-
Universality of swap for qudits: a representation theory approach
Authors:
James R. van Meter
Abstract:
An open problem of quantum information theory has been to determine under what conditions universal exchange-only computation is possible for qudits encoded on $d$-state systems for $d>2$. This problem can be posed in terms of representation theory by recognizing that each quantum mechanical swap, generated by exchange-interaction, can be identified with a transposition in a symmetric group, each…
▽ More
An open problem of quantum information theory has been to determine under what conditions universal exchange-only computation is possible for qudits encoded on $d$-state systems for $d>2$. This problem can be posed in terms of representation theory by recognizing that each quantum mechanical swap, generated by exchange-interaction, can be identified with a transposition in a symmetric group, each $d$-state system can be identified with the fundamental representation of $SU(d)$, and each encoded qudit can be identified with an irreducible representation of a Lie algebra generated by transpositions. Towards this end we first give a mathematical definition of exchange-only universality in terms of a map from the special unitary algebra on the product of qudits into a representation of a Lie algebra generated by transpositions. We show that this definition is consistent with quantum computing requirements. We then proceed with the task of characterizing universal families of qudits, that is families of encoded qudits admitting exchange-only universality. This endeavor is aided by the fact that the irreducible representations corresponding to qudits are canonically labeled by partitions. In particular we derive necessary and sufficient conditions for universality on one or two such qudits, in terms of simple arithmetic conditions on the associated partitions. We also derive necessary and sufficient conditions for universality on arbitrarily many such qudits, in terms of Littlewood--Richardson coefficients. Among other results, we prove that universal families of multiple qudits are upward closed, that universality is guaranteed for sufficiently many qudits, and that any family that is not universal can be made so by simply adding at most five ancillae. We also obtain results for 2-state systems as a special case.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Approximate exchange-only entangling gates for the three-spin-$1/2$ decoherence-free subsystem
Authors:
James. R. van Meter,
Emanuel Knill
Abstract:
The three-spin-$1/2$ decoherence-free subsystem defines a logical qubit protected from collective noise and supports exchange-only universal gates. Such logical qubits are well-suited for implementation with electrically-defined quantum dots. Exact exchange-only entangling logical gates exist but are challenging to construct and understand. We use a decoupling strategy to obtain straightforward ap…
▽ More
The three-spin-$1/2$ decoherence-free subsystem defines a logical qubit protected from collective noise and supports exchange-only universal gates. Such logical qubits are well-suited for implementation with electrically-defined quantum dots. Exact exchange-only entangling logical gates exist but are challenging to construct and understand. We use a decoupling strategy to obtain straightforward approximate entangling gates. A benefit of the strategy is that if the physical spins are aligned, then it can implement evolution under entangling Hamiltonians. Hamiltonians expressible as linear combinations of logical Pauli products not involving $σ_y$ can be implemented directly. Self-inverse gates that are constructible from these Hamiltonians, such as the CNOT, can be implemented without the assumption on the physical spins. We compare the control complexity of implementing CNOT to previous methods and find that the complexity for fault-tolerant fidelities is competitive.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2019; v1 submitted 20 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Dark-matter-like solutions to Einstein's unified field equations
Authors:
J. R. van Meter
Abstract:
Einstein originally proposed a nonsymmetric tensor field, with its symmetric part associated with the spacetime metric and its antisymmetric part associated with the electromagnetic field, as an approach to a unified field theory. Here we interpret it more modestly as an alternative to Einstein-Maxwell theory, approximating the coupling between the electromagnetic field and spacetime curvature in…
▽ More
Einstein originally proposed a nonsymmetric tensor field, with its symmetric part associated with the spacetime metric and its antisymmetric part associated with the electromagnetic field, as an approach to a unified field theory. Here we interpret it more modestly as an alternative to Einstein-Maxwell theory, approximating the coupling between the electromagnetic field and spacetime curvature in the macroscopic classical regime. Previously it was shown that the Lorentz force can be derived from this theory, albeit with deviation on the scale of a universal length constant $\ell$. Here we assume that $\ell$ is of galactic scale and show that the modified coupling of the electromagnetic field with charged particles allows a non-Maxwellian equilibrium of non-neutral plasma. The resulting electromagnetic field is "dark" in the sense that its modified Lorentz force on the plasma vanishes, yet through its modified coupling to the gravitational field it engenders a nonvanishing, effective mass density. We obtain a solution for which this mass density asymptotes approximately to that of the pseudo-isothermal model of dark matter. The resulting gravitational field produces radial acceleration, in the context of a post-Minkowskian approximation, which is negligible at small radius but yields a flat rotation curve at large radius. We further exhibit a family of such solutions which, like the pseudo-isothermal model, has a free parameter to set the mass scale (in this case related to the charge density) and a free parameter to set the length scale (in this case an integer multiple of $\ell$). Moreover, these solutions are members of a larger family with more general angular and radial dependence. They thus show promise as approximations of generalized pseudo-isothermal models, which in turn are known to fit a wide range of mass density profiles for galaxies and clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Quantum Estimation of Parameters of Classical Spacetimes
Authors:
T. G. Downes,
J. R. van Meter,
