-
Kaleidoscope of irradiated disks: MUSE observations of proplyds in the Orion Nebula Cluster. I. Sample presentation and ionization front sizes
Authors:
Mari-Liis Aru,
Karina Mauco,
Carlo F. Manara,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Stefano Facchini,
Anna F. McLeod,
Anna Miotello,
Monika G. Petr-Gotzens,
Massimo Robberto,
Giovanni P. Rosotti,
Silvia Vicente,
Andrew Winter,
Megan Ansdell
Abstract:
In the Orion Nebula Cluster (ONC), protoplanetary disks exhibit ionized gas clouds in the form of a striking teardrop shape as massive stars irradiate the disk material. We present the first spatially and spectrally resolved observations of 12 proplyds, using Integral Field Spectroscopy observations performed with the MUSE instrument in Narrow Field Mode (NFM) on the VLT. We present the morphology…
▽ More
In the Orion Nebula Cluster (ONC), protoplanetary disks exhibit ionized gas clouds in the form of a striking teardrop shape as massive stars irradiate the disk material. We present the first spatially and spectrally resolved observations of 12 proplyds, using Integral Field Spectroscopy observations performed with the MUSE instrument in Narrow Field Mode (NFM) on the VLT. We present the morphology of the proplyds in seven emission lines and measure the radius of the ionization front (I-front) of the targets in four tracers, covering transitions of different ionization states for the same element. We also derive stellar masses for the targets. The measurements follow a consistent trend of increasing I-front radius for a decreasing strength of the far-UV radiation as expected from photoevaporation models. By analyzing the ratios of the I-front radii as measured in the emission lines of Ha, [OI] 6300, [OII] 7330, and [OIII] 5007, we observe the ionization stratification, that is, the most ionized part of the flow being the furthest from the disk (and closest to the UV source). The ratios of I-front radii scale in the same way for all proplyds in our sample regardless of the incident radiation. We show that the stratification can help constrain the densities near the I-front by using a 1D photoionization model. We derive the upper limits of photoevaporative mass-loss rates by assuming ionization equilibrium, and estimate values decreasing towards lower im**ing radiation. We do not find a correlation between Mloss and stellar mass. The highest mass-loss rate is for the proplyd 244-440. These values of Mloss, combined with estimates of the disk mass with ALMA, confirm previous estimates of the short lifetime of these proplyds. This work demonstrates the potential of this dataset and offers a new set of observables to be used to test current and future models of external photoevaporation.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2024; v1 submitted 19 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
A far-ultraviolet-driven photoevaporation flow observed in a protoplanetary disk
Authors:
Olivier Berné,
Emilie Habart,
Els Peeters,
Ilane Schroetter,
Amélie Canin,
Ameek Sidhu,
Ryan Chown,
Emeric Bron,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Pamela Klaassen,
Boris Trahin,
Dries Van De Putte,
Felipe Alarcón,
Marion Zannese,
Alain Abergel,
Edwin A. Bergin,
Jeronimo Bernard-Salas,
Christiaan Boersma,
Jan Cami,
Sara Cuadrado,
Emmanuel Dartois,
Daniel Dicken,
Meriem Elyajouri,
Asunción Fuente,
Javier R. Goicoechea
, et al. (121 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Most low-mass stars form in stellar clusters that also contain massive stars, which are sources of far-ultraviolet (FUV) radiation. Theoretical models predict that this FUV radiation produces photo-dissociation regions (PDRs) on the surfaces of protoplanetary disks around low-mass stars, impacting planet formation within the disks. We report JWST and Atacama Large Millimetere Array observations of…
▽ More
Most low-mass stars form in stellar clusters that also contain massive stars, which are sources of far-ultraviolet (FUV) radiation. Theoretical models predict that this FUV radiation produces photo-dissociation regions (PDRs) on the surfaces of protoplanetary disks around low-mass stars, impacting planet formation within the disks. We report JWST and Atacama Large Millimetere Array observations of a FUV-irradiated protoplanetary disk in the Orion Nebula. Emission lines are detected from the PDR; modelling their kinematics and excitation allows us to constrain the physical conditions within the gas. We quantify the mass-loss rate induced by the FUV irradiation, finding it is sufficient to remove gas from the disk in less than a million years. This is rapid enough to affect giant planet formation in the disk.
△ Less
Submitted 29 February, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
High-resolution ALMA observations of compact discs in the wide-binary system Sz 65 and Sz 66
Authors:
J. M. Miley,
J. Carpenter,
R. Booth,
J. Jennings,
T. J. Haworth,
M. Vioque,
S. Andrews,
D. Wilner,
M. Benisty,
J. Huang,
L. Perez,
V. Guzman,
L. Ricci,
A. Isella
Abstract:
Substructures in disc density are ubiquitous in the bright extended discs that are observed with high resolution. These substructures are intimately linked to the physical mechanisms driving planet formation and disc evolution. Surveys of star-forming regions find that most discs are in fact compact, less luminous, and do not exhibit these same substructures. It remains unclear whether compact dis…
▽ More
Substructures in disc density are ubiquitous in the bright extended discs that are observed with high resolution. These substructures are intimately linked to the physical mechanisms driving planet formation and disc evolution. Surveys of star-forming regions find that most discs are in fact compact, less luminous, and do not exhibit these same substructures. It remains unclear whether compact discs also have similar substructures or if they are featureless. This suggests that different planet formation and disc evolution mechanisms operate in these discs. We investigated evidence of substructure within two compact discs around the stars Sz 65 and Sz 66 using high angular resolution observations with ALMA at 1.3 mm. The two stars form a wide-binary system with 6.36 arcsec separation. The continuum observations achieve a synthesised beam major axis of 0.026 arcsec, equivalent to about 4.0 au, enabling a search for substructure on these spatial scales and a characterisation of the gas and dust disc sizes with high precision. We analysed the data in the image plane through an analysis of reconstructed images, as well as in the uv plane by modelling the visibilities and by an analysis of the 12CO emission line. Comparisons were made with high-resolution observations of compact discs and radially extended discs. We find evidence of substructure in the dust distribution of Sz 65, namely a shallow gap centred at approximately 20 au, with an emission ring exterior to it. Ninety percent of the measured continuum flux is found within 27 au, and the distance for 12CO is 142 au. The observations show that Sz 66 is very compact: 90 per cent of the continuum flux is contained within 16 au, and 48 au for the gas. While the overall prevalence and diversity of substructure in compact discs relative to larger discs is yet to be determined, we find evidence that substructures can exist in compact discs.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2024; v1 submitted 2 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
The Molecular Cloud Lifecycle II: Formation and Destruction of Molecular Clouds Diagnosed via H$_2$ Fluorescent Emission Emission
Authors:
Blakesley Burkhart,
Shmuel Bialy,
Daniel Seifried,
Stefanie Walch,
Erika Hamden,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Keri Hoadley,
Shuo Kong,
Madisen Johnson,
Sarah Jeffreson,
Mark R. Krumholz,
Min-Young Lee,
Amiel Sternberg,
Neal J. Turner
Abstract:
Molecular hydrogen (H$_2$) formation and dissociation are key processes that drive the gas lifecycle in galaxies. Using the SImulating the LifeCycle of Molecular Clouds (SILCC) zoom-in simulation suite, we explore the utility of future observations of H$_2$ dissociation and formation for tracking the lifecycle of molecular clouds. The simulations used in this work include non-equilibrium H$_2$ for…
▽ More
Molecular hydrogen (H$_2$) formation and dissociation are key processes that drive the gas lifecycle in galaxies. Using the SImulating the LifeCycle of Molecular Clouds (SILCC) zoom-in simulation suite, we explore the utility of future observations of H$_2$ dissociation and formation for tracking the lifecycle of molecular clouds. The simulations used in this work include non-equilibrium H$_2$ formation, stellar radiation, sink particles, and turbulence. We find that, at early times in the cloud evolution, H$_2$ formation rapidly outpaces dissociation and molecular clouds build their mass from the atomic reservoir in their environment. Rapid H$_2$ formation is also associated with a higher early star formation rate. For the clouds studied here, H$_2$ is strongly out of chemical equilibrium during the early stages of cloud formation but settles into a bursty chemical steady-state about 2 Myrs after the first stars form. At the latest stage of cloud evolution, dissociation outweighs formation and the clouds enter a dispersal phase. We discuss how theories for the molecular cloud lifecycle and the star formation efficiency may be distinguished with observational measurements of H$_2$ fluorescence with a space-based high-resolution FUV spectrometer, such as the proposed Hyperion and Eos NASA Explorer missions. Such missions would enable measurements of the H$_2$ dissociation and formation rates, which we demonstrate can be connected to different phases in a molecular cloud's star-forming life, including cloud building, rapidly star-forming, H$_2$ chemical equilibrium, and cloud destruction.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2024; v1 submitted 2 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Photoevaporation obfuscates the distinction between wind and viscous angular momentum transport in protoplanetary discs
Authors:
Gavin A. L. Coleman,
Joseph K. Mroueh,
Thomas J. Haworth
Abstract:
How protoplanetary discs evolve remains an unanswered question. Competing theories of viscosity and magnetohydrodynamic disc winds have been put forward as the drivers of angular momentum transport in protoplanetary discs. These two models predict distinct differences in the disc mass, radius and accretion rates over time, that could be used to distinguish them. However that expectation is built o…
▽ More
How protoplanetary discs evolve remains an unanswered question. Competing theories of viscosity and magnetohydrodynamic disc winds have been put forward as the drivers of angular momentum transport in protoplanetary discs. These two models predict distinct differences in the disc mass, radius and accretion rates over time, that could be used to distinguish them. However that expectation is built on models that do not include another important process - photoevaporation, both internally by the host star and externally by neighbouring stars. In this work we produce numerical models of protoplanetary discs including viscosity, magnetohydrodynamic disc winds, and internal and external photoevaporation. We find that even weak levels of external photoevaporation can significantly affect the evolution of protoplanetary discs, influencing the observable features such as disc radii, that might otherwise distinguish between viscous and wind driven discs. Including internal photoevaporation further suppresses differences in evolution between viscous and wind driven discs. This makes it much more difficult than previously anticipated, to use observations of nearby star forming regions to determine whether discs are viscous or wind driven. Interestingly we find that evolved protoplanetary discs in intermediate FUV environments may be the best cases for differentiating whether they evolve through viscosity or magnetohydrodynamic disc winds. Ultimately this work demonstrates the importance of understanding what are the key evolutionary processes and including as many of those as possible when exploring the evolution of protoplanetary discs.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2023; v1 submitted 27 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
The external photoevaporation of structured protoplanetary disks
Authors:
Matías Gárate,
Paola Pinilla,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Stefano Facchini
Abstract:
The dust in planet-forming disks evolve rapidly through growth and radial drift, and external photoevaporation also contributes to this evolution in massive star-forming regions. We test whether the presence of substructures can explain the survival of the dust component and observed millimeter continuum emission in protoplanetary disks located within massive star-forming regions. We also characte…
▽ More
