieb, Ehud Nakar, Tsvi Piran

Abstract: VLBI and JVLA observations revealed that GW170817 involved a narrow jet ($ θ_j \approx 4^\circ $) that dominated the afterglow peak at our viewing angle, $ θ_{\rm obs} \approx 20^\circ $. This implies that at the time of the afterglow peak, the observed signal behaved like an afterglow of a top-hat jet seen at $ θ_{\rm obs} \gg θ_j $, and it can be modeled by analytic expressions that describe suc… ▽ More VLBI and JVLA observations revealed that GW170817 involved a narrow jet ($ θ_j \approx 4^\circ $) that dominated the afterglow peak at our viewing angle, $ θ_{\rm obs} \approx 20^\circ $. This implies that at the time of the afterglow peak, the observed signal behaved like an afterglow of a top-hat jet seen at $ θ_{\rm obs} \gg θ_j $, and it can be modeled by analytic expressions that describe such jets. We use a set of numerical simulations to calibrate these analytic relations and obtain generic equations for the peak time and flux of such an afterglow as seen from various observing angles. Using the calibrated equations and the estimated parameters of GW170817, we estimate the detectability of afterglows from future double neutron star mergers during the Advanced LIGO/Virgo observation run O3. GW170817 took place at a relatively low-density environment. Afterglows of similar events will be detectable only at small viewing angles, $ θ_{\rm obs} \lesssim 20^\circ $, and only $\sim 20\% $ of the GW detections of these events will be accompanied by a detectable afterglow. At higher densities, more typical to sGRB sites, up to $ 70\% $ of the GW detections are expected to be followed by a detectable afterglow, typically at $ θ_{\rm obs} \sim 30^\circ $. We also provide the latest time one should expect an afterglow detection. We find that for typical parameters, if the jet emission had not been detected within about a year after the merger, it is unlikely to be ever detected. △ Less

Submitted 9 July, 2019; v1 submitted 19 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Generalized compactness limit from an arbitrary viewing angle

Authors: Tatsuya Matsumoto, Ehud Nakar, Tsvi Piran

Abstract: A $γ$-ray source must have a limited optical depth to pair production. This simple condition, called compactness, implies that gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) must involve a highly relativistic motion ($Γ\gtrsim 100$) giving the first and most important clue on their nature. So far, this condition has been discussed under the assumption that the $γ$-ray sources are viewed on-axis, that is, by an observer… ▽ More A $γ$-ray source must have a limited optical depth to pair production. This simple condition, called compactness, implies that gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) must involve a highly relativistic motion ($Γ\gtrsim 100$) giving the first and most important clue on their nature. So far, this condition has been discussed under the assumption that the $γ$-ray sources are viewed on-axis, that is, by an observer within the beaming cone of the relativistic source. Recently, following the detection of the weak short GRB 170817A, an extensive interest arose in the possibility that some $γ$-ray sources are viewed off-axis. We generalize here the compactness formalism for an arbitrary viewing angle taking several possible opacity processes and $γ$-ray spectra into account. We find that for a given observables (peak luminosity, temporal variability, and spectra) the minimal Lorentz factor, $Γ_{\rm min}$, is obtained, as expected, for an on-axis observer. More remarkably we find that compactness dictates also a maximal viewing angle, $θ_{\rm max} \simeq 1/2Γ_{\rm min}$. Our limit implies for regular GRBs a very small allowed viewing angle ($\lesssim10^{-2}\,\rm rad$), making it extremely unlikely that they are viewed off-axis. For GRB 170817A we confirm earlier results that rule out the possibility that the observed $γ$-rays were seen by an on-axis observer as a regular short GRB. The short GRB 150101B was also suggested to be an off-axis event. We show that its maximal viewing angle $\lesssim0.05\,\rm rad$, which is inconsistent with the off-axis model. Finally we show that for low luminosity GRBs, compactness does not exclude by itself an off-axis model, but when combined with other consideration this option is strongly disfavored. △ Less

Submitted 7 January, 2020; v1 submitted 15 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Comments: 12 pages, 6 figures, 3 tables, accepted for publication in MNRAS

