-
Estimating Magnetic Filling Factors From Simultaneous Spectroscopy and Photometry: Disentangling Spots, Plage, and Network
Authors:
T. W. Milbourne,
D. F. Phillips,
N. Langellier,
A. Mortier,
R. D. Haywood,
S. H. Saar,
H. M. Cegla,
A. Collier Cameron,
X. Dumusque,
D. W. Latham,
L. Malavolta,
J. Maldonado,
S. Thompson,
A. Vanderburg,
C. A. Watson,
L. A. Buchhave,
M. Cecconi,
R. Cosentino,
A. Ghedina,
M. Gonzalez,
M. Lodi,
M. López-Morales,
A. Sozzetti,
R. L. Walsworth
Abstract:
State of the art radial velocity (RV) exoplanet searches are limited by the effects of stellar magnetic activity. Magnetically active spots, plage, and network regions each have different impacts on the observed spectral lines, and therefore on the apparent stellar RV. Differentiating the relative coverage, or filling factors, of these active regions is thus necessary to differentiate between acti…
▽ More
State of the art radial velocity (RV) exoplanet searches are limited by the effects of stellar magnetic activity. Magnetically active spots, plage, and network regions each have different impacts on the observed spectral lines, and therefore on the apparent stellar RV. Differentiating the relative coverage, or filling factors, of these active regions is thus necessary to differentiate between activity-driven RV signatures and Doppler shifts due to planetary orbits. In this work, we develop a technique to estimate feature-specific magnetic filling factors on stellar targets using only spectroscopic and photometric observations. We demonstrate linear and neural network implementations of our technique using observations from the solar telescope at HARPS-N, the HK Project at the Mt. Wilson Observatory, and the Total Irradiance Monitor onboard SORCE. We then compare the results of each technique to direct observations by the Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO). Both implementations yield filling factor estimates that are highly correlated with the observed values. Modeling the solar RVs using these filling factors reproduces the expected contributions of the suppression of convective blueshift and rotational imbalance due to brightness inhomogeneities. Both implementations of this technique reduce the overall activity-driven RMS RVs from 1.64 m/s to 1.02 m/s, corresponding to a 1.28 m/s reduction in the RMS variation. The technique provides an additional 0.41 m/s reduction in the RMS variation compared to traditional activity indicators.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2021; v1 submitted 19 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Identifying Exoplanets with Deep Learning. IV. Removing Stellar Activity Signals from Radial Velocity Measurements Using Neural Networks
Authors:
Zoe L. de Beurs,
Andrew Vanderburg,
Christopher J. Shallue,
Xavier Dumusque,
Andrew Collier Cameron,
Christopher Leet,
Lars A. Buchhave,
Rosario Cosentino,
Adriano Ghedina,
Raphaëlle D. Haywood,
Nicholas Langellier,
David W. Latham,
Mercedes López-Morales,
Michel Mayor,
Giusi Micela,
Timothy W. Milbourne,
Annelies Mortier,
Emilio Molinari,
Francesco Pepe,
David F. Phillips,
Matteo Pinamonti,
Giampaolo Piotto,
Ken Rice,
Dimitar Sasselov,
Alessandro Sozzetti
, et al. (2 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Exoplanet detection with precise radial velocity (RV) observations is currently limited by spurious RV signals introduced by stellar activity. We show that machine learning techniques such as linear regression and neural networks can effectively remove the activity signals (due to starspots/faculae) from RV observations. Previous efforts focused on carefully filtering out activity signals in time…
▽ More
Exoplanet detection with precise radial velocity (RV) observations is currently limited by spurious RV signals introduced by stellar activity. We show that machine learning techniques such as linear regression and neural networks can effectively remove the activity signals (due to starspots/faculae) from RV observations. Previous efforts focused on carefully filtering out activity signals in time using modeling techniques like Gaussian Process regression (e.g. Haywood et al. 2014). Instead, we systematically remove activity signals using only changes to the average shape of spectral lines, and no information about when the observations were collected. We trained our machine learning models on both simulated data (generated with the SOAP 2.0 software; Dumusque et al. 2014) and observations of the Sun from the HARPS-N Solar Telescope (Dumusque et al. 2015; Phillips et al. 2016; Collier Cameron et al. 2019). We find that these techniques can predict and remove stellar activity from both simulated data (improving RV scatter from 82 cm/s to 3 cm/s) and from more than 600 real observations taken nearly daily over three years with the HARPS-N Solar Telescope (improving the RV scatter from 1.753 m/s to 1.039 m/s, a factor of ~ 1.7 improvement). In the future, these or similar techniques could remove activity signals from observations of stars outside our solar system and eventually help detect habitable-zone Earth-mass exoplanets around Sun-like stars.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2022; v1 submitted 30 October, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Detection Limits of Low-mass, Long-period Exoplanets Using Gaussian Processes Applied to HARPS-N Solar RVs
