-
Aligning Planet-Hosting Binaries via Dissipative Precession in Circumstellar Disks
Authors:
Konstantin Gerbig,
Malena Rice,
J. J. Zanazzi,
Sam Christian,
Andrew Vanderburg
Abstract:
Recent observations have demonstrated that some subset of even moderately wide-separation planet-hosting binaries are preferentially configured such that planetary and binary orbits appear to lie within the same plane. In this work, we explore dissipation during the protoplanetary disk phase, induced by disk war** as the system is forced into nodal recession by an inclined binary companion as a…
▽ More
Recent observations have demonstrated that some subset of even moderately wide-separation planet-hosting binaries are preferentially configured such that planetary and binary orbits appear to lie within the same plane. In this work, we explore dissipation during the protoplanetary disk phase, induced by disk war** as the system is forced into nodal recession by an inclined binary companion as a possible avenue of achieving orbit-orbit alignment. We analytically model the coupled evolution of the disk angular momentum vector and stellar spin vector under the influence of a distant binary companion. We find that a population of systems with random initial orientations can appear detectably more aligned after undergoing dissipative precession, and that this process can simultaneously produce an obliquity distribution that is consistent with observations. While dissipative precession proceeds efficiently in close binaries, favorable system properties (e.g., $r_{out} \gtrsim 100$ AU, $α\gtrsim 0.05$, and/or $M_b/M_{*} \gtrsim 1$) are required to reproduce observed alignment trends at wider binary separations $a_\mathrm{b} \gtrsim450$ AU. Our framework further predicts that circum-primary planets in systems with high stellar mass ratios should be preferentially less aligned than planets in equal-mass stellar binary systems. We discover tentative evidence for this trend in \textit{Gaia} DR3 and TESS data. Our findings suggest that dissipative precession may play a significant role in sculpting orbital configurations in a sub-set of moderately-wide planet-hosting binaries, but is likely not solely responsible for their observed population-level alignment.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Sites of Planet Formation in Binary Systems. I. Evidence for Disk-Orbit Alignment in the Close Binary FO Tau
Authors:
Benjamin M. Tofflemire,
Lisa Prato,
Adam L. Kraus,
Dominique Segura-Cox,
G. H. Schaefer,
Rachel Akeson,
Sean Andrews,
Eric L. N. Jensen,
Christopher M. Johns-Krull,
J. J. Zanazzi,
M. Simon
Abstract:
Close binary systems present challenges to planet formation. As binary separations decrease, so too do the occurrence rates of protoplanetary disks in young systems and planets in mature systems. For systems that do retain disks, their disk masses and sizes are altered by the presence of the binary companion. Through the study of protoplanetary disks in binary systems with known orbital parameters…
▽ More
Close binary systems present challenges to planet formation. As binary separations decrease, so too do the occurrence rates of protoplanetary disks in young systems and planets in mature systems. For systems that do retain disks, their disk masses and sizes are altered by the presence of the binary companion. Through the study of protoplanetary disks in binary systems with known orbital parameters, we seek to determine the properties that promote disk retention and, therefore, planet formation. In this work, we characterize the young binary-disk system, FO Tau. We determine the first full orbital solution for the system, finding masses of $0.35^{+0.06}_{-0.05}\ M_\odot$ and $0.34\pm0.05\ M_\odot$ for the stellar components, a semi-major axis of $22(^{+2}_{-1})$ AU, and an eccentricity of $0.21(^{+0.04}_{-0.03})$. With long-baseline ALMA interferometry, we detect 1.3mm continuum and $^{12}{\mathrm{CO}} \ (J=2-1)$ line emission toward each of the binary components; no circumbinary emission is detected. The protoplanetary disks are compact, consistent with being truncated by the binary orbit. The dust disks are unresolved in the image plane and the more extended gas disks are only marginally resolved. Fitting the continuum and CO visibilities, we determine the inclination of each disk, finding evidence for alignment of the disk and binary orbital planes. This study is the first of its kind linking the properties of circumstellar protoplanetary disks to a precisely known binary orbit. In the case of FO Tau, we find a dynamically placid environment (coplanar, low eccentricity), which may foster its potential for planet formation.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2024; v1 submitted 19 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Dam** Obliquities of Hot Jupiter Hosts by Resonance Locking
Authors:
J. J. Zanazzi,
Janosz Dewberry,
Eugene Chiang
Abstract:
When orbiting hotter stars, hot Jupiters are often highly inclined relative to their host star equator planes. By contrast, hot Jupiters orbiting cooler stars are more aligned. Prior attempts to explain this correlation between stellar obliquity and effective temperature have proven problematic. We show how resonance locking -- the coupling of the planet's orbit to a stellar gravity mode (g mode)…
