-
Higgs in a box: investigating the nature of a scientific discovery
Authors:
Julia Woithe,
Margherita Boselli,
Panagiota Chatzidaki,
Merten Nikolay Dahlkemper,
Ruadh Duggan,
Guillaume Durey,
Niklas Herff,
Anja Kranjc Horvat,
Daniele Molaro,
Gernot Werner Scheerer,
Sascha Schmeling,
Patrick Georges Thill,
Jeff Wiener,
Sarah Zoechling
Abstract:
The discovery of the Higgs boson by the ATLAS and CMS collaborations in 2012 concluded the longest search for a particle in the history of particle physics and was based on the largest and most complex physics experiments ever conducted, involving thousands of scientists and engineers from around the world. It provided crucial evidence for a theory developed in the 1960s that describes the existen…
▽ More
The discovery of the Higgs boson by the ATLAS and CMS collaborations in 2012 concluded the longest search for a particle in the history of particle physics and was based on the largest and most complex physics experiments ever conducted, involving thousands of scientists and engineers from around the world. It provided crucial evidence for a theory developed in the 1960s that describes the existence of the invisible Brout-Englert-Higgs field and the effects of this field on the mass of elementary particles. After the discovery, the work on the theoretical prediction was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics 2013. This discovery provides a prime example of modern science in the making and a fantastic opportunity to discuss important aspects of Nature of Science (NoS) in the classroom. In this article, we draw connections between a) milestones in the discovery of the Higgs boson, b) important aspects of NoS, and c) hands-on activities with mystery boxes, which are an effective tool to enable students to experience elements of scientific discovery and explicitly reflect on NoS. We hope that this supports educators in bringing lively discussions about modern physics research into their classrooms.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2022; v1 submitted 13 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Catalyzing collaborations: Prescribed interactions at conferences determine team formation
Authors:
Emma R. Zajdela,
Kimberly Huynh,
Andy T. Wen,
Andrew L. Feig,
Richard J. Wiener,
Daniel M. Abrams
Abstract:
Collaboration plays a key role in knowledge production. Here, we show that patterns of interaction during conferences can be used to predict who will subsequently form a new collaboration, even when interaction is prescribed rather than freely chosen. We introduce a novel longitudinal dataset tracking patterns of interaction among hundreds of scientists during multi-day conferences encompassing di…
▽ More
Collaboration plays a key role in knowledge production. Here, we show that patterns of interaction during conferences can be used to predict who will subsequently form a new collaboration, even when interaction is prescribed rather than freely chosen. We introduce a novel longitudinal dataset tracking patterns of interaction among hundreds of scientists during multi-day conferences encompassing different scientific fields over the span of 5 years. We find that participants who formed new collaborations interacted 63% more on average than those who chose not to form new teams, and that those assigned to a higher interaction scenario had more than an eightfold increase in their odds of collaborating. We propose a simple mathematical framework for the process of team formation that incorporates this observation as well as the effect of memory beyond interaction time. The model accurately reproduces the collaborations formed across all conferences and outperforms seven other candidate models. This work not only suggests that encounters between individuals at conferences play an important role in sha** the future of science, but that these encounters can be designed to better catalyze collaborations.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Optimal Design of Multi-Layer Fog Collectors
Authors:
Musaddaq Azeem,
Adrien Guèrin,
Thomas Dumais,
Luis Caminos,
Raymond E. Goldstein,
Adriana I. Pesci,
Juan de Dios Rivera,
María Josefina Torres,
Jakub Wiener,
José Luis Campos,
Jacques Dumais
Abstract:
The growing concerns over desertification have spurred research into technologies aimed at acquiring water from non-traditional sources such as dew, fog, and water vapor. Some of the most promising developments have focused on improving designs to collect water from fog. However, the absence of a shared framework to predict, measure and compare the water collection efficiencies of new prototypes i…
▽ More
The growing concerns over desertification have spurred research into technologies aimed at acquiring water from non-traditional sources such as dew, fog, and water vapor. Some of the most promising developments have focused on improving designs to collect water from fog. However, the absence of a shared framework to predict, measure and compare the water collection efficiencies of new prototypes is becoming a major obstacle to progress in the field. We address this problem by providing a general theory to design efficient fog collectors as well as a concrete experimental protocol to furnish our theory with all the necessary parameters to quantify the effective water collection efficiency. We show in particular that multi-layer collectors are required for high fog collection efficiency and that all efficient designs are found within a narrow range of mesh porosity. We support our conclusions with measurements on simple multi-layer harp collectors.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2020; v1 submitted 27 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Cosmic Ray Acceleration of Cool Clouds in the Circumgalactic Medium
Authors:
Joshua Wiener,
Ellen G. Zweibel,
Mateusz Ruszkowski
Abstract:
We investigate a mechanism for accelerating cool (10$^4$ K) clouds in the circumgalactic medium (CGM) with cosmic rays (CRs), possibly explaining some characteristics of observed high velocity clouds (HVCs). Enforcing CRs to stream down their pressure gradient into a region of slow streaming speed results in significant buildup of CR pressure which can accelerate the CGM. We present the results of…
▽ More
We investigate a mechanism for accelerating cool (10$^4$ K) clouds in the circumgalactic medium (CGM) with cosmic rays (CRs), possibly explaining some characteristics of observed high velocity clouds (HVCs). Enforcing CRs to stream down their pressure gradient into a region of slow streaming speed results in significant buildup of CR pressure which can accelerate the CGM. We present the results of the first two-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations of such `CR bottlenecks,' expanding on simpler simulations in 1D from \cite{wiener17a}. Although much more investigation is required, we find two main results. First, radiative cooling in the interfaces of these clouds is sufficient to keep the cloud intact to CR wave heating. Second, cloud acceleration depends almost linearly with the injected CR flux at low values (comparable to that expected from a Milky Way-like star formation rate), but scales sublinearly at higher CR fluxes in 1D simulations. 2D simulations show hints of sublinear dependence at high CR fluxes but are consistent with pure linear dependence up to the CR fluxes tested. It is therefore plausible to accelerate cool clouds in the CGM to speeds of hundreds of km s$^{-1}$.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Constraints on Cosmic Ray Transport in Galaxy Clusters from Radio and Gamma Ray Observations
Authors:
Joshua Wiener,
Ellen G. Zweibel
Abstract:
The nature of cosmic rays (CRs) and cosmic ray transport in galaxy clusters is probed by a number of observations. Radio observations reveal the synchrotron radiation of cosmic ray electrons (CRe) spiraling around cluster magnetic fields. $γ$-ray observations reveal hadronic reactions of cosmic ray protons (CRp) with ambient gas nuclei which produce pions. To date, no such cluster-wide $γ$-ray sig…
▽ More
The nature of cosmic rays (CRs) and cosmic ray transport in galaxy clusters is probed by a number of observations. Radio observations reveal the synchrotron radiation of cosmic ray electrons (CRe) spiraling around cluster magnetic fields. $γ$-ray observations reveal hadronic reactions of cosmic ray protons (CRp) with ambient gas nuclei which produce pions. To date, no such cluster-wide $γ$-ray signal has been measured, putting an upper limit on the density of CRp present in clusters. But the presence of CRe implies some source of CRp, and consequently there must be some CRp loss mechanism. In this paper we quantify the observational constraints on this loss mechanism assuming that losses are dominated by CR transport, ultimately deriving a minimum diffusion coefficient of $\sim10^{31}$ cm$^2$ s$^{-1}$ in the Coma cluster. This lower limit on transport may help illuminate some unknown properties of the cluster field topology. Conversely, measurements of cluster field tangling scales can constrain other model parameters, such as the relative acceleration efficiency of protons to electrons. To be consistent with the Coma observations, protons cannot be accelerated more than 15 times more efficiently than electrons of the same energy.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2019; v1 submitted 5 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
High $β$ Effects on Cosmic Ray Streaming in Galaxy Clusters
Authors:
Joshua Wiener,
Ellen G. Zweibel,
S. Peng Oh
Abstract:
Diffuse, extended radio emission in galaxy clusters, commonly referred to as radio halos, indicate the presence of high energy cosmic ray (CR) electrons and cluster-wide magnetic fields. We can predict from theory the expected surface brightness of a radio halo, given magnetic field and CR density profiles. Previous studies have shown that the nature of CR transport can radically effect the expect…
▽ More
Diffuse, extended radio emission in galaxy clusters, commonly referred to as radio halos, indicate the presence of high energy cosmic ray (CR) electrons and cluster-wide magnetic fields. We can predict from theory the expected surface brightness of a radio halo, given magnetic field and CR density profiles. Previous studies have shown that the nature of CR transport can radically effect the expected radio halo emission from clusters (Wiener et al. 2013). Reasonable levels of magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) wave dam** can lead to significant CR streaming speeds. But a careful treatment of MHD waves in a high $β$ plasma, as expected in cluster environments, reveals dam** rates may be enhanced by a factor of $β^{1/2}$. This leads to faster CR streaming and lower surface brightnesses than without this effect. In this work we re-examine the simplified, 1D Coma cluster simulations (with radial magnetic fields) of Wiener et al. (2013) and discuss observable consequences of this high $β$ dam**. Future work is required to study this effect in more realistic simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2017; v1 submitted 26 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Interaction of Cosmic Rays with Cold Clouds in Galactic Halos
Authors:
Joshua Wiener,
S. Peng Oh,
Ellen G. Zweibel
Abstract:
We investigate the effects of cosmic ray (CR) dynamics on cold, dense clouds embedded in a hot, tenuous galactic halo. If the magnetic field does not increase too much inside the cloud, the local reduction in Alfvén speed imposes a bottleneck on CRs streaming out from the star-forming galactic disk. The bottleneck flattens the upstream CR gradient in the hot gas, implying that multi-phase structur…
▽ More
We investigate the effects of cosmic ray (CR) dynamics on cold, dense clouds embedded in a hot, tenuous galactic halo. If the magnetic field does not increase too much inside the cloud, the local reduction in Alfvén speed imposes a bottleneck on CRs streaming out from the star-forming galactic disk. The bottleneck flattens the upstream CR gradient in the hot gas, implying that multi-phase structure could have global effects on CR driven winds. A large CR pressure gradient can also develop on the outward-facing edge of the cloud. This pressure gradient has two independent effects. The CRs push the cloud upward, imparting it with momentum. On smaller scales, the CRs pressurize cold gas in the fronts, reducing its density, consistent with the low densities of cold gas inferred in recent COS observations of local $L_{*}$ galaxies. They also heat the material at the cloud edge, broadening the cloud-halo interface and causing an observable change in interface ionic abundances. Due to the much weaker temperature dependence of cosmic ray heating relative to thermal conductive heating, CR mediated fronts have a higher ratio of low to high ions compared to conduction fronts, in better agreement with observations. We investigate these effects separately using 1D simulations and analytic techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2017; v1 submitted 6 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Cosmic ray-driven galactic winds: streaming or diffusion?
Authors:
Joshua Wiener,
Christoph Pfrommer,
S. Peng Oh
Abstract:
Cosmic rays (CRs) have recently re-emerged as attractive candidates for mediating feedback in galaxies because of their long cooling timescales. They can have energy densities comparable to the thermal gas, but do not suffer catastrophic cooling losses. Recent simulations have shown that the momentum and energy deposited by CRs moving with respect to the ambient medium can drive galactic winds. Ho…
▽ More
Cosmic rays (CRs) have recently re-emerged as attractive candidates for mediating feedback in galaxies because of their long cooling timescales. They can have energy densities comparable to the thermal gas, but do not suffer catastrophic cooling losses. Recent simulations have shown that the momentum and energy deposited by CRs moving with respect to the ambient medium can drive galactic winds. However, simulations are hampered by our ignorance of the details of CR transport. Two key limits previously considered model CR transport as a purely diffusive process (with a constant diffusion coefficient) and as an advective streaming process. With a series of GADGET simulations, we compare and contrast the results of these different assumptions. In idealised three-dimensional galaxy formation models, we show that these two cases result in significant differences for the galactic wind mass loss rates and star formation suppression in dwarf galaxies with halo masses $M\approx10^{10}\,\textrm{M}_\odot$: diffusive CR transport results in more than ten times larger mass loss rates compared to CR streaming models. We demonstrate that this is largely due to the excitation of Alfvén waves during the CR streaming process that drains energy from the CR population to the thermal gas, which is subsequently radiated away. By contrast, CR diffusion conserves the CR energy in the absence of adiabatic changes and if CRs are efficiently scattered by Alfvén waves that are propagating up the CR gradient. Moreover, because pressure gradients are preserved by CR streaming, but not diffusion, the two can have a significantly different dynamical evolution regardless of this energy exchange. In particular, the constant diffusion coefficients usually assumed can lead to unphysically high CR fluxes.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2017; v1 submitted 8 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Cosmic Ray Streaming in Clusters of Galaxies
Authors:
Joshua Wiener,
S Peng Oh,
Fulai Guo
Abstract:
The observed bimodality in radio luminosity in galaxy clusters is puzzling. We investigate the possibility that cosmic-ray (CR) streaming in the intra-cluster medium can 'switch off' hadronically induced radio and gamma-ray emission. For self-confined CRs, this depends on the source of MHD wave dam**: if only non-linear Landau dam** operates, then CRs stream on the slow Alfvenic timescale, but…
▽ More
The observed bimodality in radio luminosity in galaxy clusters is puzzling. We investigate the possibility that cosmic-ray (CR) streaming in the intra-cluster medium can 'switch off' hadronically induced radio and gamma-ray emission. For self-confined CRs, this depends on the source of MHD wave dam**: if only non-linear Landau dam** operates, then CRs stream on the slow Alfvenic timescale, but if turbulent wave dam** operates, super-Alfvenic streaming is possible. As turbulence increases, it promotes outward streaming more than it enables inward turbulent advection. Curiously, the CR flux is independent of $\nabla f$ (as long as it is non-zero) and depends only on plasma parameters; this enables radio halos with flat inferred CR profiles to turn off. We perform 1D time-dependent calculations of a radio mini-halo (Perseus) and giant radio halo (Coma) and find that both diminish in radio luminosity by an order of magnitude in several hundred Myr, given plausible estimates for the magnetic field in the outskirts of the cluster. Due to the energy dependence of CR streaming, spectral curvature develops, and radio halos turn off more slowly at low frequencies -- properties consistent with observations. Similarly, CR streaming rapidly turns off gamma-ray emission at the high-energies probed by Cherenkov telescopes, but not at the low energies probed by Fermi. CR mediated wave-heating of the ICM is unaffected, as it is dominated by ~GeV CRs which stream Alfvenically.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
Cosmic Ray Heating of the Warm Ionized Medium
Authors:
Joshua Wiener,
Ellen G. Zweibel,
S. Peng Oh
Abstract:
Observations of line ratios in the Milky Way's warm ionized medium (WIM) suggest that photoionization is not the only heating mechanism present. For the additional heating to explain the discrepancy it would have to have a weaker dependence on the gas density than the cooling rate, $Λn_e^2$. \cite{reynolds99} suggested turbulent dissipation or magnetic field reconnection as possible heating source…
▽ More
Observations of line ratios in the Milky Way's warm ionized medium (WIM) suggest that photoionization is not the only heating mechanism present. For the additional heating to explain the discrepancy it would have to have a weaker dependence on the gas density than the cooling rate, $Λn_e^2$. \cite{reynolds99} suggested turbulent dissipation or magnetic field reconnection as possible heating sources. We investigate here the viability of MHD-wave mediated cosmic ray heating as a supplemental heating source. This heating rate depends on the gas density only through its linear dependence on the Alfvén speed, which goes as $n_e^{-1/2}$. We show that, scaled to appropriate values of cosmic ray energy density, cosmic ray heating can be significant. Furthermore, this heating is stable to perturbations. These results should also apply to warm ionized gas in other galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
A mathematical model of social group competition with application to the growth of religious non-affiliation
Authors:
Daniel M. Abrams,
Haley A. Yaple,
Richard J. Wiener
Abstract:
When groups compete for members, the resulting dynamics of human social activity may be understandable with simple mathematical models. Here, we apply techniques from dynamical systems and perturbation theory to analyze a theoretical framework for the growth and decline of competing social groups. We present a new treatment of the competition for adherents between religious and irreligious segment…
▽ More
