-
AXES-SDSS: comparison of SDSS galaxy groups with all-sky X-ray extended sources
Authors:
S. Damsted,
A. Finoguenov,
H. Lietzen,
G. A. Mamon,
J. Comparat,
E. Tempel,
I. Dmitrieva,
N. Clerc,
C. Collins,
G. Gozaliasl,
D. Eckert
Abstract:
We revisit the picture of X-ray emission of groups through the study of systematic differences in the optical properties of groups with and without X-ray emission and study the effect of large-scale density field on scaling relations. We present the identification of X-ray galaxy groups using a combination of RASS and SDSS data. We include new X-ray reanalysis of RASS, to include very extended (up…
▽ More
We revisit the picture of X-ray emission of groups through the study of systematic differences in the optical properties of groups with and without X-ray emission and study the effect of large-scale density field on scaling relations. We present the identification of X-ray galaxy groups using a combination of RASS and SDSS data. We include new X-ray reanalysis of RASS, to include very extended (up to a size of half a degree) sources and account for differences in the limiting sensitivity towards compact and very extended X-ray emission. X-ray groups exhibit less scatter in the scaling relations and selecting the groups based on the extended X-ray emission leads to an additional scatter reduction. Most of the scatter for the optical groups is associated with a small (6%) fraction of outliers, primarily associated with low optical luminosity groups found in dense regions of the cosmic web. These groups are the primary candidates for being the contaminants in the optical group catalogues. Removing those groups from the optical group sample using optically measured properties only, leads to a substantial reduction in the scatter in the most scaling relations of the optical groups. We find a density dependence of both the X-ray and optical luminosity of groups, which we associate with the assembly bias. Abridged.
△ Less
Submitted 25 June, 2024; v1 submitted 25 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
CODEX: Role of velocity substructure in the scaling relations of galaxy clusters
Authors:
S. Damsted,
A. Finoguenov,
N. Clerc,
I. Davalgaite,
C. C. Kirkpatrick,
G. A. Mamon,
J. Ider Chitham,
K. Kiiveri,
J. Comparat,
C. Collins
Abstract:
The use of galaxy clusters as cosmological probes relies on a detailed understanding of their properties. We aim to update the spectroscopic cluster identification of CODEX by running the spectroscopic group finder on the follow-up spectroscopy results and connecting the dynamical state of clusters to their scaling relations. We implemented a reproducible spectroscopic membership determination and…
▽ More
The use of galaxy clusters as cosmological probes relies on a detailed understanding of their properties. We aim to update the spectroscopic cluster identification of CODEX by running the spectroscopic group finder on the follow-up spectroscopy results and connecting the dynamical state of clusters to their scaling relations. We implemented a reproducible spectroscopic membership determination and cleaning procedures, based on the redMaPPer membership, running the spectroscopic group finder on the follow-up spectroscopy results and cleaning the membership for spectroscopic outliers. We applied the Anderson-Darling test for velocity substructure and analysed its influence on the scaling relations. We also tested the effect of the X-ray-to-optical centre offset on the scaling relations. We report on the scaling relations between richness, X-ray luminosity, and velocity dispersion for a complete sample of clusters with at least 15 members. Clusters with velocity substructure exhibit enhanced velocity dispersion for a given richness and are characterized by 2.5 times larger scatter. Clusters that have a strong offset in X-ray-to-optical centres have comparable scaling relations as clusters with substructure. We demonstrate that there is a consistency in the parameters of the scaling relations for the low- and high-richness galaxy clusters. Splitting the clusters by redshift, we note a decrease in scatter with redshift in all scaling relations. We localize the redshift range where a high scatter is observed to $z<0.15$, which is in agreement with the literature results on the scatter. We note that the increase in scatter for both high- and low-luminosity clusters is $z<0.15$, suggesting that both cooling and the resulting active galactic nucleus feedback are at the root of this scatter. Abridged.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Gravitational redshifting of galaxies in the SPIDERS cluster catalogue
Authors:
C. T. Mpetha,
C. A. Collins,
N. Clerc,
A. Finoguenov,