The dust in planet-forming disks evolve rapidly through growth and radial drift, and external photoevaporation also contributes to this evolution in massive star-forming regions. We test whether the presence of substructures can explain the survival of the dust component and observed millimeter continuum emission in protoplanetary disks located within massive star-forming regions. We also characterize the dust content removed by the photoevaporative winds. For this, we performed hydrodynamical simulations of protoplanetary disks subject to irradiation fields of $F_{UV} = 10^2$, $10^3$, and $10^4\, G_0$, with different dust trap locations. We used the FRIED grid to derive the mass loss rate for each irradiation field and disk properties, and then measure the evolution of the dust mass over time. For each simulation we estimate continuum emission at $λ= 1.3\, \textrm{mm}$ along with the radii encompassing $90\%$ of the continuum flux, and characterize the dust size distribution entrained in the photoevaporative winds, along with the resulting far-ultraviolet (FUV) cross section. Our simulations show that the presence of dust traps can extend the lifetime of the dust component of the disk to a few millionyears if the FUV irradiation is $F_{UV} \lesssim 10^3 G_0$, but only if the dust traps are located inside the photoevaporative truncation radius. The dust component of a disk quickly disperse if the FUV irradiation is strong ($10^4\, G_0$) or if the substructures are located outside the photoevaporation radius. We do find however, that the dust grains entrained with the photoevaporative winds may result in an absorption FUV cross section of $σ\approx 10^{-22}\, \textrm{cm}^2$ at early times of evolution ($<$0.1 Myr), which is enough to trigger a self-shielding effect that reduces the total mass loss rate, and slow down the disk dispersal in a negative feedback loop process.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Illuminating evaporating protostellar outflows: ERIS/SPIFFIER reveals the dissociation and ionization of HH 900
Authors:
Megan Reiter,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Carlo F. Manara,
Suzanne Ramsay,
Pamela D. Klaassen,
Dominika Itrich,
Anna F. McLeod
Abstract:
Protostellar jets and outflows are signposts of active star formation. In H II regions, molecular tracers like CO only reveal embedded portions of the outflow. Outside the natal cloud, outflows are dissociated, ionized, and eventually completely ablated, leaving behind only the high-density jet core. Before this process is complete, there should be a phase where the outflow is partially molecular…
▽ More
Protostellar jets and outflows are signposts of active star formation. In H II regions, molecular tracers like CO only reveal embedded portions of the outflow. Outside the natal cloud, outflows are dissociated, ionized, and eventually completely ablated, leaving behind only the high-density jet core. Before this process is complete, there should be a phase where the outflow is partially molecular and partially ionized. In this paper, we capture the HH 900 outflow while this process is in action. New observations from the ERIS/SPIFFIER near-IR integral field unit (IFU) spectrograph using the K-middle filter ($λ$=2.06-2.34 $μ$m) reveal H$_2$ emission from the dissociating outflow and Br-$γ$ tracing its ionized skin. Both lines trace the wide-angle outflow morphology but H$_2$ only extends $\sim$5000 au into the H II region while Br-$γ$ extends the full length of the outflow ($\sim$12,650 au), indicating rapid dissociation of the molecules. H$_2$ has higher velocities further from the driving source, consistent with a jet-driven outflow. Diagnostic line ratios indicate that photoexcitation, not just shocks, contributes to the excitation in the outflow. We argue that HH 900 is the first clear example of an evaporating molecular outflow and predict that a large column of neutral material that may be detectable with ALMA accompanies the dissociating molecules. Results from this study will help guide the interpretation of near-IR images of externally irradiated jets and outflows such as those obtained with the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) in high-mass star-forming regions where these conditions may be common.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
XUE. Molecular inventory in the inner region of an extremely irradiated Protoplanetary Disk
Authors:
María Claudia Ramirez-Tannus,
Arjan Bik,
Lars Cuijpers,
Rens Waters,
Christiane Goppl,
Thomas Henning,
Inga Kamp,
Thomas Preibisch,
Konstantin V. Getman,
Germán Chaparro,
Pablo Cuartas-Restrepo,
Alex de Koter,
Eric D. Feigelson,
Sierra L. Grant,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Sebastián Hernández,
Michael A. Kuhn,
Giulia Perotti,
Matthew S. Povich,
Megan Reiter,
Veronica Roccatagliata,
Elena Sabbi,
Benoît Tabone,
Andrew J. Winter,
Anna F. McLeod
, et al. (2 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present the first results of the eXtreme UV Environments (XUE) James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) program, that focuses on the characterization of planet forming disks in massive star forming regions. These regions are likely representative of the environment in which most planetary systems formed. Understanding the impact of environment on planet formation is critical in order to gain insights…
▽ More
We present the first results of the eXtreme UV Environments (XUE) James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) program, that focuses on the characterization of planet forming disks in massive star forming regions. These regions are likely representative of the environment in which most planetary systems formed. Understanding the impact of environment on planet formation is critical in order to gain insights into the diversity of the observed exoplanet populations. XUE targets 15 disks in three areas of NGC 6357, which hosts numerous massive OB stars, among which some of the most massive stars in our Galaxy. Thanks to JWST we can, for the first time, study the effect of external irradiation on the inner ($< 10$ au), terrestrial-planet forming regions of proto-planetary disks. In this study, we report on the detection of abundant water, CO, CO$_2$, HCN and C$_2$H$_2$ in the inner few au of XUE 1, a highly irradiated disk in NGC 6357. In addition, small, partially crystalline silicate dust is present at the disk surface. The derived column densities, the oxygen-dominated gas-phase chemistry, and the presence of silicate dust are surprisingly similar to those found in inner disks located in nearby, relatively isolated low-mass star-forming regions. Our findings imply that the inner regions of highly irradiated disks can retain similar physical and chemical conditions as disks in low-mass star-forming regions, thus broadening the range of environments with similar conditions for inner disk rocky planet formation to the most extreme star-forming regions in our Galaxy.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2023; v1 submitted 17 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
FRIED v2. A new grid of mass loss rates for externally irradiated protoplanetary discs
Authors:
Thomas J. Haworth,
Gavin A. L. Coleman,
Lin Qiao,
Andrew D. Sellek,
Kanaar Askari
Abstract:
We present a new FRIED grid of mass loss rates for externally far-ultraviolet (FUV) irradiated protoplanetary discs. As a precursor to the new grid, we also explore the microphysics of external photoevaporation, determining the impact of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) abundance, metallicity, coolant depletion (via freeze out and radial drift) and grain growth (depletion of small dust in the…
▽ More
We present a new FRIED grid of mass loss rates for externally far-ultraviolet (FUV) irradiated protoplanetary discs. As a precursor to the new grid, we also explore the microphysics of external photoevaporation, determining the impact of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) abundance, metallicity, coolant depletion (via freeze out and radial drift) and grain growth (depletion of small dust in the outer disc) on disc mass loss rates. We find that metallicity variations typically have a small effect on the mass loss rate, since the impact of changes in heating, cooling and optical depth to the disc approximately cancel out. The new FRIED grid therefore focuses on i) expanding the basic physical parameter space (disc mass, radius, UV field, stellar mass) ii) on enabling variation of the the PAH abundance and iii) including an option for grain growth to have occurred or not in the disc. What we suggest is the fiducial model is comparable to the original FRIED grid. When the PAH-to-dust ratio is lower, or the dust in the wind more abundant, the mass loss rate can be substantially lower. We demonstrate with a small set of illustrative disc evolutionary calculations that this in turn can have a significant impact on the disc mass/radius/ evolution and lifetime.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Thermodynamic limits on oxygenic photosynthesis around M-dwarf stars: Generalized models and strategies for optimization
Authors:
Samir Chitnavis,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Edward Gillen,
Conrad W. Mullineaux,
Christopher D. P. Duffy
Abstract:
We explore the feasibility and potential characteristics of photosynthetic light-harvesting on exo-planets orbiting in the habitable zone of low mass stars ($< 1$ M$_{\odot}$). As stellar temperature, $T_{s}$, decreases, the irradiance maximum red-shifts out of the $400 \textrm{nm} \leq λ< 750$ nm range of wavelengths that can be utilized by \emph{oxygenic} photosynthesis on Earth. However, limite…
▽ More
We explore the feasibility and potential characteristics of photosynthetic light-harvesting on exo-planets orbiting in the habitable zone of low mass stars ($< 1$ M$_{\odot}$). As stellar temperature, $T_{s}$, decreases, the irradiance maximum red-shifts out of the $400 \textrm{nm} \leq λ< 750$ nm range of wavelengths that can be utilized by \emph{oxygenic} photosynthesis on Earth. However, limited irradiance in this region does not preclude oxygenic photosynthesis and Earth's plants, algae and cyanobacteria all possess very efficient \emph{light-harvesting antennae} that facilitate photosynthesis in very low light. Here we construct general models of photosynthetic light-harvesting structures to determine how an oxygenic photosystem would perform in different irradiant spectral fluxes. We illustrate that the process of light-harvesting, capturing energy over a large antenna and concentrating it into a small \emph{reaction centre}, must overcome a fundamental \emph{entropic barrier}. We show that a plant-like antenna cannot be adapted to the light from stars of $T_{s}<3400$ K, as increasing antenna size offers diminishing returns on light-harvesting. This can be overcome if one introduces a slight \emph{enthalpic gradient}, to the antenna. Interestingly, this strategy appears to have been adopted by Earth's oxygenic cyanobacteria, and we conclude that \emph{bacterial} oxygenic photosynthesis is feasible around even the lowest mass M-dwarf stars.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Testing external photoevaporation in the $σ$-Orionis cluster with spectroscopy and disk mass measurements
Authors:
K. Maucó,
C. F. Manara,
M. Ansdell,
G. Bettoni,
R. Claes,
J. Alcala,
A. Miotello,
S. Facchini,
T. J. Haworth,
G. Lodato,
J. P. Williams
Abstract:
The evolution of protoplanetary disks is regulated by an interplay of several processes, either internal to the system or related to the environment. As most of the stars and planets have formed in massive stellar clusters, studying the effects of UV radiation on disk evolution is of paramount importance. Here we test the impact of external photoevaporation on the evolution of disks in the $σ$ Ori…
▽ More
The evolution of protoplanetary disks is regulated by an interplay of several processes, either internal to the system or related to the environment. As most of the stars and planets have formed in massive stellar clusters, studying the effects of UV radiation on disk evolution is of paramount importance. Here we test the impact of external photoevaporation on the evolution of disks in the $σ$ Orionis cluster by conducting the first combined large-scale UV to IR spectroscopic and mm-continuum survey of this region. We study a sample of 50 targets located at increasing distances from the central, OB system $σ$ Ori. We combine new VLT/X-Shooter spectra with new and previously published ALMA measurements of disk dust and gas fluxes and masses. We confirm the previously found decrease of $M_{\rm dust}$ in the inner $\sim$0.5 pc of the cluster. This is particularly evident when considering the disks around the more massive stars ($\ge$ 0.4 $M_{\odot}$), where those located in the inner part ($<$ 0.5 pc) have $M_{\rm dust}$ about an order of magnitude lower than the more distant ones. About half of the sample is located in the region of the $\dot{M}_{\rm acc}$ vs $M_{\rm disk}$ expected by models of external photoevaporation, namely showing shorter disk lifetimes. These are observed for all targets with projected separation from $σ$ Ori $<$ 0.5 pc, proving that the presence of a massive stellar system affects disk evolution. External photoevaporation is a viable mechanism to explain the observed shorter disk lifetimes and lower $M_{\rm dust}$ in the inner $\sim$0.5 pc of the cluster. Follow-up observations of the low stellar mass targets are crucial to confirm the dependence of the external photoevaporation process with stellar host mass. This work confirms that the effects of external photoevaporation are significant down to im**ing radiation as low as $\sim 10^{4}$ G$_0$.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