Catching Element Formation In The Act

Authors: Chris L. Fryer, Frank Timmes, Aimee L. Hungerford, Aaron Couture, Fred Adams, Wako Aoki, Almudena Arcones, David Arnett, Katie Auchettl, Melina Avila, Carles Badenes, Eddie Baron, Andreas Bauswein, John Beacom, Jeff Blackmon, Stephane Blondin, Peter Bloser, Steve Boggs, Alan Boss, Terri Brandt, Eduardo Bravo, Ed Brown, Peter Brown, Steve Bruenn. Carl Budtz-Jorgensen, Eric Burns , et al. (194 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: Gamma-ray astronomy explores the most energetic photons in nature to address some of the most pressing puzzles in contemporary astrophysics. It encompasses a wide range of objects and phenomena: stars, supernovae, novae, neutron stars, stellar-mass black holes, nucleosynthesis, the interstellar medium, cosmic rays and relativistic-particle acceleration, and the evolution of galaxies. MeV gamma-ray… ▽ More Gamma-ray astronomy explores the most energetic photons in nature to address some of the most pressing puzzles in contemporary astrophysics. It encompasses a wide range of objects and phenomena: stars, supernovae, novae, neutron stars, stellar-mass black holes, nucleosynthesis, the interstellar medium, cosmic rays and relativistic-particle acceleration, and the evolution of galaxies. MeV gamma-rays provide a unique probe of nuclear processes in astronomy, directly measuring radioactive decay, nuclear de-excitation, and positron annihilation. The substantial information carried by gamma-ray photons allows us to see deeper into these objects, the bulk of the power is often emitted at gamma-ray energies, and radioactivity provides a natural physical clock that adds unique information. New science will be driven by time-domain population studies at gamma-ray energies. This science is enabled by next-generation gamma-ray instruments with one to two orders of magnitude better sensitivity, larger sky coverage, and faster cadence than all previous gamma-ray instruments. This transformative capability permits: (a) the accurate identification of the gamma-ray emitting objects and correlations with observations taken at other wavelengths and with other messengers; (b) construction of new gamma-ray maps of the Milky Way and other nearby galaxies where extended regions are distinguished from point sources; and (c) considerable serendipitous science of scarce events -- nearby neutron star mergers, for example. Advances in technology push the performance of new gamma-ray instruments to address a wide set of astrophysical questions. △ Less

Submitted 7 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: 14 pages including 3 figures

Report number: LA-UR-18-29748

The role of radioactive nickel in sha** the plateau phase of Type II supernovae

Authors: Alexandra Kozyreva, Ehud Nakar, Roni Waldman

Abstract: In the present study, we systematically explore the effect of the radioactive 56Ni and its mixing properties in the ejecta on the plateau of Type IIP supernovae (SNe). We evaluate the importance of 56Ni in sha** light curves of SNe IIP by simulating light curves for two red supergiant models using different amounts of 56Ni and with different types of mixing: uniform distribution of 56Ni out to d… ▽ More In the present study, we systematically explore the effect of the radioactive 56Ni and its mixing properties in the ejecta on the plateau of Type IIP supernovae (SNe). We evaluate the importance of 56Ni in sha** light curves of SNe IIP by simulating light curves for two red supergiant models using different amounts of 56Ni and with different types of mixing: uniform distribution of 56Ni out to different fractions of the envelope and "boxcar" distribution of 56Ni. We find, similarly to previous studies, that 56Ni extends duration of the plateau. We find a formula to estimate the extension based on the observed bolometric light curves and show that for most SNe IIP 56Ni extends the plateau by about 20%. Another effect of 56Ni consists in reduction of the plateau decline rate, i.e. 56Ni presented in the ejecta flattens the plateau. Our simulations suggest that for typical SNe IIP it can reduce the decline rate by about 1 mag/100 day. We find that for the contribution of 56Ni seen in most SNe our simulated bolometric light curves resemble observed ones for various types of 56Ni mixing. We thereby cannot determine the level of 56Ni mixing in these SNe based on the light curve alone. However, for SN2009ib we find that only a model where 56Ni is mixed significantly throughout most of the hydrogen envelope is consistent with the observed light curve. Our light curves are available via link https://wwwmpa.mpa-garching.mpg.de/ccsnarchive/data/Kozyreva2018/. △ Less

