-
Robust Model-Based Clustering
Authors:
Juan D. Gonzalez,
Ricardo Maronna,
Victor J. Yohai,
Ruben H. Zamar
Abstract:
We propose a new class of robust and Fisher-consistent estimators for mixture models. These estimators can be used to construct robust model-based clustering procedures. We study in detail the case of multivariate normal mixtures and propose a procedure that uses S estimators of multivariate location and scatter. We develop an algorithm to compute the estimators and to build the clusters which is…
▽ More
We propose a new class of robust and Fisher-consistent estimators for mixture models. These estimators can be used to construct robust model-based clustering procedures. We study in detail the case of multivariate normal mixtures and propose a procedure that uses S estimators of multivariate location and scatter. We develop an algorithm to compute the estimators and to build the clusters which is quite similar to the EM algorithm. An extensive Monte Carlo simulation study shows that our proposal compares favorably with other robust and non robust model-based clustering procedures. We apply ours and alternative procedures to a real data set and again find that the best results are obtained using our proposal.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2021; v1 submitted 12 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Regularized K-means through hard-thresholding
Authors:
Jakob Raymaekers,
Ruben H. Zamar
Abstract:
We study a framework of regularized $K$-means methods based on direct penalization of the size of the cluster centers. Different penalization strategies are considered and compared through simulation and theoretical analysis. Based on the results, we propose HT $K$-means, which uses an $\ell_0$ penalty to induce sparsity in the variables. Different techniques for selecting the tuning parameter are…
▽ More
We study a framework of regularized $K$-means methods based on direct penalization of the size of the cluster centers. Different penalization strategies are considered and compared through simulation and theoretical analysis. Based on the results, we propose HT $K$-means, which uses an $\ell_0$ penalty to induce sparsity in the variables. Different techniques for selecting the tuning parameter are discussed and compared. The proposed method stacks up favorably with the most popular regularized $K$-means methods in an extensive simulation study. Finally, HT $K$-means is applied to several real data examples. Graphical displays are presented and used in these examples to gain more insight into the datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Pooled variable scaling for cluster analysis
Authors:
Jakob Raymaekers,
Ruben H. Zamar
Abstract:
We propose a new approach for scaling prior to cluster analysis based on the concept of pooled variance. Unlike available scaling procedures such as the standard deviation and the range, our proposed scale avoids dampening the beneficial effect of informative clustering variables. We confirm through an extensive simulation study and applications to well known real data examples that the proposed s…
▽ More
We propose a new approach for scaling prior to cluster analysis based on the concept of pooled variance. Unlike available scaling procedures such as the standard deviation and the range, our proposed scale avoids dampening the beneficial effect of informative clustering variables. We confirm through an extensive simulation study and applications to well known real data examples that the proposed scaling method is safe and generally useful. Finally, we use our approach to cluster a high dimensional genomic dataset consisting of gene expression data for several specimens of breast cancer cells tissue.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2020; v1 submitted 22 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Robust Clustering Using Tau-Scales
Authors:
Juan D. Gonzalez,
Victor J. Yohai,
Ruben H. Zamar
Abstract:
K means is a popular non-parametric clustering procedure introduced by Steinhaus (1956) and further developed by MacQueen (1967). It is known, however, that K means does not perform well in the presence of outliers. Cuesta-Albertos et al (1997) introduced a robust alternative, trimmed K means, which can be tuned to be robust or efficient, but cannot achieve these two properties simultaneously in a…
▽ More
K means is a popular non-parametric clustering procedure introduced by Steinhaus (1956) and further developed by MacQueen (1967). It is known, however, that K means does not perform well in the presence of outliers. Cuesta-Albertos et al (1997) introduced a robust alternative, trimmed K means, which can be tuned to be robust or efficient, but cannot achieve these two properties simultaneously in an adaptive way. To overcome this limitation we propose a new robust clustering procedure called K Tau Centers, which is based on the concept of Tau scale introduced by Yohai and Zamar (1988). We show that K Tau Centers performs well in extensive simulation studies and real data examples. We also show that the centers found by the proposed method are consistent estimators of the "true" centers defined as the minimizers of the the objective function at the population level.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
A Stepwise Approach for High-Dimensional Gaussian Graphical Models
Authors:
Ginette Lafit,
Francisco J. Nogales,
Marcelo Ruiz,
Ruben H. Zamar
Abstract:
We present a stepwise approach to estimate high dimensional Gaussian graphical models. We exploit the relation between the partial correlation coefficients and the distribution of the prediction errors, and parametrize the model in terms of the Pearson correlation coefficients between the prediction errors of the nodes' best linear predictors. We propose a novel stepwise algorithm for detecting pa…
▽ More
