-
HST SHEL: Enabling Comparative Exoplanetology with HST/STIS
Authors:
Natalie H. Allen,
David K. Sing,
Néstor Espinoza,
Richard O'Steen,
Nikolay K. Nikolov,
Zafar Rustamkulov,
Thomas M. Evans-Soma,
Lakeisha M. Ramos Rosado,
Munazza K. Alam,
Mercedes López-Morales,
Kevin B. Stevenson,
Hannah R. Wakeford,
Erin M. May,
Rafael Brahm,
Marcelo Tala Pinto
Abstract:
The Hubble Space Telescope (HST) has been our most prolific tool to study exoplanet atmospheres. As the age of JWST begins, there is a wealth of HST archival data that is useful to strengthen our inferences from JWST. Notably, HST/STIS and its 0.3-1 $μ$m wavelength coverage extends past JWST's 0.6 $μ$m wavelength cutoff and holds an abundance of potential information: alkali (Na, K) and molecular…
▽ More
The Hubble Space Telescope (HST) has been our most prolific tool to study exoplanet atmospheres. As the age of JWST begins, there is a wealth of HST archival data that is useful to strengthen our inferences from JWST. Notably, HST/STIS and its 0.3-1 $μ$m wavelength coverage extends past JWST's 0.6 $μ$m wavelength cutoff and holds an abundance of potential information: alkali (Na, K) and molecular (TiO, VO) species opacities, aerosol information, and the presence of stellar contamination. However, time series observations with HST suffer from significant instrumental systematics and can be highly dependent on choices made during the transit fitting process. This makes comparing transmission spectra of planets with different data reduction methodologies challenging, as it is difficult to discern if an observed trend is caused by differences in data reduction or underlying physical processes. Here, we present the Sculpting Hubble's Exoplanet Legacy (SHEL) program, which aims to build a consistent data reduction and light curve analysis methodology and associated database of transmission spectra from archival HST observations. In this paper, we present the SHEL analysis framework for HST/STIS and its low-resolution spectroscopy modes, G430L and G750L. We apply our methodology to four notable hot Jupiters: WASP-39 b, WASP-121 b, WASP-69 b, and WASP-17 b, and use these examples to discuss nuances behind analysis with HST/STIS. Our results for WASP-39 b, WASP-121 b, and WASP-17 b are consistent with past publications, but our analysis of WASP-69 b differs and shows evidence of either a strong scattering slope or stellar contamination. The data reduction pipeline and tutorials are available on Github.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
JWST-TST High Contrast: Achieving direct spectroscopy of faint substellar companions next to bright stars with the NIRSpec IFU
Authors:
Jean-Baptiste Ruffio,
Marshall D. Perrin,
Kielan K. W. Hoch,
Jens Kammerer,
Quinn M. Konopacky,
Laurent Pueyo,
Alex Madurowicz,
Emily Rickman,
Christopher A. Theissen,
Shubh Agrawal,
Alexandra Z. Greenbaum,
Brittany E. Miles,
Travis S. Barman,
William O. Balmer,
Jorge Llop-Sayson,
Julien H. Girard,
Isabel Rebollido,
Rémi Soummer,
Natalie H. Allen,
Jay Anderson,
Charles A. Beichman,
Andrea Bellini,
Geoffrey Bryden,
Néstor Espinoza,
Ana Glidden
, et al. (11 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The JWST NIRSpec integral field unit (IFU) presents a unique opportunity to observe directly imaged exoplanets from 3-5 um at moderate spectral resolution (R~2,700) and thereby better constrain the composition, disequilibrium chemistry, and cloud properties of their atmospheres. In this work, we present the first NIRSpec IFU high-contrast observations of a substellar companion that requires starli…
▽ More
