-
Wind-Fed GRMHD Simulations of Sagittarius A*: Tilt and Alignment of Jets and Accretion Discs, Electron Thermodynamics, and Multi-Scale Modeling of the Rotation Measure
Authors:
Sean M. Ressler,
Christopher J. White,
Eliot Quataert
Abstract:
Wind-fed models offer a unique way to form predictive models of the accretion flow surrounding Sagittarius A*. We present 3D, wind-fed MHD and GRMHD simulations spanning the entire dynamic range of accretion from parsec scales to the event horizon. We expand on previous work by including nonzero black hole spin and dynamically evolved electron thermodynamics. Initial conditions for these simulatio…
▽ More
Wind-fed models offer a unique way to form predictive models of the accretion flow surrounding Sagittarius A*. We present 3D, wind-fed MHD and GRMHD simulations spanning the entire dynamic range of accretion from parsec scales to the event horizon. We expand on previous work by including nonzero black hole spin and dynamically evolved electron thermodynamics. Initial conditions for these simulations are generated from simulations of the observed Wolf-Rayet stellar winds in the Galactic Centre. The resulting flow tends to be highly magnetized ($β\approx 2$) with an $\sim$ $r^{-1}$ density profile independent of the strength of magnetic fields in the winds. Our simulations reach the MAD state for some, but not all cases. In tilted flows, SANE jets tend to align with the angular momentum of the gas at large scales, even if that direction is perpendicular to the black hole spin axis. Conversely, MAD jets tend to align with the black hole spin axis. The gas angular momentum shows similar behavior: SANE flows tend to only partially align while MAD flows tend to fully align. With a limited number of dynamical free parameters, our models can produce accretion rates, 230 GHz flux, and unresolved linear polarization fractions roughly consistent with observations for several choices of electron heating fraction. Absent another source of large-scale magnetic field, winds with a higher degree of magnetization (e.g., where the magnetic pressure is 1/100 of the ram pressure in the winds) may be required to get a sufficiently large RM with consistent sign.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
The Gravitational-Wave Signature of Core-Collapse Supernovae
Authors:
David Vartanyan,
Adam Burrows,
Tianshu Wang,
Matthew S. B. Coleman,
Christopher J. White
Abstract:
We calculate the gravitational-wave (GW) signatures of detailed 3D core-collapse supernova simulations spanning a range of massive stars. Most of the simulations are carried out to times late enough to capture more than 95% of the total GW emission. We find that the f/g-mode and f-mode of proto-neutron star oscillations carry away most of the GW power. The f-mode frequency inexorably rises as the…
▽ More
We calculate the gravitational-wave (GW) signatures of detailed 3D core-collapse supernova simulations spanning a range of massive stars. Most of the simulations are carried out to times late enough to capture more than 95% of the total GW emission. We find that the f/g-mode and f-mode of proto-neutron star oscillations carry away most of the GW power. The f-mode frequency inexorably rises as the proto-neutron star (PNS) core shrinks. We demonstrate that the GW emission is excited mostly by accretion plumes onto the PNS that energize modal oscillations and also high-frequency (``haze") emission correlated with the phase of violent accretion. The duration of the major phase of emission varies with exploding progenitor and there is a strong correlation between the total GW energy radiated and the compactness of the progenitor. Moreover, the total GW emissions vary by as much as three orders of magnitude from star to star. For black-hole formation, the GW signal tapers off slowly and does not manifest the haze seen for the exploding models. For such failed models, we also witness the emergence of a spiral shock motion that modulates the GW emission at a frequency near $\sim$100 Hertz that slowly increases as the stalled shock sinks. We find significant angular anisotropy of both the high- and low-frequency (memory) GW emissions, though the latter have very little power.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2023; v1 submitted 6 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
An Extension of the Athena++ Code Framework for Radiation-Magnetohydrodynamics in General Relativity Using a Finite-Solid-Angle Discretization
Authors:
Christopher J. White,
Patrick D. Mullen,
Yan-Fei Jiang,
Shane W. Davis,
James M. Stone,
Viktoriya Morozova,
Lizhong Zhang
Abstract:
We extend the general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamics (GRMHD) capabilities of Athena++ to incorporate radiation. The intensity field in each finite-volume cell is discretized in angle, with explicit transport in both space and angle properly accounting for the effects of gravity on null geodesics, and with matter and radiation coupled in a locally implicit fashion. Here we describe the numerical…
▽ More
We extend the general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamics (GRMHD) capabilities of Athena++ to incorporate radiation. The intensity field in each finite-volume cell is discretized in angle, with explicit transport in both space and angle properly accounting for the effects of gravity on null geodesics, and with matter and radiation coupled in a locally implicit fashion. Here we describe the numerical procedure in detail, verifying its correctness with a suite of tests. Motivated in particular by black hole accretion in the high-accretion-rate, thin-disk regime, we demonstrate the application of the method to this problem. With excellent scaling on flagship computing clusters, the port of the algorithm to the GPU-enabled AthenaK code now allows the simulation of many previously intractable radiation-GRMHD systems.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2023; v1 submitted 8 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Millimeter Observational Signatures of Flares in Magnetically Arrested Black Hole Accretion Models
Authors:
He Jia,
Bart Ripperda,
Eliot Quataert,
Christopher J. White,
Koushik Chatterjee,
Alexander Philippov,
Matthew Liska
Abstract:
In general relativistic magneto-hydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations, accreted magnetic flux on the black hole horizon episodically decays, during which magnetic reconnection heats up the plasma near the horizon, potentially powering high-energy flares like those observed in M87* and Sgr A*. We study the mm observational counterparts of such flaring episodes. The change in 230 GHz flux during the expe…
▽ More