The VLT MUSE NFM view of outflows and externally photoevaporating discs near the Orion Bar
Authors:
Thomas J. Haworth,
Megan Reiter,
C. Robert O'Dell,
Peter Zeidler,
Olivier Berne,
Carlo F. Manara,
Giulia Ballabio,
**young S. Kim,
John Bally,
Javier R. Goicoechea,
Mari-Liis Aru,
Aashish Gupta,
Anna Miotello
Abstract:
We present VLT/MUSE Narrow Field Mode (NFM) observations of a pair of disc-bearing young stellar objects towards the Orion Bar: 203-504 and 203-506. Both of these discs are subject to external photoevaporation, where winds are launched from their outer regions due to environmental irradiation. Intriguingly, despite having projected separation from one another of only 1.65{\arcsec} (660au at 400pc)…
▽ More
We present VLT/MUSE Narrow Field Mode (NFM) observations of a pair of disc-bearing young stellar objects towards the Orion Bar: 203-504 and 203-506. Both of these discs are subject to external photoevaporation, where winds are launched from their outer regions due to environmental irradiation. Intriguingly, despite having projected separation from one another of only 1.65{\arcsec} (660au at 400pc), 203-504 has a classic teardrop shaped ``proplyd'' morphology pointing towards $θ^2$Ori A (indicating irradiation by the EUV of that star, rather than $θ^1$ Ori C) but 203-506 has no ionisation front, indicating it is not irradiated by stellar EUV at all. However, 203-506 does show [CI] 8727Å and [OI] 6300Å in emission, indicating irradiation by stellar FUV. This explicitly demonstrates the importance of FUV irradiation in driving mass loss from discs. We conclude that shielding of 203-506 from EUV is most likely due to its position on the observers side of an ionized layer lying in the foreground of the Huygens Region. We demonstrate that the outflow HH 519, previously thought to be emanating from 203-504 is actually an irradiated cloud edge and identify a new compact outflow from that object approximately along our line of sight with a velocity $\sim130$\,km\,s$^{-1}$.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Isolating Dust and Free-Free Emission in ONC Proplyds with ALMA Band 3 Observations
Authors:
Nicholas P. Ballering,
L. Ilsedore Cleeves,
Thomas J. Haworth,
John Bally,
Josh A. Eisner,
Adam Ginsburg,
Ryan D. Boyden,
Min Fang,
**young Serena Kim
Abstract:
The Orion Nebula Cluster (ONC) hosts protoplanetary disks experiencing external photoevaporation by the cluster's intense UV field. These ``proplyds" are comprised of a disk surrounded by an ionization front. We present ALMA Band 3 (3.1 mm) continuum observations of 12 proplyds. Thermal emission from the dust disks and free-free emission from the ionization fronts are both detected, and the high-r…
▽ More
The Orion Nebula Cluster (ONC) hosts protoplanetary disks experiencing external photoevaporation by the cluster's intense UV field. These ``proplyds" are comprised of a disk surrounded by an ionization front. We present ALMA Band 3 (3.1 mm) continuum observations of 12 proplyds. Thermal emission from the dust disks and free-free emission from the ionization fronts are both detected, and the high-resolution (0.057") of the observations allows us to spatially isolate these two components. The morphology is unique compared to images at shorter (sub)millimeter wavelengths, which only detect the disks, and images at longer centimeter wavelengths, which only detect the ionization fronts. The disks are small ($r_d$ = 6.4--38 au), likely due to truncation by ongoing photoevaporation. They have low spectral indices ($α\lesssim 2.1$) measured between Bands 7 and 3, suggesting the dust emission is optically thick. They harbor tens of Earth masses of dust as computed from the millimeter flux using the standard method, although their true masses may be larger due to the high optical depth. We derive their photoevaporative mass-loss rates in two ways: first, by invoking ionization equilibrium, and second using the brightness of the free-free emission to compute the density of the outflow. We find decent agreement between these measurements and $\dot M$ = 0.6--18.4 $\times$ 10$^{-7}$ $M_\odot$ yr$^{-1}$. The photoevaporation timescales are generally shorter than the $\sim$1 Myr age of the ONC, underscoring the known ``proplyd lifetime problem." Disk masses that are underestimated due to being optically thick remains one explanation to ease this discrepancy.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Photosynthesis Under a Red Sun: Predicting the absorption characteristics of an extraterrestrial light-harvesting antenna
Authors:
Christopher D. P. Duffy,
Gregoire Canchon,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Edward Gillen,
Samir Chitnavis,
Conrad W. Mullineaux
Abstract:
Here we discuss the feasibility of photosynthesis on Earth-like rocky planets in close orbit around ultra-cool red dwarf stars. Stars of this type have very limited emission in the \textit{photosynthetically active} region of the spectrum ($400 - 700$ nm), suggesting that they may not be able to support oxygenic photosynthesis. However, photoautotrophs on Earth frequently exploit very dim environm…
▽ More
Here we discuss the feasibility of photosynthesis on Earth-like rocky planets in close orbit around ultra-cool red dwarf stars. Stars of this type have very limited emission in the \textit{photosynthetically active} region of the spectrum ($400 - 700$ nm), suggesting that they may not be able to support oxygenic photosynthesis. However, photoautotrophs on Earth frequently exploit very dim environments with the aid of highly structured and extremely efficient antenna systems. Moreover, the anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria, which do not need to oxidize water to source electrons, can exploit far red and near infrared light. Here we apply a simple model of a photosynthetic antenna to a range of model stellar spectra, ranging from ultra-cool (2300 K) to Sun-like (5800 K). We assume that a photosynthetic organism will evolve an antenna that maximizes the rate of energy input while also minimizing fluctuations. The latter is the 'noise cancelling' principle recently reported by Arp et al. 2020. Applied to the Solar spectrum this predicts optimal antenna configurations in agreement with the chlorophyll Soret absorption bands. Applied to cooler stars, the optimal antenna peaks become redder with decreasing stellar temperature, crossing to the typical wavelength ranges associated with anoxygenic photoautotrophs at $\sim 3300$ K. Lastly, we compare the relative input power delivered by antennae of equivalent size around different stars and find that the predicted variation is within the same order of magnitude. We conclude that low-mass stars do not automatically present light-limiting conditions for photosynthesis but they may select for anoxygenic organisms.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Planet formation via pebble accretion in externally photoevaporating discs
Authors:
Lin Qiao,
Gavin A. L. Coleman,
Thomas J. Haworth
Abstract:
We demonstrate that planet formation via pebble accretion is sensitive to external photoevaporation of the outer disc. In pebble accretion, planets grow by accreting from a flux of solids (pebbles) that radially drift inwards from the pebble production front. If external photoevaporation truncates the outer disc fast enough, it can shorten the time before the pebble production front reaches the di…
▽ More
We demonstrate that planet formation via pebble accretion is sensitive to external photoevaporation of the outer disc. In pebble accretion, planets grow by accreting from a flux of solids (pebbles) that radially drift inwards from the pebble production front. If external photoevaporation truncates the outer disc fast enough, it can shorten the time before the pebble production front reaches the disc outer edge, cutting off the supply of pebble flux for accretion, hence limiting the pebble mass reservoir for planet growth. Conversely, cloud shielding can protect the disc from strong external photoevaporation and preserve the pebble reservoir. Because grain growth and drift can occur quickly, shielding even on a short time-scale (<1 Myr) can have a non-linear impact on the properties of planets growing by pebble accretion. For example a $10^{-3} M_\oplus$ planetary seed at 25 au stays at 25 au with a lunar mass if the disc is immediately irradiated by a $10^3$ G$_0$ field, but grows and migrates to be approximately Earth-like in both mass and orbital radius if the disc is shielded for just 1 Myr. In NGC 2024, external photoevaporation is thought to happen to discs that are <0.5 Myr old, which coupled with the results here suggests that the exact planetary parameters can be very sensitive to the star forming environment. Universal shielding for time-scales of at least $\sim1.5$ Myr would be required to completely nullify the environmental impact on planetary architectures.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Hyperion: The origin of the stars A far-UV space telescope for high-resolution spectroscopy over wide fields
Authors:
Erika Hamden,
David Schiminovich,
Shouleh Nikzad,
Neal J. Turner,
Blakesley Burkhart,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Keri Hoadley,
**young Serena Kim,
Shmuel Bialyh,
Geoff Bryden,
Haeun Chung,
Nia Imara,
Rob Kennicutt,
Jorge Pineda,
Shuo Konga,
Yasuhiro Hasegawa,
Ilaria Pascucci,
Benjamin Godard,
Mark Krumholz,
Min-Young Lee,
Daniel Seifried,
Amiel Sternberg,
Stefanie Walch,
Miles Smith,
Stephen C. Unwin
, et al. (8 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present Hyperion, a mission concept recently proposed to the December 2021 NASA Medium Explorer announcement of opportunity. Hyperion explores the formation and destruction of molecular clouds and planet-forming disks in nearby star-forming regions of the Milky Way. It does this using long-slit, high-resolution spectroscopy of emission from fluorescing molecular hydrogen, which is a powerful fa…
▽ More
We present Hyperion, a mission concept recently proposed to the December 2021 NASA Medium Explorer announcement of opportunity. Hyperion explores the formation and destruction of molecular clouds and planet-forming disks in nearby star-forming regions of the Milky Way. It does this using long-slit, high-resolution spectroscopy of emission from fluorescing molecular hydrogen, which is a powerful far-ultraviolet (FUV) diagnostic. Molecular hydrogen (H2) is the most abundant molecule in the universe and a key ingredient for star and planet formation, but is typically not observed directly because its symmetric atomic structure and lack of a dipole moment mean there are no spectral lines at visible wavelengths and few in the infrared. Hyperion uses molecular hydrogen's wealth of FUV emission lines to achieve three science objectives: (1) determining how star formation is related to molecular hydrogen formation and destruction at the boundaries of molecular clouds; (2) determining how quickly and by what process massive star feedback disperses molecular clouds; and (3) determining the mechanism driving the evolution of planet-forming disks around young solar-analog stars. Hyperion conducts this science using a straightforward, highly-efficient, single-channel instrument design. Hyperion's instrument consists of a 48 cm primary mirror, with an f/5 focal ratio. The spectrometer has two modes, both covering 138.5-161.5 nm bandpasses. A low resolution mode has a spectral resolution of R>10,000 with a slit length of 65 arcmin, while the high resolution mode has a spectral resolution of R>50,000 over a slit length of 5 armin. Hyperion occupies a 2 week long, high-earth, Lunar resonance TESS-like orbit, and conducts 2 weeks of planned observations per orbit, with time for downlinks and calibrations. Hyperion was reviewed as Category I, which is the highest rating possible, but was not selected.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
[OI] 6300Å$\,$ emission as a probe of external photoevaporation of protoplanetary discs
Authors:
Giulia Ballabio,
Thomas J. Haworth,
W. J. Henney
Abstract:
We study the utility of the [OI] 6300$\mathring{\mathrm A}$ forbidden line for identifying and interpreting externally driven photoevaporative winds in different environments and at a range of distances. Thermally excited [OI] 6300$\mathring{\mathrm A}$ is a well known tracer of inner disc winds, so any external contribution needs to be distinguishable. In external winds, the line is not thermally…
▽ More