The JWST NIRSpec integral field unit (IFU) presents a unique opportunity to observe directly imaged exoplanets from 3-5 um at moderate spectral resolution (R~2,700) and thereby better constrain the composition, disequilibrium chemistry, and cloud properties of their atmospheres. In this work, we present the first NIRSpec IFU high-contrast observations of a substellar companion that requires starlight suppression techniques. We develop specific data reduction strategies to study faint companions around bright stars, and assess the performance of NIRSpec at high contrast. First, we demonstrate an approach to forward model the companion signal and the starlight directly in the detector images, which mitigates the effects of NIRSpec's spatial undersampling. We demonstrate a sensitivity to planets that are 3e-6 fainter than their stars at 1'', or 3e-5 at 0.3''. Then, we implement a reference star point spread function (PSF) subtraction and a spectral extraction that does not require spatially and spectrally regularly sampled spectral cubes. This allows us to extract a moderate resolution (R~2,700) spectrum of the faint T-dwarf companion HD 19467 B from 2.9-5.2 um with signal-to-noise ratio (S/N)~10 per resolution element. Across this wavelength range, HD~19467~B has a flux ratio varying between 1e-5-1e-4 and a separation relative to its star of 1.6''. A companion paper by Hoch et al. more deeply analyzes the atmospheric properties of this companion based on the extracted spectrum. Using the methods developed here, NIRSpec's sensitivity may enable direct detection and spectral characterization of relatively old (~1 Gyr), cool (~250 K), and closely separated (~3-5 au) exoplanets that are less massive than Jupiter.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2024; v1 submitted 15 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
JWST-TST DREAMS: Quartz Clouds in the Atmosphere of WASP-17b
Authors:
David Grant,
Nikole K. Lewis,
Hannah R. Wakeford,
Natasha E. Batalha,
Ana Glidden,
Jayesh Goyal,
Elijah Mullens,
Ryan J. MacDonald,
Erin M. May,
Sara Seager,
Kevin B. Stevenson,
Jeff A. Valenti,
Channon Visscher,
Lili Alderson,
Natalie H. Allen,
Caleb I. Cañas,
Knicole Colón,
Mark Clampin,
Néstor Espinoza,
Amélie Gressier,
**gcheng Huang,
Zifan Lin,
Douglas Long,
Dana R. Louie,
Maria Peña-Guerrero
, et al. (17 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Clouds are prevalent in many of the exoplanet atmospheres that have been observed to date. For transiting exoplanets, we know if clouds are present because they mute spectral features and cause wavelength-dependent scattering. While the exact composition of these clouds is largely unknown, this information is vital to understanding the chemistry and energy budget of planetary atmospheres. In this…
▽ More
Clouds are prevalent in many of the exoplanet atmospheres that have been observed to date. For transiting exoplanets, we know if clouds are present because they mute spectral features and cause wavelength-dependent scattering. While the exact composition of these clouds is largely unknown, this information is vital to understanding the chemistry and energy budget of planetary atmospheres. In this work, we observe one transit of the hot Jupiter WASP-17b with JWST's MIRI LRS and generate a transmission spectrum from 5-12 $\rmμ$m. These wavelengths allow us to probe absorption due to the vibrational modes of various predicted cloud species. Our transmission spectrum shows additional opacity centered at 8.6 $\rmμ$m, and detailed atmospheric modeling and retrievals identify this feature as SiO$_2$(s) (quartz) clouds. The SiO$_2$(s) clouds model is preferred at 3.5-4.2$σ$ versus a cloud-free model and at 2.6$σ$ versus a generic aerosol prescription. We find the SiO$_2$(s) clouds are comprised of small ${\sim}0.01$ $\rmμ$m particles, which extend to high altitudes in the atmosphere. The atmosphere also shows a depletion of H$_2$O, a finding consistent with the formation of high-temperature aerosols from oxygen-rich species. This work is part of a series of studies by our JWST Telescope Scientist Team (JWST-TST), in which we will use Guaranteed Time Observations to perform Deep Reconnaissance of Exoplanet Atmospheres through Multi-instrument Spectroscopy (DREAMS).
