-
Mechanised uniform interpolation for modal logics K, GL, and iSL
Authors:
Hugo Férée,
Iris van der Giessen,
Sam van Gool,
Ian Shillito
Abstract:
The uniform interpolation property in a given logic can be understood as the definability of propositional quantifiers. We mechanise the computation of these quantifiers and prove correctness in the Coq proof assistant for three modal logics, namely: (1) the modal logic K, for which a pen-and-paper proof exists; (2) Gödel-Löb logic GL, for which our formalisation clarifies an important point in an…
▽ More
The uniform interpolation property in a given logic can be understood as the definability of propositional quantifiers. We mechanise the computation of these quantifiers and prove correctness in the Coq proof assistant for three modal logics, namely: (1) the modal logic K, for which a pen-and-paper proof exists; (2) Gödel-Löb logic GL, for which our formalisation clarifies an important point in an existing, but incomplete, sequent-style proof; and (3) intuitionistic strong Löb logic iSL, for which this is the first proof-theoretic construction of uniform interpolants. Our work also yields verified programs that allow one to compute the propositional quantifiers on any formula in this logic.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2024; v1 submitted 16 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Deciding Equations in the Time Warp Algebra
Authors:
Sam van Gool,
Adrien Guatto,
George Metcalfe,
Simon Santschi
Abstract:
Join-preserving maps on the discrete time scale $ω^+$, referred to as time warps, have been proposed as graded modalities that can be used to quantify the growth of information in the course of program execution. The set of time warps forms a simple distributive involutive residuated lattice -- called the time warp algebra -- that is equipped with residual operations relevant to potential applicat…
▽ More
Join-preserving maps on the discrete time scale $ω^+$, referred to as time warps, have been proposed as graded modalities that can be used to quantify the growth of information in the course of program execution. The set of time warps forms a simple distributive involutive residuated lattice -- called the time warp algebra -- that is equipped with residual operations relevant to potential applications. In this paper, we show that although the time warp algebra generates a variety that lacks the finite model property, it nevertheless has a decidable equational theory. We also describe an implementation of a procedure for deciding equations in this algebra, written in the OCaml programming language, that makes use of the Z3 theorem prover.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2024; v1 submitted 15 January, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Profinite lambda-terms and parametricity
Authors:
Sam van Gool,
Paul-André Melliès,
Vincent Moreau
Abstract:
Combining ideas coming from Stone duality and Reynolds parametricity, we formulate in a clean and principled way a notion of profinite lambda-term which, we show, generalizes at every type the traditional notion of profinite word coming from automata theory. We start by defining the Stone space of profinite lambda-terms as a projective limit of finite sets of usual lambda-terms, considered modulo…
▽ More
Combining ideas coming from Stone duality and Reynolds parametricity, we formulate in a clean and principled way a notion of profinite lambda-term which, we show, generalizes at every type the traditional notion of profinite word coming from automata theory. We start by defining the Stone space of profinite lambda-terms as a projective limit of finite sets of usual lambda-terms, considered modulo a notion of equivalence based on the finite standard model. One main contribution of the paper is to establish that, somewhat surprisingly, the resulting notion of profinite lambda-term coming from Stone duality lives in perfect harmony with the principles of Reynolds parametricity. In addition, we show that the notion of profinite lambda-term is compositional by constructing a cartesian closed category of profinite lambda-terms, and we establish that the embedding from lambda-terms modulo beta-eta-conversion to profinite lambda-terms is faithful using Statman's finite completeness theorem. Finally, we prove that the traditional Church encoding of finite words into lambda-terms can be extended to profinite words, and leads to a homeomorphism between the space of profinite words and the space of profinite lambda-terms of the corresponding Church type.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2023; v1 submitted 29 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
On duality and model theory for polyadic spaces
Authors:
Sam van Gool,
Jérémie Marquès
Abstract:
This paper is a study of first-order coherent logic from the point of view of duality and categorical logic. We prove a duality theorem between coherent hyperdoctrines and open polyadic Priestley spaces, which we subsequently apply to prove completeness, omitting types, and Craig interpolation theorems for coherent or intuitionistic logic. Our approach emphasizes the role of interpolation and open…
▽ More
