Showing 1–11 of 11 results for author: Khrykin, I S

FLIMFLAM DR1: The First Constraints on the Cosmic Baryon Distribution from 8 FRB sightlines

Authors: Ilya S. Khrykin, Metin Ata, Khee-Gan Lee, Sunil Simha, Yuxin Huang, J. Xavier Prochaska, Nicolas Tejos, Keith W. Bannister, Jeff Cooke, Cherie K. Day, Adam Deller, Marcin Glowacki, Alexa C. Gordon, Clancy W. James, Lachlan Marnoch, Ryan. M. Shannon, Jielai Zhang, Lucas Bernales-Cortes

Abstract: The dispersion measure of fast radio bursts (FRBs), arising from the interactions of the pulses with free electrons along the propagation path, constitutes a unique probe of the cosmic baryon distribution. Their constraining power is further enhanced in combination with observations of the foreground large-scale structure and intervening galaxies. In this work, we present the first constraints on… ▽ More The dispersion measure of fast radio bursts (FRBs), arising from the interactions of the pulses with free electrons along the propagation path, constitutes a unique probe of the cosmic baryon distribution. Their constraining power is further enhanced in combination with observations of the foreground large-scale structure and intervening galaxies. In this work, we present the first constraints on the partition of the cosmic baryons between the intergalactic medium (IGM) and circumgalactic medium (CGM), inferred from the FLIMFLAM spectroscopic survey. In its first data release, the FLIMFLAM survey targeted galaxies in the foreground of 8 localized FRBs. Using Bayesian techniques, we reconstruct the underlying ~Mpc-scale matter density field that is traced by the IGM gas. Simultaneously, deeper spectroscopy of intervening foreground galaxies (at impact parameters $b_\perp \lesssim r_{200}$) and the FRB host galaxies constrains the contribution from the CGM. Applying Bayesian parameter inference to our data and assuming a fiducial set of priors, we infer the IGM cosmic baryon fraction to be $f_{\rm igm}=0.59^{+0.11}_{-0.10}$, and a CGM gas fraction of $f_{\rm gas} = 0.55^{+0.26}_{-0.29}$ for $10^{10}\,M_\odot \lesssim M_{\rm halo}\lesssim 10^{13}\,M_\odot$ halos. The mean FRB host dispersion measure (rest-frame) in our sample is $\langle \rm{DM_{host}}\rangle = 90^{+29}_{-19}\rm{pc~cm^{-3}}$, of which $\langle{\rm DM_{host}^{unk}}\rangle =69^{+28}_{-19}~\rm{pc~cm^{-3}}$ arises from the host galaxy ISM and/or the FRB progenitor environment. While our current $f_{\rm igm}$ and $f_{\rm gas}$ uncertainties are too broad to constrain most galactic feedback models, this result marks the first measurement of the IGM and CGM baryon fractions, as well as the first systematic separation of the FRB host dispersion measure into two components: arising from the halo and from the inner ISM/FRB engine. △ Less

Submitted 1 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: 21 pages, 9 figures, 5 tables; Submitted to ApJ

The Cosmic Baryon Partition between the IGM and CGM in the SIMBA Simulations

Authors: Ilya S. Khrykin, Daniele Sorini, Khee-Gan Lee, Romeel Davé

Abstract: We use the Simba suite of cosmological hydrodynamical simulations to investigate the importance of various stellar and AGN feedback mechanisms in partitioning the cosmic baryons between the intergalactic (IGM) and circumgalactic (CGM) media in the $z\leq 1$ Universe. We identify the AGN jets as the most prominent mechanism for the redistribution of baryons between the IGM and CGM. In contrast to t… ▽ More We use the Simba suite of cosmological hydrodynamical simulations to investigate the importance of various stellar and AGN feedback mechanisms in partitioning the cosmic baryons between the intergalactic (IGM) and circumgalactic (CGM) media in the $z\leq 1$ Universe. We identify the AGN jets as the most prominent mechanism for the redistribution of baryons between the IGM and CGM. In contrast to the full feedback models, deactivating AGN jets results in $\approx20$ per cent drop in fraction of baryons residing in the IGM and a consequent increase of CGM baryon fraction by $\approx 50$ per cent. We find that stellar feedback modifies the partition of baryons on a $10$ per cent level. We further examine the physical properties of simulated haloes in different mass bins, and their response to various feedback models. On average, a sixfold decrease in the CGM mass fraction due to the inclusion of feedback from AGN jets is detected in $10^{12}M_{\odot} \leq M_{\rm 200} \leq 10^{14}M_{\odot}$ haloes. Examination of the average radial gas density profiles of $M_{200} > 10^{12}M_{\odot}$ haloes reveals up to an order of magnitude decrease in gas densities due to the AGN jet feedback. We compare gas density profiles from Simba simulations to the predictions of the modified NFW model, and show that the latter provides a reasonable approximation within the virial radii of the full range of halo masses, but only when rescaled by the appropriate mass-dependent CGM fraction of the halo. The relative partitioning of cosmic baryons and, subsequently, the feedback models can be constrained observationally with fast radio bursts (FRBs) in upcoming surveys. △ Less

