-
Definitive Surface Magnetotransport Study of SmB$_{6}$
Authors:
Yun Suk Eo,
Steven Wolgast,
Alexa Rakoski,
Dmitri Mihaliov,
Boyoun Kang,
Myung-suk Song,
Beongki Cho,
Monica Ciomaga Hatnean,
Geetha Balakrishnan,
Zachary Fisk,
Shanta Saha,
Xiangfeng Wang,
Johnpierre Paglione,
Cagliyan Kurdak
Abstract:
After the theoretical prediction that SmB$_6$ is a topological Kondo insulator, there has been an explosion of studies on the SmB$_6$ surface. However, there is not yet an agreement on even the most basic quantities such as the surface carrier density and mobility. In this paper, we carefully revisit Corbino disk magnetotransport studies to find those surface transport parameters. We first show th…
▽ More
After the theoretical prediction that SmB$_6$ is a topological Kondo insulator, there has been an explosion of studies on the SmB$_6$ surface. However, there is not yet an agreement on even the most basic quantities such as the surface carrier density and mobility. In this paper, we carefully revisit Corbino disk magnetotransport studies to find those surface transport parameters. We first show that subsurface cracks exist in the SmB$_6$ crystals, arising both from surface preparation and during the crystal growth. We provide evidence that these hidden subsurface cracks are additional conduction channels, and the large disagreement between earlier surface SmB$_6$ studies may originate from previous interpretations not taking this extra conduction path into account. We provide an update of a more reliable magnetotransport data than the previous one (Phys. Rev. B 92, 115110) and find that the orders-of-magnitude large disagreements in carrier density and mobility come from the surface preparation and the transport geometry rather than the intrinsic sample quality. From this magnetotransport study, we find an updated estimate of the carrier density and mobility of 2.71$\times$10$^{13}$ (1/cm$^2$) and 104.5 (cm$^{2}$/V$\cdot$sec), respectively. We compare our results with other studies of the SmB$_6$ surface. By this comparison, we provide insight into the disagreements and agreements of the previously reported angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy, scanning tunneling microscopy, and magnetotorque quantum oscillations measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Reduction of the low-temperature bulk gap in samarium hexaboride under high magnetic fields
Authors:
S. Wolgast,
Y. S. Eo,
K. Sun,
Ç. Kurdak,
F. F. Balakirev,
M. Jaime,
D. -J. Kim,
Z. Fisk
Abstract:
SmB$_6$ exhibits a small (15-20 meV) bandgap at low temperatures due to hybridized $d$ and $f$ electrons, a tiny (3 meV) transport activation energy $(E_{A})$ above 4 K, and surface states accessible to transport below 2 K. We study its magnetoresistance in 60-T pulsed fields between 1.5 K and 4 K. The response of the nearly $T$-independent surface states (which show no Shubnikov-de Haas oscillati…
▽ More
SmB$_6$ exhibits a small (15-20 meV) bandgap at low temperatures due to hybridized $d$ and $f$ electrons, a tiny (3 meV) transport activation energy $(E_{A})$ above 4 K, and surface states accessible to transport below 2 K. We study its magnetoresistance in 60-T pulsed fields between 1.5 K and 4 K. The response of the nearly $T$-independent surface states (which show no Shubnikov-de Haas oscillations) is distinct from that of the activated bulk. $E_{A}$ shrinks by 50% under fields up to 60 T. Data up to 93 T suggest that this trend continues beyond 100 T, in contrast with previous explanations. It rules out emerging theories to explain observed exotic magnetic quantum oscillations.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Conduction through subsurface cracks in bulk topological insulators
Authors:
S. Wolgast,
Y. S. Eo,
Ç. Kurdak,
D. -J. Kim,
Z. Fisk
Abstract:
Topological insulators (TIs) have the singular distinction of being electronic insulators while harboring metallic, conductive surfaces. In ordinary materials, defects such as cracks and deformations are barriers to electrical conduction, intuitively making the material more electrically resistive. Peculiarly, 3D TIs should become better conductors when they are cracked because the cracks themselv…
▽ More
