-
The Sun's Alfven Surface: Recent Insights and Prospects for the Polarimeter to Unify the Corona and Heliosphere (PUNCH)
Authors:
Steven R. Cranmer,
Rohit Chhiber,
Chris R. Gilly,
Iver H. Cairns,
Robin C. Colaninno,
David J. McComas,
Nour E. Raouafi,
Arcadi V. Usmanov,
Sarah E. Gibson,
Craig E. DeForest
Abstract:
The solar wind is the extension of the Sun's hot and ionized corona, and it exists in a state of continuous expansion into interplanetary space. The radial distance at which the wind's outflow speed exceeds the phase speed of Alfvenic and fast-mode magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) waves is called the Alfven radius. In one-dimensional models, this is a singular point beyond which most fluctuations in the…
▽ More
The solar wind is the extension of the Sun's hot and ionized corona, and it exists in a state of continuous expansion into interplanetary space. The radial distance at which the wind's outflow speed exceeds the phase speed of Alfvenic and fast-mode magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) waves is called the Alfven radius. In one-dimensional models, this is a singular point beyond which most fluctuations in the plasma and magnetic field cannot propagate back down to the Sun. In the multi-dimensional solar wind, this point can occur at different distances along an irregularly shaped "Alfven surface." In this article, we review the properties of this surface and discuss its importance in models of solar-wind acceleration, angular-momentum transport, MHD waves and turbulence, and the geometry of magnetically closed coronal loops. We also review the results of simulations and data analysis techniques that aim to determine the location of the Alfven surface. Combined with recent perihelia of Parker Solar Probe, these studies seem to indicate that the Alfven surface spends most of its time at heliocentric distances between about 10 and 20 solar radii. It is becoming apparent that this region of the heliosphere is sufficiently turbulent that there often exist multiple (stochastic and time-dependent) crossings of the Alfven surface along any radial ray. Thus, in many contexts, it is more useful to make use of the concept of a topologically complex "Alfven zone" rather than one closed surface. This article also reviews how the Polarimeter to Unify the Corona and Heliosphere (PUNCH) mission will measure the properties of the Alfven surface and provide key constraints on theories of solar-wind acceleration.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
WISPR Imaging of a Pristine CME
Authors:
Phillip Hess,
Alexis Rouillard,
Athanasios Kouloumvakos,
Paulett C. Liewer,
Jie Zhang,
Suman Dhakal,
Guillermo Stenborg,
Robin C. Colaninno,
Russell A. Howard
Abstract:
The Wide-field Imager for Solar Probe (WISPR) on board the Parker Solar Probe (PSP) observed a CME on 2018 November 01, the first day of the initial PSP encounter. The speed of the CME, approximately 200-300 km s$^{-1}$ in the WISPR field of view, is typical of slow, streamer blowout CMEs. This event was also observed by the LASCO coronagraphs. WISPR and LASCO view remarkably similar structures th…
▽ More
The Wide-field Imager for Solar Probe (WISPR) on board the Parker Solar Probe (PSP) observed a CME on 2018 November 01, the first day of the initial PSP encounter. The speed of the CME, approximately 200-300 km s$^{-1}$ in the WISPR field of view, is typical of slow, streamer blowout CMEs. This event was also observed by the LASCO coronagraphs. WISPR and LASCO view remarkably similar structures that enable useful cross-comparison between the two data sets as well as stereoscopic imaging of the CME. Analysis is extended to lower heights by linking the white-light observations to EUV data from AIA, which reveal a structure that erupts more than a full day earlier before the CME finally gathers enough velocity to propagate outward. This EUV feature appears as a brightness enhancement in cooler temperatures such as 171 Å, but as a cavity in nominal coronal temperatures such as 193 Å. By comparing this circular, dark feature in 193 Å\ to the dark, white-light cavity at the center of the eruption in WISPR and LASCO, it can be seen that this is one coherent structure that exists prior to the eruption in the low corona before entering the heliosphere and likely corresponds to the core of the magnetic flux rope. It is also believed that the relative weakness of the event contributed to the clarity of the flux rope in WISPR, as the CME did not experience impulsive forces or strong interaction with external structures that can lead to more complex structural evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Relationship of EUV Irradiance Coronal Dimming Slope and Depth to Coronal Mass Ejection Speed and Mass