▽ More
When orbiting hotter stars, hot Jupiters are often highly inclined relative to their host star equator planes. By contrast, hot Jupiters orbiting cooler stars are more aligned. Prior attempts to explain this correlation between stellar obliquity and effective temperature have proven problematic. We show how resonance locking -- the coupling of the planet's orbit to a stellar gravity mode (g mode) -- can solve this mystery. Cooler stars with their radiative cores are more likely to be found with g-mode frequencies increased substantially by core hydrogen burning. Strong frequency evolution in resonance lock drives strong tidal evolution; locking to an axisymmetric g mode damps semi-major axes, eccentricities, and as we show for the first time, obliquities. Around cooler stars, hot Jupiters evolve into spin-orbit alignment and may avoid engulfment. Hotter stars lack radiative cores, and therefore preserve congenital spin-orbit misalignments. We focus on resonance locks with axisymmetric modes, supplementing our technical results with simple physical interpretations, and show that non-axisymmetric modes also damp obliquity. Outstanding issues regarding the dissipation of tidally-excited modes and the disabling of resonance locks are discussed quantitatively.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2024; v1 submitted 8 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Detection of atmospheric species and dynamics in the bloated hot Jupiter WASP-172~b with ESPRESSO
Authors:
J. V. Seidel,
B. Prinoth,
E. Knudstrup,
H. J. Hoeijmakers,
J. J. Zanazzi,
S. Albrecht
Abstract:
The population of strongly irradiated Jupiter-sized planets has no equivalent in the Solar System. It is characterised by strongly bloated atmospheres and atmospheric large-scale heights. Recent space-based observations of SO2 photochemistry demonstrated the knowledge that can be gained from detailed atmospheric studies of these unusual planets about Earth's uniqueness. Aims. Here we explore the a…
▽ More
The population of strongly irradiated Jupiter-sized planets has no equivalent in the Solar System. It is characterised by strongly bloated atmospheres and atmospheric large-scale heights. Recent space-based observations of SO2 photochemistry demonstrated the knowledge that can be gained from detailed atmospheric studies of these unusual planets about Earth's uniqueness. Aims. Here we explore the atmosphere of WASP-172b a similar planet in temperature and bloating to the recently studied HD~149026~b. In this work, we characterise the atmospheric composition and subsequently the atmospheric dynamics of this prime target. Methods. We observed a particular transit of WASP-172b in front of its host star with ESO's ESPRESSO spectrograph and analysed the spectra obtained before during and after transit. Results. We detect the absorption of starlight by WASP-172b's atmosphere by sodium (5.6sigma), hydrogen (19.5sigma) and obtained a tentative detection of iron (4.1sigma). We detect strong - yet varying - blue shifts, relative to the planetary rest frame, of all of these absorption features. This allows for a preliminary study of the atmospheric dynamics of WASP-172b. Conclusions. With only one transit, we were able to detect a wide variety of species, clearly tracking different atmospheric layers with possible jets. WASP-172b is a prime follow-up target for a more in-depth characterisation both for ground and space-based observatories. If the detection of Fe is confirmed, this may suggest that radius inflation is an important determinant for the detectability of Fe in hot Jupiters, as several non-detections of Fe have been published for planets that are hotter but less inflated than WASP-172b.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Swee** Secular Resonances and Giant Planet Inclinations in Transition Discs
Authors:
J. J. Zanazzi,
Eugene Chiang
Abstract:
The orbits of some warm Jupiters are highly inclined (20$^\circ$-50$^\circ$) to those of their exterior companions. Comparable misalignments are inferred between the outer and inner portions of some transition discs. These large inclinations may originate from planet-planet and planet-disc secular resonances that sweep across interplanetary space as parent discs disperse. The maximum factor by whi…
▽ More
The orbits of some warm Jupiters are highly inclined (20$^\circ$-50$^\circ$) to those of their exterior companions. Comparable misalignments are inferred between the outer and inner portions of some transition discs. These large inclinations may originate from planet-planet and planet-disc secular resonances that sweep across interplanetary space as parent discs disperse. The maximum factor by which a seed mutual inclination can be amplified is of order the square root of the angular momentum ratio of the resonant pair. We identify those giant planet systems (e.g. Kepler-448 and Kepler-693) which may have crossed a secular resonance, and estimate the required planet masses and semimajor axes in transition discs needed to warp their innermost portions (e.g. in CQ Tau). Passage through an inclination secular resonance could also explain the hypothesized large mutual inclinations in apsidally-orthogonal warm Jupiter systems (e.g. HD 147018).
