-
Three-dimensional atmospheric dynamics of Jupiter from ground-based Doppler imaging spectroscopy in the visible
Authors:
François-Xavier Schmider,
Patrick Gaulme,
Raúl Morales-Juberías,
Jason Jackiewicz,
Ivan Gonçalves,
Tristan Guillot,
Amy A. Simon,
Michael H. Wong,
Thomas Underwood,
David Voelz,
Cristo Sanchez,
Riley DeColibus,
Sarah A. Kovac,
Sean Sellers,
Doug Gilliam,
Patrick Boumier,
Thierry Appourchaux,
Julien Dejonghe,
Jean Pierre Rivet,
Steve Markham,
Saburo Howard,
Lyu Abe,
Djamel Mekarnia,
Masahiro Ikoma,
Hidekazu Hanayama
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present three-dimensional (3D) maps of Jupiter's atmospheric circulation at cloud-top level from Doppler-imaging data obtained in the visible domain with JIVE, the second node of the JOVIAL network, which is mounted on the Dunn Solar Telescope at Sunspot, New Mexico. We report on 12 nights of observations between May 4 and May 30, 2018, representing a total of about 80 hours. Firstly, the avera…
▽ More
We present three-dimensional (3D) maps of Jupiter's atmospheric circulation at cloud-top level from Doppler-imaging data obtained in the visible domain with JIVE, the second node of the JOVIAL network, which is mounted on the Dunn Solar Telescope at Sunspot, New Mexico. We report on 12 nights of observations between May 4 and May 30, 2018, representing a total of about 80 hours. Firstly, the average zonal wind profile derived from our data is compatible with that derived from cloud-tracking measurements performed on Hubble Space Telescope images obtained in April 2018 from the Outer Planet Atmospheres Legacy (OPAL) program. Secondly, we present the first ever two-dimensional maps of Jupiter's atmospheric circulation from Doppler measurements. The zonal velocity map highlights well-known atmospheric features, such as the equatorial hot spots and the Great Red Spot (GRS). In addition to zonal winds, we derive meridional and vertical velocity fields from the Doppler data. The motions attributed to vertical flows are mainly located at the boundary between the equatorial belts and tropical zones, which could indicate active motion in theses regions. Qualitatively, these results compare well to recent Juno data that have unveiled the three-dimensional structure of Jupiter's wind field. To the contrary, the motions attributed to meridional circulation are very different from what is obtained by cloud tracking, except at the GRS. Because of limitations with data resolution and processing techniques, we acknowledge that our measurement of vertical or meridional flows of Jupiter are still to be confirmed.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2024; v1 submitted 28 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
On the hypothesis of an inverted Z-gradient inside Jupiter
Authors:
Saburo Howard,
Tristan Guillot,
Steve Markham,
Ravit Helled,
Simon Müller,
David J. Stevenson,
Jonathan I. Lunine,
Yamila Miguel,
Nadine Nettelmann
Abstract:
Models of Jupiter s interior struggle to agree with measurements of the atmospheric composition. Interior models favour a subsolar or solar abundance of heavy elements Z while atmospheric measurements suggest a supersolar abundance. One potential solution may be the presence of an inverted Z-gradient, namely an inward decrease of Z, which implies a larger heavy element abundance in the atmosphere…
▽ More
Models of Jupiter s interior struggle to agree with measurements of the atmospheric composition. Interior models favour a subsolar or solar abundance of heavy elements Z while atmospheric measurements suggest a supersolar abundance. One potential solution may be the presence of an inverted Z-gradient, namely an inward decrease of Z, which implies a larger heavy element abundance in the atmosphere than in the outer envelope. We investigate two scenarios in which the inverted Z gradient is located either where helium rain occurs (Mbar level) or at upper levels (kbar level) where a radiative region could exist. We aim to assess how plausible these scenarios are. We calculate interior and evolution models of Jupiter with such inverted Z-gradient and use constraints on the stability and the formation of an inverted Z-gradient. We find that an inverted Z-gradient at the location of helium rain cannot work as it requires a late accretion and of too much material. We find interior models with an inverted Z-gradient at upper levels, due to a radiative zone preventing downward mixing, that could satisfy the present gravity field of the planet. However, our evolution models suggest that this second scenario might not be in place. An inverted Z-gradient in Jupiter could be stable. Yet, its presence either at the Mbar level or kbar level is rather unlikely.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Rainy downdrafts in abyssal atmospheres
Authors:
S. Markham,
T. Guillot,
C. Li
Abstract:
Results from Juno's microwave radiometer indicate non-uniform mixing of ammonia vapor in Jupiter's atmosphere down to tens of bars, far beneath the cloud level. Helioseismic observations suggest solar convection may require narrow, concentrated downdrafts called entropy rain to accommodate the Sun's luminosity. Both observations suggest some mechanism of non-local convective transport. We seek to…
▽ More