E. Knill,
G. J. Milburn,
C. M. Caves
Abstract:
We describe a quantum limit to measurement of classical spacetimes. Specifically, we formulate a quantum Cramer-Rao lower bound for estimating the single parameter in any one-parameter family of spacetime metrics. We employ the locally covariant formulation of quantum field theory in curved spacetime, which allows for a manifestly background-independent derivation. The result is an uncertainty rel…
▽ More
We describe a quantum limit to measurement of classical spacetimes. Specifically, we formulate a quantum Cramer-Rao lower bound for estimating the single parameter in any one-parameter family of spacetime metrics. We employ the locally covariant formulation of quantum field theory in curved spacetime, which allows for a manifestly background-independent derivation. The result is an uncertainty relation that applies to all globally hyperbolic spacetimes. Among other examples, we apply our method to detection of gravitational waves using the electromagnetic field as a probe, as in laser-interferometric gravitational-wave detectors. Other applications are discussed, from terrestrial gravimetry to cosmology.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2017; v1 submitted 16 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
General Relativistic Simulations of Magnetized Plasmas around Merging Supermassive Black Holes
Authors:
Bruno Giacomazzo,
John G. Baker,
M. Coleman Miller,
Christopher S. Reynolds,
James R. van Meter
Abstract:
Coalescing supermassive black hole binaries are produced by the mergers of galaxies and are the most powerful sources of gravitational waves accessible to space-based gravitational observatories. Some such mergers may occur in the presence of matter and magnetic fields and hence generate an electromagnetic counterpart. In this Letter, we present the first general relativistic simulations of magnet…
▽ More
Coalescing supermassive black hole binaries are produced by the mergers of galaxies and are the most powerful sources of gravitational waves accessible to space-based gravitational observatories. Some such mergers may occur in the presence of matter and magnetic fields and hence generate an electromagnetic counterpart. In this Letter, we present the first general relativistic simulations of magnetized plasma around merging supermassive black holes using the general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic code Whisky. By considering different magnetic field strengths, going from non-magnetically dominated to magnetically dominated regimes, we explore how magnetic fields affect the dynamics of the plasma and the possible emission of electromagnetic signals. In particular we observe a total amplification of the magnetic field of ~2 orders of magnitude which is driven by the accretion onto the binary and that leads to much stronger electromagnetic signals, more than a factor of 10^4 larger than comparable calculations done in the force-free regime where such amplifications are not possible.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2012; v1 submitted 27 March, 2012;
originally announced March 2012.
-
Schrödinger-Newton "collapse" of the wave function
Authors:
J. R. van Meter
Abstract:
It has been suggested that the nonlinear Schrödinger-Newton equation might approximate the coupling of quantum mechanics with gravitation, particularly in the context of the Møller-Rosenfeld semiclassical theory. Numerical results for the spherically symmetric, time-dependent, single-particle case are presented, clarifying and extending previous work on the subject. It is found that, for a particl…
▽ More
It has been suggested that the nonlinear Schrödinger-Newton equation might approximate the coupling of quantum mechanics with gravitation, particularly in the context of the Møller-Rosenfeld semiclassical theory. Numerical results for the spherically symmetric, time-dependent, single-particle case are presented, clarifying and extending previous work on the subject. It is found that, for a particle mass greater than $\sim 1.14(\hbar^2/(Gσ))^{1/3}$, a wave packet of width $σ$ partially "collapses" to a groundstate solution found by Moroz, Penrose, and Tod, with excess probability dispersing away. However, for a mass less than $\sim 1.14(\hbar^2/(Gσ))^{1/3}$, the entire wave packet appears to spread like a free particle, albeit more slowly. It is argued that, on some scales (lower than the Planck scale), this theory predicts significant deviation from conventional (linear) quantum mechanics. However, owing to the difficulty of controlling quantum coherence on the one hand, and the weakness of gravity on the other, definitive experimental falsification poses a technologically formidable challenge.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2011; v1 submitted 9 May, 2011;
originally announced May 2011.
-
Black-hole binaries, gravitational waves, and numerical relativity
Authors:
Joan M. Centrella,
John G. Baker,
Bernard J. Kelly,
James R. van Meter
Abstract:
Understanding the predictions of general relativity for the dynamical interactions of two black holes has been a long-standing unsolved problem in theoretical physics. Black-hole mergers are monumental astrophysical events, releasing tremendous amounts of energy in the form of gravitational radiation, and are key sources for both ground- and space-based gravitational-wave detectors. The black-hole…
▽ More
Understanding the predictions of general relativity for the dynamical interactions of two black holes has been a long-standing unsolved problem in theoretical physics. Black-hole mergers are monumental astrophysical events, releasing tremendous amounts of energy in the form of gravitational radiation, and are key sources for both ground- and space-based gravitational-wave detectors. The black-hole merger dynamics and the resulting gravitational waveforms can only be calculated through numerical simulations of Einstein's equations of general relativity. For many years, numerical relativists attempting to model these mergers encountered a host of problems, causing their codes to crash after just a fraction of a binary orbit could be simulated. Recently, however, a series of dramatic advances in numerical relativity has allowed stable, robust black-hole merger simulations. This remarkable progress in the rapidly maturing field of numerical relativity, and the new understanding of black-hole binary dynamics that is emerging is chronicled. Important applications of these fundamental physics results to astrophysics, to gravitational-wave astronomy, and in other areas are also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2010; v1 submitted 25 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