We study the utility of the [OI] 6300$\mathring{\mathrm A}$ forbidden line for identifying and interpreting externally driven photoevaporative winds in different environments and at a range of distances. Thermally excited [OI] 6300$\mathring{\mathrm A}$ is a well known tracer of inner disc winds, so any external contribution needs to be distinguishable. In external winds, the line is not thermally excited and instead results from the dissociation of OH and we study how the line luminosity resulting from that process scales with the disc/environmental parameters. We find that the line luminosity increases dramatically with FUV radiation field strength above around 5000 G$_0$. The predicted luminosities from our models are consistent with measurements of the line luminosity of proplyds in the Orion Nebula Cluster. The high luminosity in strong UV environments alone may act as a diagnostic, but a rise in the [OI]-to-accretion luminosity ratio is predicted to better separate the two contributions. This could provide a means of identifying external photoevaporation in distant clusters where the proplyd morphology of evaporating discs cannot be spatially resolved.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Deep diving off the `Cosmic Cliffs': previously hidden outflows in NGC 3324 revealed by JWST
Authors:
Megan Reiter,
Jon A. Morse,
Nathan Smith,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Michael A. Kuhn,
Pamela D. Klaassen
Abstract:
We present a detailed analysis of the protostellar outflow activity in the massive star-forming region NGC 3324, as revealed by new Early Release Observations (ERO) from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST). Emission from numerous outflows is revealed in narrow-band images of hydrogen Paschen-$α$ (Pa-$α$) and molecular hydrogen. In particular, we report the discovery of 24 previously unknown outf…
▽ More
We present a detailed analysis of the protostellar outflow activity in the massive star-forming region NGC 3324, as revealed by new Early Release Observations (ERO) from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST). Emission from numerous outflows is revealed in narrow-band images of hydrogen Paschen-$α$ (Pa-$α$) and molecular hydrogen. In particular, we report the discovery of 24 previously unknown outflows based on their H$_2$ emission. We find three candidate driving sources for these H$_2$ flows in published catalogs of young stellar objects (YSOs) and we identify 15 IR point sources in the new JWST images as potential driving protostars. We also identify several Herbig-Haro (HH) objects in Pa-$α$ images from JWST; most are confirmed as jets based on their proper motions measured in a comparison with previous Hubble Space Telescope (HST) H$α$ images. This confirmed all previous HST-identified HH jets and candidate jets, and revealed 7 new HH objects. The unprecedented capabilities of JWST allow the direct comparison of atomic and molecular outflow components at comparable angular resolution. Future observations will allow quantitative analysis of the excitation, mass-loss rates, and velocities of these new flows. As a relatively modest region of massive star formation (larger than Orion but smaller than starburst clusters), NGC 3324 offers a preview of what star formation studies with JWST may provide.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
The external photoevaporation of planet-forming discs
Authors:
Andrew J. Winter,
Thomas J. Haworth
Abstract:
Planet-forming disc evolution is not independent of the star formation and feedback process in giant molecular clouds. In particular, OB stars emit UV radiation that heats and disperses discs in a process called 'external photoevaporation'. This process is understood to be the dominant environmental influence acting on planet-forming discs in typical star forming regions. Our best studied discs ar…
▽ More
Planet-forming disc evolution is not independent of the star formation and feedback process in giant molecular clouds. In particular, OB stars emit UV radiation that heats and disperses discs in a process called 'external photoevaporation'. This process is understood to be the dominant environmental influence acting on planet-forming discs in typical star forming regions. Our best studied discs are nearby, in sparse stellar groups where external photoevaporation is less effective. However the majority of discs are expected to reside in much stronger UV environments. Understanding external photoevaporation is therefore key to understanding how most discs evolve, and hence how most planets form. Here we review our theoretical and observational understanding of external photoevaporation. We also lay out key developments for the future to address existing unknowns and establish the full role of external photoevaporation in the disc evolution and planet formation process.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2022; v1 submitted 23 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
The growth and migration of massive planets under the influence of external photoevaporation
Authors:
Andrew J. Winter,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Gavin A. L. Coleman,
Sergei Nayakshin
Abstract:
The formation of gas giant planets must occur during the first few Myr of a star's lifetime, when the protoplanetary disc still contains sufficient gas to be accreted onto the planetary core. The majority of protoplanetary discs are exposed to strong ultraviolet irradiation from nearby massive stars, which drives winds and depletes the mass budget for planet formation. It remains unclear to what d…
▽ More
The formation of gas giant planets must occur during the first few Myr of a star's lifetime, when the protoplanetary disc still contains sufficient gas to be accreted onto the planetary core. The majority of protoplanetary discs are exposed to strong ultraviolet irradiation from nearby massive stars, which drives winds and depletes the mass budget for planet formation. It remains unclear to what degree external photoevaporation affects the formation of massive planets. In this work, we present a simple one dimensional model for the growth and migration of a massive planet under the influence of external FUV fields. We find that even moderate FUV fluxes $F_\mathrm{FUV}\gtrsim 100 \, G_0$ have a strong influence on planet mass and migration. By decreasing the local surface density and shutting off accretion onto the planet, external irradiation suppresses planet masses and halts migration early. The distribution of typical stellar birth environments can therefore produce an anti-correlation between semi-major axis and planet mass, which may explain the apparent decrease in planet occurrence rates at orbital periods $P_\mathrm{orb}\gtrsim 10^3$ days. Even moderate fluxes $F_\mathrm{FUV}$ strongly suppress giant planet formation and inward migration for any initial semi-major axis if the stellar host mass $M_*\lesssim 0.5\, M_\odot$, consistent with findings that massive planet occurrence is much lower around such stars. The outcomes of our prescription for external disc depletion show significant differences to the current approximation adopted in state-of-the-art population synthesis models, motivating future careful treatment of this important process.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Discovery of a 500 au Protobinary in the Massive Prestellar Core G11.92-0.61 MM2
Authors:
C. J. Cyganowski,
J. D. Ilee,
C. L. Brogan,
T. R. Hunter,
S. Zhang,
T. J. Harries,
T. J. Haworth
Abstract:
We present high-resolution (< ~160 au) Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) 1.3 mm observations of the high-mass prestellar core candidate G11.92-0.61 MM2, which reveal that this source is in fact a protobinary system with a projected separation of 505 au. The binary components, MM2E and MM2W, are compact (radii < 140 au) sources within the partially optically thick dust emission wi…
▽ More
We present high-resolution (< ~160 au) Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) 1.3 mm observations of the high-mass prestellar core candidate G11.92-0.61 MM2, which reveal that this source is in fact a protobinary system with a projected separation of 505 au. The binary components, MM2E and MM2W, are compact (radii < 140 au) sources within the partially optically thick dust emission with alpha$_{0.9 cm-1.3 mm}$=2.47-2.94. The 1.3 mm brightness temperatures, T$_b$=68.4/64.6 K for MM2E/MM2W, imply internal heating and minimum luminosities L$_*$ > 24.7 Lsun for MM2E and L$_*$ > 12.6 Lsun for MM2W. The compact sources are connected by a "bridge" of lower-surface-brightness dust emission and lie within more extended emission that may correspond to a circumbinary disk. The circumprotostellar gas mass, estimated from ~0.2" resolution VLA 0.9 cm observations assuming optically thin emission, is 6.8+/-0.9 Msun. No line emission is detected towards MM2E and MM2W in our high-resolution 1.3 mm ALMA observations. The only line detected is 13CO J=2-1, in absorption against the 1.3 mm continuum, which likely traces a layer of cooler molecular material surrounding the protostars. We also report the discovery of a highly asymmetric bipolar molecular outflow that appears to be driven by MM2E and/or MM2W in new deep, ~0.5" resolution (1680 au) ALMA 0.82 mm observations. This outflow, traced by low-excitation CH3OH emission, indicates ongoing accretion onto the protobinary system. Overall, the super-Alfvenic models of Mignon-Risse et al. (2021) agree well with the observed properties of the MM2E/MM2W protobinary, suggesting that this system may be forming in an environment with a weak magnetic field.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2022; v1 submitted 19 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Dispersal of protoplanetary discs: How stellar properties and the local environment determine the pathway of evolution
Authors:
Gavin A. L. Coleman,
Thomas J. Haworth
Abstract:
We study the evolution and final dispersal of protoplanetary discs that evolve under the action of internal and external photoevaporation, and different degrees of viscous transport. We identify five distinct dispersal pathways, which are i) very long lived discs ($>20\,$Myr), ii) inside-out dispersal where internal photoevaporation dominates and opens inner holes, iii) outside-in dispersal where…
▽ More
We study the evolution and final dispersal of protoplanetary discs that evolve under the action of internal and external photoevaporation, and different degrees of viscous transport. We identify five distinct dispersal pathways, which are i) very long lived discs ($>20\,$Myr), ii) inside-out dispersal where internal photoevaporation dominates and opens inner holes, iii) outside-in dispersal where external photoevaporation dominates through disc truncation and two intermediate regimes characterised by lingering material in the inner disc with the outer disc dispersed predominantly by either internal or external photoevaporation. We determine how the lifetime, relative impact of internal and external winds and clearing pathway varies over a wide, plausible, parameter space of stellar/disc/radiation properties. There are a number of implications, for example in high UV environments because the outer disc lifetime is shorter than the time-scale for clearing the inner disc we do not expect transition discs to be common, which appears to be reflected in the location of transition disc populations towards the Orion Nebular Cluster. Irrespective of environment, we find that ongoing star formation is required to reproduce observed disc fractions as a function of stellar cluster age. This work demonstrates the importance of including both internal and external winds for understanding protoplanetary disc evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2022; v1 submitted 5 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Thermal emission from bow shocks II: 3D magnetohydrodynamic models of Zeta Ophiuchi
Authors:
S. Green,
J. Mackey,
P. Kavanagh,
T. J. Haworth,
M. Moutzouri,
V. V. Gvaramdaze
Abstract:
The nearby, massive, runaway star Zeta Ophiuchi has a large bow shock detected in optical and infrared, and, uniquely among runaway O stars, diffuse X-ray emission is detected from the shocked stellar wind. Here we make the first detailed computational investigation of the bow shock of Zeta Ophiuchi, to test whether a simple model of the bow shock can explain the observed nebula, and to compare th…
▽ More
The nearby, massive, runaway star Zeta Ophiuchi has a large bow shock detected in optical and infrared, and, uniquely among runaway O stars, diffuse X-ray emission is detected from the shocked stellar wind. Here we make the first detailed computational investigation of the bow shock of Zeta Ophiuchi, to test whether a simple model of the bow shock can explain the observed nebula, and to compare the detected X-ray emission with simulated emission maps. We re-analysed archival {\it Chandra} observations of the thermal diffuse X-ray emission from the shocked wind region of the bow shock, finding total unabsorbed X-ray flux (0.3-2 keV band) corresponding to a diffuse luminosity of $L_\mathrm{X}=2.33~(0.79-3.45)\times10^{29}$ergs$^{-1}$. 3D MHD simulations were used to model the interaction of the star's wind with a uniform ISM using a range of stellar and ISM parameters motivated by observational constraints. Synthetic infrared, Ha, soft X-ray, emission measure, and radio 6\,GHz emission maps were generated from three simulations, for comparison with relevant observations. Simulations where the space velocity of Zeta Ophiuchi has a significant radial velocity produce infrared emission maps with opening angle of the bow shock in better agreement with observations than for the case where motion is fully in the plane of the sky. The simulation with the highest pressure has the closest match, with flux level within a factor of 2 of the observational lower limit, and emission weighted temperature of $\log_{10}(T_\mathrm{A}/\mathrm{K})=6.4$, although the morphology of the diffuse emission appears somewhat different. Observed X-ray emission is a filled bubble brightest near the star whereas simulations predict brightening towards the contact discontinuity as density increases.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2022; v1 submitted 11 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