In general relativistic magneto-hydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations, accreted magnetic flux on the black hole horizon episodically decays, during which magnetic reconnection heats up the plasma near the horizon, potentially powering high-energy flares like those observed in M87* and Sgr A*. We study the mm observational counterparts of such flaring episodes. The change in 230 GHz flux during the expected high energy flares depends primarily on the efficiency of accelerating $γ\gtrsim 100$ ($T_e \gtrsim 10^{11}$ K) electrons. For models in which the electrons are heated to $T_e \sim 10^{11}$ K during flares, the hot plasma produced by reconnection significantly enhances 230 GHz emission and increases the size of the 230 GHz image. By contrast, for models in which the electrons are heated to higher temperatures (which we argue are better motivated), the reconnection-heated plasma is too hot to produce significant 230 GHz synchrotron emission, and the 230 GHz flux decreases during high energy flares. We do not find a significant change in the mm polarization during flares as long as the emission is Faraday thin. We also present expectations for the ring-shaped image as observed by the Event Horizon Telescope during flares, as well as multi-wavelength synchrotron spectra. Our results highlight several limitations of standard post-processing prescriptions for the electron temperature in GRMHD simulations. We also discuss the implications of our results for current and future observations of flares in Sgr A*, M87*, and related systems. Appendices contain detailed convergence studies with respect to resolution and plasma magnetization.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2023; v1 submitted 21 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Magnetic Flux Transport in Radiatively Inefficient Accretion Flows and the Pathway towards a Magnetically Arrested Disk
Authors:
Prasun Dhang,
Xue-Ning Bai,
Christopher J. White
Abstract:
Large-scale magnetic fields play a vital role in determining the angular momentum transport and generating jets/outflows in the accreting systems, yet their origin remains poorly understood. We focus on radiatively inefficient accretion flows (RIAFs) around the black holes (BHs), and conduct three-dimensional general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations using the Athena++ code. We…
▽ More
Large-scale magnetic fields play a vital role in determining the angular momentum transport and generating jets/outflows in the accreting systems, yet their origin remains poorly understood. We focus on radiatively inefficient accretion flows (RIAFs) around the black holes (BHs), and conduct three-dimensional general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations using the Athena++ code. We first re-confirm that the MRI dynamo in the RIAF alone does not spontaneously form a magnetically arrested disk (MAD), conducive for strong jet formation. We next investigate the other possibility, where the large-scale magnetic fields are advected inward from external sources (e.g. the companion star in X-ray binaries, magnetized ambient medium in AGNs). Although the actual configuration of the external fields could be complex and uncertain, they are likely to be closed. As a first study, we treat them as closed field loops of different sizes, shapes and field strengths. Unlike earlier studies of flux transport, where magnetic flux is injected in the initial laminar flow, we injected the magnetic field loops in the quasi-stationary turbulent RIAF in inflow equilibrium and followed their evolution. We found that a substantial fraction ($\sim15\%-40\%$) of the flux injected at the large radii reaches the BH with a weak dependence on the loop parameters except when the loops are injected at high latitudes, away from the mid-plane. Relatively high efficiency of flux transport observed in our study hints that a MAD might be formed relatively easily close to the BH, provided that a source of the large-scale field exists at the larger radii.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2023; v1 submitted 3 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Remarkable correspondence of Sagittarius A* submillimeter variability with a stellar-wind-fed accretion flow model
Authors:
Lena Murchikova,
Christopher J. White,
Sean M. Ressler
Abstract:
We compare the 230 GHz near-horizon emission from Sagittarius A* to simulations representing three classes of accretion flows. Using the structure function to capture the variability statistics of the light curve, we find a noticeable discrepancy between the observations and models based on torus-fed accretion disks, whether those disks bring in a small or large amount of net magnetic flux. On the…
▽ More
We compare the 230 GHz near-horizon emission from Sagittarius A* to simulations representing three classes of accretion flows. Using the structure function to capture the variability statistics of the light curve, we find a noticeable discrepancy between the observations and models based on torus-fed accretion disks, whether those disks bring in a small or large amount of net magnetic flux. On the other hand, the simulations that are fed more realistically by stellar winds match the observed structure function very well. We describe the differences between models, arguing that feeding by stellar winds may be a critical component in constructing theoretical models for accretion in the Galactic Center.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Blacklight: A General-Relativistic Ray-Tracing and Analysis Tool
Authors:
Christopher J. White
Abstract:
We describe the Blacklight code, intended for post-processing general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulation data. Beyond polarized ray tracing of synchrotron radiation, it can produce a number of outputs that aid in analyzing data sets, such as maps of auxiliary quantities and false-color renderings. Additional features include support for adaptive mesh refinement input, slow-light calculati…
▽ More
We describe the Blacklight code, intended for post-processing general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulation data. Beyond polarized ray tracing of synchrotron radiation, it can produce a number of outputs that aid in analyzing data sets, such as maps of auxiliary quantities and false-color renderings. Additional features include support for adaptive mesh refinement input, slow-light calculations, and adaptive ray tracing. The code is written with ease of use, readability, and transparency as primary objectives, while it still achieves high performance. Blacklight is publicly available and released into the public domain.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2022; v1 submitted 29 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Observational Signatures of Black Hole Accretion: Rotating vs. Spherical Flows with Tilted Magnetic Fields
Authors:
He Jia,
Christopher J. White,
Eliot Quataert,
Sean M. Ressler
Abstract:
We study the observational signatures of magnetically arrested black hole accretion with non-rotating inflow onto a rotating black hole; we consider a range of angles between the black hole spin and the initial magnetic field orientation. We compare the results of our General Relativistic Magneto-Hydrodynamic simulations to more commonly used rotating initial conditions and to the Event Horizon Te…
▽ More
