-
Buoyancy torques prevent low-mass planets from stalling in low-turbulence radiative disks
Authors:
Alexandros Ziampras,
Richard P. Nelson,
Sijme-Jan Paardekooper
Abstract:
Low-mass planets migrating inwards in laminar protoplanetary disks (PPDs) experience a dynamical corotation torque, which is expected to slow down migration to a stall. However, baroclinic effects can reduce or even reverse this effect, leading to rapid inward migration. In the radiatively inefficient inner disk, one such mechanism is the buoyancy response of the disk to an embedded planet. Recent…
▽ More
Low-mass planets migrating inwards in laminar protoplanetary disks (PPDs) experience a dynamical corotation torque, which is expected to slow down migration to a stall. However, baroclinic effects can reduce or even reverse this effect, leading to rapid inward migration. In the radiatively inefficient inner disk, one such mechanism is the buoyancy response of the disk to an embedded planet. Recent work has suggested that radiative cooling can quench this response, but for parameters that are not necessarily representative of the inner regions of PPDs. We perform global three dimensional inviscid radiation hydrodynamics simulations of planet-disk interaction to investigate the effect of radiative cooling on the buoyancy-driven torque in a more realistic disk model. We find that the buoyancy response exerts a negative dynamical corotation torque -- albeit partially damped due to radiative cooling -- resulting in sustained, rapid inward migration. Models that adopt a local cooling prescription significantly overestimate the impact of the buoyancy response, highlighting the importance of a realistic treatment of radiation transport that includes radiative diffusion. Our results suggest that low-mass planets should migrate inwards faster than has been previously expected in radiative disks, with implications for the formation and orbital distribution of super-Earths and sub-Neptunes at intermediate distances from their host stars, unless additional physical processes that can slow down migration are considered.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Overstability of the 2:1 mean motion resonance: Exploring disc parameters with hydrodynamic simulations
Authors:
Zahra Afkanpour,
Sareh Ataiee,
Alexandros Ziampras,
Anna B. T. Penzlin,
Rafael Sfair,
Christoph Schäfer,
Wilhelm Kley,
Hilke Schlichting
Abstract:
Resonant planetary migration in protoplanetary discs can lead to an interplay between the resonant interaction of planets and their disc torques called overstability. While theoretical predictions and N-body simulations hinted at its existence, there was no conclusive evidence until hydrodynamical simulations were performed.
Our primary purpose is to find a hydrodynamic setup that induces overst…
▽ More
Resonant planetary migration in protoplanetary discs can lead to an interplay between the resonant interaction of planets and their disc torques called overstability. While theoretical predictions and N-body simulations hinted at its existence, there was no conclusive evidence until hydrodynamical simulations were performed.
Our primary purpose is to find a hydrodynamic setup that induces overstability in a planetary system with two moderate-mass planets in a first-order 2:1 mean motion resonance. We also aim to analyse the impact of key disc parameters, namely the viscosity, surface density, and aspect ratio, on the occurrence of overstability in this planetary system when the masses of the planets are kept constant.
We performed 2D locally isothermal hydrodynamical simulations of two planets, with masses of 5 and 10 $M_{\oplus}$, in a 2:1 resonance. Upon identifying the fiducial model in which the system exhibits overstability, we performed simulations with different disc parameters to explore the effects of the disc on the overstability of the system.
We observe an overstable planetary system in our hydrodynamic simulations. In the parameter study, we note that overstability occurs in discs characterised by low surface density and low viscosity. Increasing the surface density reduces the probability of overstability within the system. A limit cycle was observed in a specific viscous model with $α_ν = 10^{-3}$. In almost all our models, planets create partial gaps in the disc, which affects both the migration timescale and structure of the planetary system.
