-
Critical time-step size analysis and mass scaling by ghost-penalty for immersogeometric explicit dynamics
Authors:
Stein K. F. Stoter,
Sai C. Divi,
E. Harald van Brummelen,
Mats G. Larson,
Frits de Prenter,
Clemens V. Verhoosel
Abstract:
In this article, we study the effect of small-cut elements on the critical time-step size in an immersogeometric context. We analyze different formulations for second-order (membrane) and fourth-order (shell-type) equations, and derive scaling relations between the critical time-step size and the cut-element size for various types of cuts. In particular, we focus on different approaches for the we…
▽ More
In this article, we study the effect of small-cut elements on the critical time-step size in an immersogeometric context. We analyze different formulations for second-order (membrane) and fourth-order (shell-type) equations, and derive scaling relations between the critical time-step size and the cut-element size for various types of cuts. In particular, we focus on different approaches for the weak imposition of Dirichlet conditions: by penalty enforcement and with Nitsche's method. The stability requirement for Nitsche's method necessitates either a cut-size dependent penalty parameter, or an additional ghost-penalty stabilization term is necessary. Our findings show that both techniques suffer from cut-size dependent critical time-step sizes, but the addition of a ghost-penalty term to the mass matrix serves to mitigate this issue. We confirm that this form of `mass-scaling' does not adversely affect error and convergence characteristics for a transient membrane example, and has the potential to increase the critical time-step size by orders of magnitude. Finally, for a prototypical simulation of a Kirchhoff-Love shell, our stabilized Nitsche formulation reduces the solution error by well over an order of magnitude compared to a penalty formulation at equal time-step size.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Scan-based immersed isogeometric flow analysis
Authors:
Clemens V. Verhoosel,
E. Harald van Brummelen,
Sai C. Divi,
Frits de Prenter
Abstract:
This chapter reviews the work conducted by our team on scan-based immersed isogeometric analysis for flow problems. To leverage the advantageous properties of isogeometric analysis on complex scan-based domains, various innovations have been made: (i) A spline-based segmentation strategy has been developed to extract a geometry suitable for immersed analysis directly from scan data; (ii) A stabili…
▽ More
This chapter reviews the work conducted by our team on scan-based immersed isogeometric analysis for flow problems. To leverage the advantageous properties of isogeometric analysis on complex scan-based domains, various innovations have been made: (i) A spline-based segmentation strategy has been developed to extract a geometry suitable for immersed analysis directly from scan data; (ii) A stabilized equal-order velocity-pressure formulation for the Stokes problem has been proposed to attain stable results on immersed domains; (iii) An adaptive integration quadrature procedure has been developed to improve computational efficiency; (iv) A mesh refinement strategy has been developed to capture small features at a priori unknown locations, without drastically increasing the computational cost of the scan-based analysis workflow. We review the key ideas behind each of these innovations, and illustrate these using a selection of simulation results from our work. A patient-specific scan-based analysis case is reproduced to illustrate how these innovations enable the simulation of flow problems on complex scan data.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Stability and conditioning of immersed finite element methods: analysis and remedies
Authors:
Frits de Prenter,
Clemens Verhoosel,
Harald van Brummelen,
Mats Larson,
Santiago Badia
Abstract:
This review paper discusses the developments in immersed or unfitted finite element methods over the past decade. The main focus is the analysis and the treatment of the adverse effects of small cut elements. We distinguish between adverse effects regarding the stability and adverse effects regarding the conditioning of the system, and we present an overview of the developed remedies. In particula…
▽ More
This review paper discusses the developments in immersed or unfitted finite element methods over the past decade. The main focus is the analysis and the treatment of the adverse effects of small cut elements. We distinguish between adverse effects regarding the stability and adverse effects regarding the conditioning of the system, and we present an overview of the developed remedies. In particular, we provide a detailed explanation of Schwarz preconditioning, element aggregation, and the ghost penalty formulation. Furthermore, we outline the methodologies developed for quadrature and weak enforcement of Dirichlet conditions, and we discuss open questions and future research directions.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Residual-based error estimation and adaptivity for stabilized immersed isogeometric analysis using truncated hierarchical B-splines
Authors:
Sai C. Divi,
Pieter H. van Zuijlen,
Tuong Hoang,
Frits de Prenter,
Ferdinando Auricchio,
Alessandro Reali,
E. Harald van Brummelen,
Clemens V. Verhoosel
Abstract:
We propose an adaptive mesh refinement strategy for immersed isogeometric analysis, with application to steady heat conduction and viscous flow problems. The proposed strategy is based on residual-based error estimation, which has been tailored to the immersed setting by the incorporation of appropriately scaled stabilization and boundary terms. Element-wise error indicators are elaborated for the…
▽ More
We propose an adaptive mesh refinement strategy for immersed isogeometric analysis, with application to steady heat conduction and viscous flow problems. The proposed strategy is based on residual-based error estimation, which has been tailored to the immersed setting by the incorporation of appropriately scaled stabilization and boundary terms. Element-wise error indicators are elaborated for the Laplace and Stokes problems, and a THB-spline-based local mesh refinement strategy is proposed. The error estimation .and adaptivity procedure is applied to a series of benchmark problems, demonstrating the suitability of the technique for a range of smooth and non-smooth problems. The adaptivity strategy is also integrated in a scan-based analysis workflow, capable of generating reliable, error-controlled, results from scan data, without the need for extensive user interactions or interventions.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Hierarchical multigrid approaches for the finite cell method on uniform and multi-level hp-refined grids