Submitted 16 February, 2024; v1 submitted 2 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 12 pages, 4 figures, accepted by MNRAS

The FRB20190520B Sightline Intersects Foreground Galaxy Clusters

Authors: Khee-Gan Lee, Ilya S. Khrykin, Sunil Simha, Metin Ata, Yuxin Huang, J. Xavier Prochaska, Nicolas Tejos, Jeff Cooke, Kentaro Nagamine, Jielai Zhang

Abstract: The repeating fast radio burst FRB20190520B is an anomaly of the FRB population thanks to its high dispersion measure (DM$=1205\,$pc/cc) despite its low redshift of $z_\mathrm{frb}=0.241$. This excess has been attributed to a large host contribution of $DM_{host}\approx 900\,$pc/cc, far larger than any other known FRB. In this paper, we describe spectroscopic observations of the FRB20190520B field… ▽ More The repeating fast radio burst FRB20190520B is an anomaly of the FRB population thanks to its high dispersion measure (DM$=1205\,$pc/cc) despite its low redshift of $z_\mathrm{frb}=0.241$. This excess has been attributed to a large host contribution of $DM_{host}\approx 900\,$pc/cc, far larger than any other known FRB. In this paper, we describe spectroscopic observations of the FRB20190520B field obtained as part of the FLIMFLAM survey, which yielded 701 galaxy redshifts in the field. We find multiple foreground galaxy groups and clusters, for which we then estimated halo masses by comparing their richness with numerical simulations. We discover two separate $M_{halo} >10^{14}\,M_\odot$ galaxy clusters, at $z=0.1867$ and $z=0.2170$, respectively, that are directly intersected by the FRB sightline within their characteristic halo radius \rvir{}. Subtracting off their estimated DM contributions as well that of the diffuse intergalactic medium, we estimate a host contribution of $DM_{host}=430^{+140}_{-220}\,$pc/cc or $DM_{host}=280^{+140}_{-170}\,$pc/cc (observed frame) depending on whether we assume the halo gas extends to $r_{200}$ or $2\times r_{200}$. This significantly smaller $DM_{host}$ -- no longer the largest known value -- is now consistent with H$α$ emission measures of the host galaxy without invoking unusually high gas temperatures. Combined with the observed FRB scattering timescale, we estimate the turbulent fluctuation and geometric amplification factor of the scattering layer to be $\tilde{F} G\approx4.5 - 11\,(\mathrm{pc^2\;km})^{-1/3}$, suggesting most of the gas is close to the FRB host. This result illustrates the importance of incorporating foreground data for FRB analyses, both for understanding the nature of FRBs and to realize their potential as a cosmological probe. △ Less

Submitted 14 August, 2023; v1 submitted 8 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: Accepted by ApJL. Interactive figure included (link in text). Note numerical values have changed from v1

Searching for the sources of excess extragalactic dispersion of FRBs

Authors: Sunil Simha, Khee-Gan Lee, J. Xavier Prochaska, Ilya S. Khrykin, Yuxin Huang, Nicolas Tejos, Lachlan Marnoch, Metin Ata, Lucas Bernales, Shivani Bhandari, Jeff Cooke, Adam T. Deller, Suart Ryder, Jielai Zhang