J. A. Peacock,
J. Comparat,
D. Schneider,
R. Capasso,
S. Damsted,
K. Furnell,
A. Merloni,
N. D. Padilla,
A. Saro
Abstract:
Data from the SPectroscopic IDentification of ERosita Sources (SPIDERS) are searched for a detection of the gravitational redshifting of light from $\sim\!20\,000$ galaxies in $\sim\!2500$ galaxy clusters using three definitions of the cluster centre: its Brightest Cluster Galaxy (BCG), the redMaPPer identified Central Galaxy (CG), or the peak of X-ray emission. Distributions of velocity offsets b…
▽ More
Data from the SPectroscopic IDentification of ERosita Sources (SPIDERS) are searched for a detection of the gravitational redshifting of light from $\sim\!20\,000$ galaxies in $\sim\!2500$ galaxy clusters using three definitions of the cluster centre: its Brightest Cluster Galaxy (BCG), the redMaPPer identified Central Galaxy (CG), or the peak of X-ray emission. Distributions of velocity offsets between galaxies and their host cluster's centre, found using observed redshifts, are created. The quantity $\hatΔ$, the average of the radial velocity difference between the cluster members and the cluster systemic velocity, reveals information on the size of a combination of effects on the observed redshift, dominated by gravitational redshifting. The change of $\hatΔ$ with radial distance is predicted for SPIDERS galaxies in General Relativity (GR), and $f(R)$ gravity, and compared to the observations. The values of $\hatΔ=-13.5\pm4.7$ km s$^{-1}$, $\hatΔ=-12.5\pm5.1$ km s$^{-1}$, and $\hatΔ=-18.6\pm4.8$ km s$^{-1}$ for the BCG, X-ray and CG cases respectively broadly agree with the literature. There is no significant preference of one gravity theory over another, but all cases give a clear detection ($>2.5σ$) of $\hatΔ$. The BCG centroid is deemed to be the most robust method in this analysis, due to no well defined central redshift when using an X-ray centroid, and CGs identified by redMaPPer with no associated spectroscopic redshift. For future gravitational redshift studies, an order of magnitude more galaxies, $\sim\!500\,000$, will be required-a possible feat with the forthcoming Vera C. Rubin Observatory, Euclid and eROSITA.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2021; v1 submitted 22 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
SPIDERS: An Overview of The Largest Catalogue of Spectroscopically Confirmed X-ray Galaxy Clusters
Authors:
C. C. Kirkpatrick,
N. Clerc,
A. Finoguenov,
S. Damsted,
J. Ider Chitham,
A. E. Kukkola,
A. Gueguen,
K. Furnell,
E. Rykoff,
J. Comparat,
A. Saro,
R. Capasso,
N. Padilla,
G. Erfanianfar,
G. A. Mamon,
C. Collins,
A. Merloni,
J. R. Brownstein,
D. P. Schneider
Abstract:
SPIDERS is the spectroscopic follow-up effort of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey IV (SDSS-IV) project for the identification of X-ray selected galaxy clusters. We present our catalogue of 2740 visually inspected galaxy clusters as a part of the SDSS Data Release 16 (DR16). Here we detail the target selection, our methods for validation of the candidate clusters, performance of the survey, the constru…
▽ More
SPIDERS is the spectroscopic follow-up effort of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey IV (SDSS-IV) project for the identification of X-ray selected galaxy clusters. We present our catalogue of 2740 visually inspected galaxy clusters as a part of the SDSS Data Release 16 (DR16). Here we detail the target selection, our methods for validation of the candidate clusters, performance of the survey, the construction of the final sample, and a full description of what is found in the catalogue. Of the sample, the median number of members per cluster is approximately 10, with 818 having 15 or greater. We find that we are capable of validating over 99% of clusters when 5 redshifts are obtained below $z<0.3$ and when 9 redshifts are obtained above $z>0.3$. We discuss the improvements of this catalogue's identification of cluster using 33,340 redshifts, with $Δz_{\rm{phot}} / Δz_{\rm{spec}} \sim 100$, over other photometric and spectroscopic surveys, as well as present an update to previous ($σ- L_{X}$) and ($σ- λ$) relations. Finally, we present our cosmological constraints derived using the velocity dispersion function.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Clustering of CODEX clusters
Authors:
Valtteri Lindholm,
Alexis Finoguenov,
Johan Comparat,
Charles C. Kirkpatrick,
Eli Rykoff,
Nicolas Clerc,
Chris Collins,
Sanna Damsted,
Jacob Ider Chitham,
Nelson Padilla
Abstract:
Aims. We analyze the autocorrelation function of a large contiguous sample of galaxy clusters, the Constrain Dark Energy with X-ray (CODEX) sample, in which we take particular care of cluster definition. These clusters were X-ray selected using the RASS survey and then identified as galaxy clusters using the code redMaPPer run on the photometry of the SDSS. We develop methods for precisely account…
▽ More
Aims. We analyze the autocorrelation function of a large contiguous sample of galaxy clusters, the Constrain Dark Energy with X-ray (CODEX) sample, in which we take particular care of cluster definition. These clusters were X-ray selected using the RASS survey and then identified as galaxy clusters using the code redMaPPer run on the photometry of the SDSS. We develop methods for precisely accounting for the sample selection effects on the clustering and demonstrate their robustness using numerical simulations. Methods. Using the clean CODEX sample, which was obtained by applying a redshift-dependent richness selection, we computed the two-point autocorrelation function of galaxy clusters in the $0.1<z<0.3$ and $0.3<z<0.5$ redshift bins. We compared the bias in the measured correlation function with values obtained in numerical simulations using a similar cluster mass range. Results. By fitting a power law, we measured a correlation length $r_0=18.7 \pm 1.1$ and slope $γ=1.98 \pm 0.14$ for the correlation function in the full redshift range. By fixing the other cosmological parameters to their WMAP9 values, we reproduced the observed shape of the correlation function under the following cosmological conditions: $Ω_{m_0}=0.22^{+0.04}_{-0.03}$ and $S_8=σ_8 (Ω_{m_0} /0.3)^{0.5}=0.85^{+0.10}_{-0.08}$ with estimated additional systematic errors of $σ_{Ω_{m_0}} = 0.02$ and $σ_{S_8} = 0.20$. We illustrate the complementarity of clustering constraints by combining them with CODEX cosmological constraints based on the X-ray luminosity function, deriving $Ω_{m_0} = 0.25 \pm 0.01$ and $σ_8 = 0.81^{+0.01}_{-0.02}$ with an estimated additional systematic error of $σ_{Ω_{m_0}} = 0.07$ and $σ_{σ_8} = 0.04$. The mass calibration and statistical quality of the mass tracers are the dominant source of uncertainty.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
SPIDERS: overview of the X-ray galaxy cluster follow-up and the final spectroscopic data release
Authors:
N. Clerc,
C. C. Kirkpatrick,
A. Finoguenov,
R. Capasso,
J. Comparat,
S. Damsted,
K. Furnell,
A. E. Kukkola,
J. Ider Chitham,
A. Merloni,
M. Salvato,
A. Gueguen,
T. Dwelly,
C. Collins,
A. Saro,
G. Erfanianfar,
D. P. Schneider,
J. Brownstein,
G. A. Mamon,
N. Padilla,
E. Jullo,
D. Bizyaev
Abstract:
SPIDERS (The SPectroscopic IDentification of eROSITA Sources) is a large spectroscopic programme for X-ray selected galaxy clusters as part of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey-IV (SDSS-IV). We describe the final dataset in the context of SDSS Data Release 16 (DR16): the survey overall characteristics, final targeting strategies, achieved completeness and spectral quality, with special emphasis on its…
▽ More
SPIDERS (The SPectroscopic IDentification of eROSITA Sources) is a large spectroscopic programme for X-ray selected galaxy clusters as part of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey-IV (SDSS-IV). We describe the final dataset in the context of SDSS Data Release 16 (DR16): the survey overall characteristics, final targeting strategies, achieved completeness and spectral quality, with special emphasis on its use as a galaxy cluster sample for cosmology applications. SPIDERS now consists of about 27,000 new optical spectra of galaxies selected within 4,000 photometric red sequences, each associated with an X-ray source. The excellent spectrograph efficiency and a robust analysis pipeline yield a spectroscopic redshift measurement success rate exceeding 98%, with a median velocity accuracy of 20 km s$^{-1}$ (at $z=0.2$). Using the catalogue of 2,740 X-ray galaxy clusters confirmed with DR16 spectroscopy, we reveal the three-dimensional map of the galaxy cluster distribution in the observable Universe up to $z\sim0.6$. We highlight the homogeneity of the member galaxy spectra among distinct regions of the galaxy cluster phase space. Aided by accurate spectroscopic redshifts and by a model of the sample selection effects, we compute the galaxy cluster X-ray luminosity function and we present its lack of evolution up to $z=0.6$. Finally we discuss the prospects of forthcoming large multiplexed spectroscopic programmes dedicated to follow up the next generation of all-sky X-ray source catalogues.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
CODEX clusters. The Survey, the Catalog, and Cosmology of the X-ray Luminosity Function
Authors:
A. Finoguenov,
E. Rykoff,
N. Clerc,
M. Costanzi,
S. Hagstotz,
J. Ider Chitham,
K. Kiiveri,
C. C. Kirkpatrick,
R. Capasso,