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
ACCESS, LRG-BEASTS, & MOPSS: Featureless Optical Transmission Spectra of WASP-25b and WASP-124b
Authors:
Chima D. McGruder,
Mercedes López-Morales,
James Kirk,
Erin May,
Benjamin V. Rackham,
Munazza K. Alam,
Natalie H. Allen,
John D. Monnier,
Kelly Meyer,
Tyler Gardner,
Kevin Ortiz Ceballos,
Eva-Maria Ahrer,
Peter J. Wheatley,
George W. King,
Andrés Jordán,
David J. Osip,
Néstor Espinoza
Abstract:
We present new optical transmission spectra for two hot Jupiters: WASP-25b (M = 0.56~M$_J$; R = 1.23 R$_J$; P =~3.76 days) and WASP-124b (M = 0.58~M$_J$; R = 1.34 R$_J$; P = 3.37 days), with wavelength coverages of 4200 - 9100Å and 4570 - 9940Å, respectively. These spectra are from the ESO Faint Object Spectrograph and Camera (v.2) mounted on the New Technology Telescope (NTT) and Inamori-Magellan…
▽ More
We present new optical transmission spectra for two hot Jupiters: WASP-25b (M = 0.56~M$_J$; R = 1.23 R$_J$; P =~3.76 days) and WASP-124b (M = 0.58~M$_J$; R = 1.34 R$_J$; P = 3.37 days), with wavelength coverages of 4200 - 9100Å and 4570 - 9940Å, respectively. These spectra are from the ESO Faint Object Spectrograph and Camera (v.2) mounted on the New Technology Telescope (NTT) and Inamori-Magellan Areal Camera & Spectrograph on Magellan Baade. No strong spectral features were found in either spectra, with the data probing 4 and 6 scale heights, respectively. \texttt{Exoretrievals} and \texttt{PLATON} retrievals favor stellar activity for WASP-25b, while the data for WASP-124b did not favor one model over another. For both planets the retrievals found a wide range in the depths where the atmosphere could be optically thick ($\sim0.4μ$ - 0.2 bars for WASP-25b and 1.6 $μ$ -- 32 bars for WASP-124b) and recovered a temperature that is consistent with the planets' equilibrium temperatures, but with wide uncertainties (up to $\pm$430$^\circ$K). For WASP-25b, the models also favor stellar spots that are $\sim$500-3000$^\circ$K cooler than the surrounding photosphere. The fairly weak constraints on parameters are owing to the relatively low precision of the data, with an average precision of 840 and 1240 ppm per bin for WASP-25b and WASP-124b, respectively. However, some contribution might still be due to an inherent absence of absorption or scattering in the planets' upper atmospheres, possibly because of aerosols. We attempt to fit the strength of the sodium signals to the aerosol-metallicity trend proposed by McGruder et al. 2023, and find WASP-25b and WASP-124b are consistent with the prediction, though their uncertainties are too large to confidently confirm the trend.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2023; v1 submitted 11 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Early Release Science of the exoplanet WASP-39b with JWST NIRISS
Authors:
Adina D. Feinstein,
Michael Radica,
Luis Welbanks,
Catriona Anne Murray,
Kazumasa Ohno,
Louis-Philippe Coulombe,
Néstor Espinoza,
Jacob L. Bean,
Johanna K. Teske,
Björn Benneke,
Michael R. Line,
Zafar Rustamkulov,
Arianna Saba,
Angelos Tsiaras,
Joanna K. Barstow,
Jonathan J. Fortney,
Peter Gao,
Heather A. Knutson,
Ryan J. MacDonald,
Thomas Mikal-Evans,
Benjamin V. Rackham,
Jake Taylor,
Vivien Parmentier,
Natalie M. Batalha,
Zachory K. Berta-Thompson
, et al. (64 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Transmission spectroscopy provides insight into the atmospheric properties and consequently the formation history, physics, and chemistry of transiting exoplanets. However, obtaining precise inferences of atmospheric properties from transmission spectra requires simultaneously measuring the strength and shape of multiple spectral absorption features from a wide range of chemical species. This has…
▽ More
