-
A $~75\%$ Occurrence Rate of Debris Discs around F stars in the $β$ Pic Moving Group
Authors:
Nicole Pawellek,
Mark Wyatt,
Luca Matrà,
Grant Kennedy,
Ben Yelverton
Abstract:
Only 20\% of old field stars have detectable debris discs, leaving open the question of what disc, if any, is present around the remaining 80\%. Young moving groups allow to probe this population, since discs are expected to have been brighter early on. This paper considers the population of F~stars in the 23~Myr-old BPMG where we find that 9/12 targets possess discs. We also analyse archival ALMA…
▽ More
Only 20\% of old field stars have detectable debris discs, leaving open the question of what disc, if any, is present around the remaining 80\%. Young moving groups allow to probe this population, since discs are expected to have been brighter early on. This paper considers the population of F~stars in the 23~Myr-old BPMG where we find that 9/12 targets possess discs. We also analyse archival ALMA data to derive radii for 4 of the discs, presenting the first image of the 63au radius disc of HD~164249. Comparing the BPMG results to disc samples from $\sim45$~Myr and $\sim150$~Myr-old moving~groups, and to discs found around field stars, we find the disc incidence rate in young moving~groups is comparable to that of the BPMG and significantly higher than that of field~stars. The BPMG discs tend to be smaller than those around field~stars. However, this difference is not statistically significant due to the small number of targets. Yet, by analysing the fractional luminosity vs disc radius parameter space we find that the fractional luminosities in the populations considered drop by two orders of magnitude within the first 100~Myr. This is much faster than expected by collisional evolution, implying a decay equivalent to $1/\text{age}^2$. We attribute this depletion to embedded planets which would be around 170~$M_\text{earth}$ to cause a depletion on the appropriate timescale. However, we cannot rule out that different birth environments of nearby young clusters result in brighter debris discs than the progenitors of field~stars which likely formed in a more dense environment.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Mutual inclinations between giant planets and their debris discs in HD 113337 and HD 38529
Authors:
Jerry W. Xuan,
Grant M. Kennedy,
Mark C. Wyatt,
Ben Yelverton
Abstract:
HD 113337 and HD 38529 host pairs of giant planets, a debris disc, and wide M-type stellar companions. We measure the disc orientation with resolved images from Herschel and constrain the three-dimensional orbits of the outer planets with Gaia DR2 and Hipparcos astrometry. Resolved disc modelling leaves degeneracy in the disc orientation, so we derive four separate planet-disc mutual inclination (…
▽ More
HD 113337 and HD 38529 host pairs of giant planets, a debris disc, and wide M-type stellar companions. We measure the disc orientation with resolved images from Herschel and constrain the three-dimensional orbits of the outer planets with Gaia DR2 and Hipparcos astrometry. Resolved disc modelling leaves degeneracy in the disc orientation, so we derive four separate planet-disc mutual inclination ($ΔI$) solutions. The most aligned solutions give $ΔI=17-32°$ for HD 113337 and $ΔI=21-45°$ for HD 38529 (both 1$σ$). In both systems, there is a small probability (<0.3 per cent) that the planet and disc are nearly aligned ($ΔI < 3°$). The stellar and planetary companions cause the orbits of disc material to precess about a plane defined by the forced inclination. We determine this as well as the precession time-scale to interpret the mutual inclination results. We find that the debris discs in both systems could be warped via joint influences of the outer planet and stellar companion, potentially explaining the observed misalignments. However, this requires HD 113337 to be old (0.8-1.7 Gyr), whereas if young (14-21 Myr), the observed misalignment in HD 113337 could be inherited from the protoplanetary disc phase. For both systems, the inclination of the stellar spin axis is consistent with the disc and outer planet inclinations, which instead supports system-wide alignment or near alignment. High-resolution observations of the discs and improved constraints on the planetary orbits would provide firmer conclusions about the (mis)alignment status.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
No significant correlation between radial velocity planet presence and debris disc properties
Authors:
Ben Yelverton,
Grant M. Kennedy,
Kate Y. L. Su
Abstract:
We investigate whether the tentative correlation between planets and debris discs which has been previously identified can be confirmed at high significance. We compile a sample of 201 stars with known planets and existing far infrared observations. The sample is larger than those studied previously since we include targets from an unpublished Herschel survey of planet hosts. We use spectral energ…
▽ More