Submitted 21 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: 13 pages, 22 figures. Accepted for publication in MNRAS. Light curves available via https://wwwmpa.mpa-garching.mpg.de/ccsnarchive/data/Kozyreva2018/

Numerical simulations of AGN wind feedback on black hole accretion: probing down to scales within the sphere of influence

Authors: Meir Zeilig Hess, Amir Levinson, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: Several processes may limit the accretion rate onto a super-massive black hole (SMBH). Two processes that are commonly considered (e.g., for sub-grid prescriptions) are Bondi-Hoyle-Lyttleton accretion and the Eddington limit. A third one is AGN wind feedback. It has been long suggested that such a wind feedback regulates the final SMBH mass, however, it has been shown recently that AGN winds can a… ▽ More Several processes may limit the accretion rate onto a super-massive black hole (SMBH). Two processes that are commonly considered (e.g., for sub-grid prescriptions) are Bondi-Hoyle-Lyttleton accretion and the Eddington limit. A third one is AGN wind feedback. It has been long suggested that such a wind feedback regulates the final SMBH mass, however, it has been shown recently that AGN winds can also regulate the average accretion rate at a level consistent with observations of high redshift AGNs. In this paper we study the effect of wind feedback on the accretion rate using 2D, high resolution hydrodynamic simulations, that incorporate a self-consistent wind injection scheme and resolves the SMBH sphere of influence. Two different cases are explored and compared: one in which the initial gas density is uniform, and one in which it has an isothermal sphere profile. We also compare simulations with and without cooling. Our main finding is that for reasonable parameters, AGN feedback always limits the accretion rate to be far below the Bondi-Hoyle-Lyttleton limit. For typical wind parameters and a uniform ISM densities of the order $1 {cm}^{-3}$, the accretion rate is found to be several orders of magnitudes smaller than that inferred in large samples of high redshift AGNs. On the other hand, the accretion rate obtained for initially isothermal density profile is found to be consistent with the observations, particularly when cooling is included. Furthermore, it roughly scales as $σ^{5}$ with the velocity dispersion of the bulge, in accord with the $M-σ$ relation. △ Less

Submitted 6 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: 13 pages, 13 figures

A Strong Jet Signature in the Late-Time Lightcurve of GW170817

Authors: K. P. Mooley, D. A. Frail, D. Dobie, E. Lenc, A. Corsi, K. De, A. J. Nayana, S. Makhathini, I. Heywood, T. Murphy, D. L. Kaplan, P. Chandra, O. Smirnov, E. Nakar, G. Hallinan, F. Camilo, R. Fender, S. Goedhart, P. Groot, M. M. Kasliwal, S. R. Kulkarni, P. A. Woudt

Abstract: We present new 0.6-10 GHz observations of the binary neutron star merger GW170817 covering the period up to 300 days post-merger, taken with the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array, the Australia Telescope Compact Array, the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope and the MeerKAT telescope. We use these data to precisely characterize the decay phase of the late-time radio light curve. We find that the tempora… ▽ More We present new 0.6-10 GHz observations of the binary neutron star merger GW170817 covering the period up to 300 days post-merger, taken with the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array, the Australia Telescope Compact Array, the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope and the MeerKAT telescope. We use these data to precisely characterize the decay phase of the late-time radio light curve. We find that the temporal decay is consistent with a power-law slope of t^-2.2, and that the transition between the power-law rise and decay is relatively sharp. Such a slope cannot be produced by a quasi-isotropic (cocoon-dominated) outflow, but is instead the classic signature of a relativistic jet. This provides strong observational evidence that GW170817 produced a successful jet, and directly demonstrates the link between binary neutron star mergers and short-hard GRBs. Using simple analytical arguments, we derive constraints on the geometry and the jet opening angle of GW170817. These results are consistent with those from our companion Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) paper, reporting superluminal motion in GW170817. △ Less

Submitted 30 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 11 pages, 3 figures, 3 tables. Accepted for publication in ApJ Letters