Topological insulators (TIs) have the singular distinction of being electronic insulators while harboring metallic, conductive surfaces. In ordinary materials, defects such as cracks and deformations are barriers to electrical conduction, intuitively making the material more electrically resistive. Peculiarly, 3D TIs should become better conductors when they are cracked because the cracks themselves, which act as conductive topological surfaces, provide additional paths for the electrical current. Significantly, for a TI material, any surface or extended defect harbors such conduction. In this letter, we demonstrate that small subsurface cracks formed within the predicted 3D TI samarium hexaboride (SmB$_{6}$) via systematic scratching or sanding results in such an increase in the electrical conduction. SmB$_{6}$ is in a unique position among TIs to exhibit this effect because its single-crystals are thick enough to harbor cracks, and because it remarkably does not appear to suffer from conduction through bulk impurities. Our results not only strengthen the building case for SmB$_{6}$'s topological nature, but are relevant to all TIs with cracks, including TI films with grain boundaries.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Influence of Helical Spin Structure on the Magnetoresistance of an Ideal Topological Insulator
Authors:
Teoman Ozturk,
Richard L. Field III,
Yun Suk Eo,
Steven Wolgast,
Kai Sun,
Cagliyan Kurdak
Abstract:
In an ideal topological insulator, the helical spin structure of surface electrons suppresses backscattering and thus can enhance surface conductivity. We investigate the effect of perpendicular magnetic field on the spin structure of electrons at the Fermi energy and calculate a magnetic-field dependent topological enhancement factor for different disorder potentials, ranging from short-range dis…
▽ More
In an ideal topological insulator, the helical spin structure of surface electrons suppresses backscattering and thus can enhance surface conductivity. We investigate the effect of perpendicular magnetic field on the spin structure of electrons at the Fermi energy and calculate a magnetic-field dependent topological enhancement factor for different disorder potentials, ranging from short-range disorder to screened Coulomb potential. Within the Boltzmann approximation, the topological enhancement factor reaches its maximum value of 4 for a short-range disorder at zero magnetic field and approaches a value of 1 at high magnetic fields independent of the nature of the disorder potential.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2014; v1 submitted 2 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Hysteretic Magnetotransport in SmB6 at Low Magnetic Fields
Authors:
Yun Suk Eo,
Steven Wolgast,
Teoman Ozturk,
Gang Li,
Ziji Xiang,
Colin Tinsman,
Tomoya Asaba,
Fan Yu,
Benjamin Lawson,
James W. Allen,
Kai Sun,
Lu Li,
Cagliyan Kurdak,
Dae-Jeong Kim,
Zachary Fisk
Abstract:
Utilizing Corbino disc structures, we have examined the magnetic field response of resistivity for the surface states of SmB6 on different crystalline surfaces at low temperatures. Our results reveal a hysteretic behavior whose magnitude depends on the magnetic field sweep rate and temperature. Although this feature becomes smaller when the field sweep is slower, a complete elimination or saturati…
▽ More
Utilizing Corbino disc structures, we have examined the magnetic field response of resistivity for the surface states of SmB6 on different crystalline surfaces at low temperatures. Our results reveal a hysteretic behavior whose magnitude depends on the magnetic field sweep rate and temperature. Although this feature becomes smaller when the field sweep is slower, a complete elimination or saturation is not observed in our slowest sweep-rate measurements, which is much slower than a typical magnetotransport trace. These observations cannot be explained by quantum interference corrections such as weak anti-localization. Instead, they are consistent with behaviors of glassy surface magnetic ordering, whose magnetic origin is most likely from samarium oxide (Sm2O3) forming on the surface during exposure to ambient conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Magnetotransport Measurements of the Surface States of Samarium Hexaboride using Corbino Structures
Authors:
Steven Wolgast,
Yun Suk Eo,
Teoman Ozturk,
Gang Li,
Ziji Xiang,
Colin Tinsman,
Tomoya Asaba,
Ben Lawson,
Fan Yu,
J. W. Allen,
Kai Sun,
Lu Li,
Cagliyan Kurdak,
Dae-Jeong Kim,
Zachary Fisk
Abstract:
The recent conjecture of a topologically-protected surface state in SmB$_6$ and the verification of robust surface conduction below 4 K have prompted a large effort to understand the surface states. Conventional Hall transport measurements allow current to flow on all surfaces of a topological insulator, so such measurements are influenced by contributions from multiple surfaces of varying transpo…
▽ More
