-
Scaling Beyond Bandwidth Limitations: Wireless Control With Stability Guarantees Under Overload
Authors:
Fabian Mager,
Dominik Baumann,
Carsten Herrmann,
Sebastian Trimpe,
Marco Zimmerling
Abstract:
An important class of cyber-physical systems relies on multiple agents that jointly perform a task by coordinating their actions over a wireless network. Examples include self-driving cars in intelligent transportation and production robots in smart manufacturing. However, the scalability of existing control-over-wireless solutions is limited as they cannot resolve overload situations in which the…
▽ More
An important class of cyber-physical systems relies on multiple agents that jointly perform a task by coordinating their actions over a wireless network. Examples include self-driving cars in intelligent transportation and production robots in smart manufacturing. However, the scalability of existing control-over-wireless solutions is limited as they cannot resolve overload situations in which the communication demand exceeds the available bandwidth. This paper presents a novel co-design of distributed control and wireless communication that overcomes this limitation by dynamically allocating the available bandwidth to agents with the greatest need to communicate. Experiments on a real cyber-physical testbed with 20 agents, each consisting of a low-power wireless embedded device and a cart-pole system, demonstrate that our solution achieves significantly better control performance under overload than the state of the art. We further prove that our co-design guarantees closed-loop stability for physical systems with stochastic linear time-invariant dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2022; v1 submitted 16 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Wireless Control for Smart Manufacturing: Recent Approaches and Open Challenges
Authors:
Dominik Baumann,
Fabian Mager,
Ulf Wetzker,
Lothar Thiele,
Marco Zimmerling,
Sebastian Trimpe
Abstract:
Smart manufacturing aims to overcome the limitations of today's rigid assembly lines by making the material flow and manufacturing process more flexible, versatile, and scalable. The main economic drivers are higher resource and cost efficiency as the manufacturers can more quickly adapt to changing market needs and also increase the lifespan of their production sites. The ability to close feedbac…
▽ More
Smart manufacturing aims to overcome the limitations of today's rigid assembly lines by making the material flow and manufacturing process more flexible, versatile, and scalable. The main economic drivers are higher resource and cost efficiency as the manufacturers can more quickly adapt to changing market needs and also increase the lifespan of their production sites. The ability to close feedback loops fast and reliably over long distances among mobile robots, remote sensors, and human operators is a key enabler for smart manufacturing. Thus, this article provides a perspective on control and coordination over wireless networks. Based on an analysis of real-world use cases, we identify the main technical challenges that need to be solved to close the large gap between the current state of the art in industry and the vision of smart manufacturing. We discuss to what extent existing control-over-wireless solutions in the literature address those challenges, including our own approach toward a tight integration of control and wireless communication. In addition to a theoretical analysis of closed-loop stability, practical experiments on a cyber-physical testbed demonstrate that our approach supports relevant smart manufacturing scenarios. The article concludes with a discussion of open challenges and future research directions.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
The Time-Triggered Wireless Architecture
Authors:
Romain Jacob,
Licong Zhang,
Marco Zimmerling,
Jan Beutel,
Samarjit Chakraborty,
Lothar Thiele
Abstract:
Wirelessly interconnected sensors, actuators, and controllers promise greater flexibility, lower installation and maintenance costs, and higher robustness in harsh conditions than wired solutions. However, to facilitate the adoption of wireless communication in cyber-physical systems (CPS), the functional and non-functional properties must be similar to those known from wired architectures. We thu…
▽ More
Wirelessly interconnected sensors, actuators, and controllers promise greater flexibility, lower installation and maintenance costs, and higher robustness in harsh conditions than wired solutions. However, to facilitate the adoption of wireless communication in cyber-physical systems (CPS), the functional and non-functional properties must be similar to those known from wired architectures. We thus present Time-Triggered Wireless (TTW), a wireless architecture for multi-mode CPS that offers reliable communication with guarantees on end-to-end delays among distributed applications executing on low-cost, low-power embedded devices. We achieve this by exploiting the high reliability and deterministic behavior of a synchronous transmission based communication stack we design, and by coupling the timings of distributed task executions and message exchanges across the wireless network by solving a novel co-scheduling problem. While some of the concepts in TTW have existed for some time and TTW has already been successfully applied for feedback control and coordination of multiple mechanical systems with closed-loop stability guarantees, this paper presents the key algorithmic, scheduling, and networking mechanisms behind TTW, along with their experimental evaluation, which have not been known so far. TTW is open source and ready to use: ttw.ethz.ch