We present a stepwise approach to estimate high dimensional Gaussian graphical models. We exploit the relation between the partial correlation coefficients and the distribution of the prediction errors, and parametrize the model in terms of the Pearson correlation coefficients between the prediction errors of the nodes' best linear predictors. We propose a novel stepwise algorithm for detecting pairs of conditionally dependent variables. We show that the proposed algorithm outperforms existing methods such as the graphical lasso and CLIME in simulation studies and real life applications. In our comparison we report different performance measures that look at different desirable features of the recovered graph and consider several model settings.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Regression Phalanxes
Authors:
Hongyang Zhang,
William J. Welch,
Ruben H. Zamar
Abstract:
Tomal et al. (2015) introduced the notion of "phalanxes" in the context of rare-class detection in two-class classification problems. A phalanx is a subset of features that work well for classification tasks. In this paper, we propose a different class of phalanxes for application in regression settings. We define a "Regression Phalanx" - a subset of features that work well together for prediction…
▽ More
Tomal et al. (2015) introduced the notion of "phalanxes" in the context of rare-class detection in two-class classification problems. A phalanx is a subset of features that work well for classification tasks. In this paper, we propose a different class of phalanxes for application in regression settings. We define a "Regression Phalanx" - a subset of features that work well together for prediction. We propose a novel algorithm which automatically chooses Regression Phalanxes from high-dimensional data sets using hierarchical clustering and builds a prediction model for each phalanx for further ensembling. Through extensive simulation studies and several real-life applications in various areas (including drug discovery, chemical analysis of spectra data, microarray analysis and climate projections) we show that an ensemble of Regression Phalanxes improves prediction accuracy when combined with effective prediction methods like Lasso or Random Forests.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Ensembles of phalanxes across assessment metrics for robust ranking of homologous proteins
Authors:
Jabed H Tomal,
William J Welch,
Ruben H Zamar
Abstract:
Two proteins are homologous if they have a common evolutionary origin, and the binary classification problem is to identify proteins in a candidate set that are homologous to a particular native protein. The feature (explanatory) variables available for classification are various measures of similarity of proteins. There are multiple classification problems of this type for different native protei…
▽ More
Two proteins are homologous if they have a common evolutionary origin, and the binary classification problem is to identify proteins in a candidate set that are homologous to a particular native protein. The feature (explanatory) variables available for classification are various measures of similarity of proteins. There are multiple classification problems of this type for different native proteins and their respective candidate sets. Homologous proteins are rare in a single candidate set, giving a highly unbalanced two-class problem. The goal is to rank proteins in a candidate set according to the probability of being homologous to the set's native protein. An ideal classifier will place all the homologous proteins at the head of such a list. Our approach uses an ensemble of models in a classifier and an ensemble of assessment metrics. For a given metric a classifier combines models, each based on a subset of the available feature variables which we call phalanxes. The proposed ensemble of phalanxes identifies strong and diverse subsets of feature variables. A second phase of ensembling aggregates classifiers based on diverse evaluation metrics. The overall result is called an ensemble of phalanxes and metrics. It provide robustness against both close and distant homologues.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2019; v1 submitted 21 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Multivariate Location and Scatter Matrix Estimation Under Cellwise and Casewise Contamination
Authors:
Andy Leung,
Victor J. Yohai,
Ruben H. Zamar
Abstract:
We consider the problem of multivariate location and scatter matrix estimation when the data contain cellwise and casewise outliers. Agostinelli et al. (2015) propose a two-step approach to deal with this problem: first, apply a univariate filter to remove cellwise outliers and second, apply a generalized S-estimator to downweight casewise outliers. We improve this proposal in three main direction…
▽ More
We consider the problem of multivariate location and scatter matrix estimation when the data contain cellwise and casewise outliers. Agostinelli et al. (2015) propose a two-step approach to deal with this problem: first, apply a univariate filter to remove cellwise outliers and second, apply a generalized S-estimator to downweight casewise outliers. We improve this proposal in three main directions. First, we introduce a consistent bivariate filter to be used in combination with the univariate filter in the first step. Second, we propose a new fast subsampling procedure to generate starting points for the generalized S-estimator in the second step. Third, we consider a non-monotonic weight function for the generalized S-estimator to better deal with casewise outliers in high dimension. A simulation study and real data example show that, unlike the original two-step procedure, the modified two-step approach performs and scales well for high dimension. Moreover, the modified procedure outperforms the original one and other state-of-the-art robust procedures under cellwise and casewise data contamination.