The Spectrum of a Fast Shock Breakout from a Stellar Wind

Authors: Kunihito Ioka, Amir Levinson, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: The breakout of a fast ($>0.1 c$), yet sub-relativistic shock from a thick stellar wind is expected to produce a pulse of X-rays with a rise time of seconds to hours. Here, we construct a semi-analytic model for the breakout of a sub-relativistic, radiation-mediated shock from a thick stellar wind, and use it to compute the spectrum of the breakout emission. The model incorporates photon escape th… ▽ More The breakout of a fast ($>0.1 c$), yet sub-relativistic shock from a thick stellar wind is expected to produce a pulse of X-rays with a rise time of seconds to hours. Here, we construct a semi-analytic model for the breakout of a sub-relativistic, radiation-mediated shock from a thick stellar wind, and use it to compute the spectrum of the breakout emission. The model incorporates photon escape through the finite optical depth wind, assuming a diffusion approximation and a quasi-steady evolution of the shock structure during the breakout phase. We find that in sufficiently fast shocks, for which the breakout velocity exceeds about $0.1c$, the time-integrated spectrum of the breakout pulse is non-thermal, and the time-resolved temperature is expected to exhibit substantial decrease (roughly by one order of magnitude) during breakout, when the flux is still rising, because of the photon generation by the shock compression associated with the photon escape. We also derive a closure relation between the breakout duration, peak luminosity, and characteristic temperature that can be used to test whether an observed X-ray flare is consistent with being associated with a sub-relativistic shock breakout from a thick stellar wind or not. We also discuss implications of the spectral softening for a possible breakout event XRT 080109/SN 2008D. △ Less

Submitted 4 February, 2019; v1 submitted 25 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 8 pages, 8 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

Observational constraints on the structure of gamma-ray burst jets

Authors: Paz Beniamini, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: Motivated by GW170817 we examine constraints that observations put on the angular structure of long gamma-ray burst (GRB) jets. First, the relatively narrow observed distribution of $E_{X}/E_γ$ (the isotropic equivalent early X-ray afterglow to prompt $γ$-ray energy ratio) implies that at any angle that $γ$-rays are emitted the Lorentz factor must be high. Specifically, the Lorentz factor of $γ$-r… ▽ More Motivated by GW170817 we examine constraints that observations put on the angular structure of long gamma-ray burst (GRB) jets. First, the relatively narrow observed distribution of $E_{X}/E_γ$ (the isotropic equivalent early X-ray afterglow to prompt $γ$-ray energy ratio) implies that at any angle that $γ$-rays are emitted the Lorentz factor must be high. Specifically, the Lorentz factor of $γ$-ray emitting material cannot drop rapidly with angle, and must be $Γ(θ)\gtrsim 50$ even if there are angles for which the gamma-ray received energy is lower by three orders of magnitude compared to the jet core. Second, jets with an angular structure of the $γ$-ray emission that over-produce events with a $γ$-ray luminosity below the peak of the observed luminosity function are ruled-out. This eliminates models in which the $γ$-ray energy angular distribution isn't sufficiently steep and the Lorentz factor distribution isn't sufficiently shallow. Finally, models with a steep structure (e.g. Gaussian) which are detected away from the jet core generate afterglow light-curves that were never observed. We conclude that even if the jet kinetic energy distribution drops continuously with latitude, efficient $γ$-ray emission seems to be restricted to material with $Γ\gtrsim 50$ and is most likely confined to a narrow region around the core. While our study is confined to long GRBs, where the observed sample is larger and more complete, there are indications that similar conclusions may be applicable also to short GRBs. We discuss the possible implications to the $γ$-rays observed in GRB 170817A. △ Less

Submitted 10 December, 2018; v1 submitted 22 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Comments: 11 pages, 11 figures. Published in MNRAS

Supernova PTF12glz: a possible shock breakout driven through an aspherical wind

Authors: Maayane T. Soumagnac, Eran O. Ofek, Avishay Gal-Yam, Eli Waxmann, Sivan Ginzburg, Nora Linn Strotjohann, Tom A. Barlow, Ehud Behar, Doron Chelouche, Christoffer Fremling, Noam Ganot, Suvi Gerazi, Mansi M. Kasliwal, Shai Kaspi, Shrinivas R. Kulkarni, Russ R. Laher, Dan Maoz, Christopher D. Martin, Ehud Nakar, James D. Neill, Peter E. Nugent, Dovi Poznanski, Steve Schulze, Ofer Yaron