We investigate whether the tentative correlation between planets and debris discs which has been previously identified can be confirmed at high significance. We compile a sample of 201 stars with known planets and existing far infrared observations. The sample is larger than those studied previously since we include targets from an unpublished Herschel survey of planet hosts. We use spectral energy distribution modelling to characterise Kuiper belt analogue debris discs within the sample, then compare the properties of the discs against a control sample of 294 stars without known planets. Survival analysis suggests that there is a significant ($p\sim 0.002$) difference between the disc fractional luminosity distributions of the two samples. However, this is largely a result of the fact that the control sample contains a higher proportion of close binaries and of later-type stars; both of these factors are known to reduce disc detection rates. Considering only Sun-like stars without close binary companions in each sample greatly reduces the significance of the difference ($p\sim 0.3$). We also find no evidence for a difference in the disc fractional luminosities of stars hosting planets more or less massive than Saturn ($p\sim 0.9$). Finally, we find that the planet hosts have cooler discs than the control stars, but this is likely a detection bias, since the warmest discs in the control sample are also the faintest, and would thus be undetectable around the more distant planet hosts. Considering only discs in each sample that could have been detected around a typical planet host, we find $p\sim 0.07$ for the temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
A statistically significant lack of debris discs in medium separation binary systems
Authors:
Ben Yelverton,
Grant M. Kennedy,
Kate Y. L. Su,
Mark C. Wyatt
Abstract:
We compile a sample of 341 binary and multiple star systems with the aim of searching for and characterising Kuiper belt-like debris discs. The sample is assembled by combining several smaller samples studied in previously published work with targets from two unpublished Herschel surveys. We find that 38 systems show excess emission at 70 or 100 $μ$m suggestive of a debris disc. While nine of the…
▽ More
We compile a sample of 341 binary and multiple star systems with the aim of searching for and characterising Kuiper belt-like debris discs. The sample is assembled by combining several smaller samples studied in previously published work with targets from two unpublished Herschel surveys. We find that 38 systems show excess emission at 70 or 100 $μ$m suggestive of a debris disc. While nine of the discs appear to be unstable to perturbations from their host binary based on a simple analysis of their inferred radii, we argue that the evidence for genuine instability is not strong, primarily because of uncertainty in the true disc radii, uncertainty in the boundaries of the unstable regions, and orbital projection effects. The binary separation distributions of the disc-bearing and disc-free systems are different at a confidence level of $99.4\%$, indicating that binary separation strongly influences the presence of detectable levels of debris. No discs are detected for separations between $\sim$25 and 135 au; this is likely a result of binaries whose separations are comparable with typical disc radii clearing out their primordial circumstellar or circumbinary material via dynamical perturbations. The disc detection rate is $19^{+5}_{-3}\%$ for binaries wider than 135 au, similar to published results for single stars. Only $8^{+2}_{-1}\%$ of systems with separations below 25 au host a detectable disc, which may suggest that planetesimal formation is inhibited in binaries closer than a few tens of au, similar to the conclusions of studies of known planet-hosting binaries.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2019; v1 submitted 10 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
A circumbinary protoplanetary disc in a polar configuration
Authors:
Grant M. Kennedy,
Luca Matrà,
Stefano Facchini,
Julien Milli,
Olja Panić,
Daniel Price,
David J. Wilner,
Mark C. Wyatt,
Ben M. Yelverton
Abstract:
Nearly all young stars are initially surrounded by `protoplanetary' discs of gas and dust, and in the case of single stars at least 30\% of these discs go on to form planets. The process of protoplanetary disc formation can result in initial misalignments, where the disc orbital plane is different to the stellar equator in single star systems, or to the binary orbital plane in systems with two sta…
▽ More
Nearly all young stars are initially surrounded by `protoplanetary' discs of gas and dust, and in the case of single stars at least 30\% of these discs go on to form planets. The process of protoplanetary disc formation can result in initial misalignments, where the disc orbital plane is different to the stellar equator in single star systems, or to the binary orbital plane in systems with two stars. A quirk of the dynamics means that initially misaligned `circumbinary' discs -- those that surround two stars -- are predicted to evolve to one of two possible stable configurations, one where the disc and binary orbital planes are coplanar, and one where they are perpendicular (a `polar' configuration). Prior work has found coplanar circumbinary discs, but no polar examples were known until now. Here we report the first discovery of a protoplanetary circumbinary disc in the polar configuration, supporting the predictions that such discs should exist. The disc shows some characteristics that are similar to discs around single stars, and that are attributed to dust growth. Thus, the first stages of planet formation appear able to proceed in polar circumbinary discs.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
A gap in HD 92945's broad planetesimal disc revealed by ALMA
Authors:
S. Marino,
B. Yelverton,
M. Booth,
V. Faramaz,
G. M. Kennedy,
L. Matrà,
M. C. Wyatt
Abstract:
In the last few years, multiwavelength observations have revealed the ubiquity of gaps/rings in circumstellar discs. Here we report the first ALMA observations of HD 92945 at 0.86 mm, that reveal a gap at about 73$\pm$3 au within a broad disc of planetesimals that extends from 50 to 140 au. We find that the gap is $20^{+10}_{-8}$ au wide. If cleared by a planet in situ, this planet must be less ma…
▽ More
