-
The Effects of Peeling on Finite Element Method -based EEG Source Reconstruction
Authors:
Santtu Söderholm,
Joonas Lahtinen,
Carsten H. Wolters,
Sampsa Pursiainen
Abstract:
The problem of reconstructing brain activity from electric potential measurements performed on the surface of a human head is not an easy task: not just because the solution of the related inverse problem is fundamentally ill-posed (not unique), but because the methods utilized in constructing a synthetic forward solution themselves contain many inaccuracies. One of these is the fact that the usua…
▽ More
The problem of reconstructing brain activity from electric potential measurements performed on the surface of a human head is not an easy task: not just because the solution of the related inverse problem is fundamentally ill-posed (not unique), but because the methods utilized in constructing a synthetic forward solution themselves contain many inaccuracies. One of these is the fact that the usual method of modelling primary currents in the human head via dipoles brings about at least 2 modelling errors: one from the singularity introduced by the dipole, and one from placing such dipoles near conductivity discontinuities in the active brain layer boundaries.
In this article we observe how the removal of possible source locations from the surfaces of active brain layers affects the localisation accuracy of two inverse methods, sLORETA and Dipole Scan, at different signal-to-noise ratios (SNR), when the H(div) source model is used. We also describe the finite element forward solver used to construct the synthetic EEG data, that was fed to the inverse methods as input, in addition to the meshes that were used as the domains of the forward and inverse solvers. Our results suggest that there is a slight general improvement in the localisation results, especially at lower noise levels. The applied inverse algorithm and brain compartment under observation also affect the accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2023; v1 submitted 9 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
The Localized Subtraction Approach For EEG and MEG Forward Modeling
Authors:
Malte B. Höltershinken,
Pia Lange,
Tim Erdbrügger,
Yvonne Buschermöhle,
Fabrice Wallois,
Alena Buyx,
Sampsa Pursiainen,
Johannes Vorwerk,
Christian Engwer,
Carsten H. Wolters
Abstract:
In FEM-based EEG and MEG source analysis, the subtraction approach has been proposed to simulate sensor measurements generated by neural activity. While this approach possesses a rigorous foundation and produces accurate results, its major downside is that it is computationally prohibitively expensive in practical applications. To overcome this, we developed a new approach, called the localized su…
▽ More
In FEM-based EEG and MEG source analysis, the subtraction approach has been proposed to simulate sensor measurements generated by neural activity. While this approach possesses a rigorous foundation and produces accurate results, its major downside is that it is computationally prohibitively expensive in practical applications. To overcome this, we developed a new approach, called the localized subtraction approach. This approach is designed to preserve the mathematical foundation of the subtraction approach, while also leading to sparse right-hand sides in the FEM formulation, making it efficiently computable. We achieve this by introducing a cut-off into the subtraction, restricting its influence to the immediate neighborhood of the source. In this work, this approach will be presented, analyzed, and compared to other state-of-the-art FEM right-hand side approaches. Furthermore, we discuss how to arrive at an efficient and stable implementation. We perform validation in multi-layer sphere models where analytical solutions exist. There, we demonstrate that the localized subtraction approach is vastly more efficient than the subtraction approach. Moreover, we find that for the EEG forward problem, the localized subtraction approach is less dependent on the global structure of the FEM mesh when compared to the subtraction approach. Additionally, we show the localized subtraction approach to rival, and in many cases even surpass, the other investigated approaches in terms of accuracy. For the MEG forward problem, we show the localized subtraction approach and the subtraction approach to produce highly accurate approximations of the volume currents close to the source. The localized subtraction approach thus reduces the computational cost of the subtraction approach to an extent that makes it usable in practical applications without sacrificing rigorousness and accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Validation of EEG forward modeling approaches in the presence of anisotropy in the source space
Authors:
Florian Drechsler,
Johannes Vorwerk,
Jens Haueisen,
Lars Grasedyck,
Carsten H. Wolters
Abstract:
The quality of the inverse approach in electroencephalography (EEG) source analysis is - among other things - depending on the accuracy of the forward modeling approach, i.e., the simulation of the electric potential for a known dipole source in the brain. Here, we use multilayer sphere modeling scenarios to investigate the performance of three different finite element method (FEM) based EEG forwa…
▽ More
The quality of the inverse approach in electroencephalography (EEG) source analysis is - among other things - depending on the accuracy of the forward modeling approach, i.e., the simulation of the electric potential for a known dipole source in the brain. Here, we use multilayer sphere modeling scenarios to investigate the performance of three different finite element method (FEM) based EEG forward approaches - subtraction, Venant and partial integration - in the presence of tissue conductivity anisotropy in the source space. In our studies, the effect of anisotropy on the potential is related to model errors when ignoring anisotropy and to numerical errors, convergence behavior and computational speed of the different FEM approaches. Three different source space anisotropy models that best represent adult, child and premature baby volume conduction scenarios, are used. Major findings of the study include (1) source space conductivity anisotropy has a significant effect on electric potential computation: The effect increases with increasing anisotropy ratio; (2) with numerical errors far below anisotropy effects, all three FEM approaches are able to model source space anisotropy accordingly, with the Venant approach offering the best compromise between accuracy and computational speed; (3) FE meshes have to be fine enough in the subdomain between the source and the sensors that capture its main activity. We conclude that, especially for the analysis of cortical development, but also for more general applications using EEG source analysis techniques, source space conductivity anisotropy should be modeled and the FEM Venant approach is an appropriate method.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Realistic head modeling of electromagnetic brain activity: An integrated Brainstorm pipeline from MRI data to the FEM solution
Authors:
Takfarinas Medani,
Juan Garcia-Prieto,
Francois Tadel,
Sophie Schrader,
Anand Joshi,
Christian Engwer,
Carsten H. Wolters,
John C. Mosher,
Richard M. Leahy
Abstract:
Human brain activity generates scalp potentials (electroencephalography EEG), intracranial potentials (iEEG), and external magnetic fields (magnetoencephalography MEG), all capable of being recorded, often simultaneously, for use in research and clinical applications. The so-called forward problem is the modeling of these fields at their sensors for a given putative neural source configuration. Wh…
▽ More
Human brain activity generates scalp potentials (electroencephalography EEG), intracranial potentials (iEEG), and external magnetic fields (magnetoencephalography MEG), all capable of being recorded, often simultaneously, for use in research and clinical applications. The so-called forward problem is the modeling of these fields at their sensors for a given putative neural source configuration. While early generations modeled the head as a simple set of isotropic spheres, today s ubiquitous magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) data allows detailed descriptions of head compartments with assigned isotropic and anisotropic conductivities. In this paper, we present a complete pipeline, integrated into the Brainstorm software, that allows users to generate an individual and accurate head model from the MRI and then calculate the electromagnetic forward solution using the finite element method (FEM). The head model generation is performed by the integration of the latest tools for MRI segmentation and FEM mesh generation. The final head model is divided into five main compartments: white matter, grey matter, CSF, skull, and scalp. For the isotropic compartments, widely-used default conductivity values are assigned. For the brain tissues, we use the process of the effective medium approach (EMA) to estimate anisotropic conductivity tensors from diffusion-weighted imaging (DWI) data. The FEM electromagnetic calculations are performed by the DUNEuro library, integrated into Brainstorm and accessible with a user-friendly graphical interface. This integrated pipeline, with full tutorials and example data sets freely available on the Brainstorm website, gives the neuroscience community easy access to advanced tools for electromagnetic modeling using FEM.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
DUNEuro -- A software toolbox for forward modeling in bioelectromagnetism
Authors:
Sophie Schrader,
Andreas Westhoff,
Maria Carla Piastra,
Tuuli Miinalainen,
Sampsa Pursiainen,
Johannes Vorwerk,
Heinrich Brinck,
Carsten H. Wolters,
Christian Engwer
Abstract:
Accurate and efficient source analysis in electro- and magnetoencephalography using sophisticated realistic head geometries requires advanced numerical approaches. This paper presents DUNEuro, a free and open source C++ software toolbox for forward modeling in bioelectromagnetism. Building upon the DUNE framework, it provides implementations of modern fitted and unfitted finite element methods to…