We study the observational signatures of magnetically arrested black hole accretion with non-rotating inflow onto a rotating black hole; we consider a range of angles between the black hole spin and the initial magnetic field orientation. We compare the results of our General Relativistic Magneto-Hydrodynamic simulations to more commonly used rotating initial conditions and to the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) observations of M87. We find that the mm intensity images, polarization images, and synchrotron emission spectra are very similar among the different simulations when post-processed with the same electron temperature model; observational differences due to different electron temperature models are significantly larger than those due to the different realizations of magnetically arrested accretion. The orientation of the mm synchrotron polarization is particularly insensitive to the initial magnetic field orientation, the electron temperature model, and the rotation of the inflowing plasma. The largest difference among the simulations with different initial rotation and magnetic tilt is in the strength and stability of the jet; spherical inflow leads to kink-unstable jets. We discuss the implications of our results for current and future EHT observations and for theoretical models of event-horizon-scale black hole accretion.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2022; v1 submitted 20 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
On the Origin of Pulsar and Magnetar Magnetic Fields
Authors:
Christopher J. White,
Adam Burrows,
Matthew S. B. Coleman,
David Vartanyan
Abstract:
In order to address the generation of neutron star magnetic fields, with particular focus on the dichotomy between magnetars and radio pulsars, we consider the properties of dynamos as inferred from other astrophysical systems. With sufficiently low (modified) Rossby number, convective dynamos are known to produce dipole-dominated fields whose strength scales with convective flux, and we argue tha…
▽ More
In order to address the generation of neutron star magnetic fields, with particular focus on the dichotomy between magnetars and radio pulsars, we consider the properties of dynamos as inferred from other astrophysical systems. With sufficiently low (modified) Rossby number, convective dynamos are known to produce dipole-dominated fields whose strength scales with convective flux, and we argue that these expectations should apply to the convective proto-neutron stars at the centers of core-collapse supernovae. We analyze a suite of three-dimensional simulations of core collapse, featuring a realistic equation of state and full neutrino transport, in this context. All our progenitor models, ranging from 9 solar masses to 25 solar masses, including one with initial rotation, have sufficiently vigorous proto-neutron-star convection to generate dipole fields of order ~10^15 gauss, if the modified Rossby number resides in the critical range. Thus, the magnetar/radio pulsar dichotomy may arise naturally in part from the distribution of core rotation rates in massive stars.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2021; v1 submitted 2 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
The Physical Effects of Progenitor Rotation: Comparing Two Long-Duration 3D Core-Collapse Supernova Simulations
Authors:
Matthew S. B. Coleman,
Adam Burrows,
Christopher J. White
Abstract:
We analyse and determine the effects of modest progenitor rotation in the context of core-collapse supernovae by comparing two separate long-duration three-dimensional simulations of 9 M$_{\odot}$ progenitors, one rotating with an initial spin period of $\sim$60 seconds and the other non-rotating. We determine that both models explode early, though the rotating model explodes a bit earlier. Despit…
▽ More
We analyse and determine the effects of modest progenitor rotation in the context of core-collapse supernovae by comparing two separate long-duration three-dimensional simulations of 9 M$_{\odot}$ progenitors, one rotating with an initial spin period of $\sim$60 seconds and the other non-rotating. We determine that both models explode early, though the rotating model explodes a bit earlier. Despite this difference, the asymptotic explosion energies ($\sim$10$^{50}$ ergs) and residual neutron star baryon masses ($\sim$1.3 M$_{\odot}$) are similar. We find that the proto-neutron star (PNS) core can deleptonize and cool significantly more quickly. Soon into the evolution of the rotating model, we witness more vigorous and extended PNS core convection that early in its evolution envelopes the entire inner sphere, not just a shell. Moreover, we see a corresponding excursion in both the $ν_e$ luminosity and gravitational-wave strain that may be diagnostic of this observed dramatic phenomenon. In addition, after bounce the innermost region of the rotating model seems to execute meridional circulation. The rotationally-induced growth of the convective PNS region may facilitate the growth of core B-fields by the dynamo mechanism by facilitating the achievement of the critical Rossby number condition for substantial growth of a dipole field, obviating the need for rapid rotation rates to create dipole fields of significance. The next step is to explore the progenitor-mass and spin dependencies across the progenitor continuum of the supernova explosion, dynamics, and evolution of PNS convection and its potential role in the generation of magnetar and pulsar magnetic fields.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2022; v1 submitted 29 October, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
The application of sub-seasonal to seasonal (S2S) predictions for hydropower forecasting
Authors:
Robert M. Graham,
Jethro Browell,
Douglas Bertram,
Christopher J. White
Abstract:
Inflow forecasts play an essential role in the management of hydropower reservoirs. Forecasts help operators schedule power generation in advance to maximise economic value, mitigate downstream flood risk, and meet environmental requirements. The horizon of operational inflow forecasts is often limited in range to ~2 weeks ahead, marking the predictability barrier of deterministic weather forecast…
▽ More
Inflow forecasts play an essential role in the management of hydropower reservoirs. Forecasts help operators schedule power generation in advance to maximise economic value, mitigate downstream flood risk, and meet environmental requirements. The horizon of operational inflow forecasts is often limited in range to ~2 weeks ahead, marking the predictability barrier of deterministic weather forecasts. Reliable inflow forecasts in the sub-seasonal to seasonal (S2S) range would allow operators to take proactive action to mitigate risks of adverse weather conditions, thereby improving water management and increasing revenue. This study outlines a method of deriving skilful S2S inflow forecasts using a case study reservoir in the Scottish Highlands. We generate ensemble inflow forecasts by training a linear regression model for the observed inflow onto S2S ensemble precipitation predictions from the European Centre for Medium-range Weather Forecasting (ECMWF). Subsequently, post-processing techniques from Ensemble Model Output Statistics are applied to derive calibrated S2S probabilistic inflow forecasts, without the application of a separate hydrological model. We find the S2S probabilistic inflow forecasts hold skill relative to climatological forecasts up to 6 weeks ahead. The inflow forecasts hold greater skill during winter compared with summer. The forecasts, however, struggle to predict high summer inflows, even at short lead-times. The potential for the S2S probabilistic inflow forecasts to improve water management and deliver increased economic value is confirmed using a stylised cost model. While applied to hydropower forecasting, the results and methods presented here are relevant to broader fields of water management and S2S forecasting applications.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