Abstract: We present visible-light and ultraviolet (UV) observations of the supernova PTF12glz. The SN was discovered and monitored in near-UV and R bands as part of a joint GALEX and Palomar Transient Factory campaign. It is among the most energetic Type IIn supernovae observed to date (~10^{51} erg). If the radiated energy mainly came from the thermalization of the shock kinetic energy, we show that PTF12… ▽ More We present visible-light and ultraviolet (UV) observations of the supernova PTF12glz. The SN was discovered and monitored in near-UV and R bands as part of a joint GALEX and Palomar Transient Factory campaign. It is among the most energetic Type IIn supernovae observed to date (~10^{51} erg). If the radiated energy mainly came from the thermalization of the shock kinetic energy, we show that PTF12glz was surrounded by ~1 solar mass of circumstellar material (CSM) prior to its explosive death. PTF12glz shows a puzzling peculiarity: at early times, while the freely expanding ejecta are presumably masked by the optically thick CSM, the radius of the blackbody that best fits the observations grows at ~7000 km/s. Such a velocity is characteristic of fast moving ejecta rather than optically thick CSM. This phase of radial expansion takes place before any spectroscopic signature of expanding ejecta appears in the spectrum and while both the spectroscopic data and the bolometric luminosity seem to indicate that the CSM is optically thick. We propose a geometrical solution to this puzzle, involving an aspherical structure of the CSM around PTF12glz. By modelling radiative diffusion through a slab of CSM, we show that an aspherical geometry of the CSM can result in a growing effective radius. This simple model also allows us to recover the decreasing blackbody temperature of PTF12glz. SLAB-Diffusion, the code we wrote to model the radiative diffusion of photons through a slab of CSM and evaluate the observed radius and temperature, is made available on-line. △ Less

Submitted 7 November, 2020; v1 submitted 8 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Comments: Accepted by ApJ

Constraints on the emitting region of the gamma-rays observed in GW170817

Authors: Tatsuya Matsumoto, Ehud Nakar, Tsvi Piran

Abstract: The gravitational waves from the neutron star merger event GW170817 were accompanied by an unusually weak short GRB 170817A, by an optical/IR macronova/kilonova and by a long lasting radio to X-rays counterpart. While association of short GRBs with mergers was predicted a long time ago, the luminosity of this prompt γ-ray emission was weaker by a few orders of magnitude than all known previous sGR… ▽ More The gravitational waves from the neutron star merger event GW170817 were accompanied by an unusually weak short GRB 170817A, by an optical/IR macronova/kilonova and by a long lasting radio to X-rays counterpart. While association of short GRBs with mergers was predicted a long time ago, the luminosity of this prompt γ-ray emission was weaker by a few orders of magnitude than all known previous sGRBs and it was softer than typical sGRBs. This raise the question whether the γ-rays that we have seen were a regular sGRB viewed off-axis. We revisit this question following recent refined analyses of the γ-ray signal and the VLBI observations that revealed the angular structure of the relativistic outflow: observing angle of $\sim\,20^\circ$, a narrow jet with core $\lesssim5^\circ$ and $E_{\rm iso}>10^{52}\,{\rm ergs}$. We show here that: (i) The region emitting the observed $γ$-rays must have been moving with a Lorentz factor $Γ\gtrsim5$; (ii) The observed γ-rays were not "off-axis" emission (viewing angle $>1/Γ$) emerging from the core of the jet, where a regular sGRB was most likely produced; (iii) The $γ$-ray emission region was either "on-axis" (at an angle $<1/Γ$) or if it was "off-axis" then the observing angle must have been small ($<5^\circ$) and the on-axis emission from this region was too faint and too hard to resemble a regular sGRB. △ Less

Submitted 12 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures, submitted to MNRAS, comments welcome!!!