The Final Merger of Black-Hole Binaries
Authors:
Joan M. Centrella,
John G. Baker,
Bernard J. Kelly,
James R. van Meter
Abstract:
Recent breakthroughs in the field of numerical relativity have led to dramatic progress in understanding the predictions of General Relativity for the dynamical interactions of two black holes in the regime of very strong gravitational fields. Such black-hole binaries are important astrophysical systems and are a key target of current and develo** gravitational-wave detectors. The waveform signa…
▽ More
Recent breakthroughs in the field of numerical relativity have led to dramatic progress in understanding the predictions of General Relativity for the dynamical interactions of two black holes in the regime of very strong gravitational fields. Such black-hole binaries are important astrophysical systems and are a key target of current and develo** gravitational-wave detectors. The waveform signature of strong gravitational radiation emitted as the black holes fall together and merge provides a clear observable record of the process. After decades of slow progress, these mergers and the gravitational-wave signals they generate can now be routinely calculated using the methods of numerical relativity. We review recent advances in understanding the predicted physics of events and the consequent radiation, and discuss some of the impacts this new knowledge is having in various areas of astrophysics.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2010; v1 submitted 11 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
A General Formula for Black Hole Gravitational Wave Kicks
Authors:
James R. van Meter,
M. Coleman Miller,
John G. Baker,
William D. Boggs,
Bernard J. Kelly
Abstract:
Although the gravitational wave kick velocity in the orbital plane of coalescing black holes has been understood for some time, apparently conflicting formulae have been proposed for the dominant out-of-plane kick, each a good fit to different data sets. This is important to resolve because it is only the out-of-plane kicks that can reach more than 500 km/s and can thus eject merged remnants from…
▽ More
Although the gravitational wave kick velocity in the orbital plane of coalescing black holes has been understood for some time, apparently conflicting formulae have been proposed for the dominant out-of-plane kick, each a good fit to different data sets. This is important to resolve because it is only the out-of-plane kicks that can reach more than 500 km/s and can thus eject merged remnants from galaxies. Using a different ansatz for the out-of-plane kick, we show that we can fit almost all existing data to better than 5 %. This is good enough for any astrophysical calculation, and shows that the previous apparent conflict was only because the two data sets explored different aspects of the kick parameter space.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
-
Modeling Flows Around Merging Black Hole Binaries
Authors:
James R. van Meter,
John H. Wise,
M. Coleman Miller,
Christopher S. Reynolds,
Joan M. Centrella,
John G. Baker,
William D. Boggs,
Bernard J. Kelly,
Sean T. McWilliams
Abstract:
Coalescing massive black hole binaries are produced by the mergers of galaxies. The final stages of the black hole coalescence produce strong gravitational radiation that can be detected by the space-borne LISA. In cases where the black hole merger takes place in the presence of gas and magnetic fields, various types of electromagnetic signals may also be produced. Modeling such electromagnetic…
▽ More
Coalescing massive black hole binaries are produced by the mergers of galaxies. The final stages of the black hole coalescence produce strong gravitational radiation that can be detected by the space-borne LISA. In cases where the black hole merger takes place in the presence of gas and magnetic fields, various types of electromagnetic signals may also be produced. Modeling such electromagnetic counterparts of the final merger requires evolving the behavior of both gas and fields in the strong-field regions around the black holes. We have taken a step towards solving this problem by map** the flow of pressureless matter in the dynamic, 3-D general relativistic spacetime around the merging black holes. We find qualitative differences in collision and outflow speeds, including a signature of the merger when the net angular momentum of the matter is low, between the results from single and binary black holes, and between nonrotating and rotating holes in binaries. If future magnetohydrodynamic results confirm these differences, it may allow assessment of the properties of the binaries as well as yielding an identifiable electromagnetic counterpart to the attendant gravitational wave signal.
△ Less
Submitted 31 July, 2009;
originally announced August 2009.
-
Status of NINJA: the Numerical INJection Analysis project
Authors:
Benjamin Aylott,
John G. Baker,
William D. Boggs,
Michael Boyle,
Patrick R. Brady,
Duncan A. Brown,
Bernd Brügmann,
Luisa T. Buchman,
Alessandra Buonanno,
Laura Cadonati,
Jordan Camp,
Manuela Campanelli,
Joan Centrella,
Shourov Chatterjis,
Nelson Christensen,
Tony Chu,
Peter Diener,
Nils Dorband,
Zachariah B. Etienne,
Joshua Faber,
Stephen Fairhurst,
Benjamin Farr,
Sebastian Fischetti,
Gianluca Guidi,
Lisa M. Goggin
, et al. (52 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The 2008 NRDA conference introduced the Numerical INJection Analysis project (NINJA), a new collaborative effort between the numerical relativity community and the data analysis community. NINJA focuses on modeling and searching for gravitational wave signatures from the coalescence of binary system of compact objects. We review the scope of this collaboration and the components of the first NIN…
▽ More
The 2008 NRDA conference introduced the Numerical INJection Analysis project (NINJA), a new collaborative effort between the numerical relativity community and the data analysis community. NINJA focuses on modeling and searching for gravitational wave signatures from the coalescence of binary system of compact objects. We review the scope of this collaboration and the components of the first NINJA project, where numerical relativity groups shared waveforms and data analysis teams applied various techniques to detect them when embedded in colored Gaussian noise.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2009;
originally announced May 2009.