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2023; v1 submitted 20 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Two Candidate KH 15D-like Systems from the Zwicky Transient Facility
Authors:
Wei Zhu,
Klaus Bernhard,
Fei Dai,
Min Fang,
J. J. Zanazzi,
Weicheng Zang,
Subo Dong,
Franz-Josef Hambsch,
Tianjun Gan,
Zexuan Wu,
Michael Poon
Abstract:
KH 15D contains a circumbinary disk that is tilted relative to the orbital plane of the central binary. The precession of the disk and the orbital motion of the binary together produce rich phenomena in the photometric light curve. In this work, we present the discovery and preliminary analysis of two objects that resemble the key features of KH 15D from the Zwicky Transient Facility. These new ob…
▽ More
KH 15D contains a circumbinary disk that is tilted relative to the orbital plane of the central binary. The precession of the disk and the orbital motion of the binary together produce rich phenomena in the photometric light curve. In this work, we present the discovery and preliminary analysis of two objects that resemble the key features of KH 15D from the Zwicky Transient Facility. These new objects, Bernhard-1 and Bernhard-2, show large-amplitude ($>1.5\,$mag), long-duration (more than tens of days), and periodic dimming events. A one-sided screen model is developed to model the photometric behaviour of these objects, the physical interpretation of which is a tilted, warped circumbinary disk occulting the inner binary. Changes in the object light curves suggest potential precession periods over timescales longer than 10 years. Additional photometric and spectroscopic observations are encouraged to better understand the nature of these interesting systems.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2022; v1 submitted 1 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
A Tale of Two Circularization Periods
Authors:
J. J. Zanazzi
Abstract:
We re-analyze the pristine eclipsing binary data from the $\textit{Kepler}$ and TESS missions, focusing on eccentricity measurements at short orbital periods to emperically constrain tidal circularization. We find an average circularization period of $~$6 days, as well as a short circularization period of $\sim$3 days for the $\textit{Kepler}$/TESS field binaries. We argue previous spectroscopic b…
▽ More
We re-analyze the pristine eclipsing binary data from the $\textit{Kepler}$ and TESS missions, focusing on eccentricity measurements at short orbital periods to emperically constrain tidal circularization. We find an average circularization period of $~$6 days, as well as a short circularization period of $\sim$3 days for the $\textit{Kepler}$/TESS field binaries. We argue previous spectroscopic binary surveys reported longer circularization periods due to small sample sizes, which were contaminated by an abundance of binaries with circular orbits out to $\sim$10 days, but we re-affirm their data shows a difference between the eccentricity distributions of young ($<$1 Gyr) and old ($>$3 Gyr) binaries. Our work calls into question the long circularization periods quoted often in the literature.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
On the equations of warped disc dynamics
Authors:
C. P. Dullemond,
C. N. Kimmig,
J. J. Zanazzi
Abstract:
The 1-D evolution equations for warped discs come in two flavors: For very viscous discs the internal torque vector G is uniquely determined by the local conditions in the disc, and warps tend to damp out rapidly if they are not continuously driven. For very inviscid discs, on the other hand, G becomes a dynamic quantity, and a warp will propagate through the disc as a wave. The equations governin…
▽ More
The 1-D evolution equations for warped discs come in two flavors: For very viscous discs the internal torque vector G is uniquely determined by the local conditions in the disc, and warps tend to damp out rapidly if they are not continuously driven. For very inviscid discs, on the other hand, G becomes a dynamic quantity, and a warp will propagate through the disc as a wave. The equations governing both regimes are usually treated separately. A unified set of equations was postulated recently by Martin et al. (2019), but not yet derived from the underlying physics. The standard method for deriving these equations is based on a perturbation series expansion, which is a powerful, but somewhat abstract technique. A more straightforward method is to employ the warped shearing box framework of Ogilvie and Latter (2013), which so far has not yet been used to derive the equations for the wavelike regime. The goal of this paper is to analyze the warped disc equations in both regimes using the warped shearing box framework, to derive a unified set of equations, valid for small warps, and to discuss how our results can be interpreted in terms of the affine tilted-slab approach of Ogilvie (2018).
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Detection and Bulk Properties of the HR 8799 Planets with High Resolution Spectroscopy
Authors:
Jason J. Wang,
Jean-Baptiste Ruffio,
Evan Morris,
Jacques-Robert Delorme,
Nemanja Jovanovic,
Jacklyn Pezzato,
Daniel Echeverri,
Luke Finnerty,
Callie Hood,
J. J. Zanazzi,
Marta L. Bryan,
Charlotte Z. Bond,
Sylvain Cetre,
Emily C. Martin,
Dimitri Mawet,
Andy Skemer,
Ashley Baker,
Jerry W. Xuan,
J. Kent Wallace,
Ji Wang,
Randall Bartos,
Geoffrey A. Blake,
Andy Boden,
Cam Buzard,
Benjamin Calvin
, et al. (27 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Using the Keck Planet Imager and Characterizer (KPIC), we obtained high-resolution (R$\sim$35,000) $K$-band spectra of the four planets orbiting HR 8799. We clearly detected \water{} and CO in the atmospheres of HR 8799 c, d, and e, and tentatively detected a combination of CO and \water{} in b. These are the most challenging directly imaged exoplanets that have been observed at high spectral reso…
▽ More
Using the Keck Planet Imager and Characterizer (KPIC), we obtained high-resolution (R$\sim$35,000) $K$-band spectra of the four planets orbiting HR 8799. We clearly detected \water{} and CO in the atmospheres of HR 8799 c, d, and e, and tentatively detected a combination of CO and \water{} in b. These are the most challenging directly imaged exoplanets that have been observed at high spectral resolution to date when considering both their angular separations and flux ratios. We developed a forward modeling framework that allows us to jointly fit the spectra of the planets and the diffracted starlight simultaneously in a likelihood-based approach and obtained posterior probabilities on their effective temperatures, surface gravities, radial velocities, and spins. We measured $v\sin(i)$ values of $10.1^{+2.8}_{-2.7}$~km/s for HR 8799 d and $15.0^{+2.3}_{-2.6}$~km/s for HR 8799 e, and placed an upper limit of $< 14$~km/s of HR 8799 c. Under two different assumptions of their obliquities, we found tentative evidence that rotation velocity is anti-correlated with companion mass, which could indicate that magnetic braking with a circumplanetary disk at early times is less efficient at spinning down lower mass planets.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
