-
No-broadcasting characterizes operational contextuality
Authors:
Pauli Jokinen,
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Martin Plávala,
Juha-Pekka Pellonpää,
Jukka Kiukas,
Roope Uola
Abstract:
Operational contextuality forms a rapidly develo** subfield of quantum information theory. However, the characterization of the quantum mechanical entities that fuel the phenomenon has remained unknown with many partial results existing. Here, we present a resolution to this problem by connecting operational contextuality one-to-one with the no-broadcasting theorem. The connection works both on…
▽ More
Operational contextuality forms a rapidly develo** subfield of quantum information theory. However, the characterization of the quantum mechanical entities that fuel the phenomenon has remained unknown with many partial results existing. Here, we present a resolution to this problem by connecting operational contextuality one-to-one with the no-broadcasting theorem. The connection works both on the level of full quantum theory and subtheories thereof. We demonstrate the connection in various relevant cases, showing especially that for quantum states the possibility of demonstrating contextuality is exactly characterized by non-commutativity, and for measurements this is done by a norm-1 property closely related to repeatability. Moreover, we show how techniques from broadcasting can be used to simplify known foundational results in contextuality.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Memory attacks in network nonlocality and self-testing
Authors:
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Costantino Budroni,
Miguel Navascues
Abstract:
We study what can or cannot be certified in communication scenarios where the assumption of independence and identical distribution (iid) between experimental rounds fails. In this respect, we prove that membership tests for non-convex sets of correlations cannot be formulated in the non-iid regime. Similarly, it is impossible to self-test non-extreme quantum operations, such as mixed states, or n…
▽ More
We study what can or cannot be certified in communication scenarios where the assumption of independence and identical distribution (iid) between experimental rounds fails. In this respect, we prove that membership tests for non-convex sets of correlations cannot be formulated in the non-iid regime. Similarly, it is impossible to self-test non-extreme quantum operations, such as mixed states, or noisy quantum measurements, unless one allows more than a single use thereof within the same experimental round. One consequence of our results is that non-classicality in causal networks without inputs cannot be experimentally demonstrated. By analyzing optimal non-iid strategies in the triangle scenario, we raise the need to take into account the prior communication required to set up a causal network.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
A theory-independent bound saturated by quantum mechanics
Authors:
Lin Htoo Zaw,
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Valerio Scarani
Abstract:
Tsirelson's original inequality for the precession protocol, first introduced for the harmonic oscillator but applicable to all uniformly-precessing systems, serves as a monopartite test of quantumness. Given that the system is undergoing a uniform precession, the signs of the positions of a classical oscillator must satisfy that inequality, which is violated by certain quantum states. We consider…
▽ More
Tsirelson's original inequality for the precession protocol, first introduced for the harmonic oscillator but applicable to all uniformly-precessing systems, serves as a monopartite test of quantumness. Given that the system is undergoing a uniform precession, the signs of the positions of a classical oscillator must satisfy that inequality, which is violated by certain quantum states. We consider this inequality for measurements with finitely many outcomes in a theory-independent manner. We derive a general bound which depends only on the minimum positive and negative values of the spectrum of the observable. Given any such two values, we construct a quantum observable that saturates this bound. A notable example is the angular momentum of a spin-$3/2$ particle. We also relate our findings to the recently-introduced notion of constrained conditional probabilities.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Monogamy relations for relativistically causal correlations
Authors:
Mirjam Weilenmann
Abstract:
Non-signalling conditions encode minimal requirements that any (quantum) systems put into spatial arrangements must satisfy in order to be consistent with special relativity. Recent works have argued that in scenarios involving more that two parties, conditions compatible with relativistic causality do not have to satisfy all possible non-signalling conditions but only a subset of them. Here we sh…
▽ More