-
Testing gravitational-wave searches with numerical relativity waveforms: Results from the first Numerical INJection Analysis (NINJA) project
Authors:
Benjamin Aylott,
John G. Baker,
William D. Boggs,
Michael Boyle,
Patrick R. Brady,
Duncan A. Brown,
Bernd Brügmann,
Luisa T. Buchman,
Alessandra Buonanno,
Laura Cadonati,
Jordan Camp,
Manuela Campanelli,
Joan Centrella,
Shourov Chatterji,
Nelson Christensen,
Tony Chu,
Peter Diener,
Nils Dorband,
Zachariah B. Etienne,
Joshua Faber,
Stephen Fairhurst,
Benjamin Farr,
Sebastian Fischetti,
Gianluca Guidi,
Lisa M. Goggin
, et al. (52 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Numerical INJection Analysis (NINJA) project is a collaborative effort between members of the numerical relativity and gravitational-wave data analysis communities. The purpose of NINJA is to study the sensitivity of existing gravitational-wave search algorithms using numerically generated waveforms and to foster closer collaboration between the numerical relativity and data analysis communi…
▽ More
The Numerical INJection Analysis (NINJA) project is a collaborative effort between members of the numerical relativity and gravitational-wave data analysis communities. The purpose of NINJA is to study the sensitivity of existing gravitational-wave search algorithms using numerically generated waveforms and to foster closer collaboration between the numerical relativity and data analysis communities. We describe the results of the first NINJA analysis which focused on gravitational waveforms from binary black hole coalescence. Ten numerical relativity groups contributed numerical data which were used to generate a set of gravitational-wave signals. These signals were injected into a simulated data set, designed to mimic the response of the Initial LIGO and Virgo gravitational-wave detectors. Nine groups analysed this data using search and parameter-estimation pipelines. Matched filter algorithms, un-modelled-burst searches and Bayesian parameter-estimation and model-selection algorithms were applied to the data. We report the efficiency of these search methods in detecting the numerical waveforms and measuring their parameters. We describe preliminary comparisons between the different search methods and suggest improvements for future NINJA analyses.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2009; v1 submitted 28 January, 2009;
originally announced January 2009.
-
The Samurai Project: verifying the consistency of black-hole-binary waveforms for gravitational-wave detection
Authors:
Mark Hannam,
Sascha Husa,
John G. Baker,
Michael Boyle,
Bernd Bruegmann,
Tony Chu,
Nils Dorband,
Frank Herrmann,
Ian Hinder,
Bernard J. Kelly,
Lawrence E. Kidder,
Pablo Laguna,
Keith D. Matthews,
James R. van Meter,
Harald P. Pfeiffer,
Denis Pollney,
Christian Reisswig,
Mark A. Scheel,
Deirdre Shoemaker
Abstract:
We quantify the consistency of numerical-relativity black-hole-binary waveforms for use in gravitational-wave (GW) searches with current and planned ground-based detectors. We compare previously published results for the $(\ell=2,| m | =2)$ mode of the gravitational waves from an equal-mass nonspinning binary, calculated by five numerical codes. We focus on the 1000M (about six orbits, or 12 GW…
▽ More
We quantify the consistency of numerical-relativity black-hole-binary waveforms for use in gravitational-wave (GW) searches with current and planned ground-based detectors. We compare previously published results for the $(\ell=2,| m | =2)$ mode of the gravitational waves from an equal-mass nonspinning binary, calculated by five numerical codes. We focus on the 1000M (about six orbits, or 12 GW cycles) before the peak of the GW amplitude and the subsequent ringdown. We find that the phase and amplitude agree within each code's uncertainty estimates. The mismatch between the $(\ell=2,| m| =2)$ modes is better than $10^{-3}$ for binary masses above $60 M_{\odot}$ with respect to the Enhanced LIGO detector noise curve, and for masses above $180 M_{\odot}$ with respect to Advanced LIGO, Virgo and Advanced Virgo. Between the waveforms with the best agreement, the mismatch is below $2 \times 10^{-4}$. We find that the waveforms would be indistinguishable in all ground-based detectors (and for the masses we consider) if detected with a signal-to-noise ratio of less than $\approx14$, or less than $\approx25$ in the best cases.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2009; v1 submitted 16 January, 2009;
originally announced January 2009.
-
Mergers of nonspinning black-hole binaries: Gravitational radiation characteristics
Authors:
John G. Baker,
William D. Boggs,
Joan Centrella,
Bernard J. Kelly,
Sean T. McWilliams,
James R. van Meter
Abstract:
We present a detailed descriptive analysis of the gravitational radiation from black-hole binary mergers of nonspinning black holes, based on numerical simulations of systems varying from equal-mass to a 6:1 mass ratio. Our primary goal is to present relatively complete information about the waveforms, including all the leading multipolar components, to interested researchers. In our analysis, w…
▽ More
We present a detailed descriptive analysis of the gravitational radiation from black-hole binary mergers of nonspinning black holes, based on numerical simulations of systems varying from equal-mass to a 6:1 mass ratio. Our primary goal is to present relatively complete information about the waveforms, including all the leading multipolar components, to interested researchers. In our analysis, we pursue the simplest physical description of the dominant features in the radiation, providing an interpretation of the waveforms in terms of an {\em implicit rotating source}. This interpretation applies uniformly to the full wave train, from inspiral through ringdown. We emphasize strong relationships among the $\ell=m$ modes that persist through the full wave train. Exploring the structure of the waveforms in more detail, we conduct detailed analytic fitting of the late-time frequency evolution, identifying a key quantitative feature shared by the $\ell=m$ modes among all mass ratios. We identify relationships, with a simple interpretation in terms of the implicit rotating source, among the evolution of frequency and amplitude, which hold for the late-time radiation. These detailed relationships provide sufficient information about the late-time radiation to yield a predictive model for the late-time waveforms, an alternative to the common practice of modeling by a sum of quasinormal mode overtones. We demonstrate an application of this in a new effective-one-body-based analytic waveform model.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2008; v1 submitted 9 May, 2008;
originally announced May 2008.