This paper is a study of first-order coherent logic from the point of view of duality and categorical logic. We prove a duality theorem between coherent hyperdoctrines and open polyadic Priestley spaces, which we subsequently apply to prove completeness, omitting types, and Craig interpolation theorems for coherent or intuitionistic logic. Our approach emphasizes the role of interpolation and openness properties, and allows for a modular, syntax-free treatment of these model-theoretic results. As further applications of the same method, we prove completeness theorems for constant domain and Gödel-Dummett intuitionistic predicate logics.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2023; v1 submitted 3 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Topological Duality for Distributive Lattices: Theory and Applications
Authors:
Mai Gehrke,
Sam van Gool
Abstract:
This book is a course in Stone-Priestley duality theory, with applications to logic and theoretical computer science. Our target audience are graduate students and researchers in mathematics and computer science. Our aim is to get in a fairly full palette of duality tools as directly and quickly as possible, then to illustrate and further elaborate these tools within the setting of three emblemati…
▽ More
This book is a course in Stone-Priestley duality theory, with applications to logic and theoretical computer science. Our target audience are graduate students and researchers in mathematics and computer science. Our aim is to get in a fairly full palette of duality tools as directly and quickly as possible, then to illustrate and further elaborate these tools within the setting of three emblematic applications: semantics of propositional logics, domain theory in logical form, and the theory of profinite monoids for the study of regular languages and automata.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2023; v1 submitted 7 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
First-order separation over countable ordinals
Authors:
Thomas Colcombet,
Sam van Gool,
Rémi Morvan
Abstract:
We show that the existence of a first-order formula separating two monadic second order formulas over countable ordinal words is decidable. This extends the work of Henckell and Almeida on finite words, and of Place and Zeitoun on $ω$-words. For this, we develop the algebraic concept of monoid (resp. $ω$-semigroup, resp. ordinal monoid) with aperiodic merge, an extension of monoids (resp. $ω$-semi…
▽ More
We show that the existence of a first-order formula separating two monadic second order formulas over countable ordinal words is decidable. This extends the work of Henckell and Almeida on finite words, and of Place and Zeitoun on $ω$-words. For this, we develop the algebraic concept of monoid (resp. $ω$-semigroup, resp. ordinal monoid) with aperiodic merge, an extension of monoids (resp. $ω$-semigroup, resp. ordinal monoid) that explicitly includes a new operation capturing the loss of precision induced by first-order indistinguishability. We also show the computability of FO-pointlike sets, and the decidability of the covering problem for first-order logic on countable ordinal words.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Time Warps, from Algebra to Algorithms
Authors:
Sam van Gool,
Adrien Guatto,
George Metcalfe,
Simon Santschi
Abstract:
Graded modalities have been proposed in recent work on programming languages as a general framework for refining type systems with intensional properties. In particular, continuous endomaps of the discrete time scale, or time warps, can be used to quantify the growth of information in the course of program execution. Time warps form a complete residuated lattice, with the residuals playing an impo…
▽ More
Graded modalities have been proposed in recent work on programming languages as a general framework for refining type systems with intensional properties. In particular, continuous endomaps of the discrete time scale, or time warps, can be used to quantify the growth of information in the course of program execution. Time warps form a complete residuated lattice, with the residuals playing an important role in potential programming applications. In this paper, we study the algebraic structure of time warps, and prove that their equational theory is decidable, a necessary condition for their use in real-world compilers. We also describe how our universal-algebraic proof technique lends itself to a constraint-based implementation, establishing a new link between universal algebra and verification technology.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2021; v1 submitted 11 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Priestley duality for MV-algebras and beyond
Authors:
Wesley Fussner,
Mai Gehrke,
Sam van Gool,
Vincenzo Marra
Abstract:
We provide a new perspective on extended Priestley duality for a large class of distributive lattices equipped with binary double quasioperators. Under this approach, non-lattice binary operations are each presented as a pair of partial binary operations on dual spaces. In this enriched environment, equational conditions on the algebraic side of the duality may more often be rendered as first-orde…
▽ More