Non-signalling conditions encode minimal requirements that any (quantum) systems put into spatial arrangements must satisfy in order to be consistent with special relativity. Recent works have argued that in scenarios involving more that two parties, conditions compatible with relativistic causality do not have to satisfy all possible non-signalling conditions but only a subset of them. Here we show that correlations satisfying only this subset of constraints have to satisfy highly non-local monogamy relations between the effects of space-like separated random variables. These monogamy relations take the form of new entropic inequalities between the various systems and we give a general method to derive them. Using these monogamy relations we refute previous suggestions for physical mechanisms that could lead to relativistically causal correlations, demonstrating that such mechanisms would lead to superluminal signalling.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Optimisation of time-ordered processes in the finite and asymptotic regime
Authors:
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Costantino Budroni,
Miguel Navascues
Abstract:
Many problems in quantum information theory can be formulated as optimizations over the sequential outcomes of dynamical systems subject to unpredictable external influences. Such problems include many-body entanglement detection through adaptive measurements, computing the maximum average score of a preparation game over a continuous set of target states and limiting the behavior of a (quantum) f…
▽ More
Many problems in quantum information theory can be formulated as optimizations over the sequential outcomes of dynamical systems subject to unpredictable external influences. Such problems include many-body entanglement detection through adaptive measurements, computing the maximum average score of a preparation game over a continuous set of target states and limiting the behavior of a (quantum) finite-state automaton. In this work, we introduce tractable relaxations of this class of optimization problems. To illustrate their performance, we use them to: (a) compute the probability that a finite-state automaton outputs a given sequence of bits; (b) develop a new many-body entanglement detection protocol; (c) let the computer invent an adaptive protocol for magic state detection. As we further show, the maximum score of a sequential problem in the limit of infinitely many time steps is in general incomputable. Nonetheless, we provide general heuristics to bound this quantity and show that they provide useful estimates in relevant scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2024; v1 submitted 6 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Multi-system measurements in generalized probabilistic theories and their role in information processing
Authors:
Giorgos Eftaxias,
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Roger Colbeck
Abstract:
Generalized probabilistic theories (GPTs) provide a framework in which a range of possible theories can be examined, including classical theory, quantum theory and those beyond. In general, enlarging the state space of a GPT leads to fewer possible measurements because the additional states give stronger constraints on the set of effects, the constituents of measurements. This can have implication…
▽ More
Generalized probabilistic theories (GPTs) provide a framework in which a range of possible theories can be examined, including classical theory, quantum theory and those beyond. In general, enlarging the state space of a GPT leads to fewer possible measurements because the additional states give stronger constraints on the set of effects, the constituents of measurements. This can have implications for information processing. In boxworld, for example, a GPT in which any no-signalling distribution can be realised, there is no analogue of a measurement in the Bell basis and hence the analogue of entanglement swap** is impossible. A comprehensive study of measurements on multiple systems in boxworld has been lacking. Here we consider such measurements in detail, distinguishing those that can be performed by interacting with individual systems sequentially (termed wirings), and the more interesting set of those that cannot. We compute all the possible boxworld effects for cases with small numbers of inputs, outputs and parties, identifying those that are wirings. The large state space of boxworld leads to a small effect space and hence the effects of boxworld are widely applicable in GPTs. We also show some possible uses of non-wirings for information processing by studying state discrimination, nonlocality distillation and the boxworld analogue of nonlocality without entanglement. Finally, we connect our results to the study of logically consistent classical processes and to the composition of contextuality scenarios. By enhancing understanding of measurements in boxworld, our results could be useful in studies of possible underlying principles on which quantum theory can be based.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2024; v1 submitted 9 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Advantages of multi-copy nonlocality distillation and its application to minimizing communication complexity
Authors:
Giorgos Eftaxias,
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Roger Colbeck
Abstract:
Nonlocal correlations are a central feature of quantum theory, and understanding why quantum theory has a limited amount of nonlocality is a fundamental problem. Since nonlocality also has technological applications, e.g., for device-independent cryptography, it is useful to understand it as a resource and, in particular, whether and how different types of nonlocality can be interconverted. Here w…
▽ More