-
Modeling kicks from the merger of generic black-hole binaries
Authors:
John G. Baker,
William D. Boggs,
Joan Centrella,
Bernard J. Kelly,
Sean T. McWilliams,
M. Coleman Miller,
James R. van Meter
Abstract:
Recent numerical relativistic results demonstrate that the merger of comparable-mass spinning black holes has a maximum ``recoil kick'' of up to $\sim 4000 \kms$. However the scaling of these recoil velocities with mass ratio is poorly understood. We present new runs showing that the maximum possible kick perpendicular to the orbital plane does not scale as $\simη^2$ (where $η$ is the symmetric…
▽ More
Recent numerical relativistic results demonstrate that the merger of comparable-mass spinning black holes has a maximum ``recoil kick'' of up to $\sim 4000 \kms$. However the scaling of these recoil velocities with mass ratio is poorly understood. We present new runs showing that the maximum possible kick perpendicular to the orbital plane does not scale as $\simη^2$ (where $η$ is the symmetric mass ratio), as previously proposed, but is more consistent with $\simη^3$, at least for systems with low orbital precession. We discuss the effect of this dependence on galactic ejection scenarios and retention of intermediate-mass black holes in globular clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2008; v1 submitted 4 February, 2008;
originally announced February 2008.
-
Gravitational waves from black-hole mergers
Authors:
John G. Baker,
William D. Boggs,
Joan M. Centrella,
Bernard J. Kelly,
Sean T. McWilliams,
James R. van Meter
Abstract:
Coalescing black-hole binaries are expected to be the strongest sources of gravitational waves for ground-based interferometers as well as the space-based interferometer LISA. Recent progress in numerical relativity now makes it possible to calculate the waveforms from the strong-field dynamical merger and is revolutionizing our understanding of these systems. We review these dramatic developmen…
▽ More
Coalescing black-hole binaries are expected to be the strongest sources of gravitational waves for ground-based interferometers as well as the space-based interferometer LISA. Recent progress in numerical relativity now makes it possible to calculate the waveforms from the strong-field dynamical merger and is revolutionizing our understanding of these systems. We review these dramatic developments, emphasizing applications to issues in gravitational wave observations. These new capabilities also make possible accurate calculations of the recoil or kick imparted to the final remnant black hole when the merging components have unequal masses, or unequal or unaligned spins. We highlight recent work in this area, focusing on results of interest to astrophysics.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2007; v1 submitted 30 August, 2007;
originally announced August 2007.
-
Anatomy of the binary black hole recoil: A multipolar analysis
Authors:
Jeremy D. Schnittman,
Alessandra Buonanno,
James R. van Meter,
John G. Baker,
William D. Boggs,
Joan Centrella,
Bernard J. Kelly,
Sean T. McWilliams
Abstract:
We present a multipolar analysis of the gravitational recoil computed in recent numerical simulations of binary black hole (BH) coalescence, for both unequal masses and non-zero, non-precessing spins. We show that multipole moments up to and including l=4 are sufficient to accurately reproduce the final recoil velocity (within ~2%) and that only a few dominant modes contribute significantly to i…
▽ More
We present a multipolar analysis of the gravitational recoil computed in recent numerical simulations of binary black hole (BH) coalescence, for both unequal masses and non-zero, non-precessing spins. We show that multipole moments up to and including l=4 are sufficient to accurately reproduce the final recoil velocity (within ~2%) and that only a few dominant modes contribute significantly to it (within ~5%). We describe how the relative amplitudes, and more importantly, the relative phases, of these few modes control the way in which the recoil builds up throughout the inspiral, merger, and ringdown phases. We also find that the numerical results can be reproduced by an ``effective Newtonian'' formula for the multipole moments obtained by replacing the radial separation in the Newtonian formulae with an effective radius computed from the numerical data. Beyond the merger, the numerical results are reproduced by a superposition of three Kerr quasi-normal modes (QNMs). Analytic formulae, obtained by expressing the multipole moments in terms of the fundamental QNMs of a Kerr BH, are able to explain the onset and amount of ``anti-kick'' for each of the simulations. Lastly, we apply this multipolar analysis to help explain the remarkable difference between the amplitudes of planar and non-planar kicks for equal-mass spinning black holes.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2007; v1 submitted 2 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
-
Toward faithful templates for non-spinning binary black holes using the effective-one-body approach
Authors:
Alessandra Buonanno,
Yi Pan,
John G. Baker,
Joan Centrella,
Bernard J. Kelly,
Sean T. McWilliams,
James R. van Meter
Abstract:
We present an accurate approximation of the full gravitational radiation waveforms generated in the merger of non-eccentric systems of two non-spinning black holes. Utilizing information from recent numerical relativity simulations and the natural flexibility of the effective-one-body (EOB) model, we extend the latter so that it can successfully match the numerical relativity waveforms during th…
▽ More
We present an accurate approximation of the full gravitational radiation waveforms generated in the merger of non-eccentric systems of two non-spinning black holes. Utilizing information from recent numerical relativity simulations and the natural flexibility of the effective-one-body (EOB) model, we extend the latter so that it can successfully match the numerical relativity waveforms during the last stages of inspiral, merger and ringdown. By ``successfully'' here, we mean with phase differences < 8% of a gravitational-wave cycle accumulated by the end of the ringdown phase, maximizing only over time of arrival and initial phase. We obtain this result by simply adding a 4-post-Newtonian order correction in the EOB radial potential and determining the (constant) coefficient by imposing high-matching performances with numerical waveforms of mass ratios m1/m2 = 1, 3/2, 2 and 4, m1 and m2 being the individual black-hole masses. The final black-hole mass and spin predicted by the numerical simulations are used to determine the ringdown frequency and decay time of three quasi-normal-mode damped sinusoids that are attached to the EOB inspiral-(plunge) waveform at the EOB light-ring. The EOB waveforms might be tested and further improved in the future by comparison with extremely long and accurate inspiral numerical-relativity waveforms. They may already be employed for coherent searches and parameter estimation of gravitational waves emitted by non-spinning coalescing binary black holes with ground-based laser-interferometer detectors.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2008; v1 submitted 25 June, 2007;
originally announced June 2007.