J. Comparat,
S. Damsted,
R. Dupke,
G. Erfanianfar,
J. Patrick Henry,
F. Kaefer,
J-P. Kneib,
V. Lindholm,
E. Rozo,
L. van Waerbeke,
J. Weller
Abstract:
Large area catalogs of galaxy clusters constructed from ROSAT All Sky Survey provide the base for our knowledge on the population of clusters thanks to the long-term multiwavelength efforts on their follow-up. Advent of large area photometric surveys superseding in depth previous all-sky data allows us to revisit the construction of X-ray cluster catalogs, extending the study to lower cluster mass…
▽ More
Large area catalogs of galaxy clusters constructed from ROSAT All Sky Survey provide the base for our knowledge on the population of clusters thanks to the long-term multiwavelength efforts on their follow-up. Advent of large area photometric surveys superseding in depth previous all-sky data allows us to revisit the construction of X-ray cluster catalogs, extending the study to lower cluster masses and to higher redshifts and to provide the modelling of the selection function. We perform a wavelet detection of X-ray sources and make extensive simulations of the detection of clusters in the RASS data. We assign an optical richness to each of the 24,788 detected X-ray sources in the 10,382 square degrees of SDSS BOSS area, using redMaPPer version 5.2. We name this survey COnstrain Dark Energy with X-ray (CODEX) clusters. We show that there is no obvious separation of sources on galaxy clusters and AGN, based on distribution of systems on their richness. This is a combination of increasing number of galaxy groups and their selection as identification of an X-ray sources either by chance or due to groups hosting an AGN. To clean the sample, we use a cut on the optical richness at the level corresponding to the 10\% completeness of the survey and include it into the modelling of cluster selection function. We present the X-ray catalog extending to a redshift of 0.6 down to X-ray fluxes of $10^{-13}$ ergs s$^{-1}$ cm$^{-2}$. We provide the modelling of the sample selection and discuss the redshift evolution of the high end of the X-ray luminosity function (XLF). Our results on $z<0.3$ XLF are in agreement with previous studies, while we provide new constraints on the $0.3<z<0.6$ XLF. We find a lack of strong redshift evolution of the XLF, provide exact modeling of the effect of low number statistics and AGN contamination and present the resulting constraints on the flat $Λ$CDM.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2020; v1 submitted 6 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
The Sixteenth Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Surveys: First Release from the APOGEE-2 Southern Survey and Full Release of eBOSS Spectra
Authors:
Romina Ahumada,
Carlos Allende Prieto,
Andres Almeida,
Friedrich Anders,
Scott F. Anderson,
Brett H. Andrews,
Borja Anguiano,
Riccardo Arcodia,
Eric Armengaud,
Marie Aubert,
Santiago Avila,
Vladimir Avila-Reese,
Carles Badenes,
Christophe Balland,
Kat Barger,
Jorge K. Barrera-Ballesteros,
Sarbani Basu,
Julian Bautista,
Rachael L. Beaton,
Timothy C. Beers,
B. Izamar T. Benavides,
Chad F. Bender,
Mariangela Bernardi,
Matthew Bershady,
Florian Beutler
, et al. (289 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This paper documents the sixteenth data release (DR16) from the Sloan Digital Sky Surveys; the fourth and penultimate from the fourth phase (SDSS-IV). This is the first release of data from the southern hemisphere survey of the Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment 2 (APOGEE-2); new data from APOGEE-2 North are also included. DR16 is also notable as the final data release for the…
▽ More
This paper documents the sixteenth data release (DR16) from the Sloan Digital Sky Surveys; the fourth and penultimate from the fourth phase (SDSS-IV). This is the first release of data from the southern hemisphere survey of the Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment 2 (APOGEE-2); new data from APOGEE-2 North are also included. DR16 is also notable as the final data release for the main cosmological program of the Extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (eBOSS), and all raw and reduced spectra from that project are released here. DR16 also includes all the data from the Time Domain Spectroscopic Survey (TDSS) and new data from the SPectroscopic IDentification of ERosita Survey (SPIDERS) programs, both of which were co-observed on eBOSS plates. DR16 has no new data from the Map** Nearby Galaxies at Apache Point Observatory (MaNGA) survey (or the MaNGA Stellar Library "MaStar"). We also preview future SDSS-V operations (due to start in 2020), and summarize plans for the final SDSS-IV data release (DR17).