Nonlocal correlations are a central feature of quantum theory, and understanding why quantum theory has a limited amount of nonlocality is a fundamental problem. Since nonlocality also has technological applications, e.g., for device-independent cryptography, it is useful to understand it as a resource and, in particular, whether and how different types of nonlocality can be interconverted. Here we focus on nonlocality distillation which involves using several copies of a nonlocal resource to generate one with more nonlocality. We introduce several distillation schemes which distil an extended part of the set of nonlocal correlations including quantum correlations. Our schemes are based on a natural set of operational procedures known as wirings that can be applied regardless of the underlying theory. Some are sequential algorithms that repeatedly use a two-copy protocol, while others are genuine three-copy distillation protocols. In some regions we prove that genuine three-copy protocols are strictly better than two-copy protocols. By applying our new protocols we also increase the region in which nonlocal correlations are known to give rise to trivial communication complexity. This brings us closer to an understanding of the sets of nonlocal correlations that can be recovered from information-theoretic principles, which, in turn, enhances our understanding of what is special about quantum theory.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2023; v1 submitted 6 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Testing real quantum theory in an optical quantum network
Authors:
Zheng-Da Li,
Ya-Li Mao,
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Armin Tavakoli,
Hu Chen,
Lixin Feng,
Sheng-Jun Yang,
Marc-Olivier Renou,
David Trillo,
Thinh P. Le,
Nicolas Gisin,
Antonio Acín,
Miguel Navascués,
Zizhu Wang,
**gyun Fan
Abstract:
Quantum theory is commonly formulated in complex Hilbert spaces. However, the question of whether complex numbers need to be given a fundamental role in the theory has been debated since its pioneering days. Recently it has been shown that tests in the spirit of a Bell inequality can reveal quantum predictions in entanglement swap** scenarios that cannot be modelled by the natural real-number an…
▽ More
Quantum theory is commonly formulated in complex Hilbert spaces. However, the question of whether complex numbers need to be given a fundamental role in the theory has been debated since its pioneering days. Recently it has been shown that tests in the spirit of a Bell inequality can reveal quantum predictions in entanglement swap** scenarios that cannot be modelled by the natural real-number analog of standard quantum theory. Here, we tailor such tests for implementation in state-of-the-art photonic systems. We experimentally demonstrate quantum correlations in a network of three parties and two independent EPR sources that violate the constraints of real quantum theory by over $4.5$ standard deviations, hence disproving real quantum theory as a universal physical theory.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Quantum theory based on real numbers can be experimentally falsified
Authors:
Marc-Olivier Renou,
David Trillo,
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Thinh P. Le,
Armin Tavakoli,
Nicolas Gisin,
Antonio Acin,
Miguel Navascues
Abstract:
While complex numbers are essential in mathematics, they are not needed to describe physical experiments, expressed in terms of probabilities, hence real numbers. Physics however aims to explain, rather than describe, experiments through theories. While most theories of physics are based on real numbers, quantum theory was the first to be formulated in terms of operators acting on complex Hilbert…
▽ More
While complex numbers are essential in mathematics, they are not needed to describe physical experiments, expressed in terms of probabilities, hence real numbers. Physics however aims to explain, rather than describe, experiments through theories. While most theories of physics are based on real numbers, quantum theory was the first to be formulated in terms of operators acting on complex Hilbert spaces. This has puzzled countless physicists, including the fathers of the theory, for whom a real version of quantum theory, in terms of real operators, seemed much more natural. In fact, previous works showed that such "real quantum theory" can reproduce the outcomes of any multipartite experiment, as long as the parts share arbitrary real quantum states. Thus, are complex numbers really needed in the quantum formalism? Here, we show this to be case by proving that real and complex quantum theory make different predictions in network scenarios comprising independent states and measurements. This allows us to devise a Bell-like experiment whose successful realization would disprove real quantum theory, in the same way as standard Bell experiments disproved local physics.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2021; v1 submitted 26 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Optimized detection of high-dimensional entanglement
Authors:
Xiao-Min Hu,
Wen-Bo Xing,
Yu Guo,
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Edgar A. Aguilar,
Xiaoqin Gao,
Bi-Heng Liu,
Yun-Feng Huang,
Chuan-Feng Li,
Guang-Can Guo,
Zizhu Wang,
Miguel Navascués
Abstract:
Entanglement detection is one of the most conventional tasks in quantum information processing. While most experimental demonstrations of high-dimensional entanglement rely on fidelity-based witnesses, these are powerless to detect entanglement within a large class of entangled quantum states, the so-called unfaithful states. In this paper, we introduce a highly flexible automated method to constr…