When groups compete for members, the resulting dynamics of human social activity may be understandable with simple mathematical models. Here, we apply techniques from dynamical systems and perturbation theory to analyze a theoretical framework for the growth and decline of competing social groups. We present a new treatment of the competition for adherents between religious and irreligious segments of modern secular societies and compile a new international data set tracking the growth of religious non-affiliation. Data suggest a particular case of our general growth law, leading to clear predictions about possible future trends in society.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2011; v1 submitted 6 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
Visualizing the robustness of query execution
Authors:
Goetz Graefe,
Harumi Kuno,
Janet Wiener
Abstract:
In database query processing, actual run-time conditions (e.g., actual selectivities and actual available memory) very often differ from compile-time expectations of run-time conditions (e.g., estimated predicate selectivities and anticipated memory availability). Robustness of query processing can be defined as the ability to handle unexpected conditions. Robustness of query execution, specific…
▽ More
In database query processing, actual run-time conditions (e.g., actual selectivities and actual available memory) very often differ from compile-time expectations of run-time conditions (e.g., estimated predicate selectivities and anticipated memory availability). Robustness of query processing can be defined as the ability to handle unexpected conditions. Robustness of query execution, specifically, can be defined as the ability to process a specific plan efficiently in an unexpected condition. We focus on query execution (run-time), ignoring query optimization (compile-time), in order to complement existing research and to explore untapped potential for improved robustness in database query processing.
One of our initial steps has been to devise diagrams or maps that show how well plans perform in the face of varying run-time conditions and how gracefully a system's query architecture, operators, and their implementation degrade in the face of adverse conditions. In this paper, we show several kinds of diagrams with data from three real systems and report on what we have learned both about these visualization techniques and about the three database systems
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
Localized transverse bursts in inclined layer convection
Authors:
Karen E. Daniels,
Richard J. Wiener,
Eberhard Bodenschatz
Abstract:
We investigate a novel bursting state in inclined layer thermal convection in which convection rolls exhibit intermittent, localized, transverse bursts. With increasing temperature difference, the bursts increase in duration and number while exhibiting a characteristic wavenumber, magnitude, and size. We propose a mechanism which describes the duration of the observed bursting intervals and comp…
▽ More
We investigate a novel bursting state in inclined layer thermal convection in which convection rolls exhibit intermittent, localized, transverse bursts. With increasing temperature difference, the bursts increase in duration and number while exhibiting a characteristic wavenumber, magnitude, and size. We propose a mechanism which describes the duration of the observed bursting intervals and compare our results to bursting processes in other systems.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2002;
originally announced August 2002.
-
Asymmetries between the production of D+ and D- mesons from 500 GeV/c pi- nucleon interactions as a function of xF and pt**2
Authors:
E. M. Aitala,
S. Amato,
J. C. Anjos,
J. A. Appel,
M. Aryal,
D. Ashery,
J. Astorga,
S. Banerjee,
I. Bediaga,
G. Blaylock,
S. B. Bracker,
P. R. Burchat,
R. A. Burnstein,
T. Carter,
H. S. Carvalho,
I. Costa,
L. M. Cremaldi,
C. Darling,
K. Denisenko,
A. Fernandez,
P. Gagnon,
S. Gerzon,
C. Gobel,
K. Gounder,
D. Granite
, et al. (53 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present asymmetries between the production of D+ and D- mesons in Fermilab experiment E791 as a function of xF and pt**2. The data used here consist of 74,000 fully-reconstructed charmed mesons produced by a 500 GeV/c pi- beam on C and Pt foils. The measurements are compared to results of models which predict differences between the production of heavy-quark mesons that have a light quark in…
▽ More
We present asymmetries between the production of D+ and D- mesons in Fermilab experiment E791 as a function of xF and pt**2. The data used here consist of 74,000 fully-reconstructed charmed mesons produced by a 500 GeV/c pi- beam on C and Pt foils. The measurements are compared to results of models which predict differences between the production of heavy-quark mesons that have a light quark in common with the beam (leading particles) and those that do not (non-leading particles). While the default models do not agree with our data, we can reach agreement with one of them, PYTHIA, by making a limited number of changes to parameters used.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 1996;
originally announced January 1996.