The Effects of Tilt on the Time Variability of Millimeter and Infrared Emission from Sagittarius A*
Authors:
Christopher J. White,
Eliot Quataert
Abstract:
Using a combination of general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamics simulations and ray tracing of synchrotron emission, we study the effect of modest (24 degrees) misalignment between the black hole spin and plasma angular momentum, focusing on the variability of total flux, image centroids, and image sizes. We consider both millimeter and infrared (IR) observables motivated by Sagittarius A* (Sgr A…
▽ More
Using a combination of general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamics simulations and ray tracing of synchrotron emission, we study the effect of modest (24 degrees) misalignment between the black hole spin and plasma angular momentum, focusing on the variability of total flux, image centroids, and image sizes. We consider both millimeter and infrared (IR) observables motivated by Sagittarius A* (Sgr A*), though our results apply more generally to optically thin flows. For most quantities, tilted accretion is more variable, primarily due to a significantly hotter and denser "coronal" region well off the disk midplane. We find (1) a 150% increase in millimeter light curve variability when adding tilt to the flow; (2) the tilted image centroid in the millimeter shifts on a scale of 3.7 microarcseconds over 28 hours (5000 gravitational times) for some electron temperature models; (3) tilted disk image diameters in the millimeter can be 10% larger (52 versus 47 microarcseconds) than those of aligned disks at certain viewing angles; (4) the tilted models produce significant IR flux, similar to that seen in Sgr A*, with comparable or even greater variability than observed; (5) for some electron models, the tilted IR centroid moves by more than 50 microarcseconds over several hours, in a similar fashion to the centroid motion detected by the GRAVITY interferometer.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2021; v1 submitted 26 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Numerical simulation of hot accretion flows (IV): effects of black hole spin and magnetic field strength on the wind and the comparison between wind and jet properties
Authors:
Hai Yang,
Feng Yuan,
Ye-fei Yuan,
Christopher J. White
Abstract:
This is the fourth paper of our series of works studying winds from hot accretion flows around black holes. In the first two papers, we have shown the existence of strong winds in hot accretion flows using hydrodynamical and magnetohydrodynamical (MHD) simulations. In the third paper, by using three dimensional general relativity MHD numerical simulation data of hot accretion flows and adopting a…
▽ More
This is the fourth paper of our series of works studying winds from hot accretion flows around black holes. In the first two papers, we have shown the existence of strong winds in hot accretion flows using hydrodynamical and magnetohydrodynamical (MHD) simulations. In the third paper, by using three dimensional general relativity MHD numerical simulation data of hot accretion flows and adopting a "virtual particle trajectory" data analysis approach, we have calculated the properties of wind, such as its mass flux and velocity. However, that paper focuses only on a non-spinning black hole and SANE (standard and normal accretion). In the present paper, we extend the third paper by including cases of a rapidly rotating black hole and MAD (magnetically arrested disk). We focus on investigating the effect of spin and magnetic field on the properties of wind and jet. It is found that a larger spin and stronger magnetic field usually enhance the wind and jet. The formulae describing the mass flux, poloidal velocity, and fluxes of momentum, kinetic energy, and total energy of wind and jet are presented. One interesting finding, among others, is that even in the case of very rapidly spinning black hole where the jet is supposed to be the strongest, the momentum flux of jet is smaller than that of wind, while the total energy flux of jet is larger than that of wind by at most a factor of 10. This result suggests that wind potentially plays a more important role than jet at least for some problems in active galactic nuclei feedback.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2021; v1 submitted 5 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Magnetically Modified Spherical Accretion in GRMHD: Reconnection-Driven Convection and Jet Propagation
Authors:
Sean M. Ressler,
Eliot Quataert,
Christopher J. White,
Omer Blaes
Abstract:
We present 3D general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic(GRMHD) simulations of zero angular momentum accretion around a rapidly rotating black hole, modified by the presence of initially uniform magnetic fields. We consider serveral angles between the magnetic field direction and the black hole spin. In the resulting flows, the midplane dynamics are governed by magnetic reconnection-driven turbulenc…
▽ More
We present 3D general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic(GRMHD) simulations of zero angular momentum accretion around a rapidly rotating black hole, modified by the presence of initially uniform magnetic fields. We consider serveral angles between the magnetic field direction and the black hole spin. In the resulting flows, the midplane dynamics are governed by magnetic reconnection-driven turbulence in a magnetically arrested (or a nearly arrested) state. Electromagnetic jets with outflow efficiencies ~10-200% occupy the polar regions, reaching several hundred gravitational radii before they dissipate due to the kink instability. The jet directions fluctuate in time and can be tilted by as much as ~30 degrees with respect to black hole spin, but this tilt does not depend strongly on the tilt of the initial magnetic field. A jet forms even when there is no initial net vertical magnetic flux since turbulent, horizon-scale fluctuations can generate a net vertical field locally. Peak jet power is obtained for an initial magnetic field tilted by 40-80 degrees with respect to the black hole spin because this maximizes the amount of magnetic flux that can reach the black hole. These simulations may be a reasonable model for low luminosity black hole accretion flows such as Sgr A* or M87.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
The Effects of Resolution on Black Hole Accretion Simulations of Jets
Authors:
Christopher J. White,
Fiona Chrystal
Abstract:
We perform three general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulations of black hole accretion designed to test how sensitive results are to grid resolution in the jet region. The cases differ only in numerics, modelling the same physical scenario of a radiatively inefficient, geometrically thick, magnetically arrested flow onto a rapidly spinning black hole. Properties inferred with the coarsest g…
▽ More