Abstract: The FLIMFLAM survey is collecting spectroscopic data of field galaxies near fast radio burst (FRB) sightlines to constrain key parameters describing the distribution of matter in the Universe. In this work, we leverage the survey data to determine the source of the excess extragalactic dispersion measure (DM), compared to the Macquart relation estimate of four FRBs: FRB20190714A, FRB20200430A, FRB… ▽ More The FLIMFLAM survey is collecting spectroscopic data of field galaxies near fast radio burst (FRB) sightlines to constrain key parameters describing the distribution of matter in the Universe. In this work, we leverage the survey data to determine the source of the excess extragalactic dispersion measure (DM), compared to the Macquart relation estimate of four FRBs: FRB20190714A, FRB20200430A, FRB20200906A, and FRB20210117A. By modeling the gas distribution around the foreground galaxy halos and galaxy groups of the sightlines, we estimate $\rm DM_{halos}$, their contribution to the FRB dispersion measures. The FRB20190714A sightline shows a clear excess of foreground halos which contribute roughly 2/3$^{rd}$ of the observed excess DM, thus implying a baryon-dense sightline. FRB20200906A shows a smaller but non-negligible foreground halo contribution, and further analysis of the IGM is necessary to ascertain the true cosmic contribution to its DM. RB20200430A and FRB20210117A show negligible foreground contributions, implying a large host galaxy excess and/or progenitor environment excess. △ Less

Submitted 13 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: 14 pages, 6 figures, 3 tables. Data access available here: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1gVVwTAmiHJtFB_GD56hgmDylXHYbOTFS

Constraining the Cosmic Baryon Distribution with Fast Radio Burst Foreground Map**

Authors: Khee-Gan Lee, Metin Ata, Ilya S. Khrykin, Yuxin Huang, J. Xavier Prochaska, Jeff Cooke, Jielai Zhang, Adam Batten

Abstract: The dispersion measures (DM) of fast radio bursts (FRBs) encode the integrated electron density along the line-of-sight, which is typically dominated by the intergalactic medium (IGM) contribution in the case of extragalactic FRBs. In this paper, we show that incorporating wide-field spectroscopic galaxy survey data in the foreground of localized FRBs can significantly improve constraints on the p… ▽ More The dispersion measures (DM) of fast radio bursts (FRBs) encode the integrated electron density along the line-of-sight, which is typically dominated by the intergalactic medium (IGM) contribution in the case of extragalactic FRBs. In this paper, we show that incorporating wide-field spectroscopic galaxy survey data in the foreground of localized FRBs can significantly improve constraints on the partition of diffuse cosmic baryons. Using mock DMs and realistic lightcone galaxy catalogs derived from the Millennium simulation, we define spectroscopic surveys that can be carried out with 4m and 8m-class wide field spectroscopic facilities. On these simulated surveys, we carry out Bayesian density reconstructions in order to estimate the foreground matter density field. In comparison with the `true' matter density field, we show that these can help reduce the uncertainties in the foreground structures by $\sim 2-3\times$ compared to cosmic variance. We calculate the Fisher matrix to forecast that $N=30\: (96)$ localized FRBs should be able to constrain the diffuse cosmic baryon fraction to $\sim 10\%\: (\sim 5\%) $, and parameters governing the size and baryon fraction of galaxy circumgalactic halos to within $\sim 20-25\%\: (\sim 8-12\%)$. From the Fisher analysis, we show that the foreground data increases the sensitivity of localized FRBs toward our parameters of interest by $\sim 25\times$. We briefly introduce FLIMFLAM, an ongoing galaxy redshift survey that aims to obtain foreground data on $\sim 30$ localized FRB fields. △ Less

Submitted 25 January, 2022; v1 submitted 1 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: 27 pages, 12 Figures. Accepted by ApJ