-
A data-analysis driven comparison of analytic and numerical coalescing binary waveforms: nonspinning case
Authors:
Yi Pan,
Alessandra Buonanno,
John G. Baker,
Joan Centrella,
Bernard J. Kelly,
Sean T. McWilliams,
Frans Pretorius,
James R. van Meter
Abstract:
We compare waveforms obtained by numerically evolving nonspinning binary black holes to post-Newtonian (PN) template families currently used in the search for gravitational waves by ground-based detectors. We find that the time-domain 3.5PN template family, which includes the inspiral phase, has fitting factors (FFs) >= 0.96 for binary systems with total mass M = 10 ~ 20 Msun. The time-domain 3.…
▽ More
We compare waveforms obtained by numerically evolving nonspinning binary black holes to post-Newtonian (PN) template families currently used in the search for gravitational waves by ground-based detectors. We find that the time-domain 3.5PN template family, which includes the inspiral phase, has fitting factors (FFs) >= 0.96 for binary systems with total mass M = 10 ~ 20 Msun. The time-domain 3.5PN effective-one-body template family, which includes the inspiral, merger and ring-down phases, gives satisfactory signal-matching performance with FFs >= 0.96 for binary systems with total mass M = 10 ~ 120 Msun. If we introduce a cutoff frequency properly adjusted to the final black-hole ring-down frequency, we find that the frequency-domain stationary-phase-approximated template family at 3.5PN order has FFs >= 0.96 for binary systems with total mass M = 10 ~ 20 Msun. However, to obtain high matching performances for larger binary masses, we need to either extend this family to unphysical regions of the parameter space or introduce a 4PN order coefficient in the frequency-domain GW phase. Finally, we find that the phenomenological Buonanno-Chen-Vallisneri family has FFs >= 0.97 with total mass M=10 ~ 120Msun. The main analyses use the noise spectral-density of LIGO, but several tests are extended to VIRGO and advanced LIGO noise-spectral densities.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2007; v1 submitted 16 April, 2007;
originally announced April 2007.
-
Modeling kicks from the merger of non-precessing black-hole binaries
Authors:
John G. Baker,
William D. Boggs,
Joan Centrella,
Bernard J. Kelly,
Sean T. McWilliams,
M. Coleman Miller,
James R. van Meter
Abstract:
Several groups have recently computed the gravitational radiation recoil produced by the merger of two spinning black holes. The results suggest that spin can be the dominant contributor to the kick, with reported recoil speeds of hundreds to even thousands of kilometers per second. The parameter space of spin kicks is large, however, and it is ultimately desirable to have a simple formula that…
▽ More
Several groups have recently computed the gravitational radiation recoil produced by the merger of two spinning black holes. The results suggest that spin can be the dominant contributor to the kick, with reported recoil speeds of hundreds to even thousands of kilometers per second. The parameter space of spin kicks is large, however, and it is ultimately desirable to have a simple formula that gives the approximate magnitude of the kick given a mass ratio, spin magnitudes, and spin orientations. As a step toward this goal, we perform a systematic study of the recoil speeds from mergers of black holes with mass ratio $q\equiv m_1/m_2=2/3$ and dimensionless spin parameters of $a_1/m_1$ and $a_2/m_2$ equal to 0 or 0.2, with directions aligned or anti-aligned with the orbital angular momentum. We also run an equal-mass $a_1/m_1=-a_2/m_2=0.2$ case, and find good agreement with previous results. We find that, for currently reported kicks from aligned or anti-aligned spins, a simple kick formula inspired by post-Newtonian analyses can reproduce the numerical results to better than $\sim$10%.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2007; v1 submitted 14 February, 2007;
originally announced February 2007.
