-
Dynamics of McMillan map**s II. Axially symmetric map
Authors:
Tim Zolkin,
Brandon Cathey,
Sergei Nagaitsev
Abstract:
In this article, we investigate the transverse dynamics of a single particle in a model integrable accelerator lattice, based on a McMillan axially-symmetric electron lens. Although the McMillan e-lens has been considered as a device potentially capable of mitigating collective space charge forces, some of its fundamental properties have not been described yet. The main goal of our work is to clos…
▽ More
In this article, we investigate the transverse dynamics of a single particle in a model integrable accelerator lattice, based on a McMillan axially-symmetric electron lens. Although the McMillan e-lens has been considered as a device potentially capable of mitigating collective space charge forces, some of its fundamental properties have not been described yet. The main goal of our work is to close this gap and understand the limitations and potentials of this device. It is worth mentioning that the McMillan axially symmetric map provides the first-order approximations of dynamics for a general linear lattice plus an arbitrary thin lens with motion separable in polar coordinates. Therefore, advancements in its understanding should give us a better picture of more generic and not necessarily integrable round beams. In the first part of the article, we classify all possible regimes with stable trajectories and find the canonical action-angle variables. This provides an evaluation of the dynamical aperture, Poincaré rotation numbers as functions of amplitudes, and thus determines the spread in nonlinear tunes. Also, we provide a parameterization of invariant curves, allowing for the immediate determination of the map image forward and backward in time. The second part investigates the particle dynamics as a function of system parameters. We show that there are three fundamentally different configurations of the accelerator optics causing different regimes of nonlinear oscillations. Each regime is considered in great detail, including the limiting cases of large and small amplitudes. In addition, we analyze the dynamics in Cartesian coordinates and provide a description of observable variables and corresponding spectra.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Dynamics of McMillan map**s I. McMillan multipoles
Authors:
Tim Zolkin,
Sergei Nagaitsev,
Ivan Morozov
Abstract:
In this article, we consider two dynamical systems: the McMillan sextupole and octupole integrable map**s, originally proposed by Edwin McMillan. Both represent the simplest symmetric McMillan maps, characterized by a single intrinsic parameter. While these systems find numerous applications across various domains of mathematics and physics, some of their dynamical properties remain unexplored.…
▽ More
In this article, we consider two dynamical systems: the McMillan sextupole and octupole integrable map**s, originally proposed by Edwin McMillan. Both represent the simplest symmetric McMillan maps, characterized by a single intrinsic parameter. While these systems find numerous applications across various domains of mathematics and physics, some of their dynamical properties remain unexplored. We aim to bridge this gap by providing a comprehensive description of all stable trajectories, including the parametrization of invariant curves, Poincaré rotation numbers, and canonical action-angle variables.
In the second part, we establish connections between these maps and general chaotic maps in standard form. Our investigation reveals that the McMillan sextupole and octupole serve as first-order approximations of the dynamics around the fixed point, akin to the linear map and quadratic invariant (known as the Courant-Snyder invariant in accelerator physics), which represents zeroth-order approximations (referred to as linearization). Furthermore, we propose a novel formalism for nonlinear Twiss parameters, which accounts for the dependence of rotation number on amplitude. This stands in contrast to conventional betatron phase advance used in accelerator physics, which remains independent of amplitude. Notably, in the context of accelerator physics, this new formalism demonstrates its capability in predicting dynamical aperture around low-order resonances for flat beams, a critical aspect in beam injection/extraction scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Integrable symplectic maps with a polygon tessellation
Authors:
Timofey Zolkin,
Yaroslav Kharkov,
Sergei Nagaitsev
Abstract:
The identification of integrable dynamics remains a formidable challenge, and despite centuries of research, only a handful of examples are known to date. In this article, we explore a special form of area-preserving (symplectic) map**s derived from the stroboscopic Poincare cross-section of a kicked rotator. Notably, Suris' theorem constrains the integrability within this category of map**s,…
▽ More
The identification of integrable dynamics remains a formidable challenge, and despite centuries of research, only a handful of examples are known to date. In this article, we explore a special form of area-preserving (symplectic) map**s derived from the stroboscopic Poincare cross-section of a kicked rotator. Notably, Suris' theorem constrains the integrability within this category of map**s, outlining potential scenarios with analytic invariants of motion. In this paper, we challenge the assumption of the analyticity of the invariant, by exploring piecewise linear transformations on a torus and associated systems on the plane, incorporating arithmetic quasiperiodicity and discontinuities. By introducing a new automated technique, we discovered previously unknown scenarios featuring polygonal invariants that form perfect tessellations and, moreover, fibrations of the plane/torus. In this way, this work reveals a novel category of planar tilings characterized by discrete symmetries that emerge from the invertibility of transformations and are intrinsically linked to the presence of integrability. Our algorithm relies on the analysis of the Poincare rotation number and its piecewise monotonic nature for integrable cases, contrasting with the noisy behavior in the case of chaos, thereby allowing for clear separation. Some of the newly discovered systems exhibit the peculiar behavior of integrable diffusion, marked by infinite and quasi-random hop** between tiles while being confined to a set of invariant segments. Finally, through the implementation of a smoothening procedure, all map**s can be generalized to quasi-integrable scenarios with smooth invariant motion, thereby opening doors to potential practical applications.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2023; v1 submitted 29 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Symplectic Particle Tracking in a Thick Nonlinear McMillan Lens for the Fermilab Integrable Optics Test Accelerator (IOTA)
Authors:
B. Cathey,
G. Stancari,
T. Zolkin
Abstract:
The McMillan system is a novel method to increase the tune spread of a beam without decreasing its dynamic aperture due to the systems integrability. While the ideal system is based on an infinitely thin kick, the physical design requires a thick electron lens, including a solenoid. Particle transport through the lens is difficult to simulate due to the nature of the force on the circulating beam.…
▽ More
The McMillan system is a novel method to increase the tune spread of a beam without decreasing its dynamic aperture due to the systems integrability. While the ideal system is based on an infinitely thin kick, the physical design requires a thick electron lens, including a solenoid. Particle transport through the lens is difficult to simulate due to the nature of the force on the circulating beam. This paper demonstrates accurate simulation of a thick McMillan lens in a solenoid using symplectic integrators derived from Yoshidas method.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
McMillan map and nonlinear Twiss parameters
Authors:
Timofey Zolkin,
Sergei Nagaitsev,
Ivan Morozov
Abstract:
In this article we consider two dynamical systems: the McMillan sextupole and octupole integrable map**s originally introduced by Edwin McMillan; the second one is also known as canonical McMillan map. Both of them are simplest symmetric McMillan maps with only one intrinsic parameter, the trace of the Jacobian at the fixed point. While these dynamical systems have numerous of applications and a…
▽ More
In this article we consider two dynamical systems: the McMillan sextupole and octupole integrable map**s originally introduced by Edwin McMillan; the second one is also known as canonical McMillan map. Both of them are simplest symmetric McMillan maps with only one intrinsic parameter, the trace of the Jacobian at the fixed point. While these dynamical systems have numerous of applications and are used in many areas of math and physics, some of their dynamical properties have not been described yet. We fulfill the gap and provide complete description of all stable trajectories including parametrization of invariant curves, Pioncaré rotation numbers and canonical action-angle variables.
In the second part we relate these maps with general chaotic map in McMillan-Turaev form. We show that McMillan sextupole and octupole map**s are first order approximations of dynamics around the fixed point, in a similar way as linear map and quadratic invariant (Courant-Snyder invariant in accelerator physics) is the zeroth order approximation (known as linearization). Finally we suggest the new formalism of nonlinear Twiss parameters which incorporate dependence of rotation number as a function of amplitude, in contrast to e.g. betatron phase advance used in accelerator physics which is independent of amplitude. Specifically in application to accelerator physics this new formalism is capable of predicting dynamical aperture around 1-st, 2-nd, 3-rd and 4-th order resonances for flat beams, which is critical for beam injection/extraction.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Accelerator and Beam Physics: Grand Challenges and Research Opportunities
Authors:
S. Nagaitsev,
V. Shiltsev,
A. Valishev,
T. Zolkin,
J. -L. Vay,
M. Bai,
Y. Cai,
M. J. Hogan,
Z. Huang,
J. Seeman,
B. Dunham,
X. Huang,
T. Roser,
M. Minty,
J. Rosenzweig,
P. Piot,
J. Power,
J. M. Byrd,
A. Seryi,
S. Lund,
J. R. Patterson
Abstract:
Accelerator and beam physics (ABP) is the science of the motion, generation, acceleration, manipulation, prediction, observation and use of charged particle beams. It focuses on fundamental long-term accelerator and beam physics research and development. Accelerator and beam physics research has resulted in important advances in accelerator science, yet support for this research is declining. NSF…
▽ More
Accelerator and beam physics (ABP) is the science of the motion, generation, acceleration, manipulation, prediction, observation and use of charged particle beams. It focuses on fundamental long-term accelerator and beam physics research and development. Accelerator and beam physics research has resulted in important advances in accelerator science, yet support for this research is declining. NSF has terminated its program in accelerator Science and funding by DOE through GARD and Accelerator Stewardship has been steady or declining. The declining support for accelerator research will slow advances and threaten student training and work-force development in accelerator science. We propose a robust and scientifically challenging program in accelerator and beam physics, which will position the field of US High Energy Physics to be productive and competitive for decades to come.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Machine-assisted discovery of integrable symplectic map**s
Authors:
Timofey Zolkin,
Yaroslav Kharkov,
Sergei Nagaitsev
Abstract:
We present a new automated method for finding integrable symplectic maps of the plane. These dynamical systems possess a hidden symmetry associated with an existence of conserved quantities, i.e. integrals of motion. The core idea of the algorithm is based on the knowledge that the evolution of an integrable system in the phase space is restricted to a lower-dimensional submanifold. Limiting ourse…
▽ More
We present a new automated method for finding integrable symplectic maps of the plane. These dynamical systems possess a hidden symmetry associated with an existence of conserved quantities, i.e. integrals of motion. The core idea of the algorithm is based on the knowledge that the evolution of an integrable system in the phase space is restricted to a lower-dimensional submanifold. Limiting ourselves to polygon invariants of motion, we analyze the shape of individual trajectories thus successfully distinguishing integrable motion from chaotic cases. For example, our method rediscovers some of the famous McMillan-Suris integrable map**s and discrete Painlevé equations. In total, over 100 new integrable families are presented and analyzed; some of them are isolated in the space of parameters, and some of them are families with one parameter (or the ratio of parameters) being continuous or discrete. At the end of the paper, we suggest how newly discovered maps are related to a general 2D symplectic map via an introduction of discrete perturbation theory and propose a method on how to construct smooth near-integrable dynamical systems based on map**s with polygon invariants.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2023; v1 submitted 31 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Extracting Dynamical Frequencies from Invariants of Motion in Finite-Dimensional Nonlinear Integrable Systems
Authors:
Chad E. Mitchell,
Robert D. Ryne,
Kilean Hwang,
Sergei Nagaitsev,
Timofey Zolkin
Abstract:
Integrable dynamical systems play an important role in many areas of science, including accelerator and plasma physics. An integrable dynamical system with $n$ degrees of freedom (DOF) possesses $n$ nontrivial integrals of motion, and can be solved, in principle, by covering the phase space with one or more charts in which the dynamics can be described using action-angle coordinates. To obtain the…
▽ More
Integrable dynamical systems play an important role in many areas of science, including accelerator and plasma physics. An integrable dynamical system with $n$ degrees of freedom (DOF) possesses $n$ nontrivial integrals of motion, and can be solved, in principle, by covering the phase space with one or more charts in which the dynamics can be described using action-angle coordinates. To obtain the frequencies of motion, both the transformation to action-angle coordinates and its inverse must be known in explicit form. However, no general algorithm exists for constructing this transformation explicitly from a set of $n$ known (and generally coupled) integrals of motion. In this paper we describe how one can determine the dynamical frequencies of the motion as functions of these $n$ integrals in the absence of explicitly-known action-angle variables, and we provide several examples.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2021; v1 submitted 4 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Accelerator and Beam Physics Research Goals and Opportunities
Authors:
S. Nagaitsev,
Z. Huang,
J. Power,
J. -L. Vay,
P. Piot,
L. Spentzouris,
J. Rosenzweig,
Y. Cai,
S. Cousineau,
M. Conde,
M. Hogan,
A. Valishev,
M. Minty,
T. Zolkin,
X. Huang,
V. Shiltsev,
J. Seeman,
J. Byrd,
Y. Hao,
B. Dunham,
B. Carlsten,
A. Seryi,
R. Patterson
Abstract:
This report is a summary of two preparatory workshops, documenting the community vision for the national accelerator and beam physics research program. It identifies the Grand Challenges of accelerator and beam physics (ABP) field and documents research opportunities to address these Grand Challenges. This report will be used to develop a strategic research roadmap for the field of accelerator sci…
▽ More
This report is a summary of two preparatory workshops, documenting the community vision for the national accelerator and beam physics research program. It identifies the Grand Challenges of accelerator and beam physics (ABP) field and documents research opportunities to address these Grand Challenges. This report will be used to develop a strategic research roadmap for the field of accelerator science.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2021; v1 submitted 11 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Betatron frequency and the Poincare rotation number
Authors:
Sergei Nagaitsev,
Timofey Zolkin
Abstract:
Symplectic maps are routinely used to describe single-particle dynamics in circular accelerators. In the case of a linear accelerator map, the rotation number (the betatron frequency) can be easily calculated from the map itself. In the case of a nonlinear map, the rotation number is normally obtained numerically, by iterating the map for given initial conditions, or through a normal form analysis…
▽ More
Symplectic maps are routinely used to describe single-particle dynamics in circular accelerators. In the case of a linear accelerator map, the rotation number (the betatron frequency) can be easily calculated from the map itself. In the case of a nonlinear map, the rotation number is normally obtained numerically, by iterating the map for given initial conditions, or through a normal form analysis, a type of a perturbation theory for maps. Integrable maps, a subclass of symplectic maps, allow for an analytic evaluation of their rotation numbers. In this paper we propose an analytic expression to determine the rotation number for integrable symplectic maps of the plane and present several examples, relevant to accelerators. These new results can be used to analyze the topology of the accelerator Hamiltonians as well as to serve as the starting point for a perturbation theory for maps.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
TMCI with Resonator Wakes
Authors:
Alexey Burov,
Timofey Zolkin
Abstract:
Transverse mode-coupling instability (TMCI) with a high-frequency resonator wake is examined by the Nested Head-Tail Vlasov solver (NHT), where a Gaussian bunch in a parabolic potential (GP model) is represented by concentric rings in the longitudinal phase space. It is shown that multiple mode couplings and decouplings make impossible an unambiguous definition of the threshold, unless Landau damp…
▽ More
Transverse mode-coupling instability (TMCI) with a high-frequency resonator wake is examined by the Nested Head-Tail Vlasov solver (NHT), where a Gaussian bunch in a parabolic potential (GP model) is represented by concentric rings in the longitudinal phase space. It is shown that multiple mode couplings and decouplings make impossible an unambiguous definition of the threshold, unless Landau dam** is taken into account. To address this problem, instead of a single instability threshold, an interval of thresholds is suggested, bounded by the low and high intensity ones. For the broadband impedance model, the high intensity threshold is shown to follow Zotter's scaling, but smaller by about a factor of two. The same scaling, this time smaller than Zotter's by a factor of four, is found for the ABS model (Air Bag Square well).
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2018; v1 submitted 19 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
TMCI and Space Charge II
Authors:
Timofey Zolkin,
Alexey Burov,
Bipul Pandey
Abstract:
Transverse mode-coupling instability (TMCI) is known to limit bunch intensity. Since space charge (SC) changes coherent spectra, it affects the TMCI threshold. Generally, there are only two types of TMCI with respect to SC: the vanishing type and the strong space charge (SSC) type. For the former, the threshold value of the wake tune shift is asymptotically proportional to the SC tune shift, as it…
▽ More
Transverse mode-coupling instability (TMCI) is known to limit bunch intensity. Since space charge (SC) changes coherent spectra, it affects the TMCI threshold. Generally, there are only two types of TMCI with respect to SC: the vanishing type and the strong space charge (SSC) type. For the former, the threshold value of the wake tune shift is asymptotically proportional to the SC tune shift, as it was first observed twenty years ago by M. Blaskiewicz for exponential wakes. For the latter, the threshold value of the wake tune shift is asymptotically inversely proportional to the SC, as it was shown by one of the authors. In the presented studies of various wakes, potential wells, and bunch distributions, the second type of instability was always observed for cosine wakes; it was also seen for the sine wakes in the case of a bunch within a square potential well. The vanishing TMCI was observed for all other wakes and distributions we discuss in this paper: always for the negative wakes, and always, except the cosine wake, for parabolic potential wells. At the end of this paper, we consider high-frequency broadband wake, suggested as a model impedance for CERN SPS ring. As expected, TMCI is of the vanishing type in this case. Thus, SPS Q26 instability, observed at strong SC almost with the same bunch parameters as it would be observed without SC, cannot be TMCI.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2018; v1 submitted 29 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
TMCI and Space Charge
Authors:
T. Zolkin,
A. Burov
Abstract:
Transverse mode-coupling instability (TMCI) is known to limit bunch intensity. Since space charge (SC) changes the spectra of the collective modes, it affects the TMCI threshold as well. In agreement with results of M. Blaskiewicz and V. Balbekov, we found that, when the wake is negative or it essentially negative, the instability threshold increases as fast as the space charge tune shift when the…
▽ More
Transverse mode-coupling instability (TMCI) is known to limit bunch intensity. Since space charge (SC) changes the spectra of the collective modes, it affects the TMCI threshold as well. In agreement with results of M. Blaskiewicz and V. Balbekov, we found that, when the wake is negative or it essentially negative, the instability threshold increases as fast as the space charge tune shift when the latter is large enough. In contrast, for oscillating wakes, when the oscillations are sufficiently pronounced, the threshold dependence on SC is non-monotonic; at sufficiently high SC tune shift the threshold goes inversely proportional to that.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Rotation number of integrable symplectic map**s of the plane
Authors:
Timofey Zolkin,
Sergei Nagaitsev,
Viatcheslav Danilov
Abstract:
Symplectic map**s are discrete-time analogs of Hamiltonian systems. They appear in many areas of physics, including, for example, accelerators, plasma, and fluids. Integrable map**s, a subclass of symplectic map**s, are equivalent to a Twist map, with a rotation number, constant along the phase trajectory. In this letter, we propose a succinct expression to determine the rotation number and…
▽ More
Symplectic map**s are discrete-time analogs of Hamiltonian systems. They appear in many areas of physics, including, for example, accelerators, plasma, and fluids. Integrable map**s, a subclass of symplectic map**s, are equivalent to a Twist map, with a rotation number, constant along the phase trajectory. In this letter, we propose a succinct expression to determine the rotation number and present two examples. Similar to the period of the bounded motion in Hamiltonian systems, the rotation number is the most fundamental property of integrable maps and it provides a way to analyze the phase-space dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
On sector magnets or transverse electromagnetic fields in cylindrical coordinates
Authors:
Timofey Zolkin
Abstract:
The Laplace's equations for the scalar and vector potentials describing electric or magnetic fields in cylindrical coordinates with translational invariance along azimuthal coordinate are considered. The series of special functions which, when expanded in power series in radial and vertical coordinates, in lowest order replicate the harmonic homogeneous polynomials of two variables are found. Thes…
▽ More
The Laplace's equations for the scalar and vector potentials describing electric or magnetic fields in cylindrical coordinates with translational invariance along azimuthal coordinate are considered. The series of special functions which, when expanded in power series in radial and vertical coordinates, in lowest order replicate the harmonic homogeneous polynomials of two variables are found. These functions are based on radial harmonics found by Edwin~M.~McMillan in his more-than-40-years "forgotten" article, which will be discussed. In addition to McMillan's harmonics, second family of adjoint radial harmonics is introduced, in order to provide symmetric description between electric and magnetic fields and to describe fields and potentials in terms of same special functions. Formulas to relate any transverse fields specified by the coefficients in the power series expansion in radial or vertical planes in cylindrical coordinates with the set of new functions are provided.
This result is no doubt important for potential theory while also critical for theoretical studies, design and proper modeling of sector dipoles, combined function dipoles and any general sector element for accelerator physics. All results are presented in connection with these problems.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
