-
Timescales of Chaos in the Inner Solar System: Lyapunov Spectrum and Quasi-integrals of Motion
Authors:
Federico Mogavero,
Nam H. Hoang,
Jacques Laskar
Abstract:
Numerical integrations of the Solar System reveal a remarkable stability of the orbits of the inner planets over billions of years, in spite of their chaotic variations characterized by a Lyapunov time of only 5 million years and the lack of integrals of motion able to constrain their dynamics. To open a window on such long-term behavior, we compute the entire Lyapunov spectrum of a forced secular…
▽ More
Numerical integrations of the Solar System reveal a remarkable stability of the orbits of the inner planets over billions of years, in spite of their chaotic variations characterized by a Lyapunov time of only 5 million years and the lack of integrals of motion able to constrain their dynamics. To open a window on such long-term behavior, we compute the entire Lyapunov spectrum of a forced secular model of the inner planets. We uncover a hierarchy of characteristic exponents that spans two orders of magnitude, manifesting a slow-fast dynamics with a broad separation of timescales. A systematic analysis of the Fourier harmonics of the Hamiltonian, based on computer algebra, reveals three symmetries that characterize the strongest resonances responsible for the orbital chaos. These symmetries are broken only by weak resonances, leading to the existence of quasi-integrals of motion that are shown to relate to the smallest Lyapunov exponents. A principal component analysis of the orbital solutions independently confirms that the quasi-integrals are among the slowest degrees of freedom of the dynamics. Strong evidence emerges that they effectively constrain the chaotic diffusion of the orbits, playing a crucial role in the statistical stability over the Solar System lifetime.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Long-term instability of the inner Solar System: numerical experiments
Authors:
Nam H. Hoang,
Federico Mogavero,
Jacques Laskar
Abstract:
Apart from being chaotic, the inner planets in the Solar System constitute an open system, as they are forced by the regular long-term motion of the outer ones. No integrals of motion can bound a priori the stochastic wanderings in their high-dimensional phase space. Still, the probability of a dynamical instability is remarkably low over the next 5 billion years, a timescale thousand times longer…
▽ More
Apart from being chaotic, the inner planets in the Solar System constitute an open system, as they are forced by the regular long-term motion of the outer ones. No integrals of motion can bound a priori the stochastic wanderings in their high-dimensional phase space. Still, the probability of a dynamical instability is remarkably low over the next 5 billion years, a timescale thousand times longer than the Lyapunov time. The dynamical half-life of Mercury has indeed been estimated recently at 40 billion years. By means of the computer algebra system TRIP, we consider a set of dynamical models resulting from truncation of the forced secular dynamics recently proposed for the inner planets at different degrees in eccentricities and inclinations. Through ensembles of $10^3$ to $10^5$ numerical integrations spanning 5 to 100 Gyr, we find that the Hamiltonian truncated at degree 4 practically does not allow any instability over 5 Gyr. The destabilisation is mainly due to terms of degree 6. This surprising result suggests an analogy to the Fermi-Pasta-Ulam-Tsingou problem, in which tangency to Toda Hamiltonian explains the very long timescale of thermalisation, which Fermi unsuccessfully looked for.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
The origin of chaos in the Solar System through computer algebra
Authors:
Federico Mogavero,
Jacques Laskar
Abstract:
The discovery of the chaotic motion of the planets in the Solar System dates back more than 30 years. Still, no analytical theory has satisfactorily addressed the origin of chaos so far. Implementing canonical perturbation theory in the computer algebra system TRIP, we systematically retrieve the secular resonances at work along the orbital solution of a forced long-term dynamics of the inner plan…
▽ More
The discovery of the chaotic motion of the planets in the Solar System dates back more than 30 years. Still, no analytical theory has satisfactorily addressed the origin of chaos so far. Implementing canonical perturbation theory in the computer algebra system TRIP, we systematically retrieve the secular resonances at work along the orbital solution of a forced long-term dynamics of the inner planets. We compare the time statistic of their half-widths to the ensemble distribution of the maximum Lyapunov exponent and establish dynamical sources of chaos in an unbiased way. New resonances are predicted by the theory and checked against direct integrations of the Solar System. The image of an entangled dynamics of the inner planets emerges.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Chaotic diffusion of the fundamental frequencies in the Solar System
Authors:
Nam H. Hoang,
Federico Mogavero,
Jacques Laskar
Abstract:
The long-term variations in the orbit of the Earth govern the insolation on its surface and hence its climate. The use of the astronomical signal, whose imprint has been recovered in the geological records, has revolutionized the determination of the geological timescales. However, the orbital variations beyond 60 Myr cannot be reliably predicted because of the chaotic dynamics of the planetary or…
▽ More
The long-term variations in the orbit of the Earth govern the insolation on its surface and hence its climate. The use of the astronomical signal, whose imprint has been recovered in the geological records, has revolutionized the determination of the geological timescales. However, the orbital variations beyond 60 Myr cannot be reliably predicted because of the chaotic dynamics of the planetary orbits in the Solar System. Taking this dynamical uncertainty into account is necessary for a complete astronomical calibration of geological records. Our work addresses this problem with a statistical analysis of 120 000 orbital solutions of the secular model of the Solar System ranging from 500 Myr to 5 Gyr. We obtain the marginal probability density functions of the fundamental secular frequencies using kernel density estimation. The uncertainty of the density estimation is also obtained here in the form of confidence intervals determined by the moving block bootstrap method. The results of the secular model are shown to be in good agreement with those of the direct integrations of a comprehensive model of the Solar System. Application of our work is illustrated on two geological data sets: the Newark-Hartford records and the Libsack core.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2023; v1 submitted 28 May, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Long-term dynamics of the solar system inner planets
Authors:
Federico Mogavero,
Jacques Laskar
Abstract:
Although the discovery of the chaotic motion of the inner planets in the solar system dates back to more than thirty years ago, the secular chaos of their orbits still dares more analytical analyses. Apart from the high-dimensional structure of the motion, this is probably related to the lack of an adequately simple dynamical model. Here, we consider a new secular dynamics for the inner planets, w…
▽ More
Although the discovery of the chaotic motion of the inner planets in the solar system dates back to more than thirty years ago, the secular chaos of their orbits still dares more analytical analyses. Apart from the high-dimensional structure of the motion, this is probably related to the lack of an adequately simple dynamical model. Here, we consider a new secular dynamics for the inner planets, with the aim of retaining a fundamental set of interactions responsible for their chaotic behaviour, while being consistent with the predictions of the most precise orbital solutions currently available. We exploit the regularity in the secular motion of the outer planets, to predetermine a quasi-periodic solution for their orbits. This reduces the secular phase space to the degrees of freedom dominated by the inner planets. On top of that, the smallness of the inner planet masses and the absence of strong mean-motion resonances permits to restrict ourselves to first-order secular averaging. The resulting dynamics can be integrated numerically in a very efficient way through Gauss's method, while computer algebra allows for analytical inspection of planet interactions, once the Hamiltonian is truncated at a given total degree in eccentricities and inclinations. The new model matches very satisfactorily reference orbital solutions of the solar system over timescales shorter than or comparable to the Lyapunov time. It correctly reproduces the maximum Lyapunov exponent of the inner system and the statistics of the high eccentricities of Mercury over the next five billion years. The destabilizing role of the $g_1-g_5$ secular resonance also arises. A numerical experiment, consisting of a thousand orbital solutions over one hundred billion years, reveals the essential properties of the stochastic process driving the destabilization of the inner solar system and clarifies its current metastable state.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Addressing the statistical mechanics of planet orbits in the solar system
Authors:
Federico Mogavero
Abstract:
The chaotic nature of planet dynamics in the solar system suggests the relevance of a statistical approach to planetary orbits. In such a statistical description, the time-dependent position and velocity of the planets are replaced by the probability density function (PDF) of their orbital elements. It is quite natural to set up this kind of approach in the framework of statistical mechanics. In t…
▽ More
The chaotic nature of planet dynamics in the solar system suggests the relevance of a statistical approach to planetary orbits. In such a statistical description, the time-dependent position and velocity of the planets are replaced by the probability density function (PDF) of their orbital elements. It is quite natural to set up this kind of approach in the framework of statistical mechanics. In the present paper I focus on the collisionless excitation of eccentricities and inclinations by gravitational interactions in a planetary system, the prototype of such a dynamics being the future planet trajectories in the solar system. I thus address the statistical mechanics of the planetary orbits in the solar system and try to reproduce the PDFs numerically constructed by Laskar (2008). I show that the microcanonical ensemble of the Laplace-Lagrange theory accurately reproduce the statistics of the giant planet orbits. To model the inner planets I then investigate the ansatz of equiprobability in the phase space constrained by the secular integrals of motion. The eccentricity and inclination PDFs of Earth and Venus are reproduced with no free parameters. Within the limitations of a stationary model, the predictions also show a reasonable agreement with Mars PDFs and that of Mercury inclination. The eccentricity of Mercury demands in contrast a deeper analysis. I finally revisit Laskar's random walk approach to the time dependence of the inner planet PDFs. Such a statistical theory could be combined with direct numerical simulations of planet trajectories in the context of planet formation, which is likely to be a chaotic process.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Campaign 9 of the $K2$ Mission: Observational Parameters, Scientific Drivers, and Community Involvement for a Simultaneous Space- and Ground-based Microlensing Survey
Authors:
Calen B. Henderson,
Radosław Poleski,
Matthew Penny,
Rachel A. Street,
David P. Bennett,
David W. Hogg,
B. Scott Gaudi,
W. Zhu,
T. Barclay,
G. Barentsen,
S. B. Howell,
F. Mullally,
A. Udalski,
M. K. Szymański,
J. Skowron,
P. Mróz,
S. Kozłowski,
Ł. Wyrzykowski,
P. Pietrukowicz,
I. Soszyński,
K. Ulaczyk,
M. Pawlak,
T. Sumi,
F. Abe,
Y. Asakura