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2020; v1 submitted 5 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Mass Calibration of the CODEX Cluster Sample using SPIDERS Spectroscopy -- II. The X-ray Luminosity-Mass Relation
Authors:
R. Capasso,
J. J. Mohr,
A. Saro,
A. Biviano,
N. Clerc,
A. Finoguenov,
M. Klein,
S. Grandis,
C. Collins,
S. Damsted,
C. Kirkpatrick,
A. Kukkola
Abstract:
We perform the calibration of the X-ray luminosity--mass scaling relation on a sample of 344 CODEX clusters with $z<0.66$ using the dynamics of their member galaxies. Spectroscopic follow-up measurements have been obtained from the SPIDERS survey, leading to a sample of 6,658 red member galaxies. We use the Jeans equation to calculate halo masses, assuming an NFW mass profile and analyzing a broad…
▽ More
We perform the calibration of the X-ray luminosity--mass scaling relation on a sample of 344 CODEX clusters with $z<0.66$ using the dynamics of their member galaxies. Spectroscopic follow-up measurements have been obtained from the SPIDERS survey, leading to a sample of 6,658 red member galaxies. We use the Jeans equation to calculate halo masses, assuming an NFW mass profile and analyzing a broad range of anisotropy profiles. With a scaling relation of the form $L_{\rm{X}} \propto \text{A}_{\rm{X}}M_{\text{200c}}^{\text{B}_{\rm{X}}} E(z)^2 (1+z)^{γ_{\rm{X}}}$, we find best fit parameters $ \text{A}_{\rm{X}}=5.7^{+0.4}_{-0.5} (\pm0.6)\times10^{43}\,\mathrm{erg\,s^{-1}}$, $\text{B}_{\rm{X}}=2.5\pm0.2(\pm0.07)$, $γ_{\rm{X}}=-2.6^{+1.1}_{-1.2}(\pm0.74)$, where we include systematic uncertainties in parentheses and for a pivot mass and redshift of $3\times10^{14}M_\odot$ and 0.16, respectively. We compare our constraints with previous results, and we combine our sample with the SPT SZE--selected cluster subsample observed with \XMM\, extending the validity of our results to a wider range of redshifts and cluster masses.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2020; v1 submitted 10 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Stellar mass -- halo mass relation for the brightest central galaxies of X-ray clusters since z~0.65
Authors:
G. Erfanianfar,
A. Finoguenov,
K. Furnell,
P. Popesso,
A. Biviano,
S. Wuyts,
C. A. Collins,
M. Mirkazemi,
J. Comparat,
H. Khosroshahi,
K. Nandra,
R. Capasso,
E. Rykoff,
D. Wilman,
A. Merloni,
N. Clerc,
M. Salvato,
J. I. Chitham,
L. S. Kelvin,
G. Gozaliasl,
A. Weijmans,
J. Brownstein,
E. Egami,
M. J. Pereira,
D. P. Schneider
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present the brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs) catalog for SPectroscoic IDentification of eROSITA Sources (SPIDERS) DR14 cluster program value-added catalog. We list the 416 BCGs identified as part of this process, along with their stellar mass, star formation rates, and morphological properties. We identified the BCGs based on the available spectroscopic data from SPIDERS and photometric data f…
▽ More
We present the brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs) catalog for SPectroscoic IDentification of eROSITA Sources (SPIDERS) DR14 cluster program value-added catalog. We list the 416 BCGs identified as part of this process, along with their stellar mass, star formation rates, and morphological properties. We identified the BCGs based on the available spectroscopic data from SPIDERS and photometric data from SDSS. We computed stellar masses and SFRs of the BCGs on the basis of SDSS, WISE, and GALEX photometry using spectral energy distribution fitting. Morphological properties for all BCGs were derived by Sersic profile fitting using the software package SIGMA in different optical bands (g,r,i). We combined this catalog with the BCGs