We perform three general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulations of black hole accretion designed to test how sensitive results are to grid resolution in the jet region. The cases differ only in numerics, modelling the same physical scenario of a radiatively inefficient, geometrically thick, magnetically arrested flow onto a rapidly spinning black hole. Properties inferred with the coarsest grid generally agree with those found with higher resolutions, including total jet power and its decomposition into different forms, velocity structure, nonaxisymmetric structure, and the appearance of resolved millimetre images. Some measures of variability and magnetization are sensitive to resolution. We conclude that most results obtained by limiting resolution near the jet for computational expediency should still be reliable, at least insofar as they would not be improved with a finer grid.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Looking for the underlying cause of black hole X-ray variability in GRMHD simulations
Authors:
D. A. Bollimpalli,
R. Mahmoud,
C. Done,
P. C. Fragile,
W. Kluźniak,
R. Narayan,
C. J. White
Abstract:
Long-term observations have shown that black hole X-ray binaries exhibit strong, aperiodic variability on time-scales of a few milliseconds to seconds. The observed light curves display various characteristic features like a log-normal distribution of flux and a linear rms-flux relation, which indicate that the underlying variability process is stochastic in nature. It is also thought to be intrin…
▽ More
Long-term observations have shown that black hole X-ray binaries exhibit strong, aperiodic variability on time-scales of a few milliseconds to seconds. The observed light curves display various characteristic features like a log-normal distribution of flux and a linear rms-flux relation, which indicate that the underlying variability process is stochastic in nature. It is also thought to be intrinsic to accretion. This variability has been modelled as inward propagating fluctuations of mass accretion rate, although the physical process driving the fluctuations remains puzzling. In this work, we analyse five exceptionally long duration general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations of optically thin, geometrically thick, black hole accretion flows to look for hints of propagating fluctuations in the simulation data. We find that the accretion profiles from these simulations do show evidence for inward propagating fluctuations below the viscous frequency by featuring strong radial coherence and positive time lags when comparing smaller to larger radii, although these time lags are generally shorter than the viscous time-scale and frequency independent. Our simulations also support the notion that the fluctuations in $\dot{M}$ build up in a multiplicative manner, as the simulations exhibit linear rms-mass flux relations, as well as log-normal distributions of their mass fluxes. When combining the mass fluxes from the simulations with an assumed emissivity profile, we additionally find broad agreement with observed power spectra and time lags, including a recovery of the frequency dependency of the time lags.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2020; v1 submitted 1 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Ab Initio Horizon-Scale Simulations of Magnetically Arrested Accretion in Sagittarius A* Fed by Stellar Winds
Authors:
Sean M. Ressler,
Christopher J. White,
Eliot Quataert,
James M. Stone
Abstract:
We present 3D general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations of the accretion flow surrounding Sagittarius A* that are initialized using larger-scale MHD simulations of the $\sim$ 30 Wolf--Rayet (WR) stellar winds in the Galactic center. The properties of the resulting accretion flow on horizon scales are set not by ad hoc initial conditions but by the observationally constrained pro…
▽ More
We present 3D general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations of the accretion flow surrounding Sagittarius A* that are initialized using larger-scale MHD simulations of the $\sim$ 30 Wolf--Rayet (WR) stellar winds in the Galactic center. The properties of the resulting accretion flow on horizon scales are set not by ad hoc initial conditions but by the observationally constrained properties of the WR winds with limited free parameters. For this initial study we assume a non-spinning black hole. Our simulations naturally produce a $\sim 10^{-8} M_\odot$ yr$^{-1}$ accretion rate, consistent with previous phenomenological estimates. We find that a magnetically arrested flow is formed by the continuous accretion of coherent magnetic field being fed from large radii. Near the event horizon, the magnetic field is so strong that it tilts the gas with respect to the initial angular momentum and concentrates the originally quasi-spherical flow to a narrow disk-like structure. We also present 230 GHz images calculated from our simulations where the inclination angle and physical accretion rate are not free parameters but are determined by the properties of the WR stellar winds. The image morphology is highly time variable. Linear polarization on horizon scales is coherent with weak internal Faraday rotation.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2020; v1 submitted 29 May, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
The Athena++ Adaptive Mesh Refinement Framework: Design and Magnetohydrodynamic Solvers
Authors:
James M. Stone,
Kengo Tomida,
Christopher J. White,
Kyle G. Felker
Abstract:
The design and implementation of a new framework for adaptive mesh refinement (AMR) calculations is described. It is intended primarily for applications in astrophysical fluid dynamics, but its flexible and modular design enables its use for a wide variety of physics. The framework works with both uniform and nonuniform grids in Cartesian and curvilinear coordinate systems. It adopts a dynamic exe…
▽ More
The design and implementation of a new framework for adaptive mesh refinement (AMR) calculations is described. It is intended primarily for applications in astrophysical fluid dynamics, but its flexible and modular design enables its use for a wide variety of physics. The framework works with both uniform and nonuniform grids in Cartesian and curvilinear coordinate systems. It adopts a dynamic execution model based on a simple design called a "task list" that improves parallel performance by overlap** communication and computation, simplifies the inclusion of a diverse range of physics, and even enables multiphysics models involving different physics in different regions of the calculation. We describe physics modules implemented in this framework for both non-relativistic and relativistic magnetohydrodynamics (MHD). These modules adopt mature and robust algorithms originally developed for the Athena MHD code and incorporate new extensions: support for curvilinear coordinates, higher-order time integrators, more realistic physics such as a general equation of state, and diffusion terms that can be integrated with super-time-step** algorithms. The modules show excellent performance and scaling, with well over 80% parallel efficiency on over half a million threads. The source code has been made publicly available.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
The Structure of Radiatively Inefficient Black Hole Accretion Flows
Authors:
Christopher J. White,
Eliot Quataert,
Charles F. Gammie
Abstract:
We run three long-timescale general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulations of radiatively inefficient accretion flows onto non-rotating black holes. Our aim is to achieve steady-state behavior out to large radii and understand the resulting flow structure. A simulation with adiabatic index Gamma = 4/3 and small initial alternating poloidal magnetic field loops is run to a time of 440,000 GM/…