△ Less
Submitted 25 December, 2016; v1 submitted 1 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Robust regression estimation and inference in the presence of cellwise and casewise contamination
Authors:
Andy Leung,
Hongyang Zhang,
Ruben H. Zamar
Abstract:
Cellwise outliers are likely to occur together with casewise outliers in modern data sets with relatively large dimension. Recent work has shown that traditional robust regression methods may fail for data sets in this paradigm. The proposed method, called three-step regression, proceeds as follows: first, it uses a consistent univariate filter to detect and eliminate extreme cellwise outliers; se…
▽ More
Cellwise outliers are likely to occur together with casewise outliers in modern data sets with relatively large dimension. Recent work has shown that traditional robust regression methods may fail for data sets in this paradigm. The proposed method, called three-step regression, proceeds as follows: first, it uses a consistent univariate filter to detect and eliminate extreme cellwise outliers; second, it applies a robust estimator of multivariate location and scatter to the filtered data to down-weight casewise outliers; third, it computes robust regression coefficients from the estimates obtained in the second step. The three-step estimator is shown to be consistent and asymptotically normal at the central model under some assumptions on the tail distributions of the continuous covariates. The estimator is extended to handle both numerical and dummy covariates using an iterative algorithm. Extensive simulation results show that the three-step estimator is resilient to cellwise outliers. It also performs well under casewise contaminations when comparing with traditional high breakdown point estimators.
△ Less
Submitted 25 December, 2016; v1 submitted 8 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Multi-rank Sparse Hierarchical Clustering
Authors:
Hongyang Zhang,
Ruben H. Zamar
Abstract:
There has been a surge in the number of large and flat data sets - data sets containing a large number of features and a relatively small number of observations - due to the growing ability to collect and store information in medical research and other fields. Hierarchical clustering is a widely used clustering tool. In hierarchical clustering, large and flat data sets may allow for a better cover…
▽ More
There has been a surge in the number of large and flat data sets - data sets containing a large number of features and a relatively small number of observations - due to the growing ability to collect and store information in medical research and other fields. Hierarchical clustering is a widely used clustering tool. In hierarchical clustering, large and flat data sets may allow for a better coverage of clustering features (features that help explain the true underlying clusters) but, such data sets usually include a large fraction of noise features (non-clustering features) that may hide the underlying clusters. Witten and Tibshirani (2010) proposed a sparse hierarchical clustering framework to cluster the observations using an adaptively chosen subset of the features, however, we show that this framework has some limitations when the data sets contain clustering features with complex structure. In this paper, we propose the Multi-rank sparse hierarchical clustering (MrSHC). We show that, using simulation studies and real data examples, MrSHC produces superior feature selection and clustering performance comparing to the classical (of-the-shelf) hierarchical clustering and the existing sparse hierarchical clustering framework.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2017; v1 submitted 2 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Robust estimation of multivariate location and scatter in the presence of cellwise and casewise contamination
Authors:
Claudio Agostinelli,
Andy Leung,
Victor J. Yohai,
Ruben H. Zamar
Abstract:
Multivariate location and scatter matrix estimation is a cornerstone in multivariate data analysis. We consider this problem when the data may contain independent cellwise and casewise outliers. Flat data sets with a large number of variables and a relatively small number of cases are common place in modern statistical applications. In these cases global down-weighting of an entire case, as perfor…
▽ More
Multivariate location and scatter matrix estimation is a cornerstone in multivariate data analysis. We consider this problem when the data may contain independent cellwise and casewise outliers. Flat data sets with a large number of variables and a relatively small number of cases are common place in modern statistical applications. In these cases global down-weighting of an entire case, as performed by traditional robust procedures, may lead to poor results. We highlight the need for a new generation of robust estimators that can efficiently deal with cellwise outliers and at the same time show good performance under casewise outliers.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Ensembling classification models based on phalanxes of variables with applications in drug discovery
Authors:
Jabed H. Tomal,
William J. Welch,
Ruben H. Zamar
Abstract:
Statistical detection of a rare class of objects in a two-class classification problem can pose several challenges. Because the class of interest is rare in the training data, there is relatively little information in the known class response labels for model building. At the same time the available explanatory variables are often moderately high dimensional. In the four assays of our drug-discove…
▽ More
