-
Direction of spontaneous processes in non-equilibrium systems with movable/permeable internal walls
Authors:
Robert Hołyst,
Paweł Jan Żuk,
Anna Maciołek,
Karol Makuch,
Konrad Giżyński
Abstract:
The second law of equilibrium thermodynamics explains the direction of spontaneous processes in a system after removing internal constraints. When the system only exchanges energy with the environment as heat, the second law states that spontaneous processes at constant temperature satisfy: $\textrm{d} U - δQ \leq 0$. Here, $\textrm{d} U$ is the infinitesimal change of the internal energy, and…
▽ More
The second law of equilibrium thermodynamics explains the direction of spontaneous processes in a system after removing internal constraints. When the system only exchanges energy with the environment as heat, the second law states that spontaneous processes at constant temperature satisfy: $\textrm{d} U - δQ \leq 0$. Here, $\textrm{d} U$ is the infinitesimal change of the internal energy, and $δQ$ is the infinitesimal heat exchanged in the process. We will consider three different systems in a heat flow: ideal gas, van der Waals gas, and a binary mixture of ideal gases. We will also study ideal gas and van der Waals gas in the heat flow and gravitational field. We will divide each system internally into two subsystems by a movable wall. We will show that the direction of the motion of the wall, after release, at constant boundary conditions is determined by the same inequality as in equilibrium thermodynamics. The only difference between equilibrium and non-equilibrium law is the dependence of the net heat change, $δQ$, on the state parameters of the system. We will also consider a wall thick and permeable to gas particles and derive Archimedes' principle in the heat flow. Finally, we will study the ideal gas's Couette flow, where the direction of the motion of the internal wall follows from the inequality $\textrm{d} E - δQ - δW_s \leq 0$, with $\textrm{d} E$ being the infinitesimal change of the total energy (internal and kinetic) and $δW_s$ the infinitesimal work exchanged with the environment due to shear force. Ultimately, we will synthesize all these cases in a framework of the second law of non-equilibrium thermodynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2024; v1 submitted 5 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Parameters of state in the global thermodynamics of binary ideal gas mixtures in a stationary heat flow
Authors:
Anna Maciolek,
Robert Holyst,
Karol Makuch,
Konrad Giżynski,
Pawel J. Żuk
Abstract:
We formulate the first law of global thermodynamics for stationary states of the binary ideal gas mixture subjected to heat flow. We map the non-uniform system onto the uniform one and show that the internal energy $U(S^*,V,N_1,N_2,f_1^*,f_2^*)$ is the function of the following parameters of state: a non-equilibrium entropy $S^*$, volume $V$, number of particles of the first component, $N_1$, numb…
▽ More
We formulate the first law of global thermodynamics for stationary states of the binary ideal gas mixture subjected to heat flow. We map the non-uniform system onto the uniform one and show that the internal energy $U(S^*,V,N_1,N_2,f_1^*,f_2^*)$ is the function of the following parameters of state: a non-equilibrium entropy $S^*$, volume $V$, number of particles of the first component, $N_1$, number of particles of the second component $N_2$ and the renormalized degrees of freedom. The parameters $f_1^*,f_2^*$, $N_1, N_2$ satisfy the relation $x_1f_1^*/f_1+x_2f_2^*/f_2=1$ ($f_1$, where $x_i$ is the fraction of $i$ component, and $f_2$ are the degrees of freedom for each component respectively). Thus only 5 parameters of state describe the non-equilibrium state of the binary mixture in the heat flow. We calculate the non-equilibrium entropy $S^{*}$ and new thermodynamic parameters of state $f_1^*, f_2^*$ explicitly. The latter are responsible for heat generation due to the concentration gradients. The theory reduces to equilibrium thermodynamics, when the heat flux goes to zero. As in equilibrium thermodynamics, the steady-state fundamental equation also leads to the thermodynamic Maxwell relations for measurable steady-state properties.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Modified Kirchhoff's Laws for Electric-Double-Layer Charging in Arbitrary Porous Networks
Authors:
Filipe Henrique,
Pawel J. Zuk,
Ankur Gupta
Abstract:
Understanding the dynamics of electric-double-layer (EDL) charging in porous media is essential for advancements in next-generation energy storage devices. Due to the high computational demands of direct numerical simulations and a lack of interfacial boundary conditions for reduced-order models, the current understanding of EDL charging is limited to simple geometries. Here, we present a theoreti…