We demonstrate the existence of overstability using hydrodynamic simulations but find deviations from the analytic approximation and show that the main contribution to this deviation can be attributed to dynamic gap opening.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Migration of low-mass planets in inviscid disks: the effect of radiation transport on the dynamical corotation torque
Authors:
Alexandros Ziampras,
Richard P. Nelson,
Sijme-Jan Paardekooper
Abstract:
Low-mass planets migrate in the type-I regime. In the inviscid limit, the contrast between the vortensity trapped inside the planet's corotating region and the background disk vortensity leads to a dynamical corotation torque, which is thought to slow down inward migration. We investigate the effect of radiative cooling on low-mass planet migration using inviscid 2D hydrodynamical simulations. We…
▽ More
Low-mass planets migrate in the type-I regime. In the inviscid limit, the contrast between the vortensity trapped inside the planet's corotating region and the background disk vortensity leads to a dynamical corotation torque, which is thought to slow down inward migration. We investigate the effect of radiative cooling on low-mass planet migration using inviscid 2D hydrodynamical simulations. We find that cooling induces a baroclinic forcing on material U-turning near the planet, resulting in vortensity growth in the corotating region, which in turn weakens the dynamical corotation torque and leads to 2-3x faster inward migration. This mechanism is most efficient when cooling acts on a timescale similar to the U-turn time of material inside the corotating region, but is nonetheless relevant for a substantial radial range in a typical disk (5-50 au). As the planet migrates inwards, the contrast between the vortensity inside and outside the corotating region increases and partially regulates the effect of baroclinic forcing. As a secondary effect, we show that radiative dam** can further weaken the vortensity barrier created by the planet's spiral shocks, supporting inward migration. Finally, we highlight that a self-consistent treatment of radiative diffusion as opposed to local cooling is critical in order to avoid overestimating the vortensity growth and the resulting migration rate.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Buoyancy response of a disk to an embedded planet: a cross-code comparison at high resolution
Authors:
Alexandros Ziampras,
Sijme-Jan Paardekooper,
Richard P. Nelson
Abstract:
In radiatively inefficient, laminar protoplanetary disks, embedded planets can excite a buoyancy response as gas gets deflected vertically near the planet. This results in vertical oscillations that drive a vortensity growth in the planet's corotating region, speeding up inward migration in the type-I regime. We present a comparison between PLUTO/IDEFIX and FARGO3D using 3D, inviscid, adiabatic nu…
▽ More
In radiatively inefficient, laminar protoplanetary disks, embedded planets can excite a buoyancy response as gas gets deflected vertically near the planet. This results in vertical oscillations that drive a vortensity growth in the planet's corotating region, speeding up inward migration in the type-I regime. We present a comparison between PLUTO/IDEFIX and FARGO3D using 3D, inviscid, adiabatic numerical simulations of planet-disk interaction that feature the buoyancy response of the disk, and show that PLUTO/IDEFIX struggle to resolve higher-order modes of the buoyancy-related oscillations, weakening vortensity growth and the associated torque. We interpret this as a drawback of total-energy-conserving, finite-volume schemes. Our results indicate that a very high resolution or high-order scheme is required in shock-capturing codes in order to adequately capture this effect.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Measuring the Numerical Viscosity in Simulations of Protoplanetary Disks in Cartesian Grids -- The Viscously Spreading Ring Revisited
Authors:
Jibin Joseph,
Alexandros Ziampras,
Lucas Jordan,
George A. Turpin,
Richard P. Nelson
Abstract:
Hydrodynamical simulations solve the governing equations on a discrete grid of space and time. This discretization causes numerical diffusion similar to a physical viscous diffusion, whose magnitude is often unknown or poorly constrained. With the current trend of simulating accretion disks with no or very low prescribed physical viscosity, it becomes essential to understand and quantify this inhe…
▽ More
Hydrodynamical simulations solve the governing equations on a discrete grid of space and time. This discretization causes numerical diffusion similar to a physical viscous diffusion, whose magnitude is often unknown or poorly constrained. With the current trend of simulating accretion disks with no or very low prescribed physical viscosity, it becomes essential to understand and quantify this inherent numerical diffusion, in the form of a numerical viscosity. We study the behavior of the viscous spreading ring and the spiral instability that develops in it. We then use this setup to quantify the numerical viscosity in Cartesian grids and study its properties. We simulate the viscous spreading ring and the related instability on a two-dimensional polar grid using PLUTO as well as FARGO, and ensure convergence of our results with a resolution study. We then repeat our models on a Cartesian grid and measure the numerical viscosity by comparing results to the known analytical solution, using PLUTO and Athena++. We find that the numerical viscosity in a Cartesian grid scales with resolution as approximately $ν_{num}\proptoΔx^2$ and is equivalent to an effective $α\sim10^{-4}$ for a common numerical setup. We also show that the spiral instability manifests as a single leading spiral throughout the whole domain on polar grids. This is contrary to previous results and indicates that sufficient resolution is necessary in order to correctly resolve the instability. Our results are relevant in the context of models where the origin should be included in the computational domain, or when polar grids cannot be used. Examples of such cases include models of disk accretion onto a central binary and inherently Cartesian codes.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Modeling planet-induced gaps and rings in ALMA disks: the role of in-plane radiative diffusion