A Hubble constant measurement from superluminal motion of the jet in GW170817

Authors: Kenta Hotokezaka, Ehud Nakar, Ore Gottlieb, Samaya Nissanke, Kento Masuda, Gregg Hallinan, Kunal P. Mooley, Adam. T. Deller

Abstract: The Hubble constant ($H_0$) measures the current expansion rate of the Universe, and plays a fundamental role in cosmology. Tremendous effort has been dedicated over the past decades to measure $H_0$. Notably, Planck cosmic microwave background (CMB) and the local Cepheid-supernovae distance ladder measurements determine $H_0$ with a precision of $\sim 1\%$ and $\sim 2\%$ respectively. A $3$-$σ$ l… ▽ More The Hubble constant ($H_0$) measures the current expansion rate of the Universe, and plays a fundamental role in cosmology. Tremendous effort has been dedicated over the past decades to measure $H_0$. Notably, Planck cosmic microwave background (CMB) and the local Cepheid-supernovae distance ladder measurements determine $H_0$ with a precision of $\sim 1\%$ and $\sim 2\%$ respectively. A $3$-$σ$ level of discrepancy exists between the two measurements, for reasons that have yet to be understood. Gravitational wave (GW) sources accompanied by electromagnetic (EM) counterparts offer a completely independent standard siren (the GW analogue of an astronomical standard candle) measurement of $H_0$, as demonstrated following the discovery of the neutron star merger, GW170817. This measurement does not assume a cosmological model and is independent of a cosmic distance ladder. The first joint analysis of the GW signal from GW170817 and its EM localization led to a measurement of $H_0=74^{+16}_{-8}$ km/s/Mpc (median and symmetric $68\%$ credible interval). In this analysis, the degeneracy in the GW signal between the source distance and the weakly constrained viewing angle dominated the $H_0$ measurement uncertainty. Recently, Mooley et al. (2018) obtained tight constraints on the viewing angle using high angular resolution imaging of the radio counterpart of GW170817. Here we obtain a significantly improved measurement $H_0=68.9^{+4.7}_{-4.6}$ km/s/Mpc by using these new radio observations, combined with the previous GW and EM data. We estimate that 15 more localized GW170817-like events (comparable signal-to-noise ratio, favorable orientation), having radio images and light curve data, will potentially bring resolution to the tension between the Planck and Cepheid-supernova measurements, as compared to 50-100 GW events without such data. △ Less

Submitted 29 June, 2018; v1 submitted 27 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Comments: 29 pages, 9 figures

Superluminal motion of a relativistic jet in the neutron star merger GW170817

Authors: K. P. Mooley, A. T. Deller, O. Gottlieb, E. Nakar, G. Hallinan, S. Bourke, D. A. Frail, A. Horesh, A. Corsi, K. Hotokezaka

Abstract: The binary neutron star merger GW170817 was accompanied by radiation across the electromagnetic spectrum and localized to the galaxy NGC 4993 at a distance of 41+/-3 Mpc. The radio and X-ray afterglows of GW170817 exhibited delayed onset, a gradual rise in the emission with time as t^0.8, a peak at about 150 days post-merger, followed by a relatively rapid decline. To date, various models have bee… ▽ More The binary neutron star merger GW170817 was accompanied by radiation across the electromagnetic spectrum and localized to the galaxy NGC 4993 at a distance of 41+/-3 Mpc. The radio and X-ray afterglows of GW170817 exhibited delayed onset, a gradual rise in the emission with time as t^0.8, a peak at about 150 days post-merger, followed by a relatively rapid decline. To date, various models have been proposed to explain the afterglow emission, including a choked-jet cocoon and a successful-jet cocoon (a.k.a. structured jet). However, the observational data have remained inconclusive as to whether GW170817 launched a successful relativistic jet. Here we show, through Very Long Baseline Interferometry, that the compact radio source associated with GW170817 exhibits superluminal motion between two epochs at 75 and 230 days post-merger. This measurement breaks the degeneracy between the models and indicates that, while the early-time radio emission was powered by a wider-angle outflow (cocoon), the late-time emission was most likely dominated by an energetic and narrowly-collimated jet, with an opening angle of <5 degrees, and observed from a viewing angle of about 20 degrees. The imaging of a collimated relativistic outflow emerging from GW170817 adds substantial weight to the growing evidence linking binary neutron star mergers and short gamma-ray bursts. △ Less