▽ More
Understanding the dynamics of electric-double-layer (EDL) charging in porous media is essential for advancements in next-generation energy storage devices. Due to the high computational demands of direct numerical simulations and a lack of interfacial boundary conditions for reduced-order models, the current understanding of EDL charging is limited to simple geometries. Here, we present a theoretical framework to predict EDL charging in arbitrary networks of long pores in the Debye-Hückel limit without restrictions on EDL thickness and pore radii. We demonstrate that electrolyte transport is described by Kirchhoff's laws in terms of the electrochemical potential of charge (the valence-weighted average of the ion electrochemical potentials) instead of the electric potential. By employing this equivalent circuit representation with modified Kirchhoff's laws, our methodology accurately captures the spatial and temporal dependencies of charge density and electric potential, matching results obtained from computationally intensive direct numerical simulations. Our framework provides results up to five orders of magnitude faster, enabling the efficient simulation of thousands of pores within a day. We employ the framework to study the impact of pore connectivity and polydispersity on electrode charging dynamics for pore networks and discuss how these factors affect the timescale, energy density, and power density of the capacitive charging. The scalability and versatility of our methodology make it a rational tool for designing 3D-printed electrodes and for interpreting geometric effects on electrode impedance spectroscopy measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2023; v1 submitted 24 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Steady state thermodynamics of ideal gas in shear flow
Authors:
Karol Makuch,
Konrad Giżyński,
Robert Hołyst,
Anna Maciołek,
Paweł J. Żuk
Abstract:
Equilibrium thermodynamics describes the energy exchange of a body with its environment. Here, we describe the global energy exchange of an ideal gas in the Coutte flow in a thermodynamic-like manner. We derive a fundamental relation between internal energy as a function of parameters of state. We analyze a non-equilibrium transition in the system and postulate the extremum principle, which determ…
▽ More
Equilibrium thermodynamics describes the energy exchange of a body with its environment. Here, we describe the global energy exchange of an ideal gas in the Coutte flow in a thermodynamic-like manner. We derive a fundamental relation between internal energy as a function of parameters of state. We analyze a non-equilibrium transition in the system and postulate the extremum principle, which determines stable stationary states in the system. The steady-state thermodynamic framework resembles equilibrium thermodynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Steady thermodynamic fundamental relation for the interacting system in a heat flow
Authors:
Robert Hołyst,
Karol Makuch,
Konrad Giżyński,
Anna Maciołek,
Paweł J. Żuk
Abstract:
There is a long-standing question of whether it is possible to extend the formalism of equilibrium thermodynamics to the case of non-equilibrium systems in steady states. We have made such an extension for an ideal gas in a heat flow [Hołyst \emph{et al.}, J. Chem. Phys. 157, 194108 (2022)]. Here we investigate whether such a description exists for the system with interactions: the Van der Waals g…
▽ More
There is a long-standing question of whether it is possible to extend the formalism of equilibrium thermodynamics to the case of non-equilibrium systems in steady states. We have made such an extension for an ideal gas in a heat flow [Hołyst \emph{et al.}, J. Chem. Phys. 157, 194108 (2022)]. Here we investigate whether such a description exists for the system with interactions: the Van der Waals gas in a heat flow. We introduce the parameters of state, each associated with a single way of changing energy. The first law of non-equilibrium thermodynamics follows from these parameters. The internal energy $U$ for the non-equilibrium states has the same form as in equilibrium thermodynamics. For the Van der Waals gas, $U(S^*, V, N, a^*,b^* )$ is a function of only 5 parameters of state (irrespective of the number of parameters characterizing the boundary conditions): the entropy $S^*$, volume $V$, number of particles $N$, and the rescaled Van der Waals parameters $a^*$, $b^*$. The state parameters, $a^*$, $b^*$, together with $S^*$, determine the net heat exchange with the environment.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Impact of Asymmetries in Valences and Diffusivities on the Transport of a Binary Electrolyte in a Charged Cylindrical Pore
Authors:
Filipe Henrique,
Pawel J. Zuk,
Ankur Gupta
Abstract:
Ion transport in porous media is present in a wealth of technologies, e.g., energy storage devices such as batteries and supercapacitors, and environmental technologies such as electrochemical carbon capture and capacitive deionization. Recent studies on flat-plate electrodes have demonstrated that asymmetries in ion properties, such as valences and diffusivities, lead to intriguing and counter-in…
▽ More
Ion transport in porous media is present in a wealth of technologies, e.g., energy storage devices such as batteries and supercapacitors, and environmental technologies such as electrochemical carbon capture and capacitive deionization. Recent studies on flat-plate electrodes have demonstrated that asymmetries in ion properties, such as valences and diffusivities, lead to intriguing and counter-intuitive physical phenomena. Yet, the consequences of such asymmetries to ion transport have seldom been explored in porous geometries. To bridge this knowledge gap, we conduct a perturbation expansion of the Poisson-Nernst-Planck equations in a cylindrical pore in the limit of small potentials for a binary electrolyte with arbitrary valences and diffusivities. We obtain good agreement between the perturbation analysis and direct numerical simulations. Our analysis reveals that the charge and the salt transport are coupled with each other. Further, the coupling between the charge and salt transport processes is enhanced with an increase in valence and diffusivity asymmetries of ions. We observe that the mismatch of the ionic diffusivities induces a non-trivial salt dynamics, producing either transient depletion or enhancement of salt in the pore. In the regime of high static diffusion layer conductance, we obtain an analytical solution to our perturbation model. The solution elucidates how electrolyte asymmetry induces two charging timescales that are set by the relative pore size. In the overlap**-double-layer regime, these timescales reduce to the diffusion times of each ion such that the transport of the two ions appears to be decoupled. Overall, our work underscores that the asymmetry in cation and anion diffusivities fundamentally alters the behavior of ionic transport inside a charged cylindrical pore and opens up new avenues of research on electrolyte transport in porous materials.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2022; v1 submitted 13 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Thermodynamics of stationary states of the ideal gas in a heat flow
Authors:
Robert Hołyst,
Karol Makuch,
Anna Maciołek,
Paweł J. Żuk
Abstract:
There is a long-standing question as to whether and to what extent it is possible to describe nonequilibrium systems in stationary states in terms of global thermodynamic functions. The positive answers have been obtained only for isothermal systems or systems with small temperature differences. We formulate thermodynamics of the stationary states of the ideal gas subjected to heat flow in the for…
▽ More
There is a long-standing question as to whether and to what extent it is possible to describe nonequilibrium systems in stationary states in terms of global thermodynamic functions. The positive answers have been obtained only for isothermal systems or systems with small temperature differences. We formulate thermodynamics of the stationary states of the ideal gas subjected to heat flow in the form of the zeroth, first, and second law. Surprisingly, the formal structure of steady state thermodynamics is the same as in equilibrium thermodynamics. We rigorously show that $U$ satisfies the following equation $dU=T^{*}dS^{*}-pdV$ for a constant number of particles, irrespective of the shape of the container, boundary conditions, size of the system, or mode of heat transfer into the system. We calculate $S^{*}$ and $T^{*}$ explicitly. The theory selects stable nonequilibrium steady states in a multistable system of ideal gas subjected to volumetric heating. It reduces to equilibrium thermodynamics when heat flux goes to zero.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2022; v1 submitted 25 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Charging Dynamics of Electrical Double Layers Inside a Cylindrical Pore: Predicting the Effects of Arbitrary Pore Size
Authors:
Filipe Henrique,
Pawel J. Zuk,
Ankur Gupta
Abstract:
Porous electrodes are found in energy storage devices such as supercapacitors and pseudocapacitors. However, the effect of electrode-pore-size distribution over their energy storage properties remains unclear. Here, we develop a model for the charging of electrical double layers inside a cylindrical pore for arbitrary pore size. We assume small applied potentials and perform a regular perturbation…
▽ More
Porous electrodes are found in energy storage devices such as supercapacitors and pseudocapacitors. However, the effect of electrode-pore-size distribution over their energy storage properties remains unclear. Here, we develop a model for the charging of electrical double layers inside a cylindrical pore for arbitrary pore size. We assume small applied potentials and perform a regular perturbation analysis to predict the evolution of electrical potential and ion concentrations in both the radial and axial directions. We validate our perturbation model with direct numerical simulations of the Poisson-Nernst-Planck equations, and obtain quantitative agreement between the two approaches for small and moderate potentials. Our analysis yields two main characteristic features of arbitrary pore size: i) a monotonic decrease of the charging timescale with an increase in relative pore size (pore size relative to Debye length); ii) large potential changes for overlap** double layers in a thin transition region, which we approximate mathematically by a jump discontinuity. We quantify the contributions of electromigration and charge diffusion fluxes which provide mechanistic insights into the dependence of charging timescale and capacitance on pore size. We develop a modified transmission circuit model that captures the effect of arbitrary pore size and demonstrate that a time-dependent transition-region resistor needs to be included in the circuit. We also derive phenomenological expressions for average effective capacitance and charging timescale as a function of pore-size distribution. We show that the capacitance and charging timescale increase with smaller average pore sizes and with smaller polydispersity, resulting in a gain of energy density at a constant power density. Overall, our results advance the mechanistic understanding of electrical-double-layer charging.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2021; v1 submitted 25 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Continuous non-equilibrium transition driven by the heat flow
Authors:
Yirui Zhang,
Marek Litniewski,
Karol Makuch,
Pawel J. Zuk,
Anna Maciolek,
Robert Holyst
Abstract:
We discovered an out-of-equilibrium transition in the ideal gas between two walls, divided by an inner, adiabatic, movable wall. The system is driven out-of-equilibrium by supplying energy directly into the volume of the gas. At critical heat flux, we have found a continuous transition to the state with a low-density, hot gas on one side of the movable wall and a dense, cold gas on the other side.…
▽ More
We discovered an out-of-equilibrium transition in the ideal gas between two walls, divided by an inner, adiabatic, movable wall. The system is driven out-of-equilibrium by supplying energy directly into the volume of the gas. At critical heat flux, we have found a continuous transition to the state with a low-density, hot gas on one side of the movable wall and a dense, cold gas on the other side. Molecular dynamic simulations of the soft-sphere fluid confirm the existence of the transition in the interacting system. We introduce a stationary state Helmholtz-like function whose minimum determines the stable positions of the internal wall. This transition can be used as a paradigm of transitions in stationary states and the Helmholtz-like function as a paradigm of the thermodynamic description of these states.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2021; v1 submitted 23 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Generalization of the Rotne-Prager-Yamakawa mobility and shear disturbance tensors
Authors:
Eligiusz Wajnryb,
Krzysztof A. Mizerski,
Pawel J. Zuk,
Piotr Szymczak
Abstract:
Rotne-Prager-Yamakawa approximation is one of the most commonly used methods of including hydrodynamic interactions in modelling of colloidal suspensions and polymer solutions. The two main merits of this approximation is that it includes all long-range terms (i.e. decaying as R^-3 or slower in interparticle distances) and that the diffusion matrix is positive definite, which is essential for Brow…
▽ More
Rotne-Prager-Yamakawa approximation is one of the most commonly used methods of including hydrodynamic interactions in modelling of colloidal suspensions and polymer solutions. The two main merits of this approximation is that it includes all long-range terms (i.e. decaying as R^-3 or slower in interparticle distances) and that the diffusion matrix is positive definite, which is essential for Brownian dynamics modelling. Here, we extend the Rotne-Prager-Yamakawa approach to include both translational and rotational degrees of freedom, and derive the regularizing corrections to account for overlap** particles. Additionally, we show how the Rotne-Prager-Yamakawa approximation can be generalized for other geometries and boundary conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