Authors:
Alexandros Ziampras,
Richard P. Nelson,
Roman R. Rafikov
Abstract:
ALMA observations of protoplanetary disks in dust continuum emission reveal a variety of annular structures. Attributing the existence of such features to embedded planets is a popular scenario, supported by studies using hydrodynamical models. Recent work has shown that radiative cooling greatly influences the capability of planet-driven spiral density waves to transport angular momentum, ultimat…
▽ More
ALMA observations of protoplanetary disks in dust continuum emission reveal a variety of annular structures. Attributing the existence of such features to embedded planets is a popular scenario, supported by studies using hydrodynamical models. Recent work has shown that radiative cooling greatly influences the capability of planet-driven spiral density waves to transport angular momentum, ultimately deciding the number, position, and depth of rings and gaps that a planet can carve in a disk. However, radiation transport has only been treated via local thermal relaxation, not taking into account radiative diffusion along the disk plane. We compare the previous state-of-the-art models of planet-disk interaction with local cooling prescriptions to our new models that include cooling in the vertical direction and radiative diffusion in the plane of the disk, and show that the response of the disk to the induced spiral waves can differ significantly when comparing these two treatments of the disk thermodynamics. We follow up with synthetic emission maps of ALMA systems, and show that our new models reproduce the observations found in the literature better than models with local cooling. We conclude that appropriate treatment of radiation transport is key to constraining the parameter space when interpreting ALMA observations using the planet-disk interaction scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Hydrodynamic turbulence in disks with embedded planets
Authors:
Alexandros Ziampras,
Wilhelm Kley,
Richard P. Nelson
Abstract:
The vertical shear instability (VSI) is a source of hydrodynamic turbulence that can drive vigorous vertical mixing and moderate levels of accretion in protoplanetary disks, and it could be observable in the near future. With high-resolution three-dimensional numerical hydrodynamics simulations, we modeled the behavior of the VSI in protoplanetary disks with and without embedded planets. We then m…
▽ More
The vertical shear instability (VSI) is a source of hydrodynamic turbulence that can drive vigorous vertical mixing and moderate levels of accretion in protoplanetary disks, and it could be observable in the near future. With high-resolution three-dimensional numerical hydrodynamics simulations, we modeled the behavior of the VSI in protoplanetary disks with and without embedded planets. We then measured its accretion and mixing capabilities by comparing the full Reynolds stress, which includes the contribution of nonaxisymmetric features, such as spiral arms and vortices, to the Reynolds stress due to the azimuthally averaged velocity field, which can be attributed to good approximation to the VSI. We verified that the VSI can contribute to the accretion stress and showed that, depending on disk conditions, an embedded planet can coexist with or suppress VSI turbulent stress. Specifically, the presence of spiral shocks launched by a planet or planet-generated vortices can interfere with the VSI near the planet's vicinity, with the instability recovering at large enough distances from the planet or vortex. Our results suggest that observations of VSI signatures are unlikely in disks that contain massive, nonaxisymmetric features.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Razor-thin dust layers in protoplanetary disks: Limits on the vertical shear instability
Authors:
C. P. Dullemond,
A. Ziampras,
D. Ostertag,
C. Dominik
Abstract:
Context: Recent observations with the Atacama Large Millimeter Array (ALMA) have shown that the large dust aggregates observed at millimeter wavelengths settle to the midplane into a remarkably thin layer. Aims: We intend to find out if the geometric thinness of these layers is evidence against the vertical shear instability (VSI) operating in these disks. Methods: We performed hydrodynamic simula…
▽ More
Context: Recent observations with the Atacama Large Millimeter Array (ALMA) have shown that the large dust aggregates observed at millimeter wavelengths settle to the midplane into a remarkably thin layer. Aims: We intend to find out if the geometric thinness of these layers is evidence against the vertical shear instability (VSI) operating in these disks. Methods: We performed hydrodynamic simulations of a protoplanetary disk with a locally isothermal equation of state, and let the VSI fully develop. We sprinkled dust particles and followed their motion as they got stirred up by the VSI. We determined for which grain size the layer becomes geometrically thin enough to be consistent with ALMA observations. We then verified if, with these grain sizes, it is still possible to generate a moderately optically thick layer at millimeter wavelengths, as observations appear to indicate. Results: We found that even very large dust aggregates with Stokes numbers close to unity get stirred up to relatively large heights above the midplane by the VSI, which is in conflict with the observed geometric thinness. For grains so large that the Stokes number exceeds unity, the layer can be made to remain thin, but we show that it is hard to make dust layers optically thick at ALMA wavelengths (e.g., tau(1.3mm)>=1) with such large dust aggregates. Conclusions: We conclude that protoplanetary disks with geometrically thin midplane dust layers cannot be VSI unstable, at least not down to the disk midplane. Explanations for the inhibition of the VSI include a reduced dust-to-gas ratio of the small dust grains that are responsible for the radiative cooling of the disk. A reduction of small grains by a factor of between 10 and 100 is sufficient to quench the VSI. Such a reduction is plausible in dust growth models, and still consistent with observations at optical and infrared wavelengths.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
How cooling influences circumbinary discs
Authors:
Prakruti Sudarshan,
Anna B. T. Penzlin,
Alexandros Ziampras,
