Showing 1–50 of 65 results for author: Youdin, A

Rossby wave instability in weakly ionized protoplanetary disks. I. azimuthal or vertical B-fields

Authors: Can Cui, Ashutosh Tripathi, Cong Yu, Min-Kai Lin, Andrew Youdin

Abstract: Rossby wave instability (RWI) is considered the underlying mechanism to crescent-shaped azimuthal asymmetries, discovered in (sub-)millimeter dust continuum of many protoplanetary disks. Previous works on linear theory were conducted in the hydrodynamic limit. Nevertheless, protoplanetary disks are likely magnetized and weakly ionized. We examine the influence of magnetic fields and non-ideal magn… ▽ More Rossby wave instability (RWI) is considered the underlying mechanism to crescent-shaped azimuthal asymmetries, discovered in (sub-)millimeter dust continuum of many protoplanetary disks. Previous works on linear theory were conducted in the hydrodynamic limit. Nevertheless, protoplanetary disks are likely magnetized and weakly ionized. We examine the influence of magnetic fields and non-ideal magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) effects - namely, Ohmic resistivity, Hall drift, and ambipolar diffusion - on the RWI unstable modes. We perform radially global linear analyses, employing constant azimuthal ($B_φ$) or vertical ($B_z$) background magnetic fields. It is found that, in the ideal MHD regime, magnetism can either enhance or diminish RWI growth. Strong non-ideal MHD effects cause RWI growth rates to recover hydrodynamic results. The sign of Hall Elsässer number subtly complicates the results, and vertical wavenumbers generically diminish growth rates. △ Less

Submitted 2 July, 2024; originally announced July 2024.

Comments: 13 pages, 4 figures, submitted to MNRAS

Rapid protoplanet formation in vortices: three-dimensional local simulations with selfgravity

Authors: Wladimir Lyra, Chao-Chin Yang, Jacob B. Simon, Orkan M. Umurhan, Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: Disk vortices, seen in numerical simulations of protoplanetary disks and found observationally in ALMA and VLA images of these objects, are promising sites for planet formation given their pebble trap** abilities. Previous works have shown strong concentration of pebbles in vortices, but gravitational collapse has only been shown in low-resolution, two-dimensional, global models. In this letter,… ▽ More Disk vortices, seen in numerical simulations of protoplanetary disks and found observationally in ALMA and VLA images of these objects, are promising sites for planet formation given their pebble trap** abilities. Previous works have shown strong concentration of pebbles in vortices, but gravitational collapse has only been shown in low-resolution, two-dimensional, global models. In this letter, we aim to study the pebble concentration and gravitational collapse of pebble clouds in vortices via high-resolution, three-dimensional, local models. We performed simulations of the dynamics of gas and solids in a local shearing box where the gas is subject to convective overstability, generating a persistent giant vortex. We find that the vortex produces objects of Moon and Mars mass, with mass function of power law $d\ln N/d\ln M=-1.6\pm 0.3$. The protoplanets grow rapidly, doubling in mass in about 5 orbits, following pebble accretion rates. The mass range and mass doubling rate are in broad agreement with previous low resolution global models. We conclude that Mars-mass planetary embryos are the natural outcome of planet formation inside the disk vortices seen in millimeter and radio images of protoplanetary disks. △ Less

Submitted 25 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Comments: 9 pages, 5 figures, accepted for publication in ApJ letters

Magnetically Driven Turbulence in the Inner Regions of Protoplanetary Disks

Authors: David G. Rea, Jacob B. Simon, Daniel Carrera, Geoffroy Lesur, Wladimir Lyra, Debanjan Sengupta, Chao-Chin Yang, Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: Given the important role turbulence plays in the settling and growth of dust grains in protoplanetary disks, it is crucial that we determine whether these disks are turbulent and to what extent. Protoplanetary disks are weakly ionized near the mid-plane, which has led to a paradigm in which largely laminar magnetic field structures prevail deeper in the disk, with angular momentum being transporte… ▽ More Given the important role turbulence plays in the settling and growth of dust grains in protoplanetary disks, it is crucial that we determine whether these disks are turbulent and to what extent. Protoplanetary disks are weakly ionized near the mid-plane, which has led to a paradigm in which largely laminar magnetic field structures prevail deeper in the disk, with angular momentum being transported via magnetically launched winds. Yet, there has been little exploration on the precise behavior of the gas within the bulk of the disk. We carry out 3D, local shearing box simulations that include all three low-ionization effects (Ohmic diffusion, ambipolar diffusion, and the Hall effect) to probe the nature of magnetically driven gas dynamics 1-30 AU from the central star. We find that gas turbulence can persist with a generous yet physically motivated ionization prescription (order unity Elsasser numbers). The gas velocity fluctuations range from 0.03-0.09 of the sound speed $c_s$ at the disk mid-plane to $\sim c_s$ near the disk surface, and are dependent on the initial magnetic field strength. However, the turbulent velocities do not appear to be strongly dependent on the field polarity, and thus appear to be insensitive to the Hall effect. The mid-plane turbulence has the potential to drive dust grains to collision velocities exceeding their fragmentation limit, and likely reduces the efficacy of particle clum** in the mid-plane, though it remains to be seen if this level of turbulence persists in disks with lower ionization levels. △ Less

Submitted 10 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: 23 pages, 19 figures, 2 tables, submitted to ApJ

A thermodynamic criterion for the formation of Circumplanetary Disks

Authors: Leonardo Krapp, Kaitlin M. Kratter, Andrew N. Youdin, Pablo Benítez-Llambay, Frédéric Masset, Philip J. Armitage

Abstract: The formation of circumplanetary disks is central to our understanding of giant planet formation, influencing their growth rate during the post-runaway phase and observability while embedded in protoplanetary disks. We use 3D global multifluid radiation hydrodynamics simulations with the FARGO3D code to define the thermodynamic conditions that enable circumplanetary disk formation around Jovian pl… ▽ More The formation of circumplanetary disks is central to our understanding of giant planet formation, influencing their growth rate during the post-runaway phase and observability while embedded in protoplanetary disks. We use 3D global multifluid radiation hydrodynamics simulations with the FARGO3D code to define the thermodynamic conditions that enable circumplanetary disk formation around Jovian planets on wide orbits. Our simulations include stellar irradiation, viscous heating, static mesh refinement, and active calculation of opacity based on evolving dust fluids. We find a necessary condition for the formation of circumplanetary disks in terms of a mean cooling time: when the cooling time is at least one order of magnitude shorter than the orbital time scale, the specific angular momentum of the gas is nearly Keplerian at scales of $R_{\rm{Hill}}/3$. We show that the inclusion of multifluid dust dynamics favors rotational support because dust settling produces an anisotropic opacity distribution that favors rapid cooling. In all our models with radiation hydrodynamics, specific angular momentum decreases as time evolves in agreement with the formation of an inner isentropic envelope due to compressional heating. The isentropic envelope can extend up to $R_{\rm{Hill}}/3$ and shows negligible rotational support. Thus, our results imply that young gas giant planets may host spherical isentropic envelopes, rather than circumplanetary disks. △ Less

Submitted 26 February, 2024; v1 submitted 22 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: 17 pages, 10 figures, submitted to ApJ. Comments are welcome

A solution for the density dichotomy problem of Kuiper Belt objects with multi-species streaming instability and pebble accretion

Authors: Manuel H. Cañas, Wladimir Lyra, Daniel Carrera, Leonardo Krapp, Debanjan Sengupta, Jacob B. Simon, Orkan M. Umurhan, Chao-Chin Yang, Andrew Youdin

Abstract: Kuiper belt objects show an unexpected trend, whereby large bodies have increasingly higher densities, up to five times greater than their smaller counterparts. Current explanations for this trend assume formation at constant composition, with the increasing density resulting from gravitational compaction. However, this scenario poses a timing problem to avoid early melting by decay of $^{26}$Al.… ▽ More Kuiper belt objects show an unexpected trend, whereby large bodies have increasingly higher densities, up to five times greater than their smaller counterparts. Current explanations for this trend assume formation at constant composition, with the increasing density resulting from gravitational compaction. However, this scenario poses a timing problem to avoid early melting by decay of $^{26}$Al. We aim to explain the density trend in the context of streaming instability and pebble accretion. Small pebbles experience lofting into the atmosphere of the disk, being exposed to UV and partially losing their ice via desorption. Conversely, larger pebbles are shielded and remain more icy. We use a shearing box model including gas and solids, the latter split into ices and silicate pebbles. Self-gravity is included, allowing dense clumps to collapse into planetesimals. We find that the streaming instability leads to the formation of mostly icy planetesimals, albeit with an unexpected trend that the lighter ones are more silicate-rich than the heavier ones. We feed the resulting planetesimals into a pebble accretion integrator with a continuous size distribution, finding that they undergo drastic changes in composition as they preferentially accrete silicate pebbles. The density and masses of large KBOs are best reproduced if they form between 15 and 22\,AU. Our solution avoids the timing problem because the first planetesimals are primarily icy, and $^{26}$Al is mostly incorporated in the slow phase of silicate pebble accretion. Our results lend further credibility to the streaming instability and pebble accretion as formation and growth mechanisms. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Comments: 24 pages, 13 figures, accepted to The Planetary Science Journal

Streaming Instability and Turbulence: Conditions for Planetesimal Formation

Authors: Jeonghoon Lim, Jacob B. Simon, Rixin Li, Philip J. Armitage, Daniel Carrera, Wladimir Lyra, David G. Rea, Chao-Chin Yang, Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: The streaming instability (SI) is a leading candidate for planetesimal formation, which can concentrate solids through two-way aerodynamic interactions with the gas. The resulting concentrations can become sufficiently dense to collapse under particle self-gravity, forming planetesimals. Previous studies have carried out large parameter surveys to establish the critical particle to gas surface den… ▽ More The streaming instability (SI) is a leading candidate for planetesimal formation, which can concentrate solids through two-way aerodynamic interactions with the gas. The resulting concentrations can become sufficiently dense to collapse under particle self-gravity, forming planetesimals. Previous studies have carried out large parameter surveys to establish the critical particle to gas surface density ratio ($Z$), above which SI-induced concentration triggers planetesimal formation. The threshold $Z$ depends on the dimensionless stop** time ($τ_s$, a proxy for dust size). However, these studies neglected both particle self-gravity and external turbulence. Here, we perform 3D stratified shearing box simulations with both particle self-gravity and turbulent forcing, which we characterize via $α_D$ that measures turbulent diffusion. We find that forced turbulence, at amplitudes plausibly present in some protoplanetary disks, can increase the threshold $Z$ by up to an order of magnitude. For example, for $τ_s = 0.01$, planetesimal formation occurs when $Z \gtrsim 0.06$, $\gtrsim 0.1$, and $\gtrsim 0.2$ at $α_D = 10^{-4}$, $10^{-3.5}$, and $10^{-3}$, respectively. We provide a single fit to the critical $Z$ as a function of $α_D$ and $τ_s$ required for the SI to work (though limited to the range $τ_s = 0.01$--0.1). Our simulations also show that planetesimal formation requires a mid-plane particle-to-gas density ratio that exceeds unity, with the critical value being independent of $α_D$. Finally, we provide the estimation of particle scale height that accounts for both particle feedback and external turbulence. △ Less

Submitted 19 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: 27 pages, 13 figures, submitted to The Astrophysical Journal

Dust Dynamics in Hall-effected Protoplanetary Disks. I. Background Drift Hall Instability

Authors: Yinhao Wu, Min-Kai Lin, Can Cui, Leonardo Krapp, Yueh-Ning Lee, Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: Recent studies have shown that the large-scale gas dynamics of protoplanetary disks (PPDs) are controlled by non-ideal magneto-hydrodynamics (MHD), but how this influences dust dynamics is not fully understood. To this end, we investigate the stability of dusty, magnetized disks subject to the Hall effect, which applies to planet-forming regions of PPDs. We find a novel Background Drift Hall Insta… ▽ More Recent studies have shown that the large-scale gas dynamics of protoplanetary disks (PPDs) are controlled by non-ideal magneto-hydrodynamics (MHD), but how this influences dust dynamics is not fully understood. To this end, we investigate the stability of dusty, magnetized disks subject to the Hall effect, which applies to planet-forming regions of PPDs. We find a novel Background Drift Hall Instability (BDHI) that may facilitate planetesimal formation in Hall-effected disk regions. Through a combination of linear analysis and nonlinear simulations, we demonstrate the viability and characteristics of BDHI. We find it can potentially dominate over the classical streaming instability (SI) and standard MHD instabilities at low dust-to-gas ratios and weak magnetic fields. We also identify magnetized versions of the classic SI, but these are usually subdominant. We highlight the complex interplay between magnetic fields and dust-gas dynamics in PPDs, underscoring the need to consider non-ideal MHD like the Hall effect in the broader narrative of planet formation. △ Less

Submitted 14 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: 23 pages, 12 figures, accepted by ApJ. Welcome any comments and suggestions!