▽ More
Entanglement detection is one of the most conventional tasks in quantum information processing. While most experimental demonstrations of high-dimensional entanglement rely on fidelity-based witnesses, these are powerless to detect entanglement within a large class of entangled quantum states, the so-called unfaithful states. In this paper, we introduce a highly flexible automated method to construct optimal tests for entanglement detection given a bipartite target state of arbitrary dimension, faithful or unfaithful, and a set of local measurement operators. By restricting the number or complexity of the considered measurement settings, our method outputs the most convenient protocol which can be implemented using a wide range of experimental techniques such as photons, superconducting qudits, cold atoms or trapped ions. With an experimental quantum optics setup that can prepare and measure arbitrary high-dimensional mixed states, we implement some $3$-setting protocols generated by our method. These protocols allow us to experimentally certify 2- and 3-unfaithful entanglement in 4-dimensional photonic states, some of which contain well above 50% of noise.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2021; v1 submitted 4 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Quantum Preparation Games
Authors:
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Edgar A. Aguilar,
Miguel Navascues
Abstract:
A preparation game is a task whereby a player sequentially sends a number of quantum states to a referee, who probes each of them and announces the measurement result. The measurement setting in each round, as well as the final score of the game, are decided by the referee based on the past history of settings and measurement outcomes. Many experimental tasks in quantum information, such as entang…
▽ More
A preparation game is a task whereby a player sequentially sends a number of quantum states to a referee, who probes each of them and announces the measurement result. The measurement setting in each round, as well as the final score of the game, are decided by the referee based on the past history of settings and measurement outcomes. Many experimental tasks in quantum information, such as entanglement quantification or magic state detection, can be cast as preparation games. In this paper, we introduce general methods to design $n$-round preparation games, with tight bounds on the average game scores achievable by players subject to constraints on their preparation devices. We illustrate our results by devising new adaptive measurement protocols for entanglement detection and quantification. Surprisingly, we find that the standard procedure in entanglement detection, namely, estimating $n$ times the average value of a given entanglement witness, is in general sub-optimal for detecting the entanglement of a specific quantum state. On the contrary, there exist $n$-round experimental scenarios where detecting the entanglement of a known state optimally requires adaptive measurement schemes.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2021; v1 submitted 4 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Towards correlation self-testing of quantum theory in the adaptive Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt game
Authors:
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Roger Colbeck
Abstract:
Correlation self-testing of a theory addresses the question of whether we can identify the set of correlations realisable in a theory from its performance in a particular information processing task. Applied to quantum theory it aims to identify an information processing task whose optimal performance is achieved only by theories realising the same correlations as quantum theory in any causal stru…
▽ More
Correlation self-testing of a theory addresses the question of whether we can identify the set of correlations realisable in a theory from its performance in a particular information processing task. Applied to quantum theory it aims to identify an information processing task whose optimal performance is achieved only by theories realising the same correlations as quantum theory in any causal structure. In [Phys. Rev. Lett. 125 060406 (2020)] we introduced a candidate task for this, the adaptive CHSH game. Here, we analyse the maximum probability of winning this game in different generalised probabilistic theories. We show that theories with a joint state space given by the minimal or the maximal tensor product are inferior to quantum theory, before considering other tensor products in theories whose elementary systems have various two-dimensional state spaces. For these, we find no theories that outperform quantum theory in the adaptive CHSH game and prove that it is impossible to recover the quantum performance in various cases. This is the first step towards a general solution that, if successful, will have wide-ranging consequences, in particular, enabling an experiment that could rule out all theories in which the set of realisable correlations does not coincide with the quantum set.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2024; v1 submitted 10 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Self-testing of physical theories, or, is quantum theory optimal with respect to some information-processing task?