Transmission spectroscopy provides insight into the atmospheric properties and consequently the formation history, physics, and chemistry of transiting exoplanets. However, obtaining precise inferences of atmospheric properties from transmission spectra requires simultaneously measuring the strength and shape of multiple spectral absorption features from a wide range of chemical species. This has been challenging given the precision and wavelength coverage of previous observatories. Here, we present the transmission spectrum of the Saturn-mass exoplanet WASP-39b obtained using the SOSS mode of the NIRISS instrument on the JWST. This spectrum spans $0.6 - 2.8 μ$m in wavelength and reveals multiple water absorption bands, the potassium resonance doublet, as well as signatures of clouds. The precision and broad wavelength coverage of NIRISS-SOSS allows us to break model degeneracies between cloud properties and the atmospheric composition of WASP-39b, favoring a heavy element enhancement ("metallicity") of $\sim 10 - 30 \times$ the solar value, a sub-solar carbon-to-oxygen (C/O) ratio, and a solar-to-super-solar potassium-to-oxygen (K/O) ratio. The observations are best explained by wavelength-dependent, non-gray clouds with inhomogeneous coverage of the planet's terminator.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Early Release Science of the exoplanet WASP-39b with JWST NIRCam
Authors:
Eva-Maria Ahrer,
Kevin B. Stevenson,
Megan Mansfield,
Sarah E. Moran,
Jonathan Brande,
Giuseppe Morello,
Catriona A. Murray,
Nikolay K. Nikolov,
Dominique J. M. Petit dit de la Roche,
Everett Schlawin,
Peter J. Wheatley,
Sebastian Zieba,
Natasha E. Batalha,
Mario Damiano,
Jayesh M Goyal,
Monika Lendl,
Joshua D. Lothringer,
Sagnick Mukherjee,
Kazumasa Ohno,
Natalie M. Batalha,
Matthew P. Battley,
Jacob L. Bean,
Thomas G. Beatty,
Björn Benneke,
Zachory K. Berta-Thompson
, et al. (74 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Measuring the metallicity and carbon-to-oxygen (C/O) ratio in exoplanet atmospheres is a fundamental step towards constraining the dominant chemical processes at work and, if in equilibrium, revealing planet formation histories. Transmission spectroscopy provides the necessary means by constraining the abundances of oxygen- and carbon-bearing species; however, this requires broad wavelength covera…
▽ More
Measuring the metallicity and carbon-to-oxygen (C/O) ratio in exoplanet atmospheres is a fundamental step towards constraining the dominant chemical processes at work and, if in equilibrium, revealing planet formation histories. Transmission spectroscopy provides the necessary means by constraining the abundances of oxygen- and carbon-bearing species; however, this requires broad wavelength coverage, moderate spectral resolution, and high precision that, together, are not achievable with previous observatories. Now that JWST has commenced science operations, we are able to observe exoplanets at previously uncharted wavelengths and spectral resolutions. Here we report time-series observations of the transiting exoplanet WASP-39b using JWST's Near InfraRed Camera (NIRCam). The long-wavelength spectroscopic and short-wavelength photometric light curves span 2.0 - 4.0 $μ$m, exhibit minimal systematics, and reveal well-defined molecular absorption features in the planet's spectrum. Specifically, we detect gaseous H$_2$O in the atmosphere and place an upper limit on the abundance of CH$_4$. The otherwise prominent CO$_2$ feature at 2.8 $μ$m is largely masked by H$_2$O. The best-fit chemical equilibrium models favour an atmospheric metallicity of 1-100$\times$ solar (i.e., an enrichment of elements heavier than helium relative to the Sun) and a sub-stellar carbon-to-oxygen (C/O) ratio. The inferred high metallicity and low C/O ratio may indicate significant accretion of solid materials during planet formation or disequilibrium processes in the upper atmosphere.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Early Release Science of the Exoplanet WASP-39b with JWST NIRSpec G395H
Authors:
Lili Alderson,
Hannah R. Wakeford,
Munazza K. Alam,
Natasha E. Batalha,
Joshua D. Lothringer,
Jea Adams Redai,
Saugata Barat,
Jonathan Brande,
Mario Damiano,
Tansu Daylan,
Néstor Espinoza,
Laura Flagg,
Jayesh M. Goyal,
David Grant,
Renyu Hu,
Julie Inglis,
Elspeth K. H. Lee,
Thomas Mikal-Evans,
Lakeisha Ramos-Rosado,
Pierre-Alexis Roy,
Nicole L. Wallack,
Natalie M. Batalha,
Jacob L. Bean,
Björn Benneke,
Zachory K. Berta-Thompson
