-
The Potential of Asteroseismology to Resolve the Blue Supergiant Problem
Authors:
Earl Patrick Bellinger,
Selma E. de Mink,
Walter E. van Rossem,
Stephen Justham
Abstract:
Despite major progress in our understanding of massive stars, concerning discrepancies still remain between observations and theory. Most notable are the numerous stars observed beyond the theoretical main sequence, an evolutionary phase expected to be short-lived and hence sparsely populated. This is the "Blue Supergiant Problem." Stellar models with abnormal internal structures can provide long-…
▽ More
Despite major progress in our understanding of massive stars, concerning discrepancies still remain between observations and theory. Most notable are the numerous stars observed beyond the theoretical main sequence, an evolutionary phase expected to be short-lived and hence sparsely populated. This is the "Blue Supergiant Problem." Stellar models with abnormal internal structures can provide long-lived solutions for this problem: core hydrogen-burning stars with oversized cores may explain the hotter ones, and core helium-burning stars with undersized cores may explain the cooler ones. Such stars may result from enhanced or suppressed mixing in single stars, or, more likely, as the products of binary interaction and stellar mergers.
Here we investigate the potential of asteroseismology to uncover the nature of blue supergiants. We construct stellar models for the above scenarios and show that they predict $g$-mode period spacings that differ by an order of magnitude: $\sim$ 200~min versus $\sim$ 20~min for long-lived core H and He burning stars, respectively. For the classical scenario of H-shell-burning stars rapidly crossing the Hertzsprung gap, we furthermore predict changes of the order of $10^{-2}\,μ\rm{Hz\,yr}^{-1}$ in high-frequency modes; this effect would be in principle observable from $\sim 5$~yr of asteroseismic monitoring if these modes can be identified. This raises the possibility of revealing the internal structure of blue supergiants, and thus determining whether these stars are indeed binary merger products. These asteroseismic diagnostics may be measurable through long time-series observations from the ongoing TESS mission and upcoming PLATO mission, thereby laying a path toward resolving the blue supergiant problem.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2024; v1 submitted 31 October, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Red Horizontal Branch stars: an asteroseismic perspective
Authors:
Massimiliano Matteuzzi,
Josefina Montalbán,
Andrea Miglio,
Mathieu Vrard,
Giada Casali,
Amalie Stokholm,
Marco Tailo,
Warrick Ball,
Walter E. van Rossem,
Marica Valentini
Abstract:
Robust age estimates of red giant stars are now possible thanks to the precise inference of their mass based on asteroseismic constraints. However, there are cases where such age estimates can be highly precise yet very inaccurate. An example is giants that have undergone mass loss or mass transfer events that have significantly altered their mass. In this context, stars with "apparent" ages signi…
▽ More
Robust age estimates of red giant stars are now possible thanks to the precise inference of their mass based on asteroseismic constraints. However, there are cases where such age estimates can be highly precise yet very inaccurate. An example is giants that have undergone mass loss or mass transfer events that have significantly altered their mass. In this context, stars with "apparent" ages significantly higher than the age of the Universe are candidates as stripped stars, or stars that have lost more mass than expected, most likely via interaction with a companion star, or because of the poorly understood mass-loss mechanism along the red-giant branch. In this work we identify examples of such objects among red giants observed by $\textit{Kepler}$, both at low ([Fe/H] $ \lesssim -0.5$) and solar metallicity. By modelling their structure and pulsation spectra, we find a consistent picture confirming that these are indeed low-mass objects consisting of a He core of $\approx 0.5 \, M_\odot$ and an envelope of $\approx 0.1 - 0.2 \, M_\odot$. Moreover, we find that these stars are characterised by a rather extreme coupling ($q \gtrsim 0.4$) between the pressure-mode and gravity-mode cavities, i.e. much higher than the typical value for red clump stars, providing thus a direct seismic signature of their peculiar structure. The complex pulsation spectra of these objects, if observed with sufficient frequency resolution, hold detailed information about the structural properties of likely products of mass strip**, hence can potentially shed light on their formation mechanism. On the other hand, our tests highlight the difficulties associated with measuring reliably the large frequency separation, especially in shorter datasets, with impact on the reliability of the inferred masses and ages of low-mass Red Clump stars with e.g. K2 or TESS data.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Chronologically dating the early assembly of the Milky Way