Authors:
N. Langellier,
T. W. Milbourne,
D. F. Phillips,
R. D. Haywood,
S. H. Saar,
A. Mortier,
L. Malavolta,
S. Thompson,
A. Collier Cameron,
X. Dumusque,
H. M. Cegla,
D. W. Latham,
J. Maldonado,
C. A. Watson,
N. Buchschacher,
M. Cecconi,
D. Charbonneau,
R. Cosentino,
A. Ghedina,
M. Gonzalez,
C-H. Li,
M. Lodi,
M. López-Morales,
G. Micela,
E. Molinari
, et al. (7 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Radial velocity (RV) searches for Earth-mass exoplanets in the habitable zone around Sun-like stars are limited by the effects of stellar variability on the host star. In particular, suppression of convective blueshift and brightness inhomogeneities due to photospheric faculae/plage and starspots are the dominant contribution to the variability of such stellar RVs. Gaussian process (GP) regression…
▽ More
Radial velocity (RV) searches for Earth-mass exoplanets in the habitable zone around Sun-like stars are limited by the effects of stellar variability on the host star. In particular, suppression of convective blueshift and brightness inhomogeneities due to photospheric faculae/plage and starspots are the dominant contribution to the variability of such stellar RVs. Gaussian process (GP) regression is a powerful tool for statistically modeling these quasi-periodic variations. We investigate the limits of this technique using 800 days of RVs from the solar telescope on the High Accuracy Radial velocity Planet Searcher for the Northern hemisphere (HARPS-N) spectrograph. These data provide a well-sampled time series of stellar RV variations. Into this data set, we inject Keplerian signals with periods between 100 and 500 days and amplitudes between 0.6 and 2.4 m s$^{-1}$. We use GP regression to fit the resulting RVs and determine the statistical significance of recovered periods and amplitudes. We then generate synthetic RVs with the same covariance properties as the solar data to determine a lower bound on the observational baseline necessary to detect low-mass planets in Venus-like orbits around a Sun-like star. Our simulations show that discovering planets with a larger mass ($\sim$ 0.5 m s$^{-1}$) using current-generation spectrographs and GP regression will require more than 12 yr of densely sampled RV observations. Furthermore, even with a perfect model of stellar variability, discovering a true exo-Venus ($\sim$ 0.1 m s$^{-1}$) with current instruments would take over 15 yr. Therefore, next-generation spectrographs and better models of stellar variability are required for detection of such planets.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2021; v1 submitted 13 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Unsigned magnetic flux as a proxy for radial-velocity variations in Sun-like stars
Authors:
R. D. Haywood,
T. W. Milbourne,
S. H. Saar,
A. Mortier,
D. Phillips,
D. Charbonneau,
A. Collier Cameron,
H. M. Cegla,
N. Meunier,
M. L. Palumbo III
Abstract:
We estimate disc-averaged RV variations of the Sun over the last magnetic cycle, from the single Fe I line observed by SDO/HMI, using a physical model for rotationally modulated magnetic activity that was previously validated against HARPS-N solar observations. We estimate the disc-averaged, unsigned magnetic flux and show that a simple linear fit to it reduces the RMS of RV variations by 62%, i.e…
▽ More
We estimate disc-averaged RV variations of the Sun over the last magnetic cycle, from the single Fe I line observed by SDO/HMI, using a physical model for rotationally modulated magnetic activity that was previously validated against HARPS-N solar observations. We estimate the disc-averaged, unsigned magnetic flux and show that a simple linear fit to it reduces the RMS of RV variations by 62%, i.e. a factor of 2.6. We additionally apply the FF' method, which predicts RV variations based on a star's photometric variations. At cycle maximum, we find that additional physical processes must be at play beyond suppression of convective blueshift and velocity imablances resulting from brightness inhomogeneities, in agreement with recent studies of solar RV variations. By modelling RV variations over the magnetic cycle using a linear fit to the unsigned magnetic flux, we recover injected planets at an orbital period of about 300 days with RV semi-amplitudes down to 0.3 m/s. To reach semi-amplitudes of 0.1 m/s, we will need to identify and model additional physical phenomena that are not well traced by the unsigned magnetic flux or FF'. The unsigned magnetic flux is an excellent proxy for rotationally modulated, activity-induced RV variations, and could become a key tool in confirming and characterising Earth analogs orbiting Sun-like stars. The present study motivates ongoing and future efforts to develop observation and analysis techniques to measure the unsigned magnetic flux at high precision in slowly rotating, relatively inactive stars like the Sun.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