, et al. (67 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Measuring the abundances of carbon and oxygen in exoplanet atmospheres is considered a crucial avenue for unlocking the formation and evolution of exoplanetary systems. Access to an exoplanet's chemical inventory requires high-precision observations, often inferred from individual molecular detections with low-resolution space-based and high-resolution ground-based facilities. Here we report the m…
▽ More
Measuring the abundances of carbon and oxygen in exoplanet atmospheres is considered a crucial avenue for unlocking the formation and evolution of exoplanetary systems. Access to an exoplanet's chemical inventory requires high-precision observations, often inferred from individual molecular detections with low-resolution space-based and high-resolution ground-based facilities. Here we report the medium-resolution (R$\sim$600) transmission spectrum of an exoplanet atmosphere between 3-5 $μ$m covering multiple absorption features for the Saturn-mass exoplanet WASP-39b, obtained with JWST NIRSpec G395H. Our observations achieve 1.46x photon precision, providing an average transit depth uncertainty of 221 ppm per spectroscopic bin, and present minimal impacts from systematic effects. We detect significant absorption from CO$_2$ (28.5$σ$) and H$_2$O (21.5$σ$), and identify SO$_2$ as the source of absorption at 4.1 $μ$m (4.8$σ$). Best-fit atmospheric models range between 3 and 10x solar metallicity, with sub-solar to solar C/O ratios. These results, including the detection of SO$_2$, underscore the importance of characterising the chemistry in exoplanet atmospheres, and showcase NIRSpec G395H as an excellent mode for time series observations over this critical wavelength range.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Early Release Science of the exoplanet WASP-39b with JWST NIRSpec PRISM
Authors:
Z. Rustamkulov,
D. K. Sing,
S. Mukherjee,
E. M. May,
J. Kirk,
E. Schlawin,
M. R. Line,
C. Piaulet,
A. L. Carter,
N. E. Batalha,
J. M. Goyal,
M. López-Morales,
J. D. Lothringer,
R. J. MacDonald,
S. E. Moran,
K. B. Stevenson,
H. R. Wakeford,
N. Espinoza,
J. L. Bean,
N. M. Batalha,
B. Benneke,
Z. K. Berta-Thompson,
I. J. M. Crossfield,
P. Gao,
L. Kreidberg
, et al. (69 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Transmission spectroscopy of exoplanets has revealed signatures of water vapor, aerosols, and alkali metals in a few dozen exoplanet atmospheres. However, these previous inferences with the Hubble and Spitzer Space Telescopes were hindered by the observations' relatively narrow wavelength range and spectral resolving power, which precluded the unambiguous identification of other chemical species…
▽ More
Transmission spectroscopy of exoplanets has revealed signatures of water vapor, aerosols, and alkali metals in a few dozen exoplanet atmospheres. However, these previous inferences with the Hubble and Spitzer Space Telescopes were hindered by the observations' relatively narrow wavelength range and spectral resolving power, which precluded the unambiguous identification of other chemical species$-$in particular the primary carbon-bearing molecules. Here we report a broad-wavelength 0.5-5.5 $μ$m atmospheric transmission spectrum of WASP-39 b, a 1200 K, roughly Saturn-mass, Jupiter-radius exoplanet, measured with JWST NIRSpec's PRISM mode as part of the JWST Transiting Exoplanet Community Early Release Science Team program. We robustly detect multiple chemical species at high significance, including Na (19$σ$), H$_2$O (33$σ$), CO$_2$ (28$σ$), and CO (7$σ$). The non-detection of CH$_4$, combined with a strong CO$_2$ feature, favours atmospheric models with a super-solar atmospheric metallicity. An unanticipated absorption feature at 4$μ$m is best explained by SO$_2$ (2.7$σ$), which could be a tracer of atmospheric photochemistry. These observations demonstrate JWST's sensitivity to a rich diversity of exoplanet compositions and chemical processes.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
ACCESS: Tentative detection of H$_2$O in the ground-based optical transmission spectrum of the low-density hot Saturn HATS-5b
Authors:
Natalie H. Allen,
Néstor Espinoza,
Andrés Jordán,
Mercedes López-Morales,
Dániel Apai,
Benjamin V. Rackham,
James Kirk,
David J. Osip,
Ian C. Weaver,
Chima McGruder,
Kevin Ortiz Ceballos,
Henrique Reggiani,