▽ More
Accurate and efficient source analysis in electro- and magnetoencephalography using sophisticated realistic head geometries requires advanced numerical approaches. This paper presents DUNEuro, a free and open source C++ software toolbox for forward modeling in bioelectromagnetism. Building upon the DUNE framework, it provides implementations of modern fitted and unfitted finite element methods to efficiently solve the forward problems in electro- and magnetoencephalography. The user can choose between a variety of different source models that are implemented. The software's aim is to provide interfaces that are extendible and easy-to-use. In order to enable a closer integration into existing analysis pipelines, interfaces to Python and Matlab are provided. The practical use is demonstrated by a source analysis example of somatosensory evoked potentials using a realistic six compartment head model.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2021; v1 submitted 9 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Bayesian Modelling of Skull Conductivity Uncertainties in EEG Source Imaging
Authors:
Ville Rimpiläinen,
Alexandra Koulouri,
Felix Lucka,
Jari P Kaipio,
Carsten H Wolters
Abstract:
Knowing the correct skull conductivity is crucial for the accuracy of EEG source imaging, but unfortunately, its true value, which is inter- and intra-individually varying, is difficult to determine. In this paper, we propose a statistical method based on the Bayesian approximation error approach to compensate for source imaging errors related to erroneous skull conductivity. We demonstrate the po…
▽ More
Knowing the correct skull conductivity is crucial for the accuracy of EEG source imaging, but unfortunately, its true value, which is inter- and intra-individually varying, is difficult to determine. In this paper, we propose a statistical method based on the Bayesian approximation error approach to compensate for source imaging errors related to erroneous skull conductivity. We demonstrate the potential of the approach by simulating EEG data of focal source activity and using the dipole scan algorithm and a sparsity promoting prior to reconstruct the underlying sources. The results suggest that the greatest improvements with the proposed method can be achieved when the focal sources are close to the skull.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Advanced boundary electrode modeling for tES and parallel tES/EEG
Authors:
Britte Agsten,
Sven Wagner,
Sampsa Pursiainen,
Carsten H. Wolters
Abstract:
This paper explores advanced electrode modeling in the context of separate and parallel transcranial electrical stimulation (tES) and electroencephalography (EEG) measurements. We focus on boundary condition based approaches that do not necessitate adding auxiliary elements, e.g. sponges, to the computational domain. In particular, we investigate the complete electrode model (CEM) which incorporat…
▽ More
This paper explores advanced electrode modeling in the context of separate and parallel transcranial electrical stimulation (tES) and electroencephalography (EEG) measurements. We focus on boundary condition based approaches that do not necessitate adding auxiliary elements, e.g. sponges, to the computational domain. In particular, we investigate the complete electrode model (CEM) which incorporates a detailed description of the skin-electrode interface including its contact surface, impedance and normal current distribution. The CEM can be applied for both tES and EEG electrodes which is advantageous when a parallel system is used. In comparison to the CEM, we test two important reduced approaches: the gap model (GAP) and the point electrode model (PEM). We aim to find out the differences of these approaches for a realistic numerical setting based on the stimulation of the auditory cortex. The results obtained suggest, among other things, that GAP and GAP/PEM are sufficiently accurate for the practical application of tES and parallel tES/EEG, respectively. Differences between CEM and GAP were observed mainly in the skin compartment, where only CEM explains the heating effects characteristic to tES.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Electroencephalography (EEG) Forward Modeling via H(div) Finite Element Sources with Focal Interpolation
Authors:
Sampsa Pursiainen,
Johannes Vorwerk,
Carsten H. Wolters
Abstract:
The goal of this study is to develop focal, accurate and robust finite element method (FEM) based approaches which can predict the electric potential on the surface of the computational domain given its structure and internal primary source current distribution. While conducting an EEG evaluation, the placement of source currents to the geometrically complex grey matter compartment is a challengin…
▽ More