Authors:
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Roger Colbeck
Abstract:
Self-testing usually refers to the task of taking a given set of observed correlations that are assumed to arise via a process that is accurately described by quantum theory, and trying to infer the quantum state and measurements. In other words it is concerned with the question of whether we can tell what quantum black-box devices are doing by looking only at their input-output behaviour and is k…
▽ More
Self-testing usually refers to the task of taking a given set of observed correlations that are assumed to arise via a process that is accurately described by quantum theory, and trying to infer the quantum state and measurements. In other words it is concerned with the question of whether we can tell what quantum black-box devices are doing by looking only at their input-output behaviour and is known to be possible in several cases. Here we introduce a more general question: is it possible to self-test a theory, and, in particular, quantum theory? More precisely, we ask whether within a particular causal structure there are tasks that can only be performed in theories that have the same correlations as quantum mechanics in any scenario. We present a candidate task for such a correlation self-test and analyse it in a range of generalised probabilistic theories (GPTs), showing that none of these perform better than quantum theory. A generalisation of our results showing that all non-quantum GPTs are strictly inferior to quantum mechanics for this task would point to a new way to axiomatise quantum theory, and enable an experimental test that simultaneously rules out such GPTs.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2024; v1 submitted 29 February, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Entanglement Detection Beyond Measuring Fidelities
Authors:
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Benjamin Dive,
David Trillo,
Edgar A. Aguilar,
Miguel Navascués
Abstract:
One of the most widespread methods to determine if a quantum state is entangled, or to quantify its entanglement dimensionality, is by measuring its fidelity with respect to a pure state. In this Letter we find a large class of states whose entanglement cannot be detected in this manner; we call them unfaithful. We find that unfaithful states are ubiquitous in information theory. For small dimensi…
▽ More
One of the most widespread methods to determine if a quantum state is entangled, or to quantify its entanglement dimensionality, is by measuring its fidelity with respect to a pure state. In this Letter we find a large class of states whose entanglement cannot be detected in this manner; we call them unfaithful. We find that unfaithful states are ubiquitous in information theory. For small dimensions, we check numerically that most bipartite states are both entangled and unfaithful. Similarly, numerical searches in low dimensions show that most pure entangled states remain entangled but become unfaithful when a certain amount of white noise is added. We also find that faithfulness can be self-activated, i.e., there exist instances of unfaithful states whose tensor powers are faithful. To explore how the fidelity approach limits the quantification of entanglement dimensionality, we generalize the notion of an unfaithful state to that of a D-unfaithful state, one that cannot be certified as D-dimensionally entangled by measuring its fidelity with respect to a pure state. For describing such states, we additionally introduce a hierarchy of semidefinite programming relaxations that fully characterizes the set of states of Schmidt rank at most D.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2020; v1 submitted 20 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Analysing causal structures in generalised probabilistic theories
Authors:
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Roger Colbeck
Abstract:
Causal structures give us a way to understand the origin of observed correlations. These were developed for classical scenarios, but quantum mechanical experiments necessitate their generalisation. Here we study causal structures in a broad range of theories, which include both quantum and classical theory as special cases. We propose a method for analysing differences between such theories based…
▽ More
Causal structures give us a way to understand the origin of observed correlations. These were developed for classical scenarios, but quantum mechanical experiments necessitate their generalisation. Here we study causal structures in a broad range of theories, which include both quantum and classical theory as special cases. We propose a method for analysing differences between such theories based on the so-called measurement entropy. We apply this method to several causal structures, deriving new relations that separate classical, quantum and more general theories within these causal structures. The constraints we derive for the most general theories are in a sense minimal requirements of any causal explanation in these scenarios. In addition, we make several technical contributions that give insight for the entropic analysis of quantum causal structures. In particular, we prove that for any causal structure and for any generalised probabilistic theory, the set of achievable entropy vectors form a convex cone.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2021; v1 submitted 11 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Smooth entropy in axiomatic thermodynamics
Authors:
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Lea Krämer Gabriel,
Philippe Faist,
Renato Renner
Abstract:
Thermodynamics can be formulated in either of two approaches, the phenomenological approach, which refers to the macroscopic properties of systems, and the statistical approach, which describes systems in terms of their microscopic constituents. We establish a connection between these two approaches by means of a new axiomatic framework that can take errors and imprecisions into account. This link…
▽ More