The spectral impact of magnetic activity on disk-integrated HARPS-N solar observations: exploring new activity indicators
Authors:
A. P. G. Thompson,
C. A. Watson,
R. D. Haywood,
J. C. Costes,
E. de Mooij,
A. Collier Cameron,
X. Dumusque,
D. F. Phillips,
S. H. Saar,
A. Mortier,
T. W. Milbourne,
S. Aigrain,
H. M. Cegla,
D. Charbonneau,
R. Cosentino,
A. Ghedina,
D. W. Latham,
M. López-Morales,
G. Micela,
E. Molinari,
E. Poretti,
A. Sozzetti,
S. Thompson,
R. Walsworth
Abstract:
Stellar activity is the major roadblock on the path to finding true Earth-analogue planets with the Doppler technique. Thus, identifying new indicators that better trace magnetic activity (i.e. faculae and spots) is crucial to aid in disentangling these signals from that of a planet's Doppler wobble. In this work, we investigate activity related features as seen in disk-integrated spectra from the…
▽ More
Stellar activity is the major roadblock on the path to finding true Earth-analogue planets with the Doppler technique. Thus, identifying new indicators that better trace magnetic activity (i.e. faculae and spots) is crucial to aid in disentangling these signals from that of a planet's Doppler wobble. In this work, we investigate activity related features as seen in disk-integrated spectra from the HARPS-N solar telescope. We divide high-activity spectral echelle orders by low-activity master templates (as defined using both log R'HK and images from the Solar Dynamics Observatory, SDO), creating "relative spectra". With resolved images of the surface of the Sun (via SDO), the faculae and spot filling factors can be calculated, giving a measure of activity independent of, and in addition to, log R'HK. We find pseudo-emission (and pseudo-absorption) features in the relative spectra that are similar to those reported in our previous work on alpha Cen B. In alpha Cen B, the features are shown to correlate better to changes in faculae filling factor than spot filling factor. In this work we more confidently identify changes in faculae coverage of the visible hemisphere of the Sun as the source of features produced in the relative spectra. Finally, we produce trailed spectra to observe the RV component of the features, which show that the features move in a redward direction as one would expect when tracking active regions rotating on the surface of a star.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Testing the Spectroscopic Extraction of Suppression of Convective Blueshift
Authors:
M. Miklos,
T. W. Milbourne,
R. D. Haywood,
D. F. Phillips,
S. H. Saar,
N. Meunier,
H. M. Cegla,
X. Dumusque,
N. Langellier,
J. Maldonado,
L. Malavolta,
A. Mortier,
S. Thompson,
C. A. Watson,
M. Cecconi,
R. Cosentino,
A. Ghedina,
C-H. Li,
M. López-Morales,
E. Molinari,
E. Poretti,
D. Sasselov,
A. Sozzetti,
R. L. Walsworth
Abstract:
Efforts to detect low-mass exoplanets using stellar radial velocities (RVs) are currently limited by magnetic photospheric activity. Suppression of convective blueshift is the dominant magnetic contribution to RV variability in low-activity Sun-like stars. Due to convective plasma motions, the magnitude of RV contributions from the suppression of convective blueshift is related to the depth of for…
▽ More
Efforts to detect low-mass exoplanets using stellar radial velocities (RVs) are currently limited by magnetic photospheric activity. Suppression of convective blueshift is the dominant magnetic contribution to RV variability in low-activity Sun-like stars. Due to convective plasma motions, the magnitude of RV contributions from the suppression of convective blueshift is related to the depth of formation of photospheric spectral lines of a given species used to compute the RV time series. Meunier et al. (2017), used this relation to demonstrate a method for spectroscopic extraction of the suppression of convective blueshift in order to isolate RV contributions, including planetary RVs, that contribute equally to the timeseries for each spectral line. Here, we extract disk-integrated solar RVs from observations over a 2.5 year time span made with the solar telescope integrated with the HARPS-N spectrograph at the Telescopio Nazionale Galileo (La Palma, Canary Islands, Spain). We apply the methods outlined by Meunier et al. (2017). We are not, however, able to isolate physically meaningful contributions of the suppression of convective blueshift from this solar dataset, potentially because our dataset is from solar minimum when the suppression of convective blueshift may not sufficiently dominate activity contributions to RVs. This result indicates that, for low-activity Sun-like stars, one must include additional RV contributions from activity sources not considered in the Meunier et al. (2017) model at different timescales as well as instrumental variation in order to reach the sub-meter per second RV sensitivity necessary to detect low-mass planets in orbit around Sun-like stars.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2020; v1 submitted 20 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Sensitivity of low-degree solar p modes to active and ephemeral regions: frequency shifts back to the Maunder Minimum