Statistical detection of a rare class of objects in a two-class classification problem can pose several challenges. Because the class of interest is rare in the training data, there is relatively little information in the known class response labels for model building. At the same time the available explanatory variables are often moderately high dimensional. In the four assays of our drug-discovery application, compounds are active or not against a specific biological target, such as lung cancer tumor cells, and active compounds are rare. Several sets of chemical descriptor variables from computational chemistry are available to classify the active versus inactive class; each can have up to thousands of variables characterizing molecular structure of the compounds. The statistical challenge is to make use of the richness of the explanatory variables in the presence of scant response information. Our algorithm divides the explanatory variables into subsets adaptively and passes each subset to a base classifier. The various base classifiers are then ensembled to produce one model to rank new objects by their estimated probabilities of belonging to the rare class of interest. The essence of the algorithm is to choose the subsets such that variables in the same group work well together; we call such groups phalanxes.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2015; v1 submitted 19 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
Propagation of outliers in multivariate data
Authors:
Fatemah Alqallaf,
Stefan Van Aelst,
Victor J. Yohai,
Ruben H. Zamar
Abstract:
We investigate the performance of robust estimates of multivariate location under nonstandard data contamination models such as componentwise outliers (i.e., contamination in each variable is independent from the other variables). This model brings up a possible new source of statistical error that we call "propagation of outliers." This source of error is unusual in the sense that it is generat…
▽ More
We investigate the performance of robust estimates of multivariate location under nonstandard data contamination models such as componentwise outliers (i.e., contamination in each variable is independent from the other variables). This model brings up a possible new source of statistical error that we call "propagation of outliers." This source of error is unusual in the sense that it is generated by the data processing itself and takes place after the data has been collected. We define and derive the influence function of robust multivariate location estimates under flexible contamination models and use it to investigate the effect of propagation of outliers. Furthermore, we show that standard high-breakdown affine equivariant estimators propagate outliers and therefore show poor breakdown behavior under componentwise contamination when the dimension $d$ is high.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
-
Discussion: Conditional growth charts
Authors:
Matias Salibian-Barrera,
Ruben H. Zamar
Abstract:
Discussion of Conditional growth charts [math.ST/0702634]
Discussion of Conditional growth charts [math.ST/0702634]
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2007;
originally announced February 2007.
-
Robust nonparametric inference for the median
Authors:
Victor J. Yohai,
Ruben H. Zamar
Abstract:
We consider the problem of constructing robust nonparametric confidence intervals and tests of hypothesis for the median when the data distribution is unknown and the data may contain a small fraction of contamination. We propose a modification of the sign test (and its associated confidence interval) which attains the nominal significance level (probability coverage) for any distribution in the…
▽ More
We consider the problem of constructing robust nonparametric confidence intervals and tests of hypothesis for the median when the data distribution is unknown and the data may contain a small fraction of contamination. We propose a modification of the sign test (and its associated confidence interval) which attains the nominal significance level (probability coverage) for any distribution in the contamination neighborhood of a continuous distribution. We also define some measures of robustness and efficiency under contamination for confidence intervals and tests. These measures are computed for the proposed procedures.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2005;
originally announced March 2005.
-
Uniform asymptotics for robust location estimates when the scale is unknown
Authors:
Matias Salibian-Barrera,
Ruben H. Zamar
Abstract:
Most asymptotic results for robust estimates rely on regularity conditions that are difficult to verify in practice. Moreover, these results apply to fixed distribution functions. In the robustness context the distribution of the data remains largely unspecified and hence results that hold uniformly over a set of possible distribution functions are of theoretical and practical interest. Also, it…
▽ More
Most asymptotic results for robust estimates rely on regularity conditions that are difficult to verify in practice. Moreover, these results apply to fixed distribution functions. In the robustness context the distribution of the data remains largely unspecified and hence results that hold uniformly over a set of possible distribution functions are of theoretical and practical interest. Also, it is desirable to be able to determine the size of the set of distribution functions where the uniform properties hold. In this paper we study the problem of obtaining verifiable regularity conditions that suffice to yield uniform consistency and uniform asymptotic normality for location robust estimates when the scale of the errors is unknown.
We study M-location estimates calculated with an S-scale and we obtain uniform asymptotic results over contamination neighborhoods. Moreover, we show how to calculate the maximum size of the contamination neighborhoods where these uniform results hold. There is a trade-off between the size of these neighborhoods and the breakdown point of the scale estimate.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2004;
originally announced October 2004.