The first measurement of the quasar lifetime distribution

Authors: Ilya S. Khrykin, Joseph F. Hennawi, Gabor Worseck, Frederick B. Davies

Abstract: Understanding the growth of the supermassive black holes powering luminous quasars, their co-evolution with host galaxies, and impact on the surrounding intergalactic medium depends sensitively on the duration of quasar accretion episodes. Unfortunately, this time-scale, known as the quasar lifetime, $t_{\rm Q}$, is still uncertain by orders of magnitude (… ▽ More Understanding the growth of the supermassive black holes powering luminous quasars, their co-evolution with host galaxies, and impact on the surrounding intergalactic medium depends sensitively on the duration of quasar accretion episodes. Unfortunately, this time-scale, known as the quasar lifetime, $t_{\rm Q}$, is still uncertain by orders of magnitude ($t_{\rm Q}\simeq 0.01~{\rm Myr}-1~{\rm Gyr}$). However, the extent of the He II Ly$α$ proximity zones in the absorption spectra of $z_{\rm qso}\sim3-4$ quasars constitutes a unique probe, providing sensitivity to lifetimes up to $\sim 30$ Myr. Our recent analysis of $22$ archival He II proximity zone spectra reveals a surprisingly broad range of emission timescales, indicating that some quasars turned on $\lesssim 1$ Myr ago, whereas others have been shining for $\gtrsim 30$ Myr. Determining the underlying quasar lifetime distribution (QLD) from proximity zone measurements is a challenging task owing to: 1) the limited sensitivity of individual measurements; 2) random sampling of the quasar light curves; 3) density fluctuations in the quasar environment; and 4) the inhomogeneous ionization state of He II in a reionizing IGM. We combine a semi-numerical He II reionization model, hydrodynamical simulations post-processed with ionizing radiative transfer, and a novel statistical framework to infer the QLD from an ensemble of proximity zone measurements. Assuming a log-normal QLD, we infer a mean $\langle {\rm log}_{10}\left(t_{\rm Q}/{\rm Myr}\right)\rangle=0.22^{+0.22}_{-0.25}$ and standard deviation $σ_{{\rm log}_{10}t_{\rm Q}}=0.80^{+0.37}_{-0.27}$. Our results allow us to estimate the probability of detecting young quasars with $t_{\rm Q}\leq0.1$ Myr from their proximity zone sizes yielding $p\left(\leq 0.1~{\rm Myr}\right)=0.19^{+0.11}_{-0.09}$, which is broadly consistent with recent determination at $z\sim 6$. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: 14 pages, 10 figures, submitted to MNRAS

Dating individual quasars with the HeII proximity effect

Authors: Gábor Worseck, Ilya S. Khrykin, Joseph F. Hennawi, J. Xavier Prochaska, Emanuele Paolo Farina

Abstract: Constraints on the time-scales of quasar activity are key to understanding the formation and growth of supermassive black holes (SMBHs), quasar triggering mechanisms, and possible feedback effects on their host galaxies. However, observational estimates of this so-called quasar lifetime are highly uncertain (t_Q~10^4-10^9 yr), because most methods are indirect and involve many model-dependent assu… ▽ More Constraints on the time-scales of quasar activity are key to understanding the formation and growth of supermassive black holes (SMBHs), quasar triggering mechanisms, and possible feedback effects on their host galaxies. However, observational estimates of this so-called quasar lifetime are highly uncertain (t_Q~10^4-10^9 yr), because most methods are indirect and involve many model-dependent assumptions. Direct evidence of earlier activity is gained from the higher ionization state of the intergalactic medium (IGM) in the quasar environs, observable as enhanced Ly$α$ transmission in the so-called proximity zone. Due to the ~30 Myr equilibration time-scale of HeII in the z~3 IGM, the size of the HeII proximity zone depends on the time the quasar had been active before our observation t_on<t_Q, enabling up to $\pm$0.2 dex precise measurements of individual quasar on-times that are comparable to the e-folding time-scale t_S~44 Myr of SMBH growth. Here we present the first statistical sample of 13 quasars whose accurate and precise systemic redshifts allow for measurements of sufficiently precise HeII quasar proximity zone sizes between ~2 and ~15 proper Mpc from science-grade Hubble Space Telescope (HST) spectra. Comparing these sizes to predictions from cosmological hydrodynamical simulations post-processed with one-dimensional radiative transfer, we infer a broad range of quasar on-times from t_on<1 Myr to t_on>30 Myr that does not depend on quasar luminosity, black hole mass, or Eddington ratio. These results point to episodic quasar activity over a long duty cycle, but do not rule out substantial SMBH growth during phases of radiative inefficiency or obscuration. △ Less