On the Origin of Dust Structures in Protoplanetary Disks: Constraints from the Rossby Wave Instability

Authors: Eonho Chang, Andrew N. Youdin, Leonardo Krapp

Abstract: High resolution sub-mm observations of protoplanetary disks with ALMA have revealed that dust rings are common in large, bright disks. The leading explanation for these structures is dust-trap** in a local gas pressure maximum, caused by an embedded planet or other dynamical process. Independent of origin, such dust traps should be stable for many orbits to collect significant dust. However, rin… ▽ More High resolution sub-mm observations of protoplanetary disks with ALMA have revealed that dust rings are common in large, bright disks. The leading explanation for these structures is dust-trap** in a local gas pressure maximum, caused by an embedded planet or other dynamical process. Independent of origin, such dust traps should be stable for many orbits to collect significant dust. However, ring-like perturbations in gas disks are also known to trigger the Rossby Wave Instability (RWI). We investigate whether axisymmetric pressure bumps can simultaneously trap dust and remain stable to the RWI. The answer depends on the thermodynamic properties of pressure bumps. For isothermal bumps, dust traps are RWI-stable for widths from ${\sim}1$ to several gas scale-heights. Adiabatic dust traps are stable over a smaller range of widths. For temperature bumps with no surface density component, however, all dust traps tend to be unstable. Smaller values of disk aspect ratio allow stable dust trap** at lower bump amplitudes and over a larger range of widths. We also report a new approximate criterion for RWI. Instability occurs when the radial oscillation frequency is $\lesssim75$\% of the Keplerian frequency, which differs from the well-known Lovelace necessary (but not sufficient) criterion for instability. Our results can guide ALMA observations of molecular gas by constraining the resolution and sensitivity needed to identify the pressure bumps thought to be responsible for dust rings. △ Less

Submitted 6 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: 11 pages, 5 figures, accepted to ApJL

Hydro-, Magnetohydro-, and Dust-Gas Dynamics of Protoplanetary Disks

Authors: G. Lesur, B. Ercolano, M. Flock, M. -K. Lin, C. -C. Yang, J. A. Barranco, P. Benitez-Llambay, J. Goodman, A. Johansen, H. Klahr, G. Laibe, W. Lyra, P. Marcus, R. P. Nelson, J. Squire, J. B. Simon, N. Turner, O. M. Umurhan, A. N. Youdin

Abstract: The building of planetary systems is controlled by the gas and dust dynamics of protoplanetary disks. While the gas is simultaneously accreted onto the central star and dissipated away by winds, dust grains aggregate and collapse to form planetesimals and eventually planets. This dust and gas dynamics involves instabilities, turbulence and complex non-linear interactions which ultimately control t… ▽ More The building of planetary systems is controlled by the gas and dust dynamics of protoplanetary disks. While the gas is simultaneously accreted onto the central star and dissipated away by winds, dust grains aggregate and collapse to form planetesimals and eventually planets. This dust and gas dynamics involves instabilities, turbulence and complex non-linear interactions which ultimately control the observational appearance and the secular evolution of these disks. This chapter is dedicated to the most recent developments in our understanding of the dynamics of gaseous and dusty disks, covering hydrodynamic and magnetohydrodynamic turbulence, gas-dust instabilities, dust clum** and disk winds. We show how these physical processes have been tested from observations and highlight standing questions that should be addressed in the future. △ Less

Submitted 18 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: 32 pages, 7 figures, to appear in Protostars and Planets VII, eds: Shu-ichiro Inutsuka, Yuri Aikawa, Takayuki Muto, Kengo Tomida, and Motohide Tamura

The 3D dust and opacity distribution of protoplanets in multi-fluid global simulations

Authors: Leonardo Krapp, Kaitlin M. Kratter, Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: The abundance and distribution of solids inside the Hill sphere are central to our understanding of the giant planet dichotomy. Here, we present a three-dimensional characterization of the dust density, mass flux, and mean opacities in the envelope of sub-thermal and super-thermal mass planets. We simulate the dynamics of multiple dust species in a global protoplanetary disk model accounting for d… ▽ More The abundance and distribution of solids inside the Hill sphere are central to our understanding of the giant planet dichotomy. Here, we present a three-dimensional characterization of the dust density, mass flux, and mean opacities in the envelope of sub-thermal and super-thermal mass planets. We simulate the dynamics of multiple dust species in a global protoplanetary disk model accounting for dust feedback. We find that the meridional flows do not effectively stir dust grains at scales of the Bondi sphere. Thus the dust-settling driven by the stellar gravitational potential sets the latitudinal dust density gradient within the planet envelope. Not only does the planet's potential enhance this gradient, but also the spiral wakes serve as another source of asymmetry. These asymmetries substantially alter the inferred mean Rosseland and Planck opacities. In cases with the moderate-to-strong dust settling, the opacity gradient can range from a few percent to more than two orders of magnitude between the mid-plane and the polar regions of the Bondi sphere. Finally, we show that this strong latitudinal opacity gradient can introduce a transition between optically thick and thin regimes at the scales of the planet envelope. We suggest that this transition is likely to occur when the equilibrium scale height of hundred-micron-sized particles is smaller than the Hill radius of the forming planet. This work calls into question the adoption of a constant opacity derived from well-mixed distributions and demonstrates the need for global radiation hydrodynamics models of giant planet formation which account for dust dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 9 March, 2022; v1 submitted 5 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Comments: 19 pages, 13 figures, accepted for publication in The Astrophysical Journal

Dynamical stability of giant planets: the critical adiabatic index in the presence of a solid core

Authors: Suman Kumar Kundu, Eric R. Coughlin, Andrew N. Youdin, Philip J. Armitage

Abstract: The dissociation and ionization of hydrogen, during the formation of giant planets via core accretion, reduces the effective adiabatic index $γ$ of the gas and could trigger dynamical instability. We generalize the analysis of Chandrasekhar, who determined that the threshold for instability of a self-gravitating hydrostatic body lies at $γ=4/3$, to account for the presence of a planetary core, whi… ▽ More The dissociation and ionization of hydrogen, during the formation of giant planets via core accretion, reduces the effective adiabatic index $γ$ of the gas and could trigger dynamical instability. We generalize the analysis of Chandrasekhar, who determined that the threshold for instability of a self-gravitating hydrostatic body lies at $γ=4/3$, to account for the presence of a planetary core, which we model as an incompressible fluid. We show that the dominant effect of the core is to stabilize the envelope to radial perturbations, in some cases completely (i.e. for all $γ> 1$). When instability is possible, unstable planetary configurations occupy a strip of $γ$ values whose upper boundary falls below $γ=4/3$. Fiducial evolutionary tracks of giant planets forming through core accretion appear unlikely to cross the dynamical instability strip that we define. △ Less

Submitted 6 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Global 3D Radiation Hydrodynamic Simulations of Proto-Jupiter's Convective Envelope

Authors: Zhaohuan Zhu, Yan-Fei Jiang, Hans Baehr, Andrew N. Youdin, Philip J. Armitage, Rebecca G. Martin

Abstract: The core accretion model of giant planet formation has been challenged by the discovery of recycling flows between the planetary envelope and the disc that can slow or stall envelope accretion. We carry out 3D radiation hydrodynamic simulations with an updated opacity compilation to model the proto-Jupiter's envelope. To isolate the 3D effects of convection and recycling, we simulate both isolated… ▽ More The core accretion model of giant planet formation has been challenged by the discovery of recycling flows between the planetary envelope and the disc that can slow or stall envelope accretion. We carry out 3D radiation hydrodynamic simulations with an updated opacity compilation to model the proto-Jupiter's envelope. To isolate the 3D effects of convection and recycling, we simulate both isolated spherical envelopes and envelopes embedded in discs. The envelopes are heated at given rates to achieve steady states, enabling comparisons with 1D models. We vary envelope properties to obtain both radiative and convective solutions. Using a passive scalar, we observe significant mass recycling on the orbital timescale. For a radiative envelope, recycling can only penetrate from the disc surface until $\sim$0.1-0.2 planetary Hill radii, while for a convective envelope, the convective motion can "dredge up" the deeper part of the envelope so that the entire convective envelope is recycled efficiently. This recycling, however, has only limited effects on the envelopes' thermal structure. The radiative envelope embedded in the disc has identical structure as the isolated envelope. The convective envelope has a slightly higher density when it is embedded in the disc. We introduce a modified 1D approach which can fully reproduce our 3D simulations. With our updated opacity and 1D model, we recompute Jupiter's envelope accretion with a 10 $M_{\oplus}$ core, and the timescale to runaway accretion is shorter than the disc lifetime as in prior studies. Finally, we discuss the implications of the efficient recycling on the observed chemical abundances of the planetary atmosphere (especially for super-Earths and mini-Neptunes). △ Less

Submitted 1 September, 2021; v1 submitted 22 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 24 pages, 17 figures, Accepted for publication in MNRAS

Thresholds for Particle Clum** by the Streaming Instability

Authors: Rixin Li, Andrew Youdin

Abstract: The streaming instability (SI) is a mechanism to aerodynamically concentrate solids in protoplanetary disks and trigger the formation of planetesimals. The SI produces strong particle clum** if the ratio of solid to gas surface density -- an effective metallicity -- exceeds a critical value. This critical value depends on particle sizes and disk conditions such as radial drift-inducing pressure… ▽ More The streaming instability (SI) is a mechanism to aerodynamically concentrate solids in protoplanetary disks and trigger the formation of planetesimals. The SI produces strong particle clum** if the ratio of solid to gas surface density -- an effective metallicity -- exceeds a critical value. This critical value depends on particle sizes and disk conditions such as radial drift-inducing pressure gradients and levels of turbulence. To quantify these thresholds, we perform a suite of vertically-stratified SI simulations over a range of dust sizes and metallicities. We find a critical metallicity as low as 0.4% for the optimum particle sizes and standard radial pressure gradients (normalized value of $Π= 0.05$). This sub-Solar metallicity is lower than previous results due to improved numerical methods and computational effort. We discover a sharp increase in the critical metallicity for small solids, when the dimensionless stop** time (Stokes number) is $\leq 0.01$. We provide simple fits to the size-dependent SI clum** threshold, including generalizations to different disk models and levels of turbulence. We also find that linear, unstratified SI growth rates are a surprisingly poor predictor of particle clum** in non-linear, stratified simulations, especially when the finite resolution of simulations is considered. Our results widen the parameter space for the SI to trigger planetesimal formation. △ Less

Submitted 14 October, 2021; v1 submitted 12 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Comments: Accepted by ApJ and published online (with one interactive figure)

Planetesimal formation around the snow line. II. Dust or pebbles?