We provide a new perspective on extended Priestley duality for a large class of distributive lattices equipped with binary double quasioperators. Under this approach, non-lattice binary operations are each presented as a pair of partial binary operations on dual spaces. In this enriched environment, equational conditions on the algebraic side of the duality may more often be rendered as first-order conditions on dual spaces. In particular, we specialize our general results to the variety of MV-algebras, obtaining a duality for these in which the equations axiomatizing MV-algebras are dualized as first-order conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2023; v1 submitted 28 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
An interpolant in predicate Gödel logic
Authors:
Matthias Baaz,
Mai Gehrke,
Sam van Gool
Abstract:
A logic satisfies the interpolation property provided that whenever a formula Δ is a consequence of another formula Γ, then this is witnessed by a formula Θ which only refers to the language common to Γ and Δ. That is, the relational (and functional) symbols occurring in Θ occur in both Γ and Δ, Γ has Θ as a consequence, and Θ has Δ as a consequence. Both classical and intuitionistic predicate log…
▽ More
A logic satisfies the interpolation property provided that whenever a formula Δ is a consequence of another formula Γ, then this is witnessed by a formula Θ which only refers to the language common to Γ and Δ. That is, the relational (and functional) symbols occurring in Θ occur in both Γ and Δ, Γ has Θ as a consequence, and Θ has Δ as a consequence. Both classical and intuitionistic predicate logic have the interpolation property, but it is a long open problem which intermediate predicate logics enjoy it. In 2013 Mints, Olkhovikov, and Urquhart showed that constant domain intuitionistic logic does not have the interpolation property, while leaving open whether predicate Gödel logic does. In this short note, we show that their counterexample for constant domain intuitionistic logic does admit an interpolant in predicate Gödel logic. While this has no impact on settling the question for predicate Gödel logic, it lends some credence to a common belief that it does satisfy interpolation. Also, our method is based on an analysis of the semantic tools of Olkhovikov and it is our hope that this might eventually be useful in settling this question.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2019; v1 submitted 8 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
An open map** theorem for finitely copresented Esakia spaces
Authors:
Samuel J. van Gool,
Luca Reggio
Abstract:
We prove an open map** theorem for the topological spaces dual to finitely presented Heyting algebras. This yields in particular a short, self-contained semantic proof of the uniform interpolation theorem for intuitionistic propositional logic, first proved by Pitts in 1992. Our proof is based on the methods of Ghilardi & Zawadowski. However, our proof does not require sheaves nor games, only ba…
▽ More
We prove an open map** theorem for the topological spaces dual to finitely presented Heyting algebras. This yields in particular a short, self-contained semantic proof of the uniform interpolation theorem for intuitionistic propositional logic, first proved by Pitts in 1992. Our proof is based on the methods of Ghilardi & Zawadowski. However, our proof does not require sheaves nor games, only basic duality theory for Heyting algebras.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2018; v1 submitted 4 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Monadic second order logic as the model companion of temporal logic
Authors:
Silvio Ghilardi,
Samuel J. van Gool
Abstract:
The main focus of this paper is on bisimulation-invariant MSO, and more particularly on giving a novel model-theoretic approach to it. In model theory, a model companion of a theory is a first-order description of the class of models in which all potentially solvable systems of equations and non-equations have solutions. We show that bisimulation-invariant MSO on trees gives the model companion fo…
▽ More
The main focus of this paper is on bisimulation-invariant MSO, and more particularly on giving a novel model-theoretic approach to it. In model theory, a model companion of a theory is a first-order description of the class of models in which all potentially solvable systems of equations and non-equations have solutions. We show that bisimulation-invariant MSO on trees gives the model companion for a new temporal logic, "fair CTL", an enrichment of CTL with local fairness constraints. To achieve this, we give a completeness proof for the logic fair CTL which combines tableaux and Stone duality, and a fair CTL encoding of the automata for the modal μ-calculus. Moreover, we also show that MSO on binary trees is the model companion of binary deterministic fair CTL.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
A model-theoretic characterization of monadic second order logic on infinite words
Authors:
Silvio Ghilardi,
Samuel J. van Gool
Abstract:
Monadic second order logic and linear temporal logic are two logical formalisms that can be used to describe classes of infinite words, i.e., first-order models based on the natural numbers with order, successor, and finitely many unary predicate symbols.