-
Binary black hole late inspiral: Simulations for gravitational wave observations
Authors:
John G. Baker,
Sean T. McWilliams,
James R. van Meter,
Joan Centrella,
Dae-Il Choi,
Bernard J. Kelly,
Michael Koppitz
Abstract:
Coalescing binary black hole mergers are expected to be the strongest gravitational wave sources for ground-based interferometers, such as the LIGO, VIRGO, and GEO600, as well as the space-based interferometer LISA. Until recently it has been impossible to reliably derive the predictions of General Relativity for the final merger stage, which takes place in the strong-field regime. Recent progre…
▽ More
Coalescing binary black hole mergers are expected to be the strongest gravitational wave sources for ground-based interferometers, such as the LIGO, VIRGO, and GEO600, as well as the space-based interferometer LISA. Until recently it has been impossible to reliably derive the predictions of General Relativity for the final merger stage, which takes place in the strong-field regime. Recent progress in numerical relativity simulations is, however, revolutionizing our understanding of these systems. We examine here the specific case of merging equal-mass Schwarzschild black holes in detail, presenting new simulations in which the black holes start in the late inspiral stage on orbits with very low eccentricity and evolve for ~1200M through ~7 orbits before merging. We study the accuracy and consistency of our simulations and the resulting gravitational waveforms, which encompass ~14 cycles before merger, and highlight the importance of using frequency (rather than time) to set the physical reference when comparing models. Matching our results to PN calculations for the earlier parts of the inspiral provides a combined waveform with less than half a cycle of accumulated phase error through the entire coalescence. Using this waveform, we calculate signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) for iLIGO, adLIGO, and LISA, highlighting the contributions from the late-inspiral and merger-ringdown parts of the waveform which can now be simulated numerically. Contour plots of SNR as a function of z and M show that adLIGO can achieve SNR >~ 10 for some intermediate-mass binary black holes (IMBBHs) out to z ~ 1, and that LISA can see massive binary black holes (MBBHs) in the range 3x10^4 <~ M/M_Sun <~ 10^7 at SNR > 100 out to the earliest epochs of structure formation at z > 15.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2007; v1 submitted 19 December, 2006;
originally announced December 2006.
-
Consistency of post-Newtonian waveforms with numerical relativity
Authors:
John G. Baker,
James R. van Meter,
Sean T. McWilliams,
Joan Centrella,
Bernard J. Kelly
Abstract:
General relativity predicts the gravitational wave signatures of coalescing binary black holes. Explicit waveform predictions for such systems, required for optimal analysis of observational data, have so far been achieved using the post-Newtonian (PN) approximation. The quality of this treatment is unclear, however, for the important late-inspiral portion. We derive late-inspiral waveforms via…
▽ More
General relativity predicts the gravitational wave signatures of coalescing binary black holes. Explicit waveform predictions for such systems, required for optimal analysis of observational data, have so far been achieved using the post-Newtonian (PN) approximation. The quality of this treatment is unclear, however, for the important late-inspiral portion. We derive late-inspiral waveforms via a complementary approach, direct numerical simulation of Einstein's equations. We compare waveform phasing from simulations of the last $\sim 14$ cycles of gravitational radiation from equal-mass, nonspinning black holes with the corresponding 2.5PN, 3PN, and 3.5PN orbital phasing. We find phasing agreement consistent with internal error estimates based on either approach, suggesting that PN waveforms for this system are effective until the last orbit prior to final merger.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2007; v1 submitted 4 December, 2006;
originally announced December 2006.
-
How to move a black hole without excision: gauge conditions for the numerical evolution of a moving puncture
Authors:
James R. van Meter,
John G. Baker,
Michael Koppitz,
Dae-Il Choi
Abstract:
Recent demonstrations of unexcised black holes traversing across computational grids represent a significant advance in numerical relativity. Stable and accurate simulations of multiple orbits, and their radiated waves, result. This capability is critically undergirded by a careful choice of gauge. Here we present analytic considerations which suggest certain gauge choices, and numerically demon…
▽ More
Recent demonstrations of unexcised black holes traversing across computational grids represent a significant advance in numerical relativity. Stable and accurate simulations of multiple orbits, and their radiated waves, result. This capability is critically undergirded by a careful choice of gauge. Here we present analytic considerations which suggest certain gauge choices, and numerically demonstrate their efficacy in evolving a single moving puncture black hole.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2006; v1 submitted 5 May, 2006;
originally announced May 2006.
-
Excising das All: Evolving Maxwell waves beyond scri
Authors:
Charles W. Misner,
James R. van Meter,
David R. Fiske
Abstract:
We study the numerical propagation of waves through future null infinity in a conformally compactified spacetime. We introduce an artificial cosmological constant, which allows us some control over the causal structure near null infinity. We exploit this freedom to ensure that all light cones are tilted outward in a region near null infinity, which allows us to impose excision-style boundary con…
▽ More
We study the numerical propagation of waves through future null infinity in a conformally compactified spacetime. We introduce an artificial cosmological constant, which allows us some control over the causal structure near null infinity. We exploit this freedom to ensure that all light cones are tilted outward in a region near null infinity, which allows us to impose excision-style boundary conditions in our finite difference code. In this preliminary study we consider electromagnetic waves propagating in a static, conformally compactified spacetime.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2006; v1 submitted 9 March, 2006;
originally announced March 2006.
-
Getting a kick out of numerical relativity
Authors:
John G. Baker,
Joan Centrella,
Dae-Il Choi,
Michael Koppitz,
James R. van Meter,
M. Coleman Miller
Abstract:
Recent developments in numerical relativity have made it possible to follow reliably the coalescence of two black holes from near the innermost stable circular orbit to final ringdown. This opens up a wide variety of exciting astrophysical applications of these simulations. Chief among these is the net kick received when two unequal mass or spinning black holes merge. The magnitude of this kick…
▽ More
Recent developments in numerical relativity have made it possible to follow reliably the coalescence of two black holes from near the innermost stable circular orbit to final ringdown. This opens up a wide variety of exciting astrophysical applications of these simulations. Chief among these is the net kick received when two unequal mass or spinning black holes merge. The magnitude of this kick has bearing on the production and growth of supermassive black holes during the epoch of structure formation, and on the retention of black holes in stellar clusters. Here we report the first accurate numerical calculation of this kick, for two nonspinning black holes in a 1.5:1 mass ratio, which is expected based on analytic considerations to give a significant fraction of the maximum possible recoil. We have performed multiple runs with different initial separations, orbital angular momenta, resolutions, extraction radii, and gauges. The full range of our kick speeds is 86--116 km s$^{-1}$, and the most reliable runs give kicks between 86 and 97 km s$^{-1}$. This is intermediate between the estimates from two recent post-Newtonian analyses and suggests that at redshifts $z\gtrsim 10$, halos with masses $\lesssim 10^9 M_\odot$ will have difficulty retaining coalesced black holes after major mergers.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2006; v1 submitted 8 March, 2006;
originally announced March 2006.