Submitted 9 June, 2021; v1 submitted 4 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: 20 pages, 14 figures; accepted for publication in MNRAS

Evidence for Short $\sim 1$ Myr Lifetimes from the He II Proximity Zones of $z \sim 4$ Quasars

Authors: Ilya S. Khrykin, Joseph F. Hennawi, Gabor Worseck

Abstract: The duration of quasar accretion episodes is a key quantity for distinguishing between models for the formation and growth of supermassive black holes, the evolution of quasars, and their potential feedback effects on their host galaxies. However, this critical timescale, often referred to as the quasar lifetime, is still uncertain by orders of magnitude (… ▽ More The duration of quasar accretion episodes is a key quantity for distinguishing between models for the formation and growth of supermassive black holes, the evolution of quasars, and their potential feedback effects on their host galaxies. However, this critical timescale, often referred to as the quasar lifetime, is still uncertain by orders of magnitude ($t_{\rm Q} \simeq 0.01\,{\rm Myr} - 1\,{\rm Gyr}$). Absorption spectra of quasars exhibiting transmission in the He II Ly$α$ forest provide a unique opportunity to make precise measurements of the quasar lifetime. Indeed, the size of a quasar's He II proximity zone, the region near the quasar itself where its own radiation dramatically alters the ionization state of the surrounding intergalactic medium (IGM), depends sensitively on its lifetime for $t_{\rm Q}\lesssim 30$ Myr, comparable to the expected $e$-folding time-scale for SMBH growth $t_{\rm S}=45$ Myr. In this study we compare the sizes of He II proximity zones in the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) spectra of 6 z~4 quasars to theoretical models generated by post-processing cosmological hydrodynamical simulations with $1$D radiative transfer algorithm. We introduce a Bayesian statistical method to infer the lifetimes of individual quasars which allows us to fully marginalize over the unknown ionization state of the surrounding IGM. We measure lifetimes $0.63^{+0.82}_{-0.40}$ Myr and $5.75^{+4.72}_{-2.74}$ Myr for two objects. For the other 4 quasars large redshift uncertainties undermine our sensitivity allowing us to only place upper or lower limits. However a joint analysis of these four systems yields a measurement of their average lifetime of $\langle t_{\rm Q}\rangle = 1.17^{+1.77}_{-0.84}$ Myr. We discuss our short ~1 Myr inferred lifetimes in the context of other quasar lifetime constraints and the growth of SMBHs. △ Less

Submitted 8 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 14 pages, 9 figures, submitted to MNRAS

The Thermal Proximity Effect: A New Probe of He II Reionization History and the Quasar Lifetime

Authors: Ilya S. Khrykin, Joseph F. Hennawi, Matthew McQuinn

Abstract: Despite decades of effort, the timing and duration of He II reionization, as well as its morphology and the properties of the quasars believed to drive it, are still not well constrained. In this paper we present a new method to study both He II reionization and quasars via the thermal proximity effect -- the photoelectric heating of the intergalactic medium around quasars when their hard radiatio… ▽ More Despite decades of effort, the timing and duration of He II reionization, as well as its morphology and the properties of the quasars believed to drive it, are still not well constrained. In this paper we present a new method to study both He II reionization and quasars via the thermal proximity effect -- the photoelectric heating of the intergalactic medium around quasars when their hard radiation doubly ionizes helium. We post-process a SPH simulation with 1D radiative calculations, and study how the thermal proximity effect depends on the amount of singly ionized helium, $x_{\rm HeII,0}$, which prevailed in the IGM before the quasar turned on, and the characteristic lifetime $t_{\rm Q}$ for which quasars shine. We find that the amplitude of the temperature boost in the quasar environment depends on $x_{\rm HeII,0}$, with a characteristic value of $ΔT \simeq 10^4\,{\rm K}$ for an initially singly ionized IGM ($x_{\rm HeII,0} = 1.0$), whereas the size of the thermal proximity zone is sensitive to quasar lifetime $t_{\rm Q}$, with typical sizes of ~100 cMpc for luminous quasars shining for $t_{\rm Q}=10^8$ yr. This temperature boost is manifest as a change in the thermal broadening of H I absorption lines near the quasar. We introduce a new method based on measuring the Ly$α$ forest power spectrum as a function of distance from the quasar, and conduct Bayesian MCMC analysis to demonstrate that the thermal proximity effect should be easily detectable. For a mock dataset of 50 quasars at z~4, we predict that one can measure $x_{\rm HeII,0}$ to a precision $\approx 0.04$, and $t_{\rm Q}$ to a precision of $\approx 0.1$ dex. By applying our formalism to existing high-resolution Ly$α$ forest spectra of quasars at $3.1 \lesssim z \lesssim 5.0$, one should be able to detect the thermal proximity effect, and reconstruct the full reionization history of He II. △ Less