PION: Simulations of Wind-Blown Nebulae
Authors:
Jonathan Mackey,
Samuel Green,
Maria Moutzouri,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Robert D. Kavanagh,
Maggie Celeste,
Robert Brose,
Davit Zargaryan,
Ciarán O'Rourke
Abstract:
We present an overview of PION, an open-source software project for solving radiation-magnetohydrodynamics equations on a nested grid, aimed at modelling asymmetric nebulae around massive stars. A new implementation of hybrid OpenMP/MPI parallel algorithms is briefly introduced, and improved scaling is demonstrated compared with the current release version. Three-dimensional simulations of an expa…
▽ More
We present an overview of PION, an open-source software project for solving radiation-magnetohydrodynamics equations on a nested grid, aimed at modelling asymmetric nebulae around massive stars. A new implementation of hybrid OpenMP/MPI parallel algorithms is briefly introduced, and improved scaling is demonstrated compared with the current release version. Three-dimensional simulations of an expanding nebula around a Wolf-Rayet star are then presented and analysed, similar to previous 2D simulations in the literature. The evolution of the emission measure of the gas and the X-ray surface brightness are calculated as a function of time, and some qualitative comparison with observations is made.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
The evolution of protoplanetary discs in star formation and feedback simulations
Authors:
Lin Qiao,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Andrew D. Sellek,
Ahmad A. Ali
Abstract:
We couple star cluster formation and feedback simulations of a Carina-like star forming region with 1D disc evolutionary models to study the impact of external photoevaporation on disc populations in massive star forming regions. To investigate the effect of shielding of young stellar objects by star forming material, we track the FUV field history at each star in the cluster with two methods: i)…
▽ More
We couple star cluster formation and feedback simulations of a Carina-like star forming region with 1D disc evolutionary models to study the impact of external photoevaporation on disc populations in massive star forming regions. To investigate the effect of shielding of young stellar objects by star forming material, we track the FUV field history at each star in the cluster with two methods: i) Monte Carlo radiative transfer accounting for the shielding of stars from the FUV by the star forming cloud ii) Geometric dilution of the radiation from other stars which ignores shielding effects. We found that significant shielding only occurs for a small fraction of discs and offers protection from external photoevaporation for < 0.5 Myr. However, this initial protection can prevent significant early gas/dust mass loss and disc radius reduction due to external photoevaporation. Particularly, shielding for 0.5 Myr is sufficient for much of the solid reservoir to evolve to larger sizes where it will not be entrained in an external wind. Shielding is therefore potentially significant for terrestrial planet formation in retaining the solid mass budget, but the continued strip** of gas when shielding ends could still impact migration and the gas reservoir for giant planet atmospheres. Our models highlight issues with treating all discs in a cluster with a single characteristic age, since shielded objects are typically only the youngest. Our model predicts that the majority of discs in a 2 Myr Carina-like environment are subject to strong external photoevaporation.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
An APEX search for carbon emission from NGC 1977 proplyds
Authors:
Thomas J. Haworth,
**young S. Kim,
Lin Qiao,
Andrew J. Winter,
Jonathan P. Williams,
Cathie J. Clarke,
James E. Owen,
Stefano Facchini,
Megan Ansdell,
Mikhel Kama,
Giulia Ballabio
Abstract:
We used the Atacama Pathfinder Experiment (APEX) telescope to search for CI 1-0 (492.16GHz) emission towards 8 proplyds in NGC 1977, which is an FUV radiation environment two orders of magnitude weaker than that irradiating the Orion Nebular Cluster (ONC) proplyds. CI is expected to enable us to probe the wind launching region of externally photoevaporating discs. Of the 8 targets observed, no 3…
▽ More
We used the Atacama Pathfinder Experiment (APEX) telescope to search for CI 1-0 (492.16GHz) emission towards 8 proplyds in NGC 1977, which is an FUV radiation environment two orders of magnitude weaker than that irradiating the Orion Nebular Cluster (ONC) proplyds. CI is expected to enable us to probe the wind launching region of externally photoevaporating discs. Of the 8 targets observed, no 3$σ$ detections of the CI line were made despite reaching sensitivities deeper than the anticipated requirement for detection from prior APEX CI observations of nearby discs and models of external photoevaporation of quite massive discs. By comparing both the proplyd mass loss rates and CI flux constraints with a large grid of external photoevaporation simulations, we determine that the non-detections are in fact fully consistent with the models if the proplyd discs are very low mass. Deeper observations in CI and probes of the disc mass with other tracers (e.g. in the continuum and CO) can test this. If such a test finds higher masses, this would imply carbon depletion in the outer disc, as has been proposed for other discs with surprisingly low CI fluxes, though more massive discs would also be incompatible with models that can explain the observed mass loss rates and CI non-detections. The expected remaining lifetimes of the proplyds are estimated to be similar to those of proplyds in the ONC at 0.1Myr. Rapid destruction of discs is therefore also a feature of common, intermediate UV environments.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Determining dispersal mechanisms of protoplanetary disks using accretion and wind mass loss rates
Authors:
Yasuhiro Hasegawa,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Keri Hoadley,
**young Serena Kim,
Hina Goto,
Aine Juzikenaite,
Neal J. Turner,
Ilaria Pascucci,
Erika T. Hamden
Abstract:
Understanding the origin of accretion and dispersal of protoplanetary disks is fundamental for investigating planet formation. Recent numerical simulations show that launching winds are unavoidable when disks undergo magnetically driven accretion and/or are exposed to external UV radiation. Observations also hint that disk winds are common. We explore how the resulting wind mass loss rate can be u…
▽ More
Understanding the origin of accretion and dispersal of protoplanetary disks is fundamental for investigating planet formation. Recent numerical simulations show that launching winds are unavoidable when disks undergo magnetically driven accretion and/or are exposed to external UV radiation. Observations also hint that disk winds are common. We explore how the resulting wind mass loss rate can be used as a probe of both disk accretion and dispersal. As a proof-of-concept study, we focus on magnetocentrifugal winds, MRI (magnetorotational instability) turbulence, and external photoevapotaion. By develo** a simple, yet physically motivated disk model and coupling it with simulation results available in the literature, we compute the mass loss rate as a function of external UV flux for each mechanism. We find that different mechanisms lead to different levels of mass loss rate, indicating that the origin of disk accretion and dispersal can be determined, by observing the wind mass loss rate resulting from each mechanism. This determination provides important implications for planet formation. This work thus shows that the ongoing and future observations of the wind mass loss rate for protoplanetary disks are paramount to reliably constrain how protoplanetary disks evolve with time and how planet formation takes place in the disks.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2022; v1 submitted 6 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
A wind-blown bubble in the Central Molecular Zone cloud G0.253+0.016
Authors:
J. D. Henshaw,
M. R. Krumholz,
N. O. Butterfield,
J. Mackey,
A. Ginsburg,
T. J. Haworth,
F. Nogueras-Lara,
A. T. Barnes,
S. N. Longmore,
J. Bally,
J. M. D. Kruijssen,
E. A. C. Mills,
H. Beuther,
D. L. Walker,
C. Battersby,
A. Bulatek,
T. Henning,
J. Ott,
J. D. Soler
Abstract:
G0.253+0.016, commonly referred to as "the Brick" and located within the Central Molecular Zone, is one of the densest ($\approx10^{3-4}$ cm$^{-3}$) molecular clouds in the Galaxy to lack signatures of widespread star formation. We set out to constrain the origins of an arc-shaped molecular line emission feature located within the cloud. We determine that the arc, centred on…
▽ More
G0.253+0.016, commonly referred to as "the Brick" and located within the Central Molecular Zone, is one of the densest ($\approx10^{3-4}$ cm$^{-3}$) molecular clouds in the Galaxy to lack signatures of widespread star formation. We set out to constrain the origins of an arc-shaped molecular line emission feature located within the cloud. We determine that the arc, centred on $\{l_{0},b_{0}\}=\{0.248^{\circ}, 0.18^{\circ}\}$, has a radius of $1.3$ pc and kinematics indicative of the presence of a shell expanding at $5.2^{+2.7}_{-1.9}$ km s$^{-1}$. Extended radio continuum emission fills the arc cavity and recombination line emission peaks at a similar velocity to the arc, implying that the molecular and ionised gas are physically related. The inferred Lyman continuum photon rate is $N_{\rm LyC}=10^{46.0}-10^{47.9}$ photons s$^{-1}$, consistent with a star of spectral type B1-O8.5, corresponding to a mass of $\approx12-20$ M$_{\odot}$. We explore two scenarios for the origin of the arc: i) a partial shell swept up by the wind of an interloper high-mass star; ii) a partial shell swept up by stellar feedback resulting from in-situ star formation. We favour the latter scenario, finding reasonable (factor of a few) agreement between its morphology, dynamics, and energetics and those predicted for an expanding bubble driven by the wind from a high-mass star. The immediate implication is that G0.253+0.016 may not be as quiescent as is commonly accepted. We speculate that the cloud may have produced a $\lesssim10^{3}$ M$_{\odot}$ star cluster $\gtrsim0.4$ Myr ago, and demonstrate that the high-extinction and stellar crowding observed towards G0.253+0.016 may help to obscure such a star cluster from detection.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Chemulator: Fast, accurate thermochemistry for dynamical models through emulation
Authors:
J. Holdship,
S. Viti,
T. J. Haworth,
J. D. Ilee
Abstract:
Chemical modelling serves two purposes in dynamical models: accounting for the effect of microphysics on the dynamics and providing observable signatures. Ideally, the former must be done as part of the hydrodynamic simulation but this comes with a prohibitive computational cost which leads to many simplifications being used in practice. To produce a statistical emulator that replicates a full che…
▽ More
Chemical modelling serves two purposes in dynamical models: accounting for the effect of microphysics on the dynamics and providing observable signatures. Ideally, the former must be done as part of the hydrodynamic simulation but this comes with a prohibitive computational cost which leads to many simplifications being used in practice. To produce a statistical emulator that replicates a full chemical model capable of solving the temperature and abundances of a gas through time. This emulator should suffer only a minor loss of accuracy over including a full chemical solver in a dynamical model but would have a fraction of the computational cost. The gas-grain chemical code UCLCHEM was updated to include heating and cooling processes and a large dataset of model outputs from possible starting conditions was produced. A neural network was then trained to map directly from inputs to outputs. Chemulator replicates the outputs of UCLCHEM with an overall mean squared error (MSE) of 0.0002 for a single time step of 1000 yr and is shown to be stable over 1000 iterations with an MSE of 0.003 the log scaled temperature after one time step and 0.006 after 1000 time steps. Chemulator was found to be approximately 50,000 times faster than the time dependent model it emulates but can introduce a significant error to some models.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
First detection of a disk free of volatile elements around a young A-type star: A sign of collisions between rocky planets?