A backward-spinning star with two coplanar planets
Authors:
Maria Hjorth,
Simon Albrecht,
Teruyuki Hirano,
Joshua N. Winn,
Rebekah I. Dawson,
J. J. Zanazzi,
Emil Knudstrup,
Bun'ei Sato
Abstract:
It is widely assumed that a star and its protoplanetary disk are initially aligned, with the stellar equator parallel to the disk plane. When observations reveal a misalignment between stellar rotation and the orbital motion of a planet, the usual interpretation is that the initial alignment was upset by gravitational perturbations that took place after planet formation. Most of the previously kno…
▽ More
It is widely assumed that a star and its protoplanetary disk are initially aligned, with the stellar equator parallel to the disk plane. When observations reveal a misalignment between stellar rotation and the orbital motion of a planet, the usual interpretation is that the initial alignment was upset by gravitational perturbations that took place after planet formation. Most of the previously known misalignments involve isolated hot Jupiters, for which planet-planet scattering or secular effects from a wider-orbiting planet are the leading explanations. In theory, star/disk misalignments can result from turbulence during star formation or the gravitational torque of a wide-orbiting companion star, but no definite examples of this scenario are known. An ideal example would combine a coplanar system of multiple planets -- ruling out planet-planet scattering or other disruptive post-formation events -- with a backward-rotating star, a condition that is easier to obtain from a primordial misalignment than from post-formation perturbations. There are two previously known examples of a misaligned star in a coplanar multi-planet system, but in neither case has a suitable companion star been identified, nor is the stellar rotation known to be retrograde. Here, we show that the star K2-290 A is tilted by $124\pm 6$ degrees compared to the orbits of both of its known planets, and has a wide-orbiting stellar companion that is capable of having tilted the protoplanetary disk. The system provides the clearest demonstration that stars and protoplanetary disks can become grossly misaligned due to the gravitational torque from a neighbouring star.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Tidal Circularization of Binaries by Resonance Locking I: The Importance of the Pre-Main-Sequence
Authors:
J. J. Zanazzi,
Yanqin Wu
Abstract:
Although tidal dissipation in binary stars has been studied for over a century, theoretical predictions have yet to match the observed properties of binary populations. This work quantitatively examines the recent proposal of tidal circularization by resonance locking, where tidal dissipation arises from resonances between the star's natural oscillation frequencies and harmonics of the orbital fre…
▽ More
Although tidal dissipation in binary stars has been studied for over a century, theoretical predictions have yet to match the observed properties of binary populations. This work quantitatively examines the recent proposal of tidal circularization by resonance locking, where tidal dissipation arises from resonances between the star's natural oscillation frequencies and harmonics of the orbital frequency, and where resonances are `locked' for an extended period of time due to concurrent stellar evolution. We focus on tidal resonances with axi-symmetric gravity-modes, and examine binaries with primary masses from one to two solar masses. We find that orbital evolution via resonance locking occurs primarily during the star's pre-main-sequence phase, with the main-sequence phase contributing negligibly. Resonance locking, ignoring non-linearity, can circularize binaries with peri-centre distances out to $\sim 10$ stellar radii, corresponding to circular periods of $\sim 4-6$ days. However, we find resonantly excited gravity-modes will become nonlinear in stellar cores, which prevents them from reaching their full, linear amplitudes. We estimate that such a `saturated resonance lock' reduces the circularization period by about a third, but resonance locking remains much more effective than the cumulative actions of equilibrium tides. In a companion paper, we examine recent binary data to compare against theory.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Emission Properties of Periodic Fast Radio Bursts from the Motion of Magnetars: Testing Dynamical Models
Authors:
Dongzi Li,
J. J. Zanazzi
Abstract:
Recent observations of the periodic Fast Radio Burst source 180916.J0158+65 (FRB 180916) find small linear polarization position angle swings during and between bursts, with a burst activity window that becomes both narrower and earlier at higher frequencies. Although the observed chromatic activity window disfavors models of periodicity in FRB 180916 driven by the occultation of a neutron star by…
▽ More
Recent observations of the periodic Fast Radio Burst source 180916.J0158+65 (FRB 180916) find small linear polarization position angle swings during and between bursts, with a burst activity window that becomes both narrower and earlier at higher frequencies. Although the observed chromatic activity window disfavors models of periodicity in FRB 180916 driven by the occultation of a neutron star by the optically-thick wind from a stellar companion, the connection to theories where periodicity arises from the motion of a bursting magnetar remains unclear. In this paper, we show how altitude-dependent radio emission from magnetar curvature radiation, with bursts emitted from regions which are asymmetric with respect to the magnetic dipole axis, can lead to burst activity windows and polarization consistent with the recent observations. In particular, the fact that bursts arrive systematically earlier at higher frequencies disfavors theories where the FRB periodicity arises from forced precession of a magnetar by a companion or fallback disk, but is consistent with theories where periodicity originates from a slowly-rotating or freely-precessing magnetar. Several observational tests are proposed to verify/differentiate between the remaining theories, and pin-down which theory explains the periodicity in FRB 180916.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Constraining the Circumbinary Disk Tilt in the KH 15D system