Results from Juno's microwave radiometer indicate non-uniform mixing of ammonia vapor in Jupiter's atmosphere down to tens of bars, far beneath the cloud level. Helioseismic observations suggest solar convection may require narrow, concentrated downdrafts called entropy rain to accommodate the Sun's luminosity. Both observations suggest some mechanism of non-local convective transport. We seek to predict the depth that a concentrated density anomaly can reach before efficiently mixing with its environment in bottomless atmospheres. We modify classic self-similar analytical models of entraining thermals to account for the compressibility of an abyssal atmosphere. We compare these models to the output of high resolution three dimensional fluid dynamical simulations to more accurately model the chaotic influence of turbulence. We find that localized density anomalies propagate down to ~3-8 times their initial size without substantially mixing with their environment. Our analytic model accurately predicts the initial flow, but the self-similarity assumption breaks down after the flow becomes unstable at a characteristic penetration depth. In the context of Jupiter, our findings suggest that precipitation concentrated into localized downdrafts of size ~20km can coherently penetrate to on the order of a hundred kilometers (tens of bars) beneath its initial vaporization level without mixing with its environment. This finding is consistent with expected convective storm length-scales, and Juno MWR measurements of ammonia depletion. Compositional gradients of volatiles beneath their cloud levels may be common on stormy giant planets. In the context of the Sun, we find that turbulent downdrafts in abyssal atmospheres cannot maintain their coherence through the Sun's convective layer, a potential challenge for the entropy rain hypothesis.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Convective inhibition with an atmosphere, I: super-critical cores on sub-Neptune/super-Earths
Authors:
Steve Markham,
Dave Stevenson,
Tristan Guillot
Abstract:
In this work we generalize the notion of convective inhibition to apply in cases where there is an infinite reservoir of condensible species (i.e., an ocean). We propose a new model for the internal structure and thermal evolution of super-Earths with hydrogen envelopes. We derive the criterion for convective inhibition in a generalizes phase mixture from first principles thermodynamics. We then i…
▽ More
In this work we generalize the notion of convective inhibition to apply in cases where there is an infinite reservoir of condensible species (i.e., an ocean). We propose a new model for the internal structure and thermal evolution of super-Earths with hydrogen envelopes. We derive the criterion for convective inhibition in a generalizes phase mixture from first principles thermodynamics. We then investigate the global ocean case using a water-hydrogen system, for which we have data, as an example. We then extend our arguments to apply to a system of hydrogen and silicate vapor. We then employ a simple atmospheric model to apply our findings to super-Earths and to make predictions about their internal structures and thermal evolution. For hydrogen envelope masses roughly in the range between 0.1-10% Earth's mass, convective contact between the envelope and core may shut down because of the compositional gradient that arises from silicate partial vaporization. For envelope hydrogen masses that cause the associated basal pressure to exceed the critical pressure of pure silicate (of order a couple kilobars), the base of that envelope and top of the core lie on the critical line of the two-phase hydrogen-silicate phase diagram. The corresponding temperature is much higher than convective models would suggest. The core then cools inefficiently, with intrinsic heat fluxes potentially comparable to the Earth's internal heat flux today. This low heat flux may allow the core to remain in a high entropy supercritical state for billions of years, but the details of this depend on the nature of the two-component phase diagram at high pressure, something that is currently unknown. A supercritical core thermodynamically permits the dissolution of large quantities of hydrogen into the core.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Possible evidence of p-modes in Cassini measurements of Saturn's gravity field
Authors:
Steve Markham,
Daniele Durante,
Luciano Iess,
Dave Stevenson
Abstract:
We analyze the range rate residual data from Cassini's gravity experiment that cannot be explained with a static, zonally symmetric gravity field. In this paper we reproduce the data using a simple forward model of gravity perturbations from normal modes. To do this, we stack data from multiple flybys to improve sensitivity. We find a partially degenerate set of normal mode energy spectra which su…
▽ More
We analyze the range rate residual data from Cassini's gravity experiment that cannot be explained with a static, zonally symmetric gravity field. In this paper we reproduce the data using a simple forward model of gravity perturbations from normal modes. To do this, we stack data from multiple flybys to improve sensitivity. We find a partially degenerate set of normal mode energy spectra which successfully reproduce the unknown gravity signal from Cassini's flybys. Although there is no unique solution, we find that the models most likely to fit the data are dominated by gravitational contributions from p-modes between 500-700uHz. Because f-modes at lower frequencies have stronger gravity signals for a given amplitude, this result would suggest strong frequency dependence in normal mode excitation on Saturn. We predict peak amplitudes for p-modes on the order of several kilometers, at least an order of magnitude larger than the peak amplitudes inferred by Earth-based observations of Jupiter. The large p-mode amplitudes we predict on Saturn, if they are indeed present and steady state, would imply weak dam** with a lower bound of Q>1e7 for these modes, consistent with theoretical predictions.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Constraining the effect of convective inhibition on the thermal evolution of Uranus and Neptune
Authors:
Steve Markham,
Dave Stevenson