Authors:
M. E. van den Ancker,
N. P. Gentile Fusillo,
T. J. Haworth,
C. F. Manara,
P. A. Miles-Páez,
R. D. Oudmaijer,
O. Panic,
D. J. M. Petit dit de la Roche,
M. G. Petr-Gotzens,
M. Vioque
Abstract:
Aims. We present the first detailed analysis of the astrophysical parameters of the poorly studied Sco-Cen member HD 152384 and its circumstellar environment. Methods. We analyze newly obtained optical-near-IR XSHOOTER spectra, as well as archival TESS data, of HD 152384. In addition, we use literature photometric data to construct a detailed spectral energy distribution (SED) of the star. Results…
▽ More
Aims. We present the first detailed analysis of the astrophysical parameters of the poorly studied Sco-Cen member HD 152384 and its circumstellar environment. Methods. We analyze newly obtained optical-near-IR XSHOOTER spectra, as well as archival TESS data, of HD 152384. In addition, we use literature photometric data to construct a detailed spectral energy distribution (SED) of the star. Results. The photospheric absorption lines in the spectrum of HD 152384 are characteristic of a A0 V star, for which we derive a stellar mass of 2.1 +/- 0.1 M_sun and a stellar age > 4.5 Myr. Superimposed on the photospheric absorption, the optical spectrum also displays double-peaked emission lines of Ca II, Fe I, Mg I and Si I, typical of circumstellar disks. Notably, all Hydrogen and Helium lines appear strictly in absorption. A toy model shows that the observed emission line profiles can be reproduced by emission from a compact (radius < 0.3 au) disk seen at an inclination of ~24 degrees. Further evidence for the presence of circumstellar material comes from the detection of a moderate infrared excess in the SED, similar to those found in extreme debris disk systems. Conclusions. We conclude that HD 152384 is surrounded by a tenuous circumstellar disk which, although rich in refractory elements, is highly depleted of volatile elements. To the best of our knowledge such a disk is unique within the group of young stars. However, it is reminiscent of the disks seen in some white dwarfs, which have been attributed to the disruption of rocky planets. We suggest that the disk around HD 152384 may have a similar origin and may be due to collisions in a newly formed planetary system.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2021; v1 submitted 18 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
PION: Simulating bow shocks and circumstellar nebulae
Authors:
Jonathan Mackey,
Samuel Green,
Maria Moutzouri,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Robert D. Kavanagh,
Davit Zargaryan,
Maggie Celeste
Abstract:
Expanding nebulae are produced by mass loss from stars, especially during late stages of evolution. Multi-dimensional simulation of these nebulae requires high resolution near the star and permits resolution that decreases with distance from the star, ideally with adaptive timesteps. We report the implementation and testing of static mesh-refinement in the radiation-magnetohydrodynamics code PION,…
▽ More
Expanding nebulae are produced by mass loss from stars, especially during late stages of evolution. Multi-dimensional simulation of these nebulae requires high resolution near the star and permits resolution that decreases with distance from the star, ideally with adaptive timesteps. We report the implementation and testing of static mesh-refinement in the radiation-magnetohydrodynamics code PION, and document its performance for 2D and 3D calculations. The bow shock produced by a hot, magnetized, slowly rotating star as it moves through the magnetized ISM is simulated in 3D, highlighting differences compared with 2D calculations. Latitude-dependent, time-varying magnetized winds are modelled and compared with simulations of ring nebulae around blue supergiants from the literature. A 3D simulation of the expansion of a fast wind from a Wolf-Rayet star into the slow wind from a previous red supergiant phase of evolution is presented, with results compared with results in the literature and analytic theory. Finally the wind-wind collision from a binary star system is modelled with 3D MHD, and the results compared with previous 2D hydrodynamic calculations. A python library is provided for reading and plotting simulation snapshots, and the generation of synthetic infrared emission maps using torus is also demonstrated. It is shown that state-of-the-art 3D MHD simulations of wind-driven nebulae can be performed using PION with reasonable computational resources. The source code and user documentation is made available for the community under a BSD3 licence.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Warm millimetre dust in protoplanetary discs near massive stars
Authors:
T. J. Haworth
Abstract:
Dust plays a key role in the formation of planets and its emission also provides one of our most accessible views of protoplanetary discs. If set by radiative equilibrium with the central star, the temperature of dust in the disc plateaus at around $10-20$K in the outer regions. However sufficiently nearby massive stars can heat the outer disc to substantially higher temperatures. In this paper we…
▽ More
Dust plays a key role in the formation of planets and its emission also provides one of our most accessible views of protoplanetary discs. If set by radiative equilibrium with the central star, the temperature of dust in the disc plateaus at around $10-20$K in the outer regions. However sufficiently nearby massive stars can heat the outer disc to substantially higher temperatures. In this paper we study the radiative equilibrium temperature of discs in the presence of massive external sources and gauge the effect that it has on millimetre dust mass estimates. Since millimetre grains are not entrained in any wind we focus on geometrically simple 2D-axisymmetric disc models using radiative transfer calculations with both the host star and an external source. Recent surveys have searched for evidence of massive stars influencing disc evolution using disc properties as a function of projected separation. In assuming a disc temperature of $20$K for a disc a distance $D$ from a strong radiation source, disc masses are overestimated by a factor that scales with $D^{-1/2}$ interior to the separation that external heating becomes important. This could significantly alter dust mass estimates of discs in close proximity to $θ^1$C in the Orion Nebular Cluster. We also make an initial assessment of the effect upon snow lines. Within a parsec of an O star like $θ^1$C a CO snow line no longer exists, though the water snow line is virtually unaffected except for very close separations of $\leq0.01\,$pc.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Proplyds in the Flame Nebula NGC 2024
Authors:
Thomas J. Haworth,
**young S. Kim,
Andrew J. Winter,
Dean C. Hines,
Cathie J. Clarke,
Andrew D. Sellek,
Giulia Ballabio,
Karl R. Stapelfeldt
Abstract:
A recent survey of the inner $0.35\times0.35$pc of the NGC 2024 star forming region revealed two distinct millimetre continuum disc populations that appear to be spatially segregated by the boundary of a dense cloud. The eastern (and more embedded) population is $\sim0.2-0.5$Myr old, with an ALMA mm continuum disc detection rate of about $45\,$per cent. However this drops to only $\sim15$per cent…
▽ More
A recent survey of the inner $0.35\times0.35$pc of the NGC 2024 star forming region revealed two distinct millimetre continuum disc populations that appear to be spatially segregated by the boundary of a dense cloud. The eastern (and more embedded) population is $\sim0.2-0.5$Myr old, with an ALMA mm continuum disc detection rate of about $45\,$per cent. However this drops to only $\sim15$per cent in the 1Myr western population. When presenting this result, van Terwisga et al. (2020) suggested that the two main UV sources, IRS 1 (a B0.5V star in the western region) and IRS 2b (an O8V star in the eastern region, but embedded) have both been evaporating the discs in the depleted western population.
In this paper we report the firm discovery in archival HST data of 4 proplyds and 4 further candidate proplyds in NGC 2024, confirming that external photoevaporation of discs is occurring. However, the locations of these proplyds changes the picture. Only three of them are in the depleted western population and their evaporation is dominated by IRS 1, with no obvious impact from IRS 2b. The other 5 proplyds are in the younger eastern region and being evaporated by IRS 2b. We propose that both populations are subject to significant external photoevaporation, which happens throughout the region wherever discs are not sufficiently shielded by the interstellar medium. The external photoevaporation and severe depletion of mm grains in the 0.2-0.5Myr eastern part of NGC 2024 would be in competition even with very early planet formation.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Planet formation in intermediate-separation binary systems
Authors:
O. Panić,
T. J. Haworth,
M. G. Petr-Gotzens,
J. Miley,
M. van den Ancker,
M. Vioque,
L. Siess,
R. Parker,
C. J. Clarke,
I. Kamp,
G. Kennedy,
R. D. Oudmaijer,
I. Pascucci,
A. M. S. Richards,
T. Ratzka,
C. Qi
Abstract:
We report the first characterisation of the individual discs in the intermediate separation binary systems KK Oph and HD 144668 at millimetre wavelengths. In both systems the circum-primary and the circum-secondary discs are detected in the millimetre continuum emission, but not in $^{13}$CO nor C$^{18}$O lines. Even though the disc structure is only marginally resolved, we find indications of lar…
▽ More
We report the first characterisation of the individual discs in the intermediate separation binary systems KK Oph and HD 144668 at millimetre wavelengths. In both systems the circum-primary and the circum-secondary discs are detected in the millimetre continuum emission, but not in $^{13}$CO nor C$^{18}$O lines. Even though the disc structure is only marginally resolved, we find indications of large-scale asymmetries in the outer regions of the primary discs, most likely due to perturbation by the companion. The derived dust masses are firmly above debris disc level for all stars. The primaries have about three times more dust in their discs than the secondaries. In the case of HD 144668 the opacity spectral index of the primary and secondary differ by the large margin of 0.69 which may be a consequence of the secondary disc being more compact. Upper limits on the gas masses imply less than 0.1 M$_{\textrm{jup}}$ in any of these discs, meaning that giant planets can no longer form in them. Considering that there have been no massive gas discs identified to date in intermediate separation binaries (i.e., binaries at a few hundred au separation), this opens space for speculation whether their binarity causes the removal of gas, with tidal interaction truncating the discs and hence shortening the accretion timescale. More systematic studies in this respect are sorely needed.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
An ALMA survey of $λ$ Orionis disks: from supernovae to planet formation
Authors:
Megan Ansdell,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Jonathan P. Williams,
Stefano Facchini,
Andrew Winter,
Carlo F. Manara,
Alvaro Hacar,
Eugene Chiang,
Sierk van Terwisga,
Nienke van der Marel,
Ewine F. van Dishoeck
Abstract:
Protoplanetary disk surveys by the Atacama Large Millimeter/sub-millimeter Array (ALMA) are now probing a range of environmental conditions, from low-mass star-forming regions like Lupus to massive OB clusters like $σ$ Orionis. Here we conduct an ALMA survey of protoplanetary disks in $λ$ Orionis, a ~5 Myr old OB cluster in Orion, with dust mass sensitivities comparable to the surveys of nearby re…
▽ More
Protoplanetary disk surveys by the Atacama Large Millimeter/sub-millimeter Array (ALMA) are now probing a range of environmental conditions, from low-mass star-forming regions like Lupus to massive OB clusters like $σ$ Orionis. Here we conduct an ALMA survey of protoplanetary disks in $λ$ Orionis, a ~5 Myr old OB cluster in Orion, with dust mass sensitivities comparable to the surveys of nearby regions (~0.4 $M_\oplus$). We assess how massive OB stars impact planet formation, in particular from the supernova that may have occurred ~1 Myr ago in the core of $λ$ Orionis; studying these effects is important as most planetary systems, including our Solar System, are likely born in cluster environments. We find that the effects of massive stars, in the form of pre-supernova feedback and/or a supernova itself, do not appear to significantly reduce the available planet-forming material otherwise expected at the evolved age of $λ$ Orionis. We also compare a lingering massive "outlier" disk in $λ$ Orionis to similar systems in other evolved regions, hypothesizing that these outliers host companions in their inner disks that suppress disk dispersal to extend the lifetimes of their outer primordial disks. We conclude with numerous avenues for future work, highlighting how $λ$ Orionis still has much to teach us about perhaps one of the most common types of planet-forming environments in the Galaxy.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Searching for wide-orbit gravitational instability protoplanets with ALMA in the dust continuum
Authors:
J. Humphries,
C. Hall,
T. J. Haworth,
S. Nayakshin
Abstract:
Searches for young gas giant planets at wide separations have so far focused on techniques appropriate for compact (Jupiter sized) planets. Here we point out that protoplanets born through Gravitational Instability (GI) may remain in an initial pre-collapse phase for as long as the first $ 10^5-10^7$ years after formation. These objects are hundreds of times larger than Jupiter and their atmospher…
▽ More
Searches for young gas giant planets at wide separations have so far focused on techniques appropriate for compact (Jupiter sized) planets. Here we point out that protoplanets born through Gravitational Instability (GI) may remain in an initial pre-collapse phase for as long as the first $ 10^5-10^7$ years after formation. These objects are hundreds of times larger than Jupiter and their atmospheres are too cold ($T\sim$ tens of K) to emit in the NIR or H$α$ via accretion shocks. However, it is possible that their dust emission can be detected with ALMA, even around Class I and II protoplanetary discs. In this paper we produce synthetic observations of these protoplanets. We find that making a detection in a disc at 140 parsecs would require a few hundred minutes of ALMA band 6 observation time. Protoplanets with masses of 3-5 $M_J$ have the highest chance of being detected; less massive objects require unreasonably long observation times (1000 minutes) while more massive ones collapse into giant planets before $10^5$ years. We propose that high resolution surveys of young ($10^5-10^6$ years), massive and face on discs offer the best chance for observing protoplanets. Such a detection would help to place constraints on the protoplanet mass spectrum, explain the turnover in the occurrence frequency of gas giants with system metallicity and constrain the prevalence of GI as a planet formation mechanism. Consistent lack of detection would be evidence against GI as a common planet formation mechanism.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Illuminating a tadpole's metamorphosis III: quantifying past and present environmental impact