Authors:
Michael Poon,
J. J. Zanazzi,
Wei Zhu
Abstract:
KH 15D is a system which consists of a young, eccentric binary, and a circumbinary disk which obscures the binary as the disk precesses. We develop a self-consistent model that provides a reasonable fit to the photometric variability that was observed in the KH 15D system over the past 60 years. Our model suggests that the circumbinary disk has an inner edge $r_{\rm in}\lesssim 1 \ {\rm au}$, an o…
▽ More
KH 15D is a system which consists of a young, eccentric binary, and a circumbinary disk which obscures the binary as the disk precesses. We develop a self-consistent model that provides a reasonable fit to the photometric variability that was observed in the KH 15D system over the past 60 years. Our model suggests that the circumbinary disk has an inner edge $r_{\rm in}\lesssim 1 \ {\rm au}$, an outer edge $r_{\rm out} \sim {\rm a \ few \ au}$, and that the disk is misaligned relative to the stellar binary by $\sim$5-16 degrees, with the inner edge more inclined than the outer edge. The difference between the inclinations (warp) and longitude of ascending nodes (twist) at the inner and outer edges of the disk are of order $\sim$10 degrees and $\sim$15 degrees, respectively. We also provide constraints on other properties of the disk, such as the precession period and surface density profile. Our work demonstrates the power of photometric data in constraining the physical properties of planet-forming circumbinary disks.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2021; v1 submitted 29 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Eccentric Tidal Disruption Event Disks around Supermassive Black Holes: Dynamics and Thermal Emission
Authors:
J. J. Zanazzi,
Gordon I. Ogilvie
Abstract:
After the Tidal Disruption Event (TDE) of a star around a SuperMassive Black Hole (SMBH), if the stellar debris stream rapidly circularizes and forms a compact disk, the TDE emission is expected to peak in the soft X-ray or far Ultra-Violet (UV). The fact that many TDE candidates are observed to peak in the near UV and optical has challenged conventional TDE emission models. By idealizing a disk a…
▽ More
After the Tidal Disruption Event (TDE) of a star around a SuperMassive Black Hole (SMBH), if the stellar debris stream rapidly circularizes and forms a compact disk, the TDE emission is expected to peak in the soft X-ray or far Ultra-Violet (UV). The fact that many TDE candidates are observed to peak in the near UV and optical has challenged conventional TDE emission models. By idealizing a disk as a nested sequence of elliptical orbits which communicate adiabatically via pressure forces, and are heated by energy dissipated during the circularization of the nearly parabolic debris streams, we investigate the dynamics and thermal emission of highly eccentric TDE disks, including the effect of General-Relativistic apsidal precession from the SMBH. We calculate the properties of uniformly precessing, apsidally aligned, and highly eccentric TDE disks, and find highly eccentric disk solutions exist for realistic TDE properties (SMBH and stellar mass, periapsis distance, etc.). Taking into account compressional heating (cooling) near periapsis (apoapsis), we find our idealized eccentric disk model can produce emission consistent with the X-ray and UV/Optical luminosities of many optically bright TDE candidates. Our work attempts to quantify the thermal emission expected from the shock-heating model for TDE emission, and finds stream-stream collisions are a promising way to power optically bright TDEs.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2020; v1 submitted 14 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Periodic Fast Radio Bursts with Neutron Star Free/Radiative Precession
Authors:
J. J. Zanazzi,
Dong Lai
Abstract:
The CHIME/FRB collaboration recently reported the detection of a 16 day periodicity in the arrival times of radio bursts from FRB 180916.J0158+65. We study the possibility that the observed periodicity arises from free precession of a magnetized neutron star, and put constraints on different components of the star's magnetic fields. Using a simple geometric model, where radio bursts are emitted fr…
▽ More
The CHIME/FRB collaboration recently reported the detection of a 16 day periodicity in the arrival times of radio bursts from FRB 180916.J0158+65. We study the possibility that the observed periodicity arises from free precession of a magnetized neutron star, and put constraints on different components of the star's magnetic fields. Using a simple geometric model, where radio bursts are emitted from a rotating neutron star magnetosphere, we show that the emission pattern as a function of time can match that observed from FRB 180916.J0158+65.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2020; v1 submitted 13 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
The Structure and Stability of Extended, Inclined Circumplanetary Disk or Ring Systems
Authors:
Jessica Speedie,
J. J. Zanazzi
Abstract:
Large dips in the brightness for a number of stars have been observed, for which the tentative explanation is occultation of the star by a transiting circumplanetary disk or ring system. In order for the circumplanetary disk/rings to block the host star's light, the disk must be tilted out of the planet's orbital plane, which poses stability problems due to the radial extent of the disk required t…
▽ More
Large dips in the brightness for a number of stars have been observed, for which the tentative explanation is occultation of the star by a transiting circumplanetary disk or ring system. In order for the circumplanetary disk/rings to block the host star's light, the disk must be tilted out of the planet's orbital plane, which poses stability problems due to the radial extent of the disk required to explain the brightness dip durations. This work uses N-body integrations to study the structure and stability of circumplanetary disk/ring systems tilted out of the planet's orbital plane by the spinning planet's mass quadrupole. Simulating the disk as a collection of test particles with orbits initialized near the Laplace surface (equilibrium between tidal force from host star and force from planet's mass quadrupole), we find that many extended, inclined circumplanetary disks remain stable over the duration of the integrations (~3-16 Myr). Two dynamical resonances/instabilities excite the particle eccentricities and inclinations: the Lidov-Kozai effect which occurs in the disk's outer regions, and ivection resonance which occurs in the disk's inner regions. Our work places constraints on the maximum radial extent of inclined circumplanetary disk/ring systems, and shows that gaps present in circumplanetary disks do not necessarily imply the presence of exomoons.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2020; v1 submitted 29 November, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Tidal Disruption Event Disks around Supermassive Black Holes: Disk Warp and Inclination Evolution