Abstract:
The internal heat flows of both Uranus and Neptune remain major outstanding problems in planetary science. Uranus' surprisingly cold effective temperature is inconsistent with adiabatic thermal evolution models, while Neptune's substantial internal heat flow is twice its received insolation. In this work we constrain the magnitude of influence condensation, including latent heat and inhibition of…
▽ More
The internal heat flows of both Uranus and Neptune remain major outstanding problems in planetary science. Uranus' surprisingly cold effective temperature is inconsistent with adiabatic thermal evolution models, while Neptune's substantial internal heat flow is twice its received insolation. In this work we constrain the magnitude of influence condensation, including latent heat and inhibition of convection, can have on the thermal evolution of these bodies. We find that while the effect can be significant, it is insufficient to solve the Uranus faintness problem on its own. Self-consistently considering the effects of both latent heat release and stable stratification, methane condensation can speed up the cool down time of Uranus and Neptune by no more than 15%, assuming 5% molar methane abundance. Water condensation works in the opposite direction; water condensation can slow down the cool down timescale of Uranus and Neptune by no more than 15% assuming 12% molar water abundance. We also constrain the meteorological implications of convective inhibition. We demonstrate that sufficiently abundant condensates will relax to a state of radiative-convective equilibrium requiring finite activation energy to disrupt. We also comment on the importance of considering convective inhibition when modeling planetary interiors.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Excitation Mechanisms for Jovian Seismic Modes
Authors:
Steve Markham,
Dave Stevenson
Abstract:
Recent (2011) results from the Nice Observatory indicate the existence of global seismic modes on Jupiter in the frequency range between 0.7 and 1.5mHz with amplitudes of tens of cm/s. Currently, the driving force behind these modes is a mystery; the measured amplitudes are many orders of magnitude larger than anticipated based on theory analogous to heliosiesmology (that is, turbulent convection…
▽ More
Recent (2011) results from the Nice Observatory indicate the existence of global seismic modes on Jupiter in the frequency range between 0.7 and 1.5mHz with amplitudes of tens of cm/s. Currently, the driving force behind these modes is a mystery; the measured amplitudes are many orders of magnitude larger than anticipated based on theory analogous to heliosiesmology (that is, turbulent convection as a source of stochastic excitation). One of the most promising hypotheses is that these modes are driven by Jovian storms. This work constructs a framework to analytically model the expected equilibrium normal mode amplitudes arising from convective columns in storms. We also place rough constraints on Jupiter's seismic modal quality factor. Using this model, neither meteor strikes, turbulent convection, nor water storms can feasibly excite the order of magnitude of observed amplitudes. Next we speculate about the potential role of rock storms deeper in Jupiter's atmosphere, because the rock storms' expected energy scales make them promising candidates to be the chief source of excitation for Jovian seismic modes, based on simple scaling arguments. We also suggest some general trends in the expected partition of energy between different frequency modes. Finally we supply some commentary on potential applications to gravity, Juno, Cassini and Saturn, and future missions to Uranus and Neptune.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Radial profiles of the Phoebe ring, a vast debris disk around Saturn
Authors:
Daniel Tamayo,
Stephen R. Markham,
Matthew M. Hedman,
Joseph A. Burns,
Douglas P. Hamilton
Abstract:
We present observations at optical wavelengths with the Cassini Spacecraft's Imaging Science System of the Phoebe ring, a vast debris disk around Saturn that seems to be collisionally generated by its irregular satellites. The analysis reveals a radial profile from 80-260 Saturn radii ($R_S$) that changes behavior interior to $\approx 110 R_S$, which we attribute to either the moon Iapetus sweepin…
▽ More
We present observations at optical wavelengths with the Cassini Spacecraft's Imaging Science System of the Phoebe ring, a vast debris disk around Saturn that seems to be collisionally generated by its irregular satellites. The analysis reveals a radial profile from 80-260 Saturn radii ($R_S$) that changes behavior interior to $\approx 110 R_S$, which we attribute to either the moon Iapetus swee** up small particles, or to orbital instabilities that cause the ring to flare up vertically. Our study yields an integrated I/F at 0.635 $μ$m along Saturn's shadow in the Phoebe ring's midplane from 80-250 $R_S$ of $2.7^{+0.9}_{-0.3} \times 10^{-9}$. We develop an analytical model for the size-dependent secular dynamics of retrograde Phoebe ring grains, and compare this model to the observations. This analysis implies that 1) the "Phoebe" ring is partially sourced by debris from irregular satellites beyond Phoebe's orbit and 2) the scattered light signal is dominated by small grains ($\lesssim 20μ$m in size). If we assume that the Phoebe ring is generated through steady-state micrometeoroid bombardment, this implies a power-law size distribution with index $> 4$, which is unusually steep among solar system rings. This suggests either a steep size distribution of ejecta when material is initially released, or a subsequent process that preferentially breaks up large grains.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