Wilhelm Kley,
Richard P. Nelson
Abstract:
Circumbinary disc observations and simulations show large, eccentric inner cavities. Recent work has shown that the shape and size of these cavities depend on the aspect ratio and viscosity of the disc, as well as the binary eccentricity and mass ratio. It has been further shown that, for gaps created by planets, the cooling timescale significantly affects the shape and size of the gap. In this st…
▽ More
Circumbinary disc observations and simulations show large, eccentric inner cavities. Recent work has shown that the shape and size of these cavities depend on the aspect ratio and viscosity of the disc, as well as the binary eccentricity and mass ratio. It has been further shown that, for gaps created by planets, the cooling timescale significantly affects the shape and size of the gap. In this study, we consider the effect of different cooling models on the cavity shape in a circumbinary disc. We compare locally isothermal and radiatively cooled disc models to ones with a parametrised cooling timescale ($β$-cooling), implemented in 2D numerical simulations for varying binary eccentricities. While the shape of the cavity for radiative and locally isothermal models remains comparable, the inner disc structure changes slightly, leading to a change in the precession rate of the disc. With $β$-cooled models, the shape and size of the cavity changes dramatically towards values of $β$=1. Based on our findings, we introduce a parametrised $β$ model that accounts for the shorter cooling timescale inside the cavity while adequately reproducing the results of the radiative model, and we highlight that accurate treatment of the thermodynamics inside the cavity has a significant impact in modelling circumbinary systems.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Survival of planet-induced vortices in 2D disks
Authors:
Thomas Rometsch,
Alexandros Ziampras,
Wilhelm Kley,
William Béthune
Abstract:
Context: Several observations of protoplanetary disks display non-axisymmetric features, often interpreted as vortices. Numerical modeling has repeatedly shown that gap-opening planets are capable of producing large and long-lasting vortices at their outer gap edge, making massive planets popular candidates as the source of such features. Aims: We explore the lifetime of vortices generated by Jupi…
▽ More
Context: Several observations of protoplanetary disks display non-axisymmetric features, often interpreted as vortices. Numerical modeling has repeatedly shown that gap-opening planets are capable of producing large and long-lasting vortices at their outer gap edge, making massive planets popular candidates as the source of such features. Aims: We explore the lifetime of vortices generated by Jupiter-sized planets as a function of the thermal relaxation timescale, the level of turbulence, and the effect of disk self-gravity. Methods: We conduct 2D numerical simulations using the hydrodynamics codes PLUTO and FARGO, scanning through several physical and numerical parameters. Vortex properties are automatically extracted from thousands of simulation snapshots. Results: We find that vortices that spawn at the outer gap edge can survive for about 100-3000 planetary orbits, with the shortest lifetimes occurring for moderately efficient dissipation and cooling. However, we also observe a different regime of long-lasting vortices with lifetimes of at least 15 000 orbits for very low viscosity and very short thermal relaxation timescales. Disk self-gravity significantly shortens the lifetime of regular vortices but still allows long-lived ones to survive. Conclusions: Our results suggest that the cooling timescale plays an important role in vortex formation and lifetime and that planet-generated vortices should be observable at large distances from the star for typical thermal relaxation timescales and low turbulence levels.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Migration of Jupiter mass planets in low viscosity discs
Authors:
E. Lega,
R. P. Nelson,
A. Morbidelli,
W. Kley,
W. Béthune,
A. Crida,
D. Kloster,
H. Méheut,
T. Rometsch,
A. Ziampras
Abstract:
Type-II migration of giant planets has a speed proportional to the disc's viscosity for values of the alpha viscosity parameter larger than 1.e-4 . At lower viscosities previous studies, based on 2D simulations have shown that migration can be very chaotic and often characterized by phases of fast migration. The reason is that in low-viscosity discs vortices appear due to the Rossby-wave instabili…
▽ More
Type-II migration of giant planets has a speed proportional to the disc's viscosity for values of the alpha viscosity parameter larger than 1.e-4 . At lower viscosities previous studies, based on 2D simulations have shown that migration can be very chaotic and often characterized by phases of fast migration. The reason is that in low-viscosity discs vortices appear due to the Rossby-wave instability at the edges of the gap opened by the planet. Migration is then determined by vortex-planet interactions. Our aim is to study migration in low viscosity 3D discs. We performed numerical simulations using 2D (including self-gravity) and 3D codes. After selecting disc masses for which self-gravity is not important, 3D simulations without self-gravity can be safely used. In our nominal simulation only numerical viscosity is present. We then performed simulations with prescribed viscosity to assess the threshold below which the new migration processes appear. We show that for alpha viscosity <= 1.e-5 two migration modes are possible which differ from classical Type-II migration, in the sense that they are not proportional to the disc's viscosity. The first occurs when the gap opened by the planet is not very deep. This occurs in 3D simulations and/or when a big vortex forms at the outer edge of the planetary gap, diffusing material into the gap. We call this type of migration "vortex-driven migration". This migration is very slow and cannot continue indefinitely, because eventually the vortex dissolves. The second migration mode occurs when the gap is deep so that the planet's eccentricity grows to a value ~0.2 due to inefficient eccentricity dam** by corotation resonances. This second, faster migration mode appears to be typical of 2D models in discs with slower dam** of temperature's perturbations.
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Importance of radiative effects in gap opening by planets in protoplanetary disks
Authors:
Alexandros Ziampras,
Wilhelm Kley,
Cornelis P. Dullemond
Abstract:
Recent ALMA observations revealed concentric annular structures in several young class-II objects. In an attempt to produce the rings and gaps in some of these systems, they have been modeled numerically with a single embedded planet assuming a locally isothermal equation of state. This is often justified by observations targeting the irradiation-dominated outer regions of disks (approximately 100…
▽ More
Recent ALMA observations revealed concentric annular structures in several young class-II objects. In an attempt to produce the rings and gaps in some of these systems, they have been modeled numerically with a single embedded planet assuming a locally isothermal equation of state. This is often justified by observations targeting the irradiation-dominated outer regions of disks (approximately 100 au). We test this assumption by conducting hydrodynamics simulations of embedded planets in thin locally isothermal and radiative disks that mimic the systems HD 163296 and AS 209 in order to examine the effect of including the energy equation in a seemingly locally isothermal environment as far as planet-disk interaction is concerned. We find that modeling such disks with an ideal equation of state makes a difference in terms of the number of produced rings and the spiral arm contrast in the disk. Locally isothermal disks produce sharper annular or azimuthal features and overestimate a single planet's gap-opening capabilities by producing multiple gaps. In contrast, planets in radiative disks carve a single gap for typical disk parameters. Consequently, for accurate modeling of planets with semimajor axes up to about 100 au, radiative effects should be taken into account even in seemingly locally isothermal disks. In addition, for the case of AS 209, we find that the primary gap is significantly different between locally isothermal and radiative models. Our results suggest that multiple planets are required to explain the ring-rich structures in such systems.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
The impact of planet wakes on the location and shape of the water iceline in a protoplanetary disk
Authors:
Alexandros Ziampras,
Sareh Ataiee,
Wilhelm Kley,
Cornelis P. Dullemond,
Clément Baruteau
Abstract:
Context: Planets in accretion disks can excite spiral shocks, and---if massive enough---open gaps in their vicinity. Both of these effects can influence the overall disk thermal structure.
Aims: We model planets of different masses and semimajor axes in disks of various viscosities and accretion rates to examine their impact on disk thermodynamics and highlight the mutable, non-axisymmetric natu…
▽ More
Context: Planets in accretion disks can excite spiral shocks, and---if massive enough---open gaps in their vicinity. Both of these effects can influence the overall disk thermal structure.
Aims: We model planets of different masses and semimajor axes in disks of various viscosities and accretion rates to examine their impact on disk thermodynamics and highlight the mutable, non-axisymmetric nature of icelines in systems with massive planets.
Methods: We conduct a parameter study using numerical hydrodynamics simulations where we treat viscous heating, thermal cooling and stellar irradiation as additional source terms in the energy equation, with some runs including radiative diffusion. Our parameter space consists of a grid containing different combinations of planet and disk parameters.
Results: Both gap opening and shock heating can displace the iceline, with the effects being amplified for massive planets in optically thick disks. The gap region can split an initially hot (T>170 K) disk into a hot inner disk and a hot ring just outside of the planet's location, while shock heating can reshape the originally axisymmetric iceline into water-poor islands along spirals. We also find that radiative diffusion does not alter the picture significantly in this context.
Conclusions: Shock heating and gap opening by a planet can effectively heat up optically thick disks and in general move and/or reshape the water iceline. This can affect the gap structure and migration torques. It can also produce azimuthal features that follow the trajectory of spiral arms, creating hot zones, "islands" of vapor and ice around spirals which could affect the accretion or growth of icy aggregates.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.