Thermodynamics can be formulated in either of two approaches, the phenomenological approach, which refers to the macroscopic properties of systems, and the statistical approach, which describes systems in terms of their microscopic constituents. We establish a connection between these two approaches by means of a new axiomatic framework that can take errors and imprecisions into account. This link extends to systems of arbitrary sizes including microscopic systems, for which the treatment of imprecisions is pertinent to any realistic situation. Based on this, we identify the quantities that characterise whether certain thermodynamic processes are possible with entropy measures from information theory. In the error-tolerant case, these entropies are so-called smooth min and max entropies. Our considerations further show that in an appropriate macroscopic limit there is a single entropy measure that characterises which state transformations are possible. In the case of many independent copies of a system (the so-called i.i.d. regime), the relevant quantity is the von Neumann entropy.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Quantum Causal Structure and Quantum Thermodynamics
Authors:
Mirjam Weilenmann
Abstract:
This thesis reports progress in two domains, causal structures and microscopic thermodynamics, both of which are pertinent in the development of quantum technologies. The first part is dedicated to the analysis of causal structure, which encodes the relationship between observed variables, in general restricting the set of possible correlations between them. Our considerations rely on a recent ent…
▽ More
This thesis reports progress in two domains, causal structures and microscopic thermodynamics, both of which are pertinent in the development of quantum technologies. The first part is dedicated to the analysis of causal structure, which encodes the relationship between observed variables, in general restricting the set of possible correlations between them. Our considerations rely on a recent entropy vector method. Based on this, we develop techniques for deriving entropic constraints to differentiate between causal structures. We provide sufficient conditions for entropy vectors to be realisable within a causal structure and derive new, improved necessary conditions in terms of so-called non-Shannon inequalities. We also report that for a family of causal structures, including the bipartite Bell scenario and the bilocal causal structure, entropy vectors are unable to distinguish between classical and quantum causes, in spite of the existence of quantum correlations that are not classically reproducible. Hence, further development is needed in order to understand cause from a quantum perspective.
In the second part we explore an axiomatic framework for modelling error-tolerant processes in microscopic thermodynamics. Our axiomatisation allows for the accommodation of finite precision levels, crucial for describing experiments in the microscopic regime. It leads to the emergence of manageable quantities that give insights into the feasibility and expenditure of processes, which for adiabatic processes are shown to be smooth entropy measures. Our framework also leads to thermodynamic behaviour at the macroscopic scale, meaning that for thermodynamic equilibrium states a unique function provides necessary and sufficient conditions for state transformations, like in the traditional second law.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Effect of wall thermal inertia upon transient thermoacoustic dynamics of a swirl-stabilized flame
Authors:
Giacomo Bonciolini,
Dominik Ebi,
Ulrich Doll,
Markus Weilenmann,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
This paper shows the importance of considering the thermal state of a combustor to investigate or predict its thermoacoustic stability. This aspect is often neglected or regarded as less important than the effect of the operating parameters, such as thermal power or equivalence ratio, but under certain circumstances it can have a dramatic influence on the development of the instabilities. The pape…
▽ More
This paper shows the importance of considering the thermal state of a combustor to investigate or predict its thermoacoustic stability. This aspect is often neglected or regarded as less important than the effect of the operating parameters, such as thermal power or equivalence ratio, but under certain circumstances it can have a dramatic influence on the development of the instabilities. The paper presents experimental results collected from a combustor featuring a lean swirl-stabilized flame exhibiting thermoacoustic instability at some operating conditions. It is shown that this instability is caused by a change of the flame topology that is induced by the progressive increase of the wall temperature with the thermal power. This dependence of the instability on wall temperature leads to inertial effects and hysteresis when the operating condition is changed dynamically. A low-order model of the system reproducing this remarkable dynamics is proposed and validated against the experimental data.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Analysing causal structures with entropy
Authors:
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Roger Colbeck
Abstract:
A central question for causal inference is to decide whether a set of correlations fit a given causal structure. In general, this decision problem is computationally infeasible and hence several approaches have emerged that look for certificates of compatibility. Here we review several such approaches based on entropy. We bring together the key aspects of these entropic techniques with unified ter…
▽ More