Authors: Ryuki Hyodo, Tristan Guillot, Shigeru Ida, Satoshi Okuzumi, Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: Around the snow line, icy pebbles and silicate dust may locally pile-up and form icy and rocky planetesimals via streaming instability and/or gravitational instability. We perform 1D diffusion-advection simulations that include the back-reaction to radial drift and diffusion of icy pebbles and silicate dust, ice sublimation, release of silicate dust, and their recycling through recondensation and… ▽ More Around the snow line, icy pebbles and silicate dust may locally pile-up and form icy and rocky planetesimals via streaming instability and/or gravitational instability. We perform 1D diffusion-advection simulations that include the back-reaction to radial drift and diffusion of icy pebbles and silicate dust, ice sublimation, release of silicate dust, and their recycling through recondensation and sticking onto pebbles outside the snow line. We use a realistic description of the scale height of silicate dust obtained from Ida et al. and that of pebbles including the effects of a Kelvin-Helmholtz instability. We study the dependence of solid pile-up on distinct effective viscous parameters for turbulent diffusions in the radial and vertical directions ($α_{\rm Dr}$ and $α_{\rm Dz}$) and for the gas accretion to the star ($α_{\rm acc}$) as well as that on the pebble-to-gas mass flux ($F_{\rm p/g}$). We derive the sublimation width of drifting icy pebbles which is a critical parameter to characterize the pile-up of silicate dust and pebbles around the snow line. We identify a parameter space (in the $F_{\rm p/g}-α_{\rm acc}-α_{\rm Dz}(=α_{\rm Dr})$ space) where pebbles no longer drift inward to reach the snow line due to the back-reaction that slows down radial velocity of pebbles. We show that the pile-up of solids around the snow line occurs in a broader range of parameters for $α_{\rm acc}=10^{-3}$ than for $α_{\rm acc}=10^{-2}$. Above a critical $F_{\rm p/g}$ value, the runaway pile-up of silicate dust inside the snow line is favored for $α_{\rm Dr}/α_{\rm acc} \ll 1$, while that of pebbles outside the snow line is favored for $α_{\rm Dr}/α_{\rm acc} \sim 1$. Our results imply that a distinct evolutionary path could produce a diversity of outcomes in terms of planetesimal formation around the snow line. △ Less

Submitted 16 January, 2021; v1 submitted 11 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: 18 pages, 6 Figures, 3 Figures in Appendix, accepted for publication in Astronomy & Astrophysics (A&A)

Journal ref: A&A 646, A14 (2021)

Planetesimal formation around the snow line: I. Monte Carlo simulations of silicate dust pile-up in a turbulent disk

Authors: Shigeru Ida, Tristan Guillot, Ryuki Hyodo, Satoshi Okuzumi, Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: Context: The formation of rocky planetesimals is a long-standing problem in planet formation theory. One of the possibilities is that it results from gravitational instability as a result of pile-up of small silicate dust particles released from sublimating icy pebbles that pass the snow line. Aims: We want to understand and quantify the role of the water snow line for the formation of rock-rich a… ▽ More Context: The formation of rocky planetesimals is a long-standing problem in planet formation theory. One of the possibilities is that it results from gravitational instability as a result of pile-up of small silicate dust particles released from sublimating icy pebbles that pass the snow line. Aims: We want to understand and quantify the role of the water snow line for the formation of rock-rich and ice-rich planetesimals. In this paper, we focus on the formation of rock-rich planetesimals. A companion paper examines the combined formation of both rock-rich and ice-rich planetesimals. Methods: We develop a new Monte Carlo code to calculate the radial evolution of silicate particles in a turbulent accretion disk, accounting for the back-reaction (i.e., inertia) of the particles on their radial drift velocity and diffusion. Results depend in particular on the particle injection width (determined from the radial sublimation width of icy pebbles), the pebble scale height and the pebble mass flux through the disk. The scale height evolution of the silicate particles, which is the most important factor for the runaway pile-up, is automatically calculated in this Lagrange method. Results: From the numerical results, we derive semi-analytical relations for the scale height of the silicate dust particles and the particles-to-gas density ratio at the midplane, as functions of a pebble-to-gas mass flux ratio and the $α$ parameters for disk gas accretion and vertical/radial diffusion. We find that the runaway pile-up of the silicate particles (formation of rocky planetesimals) occurs if the pebble-to-gas mass flux ratio is $> [(α_{Dz}/α_{acc})/3 \times 10^{-2}]^{1/2}$ where $α_{Dz}$ and $α_{acc}$ are the $α$ parameters for vertical turbulent diffusion and disk gas accretion. △ Less

Submitted 26 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: 15 pages, accepted for publication in Astronomy & Astrophysics

Binary Planetesimal Formation from Gravitationally Collapsing Pebble Clouds

Authors: David Nesvorny, Rixin Li, Jacob B. Simon, Andrew N. Youdin, Derek C. Richardson, Raphael Marschall, William M. Grundy

Abstract: Planetesimals are compact astrophysical objects roughly 1-1000 km in size, massive enough to be held together by gravity. They can grow by accreting material to become full-size planets. Planetesimals themselves are thought to form by complex physical processes from small grains in protoplanetary disks. The streaming instability (SI) model states that mm/cm-size particles (pebbles) are aerodynamic… ▽ More Planetesimals are compact astrophysical objects roughly 1-1000 km in size, massive enough to be held together by gravity. They can grow by accreting material to become full-size planets. Planetesimals themselves are thought to form by complex physical processes from small grains in protoplanetary disks. The streaming instability (SI) model states that mm/cm-size particles (pebbles) are aerodynamically collected into self-gravitating clouds which then directly collapse into planetesimals. Here we analyze ATHENA simulations of the SI to characterize the initial properties (e.g., rotation) of pebble clouds. Their gravitational collapse is followed with the PKDGRAV N-body code, which has been modified to realistically account for pebble collisions. We find that pebble clouds rapidly collapse into short-lived disk structures from which planetesimals form. The planetesimal properties depend on the cloud's scaled angular momentum, l=L/(M R_H^2 Omega, where L and M are the angular momentum and mass, R_H is the Hill radius, and Omega is the orbital frequency. Low-l pebble clouds produce tight (or contact) binaries and single planetesimals. Compact high-l clouds give birth to binary planetesimals with attributes that closely resemble the equal-size binaries found in the Kuiper belt. Significantly, the SI-triggered gravitational collapse can explain the angular momentum distribution of known equal-size binaries -- a result pending verification from studies with improved resolution. About 10% of collapse simulations produce hierarchical systems with two or more large moons. These systems should be found in the Kuiper belt when observations reach the threshold sensitivity. △ Less

Submitted 13 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: Planetary Space Journal

Superparticle Method for Simulating Collisions

Authors: David Nesvorny, Andrew N. Youdin, Raphael Marschall, Derek C. Richardson

Abstract: For problems in astrophysics, planetary science and beyond, numerical simulations are often limited to simulating fewer particles than in the real system. To model collisions, the simulated particles (aka superparticles) need to be inflated to represent a collectively large collisional cross section of real particles. Here we develop a superparticle-based method that replicates the kinetic energy… ▽ More For problems in astrophysics, planetary science and beyond, numerical simulations are often limited to simulating fewer particles than in the real system. To model collisions, the simulated particles (aka superparticles) need to be inflated to represent a collectively large collisional cross section of real particles. Here we develop a superparticle-based method that replicates the kinetic energy loss during real-world collisions, implement it in an $N$-body code and test it. The tests provide interesting insights into dynamics of self gravitating collisional systems. They show how particle systems evolve over several free fall timescales to form central concentrations and equilibrated outer shells. The superparticle method can be extended to account for the accretional growth of objects during inelastic mergers. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: accepted in ApJ

Dust Settling Instability in Protoplanetary Discs

Authors: Leonardo Krapp, Andrew N. Youdin, Kaitlin M. Kratter, Pablo Benítez-Llambay

Abstract: The streaming instability (SI) has been extensively studied in the linear and non-linear regimes as a mechanism to concentrate solids and trigger planetesimal formation in the midplane of protoplanetary discs. A related dust settling instability (DSI) applies to particles while settling towards the midplane. The DSI has previously been studied in the linear regime, with predictions that it could t… ▽ More The streaming instability (SI) has been extensively studied in the linear and non-linear regimes as a mechanism to concentrate solids and trigger planetesimal formation in the midplane of protoplanetary discs. A related dust settling instability (DSI) applies to particles while settling towards the midplane. The DSI has previously been studied in the linear regime, with predictions that it could trigger particle clum** away from the midplane. This work presents a range of linear calculations and non-linear simulations, performed with FARGO3D, to assess conditions for DSI growth. We expand on previous linear analyses by including particle size distributions and performing a detailed study of the amount of background turbulence needed to stabilize the DSI. When including binned size distributions, the DSI often produces converged growth rates with fewer bins than the standard SI. With background turbulence, we find that the most favorable conditions for DSI growth are weak turbulence, characterized by $α\lesssim 10^{-6}$ with intermediate-sized grains that settle from one gas scale-height. These conditions could arise during a sudden decrease in disc turbulence following an accretion outburst. Ignoring background turbulence, we performed a parameter survey of local 2D DSI simulations. Particle clum** was either weak or occurred slower than particles settle. Clum** was reduced by a factor of two in a comparison 3D simulation. Overall, our results strongly disfavor the hypothesis that the DSI significantly promotes planetesimal formation. Non-linear simulations of the DSI with different numerical methods could support or challenge these findings. △ Less

Submitted 15 September, 2020; v1 submitted 9 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Evolution of MU69 from a binary planetesimal into contact by Kozai-Lidov oscillations and nebular drag