Authors:
J. J. Zanazzi,
Dong Lai
Abstract:
After the Tidal Disruption Event (TDE) of a star around a SuperMassive Black Hole (SMBH), the bound stellar debris rapidly forms an accretion disk. If the accretion disk is not aligned with the spinning SMBH's equatorial plane, the disk will be driven into Lense-Thirring precession around the SMBH's spin axis, possibly affecting the TDE's light curve. We carry out an eigenmode analysis of such a d…
▽ More
After the Tidal Disruption Event (TDE) of a star around a SuperMassive Black Hole (SMBH), the bound stellar debris rapidly forms an accretion disk. If the accretion disk is not aligned with the spinning SMBH's equatorial plane, the disk will be driven into Lense-Thirring precession around the SMBH's spin axis, possibly affecting the TDE's light curve. We carry out an eigenmode analysis of such a disk to understand how the disk's warp structure, precession, and inclination evolution are influenced by the disk's and SMBH's properties. We find an oscillatory warp may develop as a result of strong non-Keplarian motion near the SMBH. The global disk precession frequency matches the Lense-Thirring precession frequency of a rigid disk around a spinning black hole within a factor of a few when the disk's accretion rate is high, but deviates significantly at low accretion rates. Viscosity aligns the disk with the SMBH's equatorial plane over timescales of days to years, depending on the disk's accretion rate, viscosity, and SMBH's mass. We also examine the effect of fall-back material on the warp evolution of TDE disks, and find that the fall-back torque aligns the TDE disk with the SMBH's equatorial plane in a few to tens of days for the parameter space investigated. Our results place constraints on models of TDE emission which rely on the changing disk orientation with respect to the line of sight to explain observations.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2019; v1 submitted 25 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Effects of Disk War** on the Inclination Evolution of Star-Disk-Binary Systems
Authors:
J. J. Zanazzi,
Dong Lai
Abstract:
Several recent studies have suggested that circumstellar disks in young stellar binaries may be driven into misalignement with their host stars due to secular gravitational interactions between the star, disk and the binary companion. The disk in such systems is twisted/warped due to the gravitational torques from the oblate central star and the external companion. We calculate the disk warp profi…
▽ More
Several recent studies have suggested that circumstellar disks in young stellar binaries may be driven into misalignement with their host stars due to secular gravitational interactions between the star, disk and the binary companion. The disk in such systems is twisted/warped due to the gravitational torques from the oblate central star and the external companion. We calculate the disk warp profile, taking into account of bending wave propagation and viscosity in the disk. We show that for typical protostellar disk parameters, the disk warp is small, thereby justifying the "flat-disk" approximation adopted in previous theoretical studies. However, the viscous dissipation associated with the small disk warp/twist tends to drive the disk toward alignment with the binary or the central star. We calculate the relevant timescales for the alignment. We find the alignment is effective for sufficiently cold disks with strong external torques, especially for systems with rapidly rotating stars, but is ineffective for the majority of star-disk-binary systems. Viscous warp driven alignment may be necessary to account for the observed spin-orbit alignment in multi-planet systems if these systems are accompanied by an inclined binary companion.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2018; v1 submitted 20 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
The Ability of Significant Tidal Stress to Initiate Plate Tectonics
Authors:
J. J. Zanazzi,
Amaury H. M. J. Triaud
Abstract:
Plate tectonics is a geophysical process currently unique to Earth, has an important role in regulating the Earth's climate, and may be better understood by identifying rocky planets outside our solar system with tectonic activity. The key criterion for whether or not plate tectonics may occur on a terrestrial planet is if the stress on a planet's lithosphere from mantle convection may overcome th…
▽ More
Plate tectonics is a geophysical process currently unique to Earth, has an important role in regulating the Earth's climate, and may be better understood by identifying rocky planets outside our solar system with tectonic activity. The key criterion for whether or not plate tectonics may occur on a terrestrial planet is if the stress on a planet's lithosphere from mantle convection may overcome the lithosphere's yield stress. Although many rocky exoplanets closely orbiting their host stars have been detected, all studies to date of plate tectonics on exoplanets have neglected tidal stresses in the planet's lithosphere. Modeling a rocky exoplanet as a constant density, homogeneous, incompressible sphere, we show the tidal stress from the host star acting on close-in planets may become comparable to the stress on the lithosphere from mantle convection. We also show that tidal stresses from planet-planet interactions are unlikely to be significant for plate tectonics, but may be strong enough to trigger Earthquakes. Our work may imply planets orbiting close to their host stars are more likely to experience plate tectonics, with implications for exoplanetary geophysics and habitability. We produce a list of detected rocky exoplanets under the most intense stresses. Atmospheric and topographic observations may confirm our predictions in the near future. Investigations of planets with significant tidal stress can not only lead to observable parameters linked to the presence of active plate tectonics, but may also be used as a tool to test theories on the main driving force behind tectonic activity.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2019; v1 submitted 27 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Planet Formation in Disks with Inclined Binary Companions: Can Primordial Spin-Orbit Misalignment be Produced?