Rafael Brahm,
Florian Rodler,
Nikole K Lewis,
Jonathan Fraine
Abstract:
We present a precise ground-based optical transmission spectrum of the hot-Saturn HATS-5b ($T_{eq} =1025$ K), obtained as part of the ACCESS survey with the IMACS multi-object spectrograph mounted on the Magellan/Baade Telescope. Our spectra cover the 0.5 to 0.9 micron region, and are the product of 5 individual transits observed between 2014 and 2018. We introduce the usage of additional second-o…
▽ More
We present a precise ground-based optical transmission spectrum of the hot-Saturn HATS-5b ($T_{eq} =1025$ K), obtained as part of the ACCESS survey with the IMACS multi-object spectrograph mounted on the Magellan/Baade Telescope. Our spectra cover the 0.5 to 0.9 micron region, and are the product of 5 individual transits observed between 2014 and 2018. We introduce the usage of additional second-order light in our analyses which allows us to extract an "extra" transit light curve, improving the overall precision of our combined transit spectrum. We find that the favored atmospheric model for this transmission spectrum is a solar-metallicity atmosphere with sub-solar C/O, whose features are dominated by H$_2$O and with a depleted abundance of Na and K. If confirmed, this would point to a "clear" atmosphere at the pressure levels probed by transmission spectroscopy for HATS-5b. Our best-fit atmospheric model predicts a rich near-IR spectrum, which makes this exoplanet an excellent target for future follow-up observations with the James Webb Space Telescope, both to confirm this H$_2$O detection and to superbly constrain the atmosphere's parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Identification of carbon dioxide in an exoplanet atmosphere
Authors:
The JWST Transiting Exoplanet Community Early Release Science Team,
Eva-Maria Ahrer,
Lili Alderson,
Natalie M. Batalha,
Natasha E. Batalha,
Jacob L. Bean,
Thomas G. Beatty,
Taylor J. Bell,
Björn Benneke,
Zachory K. Berta-Thompson,
Aarynn L. Carter,
Ian J. M. Crossfield,
Néstor Espinoza,
Adina D. Feinstein,
Jonathan J. Fortney,
Neale P. Gibson,
Jayesh M. Goyal,
Eliza M. -R. Kempton,
James Kirk,
Laura Kreidberg,
Mercedes López-Morales,
Michael R. Line,
Joshua D. Lothringer,
Sarah E. Moran,
Sagnick Mukherjee
, et al. (107 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Carbon dioxide (CO2) is a key chemical species that is found in a wide range of planetary atmospheres. In the context of exoplanets, CO2 is an indicator of the metal enrichment (i.e., elements heavier than helium, also called "metallicity"), and thus formation processes of the primary atmospheres of hot gas giants. It is also one of the most promising species to detect in the secondary atmospheres…
▽ More
Carbon dioxide (CO2) is a key chemical species that is found in a wide range of planetary atmospheres. In the context of exoplanets, CO2 is an indicator of the metal enrichment (i.e., elements heavier than helium, also called "metallicity"), and thus formation processes of the primary atmospheres of hot gas giants. It is also one of the most promising species to detect in the secondary atmospheres of terrestrial exoplanets. Previous photometric measurements of transiting planets with the Spitzer Space Telescope have given hints of the presence of CO2 but have not yielded definitive detections due to the lack of unambiguous spectroscopic identification. Here we present the detection of CO2 in the atmosphere of the gas giant exoplanet WASP-39b from transmission spectroscopy observations obtained with JWST as part of the Early Release Science Program (ERS). The data used in this study span 3.0 to 5.5 μm in wavelength and show a prominent CO2 absorption feature at 4.3 μm (26σ significance). The overall spectrum is well matched by one-dimensional, 10x solar metallicity models that assume radiative-convective-thermochemical equilibrium and have moderate cloud opacity. These models predict that the atmosphere should have water, carbon monoxide, and hydrogen sulfide in addition to CO2, but little methane. Furthermore, we also tentatively detect a small absorption feature near 4.0 μm that is not reproduced by these models.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