-
The world problem: on the computability of the topology of 4-manifolds
Authors:
James R. van Meter
Abstract:
Topological classification of the 4-manifolds bridges computation theory and physics. A proof of the undecidability of the homeomorphy problem for 4-manifolds is outlined here in a clarifying way. It is shown that an arbitrary Turing machine with an arbitrary input can be encoded into the topology of a 4-manifold, such that the 4-manifold is homeomorphic to a certain other 4-manifold if and only…
▽ More
Topological classification of the 4-manifolds bridges computation theory and physics. A proof of the undecidability of the homeomorphy problem for 4-manifolds is outlined here in a clarifying way. It is shown that an arbitrary Turing machine with an arbitrary input can be encoded into the topology of a 4-manifold, such that the 4-manifold is homeomorphic to a certain other 4-manifold if and only if the corresponding Turing machine halts on the associated input. Physical implications are briefly discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2005;
originally announced June 2005.
-
Reducing reflections from mesh refinement interfaces in numerical relativity
Authors:
John G. Baker,
James R. van Meter
Abstract:
Full interpretation of data from gravitational wave observations will require accurate numerical simulations of source systems, particularly binary black hole mergers. A leading approach to improving accuracy in numerical relativity simulations of black hole systems is through fixed or adaptive mesh refinement techniques. We describe a manifestation of numerical interface truncation error which…
▽ More
Full interpretation of data from gravitational wave observations will require accurate numerical simulations of source systems, particularly binary black hole mergers. A leading approach to improving accuracy in numerical relativity simulations of black hole systems is through fixed or adaptive mesh refinement techniques. We describe a manifestation of numerical interface truncation error which appears as slowly converging, artificial reflections from refinement boundaries in a broad class of mesh refinement implementations, potentially compromising the effectiveness of mesh refinement techniques for some numerical relativity applications if left untreated. We elucidate this numerical effect by presenting a model problem which exhibits the phenomenon, but which is simple enough that its numerical error can be understood analytically. Our analysis shows that the effect is caused by variations in finite differencing error generated across low and high resolution regions, and that its slow convergence is caused by the presence of dramatic speed differences among propagation modes typical of 3+1 relativity. Lastly, we resolve the problem, presenting a class of finite differencing stencil modifications, termed mesh-adapted differencing (MAD), which eliminate this pathology in both our model problem and in numerical relativity examples.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2005;
originally announced May 2005.
-
Wave zone extraction of gravitational radiation in three-dimensional numerical relativity
Authors:
David R. Fiske,
John G. Baker,
James R. van Meter,
Dae-Il Choi,
Joan M. Centrella
Abstract:
We present convergent gravitational waveforms extracted from three-dimensional, numerical simulations in the wave zone and with causally disconnected boundaries. These waveforms last for multiple periods and are very accurate, showing a peak error to peak amplitude ratio of 2% or better. Our approach includes defining the Weyl scalar Psi_4 in terms of a three-plus-one decomposition of the Einste…
▽ More
We present convergent gravitational waveforms extracted from three-dimensional, numerical simulations in the wave zone and with causally disconnected boundaries. These waveforms last for multiple periods and are very accurate, showing a peak error to peak amplitude ratio of 2% or better. Our approach includes defining the Weyl scalar Psi_4 in terms of a three-plus-one decomposition of the Einstein equations; applying, for the first time, a novel algorithm due to Misner for computing spherical harmonic components of our wave data; and using fixed mesh refinement to focus resolution on non-linear sources while simultaneously resolving the wave zone and maintaining a causally disconnected computational boundary. We apply our techniques to a (linear) Teukolsky wave, and then to an equal mass, head-on collision of two black holes. We argue both for the quality of our results and for the value of these problems as standard test cases for wave extraction techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2005; v1 submitted 23 March, 2005;
originally announced March 2005.
-
Evolving a puncture black hole with fixed mesh refinement
Authors:
Breno Imbiriba,
John Baker,
Dae-Il Choi,
Joan Centrella,
David R. Fiske,
J. David Brown,
James R. van Meter,
Kevin Olson
Abstract:
We present an algorithm for treating mesh refinement interfaces in numerical relativity. We detail the behavior of the solution near such interfaces located in the strong field regions of dynamical black hole spacetimes, with particular attention to the convergence properties of the simulations. In our applications of this technique to the evolution of puncture initial data with vanishing shift,…
▽ More
We present an algorithm for treating mesh refinement interfaces in numerical relativity. We detail the behavior of the solution near such interfaces located in the strong field regions of dynamical black hole spacetimes, with particular attention to the convergence properties of the simulations. In our applications of this technique to the evolution of puncture initial data with vanishing shift, we demonstrate that it is possible to simultaneously maintain second order convergence near the puncture and extend the outer boundary beyond 100M, thereby approaching the asymptotically flat region in which boundary condition problems are less difficult and wave extraction is meaningful.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2006; v1 submitted 11 March, 2004;
originally announced March 2004.