Authors:
J. J. Zanazzi,
Dong Lai
Abstract:
Many hot Jupiter (HJ) systems have been observed to have their stellar spin axis misaligned with the planet's orbital angular momentum axis. The origin of this spin-orbit misalignment and the formation mechanism of HJs remain poorly understood. A number of recent works have suggested that gravitational interactions between host stars, protoplanetary disks, and inclined binary companions may tilt t…
▽ More
Many hot Jupiter (HJ) systems have been observed to have their stellar spin axis misaligned with the planet's orbital angular momentum axis. The origin of this spin-orbit misalignment and the formation mechanism of HJs remain poorly understood. A number of recent works have suggested that gravitational interactions between host stars, protoplanetary disks, and inclined binary companions may tilt the stellar spin axis with respect to the disk's angular angular momentum axis, producing planetary systems with misaligned orbits. These previous works considered idealized disk evolution models and neglected the gravitational influence of newly formed planets. In this paper, we explore how disk photoevaporation and planet formation and migration affect the inclination evolution of planet-star-disk-binary systems. We take into account planet-disk interactions and the gravitational spin-orbit coupling between the host star and the planet. We find that the rapid depletion of the inner disk via photoevaporation reduces the excitation of stellar obliquities. Depending on the formation and migration history of HJs, the spin-orbit coupling between the star and the planet may reduces and even completely suppress the excitation of stellar obliquities. Our work constrains the formation/migration history of HJs. On the other hand, planetary systems with "cold" Jupiters or close-in super-earths may experience excitation of stellar obliquities in the presence of distant inclined companions.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2018; v1 submitted 8 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Inclination Evolution of Protoplanetary Disks Around Eccentric Binaries
Authors:
J. J. Zanazzi,
Dong Lai
Abstract:
It is usually thought that viscous torque works to align a circumbinary disk with the binary's orbital plane. However, recent numerical simulations suggest that the disk may evolve to a configuration perpendicular to the binary orbit ("polar alignment") if the binary is eccentric and the initial disk-binary inclination is sufficiently large. We carry out a theoretical study on the long-term evolut…
▽ More
It is usually thought that viscous torque works to align a circumbinary disk with the binary's orbital plane. However, recent numerical simulations suggest that the disk may evolve to a configuration perpendicular to the binary orbit ("polar alignment") if the binary is eccentric and the initial disk-binary inclination is sufficiently large. We carry out a theoretical study on the long-term evolution of inclined disks around eccentric binaries, calculating the disk warp profile and dissipative torque acting on the disk. For disks with aspect ratio $H/r$ larger than the viscosity parameter $α$, bending wave propagation effectively makes the disk precess as a quasi-rigid body, while viscosity acts on the disk warp and twist to drive secular evolution of the disk-binary inclination. We derive a simple analytic criterion (in terms of the binary eccentricity and initial disk orientation) for the disk to evolve toward polar alignment with the eccentric binary. When the disk has a non-negligible angular momentum compared to the binary, the final "polar alignment" inclination angle is reduced from $90^\circ$. For typical protoplanetary disk parameters, the timescale of the inclination evolution is shorter than the disk lifetime, suggesting that highly-inclined disks and planets may exist orbiting eccentric binaries.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2017; v1 submitted 23 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Triaxial Deformation and Asynchronous Rotation of Rocky Planets in the Habitable Zone of Low-Mass Stars
Authors:
J. J. Zanazzi,
Dong Lai
Abstract:
Rocky planets orbiting M-dwarf stars in the habitable zone tend to be driven to synchronous rotation by tidal dissipation, potentially causing difficulties for maintaining a habitable climate on the planet. However, the planet may be captured into asynchronous spin-orbit resonances, and this capture may be more likely if the planet has a sufficiently large intrinsic triaxial deformation. We derive…
▽ More
Rocky planets orbiting M-dwarf stars in the habitable zone tend to be driven to synchronous rotation by tidal dissipation, potentially causing difficulties for maintaining a habitable climate on the planet. However, the planet may be captured into asynchronous spin-orbit resonances, and this capture may be more likely if the planet has a sufficiently large intrinsic triaxial deformation. We derive the analytic expression for the maximum triaxiality of a rocky planet, with and without a liquid envelope, as a function of the planet's radius, density, rigidity and critical strain of fracture. The derived maximum triaxiality is consistent with the observed triaxialities for terrestrial planets in the solar system, and indicates that rocky planets in the habitable zone of M-dwarfs can in principle be in a state of asynchronous spin-orbit resonances.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2017; v1 submitted 23 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Lidov-Kozai Mechanism in Hydrodynamical Disks: Linear Stability Analysis
Authors:
J. J. Zanazzi,
Dong Lai
Abstract:
Recent SPH simulations by Martin et al. (2014) suggest a circumstellar gaseous disk may exhibit coherent eccentricity-inclination oscillations due to the tidal forcing of an inclined binary companion, in a manner that resembles Lidov-Kozai oscillations in hierarchical triple systems. We carry out linear stability analysis for the eccentricity growth of circumstellar disks in binaries, including th…