Authors:
James Paul Mason,
Thomas N. Woods,
David F. Webb,
Barbara J. Thompson,
Robin C. Colaninno,
Angelos Vourlidas
Abstract:
Extreme ultraviolet (EUV) coronal dimmings are often observed in response to solar eruptive events. These phenomena can be generated via several different physical processes. For space weather, the most important of these is the temporary void left behind by a coronal mass ejection (CME). Massive, fast CMEs tend to leave behind a darker void that also usually corresponds to minimum irradiance for…
▽ More
Extreme ultraviolet (EUV) coronal dimmings are often observed in response to solar eruptive events. These phenomena can be generated via several different physical processes. For space weather, the most important of these is the temporary void left behind by a coronal mass ejection (CME). Massive, fast CMEs tend to leave behind a darker void that also usually corresponds to minimum irradiance for the cooler coronal emissions. If the dimming is associated with a solar flare, as is often the case, the flare component of the irradiance light curve in the cooler coronal emission can be isolated and removed using simultaneous measurements of warmer coronal lines. We apply this technique to 37 dimming events identified during two separate two-week periods in 2011, plus an event on 2010 August 7 analyzed in a previous paper, to parameterize dimming in terms of depth and slope. We provide statistics on which combination of wavelengths worked best for the flare-removal method, describe the fitting methods applied to the dimming light curves, and compare the dimming parameters with corresponding CME parameters of mass and speed. The best linear relationships found are
$$ \begin{align} v_{CME} \Big[\frac{km}{s} \Big] & \approx 2.36 \times 10^6 \Big[\frac{km}{\%} \Big] \times s_{dim} \Big[\frac{\%}{s} \Big] \\ m_{CME} [g] & \approx 2.59 \times 10^{15} \Big[\frac{g}{\%} \Big] \times \sqrt{d_{dim}} [\%]. \end{align} $$
These relationships could be used for space weather operations of estimating CME mass and speed using near-realtime irradiance dimming measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Using ForeCAT Deflections and Rotations to Constrain the Early Evolution of CMEs
Authors:
C. Kay,
M. Opher,
R. C. Colaninno,
A. Vourlidas
Abstract:
To accurately predict the space weather effects of coronal mass ejection (CME) impacts at Earth one must know if and when a CME will impact Earth, and the CME parameters upon impact. Kay et al. (2015b) presents Forecasting a CME's Altered Trajectory (ForeCAT), a model for CME deflections based on the magnetic forces from the background solar magnetic field. Knowing the deflection and rotation of a…
▽ More
To accurately predict the space weather effects of coronal mass ejection (CME) impacts at Earth one must know if and when a CME will impact Earth, and the CME parameters upon impact. Kay et al. (2015b) presents Forecasting a CME's Altered Trajectory (ForeCAT), a model for CME deflections based on the magnetic forces from the background solar magnetic field. Knowing the deflection and rotation of a CME enables prediction of Earth impacts, and the CME orientation upon impact. We first reconstruct the positions of the 2008 April 10 and the 2012 July 12 CMEs from the observations. The first of these CMEs exhibits significant deflection and rotation (34 degrees deflection and 58 degrees rotation), while the second shows almost no deflection or rotation (<3 degrees each). Using ForeCAT, we explore a range of initial parameters, such as the CME location and size, and find parameters that can successfully reproduce the behavior for each CME. Additionally, since the deflection depends strongly on the behavior of a CME in the low corona (Kay et al. (2015a, 2015b)), we are able to constrain the expansion and propagation of these CMEs in the low corona.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
Propagation of the 7 January 2014 CME and Resulting Geomagnetic Non-Event
Authors:
M. L. Mays,
B. J. Thompson,
L. K. Jian,
R. C. Colaninno,
D. Odstrcil,
C. Möstl,
M. Temmer,
N. P. Savani,
A. Taktakishvili,
P. J. MacNeice,
Y. Zheng
Abstract:
On 7 January 2014 an X1.2 flare and CME with a radial speed $\approx$2500 km s$^{-1}$ was observed from near an active region close to disk center. This led many forecasters to estimate a rapid arrival at Earth ($\approx$36 hours) and predict a strong geomagnetic storm. However, only a glancing CME arrival was observed at Earth with a transit time of $\approx$49 hours and a $K_{\rm P}$ geomagnetic…
▽ More