The goal of this study is to develop focal, accurate and robust finite element method (FEM) based approaches which can predict the electric potential on the surface of the computational domain given its structure and internal primary source current distribution. While conducting an EEG evaluation, the placement of source currents to the geometrically complex grey matter compartment is a challenging but necessary task to avoid forward errors attributable to tissue conductivity jumps. Here, this task is approached via a mathematically rigorous formulation, in which the current field is modeled via divergence conforming H(div) basis functions. Both linear and quadratic functions are used while the potential field is discretized via the standard linear Lagrangian (nodal) basis. The resulting model includes dipolar sources which are interpolated into a random set of positions and orientations utilizing two alternative approaches: the position based optimization (PBO) and the mean position/orientation (MPO) method. These results demonstrate that the present dipolar approach can reach or even surpass, at least in some respects, the accuracy of two classical reference methods, the partial integration (PI) and St. Venant (SV) approach which utilize monopolar loads instead of dipolar currents.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
A Mixed Finite Element Method to Solve the EEG Forward Problem
Authors:
Johannes Vorwerk,
Christian Engwer,
Sampsa Pursiainen,
Carsten H. Wolters
Abstract:
Finite element methods have been shown to achieve high accuracies in numerically solving the EEG forward problem and they enable the realistic modeling of complex geometries and important conductive features such as anisotropic conductivities. To date, most of the presented approaches rely on the same underlying formulation, the continuous Galerkin (CG)-FEM. In this article, a novel approach to so…
▽ More
Finite element methods have been shown to achieve high accuracies in numerically solving the EEG forward problem and they enable the realistic modeling of complex geometries and important conductive features such as anisotropic conductivities. To date, most of the presented approaches rely on the same underlying formulation, the continuous Galerkin (CG)-FEM. In this article, a novel approach to solve the EEG forward problem based on a mixed finite element method (Mixed-FEM) is introduced. To obtain the Mixed-FEM formulation, the electric current is introduced as an additional unknown besides the electric potential. As a consequence of this derivation, the Mixed-FEM is, by construction, current preserving, in contrast to the CG-FEM. Consequently, a higher simulation accuracy can be achieved in certain scenarios, e.g., when the diameter of thin insulating structures, such as the skull, is in the range of the mesh resolution.
A theoretical derivation of the Mixed-FEM approach for EEG forward simulations is presented, and the algorithms implemented for solving the resulting equation systems are described. Subsequently, first evaluations in both sphere and realistic head models are presented, and the results are compared to previously introduced CG-FEM approaches. Additional visualizations are shown to illustrate the current preserving property of the Mixed-FEM.
Based on these results, it is concluded that the newly presented Mixed-FEM can at least complement and in some scenarios even outperform the established CG-FEM approaches, which motivates a further evaluation of the Mixed-FEM for applications in bioelectromagnetism.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2017; v1 submitted 19 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
The Unfitted Discontinuous Galerkin Method for Solving the EEG Forward Problem
Authors:
Andreas Nüßing,
Carsten H. Wolters,
Heinrich Brinck,
Christian Engwer
Abstract:
Objective: The purpose of this study is to introduce and evaluate the unfitted discontinuous Galerkin finite element method (UDG-FEM) for solving the electroencephalography (EEG) forward problem. Methods: This new approach for source analysis does not use a geometry conforming volume triangulation, but instead uses a structured mesh that does not resolve the geometry. The geometry is described usi…
▽ More
Objective: The purpose of this study is to introduce and evaluate the unfitted discontinuous Galerkin finite element method (UDG-FEM) for solving the electroencephalography (EEG) forward problem. Methods: This new approach for source analysis does not use a geometry conforming volume triangulation, but instead uses a structured mesh that does not resolve the geometry. The geometry is described using level set functions and is incorporated implicitly in its mathematical formulation. As no triangulation is necessary, the complexity of a simulation pipeline and the need for manual interaction for patient specific simulations can be reduced and is comparable with that of the FEM for hexahedral meshes. In addition, it maintains conservation laws on a discrete level. Here, we present the theory for UDG-FEM forward modeling, its verification using quasi-analytical solutions in multi-layer sphere models and an evaluation in a comparison with a discontinuous Galerkin (DG-FEM) method on hexahedral and on conforming tetrahedral meshes. We furthermore apply the UDG-FEM forward approach in a realistic head model simulation study. Results: The given results show convergence and indicate a good overall accuracy of the UDG-FEM approach. UDG-FEM performs comparable or even better than DG-FEM on a conforming tetrahedral mesh while providing a less complex simulation pipeline. When compared to DG-FEM on hexahedral meshes, an overall better accuracy is achieved. Conclusion: The UDG-FEM approach is an accurate, flexible and promising method to solve the EEG forward problem. Significance: This study shows the first application of the UDG-FEM approach to the EEG forward problem.