Monadic second order logic over infinite words (S1S) can alternatively be described as a first-order logic interpreted in $\mathcal{P}(ω)$, th…
▽ More
Monadic second order logic and linear temporal logic are two logical formalisms that can be used to describe classes of infinite words, i.e., first-order models based on the natural numbers with order, successor, and finitely many unary predicate symbols.
Monadic second order logic over infinite words (S1S) can alternatively be described as a first-order logic interpreted in $\mathcal{P}(ω)$, the power set Boolean algebra of the natural numbers, equipped with modal operators for 'initial', 'next' and 'future' states. We prove that the first-order theory of this structure is the model companion of a class of algebras corresponding to the appropriate version of linear temporal logic (LTL) without until.
The proof makes crucial use of two classical, non-trivial results from the literature, namely the completeness of LTL with respect to the natural numbers, and the correspondence between S1S-formulas and Büchi automata.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2016; v1 submitted 31 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Duality and universal models for the meet-implication fragment of IPC
Authors:
Nick Bezhanishvili,
Dion Coumans,
Samuel J. van Gool,
Dick de Jongh
Abstract:
In this paper we investigate the fragment of intuitionistic logic which only uses conjunction (meet) and implication, using finite duality for distributive lattices and universal models. We give a description of the finitely generated universal models of this fragment and give a complete characterization of the up-sets of Kripke models of intuitionistic logic which can be defined by meet-implicati…
▽ More
In this paper we investigate the fragment of intuitionistic logic which only uses conjunction (meet) and implication, using finite duality for distributive lattices and universal models. We give a description of the finitely generated universal models of this fragment and give a complete characterization of the up-sets of Kripke models of intuitionistic logic which can be defined by meet-implication-formulas. We use these results to derive a new version of subframe formulas for intuitionistic logic and to show that the uniform interpolants of meet-implication-formulas are not necessarily uniform interpolants in the full intuitionistic logic.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2014; v1 submitted 4 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Distributive envelopes and topological duality for lattices via canonical extensions
Authors:
Mai Gehrke,
Sam Van Gool
Abstract:
We establish a topological duality for bounded lattices. The two main features of our duality are that it generalizes Stone duality for bounded distributive lattices, and that the morphisms on either side are not the standard ones. A positive consequence of the choice of morphisms is that those on the topological side are functional. Towards obtaining the topological duality, we develop a universa…
▽ More
We establish a topological duality for bounded lattices. The two main features of our duality are that it generalizes Stone duality for bounded distributive lattices, and that the morphisms on either side are not the standard ones. A positive consequence of the choice of morphisms is that those on the topological side are functional. Towards obtaining the topological duality, we develop a universal construction which associates to an arbitrary lattice two distributive lattice envelopes with a Galois connection between them. This is a modification of a construction of the injective hull of a semilattice by Bruns and Lakser, adjusting their concept of 'admissibility' to the finitary case. Finally, we show that the dual spaces of the distributive envelopes of a lattice coincide with completions of quasi-uniform spaces naturally associated with the lattice, thus giving a precise spatial meaning to the distributive envelopes.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Sheaf representations of MV-algebras and lattice-ordered abelian groups via duality
Authors:
Mai Gehrke,
Samuel J. van Gool,
Vincenzo Marra
Abstract:
We study representations of MV-algebras -- equivalently, unital lattice-ordered abelian groups -- through the lens of Stone-Priestley duality, using canonical extensions as an essential tool. Specifically, the theory of canonical extensions implies that the (Stone-Priestley) dual spaces of MV-algebras carry the structure of topological partial commutative ordered semigroups. We use this structure…
▽ More
We study representations of MV-algebras -- equivalently, unital lattice-ordered abelian groups -- through the lens of Stone-Priestley duality, using canonical extensions as an essential tool. Specifically, the theory of canonical extensions implies that the (Stone-Priestley) dual spaces of MV-algebras carry the structure of topological partial commutative ordered semigroups. We use this structure to obtain two different decompositions of such spaces, one indexed over the prime MV-spectrum, the other over the maximal MV-spectrum. These decompositions yield sheaf representations of MV-algebras, using a new and purely duality-theoretic result that relates certain sheaf representations of distributive lattices to decompositions of their dual spaces. Importantly, the proofs of the MV-algebraic representation theorems that we obtain in this way are distinguished from the existing work on this topic by the following features: (1) we use only basic algebraic facts about MV-algebras; (2) we show that the two aforementioned sheaf representations are special cases of a common result, with potential for generalizations; and (3) we show that these results are strongly related to the structure of the Stone-Priestley duals of MV-algebras. In addition, using our analysis of these decompositions, we prove that MV-algebras with isomorphic underlying lattices have homeomorphic maximal MV-spectra. This result is an MV-algebraic generalization of a classical theorem by Kaplansky stating that two compact Hausdorff spaces are homeomorphic if, and only if, the lattices of continuous [0, 1]-valued functions on the spaces are isomorphic.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2014; v1 submitted 12 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
A non-commutative Priestley duality
Authors:
Andrej Bauer,
Karin Cvetko-Vah,
Mai Gehrke,
Sam van Gool,
Ganna Kudryavtseva
Abstract:
We prove that the category of left-handed strongly distributive skew lattices with zero and proper homomorphisms is dually equivalent to a category of sheaves over local Priestley spaces. Our result thus provides a non-commutative version of classical Priestley duality for distributive lattices and generalizes the recent development of Stone duality for skew Boolean algebras.
From the point of v…
▽ More
We prove that the category of left-handed strongly distributive skew lattices with zero and proper homomorphisms is dually equivalent to a category of sheaves over local Priestley spaces. Our result thus provides a non-commutative version of classical Priestley duality for distributive lattices and generalizes the recent development of Stone duality for skew Boolean algebras.
From the point of view of skew lattices, Leech showed early on that any strongly distributive skew lattice can be embedded in the skew lattice of partial functions on some set with the operations being given by restriction and so-called override. Our duality shows that there is a canonical choice for this embedding.
Conversely, from the point of view of sheaves over Boolean spaces, our results show that skew lattices correspond to Priestley orders on these spaces and that skew lattice structures are naturally appropriate in any setting involving sheaves over Priestley spaces.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2013; v1 submitted 25 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Duality and canonical extensions for stably compact spaces
Authors:
Sam van Gool
Abstract:
We construct a canonical extension for strong proximity lattices in order to give an algebraic, point-free description of a finitary duality for stably compact spaces. In this setting not only morphisms, but also objects may have distinct pi- and sigma-extensions.
We construct a canonical extension for strong proximity lattices in order to give an algebraic, point-free description of a finitary duality for stably compact spaces. In this setting not only morphisms, but also objects may have distinct pi- and sigma-extensions.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2011; v1 submitted 17 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