In the last few years, multiwavelength observations have revealed the ubiquity of gaps/rings in circumstellar discs. Here we report the first ALMA observations of HD 92945 at 0.86 mm, that reveal a gap at about 73$\pm$3 au within a broad disc of planetesimals that extends from 50 to 140 au. We find that the gap is $20^{+10}_{-8}$ au wide. If cleared by a planet in situ, this planet must be less massive than 0.6 $M_\mathrm{Jup}$, or even lower if the gap was cleared by a planet that formed early in the protoplanetary disc and prevented planetesimal formation at that radius. By comparing opposite sides of the disc we also find that the disc could be asymmetric. Motivated by the asymmetry and the fact that planets might be more frequent closer to the star in exoplanetary systems, we show that the gap and asymmetry could be produced by two planets interior to the disc through secular resonances. These planets excite the eccentricity of bodies at specific disc locations, opening radial gaps in the planetesimal distribution. New observations are necessary to confirm if the disc is truly asymmetric, thus favouring the secular resonance model, or if the apparent asymmetry is due to a background galaxy, favouring the in-situ planet scenario. Finally, we also report the non-detection of CO and HCN gas confirming that no primordial gas is present. The CO and HCN non-detections are consistent with the destruction of volatile-rich Solar System-like comets.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2019; v1 submitted 5 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Empty gaps? Depleting annular regions in debris discs by secular resonance with a two-planet system
Authors:
Ben Yelverton,
Grant M. Kennedy
Abstract:
We investigate the evolution on secular time-scales of a radially extended debris disc under the influence of a system of two coplanar planets interior to the disc, showing that the secular resonances of the system can produce a depleted region in the disc by exciting the eccentricities of planetesimals. Using Laplace-Lagrange theory, we consider how the two exterior secular resonance locations, t…
▽ More
We investigate the evolution on secular time-scales of a radially extended debris disc under the influence of a system of two coplanar planets interior to the disc, showing that the secular resonances of the system can produce a depleted region in the disc by exciting the eccentricities of planetesimals. Using Laplace-Lagrange theory, we consider how the two exterior secular resonance locations, time-scales and widths depend on the masses, semi-major axes and eccentricities of the planets. In particular, we find that unless the resonances are very close to each other, one of them is very narrow and therefore unimportant for determining the observable structure of the disc. We apply these considerations to the debris disc of HD 107146, identifying combinations of the parameters of a possible unobserved two-planet system that could configure the secular resonances appropriately to reproduce the depletion observed in the disc. By performing N-body simulations of such systems, we find that planetesimal eccentricities do indeed become large near the theoretical secular resonance locations. The N-body output is post-processed to set the initial surface density profile of the disc, and to include the possible effects of collisional depletion. We find that it is possible to obtain a double-ringed disc in these simulations but not an axisymmetric one, with the inner ring having an offset whose magnitude depends on the eccentricities of the planets, and the outer ring showing spiral structure.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
ALMA observations of the narrow HR 4796A debris ring
Authors:
Grant M. Kennedy,
Sebastian Marino,
Luca Matra,
Olja Panic,
David Wilner,
Mark C. Wyatt,
Ben Yelverton
Abstract:
The young A0V star HR 4796A is host to a bright and narrow ring of dust, thought to originate in collisions between planetesimals within a belt analogous to the Solar System's Edgeworth-Kuiper belt. Here we present high spatial resolution 880$μ$m continuum images from the Atacama Large Millimeter Array. The 80au radius dust ring is resolved radially with a characteristic width of 10au, consistent…
▽ More
The young A0V star HR 4796A is host to a bright and narrow ring of dust, thought to originate in collisions between planetesimals within a belt analogous to the Solar System's Edgeworth-Kuiper belt. Here we present high spatial resolution 880$μ$m continuum images from the Atacama Large Millimeter Array. The 80au radius dust ring is resolved radially with a characteristic width of 10au, consistent with the narrow profile seen in scattered light. Our modelling consistently finds that the disk is also vertically resolved with a similar extent. However, this extent is less than the beam size, and a disk that is dynamically very cold (i.e. vertically thin) provides a better theoretical explanation for the narrow scattered light profile, so we remain cautious about this conclusion. We do not detect $^{12}$CO J=3-2 emission, concluding that unless the disk is dynamically cold the CO+CO$_2$ ice content of the planetesimals is of order a few percent or less. We consider the range of semi-major axes and masses of an interior planet supposed to cause the ring's eccentricity, finding that such a planet should be more massive than Neptune and orbit beyond 40au. Independent of our ALMA observations, we note a conflict between mid-IR pericenter-glow and scattered light imaging interpretations, concluding that models where the spatial dust density and grain size vary around the ring should be explored.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.