On 7 January 2014 an X1.2 flare and CME with a radial speed $\approx$2500 km s$^{-1}$ was observed from near an active region close to disk center. This led many forecasters to estimate a rapid arrival at Earth ($\approx$36 hours) and predict a strong geomagnetic storm. However, only a glancing CME arrival was observed at Earth with a transit time of $\approx$49 hours and a $K_{\rm P}$ geomagnetic index of only $3-$. We study the interplanetary propagation of this CME using the ensemble Wang-Sheeley-Arge (WSA)-ENLIL+Cone model, that allows a sampling of CME parameter uncertainties. We explore a series of simulations to isolate the effects of the background solar wind solution, CME shape, tilt, location, size, and speed, and the results are compared with observed in-situ arrivals at Venus, Earth, and Mars. Our results show that a tilted ellipsoid CME shape improves the initial real-time prediction to better reflect the observed in-situ signatures and the geomagnetic storm strength. CME parameters from the Graduated Cylindrical Shell model used as input to WSA--ENLIL+Cone, along with a tilted ellipsoid cloud shape, improve the arrival-time error by 14.5, 18.7, 23.4 hours for Venus, Earth, and Mars respectively. These results highlight that CME orientation and directionality with respect to observatories play an important role in understanding the propagation of this CME, and for forecasting other glancing CME arrivals. This study also demonstrates the importance of three-dimensional CME fitting made possible by multiple viewpoint imaging.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Strong coronal channelling and interplanetary evolution of a solar storm up to Earth and Mars
Authors:
Christian Möstl,
Tanja Rollett,
Rudy A. Frahm,
Ying D. Liu,
David M. Long,
Robin C. Colaninno,
Martin A. Reiss,
Manuela Temmer,
Charles J. Farrugia,
Arik Posner,
Mateja Dumbović,
Miho Janvier,
Pascal Démoulin,
Peter Boakes,
Andy Devos,
Emil Kraaikamp,
Mona L. Mays,
Bojan Vrsnak
Abstract:
The severe geomagnetic effects of solar storms or coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are to a large degree determined by their propagation direction with respect to Earth. There is a lack of understanding of the processes that determine their non-radial propagation. Here we present a synthesis of data from seven different space missions of a fast CME, which originated in an active region near the disk…
▽ More
The severe geomagnetic effects of solar storms or coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are to a large degree determined by their propagation direction with respect to Earth. There is a lack of understanding of the processes that determine their non-radial propagation. Here we present a synthesis of data from seven different space missions of a fast CME, which originated in an active region near the disk centre and, hence, a significant geomagnetic impact was forecasted. However, the CME is demonstrated to be channelled during eruption into a direction + 37+/-10 degree (longitude) away from its source region, leading only to minimal geomagnetic effects. In situ observations near Earth and Mars confirm the channelled CME motion, and are consistent with an ellipse shape of the CME-driven shock provided by the new Ellipse Evolution model, presented here. The results enhance our understanding of CME propagation and shape, which can help to improve space weather forecasts.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2015; v1 submitted 9 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Active-Region Tilt Angles: Magnetic Versus White-Light Determinations of Joy's Law
Authors:
Y. -M. Wang,
R. C. Colaninno,
T. Baranyi,
J. Li
Abstract:
The axes of solar active regions are inclined relative to the east--west direction, with the tilt angle tending to increase with latitude ("Joy's law"). Observational determinations of Joy's law have been based either on white-light images of sunspot groups or on magnetograms, where the latter have the advantage of measuring directly the physically relevant quantity (the photospheric field), but t…
▽ More