The recent conjecture of a topologically-protected surface state in SmB$_6$ and the verification of robust surface conduction below 4 K have prompted a large effort to understand the surface states. Conventional Hall transport measurements allow current to flow on all surfaces of a topological insulator, so such measurements are influenced by contributions from multiple surfaces of varying transport character. Instead, we study magnetotransport of SmB$_6$ using a Corbino geometry, which can directly measure the conductivity of a single, independent surface. Both (011) and (001) crystal surfaces show a strong negative magnetoresistance at all magnetic field angles measured. The (011) surface has a carrier mobility of $122\text{ cm}^2/\text{V}\cdot\text{sec}$ with a carrier density of $2.5\times10^{13} \text{ cm}^{-2}$, which are significantly smaller than indicated by Hall transport studies. This mobility value can explain a failure so far to observe Shubnikov-de Haas oscillations. Analysis of the angle-dependence of conductivity on the (011) surface suggests a combination of a field-dependent enhancement of the carrier density and a suppression of Kondo scattering from native oxide layer magnetic moments as the likely origin of the negative magnetoresistance. Our results also reveal a hysteretic behavior whose magnitude depends on the magnetic field sweep rate and temperature. Although this feature becomes smaller when the field sweep is slower, does not disappear or saturate during our slowest sweep-rate measurements, which is much slower than a typical magnetotransport trace. These observations cannot be explained by quantum interference corrections such as weak anti-localization, but are more likely due to an extrinsic magnetic effect such as the magnetocaloric effect or glassy ordering.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2015; v1 submitted 29 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Quantum oscillations in Kondo Insulator SmB$_6$
Authors:
G. Li,
Z. Xiang,
F. Yu,
T. Asaba,
B. Lawson,
P. Cai,
C. Tinsman,
A. Berkley,
S. Wolgast,
Y. S. Eo,
Dae-Jeong Kim,
C. Kurdak,
J. W. Allen,
K. Sun,
X. H. Chen,
Y. Y. Wang,
Z. Fisk,
Lu Li
Abstract:
In Kondo insulator samarium hexaboride SmB$_6$, strong correlation and band hybridization lead to an insulating gap and a diverging resistance at low temperature. The resistance divergence ends at about 5 Kelvin, a behavior recently demonstrated to arise from the surface conductance. However, questions remain whether and where a topological surface state exists. Quantum oscillations have not been…
▽ More
In Kondo insulator samarium hexaboride SmB$_6$, strong correlation and band hybridization lead to an insulating gap and a diverging resistance at low temperature. The resistance divergence ends at about 5 Kelvin, a behavior recently demonstrated to arise from the surface conductance. However, questions remain whether and where a topological surface state exists. Quantum oscillations have not been observed to map the Fermi surface. We solve the problem by resolving the Landau Level quantization and Fermi surface topology using torque magnetometry. The observed Fermi surface suggests a two dimensional surface state on the (101) plane. Furthermore, the tracking of the Landau Levels in the infinite magnetic field limit points to -1/2, which indicates a 2D Dirac electronic state.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Low-temperature surface conduction in the Kondo insulator SmB$_6$
Authors:
Steven Wolgast,
Cagliyan Kurdak,
Kai Sun,
J. W. Allen,
Dae-Jeong Kim,
Zachary Fisk
Abstract:
We study the transport properties of the Kondo insulator SmB$_6$ with a specialized configuration designed to distinguish bulk-dominated conduction from surface-dominated conduction. We find that as the material is cooled below 4 K, it exhibits a crossover from bulk to surface conduction with a fully insulating bulk. We take the robustness and magnitude of the surface conductivity, as is manifest…
▽ More
We study the transport properties of the Kondo insulator SmB$_6$ with a specialized configuration designed to distinguish bulk-dominated conduction from surface-dominated conduction. We find that as the material is cooled below 4 K, it exhibits a crossover from bulk to surface conduction with a fully insulating bulk. We take the robustness and magnitude of the surface conductivity, as is manifest in the literature of SmB$_6$, to be strong evidence for the topological insulator metallic surface states recently predicted for this material.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2013; v1 submitted 21 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