▽ More
We run three long-timescale general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulations of radiatively inefficient accretion flows onto non-rotating black holes. Our aim is to achieve steady-state behavior out to large radii and understand the resulting flow structure. A simulation with adiabatic index Gamma = 4/3 and small initial alternating poloidal magnetic field loops is run to a time of 440,000 GM/c^3, reaching inflow equilibrium inside a radius of 370 GM/c^2. Variations with larger alternating field loops and with Gamma = 5/3 are run to 220,000 GM/c^3, attaining equilibrium out to 170 GM/c^2 and 440 GM/c^2. There is no universal self-similar behavior obtained at radii in inflow equilibrium: the Gamma = 5/3 simulation shows a radial density profile with power law index ranging from -1 in the inner regions to -1/2 in the outer regions, while the others have a power-law slope ranging from -1/2 to close to -2. Both simulations with small field loops reach a state with polar inflow of matter, while the more ordered initial field has polar outflows. However, unbound outflows remove only a factor of order unity of the inflowing material over a factor of ~300 in radius. Our results suggest that the dynamics of radiatively inefficient accretion flows are sensitive to how the flow is fed from larger radii, and may differ appreciably in different astrophysical systems. Millimeter images appropriate for Sgr A* are qualitatively (but not quantitatively) similar in all simulations, with a prominent asymmetric image due to Doppler boosting.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
The Effects of Tilt on the Images of Black Hole Accretion Flows
Authors:
Christopher J. White,
Jason Dexter,
Omer Blaes,
Eliot Quataert
Abstract:
We analyze two 3D general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic accretion simulations in the context of how they would manifest in Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) observations of supermassive black holes. The two simulations differ only in whether the initial angular momentum of the plasma is aligned with the rapid (a = 0.9) spin of the black hole. Both have low net magnetic flux. Ray tracing is employed…
▽ More
We analyze two 3D general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic accretion simulations in the context of how they would manifest in Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) observations of supermassive black holes. The two simulations differ only in whether the initial angular momentum of the plasma is aligned with the rapid (a = 0.9) spin of the black hole. Both have low net magnetic flux. Ray tracing is employed to generate resolved images of the synchrotron emission. When using parameters appropriate for Sgr A* and assuming a viewing angle aligned with the black hole spin, we find the most prominent difference is that the central shadow in the image is noticeably eccentric in tilted models, with the ring of emission relatively unchanged. Applying this procedure to M87 with a viewing angle based on the large-scale jet, we find that adding tilt increases the angular size of the ring for fixed black hole mass and distance, while at the same time increasing the number of bright spots in the image. Our findings illustrate observable features that can distinguish tilted from aligned flows. They also show that tilted models can be viable for M87, and that not accounting for tilt can bias inferences of physical parameters. Future modeling of horizon-scale observations should account for potential angular momentum misalignment, which is likely generic at the low accretion rates appropriate for EHT targets.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2020; v1 submitted 7 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Development and Application of Numerical Techniques for General-Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamics Simulations of Black Hole Accretion
Authors:
Christopher J. White
Abstract:
We describe the implementation of sophisticated numerical techniques for general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamics simulations in the Athena++ code framework. Improvements over many existing codes include the use of advanced Riemann solvers and of staggered-mesh constrained transport. Combined with considerations for computational performance and parallel scalability, these allow us to investigate…
▽ More
We describe the implementation of sophisticated numerical techniques for general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamics simulations in the Athena++ code framework. Improvements over many existing codes include the use of advanced Riemann solvers and of staggered-mesh constrained transport. Combined with considerations for computational performance and parallel scalability, these allow us to investigate black hole accretion flows with unprecedented accuracy. The capability of the code is demonstrated by exploring magnetically arrested disks.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Remnants of Subdwarf Helium Donor Stars Ejected from Close Binaries with Thermonuclear Supernovae
Authors:
Evan B. Bauer,
Christopher J. White,
Lars Bildsten
Abstract:
Some binary systems composed of a white dwarf (WD) and a hot subdwarf (sdB) helium star will make contact within the helium burning lifetime of the sdB star. The accreted helium on the WD inevitably undergoes a thermonuclear instability, causing a detonation that is expected to transition into the WD core and lead to a thermonuclear supernova while the donor orbits nearby with high velocity. Motiv…
▽ More
Some binary systems composed of a white dwarf (WD) and a hot subdwarf (sdB) helium star will make contact within the helium burning lifetime of the sdB star. The accreted helium on the WD inevitably undergoes a thermonuclear instability, causing a detonation that is expected to transition into the WD core and lead to a thermonuclear supernova while the donor orbits nearby with high velocity. Motivated by the recent discovery of fast-moving objects that occupy unusual locations on the HR diagram, we explore the impact of the thermonuclear supernovae on the donors in this specific double detonation scenario. We use MESA to model the binary up to the moment of detonation, then 3D Athena++ to model the hydrodynamic interaction of the supernova ejecta with the donor star, calculating the amount of mass that is stripped and the entropy deposited in the deep stellar interior by the strong shock that traverses it. We show that these donor remnants are ejected with velocities primarily set by their orbital speeds: $700-900\ \rm km\ s^{-1}$. We model the long-term thermal evolution of remnants by introducing the shock entropy into MESA models. In response to this entropy change, donor remnants expand and brighten for timescales ranging from $10^6-10^8$ years, giving ample time for these runaway stars to be observed in their inflated state before they leave the galaxy. Even after surface layers are stripped, some donors retain enough mass to resume core helium burning and further delay fading for more than $10^8$ years.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2019; v1 submitted 21 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