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2016; v1 submitted 28 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
A discontinuous Galerkin Method for the EEG Forward Problem using the Subtraction Approach
Authors:
Christian Engwer,
Johannes Vorwerk,
Jakob Ludewig,
Carsten H. Wolters
Abstract:
In order to perform electroencephalography (EEG) source reconstruction, i.e., to localize the sources underlying a measured EEG, the electric potential distribution at the electrodes generated by a dipolar current source in the brain has to be simulated, which is the so-called EEG forward problem. To solve it accurately, it is necessary to apply numerical methods that are able to take the individu…
▽ More
In order to perform electroencephalography (EEG) source reconstruction, i.e., to localize the sources underlying a measured EEG, the electric potential distribution at the electrodes generated by a dipolar current source in the brain has to be simulated, which is the so-called EEG forward problem. To solve it accurately, it is necessary to apply numerical methods that are able to take the individual geometry and conductivity distribution of the subject's head into account. In this context, the finite element method (FEM) has shown high numerical accuracy with the possibility to model complex geometries and conductive features, e.g., white matter conductivity anisotropy. In this article, we introduce and analyze the application of a discontinuous Galerkin (DG) method, a finite element method that includes features of the finite volume framework, to the EEG forward problem. The DG-FEM approach fulfills the conservation property of electric charge also in the discrete case, making it attractive for a variety of applications. Furthermore, as we show, this approach can alleviate modeling inaccuracies that might occur in head geometries when using classical FE methods, e.g., so-called "skull leakage effects", which may occur in areas where the thickness of the skull is in the range of the mesh resolution. Therefore, we derive a DG formulation of the FEM subtraction approach for the EEG forward problem and present numerical results that highlight the advantageous features and the potential benefits of the proposed approach.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2016; v1 submitted 16 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
An optimization approach for well-targeted transcranial direct current stimulation
Authors:
Sven Wagner,
Martin Burger,
Carsten H. Wolters
Abstract:
Transcranial direct current stimulation is a non-invasive brain stimulation technique which modifies neural excitability by providing weak currents through scalp electrodes. The aim of this study is to introduce and analyze a novel optimization method for safe and well-targeted multi-array tDCS. For optimization, we consider an optimal control problem for a Laplace equation with Neumann boundary c…
▽ More
Transcranial direct current stimulation is a non-invasive brain stimulation technique which modifies neural excitability by providing weak currents through scalp electrodes. The aim of this study is to introduce and analyze a novel optimization method for safe and well-targeted multi-array tDCS. For optimization, we consider an optimal control problem for a Laplace equation with Neumann boundary conditions with control and point-wise gradient state constraints. We prove existence and residual and objective convergence results for the proposed methods and provide computer simulation results in a highly realistic six-compartment geometry-adapted hexahedral head model. For discretization of the proposed minimization problem the finite element method is employed and the existence of at least one minimizer to the discretized optimization problem is shown. For numerical solution of the corresponding discretized problem we employ the alternating direction method of multipliers and comprehensively examine the cortical current flow field with regard to focality, target intensity and orientation. The numerical results reveal that the optimized current flow fields show significantly higher focality and, in most cases, higher directional agreement to the target vector in comparison to standard bipolar electrode montages.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2016; v1 submitted 25 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