Authors: Wladimir Lyra, Andrew N. Youdin, Anders Johansen

Abstract: The New Horizons flyby of the cold classical Kuiper Belt object MU69 showed it to be a contact binary. The existence of other contact binaries in the 1-10km range raises the question of how common these bodies are and how they evolved into contact. Here we consider that the lobes of MU69 formed as a binary in the Solar nebula, and calculate its orbital evolution in the presence of gas. We find tha… ▽ More The New Horizons flyby of the cold classical Kuiper Belt object MU69 showed it to be a contact binary. The existence of other contact binaries in the 1-10km range raises the question of how common these bodies are and how they evolved into contact. Here we consider that the lobes of MU69 formed as a binary in the Solar nebula, and calculate its orbital evolution in the presence of gas. We find that the sub-Keplerian wind of the disk brings the drag timescales for 10km bodies under 1 Myr for quadratic-velocity drag. In the Kuiper belt, however, the drag is linear with velocity and the effect of the wind cancels out as the angular momentum gained in half an orbit is lost in the other half: the drag timescales for 10 km bodies remain over 10 Myr. In this situation we find that a combination of drag and Kozai-Lidov oscillations is a promising channel for collapse. We analytically solve the hierarchical three-body problem with drag and implement it into a Kozai plus tidal friction model. The permanent quadrupoles of the lobes make the Kozai oscillations stochastic, and as drag shrinks the semimajor axis it more easily allows the fluctuations to bring the system into contact. Evolution to contact happens very rapidly (within $10^4$ yr) in the pure, double-average quadrupole, Kozai region between $\approx 85-95^\circ$, and within 3 Myr in the drag-assisted region beyond it. The synergy between $J_2$ and gas drag widens the window of contact to 80-100$^\circ$ initial inclination, over a larger range of semimajor axes. As such, the model predicts an initial contact binary fraction of about 10\% for the cold classicals in the Kuiper belt. The speed at contact deviates from the escape velocity only because of the oblateness. For MU69, the contact velocity should be 3.3-4.2 m/s, in line with the observational evidence from the lack of deformation features and estimate of the tensile strength. △ Less

Submitted 26 November, 2020; v1 submitted 2 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Comments: 13 pages (main article) + 15 pg appendix; 14 figures. Accepted by Icarus. To appear in Icarus' special issue on Arrokoth. Proof published online on May 22nd, 2020, at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S001910352030213X?via%3Dihub

Turbulence Regulates the Rate of Planetesimal Formation via Gravitational Collapse

Authors: Daniel A. Gole, Jacob B. Simon, Rixin Li, Andrew N. Youdin, Philip J. Armitage

Abstract: We study how the interaction between the streaming instability and intrinsic gas-phase turbulence affects planetesimal formation via gravitational collapse in protoplanetary disks. Turbulence impedes the formation of particle clumps by acting as an effective turbulent diffusivity, but it can also promote planetesimal formation by concentrating solids, for example in zonal flows. We quantify the ef… ▽ More We study how the interaction between the streaming instability and intrinsic gas-phase turbulence affects planetesimal formation via gravitational collapse in protoplanetary disks. Turbulence impedes the formation of particle clumps by acting as an effective turbulent diffusivity, but it can also promote planetesimal formation by concentrating solids, for example in zonal flows. We quantify the effect of turbulent diffusivity using numerical simulations of the streaming instability in small local domains, forced with velocity perturbations that establish approximately Kolmogorov-like turbulence. We find that planetesimal formation is suppressed by turbulence once velocity fluctuations exceed $\langle δv^2 \rangle \simeq 10^{-3.5} - 10^{-3} c_s^2$. Turbulence whose strength is just below the threshold reduces the rate at which solids are bound into clumps. Our results suggest that the well-established turbulent thickening of the mid-plane solid layer is the primary mechanism by which turbulence influences planetesimal formation and that planetesimal formation requires a mid-plane solid-to-gas ratio $ε\gtrsim 0.5$. We also quantify the initial planetesimal mass function using a new clump-tracking method to determine each planetesimal mass shortly after collapse. For models in which planetesimals form, we show that the mass function is well-described by a broken power law, whose parameters are robust to the inclusion and strength of imposed turbulence. Turbulence in protoplanetary disks is likely to substantially exceed the threshold for planetesimal formation at radii where temperatures $T \gtrsim 10^3 \ {\rm K}$ lead to thermal ionization. Planetesimal formation may therefore be unviable in the inner disk out to 2-3 times the dust sublimation radius. △ Less

Submitted 21 October, 2020; v1 submitted 27 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Comments: Accepted to ApJ after revisions

Astro2020 APC White Paper: Theoretical Astrophysics 2020-2030

Authors: Juna A. Kollmeier, Lauren Anderson, Andrew Benson, Tamara Bogdanovic, Michael Boylan-Kolchin, James S. Bullock, Romeel Dave, Federico Fraschetti, Jim Fuller, Philip F. Hopkins, Manoj Kaplinghat, Kaitlin Kratter, Astrid Lamberts, M. Coleman Miller, James E. Owen, E. Sterl Phinney, Anthony L. Piro, Hans-Walter Rix, Brant Robertson, Andrew Wetzel, Coral Wheeler, Andrew N. Youdin, Matias Zaldarriaga

Abstract: The past two decades have seen a tremendous investment in observational facilities that promise to reveal new and unprecedented discoveries about the universe. In comparison, the investment in theoretical work is completely dwarfed, even though theory plays a crucial role in the interpretation of these observations, predicting new types of phenomena, and informing observing strategies. In this whi… ▽ More The past two decades have seen a tremendous investment in observational facilities that promise to reveal new and unprecedented discoveries about the universe. In comparison, the investment in theoretical work is completely dwarfed, even though theory plays a crucial role in the interpretation of these observations, predicting new types of phenomena, and informing observing strategies. In this white paper, we argue that in order to reach the promised critical breakthroughs in astrophysics over the next decade and well beyond, the national agencies must take a serious approach to investment in theoretical astrophysics research. We discuss the role of theory in sha** our understanding of the universe, and then we provide a multi-level strategy, from the grassroots to the national, to address the current underinvestment in theory relative to observational work. △ Less

Submitted 18 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: 7 pages, Submitted to the Astro2020 call for APC white papers

Trans-Neptunian Binaries as Evidence for Planetesimal Formation by the Streaming Instability

Authors: David Nesvorny, Rixin Li, Andrew N. Youdin, Jacob B. Simon, William M. Grundy

Abstract: A critical step toward the emergence of planets in a protoplanetary disk consists in accretion of planetesimals, bodies 1-1000 km in size, from smaller disk constituents. This process is poorly understood partly because we lack good observational constraints on the complex physical processes that contribute to planetesimal formation. In the outer solar system, the best place to look for clues is t… ▽ More A critical step toward the emergence of planets in a protoplanetary disk consists in accretion of planetesimals, bodies 1-1000 km in size, from smaller disk constituents. This process is poorly understood partly because we lack good observational constraints on the complex physical processes that contribute to planetesimal formation. In the outer solar system, the best place to look for clues is the Kuiper belt, where icy planetesimals survived to this day. Here we report evidence that Kuiper belt planetesimals formed by the streaming instability, a process in which aerodynamically concentrated clumps of pebbles gravitationally collapse into 100-km-class bodies. Gravitational collapse was previously suggested to explain the ubiquity of equal-size binaries in the Kuiper belt. We analyze new hydrodynamical simulations of the streaming instability to determine the model expectations for the spatial orientation of binary orbits. The predicted broad inclination distribution with 80% of prograde binary orbits matches the observations of trans-Neptunian binaries. The formation models which imply predominantly retrograde binary orbits can be ruled out. Given its applicability over a broad range of protoplanetary disk conditions, it is expected that the streaming instability seeded planetesimal formation also elsewhere in the solar system, and beyond. △ Less

Submitted 26 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: Nature Astronomy

Demographics of Planetesimals Formed by the Streaming Instability

Authors: Rixin Li, Andrew Youdin, Jacob Simon

Abstract: The streaming instability (SI) is a mechanism to aerodynamically concentrate solids in protoplanetary disks and facilitate the formation of planetesimals. Recent numerical modeling efforts have demonstrated the increasing complexity of the initial mass distribution of planetesimals. To better constrain this distribution, we conduct SI simulations including the self-gravity with hitherto the highes… ▽ More The streaming instability (SI) is a mechanism to aerodynamically concentrate solids in protoplanetary disks and facilitate the formation of planetesimals. Recent numerical modeling efforts have demonstrated the increasing complexity of the initial mass distribution of planetesimals. To better constrain this distribution, we conduct SI simulations including the self-gravity with hitherto the highest resolution. To subsequently identify all of the self-bound clumps, we develop a new clump-finding tool, PLanetesimal ANalyzer (\texttt{PLAN}). We then apply a maximum likelihood estimator to fit a suite of parameterized models with different levels of complexity to the simulated mass distribution. To determine which models are best-fitting and statistically robust, we apply three model selection criteria with different complexity penalties. We find that the initial mass distribution of clumps is not universal regarding both the functional forms and parameter values. Our model selection criteria prefer models different from those previously considered in the literature. Fits to multi-segment power law models break to a steeper distribution above masses close to 100 km collapsed planetesimals, similar to observed Kuiper Belt size distributions. We find evidence for a turnover in the low mass end of the planetesimal mass distribution in our high resolution run. Such a turnover is expected for gravitational collapse, but had not previously been reported. △ Less

Submitted 7 April, 2020; v1 submitted 21 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: accepted and published in ApJ (a typo in Table 6 (last column for VTPL) is fixed in this version (v4))

The Mass and Size Distribution of Planetesimals Formed by the Streaming Instability. II. The Effect of the Radial Gas Pressure Gradient

Authors: Charles P. Abod, Jacob B. Simon, Rixin Li, Philip J. Armitage, Andrew N. Youdin, Katherine A. Kretke

Abstract: The streaming instability concentrates solid particles in protoplanetary disks, leading to gravitational collapse into planetesimals. Despite its key role in producing particle clum** and determining critical length scales in the instability's linear regime, the influence of the disk's radial pressure gradient on planetesimal properties has not been examined in detail. Here, we use streaming ins… ▽ More The streaming instability concentrates solid particles in protoplanetary disks, leading to gravitational collapse into planetesimals. Despite its key role in producing particle clum** and determining critical length scales in the instability's linear regime, the influence of the disk's radial pressure gradient on planetesimal properties has not been examined in detail. Here, we use streaming instability simulations that include particle self-gravity to study how the planetesimal initial mass function depends on the radial pressure gradient. Fitting our results to a power-law, ${\rm d}N / {\rm d}M_p \propto M_p^{-p}$, we find a single value $p \approx 1.6$ describes simulations in which the pressure gradient varies by $\gtrsim 2$. An exponentially truncated power-law provides a significantly better fit, with a low mass slope of $p^\prime \approx 1.3$ that weakly depends on the pressure gradient. The characteristic truncation mass is found to be $\sim M_G = 4 π^5 G^2 Σ_p^3 / Ω^4$. We exclude the cubic dependence of the characteristic mass with pressure gradient suggested by linear considerations, finding instead a linear scaling. These results strengthen the case for a streaming-derived initial mass function that depends at most weakly on the aerodynamic properties of the disk and participating solids. A simulation initialized with zero pressure gradient---which is {\em not} subject to the streaming instability---also yields a top-heavy mass function but with modest evidence for a different shape. We discuss the consistency of the theoretically predicted mass function with observations of Kuiper Belt planetesimals, and describe implications for models of early stage planet formation.. △ Less

Submitted 29 August, 2019; v1 submitted 23 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 18 pages, 10 figures, 3 tables, accepted to ApJ

Homogeneous Analysis of the Dust Morphology of Transition Disks Observed with ALMA: Investigating dust trap** and the origin of the cavities

Authors: P. Pinilla, M. Tazzari, I. Pascucci, A. N. Youdin, A. Garufi, C. F. Manara, L. Testi, G. van der Plas, S. A. Barenfeld, H. Canovas, E. G. Cox, N. P. Hendler, L. M. Pérez, N. van der Marel

