-
First detection of CO$_2$ emission in a Centaur: JWST NIRSpec observations of 39P/Oterma
Authors:
O. Harrington Pinto,
M. S. P. Kelley,
G. L. Villanueva,
M. Womack,
S. Faggi,
A. McKay,
M. A. DiSanti,
C. Schambeau,
Y. Fernandez,
J. Bauer,
L. Feaga,
K. Wierzchos
Abstract:
Centaurs are minor solar system bodies with orbits transitioning between those of Trans-Neptunian Scattered Disk objects and Jupiter Family comets. 39P/Oterma is a frequently active Centaur that has recently held both Centaur and JFC classifications and was observed with the JWST NIRSpec instrument on 2022 July 27 UTC while it was 5.82 au from the Sun. For the first time, CO$_2$ gas emission was d…
▽ More
Centaurs are minor solar system bodies with orbits transitioning between those of Trans-Neptunian Scattered Disk objects and Jupiter Family comets. 39P/Oterma is a frequently active Centaur that has recently held both Centaur and JFC classifications and was observed with the JWST NIRSpec instrument on 2022 July 27 UTC while it was 5.82 au from the Sun. For the first time, CO$_2$ gas emission was detected in a Centaur, with a production rate of Q$_{CO_2}$ = (5.96 $\pm$ 0.80) $\times$ 10$^{23}$ molecules s$^{-1}$. This is the lowest detection of CO$_2$ of any Centaur or comet. CO and H$_2$O were not detected down to constraining upper limits. Derived mixing ratios of Q$_{CO}$/Q$_{CO_2}$ $\leq$2.03 and Q$_{CO_2}$/Q$_{H_2O}$ $\geq$0.60 are consistent with CO$_2$ and/or CO outgassing playing large roles in driving the activity, but not water, and show a significant difference between the coma abundances of 29P/Schwassmann-Wachmann 1, another Centaur at a similar heliocentric distance, which may be explained by thermal processing of 39P's surface during its previous Jupiter-family comet orbit. To help contextualize the JWST data we also acquired visible CCD imaging data on two dates in July (Gemini North) and September (Lowell Discovery Telescope) 2022. Image analysis and photometry based on these data are consistent with a point source detection and an estimated effective nucleus radius of 39P in the range of $R_{nuc}= $2.21 to 2.49~km.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
The LCO Outbursting Objects Key Project: Overview and Year 1 Status
Authors:
Tim Lister,
Michael S. P. Kelley,
Carrie E. Holt,
Henry H. Hsieh,
Michele T. Bannister,
Aayushi A. Verma,
Matthew M. Dobson,
Matthew M. Knight,
Youssef Moulane,
Megan E. Schwamb,
Dennis Bodewits,
James Bauer,
Joseph Chatelain,
Estela Fernández-Valenzuela,
Daniel Gardener,
Geza Gyuk,
Mark Hammergren,
Ky Huynh,
Emmanuel Jehin,
Rosita Kokotanekova,
Eva Lilly,
Man-To Hui,
Adam McKay,
Cyrielle Opitom,
Silvia Protopapa
, et al. (10 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The LCO Outbursting Objects Key (LOOK) Project uses the telescopes of the Las Cumbres Observatory (LCO) Network to: (1) to systematically monitor a sample of Dynamically New Comets over the whole sky, and (2) use alerts from existing sky surveys to rapidly respond to and characterize detected outburst activity in all small bodies. The data gathered on outbursts helps to characterize each outburst'…
▽ More
The LCO Outbursting Objects Key (LOOK) Project uses the telescopes of the Las Cumbres Observatory (LCO) Network to: (1) to systematically monitor a sample of Dynamically New Comets over the whole sky, and (2) use alerts from existing sky surveys to rapidly respond to and characterize detected outburst activity in all small bodies. The data gathered on outbursts helps to characterize each outburst's evolution with time, assess the frequency and magnitude distribution of outbursts in general, and contributes to the understanding of outburst processes and volatile distribution in the Solar System. The LOOK Project exploits the synergy between current and future wide-field surveys such as ZTF, PanSTARRS, and LSST as well as rapid-response telescope networks such as LCO, and serves as an excellent testbed for what will be needed the much larger number of objects coming from Rubin Observatory. We will describe the LOOK Project goals, the planning and target selection (including the use of NEOexchange as a Target and Observation Manager or "TOM"), and results from the first phase of observations, including the detection of activity and outbursts on the giant comet C/2014 UN271 (Bernardinelli-Bernstein) and the discovery and follow-up of outbursts on comets. Within these outburst discoveries, we present a high cadence of 7P/Pons-Winnecke with days, a large outburst on 57P/duToit-Neujmin-Delporte, and evidence that comet P/2020 X1 (ATLAS) was in outburst when discovered.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Establishing Earth's Minimoon Population through Characterization of Asteroid 2020 CD$_3$
Authors:
Grigori Fedorets,
Marco Micheli,
Robert Jedicke,
Shantanu P. Naidu,
Davide Farnocchia,
Mikael Granvik,
Nicholas Moskovitz,
Megan E. Schwamb,
Robert Weryk,
Kacper Wierzchoś,
Eric Christensen,
Theodore Pruyne,
William F. Bottke,
Quanzhi Ye,
Richard Wainscoat,
Maxime Devogèle,
Laura E. Buchanan,
Anlaug Amanda Djupvik,
Daniel M. Faes,
Dora Föhring,
Joel Roediger,
Tom Seccull,
Adam B. Smith
Abstract:
We report on our detailed characterization of Earth's second known temporary natural satellite, or minimoon, asteroid 2020 CD3. An artificial origin can be ruled out based on its area-to-mass ratio and broadband photometry, which suggest that it is a silicate asteroid belonging to the S or V complex in asteroid taxonomy. The discovery of 2020 CD3 allows for the first time a comparison between know…
▽ More
We report on our detailed characterization of Earth's second known temporary natural satellite, or minimoon, asteroid 2020 CD3. An artificial origin can be ruled out based on its area-to-mass ratio and broadband photometry, which suggest that it is a silicate asteroid belonging to the S or V complex in asteroid taxonomy. The discovery of 2020 CD3 allows for the first time a comparison between known minimoons and theoretical models of their expected physical and dynamical properties. The estimated diameter of 1.2+0.4-0.2 m and geocentric capture approximately a decade after the first known minimoon, 2006 RH120, are in agreement with theoretical predictions. The capture duration of 2020 CD3 of at least 2.7 yr is unexpectedly long compared to the simulation average, but it is in agreement with simulated minimoons that have close lunar encounters, providing additional support for the orbital models. 2020 CD3's atypical rotation period, significantly longer than theoretical predictions, suggests that our understanding of meter-scale asteroids needs revision. More discoveries and a detailed characterization of the population can be expected with the forthcoming Vera C. Rubin Observatory Legacy Survey of Space and Time.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Contemporaneous Multi-Wavelength and Precovery Observations of Active Centaur P/2019 LD2 (ATLAS
Authors:
Theodore Kareta,
Laura M. Woodney,
Charles Schambeau,
Yanga Fernandez,
Olga Harrington Pinto,
Kacper Wierzchos,
M. Womack,
S. J. Bus,
Jordan Steckloff,
Gal Sarid,
Kathryn Volk,
Walter M. Harris,
Vishnu Reddy
Abstract:
Gateway Centaur and Jupiter co-orbital P/2019 LD2 (ATLAS) (Sarid et al. 2019) provides the first opportunity to observe the migration of a Solar System small body from a Centaur orbit to a Jupiter Family Comet (JFC) four decades from now (Kareta et al., 2020; Hsieh et al. 2020). The Gateway transition region is beyond where water ice can power cometary activity, and coma production there is as poo…
▽ More
Gateway Centaur and Jupiter co-orbital P/2019 LD2 (ATLAS) (Sarid et al. 2019) provides the first opportunity to observe the migration of a Solar System small body from a Centaur orbit to a Jupiter Family Comet (JFC) four decades from now (Kareta et al., 2020; Hsieh et al. 2020). The Gateway transition region is beyond where water ice can power cometary activity, and coma production there is as poorly understood as in all Centaurs. We present contemporaneous multi-wavelength observations of LD2 from 2020 July 2-4: Gemini-North visible imaging, NASA IRTF near-infrared spectroscopy, and ARO SMT millimeter-wavelength spectroscopy. Precovery DECam images limit the nucleu's effective radius to <=1.2 km and no large outbursts were seen in archival Catalina Sky Survey observations. LD2's coma has g'-r'=0.70+/-0.07, r'-i'=0.26+/-0.07, a dust production rate of ~10-20 kg/s, and an outflow velocity between v~0.6-3.3 m/s. We did not detect CO towards LD2 on 2020 July 2-3, with a 3-sigma upper limit of Q(CO) < 4.4 * 10^27 mol/s (<200 kg/s). Near-infrared spectra show evidence for water ice at the 1-10% level depending on grain size. Spatial profiles and archival data are consistent with sustained activity. The evidence supports the hypothesis that LD2 is a typical small Centaur that will become a typical JFC, and thus it is critical to understanding the transition between these two populations. Finally, we discuss potential strategies for a community-wide, long baseline monitoring effort.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2021; v1 submitted 19 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
The visual lightcurve of comet C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp) from 1995-1999
Authors:
M. Womack,
O. Curtis,
D. A. Rabson,
O. Harrington Pinto,
K. Wierzchos,
S. Cruz Gonzalez,
G. Sarid,
C. Mentzer,
N. Lastra,
N. Pichette,
N. Ruffini,
T. Cox,
I. Rivera,
A. Micciche,
C. Jackson,
A. Homich,
S. Rosslyn Escoto,
T. Erdahl,
Marcel P. Goldschen-Ohm,
A. Tollison,
S. Reed,
J. Zilka,
B. Henning,
M. Spinar,
W. T. Uhl
Abstract:
The long-term brightness evolution of the great comet C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp) presented a remarkable opportunity to study the behavior of its coma over four years. We used approximately 2200 total visual magnitudes published in the International Comet Quarterly taken from 17 observers during the period of 1995 July - 1999 September to create a secular lightcurve. In order to account for observer dif…
▽ More
The long-term brightness evolution of the great comet C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp) presented a remarkable opportunity to study the behavior of its coma over four years. We used approximately 2200 total visual magnitudes published in the International Comet Quarterly taken from 17 observers during the period of 1995 July - 1999 September to create a secular lightcurve. In order to account for observer differences, we present a novel algorithm to reduce scatter and increase precision in a lightcurve compiled from many sources. It is implemented in a publicly available code, ICQSPLITTER. This code addresses the differences among observers by using a self-consistent statistical approach, leading to a sharper lightcurve, and improving the precision of the measured slopes. To first order, the comet's lightcurve approximately follows a r$^{-4}$ response for both pre- and post-perihelion distances. Interestingly, the pre-perihelion data are better fit with a fifth-order polynomial with inflection points at 4.0, 2.6, 2.1 and 1.1 au. We analyze these specific regions and find that they are associated with physical phenomena in the comet's evolution. Contrary to other reports, the lightcurve shows no evidence for the comet having been in outburst at discovery. Afrho values derived from the visual lightcurve data are consistent with a r$^{-1.5}$ dependence on heliocentric distance, which is similar in shape to those derived from spectroscopy and narrow-band photometry. We present correlation equations for visual magnitudes and CO and H2O production rates, which are consistent with the pre-perihelion visual magnitudes increasing almost entirely due to CO outgassing until a heliocentric distance of about 2.6 - 3.0 au. We also present two correlation equations that should prove highly useful for observation planning and data analysis, and can be generalized to be applicable to other comets.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
CO gas and dust outbursts from Centaur 29P/Schwassmann-Wachmann
Authors:
Kacper Wierzchos,
Maria Womack
Abstract:
29P/Schwassmann Wachmann is an unusual solar system object. Originally classified as a short-period comet, it is now known as a Centaur that recently transferred to its current orbit, and may become a Jupiter Family comet. It has exhibited a dust coma for over 90 years, and regularly undergoes significant dust outbursts. Carbon monoxide is routinely detected in high amounts and is typically assume…
▽ More
29P/Schwassmann Wachmann is an unusual solar system object. Originally classified as a short-period comet, it is now known as a Centaur that recently transferred to its current orbit, and may become a Jupiter Family comet. It has exhibited a dust coma for over 90 years, and regularly undergoes significant dust outbursts. Carbon monoxide is routinely detected in high amounts and is typically assumed to play a large role in generating the quiescent dust coma and outbursts. To test this hypothesis, we completed two 3-month long observing campaigns of the CO J=2-1 rotational line using the Arizona Radio Observatory 10m Sub-millimeter Telescope during 2016 and 2018-2019, and compared the results to visible magnitudes obtained at the same time. As the Centaur approached its 2019 perihelion, the quiescent dust coma grew $\sim$45\% in brightness, while it is unclear whether the quiescent CO production rate also increased. A doubling of the CO production rate on 2016 Feb 28.6 UT did not trigger an outburst nor a rise in dust production for at least 10 days. Similarly, two dust outbursts occurred in 2018 while CO production continued at quiescent rates. Two other dust outbursts may show gas involvement. The data indicate that CO- and dust-outbursts are not always well-correlated. This may be explained if CO is not always substantially incorporated with the dust component in the nucleus, or if CO is primarily released through a porous material. Additionally, other minor volatiles or physical processes may help generate dust outbursts.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
The Peculiar Volatile Composition of CO-Dominated Comet C/2016 R2 (PanSTARRS)
Authors:
Adam McKay,
Michael DiSanti,
Michael Kelley,
Matthew Knight,
Maria Womack,
Kacper Wierzchos,
Olga Harrington-Pinto,
Boncho Bonev,
Geronimo Villanueva,
Neil Dello Russo,
Anita Cochran,
Nicolas Biver,
James Bauer,
Ronald Vervack, Jr.,
Erika Gibbs,
Nathan Roth,
Hideyo Kawakita
Abstract:
Comet C/2016 R2 (PanSTARRS) has a peculiar volatile composition, with CO being the dominant volatile as opposed to H$_2$O and one of the largest N$_2$/CO ratios ever observed in a comet. Using observations obtained with the \textit{Spitzer Space Telescope}, NASA's Infrared Telescope Facility, the 3.5-meter ARC telescope at Apache Point Observatory, the Discovery Channel Telescope at Lowell Observa…
▽ More
Comet C/2016 R2 (PanSTARRS) has a peculiar volatile composition, with CO being the dominant volatile as opposed to H$_2$O and one of the largest N$_2$/CO ratios ever observed in a comet. Using observations obtained with the \textit{Spitzer Space Telescope}, NASA's Infrared Telescope Facility, the 3.5-meter ARC telescope at Apache Point Observatory, the Discovery Channel Telescope at Lowell Observatory, and the Arizona Radio Observatory 10-m Submillimeter Telescope we quantified the abundances of 12 different species in the coma of R2 PanSTARRS. We confirm the high abundances of CO and N$_2$ and heavy depletions of H$_2$O, HCN, CH$_3$OH, and H$_2$CO compared to CO reported by previous studies. We provide the first measurements (or most sensitive measurements/constraints) on H$_2$O, CO$_2$, CH$_4$, C$_2$H$_6$, OCS, C$_2$H$_2$, and NH$_3$, all of which are depleted relative to CO by at least one to two orders of magnitude compared to values commonly observed in comets. The observed species also show strong enhancements relative to H$_2$O, and even when compared to other species like CH$_4$ or CH$_3$OH most species show deviations from typical comets by at least a factor of two to three. The only mixing ratios found to be close to typical are CH$_3$OH/CO$_2$ and CH$_3$OH/CH$_4$. While R2 PanSTARRS was located at a heliocentric distance of 2.8 AU at the time of our observations in January/February 2018, we argue that this alone cannot account for the peculiar observed composition of this comet and therefore must reflect its intrinsic composition. We discuss possible implications for this clear outlier in compositional studies of comets obtained to date, and encourage future dynamical and chemical modeling in order to better understand what the composition of R2 PanSTARRS tells us about the early Solar System.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
C/2016 R2 (PANSTARRS): A comet rich in CO and depleted in HCN
Authors:
Kacper Wierzchos,
Maria Womack
Abstract:
We observed comet C/2016 R2 (PANSTARRS) with the ARO 10-m SMT, and report the first detection of CO emission from this comet with amounts high enough to be the primary driver of activity. We obtained spectra and maps of the CO J=2-1 rotational line at 230 GHz between 2017 December and 2018 January. We calculated an average production rate of Q(CO)=(4.6+/-0.4)x10$^{28}$ mol s$^{-1}$ at r ~2.9 au an…
▽ More
We observed comet C/2016 R2 (PANSTARRS) with the ARO 10-m SMT, and report the first detection of CO emission from this comet with amounts high enough to be the primary driver of activity. We obtained spectra and maps of the CO J=2-1 rotational line at 230 GHz between 2017 December and 2018 January. We calculated an average production rate of Q(CO)=(4.6+/-0.4)x10$^{28}$ mol s$^{-1}$ at r ~2.9 au and delta ~2.1 au. The CO line is thin FWHM ~ 0.8 km s$^{-1}$ with a slight blue-shift ~ -0.1 km s$^{-1}$ from the ephemeris velocity, and we derive a gas expansion velocity of V$_{exp}$ = 0.50+/-0.15 km s$^{-1}$. This comet produced approximately half the CO that comet C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp) did at 3 au. If CO production scales with nucleus surface area, then the radius need not exceed ~15 km. The spectra and map** data are consistent with CO arising from a combination of a sunward-side active area and an isotropic source. For HCN, we calculated a 3-sigma upper limit production rate of Q(HCN) < 8x10$^{24}$ molecules s$^{-1}$, which corresponds to an extraordinarily high abundance ratio limit of Q(CO)/Q(HCN) > 5000. We inferred a production rate of molecular nitrogen of Q(N$_2$) ~2.8x10$^{27}$ molecules s$^{-1}$ using our CO data and the reported N$_2$/CO column density ratio (Cochran & MacKay 2018a,b). The comet does not show the typical nitrogen depletion seen in comets, and the CO-rich, N$_2$-rich and HCN-depleted values are consistent with formation in a cold environment of T < 50 K that may have provided significant N$_2$ shielding.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Carbon monoxide in the distantly active Centaur (60558) 174P/Echeclus at 6 AU