Submitted 30 October, 2018; v1 submitted 25 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Comments: 42 pages, 4 figures (main text), 2 figures (supplementary text), 2 tables. Referee and editor comments incorporated

Journal ref: Nature, volume 561, pages 355-359 (2018)

From $γ$ to Radio - The Electromagnetic Counterpart of GW 170817

Authors: Ehud Nakar, Ore Gottlieb, Tsvi Piran, Mansi M. Kasliwal, Greg Hallinan

Abstract: The gravitational waves from the first binary neutron star merger, GW170817, were accompanied by a multi-wavelength electromagnetic counterpart, from $γ$-rays to radio. The accompanying gamma-rays, seems at first to confirm the association of mergers with short gamma-ray bursts (sGRBs). The common interpretation was that we see an emission from an sGRB jet seen off-axis. However, a closer examinat… ▽ More The gravitational waves from the first binary neutron star merger, GW170817, were accompanied by a multi-wavelength electromagnetic counterpart, from $γ$-rays to radio. The accompanying gamma-rays, seems at first to confirm the association of mergers with short gamma-ray bursts (sGRBs). The common interpretation was that we see an emission from an sGRB jet seen off-axis. However, a closer examination of the sub-luminous $γ$-rays and the peculiar radio afterglow were inconsistent with this simple interpretation. Here we present results of 3D and 2D numerical simulations that follow the hydrodynamics and emission of the outflow from a neutron star merger form its ejection and up to its deceleration by the circum-merger medium. Our results show that the entire set of $γ$-rays, X-rays and radio observations can be explained by the emission from a mildly relativistic cocoon material (Lorentz factor $\sim$2-5) that was formed while a jet propagated through the material ejected during the merger. The $γ$-rays are generated when the cocoon breaks out from the engulfing ejecta while the afterglow is produced by interaction of the cocoon matter with the interstellar medium. The strong early uv/optical signal may be a Lorentz boosted macronova/kilonova. The fate of the jet itself is currently unknown, but our full-EM models define a path to resolving between successful and choked jet scenarios, outputting coupled predictions for the image size, morphology, observed time-dependent polarization and light curve behavior from radio to X-ray. The predictive power of these models will prove key in interpreting the on-going multi-faceted observations of this unprecedented event. △ Less

Submitted 20 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Synchrotron radiation from the fast tail of dynamical ejecta of neutron star mergers

Authors: Kenta Hotokezaka, Kenta Kiuchi, Masaru Shibata, Ehud Nakar, Tsvi Piran

Abstract: We find, using high resolution numerical relativistic simulations, that the tail of the dynamical ejecta of neutron star mergers extends to mildly relativistic velocities faster than $0.7c$. The kinetic energy of this fast tail is $\sim 10^{47}$--$10^{49}$ erg, depending on the neutron star equation of state and on the binary masses. The synchrotron flare arising from the interaction of this fast… ▽ More We find, using high resolution numerical relativistic simulations, that the tail of the dynamical ejecta of neutron star mergers extends to mildly relativistic velocities faster than $0.7c$. The kinetic energy of this fast tail is $\sim 10^{47}$--$10^{49}$ erg, depending on the neutron star equation of state and on the binary masses. The synchrotron flare arising from the interaction of this fast tail with the surrounding ISM can power the observed non-thermal emission that followed GW170817, provided that the ISM density is $\sim 10^{-2}\,{\rm cm^{-3}}$, the two neutron stars had roughly equal masses and the neutron star equation of state is soft (small neutron star radii). One of the generic predictions of this scenario is that the cooling frequency crosses the X-ray band on a time scale of a few months to a year, leading to a cooling break in the X-ray light curve. If this dynamical ejecta scenario is correct, we expect that the synchrotron radio flare from the ejecta that have produced the macronova/kilonova emission will be observable on time scales of $10^3$ to $10^5$ days. Further multi-frequency observations will confirm or rule out this dynamical ejecta scenario. △ Less

Submitted 1 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: 8 pages, 6 figures

Is the macronova in GW170817 powered by the central engine?