Abstract: We analyze the dust morphology of 29 transition disks (TDs) observed with ALMA at (sub-) millimeter-emission. We perform the analysis in the visibility plane to characterize the total flux, cavity size, and shape of the ring-like structure. First, we found that the $M_{\rm{dust}}-M_\star$ relation is much flatter for TDs than the observed trends from samples of class II sources in different star f… ▽ More We analyze the dust morphology of 29 transition disks (TDs) observed with ALMA at (sub-) millimeter-emission. We perform the analysis in the visibility plane to characterize the total flux, cavity size, and shape of the ring-like structure. First, we found that the $M_{\rm{dust}}-M_\star$ relation is much flatter for TDs than the observed trends from samples of class II sources in different star forming regions. This relation demonstrates that cavities open in high (dust) mass disks, independent of the stellar mass. The flatness of this relation contradicts the idea that TDs are a more evolved set of disks. Two potential reasons (not mutually exclusive) may explain this flat relation: the emission is optically thick or/and millimeter-sized particles are trapped in a pressure bump. Second, we discuss our results of the cavity size and ring width in the context of different physical processes for cavity formation. Photoevaporation is an unlikely leading mechanism for the origin of the cavity of any of the targets in the sample. Embedded giant planets or dead zones remain as potential explanations. Although both models predict correlations between the cavity size and the ring shape for different stellar and disk properties, we demonstrate that with the current resolution of the observations, it is difficult to obtain these correlations. Future observations with higher angular resolution observations of TDs with ALMA will help to discern between different potential origins of cavities in TDs. △ Less

Submitted 4 May, 2018; v1 submitted 19 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Comments: Minor changes after language edition. Accepted for publication in ApJ

A comprehensive understanding of planet formation is required for assessing planetary habitability and for the search for life

Authors: Dániel Apai, Fred Ciesla, Gijs D. Mulders, Ilaria Pascucci, Richard Barry, Klaus Pontoppidan, Edwin Bergin, Alex Bixel, Sean Brittain, Shawn D. Domagal-Goldman, Yasuhiro Hasegawa, Hannah Jang-Condell, Renu Malhotra, Michael R. Meyer, Andrew Youdin, Johanna Teske, Neal Turner

Abstract: Dozens of habitable zone, approximately earth-sized exoplanets are known today. An emerging frontier of exoplanet studies is identifying which of these habitable zone, small planets are actually habitable (have all necessary conditions for life) and, of those, which are earth-like. Many parameters and processes influence habitability, ranging from the orbit through detailed composition including v… ▽ More Dozens of habitable zone, approximately earth-sized exoplanets are known today. An emerging frontier of exoplanet studies is identifying which of these habitable zone, small planets are actually habitable (have all necessary conditions for life) and, of those, which are earth-like. Many parameters and processes influence habitability, ranging from the orbit through detailed composition including volatiles and organics, to the presence of geological activity and plate tectonics. While some properties will soon be directly observable, others cannot be probed by remote sensing for the foreseeable future. Thus, statistical understanding of planetary systems' formation and evolution is a key supplement to the direct measurements of planet properties. Probabilistically assessing parameters we cannot directly measure is essential to reliably assess habitability, to prioritizing habitable-zone planets for follow-up, and for interpreting possible biosignatures. △ Less

Submitted 23 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: White paper submitted to the NAS Committee on Exoplanet Science Strategy

Witnessing Planetary Systems in the Making with the Next Generation Very Large Array

Authors: Luca Ricci, Andrea Isella, Sean M. Andrews, Tilman Birnstiel, Jeffrey N. Cuzzi, Gennaro D'Angelo, Ruobing Dong, Anne Dutrey, Barbara Ercolano, Paul R. Estrada, Mario Flock, Hui Li, Shang-Fei Liu, Wladimir Lyra, Karin Oberg, Satoshi Okuzumi, Laura Perez, Neal Turner, Nienke van der Marel, David Wilner, Andrew N. Youdin, Zhaohuan Zhu

Abstract: The discovery of thousands of exoplanets over the last couple of decades has shown that the birth of planets is a very efficient process in nature. Theories invoke a multitude of mechanisms to describe the assembly of planets in the disks around pre-main-sequence stars, but observational constraints have been sparse on account of insufficient sensitivity and resolution. Understanding how planets f… ▽ More The discovery of thousands of exoplanets over the last couple of decades has shown that the birth of planets is a very efficient process in nature. Theories invoke a multitude of mechanisms to describe the assembly of planets in the disks around pre-main-sequence stars, but observational constraints have been sparse on account of insufficient sensitivity and resolution. Understanding how planets form and interact with their parental disk is crucial also to illuminate the main characteristics of a large portion of the full population of planets that is inaccessible to current and near-future observations. This White Paper describes some of the main issues for our current understanding of the formation and evolution of planets, and the critical contribution expected in this field by the Next Generation Very Large Array. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: 6 pages, 3 figures, White Paper submitted to the National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine's Exoplanet Science Strategy Call for Papers

On the Numerical Robustness of the Streaming Instability: Particle Concentration and Gas Dynamics in Protoplanetary Disks

Authors: Rixin Li, Andrew N. Youdin, Jacob B. Simon

Abstract: The Streaming Instability (SI) is a mechanism to concentrate solids in protoplanetary disks. Nonlinear particle clum** from the SI can trigger gravitational collapse into planetesimals. To better understand the numerical robustness of the SI, we perform a suite of vertically-stratified 3D simulations with fixed physical parameters known to produce strong clum**. We vary the numerical implement… ▽ More The Streaming Instability (SI) is a mechanism to concentrate solids in protoplanetary disks. Nonlinear particle clum** from the SI can trigger gravitational collapse into planetesimals. To better understand the numerical robustness of the SI, we perform a suite of vertically-stratified 3D simulations with fixed physical parameters known to produce strong clum**. We vary the numerical implementation, namely the computational domain size and the vertical boundary conditions (vBCs), comparing newly-implemented outflow vBCs to the previously-used periodic and reflecting vBCs. We find strong particle clum** by the SI is mostly independent of the vBCs. However, peak particle densities are higher in larger simulation domains due to a larger particle mass reservoir. We report SI-triggered zonal flows, i.e., azimuthally-banded radial variations of gas pressure. These structures have low amplitudes, insufficient to halt particle radial drift, confirming that particle trap** in gas pressure maxima is not the mechanism of the SI. We find that outflow vBCs produce artificially large gas outflow rates at vertical boundaries. However, the outflow vBCs reduce artificial reflections at vertical boundaries, allowing more particle sedimentation, and showing less temporal variation and better convergence with box size. The radial spacing of dense particle filaments is $\sim0.15$ gas scale heights ($H$) for all vBCs, which sets the feeding zone for planetesimal growth in self-gravitating simulations. Our results validate the use of the outflow vBCs in SI simulations, even with vertical boundaries close ($\leq 0.4H$) to the disk midplane. Overall, our study demonstrates the numerical robustness of nonlinear particle clum** by the SI. △ Less

Submitted 12 June, 2018; v1 submitted 9 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: 20 pages, 14 figures, accepted for publication in the ApJ

Inside-Out Planet Formation. IV. Pebble Evolution and Planet Formation Timescales

Authors: Xiao Hu, Jonathan C. Tan, Zhaohuan Zhu, Sourav Chatterjee, Tilman Birnstiel, Andrew N. Youdin, Subhanjoy Mohanty

Abstract: Systems with tightly-packed inner planets (STIPs) are very common. Chatterjee & Tan proposed Inside-Out Planet Formation (IOPF), an in situ formation theory, to explain these planets. IOPF involves sequential planet formation from pebble-rich rings that are fed from the outer disk and trapped at the pressure maximum associated with the dead zone inner boundary (DZIB). Planet masses are set by thei… ▽ More Systems with tightly-packed inner planets (STIPs) are very common. Chatterjee & Tan proposed Inside-Out Planet Formation (IOPF), an in situ formation theory, to explain these planets. IOPF involves sequential planet formation from pebble-rich rings that are fed from the outer disk and trapped at the pressure maximum associated with the dead zone inner boundary (DZIB). Planet masses are set by their ability to open a gap and cause the DZIB to retreat outwards. We present models for the disk density and temperature structures that are relevant to the conditions of IOPF. For a wide range of DZIB conditions, we evaluate the gap opening masses of planets in these disks that are expected to lead to truncation of pebble accretion onto the forming planet. We then consider the evolution of dust and pebbles in the disk, estimating that pebbles typically grow to sizes of a few cm during their radial drift from several tens of AU to the inner, $\lesssim1\:$AU-scale disk. A large fraction of the accretion flux of solids is expected to be in such pebbles. This allows us to estimate the timescales for individual planet formation and entire planetary system formation in the IOPF scenario. We find that to produce realistic STIPs within reasonable timescales similar to disk lifetimes requires disk accretion rates of $\sim10^{-9}\:M_\odot\:{\rm yr}^{-1}$ and relatively low viscosity conditions in the DZIB region, i.e., Shakura-Sunyaev parameter of $α\sim10^{-4}$. △ Less

Submitted 18 February, 2018; v1 submitted 28 September, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

Comments: 20 pages, 13 figures, accepted by ApJ, comments welcome

A thermodynamic view of dusty protoplanetary disks

Authors: Min-Kai Lin, Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: Small solids embedded in gaseous protoplanetary disks are subject to strong dust-gas friction. Consequently, tightly-coupled dust particles almost follow the gas flow. This near conservation of dust-to-gas ratio along streamlines is analogous to the near conservation of entropy along flows of (dust-free) gas with weak heating and cooling. We develop this thermodynamic analogy into a framework to s… ▽ More Small solids embedded in gaseous protoplanetary disks are subject to strong dust-gas friction. Consequently, tightly-coupled dust particles almost follow the gas flow. This near conservation of dust-to-gas ratio along streamlines is analogous to the near conservation of entropy along flows of (dust-free) gas with weak heating and cooling. We develop this thermodynamic analogy into a framework to study dusty gas dynamics in protoplanetary disks. We show that an isothermal dusty gas behaves like an adiabatic pure gas; and that finite dust-gas coupling may be regarded as an effective heating/cooling. We exploit this correspondence to deduce that 1) perfectly coupled, thin dust layers cannot cause axisymmetric instabilities; 2) radial dust edges are unstable if the dust is vertically well-mixed; 3) the streaming instability necessarily involves a gas pressure response that lags behind dust density; 4) dust-loading introduces buoyancy forces that generally stabilizes the vertical shear instability associated with global radial temperature gradients. We also discuss dusty analogs of other hydrodynamic processes (e.g. Rossby wave instability, convective overstability, and zombie vortices), and how to simulate dusty protoplanetary disks with minor tweaks to existing codes for pure gas dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 10 October, 2017; v1 submitted 9 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: accepted by ApJ, extended discussions