Submitted 27 March, 2017; v1 submitted 17 November, 2016; originally announced November 2016.

Comments: 23 pages, 16 Figures, accepted to ApJ, two sections and one figure added

He II Proximity Effect and the Lifetime of Quasars

Authors: I. S. Khrykin, J. F. Hennawi, M. McQuinn, G. Worseck

Abstract: The lifetime of quasars is fundamental for understanding the growth of supermassive black holes, and is an important ingredient in models of the reionization of the intergalactic medium. However, despite various attempts to determine quasar lifetimes, current estimates from a variety of methods are uncertain by orders of magnitude. This work combines cosmological hydrodynamical simulations and 1D… ▽ More The lifetime of quasars is fundamental for understanding the growth of supermassive black holes, and is an important ingredient in models of the reionization of the intergalactic medium. However, despite various attempts to determine quasar lifetimes, current estimates from a variety of methods are uncertain by orders of magnitude. This work combines cosmological hydrodynamical simulations and 1D radiative transfer to investigate the structure and evolution of the He II Ly$α$ proximity zones around quasars at $z \simeq 3-4$. We show that the time evolution in the proximity zone can be described by a simple analytical model for the approach of the He II fraction $x_{\rm HeII}\left( t \right)$ to ionization equilibrium, and use this picture to illustrate how the transmission profile depends on the quasar lifetime, quasar UV luminosity, and the ionization state of helium in the ambient IGM (i.e. the average He II fraction, or equivalently the metagalactic He II ionizing background). A significant degeneracy exists between the lifetime and the average He II fraction, however the latter can be determined from measurements of the He II Ly$α$ optical depth far from quasars, allowing the lifetime to be measured. We advocate stacking existing He II quasar spectra at $z\sim 3$, and show that the shape of this average proximity zone profile is sensitive to lifetimes as long as $\sim 30$ Myr. At higher redshift $z\sim 4$ where the He II fraction is poorly constrained, degeneracies will make it challenging to determine these parameters independently. Our analytical model for He II proximity zones should also provide a useful description of the properties of H I proximity zones around quasars at $z \simeq 6-7$. △ Less

Submitted 2 June, 2016; v1 submitted 11 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: 26 pages, 18 figures, accepted to ApJ

Global Gravitationally-Organized Spiral Waves and the Structure of NGC 5247

Authors: S. A. Khoperskov, A. V. Khoperskov, I. S. Khrykin, V. I. Korchagin, D. I. Casetti-Dinescu, T. Girard, W. van Altena, D. Maitra

Abstract: Using observational data, we build numerical N-body, hydrodynamical and combined equilibrium models for the spiral galaxy NGC 5247. The models turn out to be unstable towards spiral structure formation. We simulate scenarios of spiral structure formation for different sets of equilibrium rotation curves, radial velocity dispersion profiles and disk thickness and demonstrate that in all cases a sim… ▽ More Using observational data, we build numerical N-body, hydrodynamical and combined equilibrium models for the spiral galaxy NGC 5247. The models turn out to be unstable towards spiral structure formation. We simulate scenarios of spiral structure formation for different sets of equilibrium rotation curves, radial velocity dispersion profiles and disk thickness and demonstrate that in all cases a simulated spiral pattern qualitatively agrees with the observed morphology of NGC 5247. We also demonstrate that an admixture of a gaseous component with mass of about a few percent of the total mass of the disk increases a lifetime of a spiral pattern by approximately 30%. The simulated spiral pattern in this case lasts for about 3 Gyr from the beginning of the growth of perturbations. △ Less

Submitted 13 September, 2012; originally announced September 2012.

Comments: 14 pages, 21 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS