Model selection for component network meta-analysis in connected and disconnected networks: a simulation study
Authors:
Maria Petropoulou,
Gerta Rücker,
Stephanie Weibel,
Peter Kranke,
Guido Schwarzer
Abstract:
Network meta-analysis (NMA) is widely used in evidence synthesis to estimate the effects of several competing interventions for a given clinical condition. One of the challenges is that it is not possible in disconnected networks. Component network meta-analysis (CNMA) allows technically 'reconnecting' a disconnected network with multicomponent interventions. The additive CNMA model assumes that t…
▽ More
Network meta-analysis (NMA) is widely used in evidence synthesis to estimate the effects of several competing interventions for a given clinical condition. One of the challenges is that it is not possible in disconnected networks. Component network meta-analysis (CNMA) allows technically 'reconnecting' a disconnected network with multicomponent interventions. The additive CNMA model assumes that the effect of any multicomponent intervention is the additive sum of its components. This assumption can be relaxed by adding interaction component terms, which improves the goodness of fit but decreases the network connectivity. Model selection aims at finding the model with a reasonable balance between the goodness of fit and connectivity (selected CNMA model). We aim to introduce a forward model selection strategy for CNMA models and to investigate the performance of CNMA models for connected and disconnected networks. We applied the methods to a real Cochrane review dataset and simulated data with additive, mildly, or strongly violated intervention effects. We started with connected networks, and we artificially constructed disconnected networks. We compared the results of the additive and the selected CNMAs from each connected and disconnected network with the NMA using the mean squared error and coverage probability. CNMA models provide good performance for connected networks and can be an alternative to standard NMA if additivity holds. On the contrary, model selection does not perform well for disconnected networks, and we recommend conducting separate analyses of subnetworks.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
Hyperspectral interference tomography of nacre
Authors:
Jad Salman,
Cayla A. Stifler,
Alireza Shahsafi,
Chang-Yu Sun,
Steve Weibel,
Michel Frising,
Bryan E. Rubio-Perez,
Yuzhe Xiao,
Christopher Draves,
Raymond A. Wambold,
Zhaoning Yu,
Daniel C. Bradley,
Gabor Kemeny,
Pupa U. P. A. Gilbert,
Mikhail A. Kats
Abstract:
Structural characterization of biologically formed materials is essential for understanding biological phenomena and their environment, and generating new bio-inspired engineering concepts. For example, nacre -- formed by mollusks in the ocean -- encodes local environmental conditions throughout its formation and has exceptional strength due to its nanoscale brick-and-mortar structure. This layere…
▽ More
Structural characterization of biologically formed materials is essential for understanding biological phenomena and their environment, and generating new bio-inspired engineering concepts. For example, nacre -- formed by mollusks in the ocean -- encodes local environmental conditions throughout its formation and has exceptional strength due to its nanoscale brick-and-mortar structure. This layered structure, comprising transparent aragonite tablets bonded with an ultra-thin organic polymer, also results in stunning interference colors. Existing methods of structural characterization of nacre rely on some form of cross-sectional analysis, such as scanning electron microscopy or polarization-dependent imaging contrast (PIC) map**. However, these techniques are destructive and too time- and resource-intensive to analyze large sample areas. Here we present an all-optical, rapid, and non-destructive imaging technique -- hyperspectral interference tomography (HIT) -- to spatially map the structural parameters of nacre and other disordered layered materials. We combined hyperspectral imaging with optical-interference modeling to infer the mean tablet thickness and disordering of nacre layers across entire mollusk shells at various stages of development, observing a previously unknown relationship between the growth of the mollusk and tablet thickness. Our rapid, inexpensive, and nondestructive method can be readily applied to in-field studies.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