Authors:
Megan Reiter,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Andrés E. Guzmán,
Pamela D. Klaassen,
Anna F. McLeod,
Guido Garay
Abstract:
We combine MUSE and ALMA observations with theoretical models to evaluate how a tadpole-shaped globule located in the Carina Nebula has been influenced by its environment. This globule is now relatively small (radius ~2500 au), hosts a protostellar jet+outflow (HH 900) and, with a blue-shifted velocity of ~10 km/s, is travelling faster than it should be if its kinematics were set by the turbulent…
▽ More
We combine MUSE and ALMA observations with theoretical models to evaluate how a tadpole-shaped globule located in the Carina Nebula has been influenced by its environment. This globule is now relatively small (radius ~2500 au), hosts a protostellar jet+outflow (HH 900) and, with a blue-shifted velocity of ~10 km/s, is travelling faster than it should be if its kinematics were set by the turbulent velocity dispersion of the precursor cloud. Its outer layers are currently still subject to heating, but comparing the internal and external pressures implies that the globule is in a post-collapse phase. Intriguingly the outflow is bent, implying that the YSO responsible for launching it is comoving with the globule, which requires that the star formed after the globule was up to speed since otherwise it would have been left behind. We conclude that the most likely scenario is one in which the cloud was much larger before being subject to radiatively-driven implosion, which accelerated the globule to the high observed speeds under the photoevaporative rocket effect and triggered the formation of the star responsible for the outflow. The globule may now be in a quasi-steady state following collapse. Finally, the HH 900 YSO is likely $\gtrsim$1 M$_{\odot}$ and may be the only star forming in the globule. It may be that this process of triggered star formation has prevented the globule from fragmenting to form multiple stars (e.g., due to heating) and has produced a single higher mass star.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Peter Pan Discs: finding Neverland's parameters
Authors:
Gavin A. L. Coleman,
Thomas J. Haworth
Abstract:
Peter Pan discs are a recently discovered class of long-lived discs around low-mass stars that survive for an order of magnitude longer than typical discs. In this paper we use disc evolutionary models to determine the required balance between initial conditions and the magnitude of dispersal processes for Peter Pan discs to be primordial. We find that we require low transport ($α\sim10^{-4}$), ex…
▽ More
Peter Pan discs are a recently discovered class of long-lived discs around low-mass stars that survive for an order of magnitude longer than typical discs. In this paper we use disc evolutionary models to determine the required balance between initial conditions and the magnitude of dispersal processes for Peter Pan discs to be primordial. We find that we require low transport ($α\sim10^{-4}$), extremely low external photoevaporation ($\leq10^{-9}{\rm M_{\odot}/yr}$), and relatively high disc masses ($>0.25M_*$) to produce discs with ages and accretion rates consistent with Peter Pan discs. Higher transport ($α= 10^{-3}$) results in disc lifetimes that are too short and even lower transport ($α= 10^{-5}$) leads to accretion rates smaller than those observed. The required external photoevaporation rates are so low that primordial Peter Pan discs will have formed in rare environments on the periphery of low-mass star-forming regions, or deeply embedded, and as such have never subsequently been exposed to higher amounts of UV radiation. Given that such an external photoevaporation scenario is rare, the required disc parameters and accretion properties may reflect the initial conditions and accretion rates of a much larger fraction of the discs around low-mass stars.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Testing viscous disc theory using the balance between stellar accretion and external photoevaporation of protoplanetary discs
Authors:
Andrew J. Winter,
Megan Ansdell,
Thomas J. Haworth,
J. M. Diederik Kruijssen
Abstract:
The nature and rate of (viscous) angular momentum transport in protoplanetary discs (PPDs) has important consequences for the formation process of planetary systems. While accretion rates onto the central star yield constraints on such transport in the inner regions of a PPD, empirical constraints on viscous spreading in the outer regions remain challenging to obtain. Here we demonstrate a novel m…
▽ More
The nature and rate of (viscous) angular momentum transport in protoplanetary discs (PPDs) has important consequences for the formation process of planetary systems. While accretion rates onto the central star yield constraints on such transport in the inner regions of a PPD, empirical constraints on viscous spreading in the outer regions remain challenging to obtain. Here we demonstrate a novel method to probe the angular momentum transport at the outer edge of the disc. This method applies to PPDs that have lost a significant fraction of their mass due to thermal winds driven by UV irradiation from a neighbouring OB star. We demonstrate that this external photoevaporation can explain the observed depletion of discs in the 3-5 Myr old $σ$ Orionis region, and use our model to make predictions motivating future empirical investigations of disc winds. For populations of intermediate-age PPDs, in viscous models we show that the mass flux outwards due to angular momentum redistribution is balanced by the mass-loss in the photoevaporative wind. A comparison between wind mass-loss and stellar accretion rates therefore offers an independent constraint on viscous models in the outer regions of PPDs.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Illuminating a tadpole's metamorphosis II: observing the on-going transformation with ALMA
Authors:
Megan Reiter,
Andrés E. Guzmán,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Pamela D. Klaassen,
Anna F. McLeod,
Guido Garay,
Joseph C. Mottram
Abstract:
We present new Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) observations of the tadpole, a small globule in the Carina Nebula that hosts the HH 900 jet+outflow system. Our data include $^{12}$CO, $^{13}$CO, C$^{18}$O J=2-1, $^{13}$CO, C$^{18}$O J=3-2, and serendipitous detections of DCN J=3-2 and CS J=7-6. With angular resolution comparable to the Hubble Space Telescope (HST), our data reve…
▽ More
We present new Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) observations of the tadpole, a small globule in the Carina Nebula that hosts the HH 900 jet+outflow system. Our data include $^{12}$CO, $^{13}$CO, C$^{18}$O J=2-1, $^{13}$CO, C$^{18}$O J=3-2, and serendipitous detections of DCN J=3-2 and CS J=7-6. With angular resolution comparable to the Hubble Space Telescope (HST), our data reveal for the first time the bipolar molecular outflow in CO, seen only inside the globule, that is launched from the previously unseen jet-driving protostar (the HH 900 YSO). The biconical morphology joins smoothly with the externally irradiated outflow seen in ionized gas tracers outside the globule, tracing the overall morphology of a jet-driven molecular outflow. Continuum emission at the location of the HH 900 YSO appears to be slightly flattened perpendicular to outflow axis. Model fits to the continuum have a best-fit spectral index of $\sim 2$, suggesting cold dust and the onset of grain growth. In position-velocity space, $^{13}$CO and C$^{18}$O gas kinematics trace a C-shaped morphology, similar to infall profiles seen in other sources, although the global dynamical behaviour of the gas remains unclear. Line profiles of the CO isotopologues display features consistent with externally heated gas. We estimate a globule mass of $\sim 1.9$ M$_{\odot}$, indicating a remaining lifetime of $\sim 4$ Myr, assuming a constant photoevaporation rate. This long globule lifetime will shield the disk from external irradiation perhaps prolonging its life and enabling planet formation in regions where disks are typically rapidly destroyed.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
A Three Dimensional View of Gomez's Hamburger
Authors:
Richard Teague,
Marija R. Jankovic,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Chunhua Qi,
John D. Ilee
Abstract:
Unraveling the 3D physical structure, the temperature and density distribution, of protoplanetary discs is an essential step if we are to confront simulations of embedded planets or dynamical instabilities. In this paper we focus on Submillimeter Array observations of the edge-on source, Gomez's Hamburger, believed to host an over-density hypothesised to be a product of gravitational instability i…
▽ More
Unraveling the 3D physical structure, the temperature and density distribution, of protoplanetary discs is an essential step if we are to confront simulations of embedded planets or dynamical instabilities. In this paper we focus on Submillimeter Array observations of the edge-on source, Gomez's Hamburger, believed to host an over-density hypothesised to be a product of gravitational instability in the disc, GoHam b. We demonstrate that, by leveraging the well characterised rotation of a Keplerian disc to deproject observations of molecular lines in position-position-velocity space into disc-centric coordinates, we are able to map out the emission distribution in the (r, z) plane and (x, y, z) space. We show that 12CO traces an elevated layer of $z\,/\,r \sim 0.3$, while 13CO traces deeper in the disc at $z\,/\,r \lesssim 0.2$. We localize emission associated with GoHam b, finding it at deprojected radius of approximately 500 au and at polar angle of +\- 30 degrees from the disc major axis. At the spatial resolution of $\sim 1.5^{\prime\prime}$, GoHam b is spatially unresolved, with an upper limit to its radius of $<190$~au.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2020; v1 submitted 4 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Massive discs around low-mass stars
Authors:
Thomas J. Haworth,
James Cadman,
Farzana Meru,
Cassandra Hall,
Emma Albertini,
Duncan Forgan,
Ken Rice,
James E. Owen
Abstract:
We use a suite of SPH simulations to investigate the susceptibility of protoplanetary discs to the effects of self-gravity as a function of star-disc properties. We also include passive irradiation from the host star using different models for the stellar luminosities. The critical disc-to-star mass ratio for axisymmetry (for which we produce criteria) increases significantly for low-mass stars. T…
▽ More
We use a suite of SPH simulations to investigate the susceptibility of protoplanetary discs to the effects of self-gravity as a function of star-disc properties. We also include passive irradiation from the host star using different models for the stellar luminosities. The critical disc-to-star mass ratio for axisymmetry (for which we produce criteria) increases significantly for low-mass stars. This could have important consequences for increasing the potential mass reservoir in a proto Trappist-1 system, since even the efficient Ormel et al. (2017) formation model will be influenced by processes like external photoevaporation, which can rapidly and dramatically deplete the dust reservoir. The aforementioned scaling of the critical $M_d/M_*$ for axisymmetry occurs in part because the Toomre $Q$ parameter has a linear dependence on surface density (which promotes instability) and only an $M_*^{1/2}$ dependence on shear (which reduces instability), but also occurs because, for a given $M_d/M_*$, the thermal evolution depends on the host star mass. The early phase stellar irradiation of the disc (for which the luminosity is much higher than at the zero age main sequence, particularly at low stellar masses) can also play a key role in significantly reducing the role of self-gravity, meaning that even Solar mass stars could support axisymmetric discs a factor two higher in mass than usually considered possible. We apply our criteria to the DSHARP discs with spirals, finding that self-gravity can explain the observed spirals so long as the discs are optically thick to the host star irradiation.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2020; v1 submitted 17 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Fragmentation favoured in discs around higher mass stars
Authors:
James Cadman,
Ken Rice,
Cassandra Hall,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Beth Biller
Abstract:
We investigate how a protoplanetary disc's susceptibility to gravitational instabilities and fragmentation depends on the mass of its host star. We use 1D disc models in conjunction with 3D SPH simulations to determine the critical disc-to-star mass ratios at which discs become unstable against fragmentation, finding that discs become increasingly prone to the effects of self-gravity as we increas…
▽ More
We investigate how a protoplanetary disc's susceptibility to gravitational instabilities and fragmentation depends on the mass of its host star. We use 1D disc models in conjunction with 3D SPH simulations to determine the critical disc-to-star mass ratios at which discs become unstable against fragmentation, finding that discs become increasingly prone to the effects of self-gravity as we increase the host star mass. The actual limit for stability is sensitive to the disc temperature, so if the disc is optically thin stellar irradiation can dramatically stabilise discs against gravitational instability. However, even when this is the case we find that discs around $2$M$_{\odot}$ stars are prone to fragmentation, which will act to produce wide-orbit giant planets and brown dwarfs. The consequences of this work are two-fold: that low mass stars could in principle support high disc-to-star mass ratios, and that higher mass stars have discs that are more prone to fragmentation, which is qualitatively consistent with observations that favour high-mass wide-orbit planets around higher mass stars. We also find that the initial masses of these planets depends on the temperature in the disc at large radii, which itself depends on the level of stellar irradiation.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