Structure and Evolution of Internally Heated Hot Jupiters

Authors: Thaddeus D. Komacek, Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: Hot Jupiters receive strong stellar irradiation, producing equilibrium temperatures of $1000 - 2500 \ \mathrm{Kelvin}$. Incoming irradiation directly heats just their thin outer layer, down to pressures of $\sim 0.1 \ \mathrm{bars}$. In standard irradiated evolution models of hot Jupiters, predicted transit radii are too small. Previous studies have shown that deeper heating -- at a small fraction… ▽ More Hot Jupiters receive strong stellar irradiation, producing equilibrium temperatures of $1000 - 2500 \ \mathrm{Kelvin}$. Incoming irradiation directly heats just their thin outer layer, down to pressures of $\sim 0.1 \ \mathrm{bars}$. In standard irradiated evolution models of hot Jupiters, predicted transit radii are too small. Previous studies have shown that deeper heating -- at a small fraction of the heating rate from irradiation -- can explain observed radii. Here we present a suite of evolution models for HD 209458b where we systematically vary both the depth and intensity of internal heating, without specifying the uncertain heating mechanism(s). Our models start with a hot, high entropy planet whose radius decreases as the convective interior cools. The applied heating suppresses this cooling. We find that very shallow heating -- at pressures of $1 - 10 \ \mathrm{bars}$ -- does not significantly suppress cooling, unless the total heating rate is $\gtrsim 10\%$ of the incident stellar power. Deeper heating, at $100 \ \mathrm{bars}$, requires heating at only $1\%$ of the stellar irradiation to explain the observed transit radius of $1.4 R_{\rm Jup}$ after 5 Gyr of cooling. In general, more intense and deeper heating results in larger hot Jupiter radii. Surprisingly, we find that heat deposited at $10^4 \ \mathrm{bars}$ -- which is exterior to $\approx 99\%$ of the planet's mass -- suppresses planetary cooling as effectively as heating at the center. In summary, we find that relatively shallow heating is required to explain the radii of most hot Jupiters, provided that this heat is applied early and persists throughout their evolution. △ Less

Submitted 23 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: Accepted at ApJ, 14 pages, 10 figures

Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal, 844:94, 2017 August 1

Evidence for universality in the initial planetesimal mass function

Authors: Jacob B. Simon, Philip J. Armitage, Andrew N. Youdin, Rixin Li

Abstract: Planetesimals may form from the gravitational collapse of dense particle clumps initiated by the streaming instability. We use simulations of aerodynamically coupled gas-particle mixtures to investigate whether the properties of planetesimals formed in this way depend upon the sizes of the particles that participate in the instability. Based on three high resolution simulations that span a range o… ▽ More Planetesimals may form from the gravitational collapse of dense particle clumps initiated by the streaming instability. We use simulations of aerodynamically coupled gas-particle mixtures to investigate whether the properties of planetesimals formed in this way depend upon the sizes of the particles that participate in the instability. Based on three high resolution simulations that span a range of dimensionless stop** time $6 \times 10^{-3} \leq τ\leq 2$ no statistically significant differences in the initial planetesimal mass function are found. The mass functions are fit by a power-law, ${\rm d}N / {\rm d}M_p \propto M_p^{-p}$, with $p=1.5-1.7$ and errors of $Δp \approx 0.1$. Comparing the particle density fields prior to collapse, we find that the high wavenumber power spectra are similarly indistinguishable, though the large-scale geometry of structures induced via the streaming instability is significantly different between all three cases. We interpret the results as evidence for a near-universal slope to the mass function, arising from the small-scale structure of streaming-induced turbulence. △ Less

Submitted 13 September, 2017; v1 submitted 10 May, 2017; originally announced May 2017.

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures, accepted to ApJ Letters after minor modifications, including two new figures and some new text that better clarify our results

The Role of Non-ionizing Radiation Pressure in Star Formation: The Stability of Cores and Filaments

Authors: Young Min Seo, Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: Stars form when filaments and dense cores in molecular clouds fragment and collapse due to self-gravity. In the most basic analyses of gravitational stability, the competition between self-gravity and thermal pressure sets the critical (i.e. maximum stable) mass of spheres and the critical line density of cylinders. Previous work has considered additional support from magnetic fields and turbulenc… ▽ More Stars form when filaments and dense cores in molecular clouds fragment and collapse due to self-gravity. In the most basic analyses of gravitational stability, the competition between self-gravity and thermal pressure sets the critical (i.e. maximum stable) mass of spheres and the critical line density of cylinders. Previous work has considered additional support from magnetic fields and turbulence. Here, we consider the effects of non-ionizing radiation, specifically the inward radiation pressure force that acts on dense structures embedded in an isotropic radiation field. Using hydrostatic, isothermal models, we find that irradiation lowers the critical mass and line density for gravitational collapse, and can thus act as a trigger for star formation. For structures with moderate central densities, $\sim10^3$ cm$^{-3}$, the interstellar radiation field in the Solar vicinity has an order unity effect on stability thresholds. For more evolved objects with higher central densities, a significant lowering of stability thresholds requires stronger irradiation, as can be found closer to the Galactic center or near stellar associations. Even when strong sources of ionizing radiation are absent or extincted, our study shows that interstellar irradiation can significantly influence the star formation process. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2016; originally announced June 2016.

Comments: 13pages, 10 figures, accepted to MNRAS

Vertical shear instability in the solar nebula

Authors: Min-Kai Lin, Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: We quantify the thermodynamic requirement for the Vertical Shear Instability and evaluate its relevance to realistic protoplanetary disks as a potential route to hydrodynamic turbulence. We quantify the thermodynamic requirement for the Vertical Shear Instability and evaluate its relevance to realistic protoplanetary disks as a potential route to hydrodynamic turbulence. △ Less

Submitted 4 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

Comments: IAUS 314 proceedings, main paper arXiv:1505.02163

Planetesimals in Debris Disks

Authors: Andrew N. Youdin, George H. Rieke

Abstract: Planetesimals form in gas-rich protoplanetary disks around young stars. However, protoplanetary disks fade in about 10 Myr. The planetesimals (and also many of the planets) left behind are too dim to study directly. Fortunately, collisions between planetesimals produce dusty debris disks. These debris disks trace the processes of terrestrial planet formation for 100 Myr and of exoplanetary system… ▽ More Planetesimals form in gas-rich protoplanetary disks around young stars. However, protoplanetary disks fade in about 10 Myr. The planetesimals (and also many of the planets) left behind are too dim to study directly. Fortunately, collisions between planetesimals produce dusty debris disks. These debris disks trace the processes of terrestrial planet formation for 100 Myr and of exoplanetary system evolution out to 10 Gyr. This chapter begins with a summary of planetesimal formation as a prelude to the epoch of planetesimal destruction. Our review of debris disks covers the key issues, including dust production and dynamics, needed to understand the observations. Our discussion of extrasolar debris keeps an eye on similarities to and differences from Solar System dust. △ Less

Submitted 15 December, 2015; originally announced December 2015.

Comments: A version of this review chapter (edited and with higher resolution figures) is scheduled to appear in "Planetesimals: Early Differentiation and Consequences for Planets" published by Cambridge University Press and edited by Linda T. Elkins-Tanton and Benjamin P. Weiss. The authors thank the anonymous referees for helpful advice

The Mass and Size Distribution of Planetesimals Formed by the Streaming Instability. I. The Role of Self-Gravity

Authors: Jacob B. Simon, Philip J. Armitage, Rixin Li, Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: We study the formation of planetesimals in protoplanetary disks from the gravitational collapse of solid over-densities generated via the streaming instability. To carry out these studies, we implement and test a particle-mesh self-gravity module for the Athena code that enables the simulation of aerodynamically coupled systems of gas and collisionless self-gravitating solid particles. Upon employ… ▽ More We study the formation of planetesimals in protoplanetary disks from the gravitational collapse of solid over-densities generated via the streaming instability. To carry out these studies, we implement and test a particle-mesh self-gravity module for the Athena code that enables the simulation of aerodynamically coupled systems of gas and collisionless self-gravitating solid particles. Upon employment of our algorithm to planetesimal formation simulations, we find that (when a direct comparison is possible) the Athena simulations yield predicted planetesimal properties that agree well with those found in prior work using different numerical techniques. In particular, the gravitational collapse of streaming-initiated clumps leads to an initial planetesimal mass function that is well-represented by a power-law, dN/dM ~ M^{-p}, with p = 1.6 +/- 0.1, which equates to a differential size distribution dN/dR ~ R^{-q}, with q = 2.8 +/- 0.1. We find no significant trends with resolution from a convergence study of up to 512^3 grid zones and Npar = 1.5x10^8 particles. Likewise, the power-law slope appears indifferent to changes in the relative strength of self-gravity and tidal shear, and to the time when (for reasons of numerical economy) self-gravity is turned on, though the strength of these claims is limited by small number statistics. For a typically assumed radial distribution of minimum mass solar nebula solids (assumed here to have dimensionless stop** time τ= 0.3), our results support the hypothesis that bodies on the scale of large asteroids or Kuiper Belt Objects could have formed as the high-mass tail of a primordial planetesimal population. △ Less

Submitted 31 March, 2016; v1 submitted 30 November, 2015; originally announced December 2015.

Comments: 18 pages, 16 figures, accepted to ApJ after minor revisions and title change

Cooling Requirements for the Vertical Shear Instability in Protoplanetary Disks

Authors: Min-Kai Lin, Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: The vertical shear instability (VSI) offers a potential hydrodynamic mechanism for angular momentum transport in protoplanetary disks (PPDs). The VSI is driven by a weak vertical gradient in the disk's orbital motion, but must overcome vertical buoyancy, a strongly stabilizing influence in cold disks, where heating is dominated by external irradiation. Rapid radiative cooling reduces the effective… ▽ More The vertical shear instability (VSI) offers a potential hydrodynamic mechanism for angular momentum transport in protoplanetary disks (PPDs). The VSI is driven by a weak vertical gradient in the disk's orbital motion, but must overcome vertical buoyancy, a strongly stabilizing influence in cold disks, where heating is dominated by external irradiation. Rapid radiative cooling reduces the effective buoyancy and allows the VSI to operate. We quantify the cooling timescale $t_c$ needed for efficient VSI growth, through a linear analysis of the VSI with cooling in vertically global, radially local disk models. We find the VSI is most vigorous for rapid cooling with $t_c<Ω_\mathrm{K}^{-1}h|q|/(γ-1)$ in terms of the Keplerian orbital frequency, $Ω_\mathrm{K}$; the disk's aspect-ratio, $h\ll1$; the radial power-law temperature gradient, $q$; and the adiabatic index, $γ$. For longer $t_c$, the VSI is much less effective because growth slows and shifts to smaller length scales, which are more prone to viscous or turbulent decay. We apply our results to PPD models where $t_c$ is determined by the opacity of dust grains. We find that the VSI is most effective at intermediate radii, from $\sim5$AU to $\sim50$AU with a characteristic growth time of $\sim30$ local orbital periods. Growth is suppressed by long cooling times both in the opaque inner disk and the optically thin outer disk. Reducing the dust opacity by a factor of 10 increases cooling times enough to quench the VSI at all disk radii. Thus the formation of solid protoplanets, a sink for dust grains, can impede the VSI. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 2015; v1 submitted 8 May, 2015; originally announced May 2015.