Authors:
William J. Chaplin,
Rachel Howe,
Sarbani Basu,
Yvonne Elsworth,
Timothy W. Milbourne,
Raphaëlle D. Haywood,
Guy R. Davies,
Steven J. Hale,
Andrea Miglio,
Eddie Ross
Abstract:
We explore the sensitivity of the frequencies of low-degree solar p-modes to near-surface magnetic flux on different spatial scales and strengths, specifically to active regions with strong magnetic fields and ephemeral regions with weak magnetic fields. We also use model reconstructions from the literature to calculate average frequency offsets back to the end of the Maunder minimum. We find that…
▽ More
We explore the sensitivity of the frequencies of low-degree solar p-modes to near-surface magnetic flux on different spatial scales and strengths, specifically to active regions with strong magnetic fields and ephemeral regions with weak magnetic fields. We also use model reconstructions from the literature to calculate average frequency offsets back to the end of the Maunder minimum. We find that the p-mode frequencies are at least three times less sensitive (at 95% confidence) to the ephemeral-region field than they are to the active-region field. Frequency shifts between activity cycle minima and maxima are controlled predominantly by the change of active region flux. Frequency shifts at cycle minima (with respect to a magnetically quiet Sun) are determined largely by the ephemeral flux, and are estimated to have been $0.1\,\rm μHz$ or less over the last few minima. We conclude that at epochs of cycle minimum, frequency shifts due to near-surface magnetic activity are negligible compared to the offsets between observed and model frequencies that arise from inaccurate modelling of the near-surface layers (the so-called surface term). The implication is that this will be the case for other Sun-like stars with similar activity, which has implications for asteroseismic modelling of stars.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
HARPS-N Solar Radial-Velocity Variations Are Dominated By Large, Bright Magnetic Regions
Authors:
T. W. Milbourne,
R. D. Haywood,
D. F. Phillips,
S. H. Saar,
H. M. Cegla,
A. C. Cameron,
J. Costes,
X. Dumusque,
N. Langellier,
D. W. Latham,
J. Maldonado,
L. Malavolta,
A. Mortier,
M. L. Palumbo Iii,
S. Thompson,
C. A. Watson,
F. Bouchy,
N. Buchschacher,
M. Cecconi,
D. Charbonneau,
R. Cosentino,
A. Ghedina,
A. G. Glenday,
M. Gonzalez,
C-H. Li
, et al. (15 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
State of the art radial-velocity (RV) exoplanet searches are currently limited by RV signals arising from stellar magnetic activity. We analyze solar observations acquired over a 3-year period during the decline of Carrington Cycle 24 to test models of RV variation of Sun-like stars. A purpose-built solar telescope at the High Accuracy Radial velocity Planet Searcher for the Northern hemisphere (H…
▽ More
State of the art radial-velocity (RV) exoplanet searches are currently limited by RV signals arising from stellar magnetic activity. We analyze solar observations acquired over a 3-year period during the decline of Carrington Cycle 24 to test models of RV variation of Sun-like stars. A purpose-built solar telescope at the High Accuracy Radial velocity Planet Searcher for the Northern hemisphere (HARPS-N) provides disk-integrated solar spectra, from which we extract RVs and $\log{R'_{\rm HK}}$. The Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) provides disk-resolved images of magnetic activity. The Solar Radiation and Climate Experiment (SORCE) provides near-continuous solar photometry, analogous to a Kepler light curve. We verify that the SORCE photometry and HARPS-N $\log{R'_{\rm HK}}$ correlate strongly with the SDO-derived magnetic filling factor, while the HARPS-N RV variations do not. To explain this discrepancy, we test existing models of RV variations. We estimate the contributions of the suppression of convective blueshift and the rotational imbalance due to brightness inhomogeneities to the observed HARPS-N RVs. We investigate the time variation of these contributions over several rotation periods, and how these contributions depend on the area of active regions. We find that magnetic active regions smaller than $60 \ \rm Mm^2$ do not significantly suppress convective blueshift. Our area-dependent model reduces the amplitude of activity-induced RV variations by a factor of two. The present study highlights the need to identify a proxy that correlates specifically with large, bright magnetic regions on the surfaces of exoplanet-hosting stars.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