Authors:
Josefina Montalbán,
John Ted Mackereth,
Andrea Miglio,
Fiorenzo Vincenzo,
Cristina Chiappini,
Gaël Buldgen,
Benoît Mosser,
Arlette Noels,
Richard Scuflaire,
Mathieu Vrard,
Emma Willett,
Guy R. Davies,
Oliver Hall,
Martin Bo Nielsen,
Saniya Khan,
Ben M. Rendle,
Walter E. van Rossem,
Jason W. Ferguson,
William J. Chaplin
Abstract:
The standard cosmological model ($Λ$-CDM) predicts that galaxies are built through hierarchical assembly on cosmological timescales$^{1,2}$. The Milky Way, like other disc galaxies, underwent violent mergers and accretion of small satellite galaxies in its early history. Thanks to Gaia-DR2$^3$ and spectroscopic surveys$^4$, the stellar remnants of such mergers have been identified$^{5-7}$. The chr…
▽ More
The standard cosmological model ($Λ$-CDM) predicts that galaxies are built through hierarchical assembly on cosmological timescales$^{1,2}$. The Milky Way, like other disc galaxies, underwent violent mergers and accretion of small satellite galaxies in its early history. Thanks to Gaia-DR2$^3$ and spectroscopic surveys$^4$, the stellar remnants of such mergers have been identified$^{5-7}$. The chronological dating of such events is crucial to uncover the formation and evolution of the Galaxy at high redshift, but it has so far been challenging owing to difficulties in obtaining precise ages for these oldest stars. Here we combine asteroseismology -- the study of stellar oscillations -- with kinematics and chemical abundances, to estimate precise stellar ages ($\sim$ 11%) for a sample of stars observed by the $\mathit{Kepler}$ space mission$^8$. Crucially, this sample includes not only some of the oldest stars that were formed inside the Galaxy, but also stars formed externally and subsequently accreted onto the Milky Way. Leveraging this resolution in age, we provide compelling evidence in favour of models in which the Galaxy had already formed a substantial population of its stars (which now reside mainly in its thick disc) before the in-fall of the satellite galaxy Gaia-Enceladus/Sausage$^{5,6}$ around 10 billions years ago
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2021; v1 submitted 2 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Age dating of an early Milky Way merger via asteroseismology of the naked-eye star $ν$ Indi
Authors:
William J. Chaplin,
Aldo M. Serenelli,
Andrea Miglio,
Thierry Morel,
J. Ted Mackereth,
Fiorenzo Vincenzo,
Hans Kjeldsen Sarbani Basu,
Warrick H. Ball,
Amalie Stokholm,
Kuldeep Verma,
Jakob Rørsted Mosumgaard,
Victor Silva Aguirre,
Anwesh Mazumdar,
Pritesh Ranadive,
H. M. Antia,
Yveline Lebreton,
Joel Ong,
Thierry Appourchaux,
Timothy R. Bedding,
Jørgen Christensen-Dalsgaard,
Orlagh Creevey,
Rafael A. García,
Rasmus Handberg,
Daniel Huber,
Steven D. Kawaler
, et al. (59 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Over the course of its history, the Milky Way has ingested multiple smaller satellite galaxies. While these accreted stellar populations can be forensically identified as kinematically distinct structures within the Galaxy, it is difficult in general to precisely date the age at which any one merger occurred. Recent results have revealed a population of stars that were accreted via the collision o…
▽ More
Over the course of its history, the Milky Way has ingested multiple smaller satellite galaxies. While these accreted stellar populations can be forensically identified as kinematically distinct structures within the Galaxy, it is difficult in general to precisely date the age at which any one merger occurred. Recent results have revealed a population of stars that were accreted via the collision of a dwarf galaxy, called \textit{Gaia}-Enceladus, leading to a substantial pollution of the chemical and dynamical properties of the Milky Way. Here, we identify the very bright, naked-eye star $ν$\,Indi as a probe of the age of the early in situ population of the Galaxy. We combine asteroseismic, spectroscopic, astrometric, and kinematic observations to show that this metal-poor, alpha-element-rich star was an indigenous member of the halo, and we measure its age to be $11.0 \pm 0.7$ (stat) $\pm 0.8$ (sys)$\,\rm Gyr$. The star bears hallmarks consistent with it having been kinematically heated by the \textit{Gaia}-Enceladus collision. Its age implies that the earliest the merger could have begun was 11.6 and 13.2 Gyr ago at 68 and 95% confidence, respectively. Input from computations based on hierarchical cosmological models tightens (i.e. reduces) slightly the above limits.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