A central question for causal inference is to decide whether a set of correlations fit a given causal structure. In general, this decision problem is computationally infeasible and hence several approaches have emerged that look for certificates of compatibility. Here we review several such approaches based on entropy. We bring together the key aspects of these entropic techniques with unified terminology, filling several gaps and establishing new connections regarding their relation, all illustrated with examples. We consider cases where unobserved causes are classical, quantum and post-quantum and discuss what entropic analyses tell us about the difference. This has applications to quantum cryptography, where it can be crucial to eliminate the possibility of classical causes. We discuss the achievements and limitations of the entropic approach in comparison to other techniques and point out the main open problems.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2018; v1 submitted 26 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Non-Shannon inequalities in the entropy vector approach to causal structures
Authors:
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Roger Colbeck
Abstract:
A causal structure is a relationship between observed variables that in general restricts the possible correlations between them. This relationship can be mediated by unobserved systems, modelled by random variables in the classical case or joint quantum systems in the quantum case. One way to differentiate between the correlations realisable by two different causal structures is to use entropy ve…
▽ More
A causal structure is a relationship between observed variables that in general restricts the possible correlations between them. This relationship can be mediated by unobserved systems, modelled by random variables in the classical case or joint quantum systems in the quantum case. One way to differentiate between the correlations realisable by two different causal structures is to use entropy vectors, i.e., vectors whose components correspond to the entropies of each subset of the observed variables. To date, the starting point for deriving entropic constraints within causal structures are the so-called Shannon inequalities (positivity of entropy, conditional entropy and conditional mutual information). In the present work we investigate what happens when non-Shannon entropic inequalities are included as well. We show that in general these lead to tighter outer approximations of the set of realisable entropy vectors and hence enable a sharper distinction of different causal structures. Since non-Shannon inequalities can only be applied amongst classical variables, it might be expected that their use enables an entropic distinction between classical and quantum causal structures. However, this remains an open question. We also introduce techniques for deriving inner approximations to the allowed sets of entropy vectors for a given causal structure. These are useful for proving tightness of outer approximations or for finding interesting regions of entropy space. We illustrate these techniques in several scenarios, including the triangle causal structure.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2018; v1 submitted 6 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Inability of the entropy vector method to certify nonclassicality in linelike causal structures
Authors:
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Roger Colbeck
Abstract:
Bell's theorem shows that our intuitive understanding of causation must be overturned in light of quantum correlations. Nevertheless, quantum mechanics does not permit signalling and hence a notion of cause remains. Understanding this notion is not only important at a fundamental level, but also for technological applications such as key distribution and randomness expansion. It has recently been…
▽ More
Bell's theorem shows that our intuitive understanding of causation must be overturned in light of quantum correlations. Nevertheless, quantum mechanics does not permit signalling and hence a notion of cause remains. Understanding this notion is not only important at a fundamental level, but also for technological applications such as key distribution and randomness expansion. It has recently been shown that a useful way to decide which classical causal structures could give rise to a given set of correlations is to use entropy vectors. These are vectors whose components are the entropies of all subsets of the observed variables in the causal structure. The entropy vector method employs causal relationships among the variables to restrict the set of possible entropy vectors. Here, we consider whether the same approach can lead to useful certificates of non-classicality within a given causal structure. Surprisingly, we find that for a family of causal structures that include the usual bipartite Bell structure they do not. For all members of this family, no function of the entropies of the observed variables gives such a certificate, in spite of the existence of nonclassical correlations. It is therefore necessary to look beyond entropy vectors to understand cause from a quantum perspective.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2016; v1 submitted 8 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Axiomatic relation between thermodynamic and information-theoretic entropies
Authors:
Mirjam Weilenmann,
Lea Krämer,
Philippe Faist,
Renato Renner
Abstract:
Thermodynamic entropy, as defined by Clausius, characterizes macroscopic observations of a system based on phenomenological quantities such as temperature and heat. In contrast, information-theoretic entropy, introduced by Shannon, is a measure of uncertainty. In this Letter, we connect these two notions of entropy, using an axiomatic framework for thermodynamics [Lieb, Yngvason, Proc. Roy. Soc.(2…
▽ More
Thermodynamic entropy, as defined by Clausius, characterizes macroscopic observations of a system based on phenomenological quantities such as temperature and heat. In contrast, information-theoretic entropy, introduced by Shannon, is a measure of uncertainty. In this Letter, we connect these two notions of entropy, using an axiomatic framework for thermodynamics [Lieb, Yngvason, Proc. Roy. Soc.(2013)]. In particular, we obtain a direct relation between the Clausius entropy and the Shannon entropy, or its generalisation to quantum systems, the von Neumann entropy. More generally, we find that entropy measures relevant in non-equilibrium thermodynamics correspond to entropies used in one-shot information theory.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2017; v1 submitted 27 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