Comments: Accepted by ApJ; minor changes from previous version; a poster is available at http://lavinia.as.arizona.edu/~minkailin/docs/iaus314.pdf

Minimum Core Masses for Giant Planet Formation With Realistic Equations of State and Opacities

Authors: Ana-Maria A. Piso, Andrew N. Youdin, Ruth A. Murray-Clay

Abstract: Giant planet formation by core accretion requires a core that is sufficiently massive to trigger runaway gas accretion in less that the typical lifetime of protoplanetary disks. We explore how the minimum required core mass, M_crit, depends on a non-ideal equation of state and on opacity changes due to grain growth, across a range of stellocentric distances from 5-100 AU. This minimum M_crit appli… ▽ More Giant planet formation by core accretion requires a core that is sufficiently massive to trigger runaway gas accretion in less that the typical lifetime of protoplanetary disks. We explore how the minimum required core mass, M_crit, depends on a non-ideal equation of state and on opacity changes due to grain growth, across a range of stellocentric distances from 5-100 AU. This minimum M_crit applies when planetesimal accretion does not substantially heat the atmosphere. Compared to an ideal gas polytrope, the inclusion of molecular hydrogen (H_2) dissociation and variable occupation of H_2 rotational states increases M_crit. Specifically, M_crit increases by a factor of ~2 if the H_2 spin isomers, ortho- and parahydrogen, are in thermal equilibrium, and by a factor of ~2-4 if the ortho-to-para ratio is fixed at 3:1. Lower opacities due to grain growth reduce M_crit. For a standard disk model around a Solar mass star, we calculate M_crit ~ 8 M_Earth at 5 AU, decreasing to ~5 M_Earth at 100 AU, for a realistic EOS with an equilibrium ortho-to-para ratio and for grain growth to cm-sizes. If grain coagulation is taken into account, M_crit may further reduce by up to one order of magnitude. These results for the minimum critical core mass are useful for the interpretation of surveys that find exoplanets at a range of orbital distances. △ Less

Submitted 16 December, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Comments: 21 pages, 17 figures. Accepted to ApJ

On the Minimum Core Mass for Giant Planet Formation at Wide Separations

Authors: Ana-Maria A. Piso, Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: In the core accretion hypothesis, giant planets form by gas accretion onto solid protoplanetary cores. The minimum (or critical) core mass to form a gas giant is typically quoted as 10 Earth masses. The actual value depends on several factors: the location in the protoplanetary disk, atmospheric opacity, and the accretion rate of solids. Motivated by ongoing direct imaging searches for giant plane… ▽ More In the core accretion hypothesis, giant planets form by gas accretion onto solid protoplanetary cores. The minimum (or critical) core mass to form a gas giant is typically quoted as 10 Earth masses. The actual value depends on several factors: the location in the protoplanetary disk, atmospheric opacity, and the accretion rate of solids. Motivated by ongoing direct imaging searches for giant planets, this study investigates core mass requirements in the outer disk. To determine the fastest allowed rates of gas accretion, we consider solid cores that no longer accrete planetesimals, as this would heat the gaseous envelope. Our spherical, two-layer atmospheric cooling model includes an inner convective region and an outer radiative zone that matches onto the disk. We determine the minimum core mass for a giant planet to form within a typical disk lifetime of 3 Myr. The minimum core mass declines with disk radius, from ~8.5 Earth masses at 5 AU to ~3.5 Earth masses at 100 AU, with standard interstellar grain opacities. Lower temperatures in the outer disk explain this trend, while variations in disk density are less influential. At all distances, a lower dust opacity or higher mean molecular weight reduces the critical core mass. Our non-self-gravitating, analytic cooling model reveals that self-gravity significantly affects early atmospheric evolution, starting when the atmosphere is only ~10% as massive as the core. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2014; v1 submitted 31 October, 2013; originally announced November 2013.

Comments: 18 pages, 10 figures. Accepted to ApJ

M dwarf stars in the light of (future) exoplanet searches

Authors: B. Rojas-Ayala, E. J. Hilton, A. W. Mann, S. Lépine, E. Gaidos, X. Bonfils, Ch. Helling, T. J. Henry, L. A. Rogers, K. von Braun, A. Youdin

Abstract: We present a brief overview of a splinter session on M dwarf stars as planet hosts that was organized as part of the Cool Stars 17 conference. The session was devoted to reviewing our current knowledge of M dwarf stars and exoplanets in order to prepare for current and future exoplanet searches focusing in low mass stars. We review the observational and theoretical challenges to characterize M dwa… ▽ More We present a brief overview of a splinter session on M dwarf stars as planet hosts that was organized as part of the Cool Stars 17 conference. The session was devoted to reviewing our current knowledge of M dwarf stars and exoplanets in order to prepare for current and future exoplanet searches focusing in low mass stars. We review the observational and theoretical challenges to characterize M dwarf stars and the importance of accurate fundamental parameters for the proper characterization of their exoplanets and our understanding on planet formation. △ Less

Submitted 2 November, 2012; originally announced November 2012.

Comments: 4 pages, 1 figure. Summary of the splinter session "M dwarf stars in the light of (future) exoplanet searches" held at the 17th Cambridge Workshop on Cool Stars, Stellar Systems, and the Sun, June 28th 2012, Barcelona, Spain. Submitted for publication in Astronomische Nachrichten - Astronomical Notes (AN) 334, Issue 1-2, Eds Klaus Strassmeier and Mercedes López-Morales

From Disks to Planets

Authors: Andrew N. Youdin, Scott J. Kenyon

Abstract: This pedagogical chapter covers the theory of planet formation, with an emphasis on the physical processes relevant to current research. After summarizing empirical constraints from astronomical and geophysical data, we describe the structure and evolution of protoplanetary disks. We consider the growth of planetesimals and of larger solid protoplanets, followed by the accretion of planetary atmos… ▽ More This pedagogical chapter covers the theory of planet formation, with an emphasis on the physical processes relevant to current research. After summarizing empirical constraints from astronomical and geophysical data, we describe the structure and evolution of protoplanetary disks. We consider the growth of planetesimals and of larger solid protoplanets, followed by the accretion of planetary atmospheres, including the core accretion instability. We also examine the possibility that gas disks fragment directly into giant planets and/or brown dwarfs. We defer a detailed description of planet migration and dynamical evolution to other work, such as the complementary chapter in this series by Morbidelli (available at arXiv:1106.4114). △ Less

Submitted 4 June, 2012; originally announced June 2012.

Comments: 50 pages text plus 11 figures and table of symbols. To be published in "Planets, Stars and Stellar Systems", P. Kalas and L. French (eds.). Comments and suggestions for future revisions welcome

Circumbinary Chaos: Using Pluto's Newest Moon to Constrain the Masses of Nix & Hydra

Authors: Andrew N. Youdin, Kaitlin M. Kratter, Scott J. Kenyon

Abstract: The Pluto system provides a unique local laboratory for the study of binaries with multiple low mass companions. In this paper, we study the orbital stability of P4, the most recently discovered moon in the Pluto system. This newfound companion orbits near the plane of the Pluto-Charon binary, roughly halfway between the two minor moons Nix and Hydra. We use a suite of few body integrations to con… ▽ More The Pluto system provides a unique local laboratory for the study of binaries with multiple low mass companions. In this paper, we study the orbital stability of P4, the most recently discovered moon in the Pluto system. This newfound companion orbits near the plane of the Pluto-Charon binary, roughly halfway between the two minor moons Nix and Hydra. We use a suite of few body integrations to constrain the masses of Nix and Hydra, and the orbital parameters of P4. For the system to remain stable over the age of the Solar System, the masses of Nix and Hydra likely do not exceed 5e16 kg and 9e16 kg, respectively. These upper limits assume a fixed mass ratio between Nix and Hydra at the value implied by their median optical brightness. Our study finds that stability is more sensitive to their total mass and that a downward revision of Charon's eccentricity (from our adopted value of 0.0035) is unlikely to significantly affect our conclusions. Our upper limits are an order of magnitude below existing astrometric limits on the masses of Nix and Hydra. For a density at least that of ice, the albedos of Nix and Hydra would exceed 0.3. This constraint implies they are icy, as predicted by giant impact models. Even with these low masses, P4 only remains stable if its eccentricity e < 0.02. The 5:1 commensurability with Charon is particularly unstable, Combining stability constraints with the observed mean motion places the preferred orbit for P4 just exterior to the 5:1 resonance. These predictions will be tested when the New Horizons satellite visits Pluto. Based on the results for the Pluto-Charon system, we expect that circumbinary, multi-planet systems will be more widely spaced than their singleton counterparts. Further, circumbinary exoplanets close to the three-body stability boundary, such as those found by Kepler, are less likely to have other companions nearby. △ Less

Submitted 23 May, 2012; originally announced May 2012.

Comments: 12 pages, 7 figures

Adding particle collisions to the formation of asteroids and Kuiper belt objects via streaming instabilities

Authors: Anders Johansen, Andrew Youdin, Yoram Lithwick

Abstract: Modelling the formation of super-km-sized planetesimals by gravitational collapse of regions overdense in small particles requires numerical algorithms capable of handling simultaneously hydrodynamics, particle dynamics and particle collisions. While the initial phases of radial contraction are dictated by drag forces and gravity, particle collisions become gradually more significant as filaments… ▽ More Modelling the formation of super-km-sized planetesimals by gravitational collapse of regions overdense in small particles requires numerical algorithms capable of handling simultaneously hydrodynamics, particle dynamics and particle collisions. While the initial phases of radial contraction are dictated by drag forces and gravity, particle collisions become gradually more significant as filaments contract beyond Roche density. Here we present a new numerical algorithm for treating momentum and energy exchange in collisions between numerical superparticles representing a high number of physical particles. We adopt a Monte Carlo approach where superparticle pairs in a grid cell collide statistically on the physical collision time-scale. Collisions occur by enlarging particles until they touch and solving for the collision outcome, accounting for energy dissipation in inelastic collisions. We demonstrate that superparticle collisions can be consistently implemented at a modest computational cost. In protoplanetary disc turbulence driven by the streaming instability, we argue that the relative Keplerian shear velocity should be subtracted during the collision calculation. If it is not subtracted, density inhomogeneities are too rapidly diffused away, as bloated particles exaggerate collision speeds. Local particle densities reach several thousand times the mid-plane gas density. We find efficient formation of gravitationally bound clumps, with a range of masses corresponding to contracted radii from 100 to 400 km when applied to the asteroid belt and 150 to 730 km when applied to the Kuiper belt, extrapolated using a constant self-gravity parameter. The smaller planetesimals are not observed at low resolution, but the masses of the largest planetesimals are relatively independent of resolution and treatment of collisions. △ Less

Submitted 27 November, 2011; v1 submitted 1 November, 2011; originally announced November 2011.