Authors: Tatsuya Matsumoto, Kunihito Ioka, Shota Kisaka, Ehud Nakar

Abstract: The gravitational wave event GW170817 from a binary neutron star (NS) merger is accompanied by electromagnetic counterparts, and the optical and near-infared emission is called a macronova (or kilonova). Although the radioactivity of synthesized r-process elements is widely discussed as an energy source, its decisive evidence is not clearly shown yet. We discuss a macronova powered by the central… ▽ More The gravitational wave event GW170817 from a binary neutron star (NS) merger is accompanied by electromagnetic counterparts, and the optical and near-infared emission is called a macronova (or kilonova). Although the radioactivity of synthesized r-process elements is widely discussed as an energy source, its decisive evidence is not clearly shown yet. We discuss a macronova powered by the central engine activities such as jet activities and X-rays from the matter fallback, and show that the engine model allows much broader parameter spaces, in particular smaller ejecta mass ($\sim10^{-4}-0.01\,\Msun$) than the r-process model. The blue and red macronovae are naturally explained by various combinations of the ejecta such as a cocoon and merger ejecta with the energy sources of jets and X-rays. The required energy injection is very similar to the X-ray excess observed in GRB 130603B with the power-law slope of $\sim-1.3$. The required lanthanoid fraction for the opacity can be also consistent with the Galactic one. Early or late multi-wavelength observations are crucial for revealing the central engine of short gamma-ray bursts and the r-process nucleosynthesis. △ Less

Submitted 18 May, 2018; v1 submitted 21 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Comments: 13 pages, 6 figures, 2 tables, accepted by ApJ

Implications of the radio and X-ray emission that followed GW170817

Authors: Ehud Nakar, Tsvi Piran

Abstract: The radio and X-rays that followed GW170817 increased gradually over $\sim~100$ days, resembling the radio flare predicted to arise from the interaction of a binary neutron star merger outflow with the ISM \citep{nakar2011}. Considering a blast wave moving with a Lorentz factor $Γ$, we show that an off-axis observer, namely an observer at $θ_{obs}>1/Γ$, sees a light curve rising faster than… ▽ More The radio and X-rays that followed GW170817 increased gradually over $\sim~100$ days, resembling the radio flare predicted to arise from the interaction of a binary neutron star merger outflow with the ISM \citep{nakar2011}. Considering a blast wave moving with a Lorentz factor $Γ$, we show that an off-axis observer, namely an observer at $θ_{obs}>1/Γ$, sees a light curve rising faster than $F_ν\propto t^3$. Therefore, the observed rise, $F_ν\propto~t^{0.78}$, implies that at all times we have seen an on-axis emission. Namely, the emitting matter was within $θ_{obs}<1/Γ$ at the time of observations (even if it was off-axis beforehand). The observations tightly constrain the blast wave Lorentz factor: $Γ\sim(1.5-7)(t/10~{\rm day})^{-0.21}$.The isotropic equivalent energy in the observed region increases with time, $E_{iso}\sim~10^{50}{\rm~erg} ~(t/150~{\rm day})^{1.3}$, implying that the outflow was structured. The energy increase can arise from a slower material moving behind the blast wave or from a matter moving at larger angles that has slowed down. Such a structure could have different origins, however, the only physically motivated one, proposed so far, is the interaction of a relativistic jet with the ejecta and the resulting cocoon. The jet could have been choked or successful. In the latter case, it has produced a short GRB pointing elsewhere (this successful jet-cocoon system is sometimes called a "structured jet"). Although circumstantial evidence disfavors a successful jet, the jet fate cannot be decisively determined from current observations. The light curve alone may not be sufficient to resolve this question, since both chocked and successful jets can lead to a gradual rise to a peak, followed by a decay. Therefore, the recent turnover of the light curve does not necessitate a successful jet. △ Less

Submitted 2 April, 2018; v1 submitted 29 January, 2018; originally announced January 2018.

Comments: Revised to include a discussion the implication of the observed flattening of the light curve and compare them with predictions