The Observational Anatomy of Externally Photoevaporating Planet-Forming Discs I: Atomic Carbon
Authors:
Thomas J. Haworth,
James E. Owen
Abstract:
We demonstrate the utility of CI as a tracer of photoevaporative winds that are being driven from discs by their ambient UV environment. Commonly observed CO lines only trace these winds in relatively weak UV environments and are otherwise dissociated in the wind at the intermediate to high UV fields that most young stars experience. However, CI traces unsubtle kinematic signatures of a wind in in…
▽ More
We demonstrate the utility of CI as a tracer of photoevaporative winds that are being driven from discs by their ambient UV environment. Commonly observed CO lines only trace these winds in relatively weak UV environments and are otherwise dissociated in the wind at the intermediate to high UV fields that most young stars experience. However, CI traces unsubtle kinematic signatures of a wind in intermediate UV environments ($\sim1000$G$_0$) and can be used to place constraints on the kinematics and temperature of the wind. In CI position-velocity diagrams external photoevaporation results in velocities that are faster than those from Keplerian rotation alone, as well as emission from quadrants of position-velocity space in which there would be no Keplerian emission. This is independent of viewing angle because the wind has components that are perpendicular to the azimuthal rotation of the disc. At intermediate viewing angles ($\sim 30-60^\circ$) moment 1 maps also exhibit a twisted morphology over large scales (unlike other processes that result in twists, which are typically towards the inner disc). CI is readily observable with ALMA, which means that it is now possible to identify and characterise the effect of external photoevaporation on planet-forming discs in intermediate UV environments.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2020; v1 submitted 14 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
External photoevaporation of circumstellar disks constrains the timescale for planet formation
Authors:
Francisca Concha-Ramírez,
Martijn J. C. Wilhelm,
Simon Portegies Zwart,
Thomas J. Haworth
Abstract:
Planet-forming circumstellar disks are a fundamental part of the star formation process. Since stars form in a hierarchical fashion in groups of up to hundreds or thousands, the UV radiation environment that these disks are exposed to can vary in strength by at least six orders of magnitude. This radiation can limit the masses and sizes of the disks. Diversity in star forming environments can have…
▽ More
Planet-forming circumstellar disks are a fundamental part of the star formation process. Since stars form in a hierarchical fashion in groups of up to hundreds or thousands, the UV radiation environment that these disks are exposed to can vary in strength by at least six orders of magnitude. This radiation can limit the masses and sizes of the disks. Diversity in star forming environments can have long lasting effects in disk evolution and in the resulting planetary populations. We perform simulations to explore the evolution of circumstellar disks in young star clusters. We include viscous evolution, as well as the impact of dynamical encounters and external photoevaporation. We find that photoevaporation is an important process in destroying circumstellar disks: in regions of stellar density $ρ\sim 100 \mathrm{\ M}_\odot \mathrm{\ pc}^{-3}\mathrm{\ }$ around 80% of disks are destroyed before 2 Myr of cluster evolution. Our findings are in agreement with observed disk fractions in young star forming regions and support previous estimations that planet formation must start in timescales < 0.1 - 1 Myr.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2019; v1 submitted 8 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Thermal emission from bow shocks I: 2D Hydrodynamic Models of the Bubble Nebula
Authors:
Samuel Green,
Jonathan Mackey,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Vasilii V. Gvaramadze,
Peter Duffy
Abstract:
The Bubble Nebula (or NGC 7635) is a parsec-scale seemingly spherical wind-blown bubble around the relatively unevolved O star BD+60$^\circ$2522. The small dynamical age of the nebula and significant space velocity of the star suggest that the Bubble Nebula might be a bow shock. We have run 2D hydrodynamic simulations to model the interaction of the central star's wind with the interstellar medium…
▽ More
The Bubble Nebula (or NGC 7635) is a parsec-scale seemingly spherical wind-blown bubble around the relatively unevolved O star BD+60$^\circ$2522. The small dynamical age of the nebula and significant space velocity of the star suggest that the Bubble Nebula might be a bow shock. We have run 2D hydrodynamic simulations to model the interaction of the central star's wind with the interstellar medium (ISM). The models cover a range of possible ISM number densities of $n=50-200 {\rm cm}^{-3}$ and stellar velocities of $v_{\star}=20-40$ km s$^{-1}$. Synthetic H$α$ and 24 $μ$m emission maps predict the same apparent spherical bubble shape with quantitative properties similar to observations. The synthetic maps also predict a maximum brightness similar to that from the observations and agree that the maximum brightness is at the apex of the bow shock. The best-matching simulation had $v_{\star}\approx20$ km s$^{-1}$ into an ISM with $n\sim100 {\rm cm}^{-3}$, at an angle of 60$^\circ$ with respect to the line of sight. Synthetic maps of soft ($0.3-2$ keV) and hard ($2-10$ keV) X-ray emission show that the brightest region is in the wake behind the star and not at the bow shock itself. The unabsorbed soft X-rays have luminosity $\sim10^{32}-10^{33}$ erg s$^{-1}$. The hard X-rays are fainter, luminosity $\sim 10^{30} - 10^{31}$ erg s$^{-1}$, and may be too faint for current X-ray instruments to successfully observe. Our results imply that the O star creates a bow shock as it moves through the ISM and in turn creates an asymmetric bubble visible at optical and infrared wavelengths, and predicted to be visible in X-rays. The Bubble Nebula does not appear to be unique, it could be just a favourably oriented very dense bow shock. The dense ISM surrounding BD+60$^\circ$2522 and its strong wind suggest that it could be a good candidate for detecting non-thermal emission.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
The first multi-dimensional view of mass loss from externally FUV irradiated protoplanetary discs
Authors:
Thomas J. Haworth,
Cathie J. Clarke
Abstract:
Computing the flow from externally FUV irradiated protoplanetary discs requires solving complicated and expensive photodissociation physics iteratively in conjunction with hydrodynamics. Previous studies have therefore been limited to 1D models of this process. In this paper we compare 2D-axisymmetric models of externally photoevaporating discs with their 1D analogues, finding that mass loss rates…
▽ More
Computing the flow from externally FUV irradiated protoplanetary discs requires solving complicated and expensive photodissociation physics iteratively in conjunction with hydrodynamics. Previous studies have therefore been limited to 1D models of this process. In this paper we compare 2D-axisymmetric models of externally photoevaporating discs with their 1D analogues, finding that mass loss rates are consistent to within a factor four. The mass loss rates in 2D are higher, in part because half of the mass loss comes from the disc surface (which 1D models neglect). 1D mass loss rates used as the basis for disc viscous evolutionary calculations are hence expected to be conservative. We study the anatomy of externally driven winds including the streamline morphology, kinematic, thermal and chemical structure. A key difference between the 1D and 2D models is in the chemical abundances. For instance in the 2D models CO can be dissociated at smaller radial distances from the disc outer edge than in 1D calculations because gas is photodissociated by radiation along trajectories that are assumed infinitely optically thick in 1D models. Multidimensional models will hence be critical for predicting observable signatures of environmentally photoevaporating protoplanetary discs.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2019; v1 submitted 8 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Testing the stability of supersonic ionized Bondi accretion flows with radiation hydrodynamics
Authors:
Bert Vandenbroucke,
Nina S. Sartorio,
Kenneth Wood,
Kristin Lund,
Diego Falceta-Gonçalves,
Thomas J. Haworth,
Ian Bonnell,
Eric Keto,
Daniel Tootill
Abstract:
We investigate the general stability of 1D spherically symmetric ionized Bondi accretion onto a massive object in the specific context of accretion onto a young stellar object. We first derive a new analytic expression for a steady state two temperature solution that predicts the existence of compact and hypercompact HII regions. We then show that this solution is only marginally stable if ionizat…
▽ More
We investigate the general stability of 1D spherically symmetric ionized Bondi accretion onto a massive object in the specific context of accretion onto a young stellar object. We first derive a new analytic expression for a steady state two temperature solution that predicts the existence of compact and hypercompact HII regions. We then show that this solution is only marginally stable if ionization is treated self-consistently. This leads to a recurring collapse of the HII region over time. We derive a semi-analytic model to explain this instability, and test it using spatially converged 1D radiation hydrodynamical simulations. We discuss the implications of the 1D instability on 3D radiation hydrodynamics simulations of supersonic accreting flows.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Asymmetric mid-plane gas in ALMA images of HD~100546
Authors:
J. Miley,
O. Panić,
T. J. Haworth,
I. Pascucci,
M. Wyatt,
C. Clarke,
A. M. S. Richards,
T. Ratzka
Abstract:
In this paper we present new ALMA observations towards the proto-planet hosting transitional disc of Herbig Ae/Be star HD 100546. This includes resolved 1.3 mm continuum, $^{13}$CO and the first detection of C$^{18}$O in this disc, which displays azimuthal asymmetry in regions spatially coincident with structures previously identified in HST images related to spiral arms. The lower limit on the ma…
▽ More
In this paper we present new ALMA observations towards the proto-planet hosting transitional disc of Herbig Ae/Be star HD 100546. This includes resolved 1.3 mm continuum, $^{13}$CO and the first detection of C$^{18}$O in this disc, which displays azimuthal asymmetry in regions spatially coincident with structures previously identified in HST images related to spiral arms. The lower limit on the mass of the dust disc is calculated to be 9.6x10$^{-4}$M$_\odot$. A firm lower-limit on the total gas mass calculated from optically thin, mid-plane tracing C$^{18}$O (2-1) emission is 0.018M$_\odot$ assuming ISM abundances. These mass estimates provide an estimate of gas-to-dust ratio in the disc of 19, the ratio will increase if C$^{18}$O is relatively under-abundant in the disc compared to CO and H2. Through deprojection and azimuthal averaging of the image plane we detect 1.3 mm continuum emission out to 290+/-10 au,$^{13}$CO to 390+/-10 au and C$^{18}$O to 300+/-10au. We measure a radially increasing millimetre spectral index between wavelengths of 867$μ$m and 1.3 mm, which shows that grain sizes increase towards the star, with solid particles growing to cm scales in the inner disc.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
'The Brick' is not a brick: A comprehensive study of the structure and dynamics of the Central Molecular Zone cloud G0.253+0.016
Authors:
J. D. Henshaw,
A. Ginsburg,
T. J. Haworth,
S. N. Longmore,
J. M. D. Kruijssen,
E. A. C. Mills,
V. Sokolov,
D. L. Walker,
A. T. Barnes,
Y. Contreras,
J. Bally,
C. Battersby,
H. Beuther,
N. Butterfield,
J. E. Dale,
T. Henning,
J. M. Jackson,
J. Kauffmann,
T. Pillai,
S. Ragan,
M. Riener,
Q. Zhang
Abstract:
In this paper we provide a comprehensive description of the internal dynamics of G0.253+0.016 (a.k.a. 'the Brick'); one of the most massive and dense molecular clouds in the Galaxy to lack signatures of widespread star formation. As a potential host to a future generation of high-mass stars, understanding largely quiescent molecular clouds like G0.253+0.016 is of critical importance. In this paper…
▽ More
In this paper we provide a comprehensive description of the internal dynamics of G0.253+0.016 (a.k.a. 'the Brick'); one of the most massive and dense molecular clouds in the Galaxy to lack signatures of widespread star formation. As a potential host to a future generation of high-mass stars, understanding largely quiescent molecular clouds like G0.253+0.016 is of critical importance. In this paper, we reanalyse Atacama Large Millimeter Array cycle 0 HNCO $J=4(0,4)-3(0,3)$ data at 3 mm, using two new pieces of software which we make available to the community. First, scousepy, a Python implementation of the spectral line fitting algorithm scouse. Secondly, acorns (Agglomerative Clustering for ORganising Nested Structures), a hierarchical n-dimensional clustering algorithm designed for use with discrete spectroscopic data. Together, these tools provide an unbiased measurement of the line of sight velocity dispersion in this cloud, $σ_{v_{los}, {\rm 1D}}=4.4\pm2.1$ kms$^{-1}$, which is somewhat larger than predicted by velocity dispersion-size relations for the Central Molecular Zone (CMZ). The dispersion of centroid velocities in the plane of the sky are comparable, yielding $σ_{v_{los}, {\rm 1D}}/σ_{v_{pos}, {\rm 1D}}\sim1.2\pm0.3$. This isotropy may indicate that the line-of-sight extent of the cloud is approximately equivalent to that in the plane of the sky. Combining our kinematic decomposition with radiative transfer modelling we conclude that G0.253+0.016 is not a single, coherent, and centrally-condensed molecular cloud; 'the Brick' is not a \emph{brick}. Instead, G0.253+0.016 is a dynamically complex and hierarchically-structured molecular cloud whose morphology is consistent with the influence of the orbital dynamics and shear in the CMZ.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.