Authors:
John Jomo,
Oguz Oztoprak,
Frits de Prenter,
Nils Zander,
Stefan Kollmannsberger,
Ernst Rank
Abstract:
This contribution presents a hierarchical multigrid approach for the solution of large-scale finite cell problems on both uniform grids and multi-level hp-discretizations. The proposed scheme leverages the hierarchical nature of the basis functions utilized in the finite cell method and the multi-level hp-method, which is attributed to the use of high-order integrated Legendre basis functions and…
▽ More
This contribution presents a hierarchical multigrid approach for the solution of large-scale finite cell problems on both uniform grids and multi-level hp-discretizations. The proposed scheme leverages the hierarchical nature of the basis functions utilized in the finite cell method and the multi-level hp-method, which is attributed to the use of high-order integrated Legendre basis functions and overlay meshes, to yield a simple and elegant multigrid scheme. This simplicity is reflected in the fact that all restriction and prolongation operators reduce to binary matrices that do not need to be explicitly constructed. The coarse spaces are constructed over the different polynomial orders and refinement levels of the immersed discretization. Elementwise and patchwise additive Schwarz smoothing techniques are used to mitigate the influence of the cut cells leading to convergence rates that are independent of the cut configuration, mesh size and in certain scenarios even the polynomial order. The multigrid approach is applied to second-order problems arising from the Poisson equation and linear elasticity. A series of numerical examples demonstrate the applicability of the scheme for solving large immersed systems with multiple millions and even billions of unknowns on massively parallel machines.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Unification of variational multiscale analysis and Nitsche's method, and a resulting boundary layer fine-scale model
Authors:
Stein K. F. Stoter,
Marco F. P. ten Eikelder,
Frits de Prenter,
Ido Akkerman,
E. Harald van Brummelen,
Clemens V. Verhoosel,
Dominik Schillinger
Abstract:
We show that in the variational multiscale framework, the weak enforcement of essential boundary conditions via Nitsche's method corresponds directly to a particular choice of projection operator. The consistency, symmetry and penalty terms of Nitsche's method all originate from the fine-scale closure dictated by the corresponding scale decomposition. As a result of this formalism, we are able to…
▽ More
We show that in the variational multiscale framework, the weak enforcement of essential boundary conditions via Nitsche's method corresponds directly to a particular choice of projection operator. The consistency, symmetry and penalty terms of Nitsche's method all originate from the fine-scale closure dictated by the corresponding scale decomposition. As a result of this formalism, we are able to determine the exact fine-scale contributions in Nitsche-type formulations. In the context of the advection-diffusion equation, we develop a residual-based model that incorporates the non-vanishing fine scales at the Dirichlet boundaries. This results in an additional boundary term with a new model parameter. We then propose a parameter estimation strategy for all parameters involved that is also consistent for higher-order basis functions. We illustrate with numerical experiments that our new augmented model mitigates the overly diffusive behavior that the classical residual-based fine-scale model exhibits in boundary layers at boundaries with weakly enforced essential conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Scalable multigrid methods for immersed finite element methods and immersed isogeometric analysis
Authors:
F. de Prenter,
C. V. Verhoosel,
E. H. van Brummelen,
J. A. Evans,
C. Messe,
J. Benzaken,
K. Maute
Abstract:
Ill-conditioning of the system matrix is a well-known complication in immersed finite element methods and trimmed isogeometric analysis. Elements with small intersections with the physical domain yield problematic eigenvalues in the system matrix, which generally degrades efficiency and robustness of iterative solvers. In this contribution we investigate the spectral properties of immersed finite…
▽ More
Ill-conditioning of the system matrix is a well-known complication in immersed finite element methods and trimmed isogeometric analysis. Elements with small intersections with the physical domain yield problematic eigenvalues in the system matrix, which generally degrades efficiency and robustness of iterative solvers. In this contribution we investigate the spectral properties of immersed finite element systems treated by Schwarz-type methods, to establish the suitability of these as smoothers in a multigrid method. Based on this investigation we develop a geometric multigrid preconditioner for immersed finite element methods, which provides mesh-independent and cut-element-independent convergence rates. This preconditioning technique is applicable to higher-order discretizations, and enables solving large-scale immersed systems in parallel, at a computational cost that scales linearly with the number of degrees of freedom. The performance of the preconditioner is demonstrated for conventional Lagrange basis functions and for isogeometric discretizations with both uniform B-splines and locally refined approximations based on truncated hierarchical B-splines.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Robust and parallel scalable iterative solutions for large-scale finite cell analyses
Authors:
John N. Jomo,
Frits de Prenter,
Mohamed Elhaddad,
Davide D'Angella,
Clemens V. Verhoosel,
Stefan Kollmannsberger,
Jan S. Kirschke,
Vera Nübel,
Harald van Brummelen,
Ernst Rank
Abstract:
The finite cell method is a highly flexible discretization technique for numerical analysis on domains with complex geometries. By using a non-boundary conforming computational domain that can be easily meshed, automatized computations on a wide range of geometrical models can be performed. Application of the finite cell method, and other immersed methods, to large real-life and industrial problem…
▽ More
The finite cell method is a highly flexible discretization technique for numerical analysis on domains with complex geometries. By using a non-boundary conforming computational domain that can be easily meshed, automatized computations on a wide range of geometrical models can be performed. Application of the finite cell method, and other immersed methods, to large real-life and industrial problems is often limited due to the conditioning problems associated with these methods. These conditioning problems have caused researchers to resort to direct solution methods, which signifi- cantly limit the maximum size of solvable systems. Iterative solvers are better suited for large-scale computations than their direct counterparts due to their lower memory requirements and suitability for parallel computing. These benefits can, however, only be exploited when systems are properly conditioned. In this contribution we present an Additive-Schwarz type preconditioner that enables efficient and parallel scalable iterative solutions of large-scale multi-level hp-refined finite cell analyses.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2018; v1 submitted 4 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
A note on the penalty parameter in Nitsche's method for unfitted boundary value problems
Authors:
Frits de Prenter,
Christoph Lehrenfeld,
André Massing
Abstract:
Nitsche's method is a popular approach to implement Dirichlet-type boundary conditions in situations where a strong imposition is either inconvenient or simply not feasible. The method is widely applied in the context of unfitted finite element methods. From the classical (symmetric) Nitsche's method it is well-known that the stabilization parameter in the method has to be chosen sufficiently larg…
▽ More
Nitsche's method is a popular approach to implement Dirichlet-type boundary conditions in situations where a strong imposition is either inconvenient or simply not feasible. The method is widely applied in the context of unfitted finite element methods. From the classical (symmetric) Nitsche's method it is well-known that the stabilization parameter in the method has to be chosen sufficiently large to obtain unique solvability of discrete systems. In this short note we discuss an often used strategy to set the stabilization parameter and describe a possible problem that can arise from this. We show that in specific situations error bounds can deteriorate and give examples of computations where Nitsche's method yields large and even diverging discretization errors.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Preconditioning immersed isogeometric finite element methods with application to flow problems
Authors:
Frits de Prenter,
Clemens Verhoosel,
Harald van Brummelen
Abstract:
Immersed finite element methods generally suffer from conditioning problems when cut elements intersect the physical domain only on a small fraction of their volume. De Prenter et al. [Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 316 (2017) pp. 297-327] present an analysis for symmetric positive definite (SPD) immersed problems, and for this class of problems an algebraic preconditioner…
▽ More
Immersed finite element methods generally suffer from conditioning problems when cut elements intersect the physical domain only on a small fraction of their volume. De Prenter et al. [Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 316 (2017) pp. 297-327] present an analysis for symmetric positive definite (SPD) immersed problems, and for this class of problems an algebraic preconditioner is developed. In this contribution the conditioning analysis is extended to immersed finite element methods for systems that are not SPD and the preconditioning technique is generalized to a connectivity-based preconditioner inspired by Additive-Schwarz preconditioning. This Connectivity-based Additive-Schwarz (CbAS) preconditioner is applicable to problems that are not SPD and to mixed problems, such as the Stokes and Navier-Stokes equations. A detailed numerical investigation of the effectivity of the CbAS preconditioner to a range of flow problems is presented.
△ Less
Submitted 11 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Condition number analysis and preconditioning of the finite cell method
Authors:
F. de Prenter,
C. V. Verhoosel,
G. J. van Zwieten,
E. H. van Brummelen
Abstract:
The (Isogeometric) Finite Cell Method - in which a domain is immersed in a structured background mesh - suffers from conditioning problems when cells with small volume fractions occur. In this contribution, we establish a rigorous scaling relation between the condition number of (I)FCM system matrices and the smallest cell volume fraction. Ill-conditioning stems either from basis functions being s…
▽ More
The (Isogeometric) Finite Cell Method - in which a domain is immersed in a structured background mesh - suffers from conditioning problems when cells with small volume fractions occur. In this contribution, we establish a rigorous scaling relation between the condition number of (I)FCM system matrices and the smallest cell volume fraction. Ill-conditioning stems either from basis functions being small on cells with small volume fractions, or from basis functions being nearly linearly dependent on such cells. Based on these two sources of ill-conditioning, an algebraic preconditioning technique is developed, which is referred to as Symmetric Incomplete Permuted Inverse Cholesky (SIPIC). A detailed numerical investigation of the effectivity of the SIPIC preconditioner in improving (I)FCM condition numbers and in improving the convergence speed and accuracy of iterative solvers is presented for the Poisson problem and for two- and three-dimensional problems in linear elasticity, in which Nitche's method is applied in either the normal or tangential direction. The accuracy of the preconditioned iterative solver enables mesh convergence studies of the finite cell method.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2016; v1 submitted 19 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