, et al. (96 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
$K2$'s Campaign 9 ($K2$C9) will conduct a $\sim$3.7 deg$^{2}$ survey toward the Galactic bulge from 7/April through 1/July of 2016 that will leverage the spatial separation between $K2$ and the Earth to facilitate measurement of the microlens parallax $π_{\rm E}$ for $\gtrsim…
▽ More
$K2$'s Campaign 9 ($K2$C9) will conduct a $\sim$3.7 deg$^{2}$ survey toward the Galactic bulge from 7/April through 1/July of 2016 that will leverage the spatial separation between $K2$ and the Earth to facilitate measurement of the microlens parallax $π_{\rm E}$ for $\gtrsim$127 microlensing events. These will include several that are planetary in nature as well as many short-timescale microlensing events, which are potentially indicative of free-floating planets (FFPs). These satellite parallax measurements will in turn allow for the direct measurement of the masses of and distances to the lensing systems. In this white paper we provide an overview of the $K2$C9 space- and ground-based microlensing survey. Specifically, we detail the demographic questions that can be addressed by this program, including the frequency of FFPs and the Galactic distribution of exoplanets, the observational parameters of $K2$C9, and the array of resources dedicated to concurrent observations. Finally, we outline the avenues through which the larger community can become involved, and generally encourage participation in $K2$C9, which constitutes an important pathfinding mission and community exercise in anticipation of $WFIRST$.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2016; v1 submitted 30 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Microlensing planet detection via geosynchronous and low Earth orbit satellites
Authors:
F. Mogavero,
J. P. Beaulieu
Abstract:
Planet detection through microlensing is usually limited by a well-known degeneracy in the Einstein timescale $t_E$, which prevents mass and distance of the lens to be univocally determined. It has been shown that a satellite in geosynchronous orbit could provide masses and distances for most standard planetary events ($t_E \approx 20$ days) via a microlens parallax measurement. This paper extends…
▽ More
Planet detection through microlensing is usually limited by a well-known degeneracy in the Einstein timescale $t_E$, which prevents mass and distance of the lens to be univocally determined. It has been shown that a satellite in geosynchronous orbit could provide masses and distances for most standard planetary events ($t_E \approx 20$ days) via a microlens parallax measurement. This paper extends the analysis to shorter Einstein timescales, $t_E \approx 1$ day, when dealing with the case of Jupiter-mass lenses. We then study the capabilities of a low Earth orbit satellite on even shorter timescales, $t_E \approx 0.1$ days. A Fisher matrix analysis is employed to predict how the 1-$σ$ error on parallax depends on $t_E$ and the peak magnification of the microlensing event. It is shown that a geosynchronous satellite could detect parallaxes for Jupiter-mass free floaters and discover planetary systems around very low-mass brown dwarfs. Moreover, a low Earth orbit satellite could lead to the discovery of Earth-mass free-floating planets. Limitations to these results can be the strong requirements on the photometry, the effects of blending, and in the case of the low orbit, the Earth's umbra.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2015; v1 submitted 16 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Models of magnetic-field evolution and effective viscosity in weakly collisional extragalactic plasmas
Authors:
Federico Mogavero,
Alexander A. Schekochihin
Abstract:
In weakly collisional extragalactic plasmas such as the intracluster medium, viscous stress and the rate of change of the magnetic-field strength are proportional to the local pressure anisotropy, so subject to constraints imposed by the pressure-anisotropy-driven mirror and firehose instabilities and controlled by the local instantaneous plasma beta. The dynamics of such plasmas is dramatically d…
▽ More
In weakly collisional extragalactic plasmas such as the intracluster medium, viscous stress and the rate of change of the magnetic-field strength are proportional to the local pressure anisotropy, so subject to constraints imposed by the pressure-anisotropy-driven mirror and firehose instabilities and controlled by the local instantaneous plasma beta. The dynamics of such plasmas is dramatically different from a conventional MHD fluid. The plasma is expected to stay locally in a marginal state with respect to the instabilities, but how it does this is an open question. Two models of magnetic-field evolution are investigated. In the first, marginality is achieved via suppression of the rate of change of the field. In the second, the instabilities give rise to anomalous collisionality, reducing pressure anisotropy to marginal - at the same time decreasing viscosity and so increasing the turbulent rate of strain. Implications of these models are studied in a simplified 0D setting. In the first model, the field grows explosively but on a time scale that scales with initial beta, while in the second, dynamical field strength can be reached in one large-scale turbulence turn-over time regardless of the initial seed. Both models produce very intermittent fields. Both also suffer from strong constraints on their applicability: for typical cluster-core conditions, scale separation between the fluid motions and the microscale fluctuations breaks down at beta~10^5-10^4. At larger beta (weaker fields), a fully collisionless plasma dynamo theory is needed in order to justify the growth of the field from a tiny primordial seed. However, the models discussed here are appropriate for studying the structure of the currently observed field as well as large-scale dynamics and thermodynamics of the magnetized ICM or similarly dilute astrophysical plasmas.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2014; v1 submitted 12 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