The Event Horizon General Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamic Code Comparison Project
Authors:
Oliver Porth,
Koushik Chatterjee,
Ramesh Narayan,
Charles F. Gammie,
Yosuke Mizuno,
Peter Anninos,
John G. Baker,
Matteo Bugli,
Chi-kwan Chan,
Jordy Davelaar,
Luca Del Zanna,
Zachariah B. Etienne,
P. Chris Fragile,
Bernard J. Kelly,
Matthew Liska,
Sera Markoff,
Jonathan C. McKinney,
Bhupendra Mishra,
Scott C. Noble,
Héctor Olivares,
Ben Prather,
Luciano Rezzolla,
Benjamin R. Ryan,
James M. Stone,
Niccolò Tomei
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Recent developments in compact object astrophysics, especially the discovery of merging neutron stars by LIGO, the imaging of the black hole in M87 by the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) and high precision astrometry of the Galactic Center at close to the event horizon scale by the GRAVITY experiment motivate the development of numerical source models that solve the equations of general relativistic…
▽ More
Recent developments in compact object astrophysics, especially the discovery of merging neutron stars by LIGO, the imaging of the black hole in M87 by the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) and high precision astrometry of the Galactic Center at close to the event horizon scale by the GRAVITY experiment motivate the development of numerical source models that solve the equations of general relativistic magnetohydrodynamics (GRMHD). Here we compare GRMHD solutions for the evolution of a magnetized accretion flow where turbulence is promoted by the magnetorotational instability from a set of nine GRMHD codes: Athena++, BHAC, Cosmos++, ECHO, H-AMR, iharm3D, HARM-Noble, IllinoisGRMHD and KORAL. Agreement between the codes improves as resolution increases, as measured by a consistently applied, specially developed set of code performance metrics. We conclude that the community of GRMHD codes is mature, capable, and consistent on these test problems.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2019; v1 submitted 9 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
A Resolution Study of Magnetically Arrested Disks
Authors:
Christopher J. White,
James M. Stone,
Eliot Quataert
Abstract:
We investigate numerical convergence in simulations of magnetically arrested disks around spinning black holes. Using the general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamics code Athena++, we study the same system at four resolutions (up to an effective 512 by 256 by 512 cells) and with two different spatial reconstruction algorithms. The accretion rate and general large-scale structure of the flow agree ac…
▽ More
We investigate numerical convergence in simulations of magnetically arrested disks around spinning black holes. Using the general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamics code Athena++, we study the same system at four resolutions (up to an effective 512 by 256 by 512 cells) and with two different spatial reconstruction algorithms. The accretion rate and general large-scale structure of the flow agree across the simulations. This includes the amount of magnetic flux accumulated in the saturated state and the ensuing suppression of the magnetorotational instability from the strong field. The energy of the jet and the efficiency with which spin energy is extracted via the Blandford-Znajek process also show convergence. However the spatial structure of the jet shows variation across the set of grids employed, as do the Lorentz factors. Small-scale features of the turbulence, as measured by correlation lengths, are not fully converged. Despite convergence of a number of aspects of the flow, modeling of synchrotron emission shows that variability is not converged and decreases with increasing resolution even at our highest resolutions.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Tilted Disks around Black Holes: A Numerical Parameter Survey for Spin and Inclination Angle
Authors:
Christopher J. White,
Eliot Quataert,
Omer Blaes
Abstract:
We conduct a systematic study of the properties of tilted accretion flows around spinning black holes, covering a range of tilt angles and black hole spins, using the general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamics code Athena++. The same initial magnetized torus is evolved around black holes with spins ranging from 0 to 0.9, with inclinations ranging from 0 degrees to 24 degrees. The tilted disks quick…
▽ More
We conduct a systematic study of the properties of tilted accretion flows around spinning black holes, covering a range of tilt angles and black hole spins, using the general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamics code Athena++. The same initial magnetized torus is evolved around black holes with spins ranging from 0 to 0.9, with inclinations ranging from 0 degrees to 24 degrees. The tilted disks quickly reach a warped and twisted shape that rigidly precesses about the black hole spin axis with deformations in shape large enough to hinder the application of linear bending wave theory. Magnetized polar outflows form, oriented along the disk rotation axes. At sufficiently high inclinations a pair of standing shocks develops in the disks. These shocks dramatically affect the flow at small radii, driving angular momentum transport. At high spins they redirect material more effectively than they heat it, reducing the dissipation rate relative to the mass accretion rate and lowering the radiative efficiency of the flow.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
An Extension of the Athena++ Code Framework for GRMHD Based on Advanced Riemann Solvers and Staggered-Mesh Constrained Transport
Authors:
Christopher J. White,
James M. Stone,
Charles F. Gammie
Abstract:
We present a new general relativistic magnetohydrodynamics (GRMHD) code integrated into the Athena++ framework. Improving upon the techniques used in most GRMHD codes, ours allows the use of advanced, less diffusive Riemann solvers, in particular HLLC and HLLD. We also employ a staggered-mesh constrained transport algorithm suited for curvilinear coordinate systems in order to maintain the diverge…
▽ More
We present a new general relativistic magnetohydrodynamics (GRMHD) code integrated into the Athena++ framework. Improving upon the techniques used in most GRMHD codes, ours allows the use of advanced, less diffusive Riemann solvers, in particular HLLC and HLLD. We also employ a staggered-mesh constrained transport algorithm suited for curvilinear coordinate systems in order to maintain the divergence-free constraint of the magnetic field. Our code is designed to work with arbitrary stationary spacetimes in one, two, or three dimensions, and we demonstrate its reliability in a number of tests. We also report on its promising performance and scalability.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2016; v1 submitted 3 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Upper bounds for double exponential sums along a subsequence
Authors:
Christopher J. White
Abstract:
We consider a class of double exponential sums studied in a paper of Sinai and Ulcigrai. They proved a linear bound for these sums along the sequence of denominators in the continued fraction expansion of $α$, provided $α$ is badly-approximable. We provide a proof of a result, which includes a simple proof of their theorem, and which applies for all irrational $α$.