▽ More
Recent SPH simulations by Martin et al. (2014) suggest a circumstellar gaseous disk may exhibit coherent eccentricity-inclination oscillations due to the tidal forcing of an inclined binary companion, in a manner that resembles Lidov-Kozai oscillations in hierarchical triple systems. We carry out linear stability analysis for the eccentricity growth of circumstellar disks in binaries, including the effects of gas pressure and viscosity and secular (orbital-averaged) tidal force from the inclined companion. We find that the growth of disk eccentricity depends on the dimensionless ratio ($S$) between $c_{\rm s}^2$ (the disk sound speed squared) and the tidal torque acting on the disk (per unit mass) from the companion. For $S\ll 1$, the standard Lidov-Kozai result is recovered for a thin disk annulus: eccentricity excitation occurs when the mutual inclination $I$ between the disk and binary lies between $39^\circ$ and $141^\circ$. As $S$ increases, the inclination window for eccentricity growth generally becomes narrower. For $S\gtrsim$ a few, eccentricity growth is suppressed for all inclination angles. Surprisingly, we find that for $S\sim 1$ and certain disk density/pressure profiles, eccentricity excitation can occur even when $I$ is much less than $39^\circ$.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2017; v1 submitted 16 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Extended Transiting Disks and Rings Around Planets and Brown Dwarfs: Theoretical Constraints
Authors:
J. J. Zanazzi,
Dong Lai
Abstract:
Newly formed planets (or brown dwarfs) may possess disks or rings that occupy an appreciable fraction of the planet's Hill sphere and extend beyond the Laplace radius, where the tidal torque from the host star dominates over the torque from the oblate planet. Such a disk/ring can exhibit unique, detectable transit signatures, provided that the disk/ring is significantly misaligned with the orbital…
▽ More
Newly formed planets (or brown dwarfs) may possess disks or rings that occupy an appreciable fraction of the planet's Hill sphere and extend beyond the Laplace radius, where the tidal torque from the host star dominates over the torque from the oblate planet. Such a disk/ring can exhibit unique, detectable transit signatures, provided that the disk/ring is significantly misaligned with the orbital plane of the planet. There exists tentative evidence for an extended ring system around the young K5 star 1 SWASP J140747-354542. We present a general theoretical study of the inclination (warp) profile of circumplanetary disks under the combined influences of the tidal torque from the central star, the torque from the oblate planet and the self-gravity of the disk. We calculate the steady-state warp profile ("generalized Laplace Surface") and investigate the condition for coherent precession of the disk. We find that to maintain non-negligible misalignment between the extended outer disk and the planet's orbital plane, and to ensure coherent disk precession, the disk surface density must be sufficiently large so that the self-gravity torque overcomes the tidal torque from the central star. Our analysis and quantitative results can be used to constrain the parameters of transiting circumplanetary disks that may be detected in the future.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2016; v1 submitted 8 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Electromagnetic Torques, Precession and Evolution of Magnetic Inclination of Pulsars
Authors:
J. J. Zanazzi,
Dong Lai
Abstract:
We present analytic calculations of the electromagnetic torques acting on a magnetic neutron star rotating in vacuum, including near-zone torques associated with the inertia of dipole and quadrupole magnetic fields. We incorporate these torques into the rotational dynamics of a rigid-body neutron star, and show that the effects of the inertial torque can be understood as a modification of the mome…
▽ More
We present analytic calculations of the electromagnetic torques acting on a magnetic neutron star rotating in vacuum, including near-zone torques associated with the inertia of dipole and quadrupole magnetic fields. We incorporate these torques into the rotational dynamics of a rigid-body neutron star, and show that the effects of the inertial torque can be understood as a modification of the moment of inertia tensor of the star. We apply our rotational dynamics equation to the Crab pulsar, including intrinsic distortions of the star and various electromagnetic torques, to investigate the possibility that the counter-alignment of the magnetic inclination angle, as suggested by recent observations, could be explained by pulsar precession. We find that if the effective principal axis of the pulsar is nearly aligned with either the magnetic dipole axis or the rotation axis, then precession may account for the observed counter-alignment over decade timescales. Over the spindown timescale of the pulsar, the magnetic inclination angle always decreases.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2015; v1 submitted 4 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
A Short Proof of Klee's Theorem
Authors:
John J. Zanazzi
Abstract:
In 1959, Klee proved that a convex body $K$ is a polyhedron if and only if all of its projections are polygons. In this paper, a new proof of this theorem is given for convex bodies in $\mathbb{R}^3$.
In 1959, Klee proved that a convex body $K$ is a polyhedron if and only if all of its projections are polygons. In this paper, a new proof of this theorem is given for convex bodies in $\mathbb{R}^3$.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2013; v1 submitted 10 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.