of galaxy groups and clusters extracted from the deeper AEGIS, CDFS, COSMOS, XMM-CFHTLS, and XMM-XXL surveys to study the stellar mass - halo mass relation using the largest sample of X-ray groups and clusters known to date. This result suggests that the mass growth of the central galaxy is controlled by the hierarchical mass growth of the host halo. We find a strong correlation between the stellar mass of BCGs and the mass of their host halos. This relation shows no evolution since z $\sim$ 0.65. We measure a mean scatter of 0.21 and 0.25 for the stellar mass of BCGs in a given halo mass at low ( $0.1<z < 0.3$ ) and high ( $0.3<z<0.65$ ) redshifts, respectively. We further demonstrate that the BCG mass is covariant with the richness of the host halos in the very X-ray luminous systems. We also find evidence that part of the scatter between X-ray luminosity and richness can be reduced by considering stellar mass as an additional variable.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2019; v1 submitted 5 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Mass Calibration of the CODEX Cluster Sample using SPIDERS Spectroscopy -- I. The Richness-Mass Relation
Authors:
R. Capasso,
J. J. Mohr,
A. Saro,
A. Biviano,
N. Clerc,
A. Finoguenov,
S. Grandis,
C. Collins,
G. Erfanianfar,
S. Damsted,
C. Kirkpatrick,
A. Kukkola
Abstract:
We use galaxy dynamical information to calibrate the richness-mass scaling relation of a sample of 428 galaxy clusters that are members of the CODEX sample with redshifts up to z~0.7. These clusters were X-ray selected using the ROSAT All-Sky Survey (RASS), cross-matched to associated systems in the redMaPPer catalog from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. The spectroscopic sample we analyze was obtain…
▽ More
We use galaxy dynamical information to calibrate the richness-mass scaling relation of a sample of 428 galaxy clusters that are members of the CODEX sample with redshifts up to z~0.7. These clusters were X-ray selected using the ROSAT All-Sky Survey (RASS), cross-matched to associated systems in the redMaPPer catalog from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. The spectroscopic sample we analyze was obtained in the SPIDERS program and contains ~7800 red member galaxies. Adopting NFW mass and galaxy density profiles and a broad range of orbital anisotropy profiles, we use the Jeans equation to calculate halo masses. Modeling the scaling relation as $λ\propto \text{A}_λ {M_{\text{200c}}}^{\text{B}_λ} ({1+z})^{γ_λ}$, we find the parameter constraints $\text{A}_λ=38.6^{+3.1}_{-4.1}\pm3.9$, $\text{B}_λ=0.99^{+0.06}_{-0.07}\pm0.04$, and $γ_λ=-1.13^{+0.32}_{-0.34}\pm0.49$. We find good agreement with previously published mass trends with the exception of those from stacked weak lensing analyses. We note that although the lensing analyses failed to account for the Eddington bias, this is not enough to explain the differences. We suggest that differences in the levels of contamination between pure redMaPPer and RASS+redMaPPer samples could well contribute to these differences. The redshift trend we measure is more negative than but statistically consistent with previous results. We suggest that our measured redshift trend reflects a change in the cluster galaxy red sequence fraction with redshift, noting that the trend we measure is consistent with but somewhat stronger than an independently measured redshift trend in the red sequence fraction. We also examine the impact of a plausible model of correlated scatter in X-ray luminosity and optical richness, showing it has negligible impact on our results.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2019; v1 submitted 14 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.