We consider a class of double exponential sums studied in a paper of Sinai and Ulcigrai. They proved a linear bound for these sums along the sequence of denominators in the continued fraction expansion of $α$, provided $α$ is badly-approximable. We provide a proof of a result, which includes a simple proof of their theorem, and which applies for all irrational $α$.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Slow-Speed Supernovae from the Palomar Transient Factory: Two Channels
Authors:
Christopher J. White,
Mansi M. Kasliwal,
Peter E. Nugent,
Avishay Gal-Yam,
D. Andrew Howell,
Mark Sullivan,
Ariel Goobar,
Anthony L. Piro,
Joshua S. Bloom,
Shrinivas R. Kulkarni,
Russ R. Laher,
Frank Masci,
Eran O. Ofek,
Jason Surace,
Sagi Ben-Ami,
Yi Cao,
S. Bradley Cenko,
Isobel M. Hook,
Jakob Jönsson,
Thomas Matheson,
Assaf Sternberg,
Robert M. Quimby,
Ofer Yaron
Abstract:
Since the discovery of the unusual prototype SN 2002cx, the eponymous class of low-velocity, hydrogen-poor supernovae has grown to include at most another two dozen members identified from several heterogeneous surveys, in some cases ambiguously. Here we present the results of a systematic study of 1077 hydrogen-poor supernovae discovered by the Palomar Transient Factory, leading to nine new membe…
▽ More
Since the discovery of the unusual prototype SN 2002cx, the eponymous class of low-velocity, hydrogen-poor supernovae has grown to include at most another two dozen members identified from several heterogeneous surveys, in some cases ambiguously. Here we present the results of a systematic study of 1077 hydrogen-poor supernovae discovered by the Palomar Transient Factory, leading to nine new members of this peculiar class. Moreover we find there are two distinct subclasses based on their spectroscopic, photometric, and host galaxy properties: The "SN 2002cx-like" supernovae tend to be in later-type or more irregular hosts, have more varied and generally dimmer luminosities, have longer rise times, and lack a Ti II trough when compared to the "SN 2002es-like" supernovae. None of our objects show helium, and we counter a previous claim of two such events. We also find that these transients comprise 5.6+17-3.7% (90% confidence) of all SNe Ia, lower compared to earlier estimates. Combining our objects with the literature sample, we propose that these subclasses have two distinct physical origins.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Stability of metal-rich very massive stars
Authors:
J. Goodman,
Christopher J. White
Abstract:
We revisit the stability of very massive nonrotating main-sequence stars at solar metallicity, with the goal of understanding whether radial pulsations set a physical upper limit to stellar mass. Models of up to 938 solar masses are constructed with the Mesa code, and their linear stability in the fundamental mode, assumed to be the most dangerous, is analysed with a fully nonadiabatic method. Mod…
▽ More
We revisit the stability of very massive nonrotating main-sequence stars at solar metallicity, with the goal of understanding whether radial pulsations set a physical upper limit to stellar mass. Models of up to 938 solar masses are constructed with the Mesa code, and their linear stability in the fundamental mode, assumed to be the most dangerous, is analysed with a fully nonadiabatic method. Models above 100 MSun have extended tenuous atmospheres ("shelves") that affect the stability of the fundamental. Even when positive, this growth rate is small, in agreement with previous results. We argue that small growth rates lead to saturation at small amplitudes that are not dangerous to the star. A mechanism for saturation is demonstrated involving nonlinear parametric coupling to short-wavelength g modes and the dam** of the latter by radiative diffusion. The shelves are subject to much more rapidly growing strange modes. This also agrees with previous results but is extended here to higher masses. The strange modes probably saturate via shocks rather than mode coupling but have very small amplitudes in the core, where almost all of the stellar mass resides. Although our stellar models are hydrostatic, the structure of their outer parts suggests that optically thick winds, driven by some combination of radiation pressure, transsonic convection, and strange modes, are more likely than pulsation in the fundamental mode to limit the main-sequence lifetime.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2015; v1 submitted 27 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Dynamic Phase Transition, Universality, and Finite-size Scaling in the Two-dimensional Kinetic Ising Model in an Oscillating Field
Authors:
G. Korniss,
C. J. White,
P. A. Rikvold,
M. A. Novotny
Abstract:
We study the two-dimensional kinetic Ising model below its equilibrium critical temperature, subject to a square-wave oscillating external field. We focus on the multi-droplet regime where the metastable phase decays through nucleation and growth of many droplets of the stable phase. At a critical frequency, the system undergoes a genuine non-equilibrium phase transition, in which the symmetry-b…
▽ More
We study the two-dimensional kinetic Ising model below its equilibrium critical temperature, subject to a square-wave oscillating external field. We focus on the multi-droplet regime where the metastable phase decays through nucleation and growth of many droplets of the stable phase. At a critical frequency, the system undergoes a genuine non-equilibrium phase transition, in which the symmetry-broken phase corresponds to an asymmetric stationary limit cycle for the time-dependent magnetization. We investigate the universal aspects of this dynamic phase transition at various temperatures and field amplitudes via large-scale Monte Carlo simulations, employing finite-size scaling techniques adopted from equilibrium critical phenomena. The critical exponents, the fixed-point value of the fourth-order cumulant, and the critical order-parameter distribution all are consistent with the universality class of the two-dimensional equilibrium Ising model. We also study the cross-over from the multi-droplet to the strong-field regime, where the transition disappears.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2000;
originally announced August 2000.
-
Dynamic Phase Transition and Hysteresis in Kinetic Ising Models
Authors:
P. A. Rikvold,
G. Korniss,
C. J. White,
M. A. Novotny,
S. W. Sides
Abstract:
We briefly introduce hysteresis in spatially extended systems and the dynamic phase transition observed as the frequency of the oscillating field increases beyond a critical value. Hysteresis and the decay of metastable phases are closely related phenomena, and a dynamic phase transition can occur only for field amplitudes, temperatures, and system sizes at which the metastable phase decays thro…
▽ More
We briefly introduce hysteresis in spatially extended systems and the dynamic phase transition observed as the frequency of the oscillating field increases beyond a critical value. Hysteresis and the decay of metastable phases are closely related phenomena, and a dynamic phase transition can occur only for field amplitudes, temperatures, and system sizes at which the metastable phase decays through nucleation and growth of many droplets. We present preliminary results from extensive Monte Carlo simulations of a two-dimensional kinetic Ising model in a square-wave oscillating field and estimate critical exponents by finite-size scaling techniques adapted from equilibrium critical phenomena. The estimates are consistent with the universality class of the two-dimensional equilibrium Ising model and inconsistent with two-dimensional random percolation. However, we are not aware of any theoretical arguments indicating why this should be so. Thus, the question of the universality class of this nonequilibrium critical phenomenon remains open.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 1999; v1 submitted 1 April, 1999;
originally announced April 1999.