Comments: Version accepted for publication in A&A

The Exoplanet Census: A General Method, Applied to Kepler

Authors: Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: We develop a general method to fit the planetary distribution function (PLDF) to exoplanet survey data. This maximum likelihood method accommodates more than one planet per star and any number of planet or target star properties. Application to \Kepler data relies on estimates of the efficiency of discovering transits around Solar type stars by Howard et al. (2011). These estimates are shown to ag… ▽ More We develop a general method to fit the planetary distribution function (PLDF) to exoplanet survey data. This maximum likelihood method accommodates more than one planet per star and any number of planet or target star properties. Application to \Kepler data relies on estimates of the efficiency of discovering transits around Solar type stars by Howard et al. (2011). These estimates are shown to agree with theoretical predictions for an ideal transit survey. Using announced \Kepler planet candidates, we fit the PLDF as a joint powerlaw in planet radius, down to 0.5 R_Eart, and orbital period, up to 50 days. The estimated number of planets per star in this sample is ~ 0.7 --- 1.4, where the broad range covers systematic uncertainties in the detection efficiency. To analyze trends in the PLDF we consider four planet samples, divided between shorter and longer periods at 7 days and between large and small radii at 3 R_Earth. At longer periods, the size distribution of the small planets, with index α= -1.2 \pm 0.2 steepens to α= -2.0 \pm 0.2 for the larger planet sample. For shorter periods, the opposite is seen: smaller planets follow a steep powerlaw, α= -1.9 \pm 0.2 that is much shallower, α= -0.7 \pm 0.2 at large radii. The observed deficit of intermediate-sized planets at the shortest periods may arise from the evaporation and sublimation of Neptune and Saturn-like planets. If the trend and explanation hold, it would be spectacular observational confirmation of the core accretion and migration hypotheses, and allow refinement of these theories. △ Less

Submitted 9 May, 2011; originally announced May 2011.

Comments: Submitted to ApJ

Roadmap For Small Bodies Exploration: Theoretical Studies

Authors: D. Nesvorný, A. Youdin, S. E. Dodson-Robinson, A. Barr, E. Asphaug, D. J. Scheeres

Abstract: This document covers five broad topics from theory of small bodies: planetesimal formation, cosmochemistry, thermal evolution, collisions and dynamics. Each of these topics is described in a separate section, where we prioritize selected main issues over completeness. The text points out the principal unresolved problems in each area, and suggests ways how progress can be made. This includes suppo… ▽ More This document covers five broad topics from theory of small bodies: planetesimal formation, cosmochemistry, thermal evolution, collisions and dynamics. Each of these topics is described in a separate section, where we prioritize selected main issues over completeness. The text points out the principal unresolved problems in each area, and suggests ways how progress can be made. This includes support for new code development, observations and experimental work that can be used to constrain theory, new research directions, and studies of cross-over regimes where the system's behavior is determined by several competing processes. The suggested development areas are placed in the context of NASA space exploration. △ Less

Submitted 28 March, 2011; v1 submitted 25 March, 2011; originally announced March 2011.

Comments: http://www.lpi.usra.edu/sbag/

On the Formation of Planetesimals via Secular Gravitational Instabilities with Turbulent Stirring

Authors: Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: We study the gravitational instability (GI) of small solids in a gas disk as a mechanism to form planetesimals. Dissipation from gas drag introduces secular GI, which proceeds even when standard GI criteria for a critical density or Toomre's $Q$ predict stability. We include the stabilizing effects of turbulent diffusion, which suppresses small scale GI. The radially wide rings that do collapse co… ▽ More We study the gravitational instability (GI) of small solids in a gas disk as a mechanism to form planetesimals. Dissipation from gas drag introduces secular GI, which proceeds even when standard GI criteria for a critical density or Toomre's $Q$ predict stability. We include the stabilizing effects of turbulent diffusion, which suppresses small scale GI. The radially wide rings that do collapse contain up to $\sim 0.1$ Earth masses of solids. Subsequent fragmentation of the ring (not modeled here) would produce a clan of chemically homogenous planetesimals. Particle radial drift time scales (and, to a lesser extent, disk lifetimes and sizes) restrict the viability of secular GI to disks with weak turbulent diffusion, characterized by $α\lesssim 10^{-4}$. Thus midplane dead zones are a preferred environment. Large solids with radii $\gtrsim 10$ cm collapse most rapidly because they partially decouple from the gas disk. Smaller solids, even below $\sim$ mm-sizes could collapse if particle-driven turbulence is weakened by either localized pressure maxima or super-Solar metallicity. Comparison with simulations that include particle clum** by the streaming instability shows that our linear model underpredicts rapid, small scale gravitational collapse. Thus the inclusion of more detailed gas dynamics promotes the formation of planetesimals. We discuss relevant constraints from Solar System and accretion disk observations. △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2011; originally announced February 2011.

Comments: Accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal; 20 pages, 10 figures

The Mechanical Greenhouse: Burial of Heat by Turbulence in Hot Jupiter Atmospheres

Authors: Andrew N. Youdin, Jonathan L. Mitchell

Abstract: The intense irradiation received by hot Jupiters suppresses convection in the outer layers of their atmospheres and lowers their cooling rates. "Inflated" hot Jupiters, i.e., those with anomalously large transit radii, require additional sources of heat or suppressed cooling. We consider the effect of forced turbulent mixing in the radiative layer, which could be driven by atmospheric circulation… ▽ More The intense irradiation received by hot Jupiters suppresses convection in the outer layers of their atmospheres and lowers their cooling rates. "Inflated" hot Jupiters, i.e., those with anomalously large transit radii, require additional sources of heat or suppressed cooling. We consider the effect of forced turbulent mixing in the radiative layer, which could be driven by atmospheric circulation or by another mechanism. Due to stable stratification in the atmosphere, forced turbulence drives a downward flux of heat. Weak turbulent mixing slows the cooling rate by this process, as if the planet was irradiated more intensely. Stronger turbulent mixing buries heat into the convective interior, provided the turbulence extends to the radiative-convective boundary. This inflates the planet until a balance is reached between the heat buried into and radiated from the interior. We also include the direct injection of heat due to the dissipation of turbulence or other effects. Such heating is already known to slow planetary cooling. We find that dissipation also enhances heat burial from mixing by lowering the threshold for turbulent mixing to drive heat into the interior. Strong turbulent mixing of heavy molecular species such as TiO may be necessary to explain stratospheric thermal inversions. We show that the amount of mixing required to loft TiO may overinflate the planet by our mechanism. This possible refutation of the TiO hypothesis deserves further study. Our inflation mechanism requires a deep stratified layer that only exists when the absorbed stellar flux greatly exceeds the intrinsic emitted flux. Thus it would be less effective for more luminous brown dwarfs and for longer period gas giants, including Jupiter and Saturn. △ Less

Submitted 3 August, 2010; originally announced August 2010.

Comments: 15 pages, 8 figures, accepted for publication in ApJ

Formation of Kuiper Belt Binaries by Gravitational Collapse

Authors: David Nesvorny, Andrew N. Youdin, Derek C. Richardson

Abstract: A large fraction of 100-km-class low-inclination objects in the classical Kuiper Belt (KB) are binaries with comparable mass and wide separation of components. A favored model for their formation was capture during the coagulation growth of bodies in the early KB. Instead, recent studies suggested that large objects can rapidly form in the protoplanetary disks when swarms of locally concentrated s… ▽ More A large fraction of 100-km-class low-inclination objects in the classical Kuiper Belt (KB) are binaries with comparable mass and wide separation of components. A favored model for their formation was capture during the coagulation growth of bodies in the early KB. Instead, recent studies suggested that large objects can rapidly form in the protoplanetary disks when swarms of locally concentrated solids collapse under their own gravity. Here we examine the possibility that KB binaries formed during gravitational collapse when the excess of angular momentum prevented the agglomeration of available mass into a solitary object. We find that this new mechanism provides a robust path toward the formation of KB binaries with observed properties, and can explain wide systems such as 2001 QW322 and multiples such as (47171) 1999 TC36. Notably, the gravitational collapse is capable of producing 100% binary fraction for a wide range of the swarm's initial angular momentum values. The binary components have similar masses (80% have the secondary-over-primary radius ratio >0.7) and their separation ranges from ~1,000 to ~100,000 km. The binary orbits have eccentricities from e=0 to ~1, with the majority having e<0.6. The binary orbit inclinations with respect to the initial angular momentum of the swarm range from i=0 to ~90 deg, with most cases having i<50 deg. Our binary formation mechanism implies that the primary and secondary components in each binary pair should have identical bulk composition, which is consistent with the current photometric data. We discuss the applicability of our results to the Pluto-Charon, Orcus-Vanth, (617) Patroclus-Menoetius and (90) Antiope binary systems. △ Less

Submitted 8 July, 2010; originally announced July 2010.

Comments: Astronomical Journal, in press

Forming Planetesimals in Solar and Extrasolar Nebulae

Authors: E. Chiang, A. Youdin

Abstract: Planets are built from planetesimals: solids larger than a kilometer which grow by colliding pairwise. Planetesimals themselves are unlikely to form by two-body collisions; sub-km objects have gravitational fields individually too weak, and electrostatic attraction is too feeble for growth beyond a few cm. We review the possibility that planetesimals form when self-gravity brings together vast e… ▽ More Planets are built from planetesimals: solids larger than a kilometer which grow by colliding pairwise. Planetesimals themselves are unlikely to form by two-body collisions; sub-km objects have gravitational fields individually too weak, and electrostatic attraction is too feeble for growth beyond a few cm. We review the possibility that planetesimals form when self-gravity brings together vast ensembles of small particles. Even when self-gravity is weak, aerodynamic processes can accumulate solids relative to gas, paving the way for gravitational collapse. Particles pile up as they drift radially inward. Gas turbulence stirs particles, but can also seed collapse by clum** them. While the feedback of solids on gas triggers vertical shear instabilities that obstruct self-gravity, this same feedback triggers streaming instabilities that strongly concentrate particles. Numerical simulations find that solids 10-100 cm in size gravitationally collapse in turbulent disks. We outline areas for progress, including the possibility that still smaller objects self-gravitate. △ Less

Submitted 17 September, 2009; v1 submitted 14 September, 2009; originally announced September 2009.

Comments: To appear in Annual Reviews. This review is intended to be both current and pedagogical. Incorporates suggestions from the community; further comments welcome. v2: Single-spaced

The Runts of the Litter: Why planets formed through gravitational instability can only be failed binary stars

Authors: Kaitlin M. Kratter, Ruth A. Murray-Clay, Andrew N. Youdin

Abstract: Recent direct imaging discoveries suggest a new class of massive, distant planets around A stars. These widely separated giants have been interpreted as signs of planet formation driven by gravitational instability, but the viability of this mechanism is not clear cut. In this paper, we first discuss the local requirements for fragmentation and the initial fragment mass scales. We then consider… ▽ More Recent direct imaging discoveries suggest a new class of massive, distant planets around A stars. These widely separated giants have been interpreted as signs of planet formation driven by gravitational instability, but the viability of this mechanism is not clear cut. In this paper, we first discuss the local requirements for fragmentation and the initial fragment mass scales. We then consider whether the fragment's subsequent growth can be terminated within the planetary mass regime. Finally, we place disks in the larger context of star formation and disk evolution models. We find that in order for gravitational instability to produce planets, disks must be atypically cold in order to reduce the initial fragment mass. In addition, fragmentation must occur during a narrow window of disk evolution, after infall has mostly ceased, but while the disk is still sufficiently massive to undergo gravitational instability. Under more typical conditions, disk-born objects will likely grow well above the deuterium burning planetary mass limit. We conclude that if planets are formed by gravitational instability, they must be the low mass tail of the distribution of disk-born companions. To validate this theory, on-going direct imaging surveys must find a greater abundance of brown dwarf and M-star companions to A-stars. Their absence would suggest planet formation by a different mechanism such as core accretion, which is consistent with the debris disks detected in these systems. △ Less

Submitted 26 January, 2010; v1 submitted 15 September, 2009; originally announced September 2009.

Comments: 14 pages, 6 figures, accepted to ApJ, some content changes, revised figures

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.710:1375-1386,2010