The axes of solar active regions are inclined relative to the east--west direction, with the tilt angle tending to increase with latitude ("Joy's law"). Observational determinations of Joy's law have been based either on white-light images of sunspot groups or on magnetograms, where the latter have the advantage of measuring directly the physically relevant quantity (the photospheric field), but the disadvantage of having been recorded routinely only since the mid-1960s. White-light studies employing the historical Mount Wilson (MW) database have yielded tilt angles that are smaller and that increase less steeply with latitude than those obtained from magnetic data. We confirm this effect by comparing sunspot-group tilt angles from the Debrecen Photoheliographic Database with measurements made by Li and Ulrich using MW magnetograms taken during cycles 21--23. Whether white-light or magnetic data are employed, the median tilt angles significantly exceed the mean values, and provide a better characterization of the observed distributions. The discrepancy between the white-light and magnetic results is found to have two main sources. First, a substantial fraction of the white-light "tilt angles" refer to sunspots of the same polarity. Of greater physical significance is that the magnetograph measurements include the contribution of plage areas, which are invisible in white-light images but tend to have greater axial inclinations than the adjacent sunspots. Given the large uncertainties inherent in both the white-light and the magnetic measurements, it remains unclear whether any systematic relationship exists between tilt angle and cycle amplitude during cycles 16--23.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Connecting speeds, directions and arrival times of 22 coronal mass ejections from the Sun to 1 AU
Authors:
C. Möstl,
K. Amla,
J. R. Hall,
P. C. Liewer,
E. M. De Jong,
R. C. Colaninno,
A. M. Veronig,
T. Rollett,
M. Temmer,
V. Peinhart,
J. A. Davies,
N. Lugaz,
Y. D. Liu,
C. J. Farrugia,
J. G. Luhmann,
B. Vršnak,
R. A. Harrison,
A. B. Galvin
Abstract:
Forecasting the in situ properties of coronal mass ejections (CMEs) from remote images is expected to strongly enhance predictions of space weather, and is of general interest for studying the interaction of CMEs with planetary environments. We study the feasibility of using a single heliospheric imager (HI) instrument, imaging the solar wind density from the Sun to 1 AU, for connecting remote ima…
▽ More
Forecasting the in situ properties of coronal mass ejections (CMEs) from remote images is expected to strongly enhance predictions of space weather, and is of general interest for studying the interaction of CMEs with planetary environments. We study the feasibility of using a single heliospheric imager (HI) instrument, imaging the solar wind density from the Sun to 1 AU, for connecting remote images to in situ observations of CMEs. We compare the predictions of speed and arrival time for 22 CMEs (in 2008-2012) to the corresponding interplanetary coronal mass ejection (ICME) parameters at in situ observatories (STEREO PLASTIC/IMPACT, Wind SWE/MFI). The list consists of front- and backsided, slow and fast CMEs (up to $2700 \: km \: s^{-1}$). We track the CMEs to $34.9 \pm 7.1$ degrees elongation from the Sun with J-maps constructed using the SATPLOT tool, resulting in prediction lead times of $-26.4 \pm 15.3$ hours. The geometrical models we use assume different CME front shapes (Fixed-$Φ$, Harmonic Mean, Self-Similar Expansion), and constant CME speed and direction. We find no significant superiority in the predictive capability of any of the three methods. The absolute difference between predicted and observed ICME arrival times is $8.1 \pm 6.3$ hours ($rms$ value of 10.9h). Speeds are consistent to within $284 \pm 288 \: km \: s^{-1}$. Empirical corrections to the predictions enhance their performance for the arrival times to $6.1 \pm 5.0$ hours ($rms$ value of 7.9h), and for the speeds to $53 \pm 50 \: km \: s^{-1}$. These results are important for Solar Orbiter and a space weather mission positioned away from the Sun-Earth line.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Quantitative Comparison of Methods for Predicting the Arrival of Coronal Mass Ejections at Earth based on multi-view imaging
Authors:
R. C. Colaninno,
A. Vourlidas,
C. -C. Wu
Abstract:
We investigate the performance of six methods for predicting the CME time of arrival (ToA) and velocity at Earth using a sample of nine Earth-impacting CMEs between May 2010 and June 2011. The CMEs were tracked continuously from the Sun to near Earth in multi-viewpoint imaging data from STEREO SECCHI and SOHO LASCO. We use the Graduate Cylindrical Shell (GCS) model to estimate the three-dimensiona…
▽ More