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2020; v1 submitted 18 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Synchronous Transmissions in Low-Power Wireless: A Survey of Communication Protocols and Network Services
Authors:
Marco Zimmerling,
Luca Mottola,
Silvia Santini
Abstract:
Low-power wireless communication is a central building block of Cyber-physical Systems and the Internet of Things. Conventional low-power wireless protocols make avoiding packet collisions a cornerstone design choice. The concept of synchronous transmissions challenges this view. As collisions are not necessarily destructive, under specific circumstances, commodity low-power wireless radios are of…
▽ More
Low-power wireless communication is a central building block of Cyber-physical Systems and the Internet of Things. Conventional low-power wireless protocols make avoiding packet collisions a cornerstone design choice. The concept of synchronous transmissions challenges this view. As collisions are not necessarily destructive, under specific circumstances, commodity low-power wireless radios are often able to receive useful information even in the presence of superimposed signals from different transmitters. We survey the growing number of protocols that exploit synchronous transmissions for higher robustness and efficiency as well as unprecedented functionality and versatility compared to conventional designs. The illustration of protocols based on synchronous transmissions is cast in a conceptional framework we establish, with the goal of highlighting differences and similarities among the proposed solutions. We conclude the paper with a discussion on open research questions in this field.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2020; v1 submitted 23 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Fast Feedback Control over Multi-hop Wireless Networks with Mode Changes and Stability Guarantees
Authors:
Dominik Baumann,
Fabian Mager,
Romain Jacob,
Lothar Thiele,
Marco Zimmerling,
Sebastian Trimpe
Abstract:
Closing feedback loops fast and over long distances is key to emerging cyber-physical applications; for example, robot motion control and swarm coordination require update intervals of tens of milliseconds. Low-power wireless communication technology is preferred for its low cost, small form factor, and flexibility, especially if the devices support multi-hop communication. Thus far, however, feed…
▽ More
Closing feedback loops fast and over long distances is key to emerging cyber-physical applications; for example, robot motion control and swarm coordination require update intervals of tens of milliseconds. Low-power wireless communication technology is preferred for its low cost, small form factor, and flexibility, especially if the devices support multi-hop communication. Thus far, however, feedback control over multi-hop low-power wireless networks has only been demonstrated for update intervals on the order of seconds. To fill this gap, this paper presents a wireless embedded system that supports dynamic mode changes and tames imperfections impairing control performance (e.g., jitter and message loss), and a control design that exploits the essential properties of this system to provably guarantee closed-loop stability for physical processes with linear time-invariant dynamics in the presence of mode changes. Using experiments on a cyber-physical testbed with 20 wireless devices and multiple cart-pole systems, we are the first to demonstrate and evaluate feedback control and coordination with mode changes over multi-hop networks for update intervals of 20 to 50 milliseconds.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Demo Abstract: Fast Feedback Control and Coordination with Mode Changes for Wireless Cyber-Physical Systems
Authors:
Fabian Mager,
Dominik Baumann,
Romain Jacob,
Lothar Thiele,
Sebastian Trimpe,
Marco Zimmerling
Abstract:
This abstract describes the first public demonstration of feedback control and coordination of multiple physical systems over a dynamic multi-hop low-power wireless network with update intervals of tens of milliseconds. Our running system can dynamically change between different sets of application tasks (e.g., sensing, actuation, control) executing on the spatially distributed embedded devices, w…
▽ More
This abstract describes the first public demonstration of feedback control and coordination of multiple physical systems over a dynamic multi-hop low-power wireless network with update intervals of tens of milliseconds. Our running system can dynamically change between different sets of application tasks (e.g., sensing, actuation, control) executing on the spatially distributed embedded devices, while closed-loop stability is provably guaranteed even across those so-called mode changes. Moreover, any subset of the devices can move freely, which does not affect closed-loop stability and control performance as long as the wireless network remains connected.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Control-guided Communication: Efficient Resource Arbitration and Allocation in Multi-hop Wireless Control Systems
Authors:
Dominik Baumann,
Fabian Mager,
Marco Zimmerling,
Sebastian Trimpe
Abstract:
In future autonomous systems, wireless multi-hop communication is key to enable collaboration among distributed agents at low cost and high flexibility. When many agents need to transmit information over the same wireless network, communication becomes a shared and contested resource. Event-triggered and self-triggered control account for this by transmitting data only when needed, enabling signif…
▽ More
In future autonomous systems, wireless multi-hop communication is key to enable collaboration among distributed agents at low cost and high flexibility. When many agents need to transmit information over the same wireless network, communication becomes a shared and contested resource. Event-triggered and self-triggered control account for this by transmitting data only when needed, enabling significant energy savings. However, a solution that brings those benefits to multi-hop networks and can reallocate freed up bandwidth to additional agents or data sources is still missing. To fill this gap, we propose control-guided communication, a novel co-design approach for distributed self-triggered control over wireless multi-hop networks. The control system informs the communication system of its transmission demands ahead of time, and the communication system allocates resources accordingly. Experiments on a cyber-physical testbed show that multiple cart-poles can be synchronized over wireless, while serving other traffic when resources are available, or saving energy. These experiments are the first to demonstrate and evaluate distributed self-triggered control over low-power multi-hop wireless networks at update rates of tens of milliseconds.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Evaluating Low-Power Wireless Cyber-Physical Systems
Authors:
Dominik Baumann,
Fabian Mager,
Harsoveet Singh,
Marco Zimmerling,
Sebastian Trimpe
Abstract:
Simulation tools and testbeds have been proposed to assess the performance of control designs and wireless protocols in isolation. A cyber-physical system (CPS), however, integrates control with network elements, which must be evaluated together under real-world conditions to assess control performance, stability, and associated costs. We present an approach to evaluate CPS relying on embedded dev…
▽ More
Simulation tools and testbeds have been proposed to assess the performance of control designs and wireless protocols in isolation. A cyber-physical system (CPS), however, integrates control with network elements, which must be evaluated together under real-world conditions to assess control performance, stability, and associated costs. We present an approach to evaluate CPS relying on embedded devices and low-power wireless technology. Using one or multiple inverted pendulums as physical system, our approach supports a spectrum of realistic CPS scenarios that impose different requirements onto the control and networking elements. Moreover, our approach allows one to flexibly combine simulated and real pendulums, promoting adoption, scalability, repeatability, and integration with existing wireless testbed infrastructures. A case study demonstrates implementation, execution, and measurements using the proposed evaluation approach.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Feedback Control Goes Wireless: Guaranteed Stability over Low-power Multi-hop Networks
Authors:
Fabian Mager,
Dominik Baumann,
Romain Jacob,
Lothar Thiele,
Sebastian Trimpe,
Marco Zimmerling
Abstract:
Closing feedback loops fast and over long distances is key to emerging applications; for example, robot motion control and swarm coordination require update intervals of tens of milliseconds. Low-power wireless technology is preferred for its low cost, small form factor, and flexibility, especially if the devices support multi-hop communication. So far, however, feedback control over wireless mult…
▽ More
Closing feedback loops fast and over long distances is key to emerging applications; for example, robot motion control and swarm coordination require update intervals of tens of milliseconds. Low-power wireless technology is preferred for its low cost, small form factor, and flexibility, especially if the devices support multi-hop communication. So far, however, feedback control over wireless multi-hop networks has only been shown for update intervals on the order of seconds. This paper presents a wireless embedded system that tames imperfections impairing control performance (e.g., jitter and message loss), and a control design that exploits the essential properties of this system to provably guarantee closed-loop stability for physical processes with linear time-invariant dynamics. Using experiments on a cyber-physical testbed with 20 wireless nodes and multiple cart-pole systems, we are the first to demonstrate and evaluate feedback control and coordination over wireless multi-hop networks for update intervals of 20 to 50 milliseconds.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2019; v1 submitted 24 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
TTW: A Time-Triggered-Wireless Design for CPS [ Extended version ]
Authors:
Romain Jacob,
Licong Zhang,
Marco Zimmerling,
Jan Beutel,
Samarjit Chakraborty,
Lothar Thiele
Abstract:
Wired field buses have proved their effectiveness to support Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS). However, in avionics, for ease of deployment, or for new functionality featuring mobile devices, there is a strong interest for wireless solutions. Low-power wireless protocols have been proposed, but requirements of a large class of CPS applications can still not be satisfied. This paper presents Time-Trigg…
▽ More
Wired field buses have proved their effectiveness to support Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS). However, in avionics, for ease of deployment, or for new functionality featuring mobile devices, there is a strong interest for wireless solutions. Low-power wireless protocols have been proposed, but requirements of a large class of CPS applications can still not be satisfied. This paper presents Time-Triggered-Wireless (TTW), a distributed low-power wireless system design that minimizes energy consumption and offers end-to-end timing predictability, adaptability, reliability, low latency. Our evaluation shows a reduction of communication latency by a factor 2x and of energy consumption by 33-40% compared to state-of-the-art approaches. This validates the suitability of TTW for wireless CPS applications and opens the way for implementation and real-world experience with industry partners.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2018; v1 submitted 15 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Renormalization group theory for percolation in time-varying networks
Authors:
Jens Karschau,
Marco Zimmerling,
Benjamin M. Friedrich
Abstract:
Motivated by multi-hop communication in unreliable wireless networks, we present a percolation theory for time-varying networks. We develop a renormalization group theory for a prototypical network on a regular grid, where individual links switch stochastically between active and inactive states. The question whether a given source node can communicate with a destination node along paths of active…
▽ More
Motivated by multi-hop communication in unreliable wireless networks, we present a percolation theory for time-varying networks. We develop a renormalization group theory for a prototypical network on a regular grid, where individual links switch stochastically between active and inactive states. The question whether a given source node can communicate with a destination node along paths of active links is equivalent to a percolation problem. Our theory maps the temporal existence of multi-hop paths on an effective two-state Markov process. We show analytically how this Markov process converges towards a memory-less Bernoulli process as the hop distance between source and destination node increases. Our work extends classical percolation theory to the dynamic case and elucidates temporal correlations of message losses. Quantification of temporal correlations has implications for the design of wireless communication and control protocols, e.g. in cyber-physical systems such as self-organized swarms of drones or smart traffic networks.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2018; v1 submitted 28 July, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Poster Abstract: If You Have Time, Save Energy with Pull
Authors:
David Hasenfratz,
Andreas Meier,
Matthias Woehrle,
Marco Zimmerling,
Lothar Thiele
Abstract:
We analyze push and pull for data collection in wireless sensor networks. Most applications to date use the traditional push approach, where nodes transmit sensed data immedi- ately to the sink. Using a pull approach, nodes store the data in their local flash memory, and only engage in commu- nication during dedicated collection phases. We show how one can transform an existing push-based collecti…
▽ More
We analyze push and pull for data collection in wireless sensor networks. Most applications to date use the traditional push approach, where nodes transmit sensed data immedi- ately to the sink. Using a pull approach, nodes store the data in their local flash memory, and only engage in commu- nication during dedicated collection phases. We show how one can transform an existing push-based collection protocol into a pull-based one, and compare the power consumption of both approaches on a 35-node testbed. Our results show that substantial energy gains are possible with pull, provided that the application can tolerate a long latency.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2011;
originally announced March 2011.