Authors:
Kacper Wierzchos,
Maria Womack,
Gal Sarid
Abstract:
(60558) 174P/Echeclus is an unusual object that belongs to a class of minor planets called Centaurs, which may be intermediate between Kuiper Belt Objects and Jupiter Family comets. It is sporadically active throughout its orbit at distances too far for water ice to sublimate, the source of activity for most comets. Thus, its coma must be triggered by another mechanism. In 2005, Echeclus had a str…
▽ More
(60558) 174P/Echeclus is an unusual object that belongs to a class of minor planets called Centaurs, which may be intermediate between Kuiper Belt Objects and Jupiter Family comets. It is sporadically active throughout its orbit at distances too far for water ice to sublimate, the source of activity for most comets. Thus, its coma must be triggered by another mechanism. In 2005, Echeclus had a strong outburst with peculiar behavior that raised questions about the nucleus homogeneity. In order to test nucleus models, we performed the most sensitive search to date for the highly volatile CO molecule via its J=2-1 emission toward Echeclus during 2016 May-June (at 6.1 astronomical units from the Sun) using the Arizona Radio Observatory 10-m Submillimeter Telescope. We obtained a 3.6-sigma detection with a slightly blue-shifted (delta v = -0.55 +- 0.1 km/s) and narrow (FWHM = 0.53 +- 0.23 km/s) line. The data are consistent with emission from a cold gas from the sunward side of the nucleus, as seen in two other comets at 6 AU. We derive a production rate of Q(CO) = (7.7 +- 3.3)x10^26 mol/s, which is capable of driving the estimated dust production rates. Echeclus CO outgassing rate is ~40 times lower than what is typically seen for another Centaur at this distance, 29P/Schwassmann-Wachmann 1. We also used the IRAM 30-m telescope to search for the CO J=2-1 line, and derive an upper limit that is above the SMT detection. Compared to the relatively unprocessed comet C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp), Echeclus produces significantly less CO, as do Chiron and four other Centaurs.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
CO in distantly active comets
Authors:
Maria Womack,
Gal Sarid,
Kacper Wierzchos
Abstract:
Activity of most comets near the Sun is dominated by sublimation of frozen water, the most abundant ice in comets. Some comets, however, are active well beyond the water-ice sublimation limit of ~3 AU. Three bodies dominate the observational record and modeling efforts for distantly active comets: the long-period comet C/1995 O1 Hale-Bopp and the short-period comets (with Centaur orbits) 29P/Schwa…
▽ More
Activity of most comets near the Sun is dominated by sublimation of frozen water, the most abundant ice in comets. Some comets, however, are active well beyond the water-ice sublimation limit of ~3 AU. Three bodies dominate the observational record and modeling efforts for distantly active comets: the long-period comet C/1995 O1 Hale-Bopp and the short-period comets (with Centaur orbits) 29P/Schwassmann Wachmann 1 and 2060 Chiron. We summarize what is known about these three objects emphasizing their gaseous comae. We calculate their CN/CO and CO2/CO production rate ratios from the literature and discuss implications. Using our own data we derive CO production rates for all three objects, in order to examine a correlation between gas production and different orbital histories and/or size. We find that orbital history does not appear to play a significant role in explaining 29P's CO production rates. 29P outproduces Hale-Bopp at the same heliocentric distance, even though it has been subjected to much more solar heating. Previous modeling work on such objects predicts that 29P should have been de-volatilized over a fresher comet like Hale-Bopp. This may point to 29P having a different orbital history than current models predict, with its current orbit acquired more recently. On the other hand, Chiron's CO measurements are consistent with it being significantly depleted over its original state, perhaps due to increased radiogenic heating made possible by its much larger size or its higher processing due to orbital history. Observed spectral line profiles are consistent with development and sublimation of icy grains at about 5-6 AU for 29P and Hale-Bopp, and this is probably a common feature in distantly active comets, and an important source of volatiles for all comets within 5 AU. In contrast, the narrow CO line profiles indicate a nuclear, and not extended, origin for CO beyond ~4 AU.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2017; v1 submitted 31 October, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