We investigate the performance of six methods for predicting the CME time of arrival (ToA) and velocity at Earth using a sample of nine Earth-impacting CMEs between May 2010 and June 2011. The CMEs were tracked continuously from the Sun to near Earth in multi-viewpoint imaging data from STEREO SECCHI and SOHO LASCO. We use the Graduate Cylindrical Shell (GCS) model to estimate the three-dimensional direction and height of the CMEs in every image out to $\sim$200 R$_\odot$. We fit the derived three-dimensional (deprojected) height and time data with six different methods to extrapolate the CME ToA and velocity at Earth. We compare the fitting results with the in situ data from the WIND spacecraft. We find that a simple linear fit after a height of 50$R_\odot$ gives the best ToA with a total error $\pm$13 hours. For seven (78%) of the CMEs, we are able to predict the ToA to within $\pm$6 hours. These results are a full day improvement over past CME arrival time methods that only used SOHO LASCO data. We conclude that heliographic measurements, beyond the coronagraphic field of view, of the CME front made away from the Sun-Earth line are essential for accurate predictions of their time of arrival.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2013; v1 submitted 24 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Investigation of the Forces that Govern the Three-Dimensional Propagation and Expansion of Coronal Mass Ejections from Sun to Earth
Authors:
Robin C. Colaninno
Abstract:
In this study, we analyze nine CMEs from the Sun to Earth as observed in both the remote sensing and in situ data sets. To date, this is the largest study of Earth impacting CMEs using the multi-view point remote sensing and in situ data. However, the remote sensing and in situ data of the same CME cannot be directly compared. Thus, we use several models to parameterize the two data sets. With the…
▽ More
In this study, we analyze nine CMEs from the Sun to Earth as observed in both the remote sensing and in situ data sets. To date, this is the largest study of Earth impacting CMEs using the multi-view point remote sensing and in situ data. However, the remote sensing and in situ data of the same CME cannot be directly compared. Thus, we use several models to parameterize the two data sets. With the model results, we are able to compare the arrival time, Earth impact speed, internal magnetic field, size and orientation as derived from the remote sensing and in situ methods. From the derived kinematics, we compare the predicted arrival times and impact velocities with the in situ data. We find that even with nearly continuous observations and the best available model of the CME structure, there is still a significant error in the predicted values. We estimate the various forces acting on the CME as predicted by three theoretical models of CME propagation and expansion and compare these results with the observational results. We find that the flux rope model of Chen (1989) provides the best agreement with the observations. With the flux rope model, we are able to predict the internal magnetic field of the CME near Earth from the remote sensing data to an order of magnitude. Finally, we compare the size and orientation of the CMEs as predicted from the remote sensing and in situ data. We find very little agreement between the values derived from the two data sets.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
First Determination of the True Mass of Coronal Mass Ejections: A Novel Approach to Using the Two STEREO Viewpoints
Authors:
Robin C. Colaninno,
Angelos Vourlidas
Abstract:
The twin Sun Earth Connection Coronal and Heliospheric Investigation (SECCHI) COR2 coronagraphs of the Solar Terrestrial Relations Observatory (STEREO) provide images of the solar corona from two view points in the solar system. Since their launch in late 2006, the STEREO Ahead (A) and Behind (B) spacecrafts have been slowly separating from Earth at a rate of 22.5 degrees per year. By the end of…
▽ More
The twin Sun Earth Connection Coronal and Heliospheric Investigation (SECCHI) COR2 coronagraphs of the Solar Terrestrial Relations Observatory (STEREO) provide images of the solar corona from two view points in the solar system. Since their launch in late 2006, the STEREO Ahead (A) and Behind (B) spacecrafts have been slowly separating from Earth at a rate of 22.5 degrees per year. By the end of 2007, the two spacecraft were separated by more than 40 degrees from each other. At this time, we began to see large-scale differences in the morphology and total intensity between coronal mass ejections (CMEs) observed with SECCHI-COR2 on STEREO-A and B. Due to the effects of the Thomson scattering geometry, the intensity of an observed CME is dependent on the angle it makes with the observed plane of the sky. From the intensity images, we can calculate the integrated line of sight electron density and mass. We demonstrate that is is possible to simultaneously derive the direction and true total mass of the CME if we make the simple assumption that the same mass should be observed in COR2-A and B.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
